Outdoor seating
Yes
99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille in Lancaster
Categories
Location on the map
Lancaster, Erie County, New York, US
Service options
Kerbside pickup
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Delivery
No
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Great coffee
Yes
Great dessert
Yes
Sport
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Food
Yes
Food at bar
Yes
Happy-hour food
Yes
Healthy options
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Yes
Accepts reservations
Yes
Phone: +1 716-393-3847
Site: http://www.99brickoven.com/
Site: http://www.99brickoven.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:11:30AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11:30AM–9PM
- Thursday:11:30AM–9PM
- Friday:11:30AM–10PM
- Saturday:11:30AM–10PM
- Sunday:Closed
Comments (199)
I got the potato chip fish fry...it was okay. Fries were not a good flavor (I love fries and have never said that before... usually cant mess up fries). Coleslaw was good but pasta salad was not very tasty.
Good local place. Great service. Love the margarita pizza with pepperoni.Support your local small .business
Excellent place! Usually very busy, so I suggest making reservations in advance! Great customer service, timely, polite & friendly! Not to mention the food 👌 yum!
This place is so good, I completely didnt expect that, we went for a small celebration, my husband and I got the special which was a meal for 2 for that day. Great spot, I recommend, reasonably priced in my opinion.
Always enjoy our dinners at 99 Brick Oven. Their pizzas are made with the highest quality ingredients and cooked in a traditional brick oven (I believe from Italy). Pizzas on the thin side which I prefer. Delicious and consistent quality. Plenty for two people (one pizza).Theit fillet is amazing and their burgers are equally fantastic. Roast beef sandwiches are tasty, but are sometimes more on the medium to well side (but still juicy and tender).Happy hour drink and food options at the bar. Patio is now year round. Attentive staff. Cool spot!
You can Always depend upon a Sincere Welcome, a very clean environment ... a large Menu and Definitely quality food preparation!This will become Your...Go To Place!
Meal was great but menu is somewhat limited. Nice casual place. would go again.
We enjoy supporting our local businesses, especially when the food and atmosphere is Nice!We enjoyed a late Saturday lunch on the patio with my 1st Summer Shandy while the others loved their Watermelon Sangria. We shared wings and the others all enjoyed the haddock while I had the schnitzel. Well be back to try some more of the fairly extensive menu!!
Good food and drinks. Very good service. The selection of beers was a surprise. Enjoyed the cucumber mule. Went for lunch and was very satisfied with crock of onion soup and Reuben . Both delicious.
Always excellent food.The 99 Salad, burgers and banana peppers are always a hit with my group. Can be busy so waits are sometimes long if you come at peak times.
Outstanding food and service and atmosphere. We will be back.
Best think crust pizza I have had, good environment if you want to go out with your friends and have a good time. Always busy with new people
Went for dinner with a group of 6 of us. Friday 11/19 the food was excellent. A few of us didn’t realize we had to scan the barcode for the full menu instead of just bringing us a paper menu she told us to scan the QR code... apparently it was too much to ask for the paper menu. We had to beg for refills on drinks( our drinks were easy beer and rum and coke) she forgot one of the refills and by the time she remembered the ice was melted. We asked to sit on the covered patio after dinner for a drink and she told us to go and ask ourselves... the girls that were bussing the tables were more attentive and pleasant than Our waitress was. She brought our check never asked if we wanted to split it, we asked the buss girls to ask her to split the check and she did but before she did she came back up and asked us if we really wanted it split. To which we all replied yes. Again food was really good. But the waitress wasn’t the most pleasant and I know everyone is short but we didn’t ask for anything that was over the top nor were we expecting anything over the top. We would all go there again hopefully it will be a better experience.
We will be back a very attentive hostess and waitress we made a mistake we were in the wrong restaurant and she was very kind and told us where to find the one that we were supposed to be at and looking forward to patronizing this restaurant the menu looks fantastic
Food, Service, Owners all amazing!Priced well, take-out is quick and always correct. Sit down was great except took forever for our entrees. We sat on the patio and service was dragging. They took a reservation us over the phone ahead of time it was awesome because we had out of town guests and 2 kids.We might be addicted to take out there.
Best pizza I ever had, Hubby had the potato chip fish dinner also excellent
Excellent pizza, great service!! Always enjoy going there!
Food was amazing and so was the service. Will definitely be returning.
Nice food good prices and great service.
Was there for the first time in about 4 years for lunch. Had the 99 Brick salad. Outstanding.. quality cooked chicken and plenty of it. Portobello mushrooms and roasted red peppers and feta cheese. Might have missed a few ingredients but it rocked. Companion had beef on wick with decent sized and good tasting fries. No complaints from him.. Waitress was accommodating but a smile would have more welcoming. Nadine and Dave have weathered the covid pandemic and are even better. The place is a winner.
We moved to Lancaster not too long ago and found 99 Brick Oven. It is an absolute GEM! The steak sandwich is one of the best in buffalo. The pizzas are the bomb— thin, crispy— so good. The service is also top notch. I have never had a bad meal at 99. Im so glad restaurants are reopen and we can enjoy excellent food and service!!! Also the burgers are great. All around 10/10.
Absolutely spectacular food and attentive service. Favorite is the stuffed pepperd
Excellent service and delicious food! Cant wait to go back!
Overall, I was disappointed. Ordered the seared scallops and they were not like any seared scallops Ive had. They had a flour coating that didnt sear properly and only one side was done. The mashed potatoes were lumpy and stiff. The best part of the entree was the grilled asparagus. On a positive note, the french onion soup was excellent. Probably the best Ive had. The waitress was great but the manager argued a bit about whether or not the scallops should have the flour coating. She, or the chef, should watch Hells Kitchen and learn how to make them.
A great find. Staff was on the money and our food was awesome. Im a brick oven freak. Pizza was really good. My wings were some of best Ive had. Original flavor with a crispy skin.
Just OK. Restaurant was nice. Quick seating outdoors. Lots of GF choices. I ordered pasta and it was very plain. Scoop of pasta with a ladle of sauce. No bread offered or salad. Not worth the price! Especially for a lunch menu. ☹
The food was mostly good however the mashed potatoes were lukewarm, flavorless and had lumps of what felt like undercooked potatoes it it. The portobello sandwich was delicious however it was served on narrow baguette bread which made it impossible to eat. Everything just kept falling off and was a mess. The sangria cost $9 and was a large glass but it tasted like wine and sprite mixed with chunks of strawberry or mint that kept blocking the straw. Not technically sangria nor was it worth $9.The outdoor patio is really nice. Unfortunately, you cannot reserve tables outside. There is an extra section added in the back but there is no roofing over it and it is near the dumpsters. On a warm day the smell is quite ripe.Parking is also limited.
Food and service were both very good! Seafood platter was delicious!
Wow such great food. Great service too.
Excellent fish fry..specials.. Amy the bartender is great
Always great food, and friendly staff. Will be back again and again.
This place is really cozy and very beautiful. I would definitely recommend it!!The parking is limited and the staff could be more attentive to the customers but, overall youll love it.
The food is Great! The waitresses are polite and very helpful! If you go there once you will never stop going there. Chicken wings are dynamic!
Food was great. Our waitress wasnt the best. She was nice and all but it took her forever to get the drinks. Food came relatively quick. However it felt like our table was forgotten about. Wasnt busy either.
Went in for Sunday brunch today, the food was amazing and love that the price included a nice size bloody mary! I had the French toast and the candied pecans were great! Excellent value for the money and great service. Nice to sit on their toasty patio in the middle of winter. Ill be back for sure!
The waitresses were phenomenal!! Frequent checks on the table and knew the menu. The food was great too... quaint homey atmosphere.
Friendly, helpful staff. Our app was delicious. Price however is steep. Cant justify this being a frequent flyer for us. Special occasion perhaps.
Service was good. Pizza was great! Disappointed with the stuff banana peppers, it really wasnt much appetizer but it was late so maybe they were running out
What a great restaurant! The pizza is tasty and the staff are friendly. We stopped on a busy night without reservations, but they were able to accommodate us and we had a fabulous meal. We will return.
Wow what a pleasant surprise. Great stuffed jalapeño poppers and the hand made to order pizza was one of the best I’ve ever had. Healthy portions of wine in our glass and the waitress was terrific. Definitely going back or at least getting a carry out pizza. Downside was the limited parking and only one size pizza, otherwise would have given 5 stars
Mostly great. Food is really good including burgers and fish-fry. Fast friendly service. Nice people, nice place. Why 4 stars not 5? Fix the price of the pasta on the kids menu please. Its a small bowl of pasta which isnt made on site for $7, plus $2 for a meatball or sausage. LOL kids can get a nice burger or other better things for less! Since the meat is extra, drop the price for this small bowl of pasta. I politely said something to the waitress, I didnt ask for anything, she didnt do anything... Well be back, but wont be ordering the kids pasta
Delicious food, cool all year round patio
The parking is tricky so plan for that, but the food was delicious! Great prices and really good service 👍
Great pizza! Had the lamb with goat cheese and mushrooms. Service was fast - actually too fast. Had a drink, crock of soup and the pizza all within 30 minutes. I would have liked to enjoy my date and the evening more. They probably would have got another drink from me too!
The entire staff was very kind and welcoming. The waitress was kind and attentive. 3 of the 5 people at my table ordered brick oven pizza and they did not disappoint. I personally tried each one and was impressed. The pizzas are pretty large too, 12 inches, 6 medium slices. If you come very hungry you will leave satisfied. The portions for the dinner dishes are generous and the attention to detail on the dishes was evident. Great, cozy place to eat and good variety on the menu.
Saturday night is take out night for us. Thier brick oven pizzas and Parmigian wings are awesome. We called upon arrival and our food was brought right out to us within a few minutes. Once we got home 10min away. Our food was hot and super delicious. Thank you for making it through Governor king Coumos non science based closers.
My strawberry mojito tasted like strawberry flavored rubbing alcohol and my Bavarian pretzle was very dry. However, my coconut shrimp were the best Ive had in ages and the waiting service was very good.
99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille has a fabulous menu and my Beef on Weck was most tender. A great portion of beef on a very satisfying Weck roll. Juicy, tasty and filling. A side of French Fries and a cup of horseradish. Our server spoke clearly through her mask and made it enjoyable to be her quests. The pricing matched the offerings, no short cuts here. A look around the restaurant showed the place is clean and organized. Roomy dining area and a completely stocked bar. I highly recommend a visit to 99 Brick Oven Bar and Grille. Enjoy!
Great food as always. The Margherita Pizza is absolutely perfect. Light sauce, large slices of mozzarella, fresh garlic and thin. Super reasonable prices for 2 people. Usually around $30 with an appetizer and an entree! Only 2 items feed the two of us!
Great food, friendly service and good portions! The best spinach artichoke dip ever. Would highly recommend! Reservation required especially on the weekend.
I was surprised by what a cute place this is. I live in the area, but have never made it here. Very impressed! We got the Sausage and Mushroom Pizza and the Vegetarian Pizza, both were delicious! We also got a side of fries, they were some of the best I have ever had! Service was friendly and efficient. I would highly recommend 99 Brick Oven!!
The food is great here. So many things to choose from. Cant make a bad pizza choice. There is outdoor seating and you can even reserve it. Only downfall is the small parking lot.
I had never been here before and it was so good! The ingredients were super fresh and flavorful. I tried the stuffed banana pepper pizza and it was delicious! My husband had a burger and it was easily a half pound, cooked exactly the way he ordered it. We will be going back for sure!
Went here for restaurant week and was not dissapointed. Their food is delicious. They have thee best stuffed mushrooms Ive ever eaten. The portions of their entrees are large so you will have leftovers to enjoy later. Pizza is good too. When we went it was packed and so hot inside. I dont know if it was from all the bodies or from the brick oven.
I ordered the Haddock Parmesan. The fish was dry, bland, no seasoning, tasteless. The fish had a few tomatoe slices and some parmesan cheese and breadcrumbs placed over it. I was dissappointed.. it came with mixed veggies, broccoli, zucchini, etc.. veggies were just mush and again flavorless, no seasoning. Also ordered the stuffed mushrooms with sausage spinach and goat cheese, couldnt even taste any goat cheese at all. Ordered Caesar salad, it was ok. A pile of lettuce with dressing and a few croutons, no fresh cheese.. a little boring. The only good part of this dinner was the sweet potatoe fries. Thats about it. PLEASE ADD FLAVOR TO YOUR FOOD
Lunch with old friends from the days when OUR kids were in little league. Sat o/side on their patio and what a lovely place. Have been there before but, only in the bar area. All 6 of us enjoyed our meals. The haddock sandwich special was the the best. Service was super even with the all the tables filled!
My husband and I have been here twice. Sarah the waitress is amazing! The food is good (and overpriced), but the atmosphere... If you are an interracial couple or person of color I would suggest you steer clear. The rest of the wait staff and the patrons made it very clear my husband and I were not welcome. The looks of disgust we received, as well as the way the staff tried to force us to finish and leave... It left us with a unsettling feeling to say the least.
This place has fantastic food and staff. Been coming here for 2 years now and never had a bad experience. However, at no fault of the establishment, while waiting for a table I over heard someone say that there was like 4 tables of people who have already eaten and were refusing to leave because the hockey game was on. People... Dont be ignorant, eat and move on.
Stopped in here for drinks and pizza. The pizza was the best I’ve had here in the Buffalo area!! Waitress was nice and the tables seemed to be spaced out enough for COVID guidelines. Would definitely go back!!
My fiancé and I recently moved to the Village of Lancaster. So many people said great things about this place so we knew we had to try it. We went last night and needless to say, our friends were right! Lori was our waitress and she was amazing. Super friendly and welcoming. We ordered hot chicken fingers as a starter. They were great and it was nice that they came with fries too. We each ordered our own pizzas. My fiancé got the Buffalo Traditional with prosciutto and I got the Quattro Formaggio. We got them both with light garlic on the crust. Both pizzas were delicious!!! They were cooked perfectly. We cannot wait to come back to try different pizzas and other dishes. It’s great that we can literally walk to this place. See you again soon!
Food was ok...service was horrendous. 1 hr to get food she came back once to ask for refills and clear table. another 1/2 hour to get our check because she was showing another customer stuff on her phone. We go weekly to different resturants and give reviews. This is a definate thumbs down. If you have hours to waste this is your place. Do not recommend👎👎
Nice menu-great food. We both had the pork schnitzel dinner which came with a lovely lemon- sage-butter sauce , seasonal veggies( yellow and green summer squash, green beans, red onion and broccoli) and German potato salad as well as choice of soup or salad. Warm bread with herb oil or butter. Great portion sizes.
LONG REVIEW:99 Brick Oven is our favorite restaurant and we probably get takeout or go there 2-3 times a month. Tonight for the FIRST time we had an issue with our food. I texted the owner not to be that customer to just complain, but wanted to let them know so they keep an extra eye on future orders and because we appreciate their awesome business, they are local and the customer service and food is always top notch. She was SOOO appreciative that we contacted her and kept asking how they can show their appreciation. She sent someone from the restaurant to drop off a $25 gift card 15 minutes after I talked to her. And said a business should want that feedback. We appreciate you! I never doubted they would acknowledge the issue with our order. I just wanted a thank you for telling us! I cant wait until they can open back up and we can sit down and relax with some drinks on their patio. If you ever get the chance please support them. They are doing curbside pickup and FREE delivery if you live close enough! Right now they have a dinner for 4 special with salad, garlic bread, pasta and cannolis for only $50. PLEASE SUPPORT 99 BRICK OVEN. They are the true meaning of a GREAT business that deserves to be around. Some of our favorite things are the wings, brick oven pizza and fish. They also have awesome drinks!
Sat on the patio, very nice!Had the stuffed peppers..Very good, Wings, great!And the parmesean royal pizza was outstanding!!
I NEED to come back to this place. Was looking for a place to eat in the Village of Lancaster, we are not from around there. I found 99 Brick Oven on google maps and decided to give it a try. As soon as we pulled in, the parking lot and adjacent road was packed full of cars which is always a good sign, and you could see in the “outdoor” part of the restaurant was packed too. We ended up eating in there, which seemed like an addition on as the place was so packed. The atmosphere was amazing. The bar was bustling, it was warm with so many heaters, music playing, TVs going, and people chattering but warm and cozy without feeling closterphobic. I’m a picky person and usually only have one thing per menu that I get but had so many option on this one. Ended up splitting an amazing pizza with my dad with a side of stuffed mushrooms plus a sangria and piece of peanut butter pie. ALL the food/drinks were bursting with flavor and the bill only came to $42. Will definitely be driving down to Lancaster just to try more food from there again.
Great place for a great dinner. Service is outstanding. Ive been there at least 10 times never had a bad meal or service its worth going there give it at try. You wont be disappointed at all.
Great food. Best eats and bar experience in Lancaster, NY.Owners and staff are exceptional.Layout is chunky - space is separated well, allowing for varied experiences at the same location.Again, the food is awesome. Brick oven and bakery and most all the nice bonuses you hope to find in a hidden gem. 99 Salad with a protein is my staple and wont disappoint.
This place was awesome! Love the brick oven margarita pizza. I got the gluten free version. My husband got a long island ice tea and I got a Blue Toad Tea Hard Cider on draft! Wow!! On Friday and Saturday night from 9pm to 11pm, all of their pizza is half price. They also have burgers, steaks, salads, pasta dishes, and offer a wide variety of gluten free versions! Do yourself a favor, try 99 Brick Oven!! They are awesome.
Great meal.They have an extensive menu that will satisfy just about everyone.I have the Pizza rosettes ( Buffalo) and they are excellent.Parking is a little challenging as it’s so busy... but that’s a good sign!They do take call aheads. 30min.Will be back.
Absolutely spectacular food! Love the stuffed peppers and the pizza is perfection. Service was amazingly friendly and attentive. Definitely recommend.
Excellent. Manhattan Crowder full of clams, in every spoonful.Had their fried haddock encrusted in potato chips. Service was very 👍good.
Weve been there twice in the past month and had a great experience both times. We were greeted graciously by the owner at the front desk and then again promptly by the bartender. We decided to eat at the bar and split our choices of steamed clams, salad and a brick oven pizza from daily specials. All were super. We went on a busy Saturday night for our next visit, were greeted and served equally as graciously as our foray visit- we waited less than the 20 minutes quoted for a table and were accommodated promptly and our sausage and goat cheese pizza was delicious. Brick Oven 99 also offers a nice selectionof local craft beers on tap at reasonable prices. This is our new go to spot.
Good food but a bit over priced
Good tasting food, however the charges for extras like cheese on your cheeseburger, mushrooms, etc. is a little outrageous. I ordered plain pasta for my ten-month-old. I did not order any sauce or meat, all I wanted was plain pasta for her to pick on. The restaurant charged me $7. I thought that was a little steep seeing as she only ate like 7 noodles. Very dissatisfied with the amount I spent for dinner for my 10 month old and I.
Pizza was excellent. Wings werent crispy. Stuffed hot peppers werent bad but Ive definitely had better.
Varied menu selection. 900 degree Oven does wonders for a lot of dishes. Excellent chicken wings and pizza graded by Buffalo standards!
Service was lovely at the peak of busy lunchtime during restaurant week.Food was OK but not OMG Ive never had something this yummy before! Side salad was iceberg and 2 cherry tomatoes with a single spinach leaf on top. Margarita pizza had great texture.. just the right balance of flop and crunch.Only real negative was a repulsive odor/scent that was all-present, surprisingly worse in the closed-in outdoor patio. Gas? Fish? Whatever it was, we were thankful it was masked by our foodz once it arrived.
Nice local bar / pub. Good food,I had the pork schnitzel w a honey mustard horseradish sauce...mmmm good!! Full portions for sure,you wont leave hungry .staff was very friendly and accommodating to my 90 YO mom.beer selection was o.k.,a few more local brews would b nice.didnt have room for dessert so cant help you on that one.prices are affordable. 3rd time there and we will b back again.
Food was good, a bit over priced. I ordered a margarita pizza for pick up. Waitress was very helpful and friendly. Bartender made me wait for 14 minutes to pay and pick up my food. It was pizza and i was able to see that my pizza was already out of the oven when I arrived. I finally received my order which was cold by this time from the friendly waitress.
Great place good food nice atmosphere, limited parking.
You cant have a bad experience here. Amazing food. Some of the best pizza I have ever eaten. Just wish they had more parking. Casual to more formal dining. All are welcome and you cant leave Hungry.
This restaurant offers a variety of yummies! I love the atmosphere and servers are sprays nice. But the best thing is the food. Enjoy!
Always delicious. I love the field green and apple salad. Usually sub in goat cheese instead of bleu which theyre always gracious about. Boyfriend got the salmon special today and said it was his favorite piece of salmon in a while!
Just picked up a fish fry. 1st and last time! They left the skin on the whole fish. Absolutely disgusting. Couldnt even eat it. Fries were very greasy and coleslaw was dry.
My husband had potato chip battered fish was delicious a crock of French onion soup very good I had Reuben was good had a few drinks nice bartender first time there but will go again recommended by a friend have brick oven pizza yummy
The food here is great! The outside covered,heated patio is the place to be.
Best thin crust pizza in the area! Their other food is great too. Great service, great owners. Cant wait to go back.
I’m all for supporting local hometown businesses during the pandemic. .....The scheduled pickup time was on time. Girl delivered it to my vehicle, she was pleasant. Unfortunately, when I got the 2 fish frys home they were SATURATED with grease, the sweet potato fries were skimped and DRENCHED with grease. They shorted me a honey sauce for the fries. Fish fry was soooo terrible that my wife and I only took a few bites of fish and had a few fries and then threw it ALL OUT! I expected much of a better dinner for $17.25 per dinner. Plus I gave the girl $10 tip. Terrible!!!! They could have just served me a gallon of oil from the fryer! I can’t believe how my hometown ALWAYS lets me down. I’m only giving 1 star because I can’t give a ZERO. Next time I want to waste $50 bux, I’ll drive down Aurora Street and throw a 50 bill out the window. Hopefully that will make somebody’s day.
Food was good, but they put our party of 10 near the bar, where it was too loud and too hot, and I felt crowded. Since the reservation was made in advance, and was made for a table away from the bar, that was disappointing. Food was good, and servers were pleasant. Parking was terrible. Not enough room for all the cars coming in.
Super great pizza!! I havent tried much else but it sure looks good! Staff is always friendly and accommodating. Must go!
TL:DR average food. Too expensive.The food was alright. I feel like its a little expensive for food that was only ok. Beers were good though. I had the steak sandwich with mushrooms and carmalized onions. Was good, I guess. I ordered rare it was cooked correctly but was tough. Also had the ravioli appetizer, pasta was cooked well but braised beef and cheese filling was tasteless.
Great lunch. A little busy at 2:30 PM but got seated right away.
A hidden gem. Food was delicious. Service was good. Went for restaurant week we both got the special. Absolutely delicious.The pizzas are pricey but wort every penny.
The evening was great, but came to an abrupt halt when an employee approached our table and asked us to leave our seats and sit at the bar. We looked around us, confused. There was no one waiting to be seated and there was an open table right next to us. We had only been there for an hour and twenty minutes. How uncomfortable and rude. Not happy about this. A poor way to treat your customers. Will not be going back.
Good food. Nice atmosphere
With a Warm an Inviting Atmosphere and a more than curteous and friendly staff from Top to Bottom you will not be disappointed. The food is awesome and the Brick Oven Pizza subpurb. My personal favorite the Stuffed Hot Pepper ... I add pepperoni. There are more than 99 reasons to stop in and indulge. Start with those and youll probably find 99 more.
Great food! Great service! Everything on the menu is well done, I recommend the pizza or steak sandwich. There is a reason this place is always busy, recommend trying off peak hours.
Stopped tonight after the play at Lancaster Opera House. First time visitor. Excellent salad. Pizza was the closest Ive experienced to Italy. Staff is very attentive and goes out of their way to make sure you are satisfied. Will visit again.
Take out order. No parking, had to walk several blocks for take out. Your think they would have a couple spots accommodate customers that order and pick up. Waited 20 additional minutes when told food would be ready in 25 minutes. Food is subpar. Garlic bread with cheese is basically a sub roll with cheese melted on it in the brick oven...just the outer edge of the roll was even slightly toasted. Potato salad with one meal was awful. Potatoes under cooked and crunched when bitten into. The pork schnitzel entree was very dry and very hard to cut let alone eat. Pasta entree was barely enough to feed a child and was an adult order. The only reason I gave 2 stars is because the Rosettes were fairly good and the chicken fingers as well. Will never visit, order, or patronize this restaurant again.
Food was amazing. Good service we had an issue with our pizza and they made us a new one.Will def visit again when I come back to visit
Great food. Nice and cozy atmosphere and the wait staff were very friendly!
Will not return. Went for dinner on patio, hostess and young ladies serving all wore masks, disinfecting. The older server (Not ours thankfully) had her mask dangling from one ear... going to her patrons table talking, etc. Never put it on. A male worker came from inside to patio, no mask, walking around talking.We watched 3 couples allowed to enter patio with no masks.
This place has quickly become a neighborhood favorite of ours. The staff is super friendly and professional and the food is great!
Great food. Great atmosphere. Signature wing flavor is unique and delicious off the pit. Brick oven pizzas compete with any in this area and beyond.
Good service with good food. Things were a little slow but I was there post covid and Im sure things are just ramping back up. Wish the beer list was a little longer. Would def go back though.
My husband and I went to 99 Brick Oven for drinks and dinner last night. We arrived in time for happy hour at the bar, which has a cozy feeling. We wished they would have had more than 2 craft beer offerings, but it was no big deal. We sat down at a table for dinner and ordered a ceasar salad and stuffed hot pepper pizza (we added sausage to the pizza) to split. The salad came out in two bowls, already split, which we really appreciated. The ceasar dressing was homemade and very tasty. We enjoyed the pizza also, however there seemed to only be 6 or 8 small pieces of stuffed hot pepper on our 12 inch pizza. Overall, the pizza had a good flavor and we were very glad we added sausage to it. We will return, thanks for a good meal!
I have ordered three pizzas now my family and I just cant get enough. It is the most consistent pizza weve had in awhile, and it packs a taste like no other.
Great atmosphere, the food is outstanding. Dave and Nadine are great hosts.
Great pizza, friendly staff, warm service. They go above and beyond to help make everything great! And I can’t say enough how much I appreciate their care in delivery! Thank you!
For the price, I thought the food would be better. Sausage bread was rather bland and the bread was not toasted but burnt around the edges where the cheese melted. Small piece of cake was $8.50!!!
Food was good staff was awesome. Everything felt like it was a little pricey.
The food was very good. The overall service was good. The place was cold. I am a little miffed that customers that came in after us got their food first. We waited quite awhile for our lunch.
There isnt anything on the menu that you wont enjoy. Every bite is a delicious entanglement of flavors that release your mind from the delusion that all food is the same. They do carry a variy of local breweries and your brand name brews. If you can try and get a patio table during the summer months, maybe its me but I like it outside.
$15 for a 14 pizza with very little topping. Pizza was nothing special and have had much better locally. Will not go back.Since this initial review, we have been back and ordered different food. All was OK and service was very good.
Consistently good food with excellent menu options and great service.
The pizza rosettes are unique. My two favorites are the American which has pepperoni and banana peppers and the Tuscan which has garlic and spinach. I really havent explored the rest of the menu because when I go to 99 brick, I already have rosettes on my mind.
Food was good but on the expensive side. For example side ala carte salads were in the $10+ range. Inside area is near a bar and it can be on the loud side. Outdoor patio might be a better choice on good weather days.
Great food and friendly staff. Its our go to place for a bottle of wine and steak. Its also a great spot to enjoy the sunshine and grab a cocktail during the day by utilizing their patio
Unexpected gem. These people take the food seriously. This is not mass produced corporate eating. Been on the road for hours and took a chance, and the steak is delicious, and the wild mushroom risotto made with local ingredients. And not outrageously priced either. Delicious meal from some very accomplished chefs.
Food & service was great!
Absolutely amazing place to get food. The owners are wonderful people. If youre in the market for good food, good atmosphere, and good people, this is the place for you.
Love it here. Never ever had a bad experience. Amazing drinks, amazing pizza. My favorite restaurant around.
We keep coming back here because the food is great the service is fast and friendly and all that I mention the food is wonderful.They were nice outside patio and a great brick oven pizza check it out
Great service and atmosphere. Coconut drink very good. Outdoor seating cuts off at a certain time but inside was fine as only choice.
Great service. Owners Nadine and Dave take time to personally greet you ...love the brick oven pizza and my favorite pork snitzel with lemon butter sage sauce .
The food is always good and they have a great variety of food that they offer...but, 2 of 3 times I bought takeout they did not remember to pack some sides. Very frustrating.
Always get the Buffalo Traditional Pizza, Thin Crust, Well Done with Extra Cheese and Pepperoni (sometimes half sausage)... Tastes fantastic every time! LOVE THIS PLACE!
Great food and great service. I attended a group lunch and everything was served in a timely manner and our waitress was very attentive.
I love their pizza! This restaurant is my favorite when I come to town to visit my BFF. We dont mind the wait at times, the bar helps us through that.
Love the Grill 99 pizza! However...the wings we got were not crispy or saucy, they were actually pretty horrible, and at over a buck a piece are totally unacceptable.
Really Good food and atmosphere
Beautiful outdoor seating - wonderful service and GREAT Food. I had the fish and it was great. Prices were reasonable. They had a large selection - dont miss this great local eatery.
Nice atmosphere and good food
Wow! Had a beer at the bar and ordered a brick oven pizza to go. Omg the pizza was soooo good! You like garlic this pizza was delish. And had a really nice selection of beers.
Great food. Busy the day I was there. Their parking lot is too small for the amount of seating...had to parking on a side street.
Good food, giant pretzel, and string drinks! The mood was hampered by family issues...and sadly, we were seated right next to the front door.
Good food and gluten free options. Good wings. Will be back often
The food tasted excellent and the staff was very friendly
Great atmosphere. Good fiod.
Great fish fry,pretzel and drinks. The staff is so efficient and friendly. A great experience for a local bar.
Pizza was delicious, fresh garlic was a great touch. Extra point for Guinness on tap.
The food was good. But my credit card was hacked a few days after visiting. Not a 100%. Could have been something else.
Great food and service..
Very nice place to eat. Food was very good.
Great food and drink! Get the salad, add the steak, good french onion soup, pizzas are delicious..
Good pizza fast service love the undercarriage of the pizza nice crisp.
First time going there very impressed service a number one food as well keep up the good work cant wait to go back.
This place is wonderful very good food and great pizza. None better.
Pleasantly surprised at how good the food was and service was great.
Though crowded, I could still hear my dinner partner. Food was delicious, prices were fair and the service was outstanding!
Loved this place! Our first time here and it wont be our last! Great food and outstanding service!
Great food! Great service! The vibe is awesome! Highly recommend!
99 is an ok spot. They have a nice outdoor seating area. Food is okay, a little expensive for what it is worth. Decent beer selection
Delicious Portobello mushroom sandwich! Comfortable seating on the patio.
Cold drinks and excellent food! I love this place the staff I great! I have never had a bad experience here ever!
Awesome pizza, plus a great menu of other options just as fantastic! A visit to this restaurant will not disappoint.
First visit and I found this to be exceptional. Service was great and the food was fantastic. Clean, inviting and cozy
Food was good $$$. Loud ,doors slamming front and rear.. just not a relaxing place.. . No music .. patio might have been quieter.. not a fun night.... Sorry !.
Great place to wine & dine,one of the greatest restarants around.The service is one of a kind,great staff & the owners are top notch.All food is great,but the pizzas that come out of that brick oven are incredable,freshest Ive tasted in a long time.This place is comfortable,spacious and very clean,we have a great time there.
Try the scallops and truffle mashed potatoes!
Great atmosphere, food was great and 1/2 price pizzas Friday & Saturday 9p-11p
Great service and delicious food will be coming here again, good environment.
Awesome food!! We come all the way up from long Island to eat here!! Service and food is the best!
Great food!!!! Staff friendly and great atmosphere.
Food was so good! Oatmeal cookie martini was great & Sarah was a wonderful waitress :)
Really good food, they have a kids menu and the service is fast. Nice bar too, good drinks.
Love the food. Good customer service experience as well. Gets very busy
Food was great. Had specials for Valentines day. Sat out on the heated patio-quieter.
Great atmosphere! Perfect lighting , nice bar! Stuffed Pepper Pizza was amazing!
Excellent food very clean and mindful of extra caution ! Made me very comfortable.
Great food and service. Love the patio area. Pizza is super yummy!
Great place. Great food. Great service. Best place Ive been in a long time
Best pizza Ive had. So good.
Hefty price for OK food. Like a pub trying to be fancy, its not bad, but its not the fine dining they seem to be charging you for.
Youll enjoy a personal Welcome from the Owners! I recommend the Fish Fry and ALL the trimmings! Ill be there with Friends.
First time there. Intersting concept of small plate Tuesdays. Food was excellent. Will be back.
If you like traditional New York style pizza and want some relief from the thick Western New York style pizza this is the best in all of Western New York that I have found
Upscale neighborhood bar and bistro, great food.. Some of their waitstaff arent as helpful as they should be (rude and lazy), hence the 4 star rating.
Amazing pizza and great service. Go early for a family dinner, late for a good bar scene.
Fantastic food and the service was excellent.
Great food, great drinks, friendly service. A fun place in town to go to on a date night.
Great service and awesome food! Sweet potato fries and sweet honey sauce are amazing!
First time there , excellent food and service
Always a great dinner here.
Love it great food and service thats what I like u will not be disappointed..
Awesome pizza!! Staff is great! And there floor on the patio is beautiful!!!
Went here for a beer and pizza with my dad. Really great spot just outside the village of lancaster to go and grab a bite.
My favorite place to go for lunch or dinner. Food is great, staff and owners are great.
Great food! Good service. Nice patio.
Total reviews rating 4.6
199 Reviews for 99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille 2023:
Review №1
2021-09-16Great place to try the signature wood fired pizza, it’s the real deal. We also tried the rosettes which were interesting and delicious. The place can get quite packed during dinner so there may be a long wait.
Review №2
2021-07-24My daughter and I wanted to try a new place to have dinner. The food service was excellent. The server did a great job, she was busy but made sure everyone was taken care of. She explained what the specials were, she also told us about the food. It was a great to go get something different. I recommend going there for a dinner!
Review №3
2022-05-28Went tonight for dinner around 430pm, and it was before the dinner rush. You could either eat outside under a covered area, or inside like we did. The bar has a nice ambiance, as well as the dining area. Our waitress Amanda was a great waitress. Checked on us at the right times and made it a good experience. By the time we left, a lot of people were showing up. So your best bet for a nice quieter time might be a little earlier. The only thing that wasnt great were the parmigian wings we ordered. Theyre expensive, and small. All in all would recommend to check out. Well be back again at some point.
Review №4
2022-05-10A good neighborhood restaurant and bar. Our meatball paninis were great. They were crisp on the outside and filled with sliced meatballs that were covered in melted mozerella. I really like that the meatballs were slice to make it easier to eat. There is a heated covered, partially enclosed patio, a dining room and the. An upper level with the bar and a few tables. It was nice to have the split levels; it made it easier to have a conversation. There is a back parking lot just enter driveway on the patio side.
Review №5
2022-05-15There are nothing but great things to say about their food, staff and atmosphere. I havent stopped talking about this place and recommending to others!!! Great time for any occasion or just to pop in. Youll love it!
Review №6
2021-02-25Stuffed banana pepper pizza with garlic crust definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a very long time that wasn’t your standard cheese and pepperoni. It’s a great place with the brick oven pizza that I highly recommend
Review №7
2020-09-25Love the outdoor set up they have, very cozy. The staff was friendly. Our food was ok. My chocolate martini wasnt great, way to much chocolate syrup, and was extremely weak containing very little alcohol for what they charged. I wouldnt recommend the martinis. Loved the Caesar salad, the penne pasta with meatballs wasnt bad. The meatball itself was the best part, very flavorful but the sauce was bland, and some of the noodles were a bit crunchy. However Ill return, and have to try some of the things my friends have recommended, like the pizza which looked delicious.
Review №8
2017-08-14Were very accommodating for our large party! The wings were great! Pizza crust was a little burnt and the waitress didnt provide any refills on drinks, but otherwise great restaurant!
Review №9
2022-01-10Choose to check out this location as I was looking for Beef on Weck. Had not been in western NY in too many years. The Google map menu was much lower than the actual menu.The food was excellent! The beef was tender and delicious. The roll was soft (probably home made) and well salted with kimmelweck. Service was excellent for a surprise party of 9!Will visit again when in the area.
Review №10
2022-01-19I love the pizza here. I dont know how they make their dough, but it is fantastic! I mean, I am sure they have other great foods, I just wouldnt know. I have only ever gotten pizza here, and even though I get different ones, I doubt Ill have the need or want to try anything else.