Delivery
Yes
American Pie in Bridgehampton
Categories
Location on the map
Bridgehampton, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Phone: +1 631-613-6177
Site: https://hamptonsamericanpie.hung...
Site: https://hamptonsamericanpie.hung...
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–9PM
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–10PM
- Saturday:11AM–10PM
- Sunday:11AM–9PM
American Pie in other cities:
Comments (104)
Pizza is really good. Prices fair. Not enough seating and place is always busy.
Stopped for a couple slices and a panini while out shopping. Food was very good. We will definitely be back.
If you are out there the food is great good prices nice people and some little square kinda like a pinwheel is delicious
Its your classic mini-mall pizza place but better! Good Beer selection , sports on tv, great delivery and meatball sliders to die for!
Second time in, got a slice, thought Id go back. Got a Sicilian w/ broccoli rabe and sausage. Great crust, actually NOT SWEET and can taste the yeast. Id like more broccoli rabe, but thats me. Good value for dollar. Definitely be back!
Friendly service. Disappointing pizza very stingy with the sauce.
So This 4 star rating is for the overall amount of times Ive been here compared to bad experiences. With that said tonight Sunday night January 31st 2021 I picked up a pie around 630 after being told it would be ready in 20-25 min seemed kind of long considering it wasnt very busy at all. The pie itself honestly tastes like it was a large cheese thats been sitting around to be used for slice sales and was re-heated a little to long. This was definitely not my favorite meal and I probably will not order Sunday nights if this is how the orders are treated. Any other night I love its amazing always good from pizza to heros to dessert. So would of been 5 stars but this night was bad. Very disappointing I was looking forward to pizza 🍕. Oh well it happens. Cheers!
For those who lack restraint, it would be very easy to go broke in this place. The varieties of pizza are plentiful, and the ones Ive eaten so far have all been excellent. The Chicken Bacon Ranch and the Pastrami & Provolone are my favorites of all the specialty pies. On days Im feeling less adventurous, I tend to go with sausage and extra cheese slices. Those are great as well, not least of all because they actually slice the sausage meat instead of using those balled up pig droppings commonly found on lesser pizzas.Time and time again, I have proven to my cousins that the pizza from American Pie is far superior to that of their favorite pizza place in town. You can taste the effort and stress that go into each pie, and though it may sound gross, its actually very palatable and rewarding.The staff there greets me happily, which is always nice. The seating can be a bit cramped at times, but I think the food is best enjoyed with Netflix and an ottoman anyway. I havent tried the frozen yogurt yet, but they offer many different flavors that are always very enticing.American Pie is a welcome reprieve from the cardboard crusts and terrible tomato sauces of certain chain pizzerias. I definitely recommend this place for your pizza needs.
Pretty good pizza. Pepsi only!
I have been eating here for years and it’s absolutely delicious. I like to order plain slices everywhere to compare pizzerias and they have the best plain slice recipe ever, I say recipe because they have changed the way the are being made.The flavor is the same and delicious but I feel like they definitely have made the pies thinner and baking it for the same time making them hard when ordered and heated. Maybe they had a bad pie but the last few times I’ve been there they’ve been very thin ...THE reason why I stopped going to PIZZA PLACE.
They dont believe in wearing masks here. They think it is a joke. The staff laughed when I asked why they arent wearing masks. It seems that some folks cant understand about the Delta variant and the MU variant. The CDC suggests to wear one. Idiots. I will not buy anything from them anymore.
I had an issue with my order and it literally couldn’t have been handled better! The staff at the restaurant were prompt, understanding and helpful. And the resolution was so helpful! 10/10 on their customer service tonight.
Love American Pie Pizzeria. The Pizza is really good and the staff is always friendly. I have been there during very busy hours and even though the staff was extremely busy, they always made sure to smile and make their costumers feel welcome.
Now that the third string staff is handling things, it leaves a lot to be desired. Pizza slices never get heated up well enough, nothing worse than the third bite being cold and gooey. The kitchen on the other hand does a great job of churning out delicious Italian specialties. Lobster ravioli in pomadoro sauce is superb. If you are lucky enough to live where the deliver, put an order in and you wont be disappointed.
Ok place for pizza 🍕 and a drink, a few issues with cleanliness and too many people behind the counter. Staff should be masked and gloved during present situation.
Great selection of Pasta and Pizza
This is the best pizza in bridgehampton especially for delivery the food is good and the service is better somewhat pricy
DISGUSTING staff and service. Take your money elsewhere. I’ve never been SO humiliated and spoken to in such a demeaning way in my life! One pizza was cold and the other was hard as a rock. Never again. Take your money to pizza palace or elsewhere.
My family just pass by this place. And we are so amazed the taste so good!!
Went here for lunch while my wife and I were visiting Bridgehampton and I have never had pizza like this! It was the absolute BEST pizza we have ever had!! If anyone is in long island make this a stop. I guarantee you will not be disappointed.
This is probably the best pizza place in Long Island. The pizza is great, the sandwiches are amazing (best meatball sandwich ive ever had), salads are excellent and the staff is very friendly. They need to open more locations!
Usually the pizza is amazing but Picked up Pizzas today august 5th 2021 and it was undercooked and doughy sorry to say not good
Great pizza and Italian food 😋
Pizza looks good but tastes like the dough is not proofed. Very dense with a heavy taste of raw flour
Our favorite Pizza place to order from. Always accommodating, Friendly and Delicious.
Pizza is never consistent. I recently ordered Italian wedding soup that was supposed to have fresh baby spinach and homemade meatballs, No baby spinach no meatballs just cut up grilled chicken.
I have been here a few times and have always had a pleasant experience here. They have a wide selection of food and the workers are always polite and friendly.
Just picked up a grandmas pie and it was horrible. I swear it was made a lunch time. Hard crust, not hot and hardly any tomatoes. So disappointing and used to be good place for pizza!!!
Amazing Pizza. Truly the best in the area. Super friendly staff as well.
First time trying and the Sicilian and regular pizza were great. Also very good greek salad
Their pizza is one of the best out in the Hamptons. It is always fresh and their gelato is amazing. The staff is very friendly as well. Highly recommend going here :)
Great pizza, Pat the owner is an amazing guy. Treated his customers the way they deserved to be treated. 10/10 would recommend. Amazing.
Delicious Pizza at a great price
Excellent food and customer service!!! The owner will go out of his way to please you with a special recommendation.
Great food & great service! Perfect for those nights when you need delivery - They are one of the few places in town who will deliver in Noyac,I would recommend the Hawaiian Pizza and the Meatball Garlic Knot Sliders
Olny walk in . Fantastic product. Yummy food. LOUSY DELIVERY record. 1.4 miles away and it takes 2hours for simple delivery. Place is 5star plus plus if you never order delivery.
Best Pizza and Pasta in Bridgehampton. Staff is Friendly and efficient!
Food is amazing... just when I would think I had a favorite, Id try something else offered and soon discover a completely new favorite, until the next time... so many scrumptious choices, so little time!
Pizzeria is great! Food is delicious! Owner Pat is very good person, I appreciate everything!
Absolutely disappointed. Order took almost 2hrs to be delivered. Called and was told we are busy. Food came 1. It was cold and 2. Some order was wrong. Will not order here again.
Best pizza in a 100 mile radius! The staff is friendly and aim to please. Prices are beyond reasonable!
Best pizza on the east end!!
Great service! Andrew was such a genuine human during these hard times. Its great to see! Need more of these places around!!
Great place. Great slice. Always a pleasure
Fantastic pizza. Highly recommend the white slice and margherita slice. Love the rice pudding and tres leches.
Best pizza Ive tried in my life. Diversity of menu, including not only pizza, but also pastas, salads, soups, and even ice cream
Fantastic pizza, friendly and fun stuff. Highly recommend.
But Greek salad of iceberg lettuce very inauthentic disappointing and also small portion. Tomato at this point in the season should have been much much better...
Probably one of the best pizzerias out there, great delivery time, amazing service
The food is always so good and they are friendly and quick to get the food to us! Excellent priced!
Online ordering works great. Busy at lunch and understaffed. Food is good and staff are pleasant.
High quality ingredients and people who really care about making good food make this my favorite pizza place.
My friends dads pizzeria is amazing! Has high quality food
Great Pizza!! On time delivery! Hot! Friendly!
Great pizza ideas. Cool flavors that go together on pizza, they do it well.
It has really bad service and not really good food.....my orders have been messed up 3 times in a row....never again......
Best pizza in town. I wish they will have another location in southampton.
Excellent food and service! My favorite pizza place in New York period!
Worst experience ever. Customer service is at a all time low and not helpful at all will never come here again Im mad I wasted my money here
Was not expecting the pizza to be that good for a late night eat.It was fantastic.
Food is great!! Service is fast and staff is very nice and do a great job!!
Food and service is great! The owner Pat is great person, thank you!
Pizza not bad, nice wine, friendly staff
Best pizza and gelati in hamptons . plus the deliver
Great pie, great friendly delivery, thank you.
Fast, great service with even better food. A Bridgehampton must.
Very nice place, perfect staff, delicious food!!
Amazing service. The owner Pat was so kind.
Great choices! Any pie you can think of!
Wonderful service & the best food around.
Supposed to be ready by 7 but didnt get it until 740.
Fairly priced pizza in the Hamptons
I love their meatball parm heros!
Nice service great food
They have decent Pizza
Really good paninis, good price.
Love friday night deliveries.
Good food, friendly staff
They deliver to Wainscott to some of Southampton
My favorite pizza place.
Vegetable pizza is excellent
Best pizza around!
Great food and service
Good pizza, Good people
Love them👌
Great pizza!
Excellent pizzas
I got a calzone
Great Pizza.
Sorry
Floppy pizza
Wonderfull
Good service delicious taste
Exselite
Total reviews rating 4.3
104 Reviews for American Pie 2023:
Review №1
2021-10-17This place is incredible and the staff is very delightful. I was stuffed after the Stromboli but the pizza was very delicious for my long drive home. If your ever in the Bridgehampton Area this is the place to stop. The prices are fair and you will not be disappointed. I will return for a few more slices.
Review №2
2022-04-10My wife and I have gotten food from here often and every time it has been excellent. They offer a great selection of specialty slices. My personal favorite is the sausage and peppers slice. They also have great pasta dishes and their paninis remind me of Italy. There are a lot of pizza places on Long Island but American Pie stands out. Definitely stop in if you’re on the east end.
Review №3
2022-06-13Their pizza is good, apps are good. Staff is friendly. But the last 4 times theyve messed something up with my order. Cheesesteak with no mushrooms, loaded with mushrooms. Half mushroom pie, half pepperoni, I get half plain. I just wish I could order confidently but they keep messing something up. Im a year round local and order here all the time, thinking theyre bound to get my order right. But it just keeps happening.
Review №4
2022-05-14Great pizzas. Friendly staff and comfortable surroundings.easy to get to and from. A worthwhile stop if your in the mood for Italian.
Review №5
2022-05-25The food here is soooooo goooood! I think Ive actually tried just about everything on the menu...wraps (theres one with bacon that is so yummy) , soups (best minestrone Ive had), pasta (cant decide which one is my favorite), paninis (the veggie one is so delish), pizza (Ive had so many kinds and they are all so good-I especially love the crispy crust)! I highly recommended this place if you are in the area!
Review №6
2022-06-24Hefty kid gave me back my change folded and palm down. Thought that was odd. Gave spare change as a tip anyway. Only after I left I realized I was shorted a $10. He must have guessed correctly that Im not the type for confrontation. Sad because I went there to save money compared to going to panera, and ended up paying more.
Review №7
2022-07-06Only restaurant open at 8 pm on July 5. Great pizza. Good service. Casual. Take out.
Review №8
2018-03-11Best pizza on the East End. Crust is perfectly crispy but not too thin. Sauce is wonderful, not too sweet. Great service, too. Casual, simple environment with a TV on the wall usually showing sports.
Review №9
2022-01-05We were on vacation and of course my sons wanted pizza. We were greeted by a personal staff. We tried pizza we had never had or heard of. It was a perfect experience and we look forward to eating here again our next vacation to Bridgehampton. It was neat hearing them address us from across the restaurant “Hey Arkansas! Everything tasting great? Need to try anything else?”
Review №10
2022-03-12Food is great, staff is friendly, owner pat is a great business owner and does everything he possibly can to make the customer happy wish I could give more then 5 stars, well done guys