Amish Market East in New York
Categories
Location on the map
New York, New York County, New York, US
Service options
Health and safety
Highlights
Accessibility
Offerings
Crowd
Planning
Payments
Site: https://www.eastamish45.com/
- Monday:7AM–9:30PM
- Tuesday:7AM–9:30PM
- Wednesday:7AM–9:30PM
- Thursday:7AM–9:30PM
- Friday:7AM–9:30PM
- Saturday:8AM–9:30PM
- Sunday:8AM–9:30PM
My wife bought a pumpkin pie they made there on Thanksgiving and we didn’t end up eating it. The next day when we went to eat it, it was covered in little mold spores. Absolutely disgusting they obviously don’t handle their food properly for it to go bad in one day despite being in the fridge but the worst part is that when my wife went to go return it they were unapologetic. Even though it said Amish market and was still packaged they wanted a receipt to refund her and gave her issues trying to figure out if she did something to cause mold on a still packaged pie. Then finally they gave her store credit and when she went to the counter the woman tried to charge her full price even though twice she said she had $20 store credit for the pie. Again no apology. If you are running a store that you don’t care if you sell moldy baked goods and are not apologetic about it I would be VERY concerned about the quality and integrity of all of their products.
Nice store, very geared toward lunch crowd and prepared foods. Salad/food bar has gone way downhill since covid-19. Id avoid it. Many basic items are very expensive here, but they do have great imported and specialty items. The produce department is also pretty decent. Overall, its an asset to the neighborhood.
I really liked this store. Reasonable prices. Employees arent particularly friendly (not mean either). Wanted fresh pasta but they only had fresh pumpkin pasta which is weird and not in season. The prices of cheese are cheese but I dont know if they are the real thing...parmeggiano reggiano is very expensive and it was not here and did not really taste like the legit one? These certain specialty crackers are $4 a box which is crazy but this place does not up the price at all because in Chicago, it is the same price so I did not feel gipped like some other people say. I wanted to browse longer but my husband was getting antsy...I would return.
Been going for years. Best olives and imported foods in jars. Huge inventory of delicious fresh food including homemade turkish - middle eastern style salad bar. Salad bar is not open during the virus outbreak. Produce is abundant the deli has what you crave and the fresh meat and fish are FRESH. The bakery has only the finest french style goodies to pair with excellent coffee. See for yourself, you will be returning.....seems fancy while affordable and actually simple and down to earth. Management is the best you ever want to meet and eager to please.
Amish Market need to get there act together. There are a few issues i find the fruits are not fresh avocado oranges apple plums spoiled very quickly, very expensive, the avocado if cut a few piece if you leave the rest it turn black, the bread not tasty if leave over for a few day stared to get hard ,the market and it products needed to revamp.The service and staff are wonderful.
Strongly recommended! Ive been going to this grocery shop many times now, and these guys really have the best products that are fresh and affordable. This place really has it all, and Im grateful because their staffs are amazing and helpful. I could not ask for more from these guys because they truly are the best!
This is a fantastic place! The store produces the best price than the other store in town. They also had food bars that offer a chicken meal, soups, sliders, and fries and they were very tasty! They also had some hard to find items here, as well. Every weekend, I was here doing some groceries for the family.
This is the biggest and cleanest supermarket I have ever been to. The place is very peaceful with the right foodstuff you need to make the best dishes. The ease of shopping and choices of product-lines here are just incomparable. I have been to multiple supermarkets and I still choose to shop at this place. Thank you very much!
Very expensive compared to Morton Williams right off 48th or Trader Joe’s down on 32nd. You would be better off going somewhere else. When it comes to the hot food, it looks good, but I’ve had it twice and have been disappointed twice. Better off going to the deli. Also, somehow my Apple Pay never works here
This place has variety but over the years they’ve lost their touch. Vegetables and produce are still reliable but the olives are not the same- they no longer have taste. The quality of their pre-made/made to order food no longer taste as good. I barely go anymore. I hope they do better.
Hi, would have given 5 stars. Lets start that this review is from a transgender Puerto Rican woman. 62 years of age.I am a vegan chef and being new to the neighborhood I decided to stop in. I love grocery stores. Our family owned a nice supermarket in Long Island. I have owned several brick and mortar record stores, also Long Island. I love checking every isle of a new market.The store is warm and inviting. Clean, very well stocked. Excellent and expansive selection. It was amazing.However as soon as I waked in, designer coat, high end make up, two facial masks and cute boots AND carrying a green vegan Lillys bag, two produce men sort of appear quickly. One is sort of in front of the great price of (1.49) fresh brocolli I want to reach. I say excuse me, he chats to the other a few words in Spanish. One of them being roba. Which is the word steal in Spanish.I was dissapointed. The cashier clerk, not friendly. On my way out a woman from behind the counter came out stood by the exit. Maybe I had some Rolex watches in my bag?!This happens often enough. I get it. But its really tired.I will continue to shop here. They have vegan products Big Apple Market does not carry. Nor has Big Apple Market ever racially profiled me.I could continue going to Whole Foods as the prices are cheaper. I am not followed there. Otherwise a very beautiful and lovely store.
Its a nice little grocery store, but I wouldnt make a special trip there. However, if youre in the neighborhood, its worth a visit. They have a good selection of fruits, vegetables, meats, cheese, bread, pastries, and prepared foods to-go. Also, everything at the hot/cold bar is discounted after 6:30 p.m. However, dont order anything until theyve put up the discount sign or you pay full price!
I live in the neighborhood and stop by for one or two items whenever I dont feel like going further out. They carry a few vegetables that I cant find in other markets. Fruits arent always fresh - I picked up two bags of banana once, and they were both partially rotted. Overall they have a good selection of products. However, some products are grossly overpriced (i.e their Fage. Yogurt 35.3 oz is $8.99 vs approx $6 at Whole Foods or Target). This kind of price difference reminds me its probably better off to shop somewhere else.
This place is quiet the experience, I didn’t expect it when coming in. There’s so many options and I write this review after having a lot of them. Sandwiches are all Boars head and HUGE definitely worth it. They don’t skimp. Depending what your definition of ‘personal is’ id say the personal pizza is worth the $7. Salads are pretty large too and come in an awkward shape but they’re filling. They also have a coffee / cake section. They steam the Milk in your coffee, don’t get that in many places anymore. Expect to pay ~$15 for lunch which isn’t bad for NYC. it’s also a supermarket so they got a whole ton of meats and canned goods as well.
Decent gourmet food market and lunch spot in midtown. When I used to eat gluten, the sandwiches and pizzas were really great. I havent eaten them in a while, but I imagine they are still good. The soup selection is decent and the salad bar/ hot food is fresh and delicious.
Your average pricey grocer, with a few hidden price treasures. Avocados come in bags of 4 only, for $5. They have fresh ginger for about $1 per big piece. The raw meat in the lower section of the store (hidden behind the hot food trays) was abismal - had only 3 packs of chicken breast for $12/lb and the red meat looked old.Cheeses and olives seemed like great prices for good quality stuff. During weekday lunch, the hot food and salad bar were packed.Checkout in the lower section of the store is painless and quick. At the higher floor, I got stuck in line for the cashier because it lines up adjacent to the build your own salad line. Once I figured out I was standing in the wrong line *not the only person who did this lol* I was out in no time.I do wish theyd offer a rewards program, a phone number for points or specials, anything! They do not accept coupons. I did find a dozen cage-free medium eggs for $3, though.
I love this place--its right around the corner from my apartment and I go in daily....sometimes twice for coffee. The selection of market products is outstanding and there is always something new to choose from. The baked goods live up to the Amish tradition...Im actually on my way over now for a macaroon and large coffee to kick off the day.
The sushi seems to be one of their forgotten items, so let me quickly go over it. In the kind of weird lunch land of East Midtown, the take-out sushi at Amish Market is alright. Good sized rolls and pieces, with a pretty decent variety past the standard tuna, salmon and California rolls.Im not a fan of brown rice sushi, but they have a large selection of it My biggest problem is the price. An eight piece salmon roll shouldnt be in the neighborhood of eight bucks.In the end though, theres not enough value. Unless youre one of those crazy people who gets full on very little sushi, or has lots of money to spend, this place may not be for you.
This is the least Amish store ever. That said, *it is* a nice grocery store with an extensive on site prepared foods section and cafe bakery. The hot/cold food bar is ideal for a quick tasty meal coupled with the in store seating. Everyone Ive seen working there came across as friendly but not in a fake paid-to-smile sort of way.
We thought that since this place was down the street, it was merely going to be a convenient place to stock our timeshare fridge. Once we got there to look around, we were very happy with the healthy choices they have to offer. Definitely please with the quality of products they carry, and the prices. I wish they had a location close to our house.
Have been eating food from the food bar for over 1 yr & 4 months. I never had a bad experience until today. 1st I was told by an employee that the food would be discounted by 30% starting at 6:30pm. Since it was already 6:18 I decided to wait. 6:30 came and I got my container of food. It was now 6:35 and I went to the register where I was told there was no discount until they put up a sign. I asked the manager about it and he said there is no specific time and asked me who told me 6:30. I pointed out the worker that told me and the manager said he wouldnt say that. So basically he was calling me a liar... We are talking about $3... Pretty bad customer service especially for a manager. Thanks to him I will be taking my weekly business to a place where I am not treated poorly. This is NYC, plenty of options.
Amish Market is well stocked high quality neighborhood market for our midtown area. The produce is fresh with a good selection. They have a food take a way section with food that is fresh and well prepared. The market represents a good combination of price and quality.
I have been eating food from the food bar for over 1 yr & 4 months. I never had a bad experience until today. 1st I was told by an employee that the food would be discounted by 30% starting at 6:30pm. Since it was already 6:18 I decided to wait. 6:30 came and I got my container of food. It was now 6:35 and I went to the register where I was told there was no discount until they put up a sign. I asked the manager about it and he said there is no specific time and asked me who told me 6:30. I pointed out the worker that told me and the manager said he wouldnt say that. So basically he was calling me a liar... We are talking about $3... Pretty bad customer service especially for a manager. Thanks to him I will be taking my weekly business to a place where I am not treated poorly. This is NYC, plenty of options. Good riddance Omish Market.
Went to pick up some essentials today. Noticed some non-name brand disinfectant wipes in the window - those wipes in cylindrical container similar to what Clorox makes. Couldn’t find those anywhere in a while so I decided to buy four from here. They were $19.95 each!! Talk about price gouging!
AMISH DOES NOT TRUST CUSTOMERS - I have been coming to this place for many, many years, since it opened, as it is close to my work at the United Nations - until last month. The manager, Mr. Attila, apparently has instructions from senior management not to trust anyone. The cashier did not believe me when I said I had used a 25 cent little package of butter on my bagel, so she wanted to charge me more. She had asked me to fetch the small butter bag from the garbage bin to prove I was telling her the truth (!). Mr. Attila apologized three times, but still did nothing to correct the situation. He explained that some people had tried to take advantage in the past, so the cashiers have to act in this way. He also said that these things go all the way up to senior management. So, after spending thousands of dollars having lunch at the AMISH MARKET everyday, I am making the AMISH MARKET senior management aware that you may lose me as a customer because of 50 cents. Does that make any sense in terms of customer relations, senior management? Bye, bye, Amish Market.
Total reviews rating 4.4
199 Reviews for Amish Market East 2023:
Review №1
2022-06-14It was packed with unique groceries but incredibly neat and well organized. We especially enjoyed the wood fired oven pizza. The prices were reasonable considering the neighborhood.
Review №2
2022-05-08Great selection of Olive Oils in particular as well a vast variety of top notch food items any traveler might want, to satisfy an impromptu get together.
Review №3
2022-06-22Very convenient to our hotel. Nice selection of food for a small store. Many kinds of cheese and fruit.
Review №4
2019-08-31Fantastic grocery store that stocks pretty much everything you need. Its very vegan friendly as they stock vegan wraps, snacks, tofu, hummus, amazing fruit and veg, plant milks, vegan dairy products etc,. But it also has a great meat counter, cured meats, dairy etc too. Only downside is NYC prices but this isnt their fault.
Review №5
2022-06-14Cute market. Lovely selection of cheeses, crackers, bread, fruit. Very handy to our hotel.
Review №6
2021-07-30What a deal! A salad with choice of protein, and 4 toppings for $8! It’s a big salad and a great price for this part of the city. It’s comes out to alittle under $9 with tax! They have a lot of vegetables and toppings too.
Review №7
2022-02-09I walked in and walked right out. Where was the amish food or even amish people. The name is deceiving. I live in a state where the amish are everywhere. I only eat amish food. I know the difference.Amish food has no preservatives so it spoils faster. The amish market I go to has a ton of selections. This place was limited. If the cheese doesnt come from Beemster...its not amish. If the muffins dont have 6 ingredients...its not amish. Amish means no preservatives. I saw tons of preservatives there.
Review №8
2022-05-15Very good market with selected fruits and produce, excellent options of coffee and pastry. Good place to eat during lunch break
Review №9
2022-05-21Amazing food choices and quality. Definitely recommend Avocados from there. Also the cheese collection is exquisite
Review №10
2021-07-20Glad its open today. Its a Muslim holiday, i was craving fishy and my usual go to Halal food cart guy down by the road is celebrating so hes off duty. Yes they do have food available in the evenings. Bummer on the cheesecake, I guess the pastry section closes early. Ill try again some other time. The food may be pricey but to me its worth the money spent because its tasty.