Amish Market East image 1Amish Market East image 2Amish Market East image 3Amish Market East image 4Amish Market East image 5Amish Market East image 6Amish Market East image 7Amish Market East image 8Amish Market East image 9Amish Market East image 10

Categories


Phone: +1 212-370-1761
Site: https://www.eastamish45.com/
Opening hours
  • Monday:7AM–9:30PM
  • Tuesday:7AM–9:30PM
  • Wednesday:7AM–9:30PM
  • Thursday:7AM–9:30PM
  • Friday:7AM–9:30PM
  • Saturday:8AM–9:30PM
  • Sunday:8AM–9:30PM
Edit info

Total reviews rating 4.4

199 Reviews for Amish Market East 2023:

Review №1

2022-06-14

It was packed with unique groceries but incredibly neat and well organized. We especially enjoyed the wood fired oven pizza. The prices were reasonable considering the neighborhood.

Review №2

2022-05-08

Great selection of Olive Oils in particular as well a vast variety of top notch food items any traveler might want, to satisfy an impromptu get together.

Review №3

2022-06-22

Very convenient to our hotel. Nice selection of food for a small store. Many kinds of cheese and fruit.

Review №4

2019-08-31

Fantastic grocery store that stocks pretty much everything you need. Its very vegan friendly as they stock vegan wraps, snacks, tofu, hummus, amazing fruit and veg, plant milks, vegan dairy products etc,. But it also has a great meat counter, cured meats, dairy etc too. Only downside is NYC prices but this isnt their fault.

Review №5

2022-06-14

Cute market. Lovely selection of cheeses, crackers, bread, fruit. Very handy to our hotel.

Review №6

2021-07-30

What a deal! A salad with choice of protein, and 4 toppings for $8! It’s a big salad and a great price for this part of the city. It’s comes out to alittle under $9 with tax! They have a lot of vegetables and toppings too.

Review №7

2022-02-09

I walked in and walked right out. Where was the amish food or even amish people. The name is deceiving. I live in a state where the amish are everywhere. I only eat amish food. I know the difference.Amish food has no preservatives so it spoils faster. The amish market I go to has a ton of selections. This place was limited. If the cheese doesnt come from Beemster...its not amish. If the muffins dont have 6 ingredients...its not amish. Amish means no preservatives. I saw tons of preservatives there.

Review №8

2022-05-15

Very good market with selected fruits and produce, excellent options of coffee and pastry. Good place to eat during lunch break

Review №9

2022-05-21

Amazing food choices and quality. Definitely recommend Avocados from there. Also the cheese collection is exquisite

Review №10

2021-07-20

Glad its open today. Its a Muslim holiday, i was craving fishy and my usual go to Halal food cart guy down by the road is celebrating so hes off duty. Yes they do have food available in the evenings. Bummer on the cheesecake, I guess the pastry section closes early. Ill try again some other time. The food may be pricey but to me its worth the money spent because its tasty.