Kerbside pickup
Yes
Anatolian Gyro in Brooklyn
Categories
Location on the map
Brooklyn, Kings County, New York, US
Service options
No-contact delivery
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Mask required
Yes
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Great coffee
Yes
Great tea selection
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Halal food
Yes
Healthy options
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
University students
Yes
Planning
Accepts reservations
Yes
Payments
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Phone: +1 718-769-4754
Site: https://mygyro.com/
Site: https://mygyro.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:10AM–11:30PM
- Tuesday:10AM–11:30PM
- Wednesday:10AM–11:30PM
- Thursday:10AM–11:30PM
- Friday:10AM–11:30PM
- Saturday:10AM–11:30PM
- Sunday:10AM–11:30PM
Comments (199)
Fast and courteous service, fresh and delicious food. Id recommend you take their gyro only on pita and not on any other option. Definitely pair your gyro with spicy ezme and/or eggplant salad. As for dessert, highly recommend their baklava.
Love this rustic deco Turkish restaurant. The foods are good. I always like to order the combination of meats platers. So delicious with yogurt and hot sauce on top of the meats with plenty of onions. The servers are very attentive. I’d recommend anyone to come here for good foods.
Past this place a bunch of times next had the opportunity to stop till today. This place is very busy so if you have the chance call in your order before. Order the Chicken Gryo Sandwich on Turkish bread. Everything was extremely tasty and well cooked. Service was friendly and efficient. Will definitely be back for more!
All the food here is amazingI never use to like the taste of lamb until I went here and now that’s all I getMy go too is lamb and chicken or just lambTheir shepherd salad and Turkish bread with yogurt sauce to die for
Good place, nice food and good ambiance. Parking is a big problem. Dont drive.
I have never before felt compelled to write a negative review about a restaurant, that is, until now. Anatolian Gyro is beyond gross! I ordered calamari from the restaurant via Grubhub, and what I got looked like somebody pulled the calamari out of the trash and fried it up. To add insult to injury, when I called the restaurant for a refund because the food was so bad, the manager said that a delivery person would come by and pick up the food to make sure it was not eaten. LMAO! That is beyond unprofessional! I ordered 4 items and only wanted to return 1. The other food items were not very good either, but I never requested my money back. (And everything was cold) Overall, terrible restaurant with garbage food.
Great food and nice service
Delicious chicken gyro. Place looks clean and neat. Staff friendly and eager to help. Totally worth visiting and tasting their famous dishes.
I have been going here for years, even when it was located on Sheepshead Bay Road.....around the corner now on 16th Street....Still delicious gyros....ohhhh and the same two guys are making them!! The angry looking guy and the VERY angry looking guy, LOL!!!
Extremely quick and polite service. Fair prices for dishes, considering the large portion sizes. Comfortable vibe in the restaurant, many options on the menu; theres something for everyone. Definitely would recommend this place!
Disgusting customer service. Current person who takes orders over the phone should be fired pronto. Ive been eating here since I was born and the workers who take orders get more and more rude over the years. I tried making a regular delivery order and all of a sudden we dont take card over the phone. When I got there in person its now we only take card over the phone if youve ordered many times before, we only take card over the phone when your order is large, and sometimes the machine doesnt work. Which one is it? Why does somebody have to call me back to apologize for the previous person being rude and for hanging up on me mid order?
Here comes the worst service ever. Most of them wear the masks for their neck and still serve your food. They gave me a burned bread too. Common sense and a normal hygiene is missing there along with a tasty food ...
Honestly Mutch better then other places around...Survice good, clean places.However something missong in the test..I definitely recommend to dine in!
Delicious, i would most definitely buy again and good prices. I got the uzbek gyro it cane with salad and bread for about $14. The meat was delicious.
Authentic Turkish Cuisine! Well seasoned and prepared! Gyros are the Best, Kebabs are the Best, the Hummus Dips are the Best!!! Definitely Recommend Anatolian!
Best falafel ever!😋
The food didnt meet my expectations. It was tasty or full of flavor. It was bland. The sauce was too watery. However, the baklava was tasty
For 14$ better if I cook at home by my self
If you know what you want, Call 15 minutes before you go if youre getting takeout. The place can be very crowded.
I thought there are normal place to get Turkish food but There were hairs inside one of the cold appetizers. I saw it too late I puked and I still feel hair in my mouth. also food came cold. Never ever coming back, its disgusting
Love it, I get a Chicken Gyro here a few times a week delivered to my work. Great price, BIG portions. Very nicely cooked food, tastes great everytime, is made the same way each time!
Best gyro of Brooklyn/ Ny . Keep the good job guys . Lamb gyro and bronzino r die for . Yummmy . It’s always busy take-out or dine-in .
Great place and great food. Too bad they dont have an option to dine-in now.
This is most untasy gyro and falafel i ever tried . Guys dont waist your money .
Looks like the owners are changing the way to customer satisfaction vs owners stuffing their pockets with money and dont care about anything else shame on you .
This is our families go to for dinner. The calf liver is a must try and their cold appetizers are always on point. I think their chicken shish kabob could have a bit more flavor, bit its good. Their portions are reasonable so I suggest you get that appetizer or an additional side.
Gyro is too fatty. I did not finish the gyro wrap . The wrap itself was amazing. But the gyro meat was mostly cartlidge and unchewable fat. Disappointed.Edit: decreasing two stars to one star. You definitely do not use the best ingredients possible for the gyro . Please change your gyro recipe entirely. Thank you.
Excellent food. Everything is always very fresh. Great service too. Friendly staff and terrific ownership/management. Everything is good so highly recommend everything on the menu.
Anatolian is like Starbucks. Sometimes the gyro meat is amazing. Other times the meat has no taste at all. I don’t understand how a restaurant can forget to put spices and salt. They make the gyro meat everyday, you would think they know the correct portion in order for the food to taste good.
Very good food. Personally I like the mix grill gyro.fast service.
Literally their food doesn’t taste the same like it used to be . My past 2 orders were disgusting. Salads were not fresh , lamb gyro were cut on a pieces like Kebab , was really hard to chew. Two times I was left with no lunch . Never again 👎🏻
Would be nice if I actually received my order. Apparently my driver never picked it up and the restaurant threw the food out. No offer of replacement or anything like that. Rude female receptionist. Terrible customer service. Will never order again.
I bought food here for the first time and was very pleasantly surprised. Really delicious and satisfying food. I will definitely come to try something else from the menu.
First delicious delicious delicious …😋😋Good Service and always hot food 🥘
Favorite gyro place. Always busy but their food worth it
NEVER GOING TO ORDER FROM THEM AGAIN. The WORST customer service I’ve ever had. The food I ordered came over an hour late with only a quarter of the order!!! The main dishes were missing! All I got was the bread and some undercooked meat! It was late and my kids were hungry but we decided not to make dinner. Instead we thought ordering would be less time consuming and less work for us. When I called to explain my frustration, the receptionist transferred me to someone else. Then that person kept putting me on hold and asking me to repeat the story over twice. Then she said she’ll send my order again. At this point my kids had to be in bed in an hour. I asked her when. She said “soon”! With no remorse. No care. Just “soon”. I tried to explain the details to her as to why I’m asking. She seemed to get frustrated and didn’t have a legitimate answer.It’s ok to mess up on an order. It happens. But to mess up on an entire order, wait over and hour and still get treated poorly? Not very appreciative. I told her I expected a partial refund for the inconvenience. She responded as if that was a joke.To top it off, the food came and wasn’t that great. I’ve been their customer for years. My family and my extended family often ate there. This was the last time.
The food came an hour later, bread was hard as a rock and the food was cold. When i called the female who answered the phone was EXTREMELY RUDE and told me to take it up with seamless. Horrible staff, rude female shouldn’t is losing the business money. Try beyti, much better food cheaper price.
We tried this restaurant last week & it was an amazing experience! We loved the food; especially the salads. The fish is great too. The staff is very polite, attentive & welcoming.This is a small restaurant which is family oriented. Very cozy! The desserts are delicious. We wanted to try something new & we were extremely pleased with the service, the food & the price. Love it!
Havent been there since just before COVID was a thing, but things still taste as good as I remember. The only thing I thought was too watery was the white sauce served with my gyro and the hot sauce wasnt as spicy. Nothing major. Still great food.
If I could give it to zero Stars I would have. What happened to this place.. the place is a mess theres no organization all the orders are thrown on one table and one dirty troll looking guy is the expediter trying to sort out everybodys orders it was crazy. Of course my order was wrong kabob instead of a gyro the Kabob meat was raw in the gyro sandwich was just full of pieces of fat on the menu it says chicken breast the meat is not chicken breast its possibly chicken thigh meat or another type of animal but its dark me tons of fat. Do not go to this place theres a lot of other Mediterranean kebab restaurants
We were looking for gyros near us and boy did we find them! We ordered pick up because, well we all know why. Everything was hot and ready when we arrived. We were glad to see so many outgoing orders because that usually means everything is fresh. And it was.We had a lamb gyro and shish kebab both on Turkish bread as well as a hummus appetizer. Absolutely delicious. The shisk kebab was actually med-rare! Something I have never been able to get! The bread was sublime. The service was friendly and efficient.This was our first time here. It wont be our last!
They are super cheap they didn’t spare an extra plate
Service is trash. Food is hit or miss. Some days it is amazing other days the lamb is gray, bland and cold. There are better Turkish spots out there. Its also very expensive for what youre getting. The difference between a small and a large platter is negligible but the price sure isnt. Delivery is the worst though, hope you like cold, congealed shawarma meat.
I ordered a chicken giro. It was pretty good. But I agree with others. The aerobics is not so good. One of the girls was mad rude when she gave a hard time to another girl because she let my friend to use a restroom. I was right in front of her!
Always very busy. No place for parking. No dine in. Portions of food getting smaller. quality of food getting low. They were better 2 years ago.
The food is fresh the have good service
Waited forever for chicken gyro and simple salad w shrimps. For simple salad with 4 small shrimps paid 22$, got waited forever, probably they went fishing. And famous chicken gyro was cold. Worth experience ever
My daughter and I just came back from Anatolian Gyro. The food was so fresh, delicious. The attention we received from our waiter was excellent. He was attentive and very pleasant. As a gift, we were given cute salt & pepper shakers. We always go back for yummy food!
My first visit there. The staff was nice. The atmosphere was also nice and cozy.I ordered lamb chops to go.You get 4 chops on a bed of PLAIN WHITE RICE with tomatoes and lettuce.It cost about $21.00 plus tax. THE LAMB CHOPS WERE PAPER THIN AND BLAND. This will be my one and only visit there.
Hello.I placed a simple order of chicken gyro & eggplant salad for delivery today 1.21.20at 3:44pm. I called after 1 hour asking what’s going on and they told me the delivery on the way. My wife stopped by to pick up food for herself since she’s worked in the neighborhood, I asked her to find out what’s going on and she asked in person and they told her the delivery guy is on the way, that’s already hour and half after placing the order. I called again after 2 hours telling them I’m waiting for food for 2 hours and they keep on telling me the delivery guy is on the way. Since I guess there was a shift change the girl finally admit she doesn’t know what’s going with this delivery and she can send new order right away.She did send it right away and I got the delivery after 15/20 min with overall waiting time for almost 2 & half hours.The big plate of chicken gyro was full with rice topped with a thin layer of chicken gyro, I didn’t order rice gyro.Bad service, bad timing, bad credibility, bad manners and very average food quality.Not recommended!
Was my favorite, quality if food not the same anymore
Food was super fresh...had the bronzini...could not have been better prepared...skin was crispy fish was moist. DELICIOUS! Beet salad and Shepards salad were excellent and not overseasoned. Bread basket came with warm fresh bread that was nice and light. Excellent Turkish tea and baklava to finish the meal. Service was excellent and place was VERY clean.
Turkish place, perfect for a quick snack, fast practical service, good food feels fresh and provided with care.The place does not allow for an extended stay, is eat & go, but for the price & speed it is worth it. Very low prices I have to say.The entrance also provides typical Mediterranean sweets baked in the premises & imported from different places as well as some kitchen items like the CEZVE, typical coffee pot and other curiosities.Not bad for a quick snack if youre around that side of Brooklyn.
My first time dining here and the food is absolutely delicious. We had the lamb gyro sandwich and we couldnt stop smiling. The level of flavor in the juicy lamb was out of this world. The ambience is warm and cozy with enough room to have a private conversation. The dessert was delectable, the Tres Leches and the Almond cake surprised me with complex levels of flavor. The nuttiness of the almond cake with its soft texture is perfect. The superstar is the Tres Leches, each piece I took with my fork you can see tiny cascades of milk drip down the sides and the smooth velvety texture and taste blew my mind. Please eat here, my waiter was very nice and super knowledgeable about the entire menu and very nice. Good people, delicious food, Anatolian Gyro puts passion into their food, it gets my highest recommendation.
If you are looking for tasty and reasonably priced Mediterranean food, look nor more: Anatolian gyro is just the place. I know this place for more than 3 years and like every dinner at that place. The food is fresh, tasty and portions are generous. I my opinion, salads and meat dishes are super tasty, while fish is ok. A bonus: you can always bring in your wine for free.
Both the chicken and the lamb gyros lacked flavor, so unless you showered them in the sauce, they were bland.
Talk about a place substantially going downhill, either management or ownership has recently changed. My last 3 orders something is missing, I just dont know how this is possible. I ordered for the last time, I called to have my missing items redelivered and they told me to go dispute it with my Cc company or wait 60 minutes. Food was always half decent, but this was the last straw. When theres a million other Turkish places on every corner, someone will pick up my business. If you want to be disappointed after waiting for over an hour for your order, try them, if not, go elsewhere
They are so cheap.We asked extra bread and they did not want to give. We said we would pay for it However, they still do not want to give claiming that the food is not coming with the bread. They were so rude. We got up and left eating. We were shocked by the treatment. Insane! This is what is the costumer service is in that restaurant. They are not hungry business. That`s why they do not care what you think and what you will say about them. Be careful, you may get the same treatment!!!
Really good Manti! So my husband says
The best gyro in Brooklyn, very tender and pita was fresh, only problem was to find parking.
This place been much better back in a day, but recently changed for the worst. One of the examples: ordered a food today, we in the same zip code, waiting for 1 hour and 52 minutes, calling back. Spending another 7 minutes till they able to figure out what has happened. The answer: no, you placed it just an hour ago, we got record the fact that I have a call log in my phone and sitting here with guests waiting means nothing. So, where is my food? The delivery guy just left with your order. Two hours passed while Im waiting, third coming. Also, the receptionists girls there for some reason become very rude and obnoxious. But if you come to the place and speak to the cooks or the cashier guys everything is still good, they apparently know how to deal with clients. Ive been going to and ordering out from this place for the last 15 years, but recent service changes making me change my mind.
This is one of the best turkish restaurant in sheepshead bay area.Its quite cheap and definitely worth the money you will spend..Try their lamb chops, shish kebabs and my fav is calfs liver, and in sweets their bakhlava is great too.The spot is in really nice place...Near the stationNice and clean,Stuffs are much friendly and welcoming.Suggested highly....
Theyre not looking for cleaning. The customer came in restaurant with his dog. Dogs fur was flying towards to grill. I told employees and they said that we cant do anything. Near the register I think so manager or owner was talking which is dog owner and he said that no no no its not flying for. Employee told him too. That night I didnt eat my food and put garbage. When I was leaving from location while dog and owner go inside the restaurant again. I will never go there again. Worst place in Brooklyn.
Good food but weird rules. Ordered take-out but had to stay and wait with kids to be picked up , but they kicked me out forcing me to feed two kids and a baby outside sitting on a hydrant. This didnt make any sense. I was very very upset. I eat their food, order for the office and home. This is the most strange thing to me.
Ive been coming here for years. Customer service always sucked but today when i placed an order through post mates and received only 1/3 of my order, it reached a new low. The receptionist who barely speaks english was rude over the phone and the manager refused to come when asked for. It took over two hours to receive my order from them. Definitely done ordering from this place.
Tasteless food and over priced. Definitely not going there again.1 Star.
Another disappointment. Was very unsatisfied with the long wait a couple of months ago but decided to give it another try. This was definitely my last visit. Ordered chicken and lamb shish for pick-up. After the promised 15 min 1 order was ready, however I ended up waiting another 20 minutes for the second plate. Came home to open two chicken orders. The disaster didnt stop there. The chicken was extremely dry and the plate was full of shredded lettuce and onions instead of a salad. Definitely avoiding this place at all cost from now on and suggest others to do the same if you care how your meal tastes
My favorite , the best octopus salad in the world!
Food have always been great. Very happy to see that they are doing well with the pandemic. However, just took a lot longer than expected just to get 4 gyros.
I have been ordering from them for a few months and it was always from Seamless. And today I called to the restaurant to place an order for the delivery. I never had an issue with the food, but today I was surprised. First the food took more than an hour to be delivered. When my food arrived It was cold. I called the restaurant and the girl who answered the phone told me that I was far.So I googled how long to drive from my location to their place. It showed me 10 mins . But I checked the time when I called the restaurant the 2nd time and when the delivery guy called me (18 mins ). I am so disappointed with the delivery service.
Update a year later: didnt deliver my snapple and then refused to refund me for it. I dont know why I expect common decency when I order from there twice weekly, but I guess I ask for too much as they cannot just refund me for a $3.00 Snapple. Oh and then hang up when you ask them to talk to a manager since they said only the manager could do a refund.Took over an hour to deliver food, which was not my complete order.. I have now been waiting over another an hour for the salad that they forgot. Horrible service. Ordered at 6:30 pm and it is currently 9 pm and I still do not have my food. They also refuse to allow me to speak to a manager about this situation.
Web site to order is 100% broken... order a large meal get a regular in a large container and for the money spent this place is becoming a rip off. it used to be order a large it was packed now its 1/2 empty. disappointed. guessing max profits over what 16 dollar - 18 dollar large that is about 3 dollars in cost for them they still short change it... very disappointed. used to be better going down hill.
We went to get pick up for dinner, and the service was terrible. Employees are very rude and disrespectful to customers. When we brought the food back home and started eating everything taste have cooked and hard to chew. The lamb gyros tasted old and disgusting. I do not recomment this place, they are too busy and do not care about their service and quality of food. Most of my friends told me to not go there, but i still went just to give them a chance, but this was my first and last time.
We had dinner from them the other night and the food was excellent. I would definitely from them again. The portions were also very good amount.
Great neighborhood gyro place. Maybe the best I have ever had. Get the lamb on Turkish bread and you will not regret it.Great taste. The place is also very clean and all open, you can see the food being prepared.
I have never been disappointed! A perfect place for some Turkish food. It would be nice if they gave 1 or 2 more sauces for delivery without charging though :).
Rock solid, dont get the shrimp tho. Everything is good. Faves include spicy chicken soup, lentil soup, falafel, gyro to the baklava and brown top pudding. Site is a little slow tho. Delivery is always fast and orders are correct.
The new location is bigger, cleaner and way better. It seems these guys are doing fine.The place is more like a casual cafe togo rather than a restaurant, however there waiter and busboy service. Meat food was just ok as in dozen of Turkish restaurants nearby but nothing impressive. Chicken kebab and lamb gyro were too dry and salty. Its weird because I expected gyro to be their signature dish. On the other side salads were much fresher and tastier than their competitors. Dessert was very good as well.Positive experience overall but I wish they improve their fried meat dishes.
Food cooked to order. Hot and good
Update: this place went from very good to not so good in fact its horrible.I will not order from this restaurant in the future and I no longer recommend it !!!On my last 3 orders it took over an hour for the delivery to arrive and the food was lower quality the it was in past and the salids was not fresh...This is a restaurant to avoid because on my last order the food made me sick ....I have ordered from here many times and i must say it is very good.Very fast delivery so the food is still very hot and fresh.
Warm atmosphere. Very tasty food. Both nice and polite people running the place. Wish i lived in the area so that i could eat here more often. The chocolate cake is amazing!
Dont know how the food tastes because i cant get my order of a soup and chicken gyro for hour and half and i live 6 blocks away on emmons and Nostrand. If you dont speak Russian dont bother, noone speaks English well enough to figure out anything. I called put me on hold 15 Minutes, then i called back, they still couldnt figure that out. Then hung up on me, never got my food after 130 minutes and now have to order elsewhere
Excellent food and great service and The lamb chunks are amazing!
What happened to this place? This used to be my favorite gyro spot in NYC for over ten years. I have recently visited this restaurant and was disappointed.The Shepard salad which used to the best Ive tried does not taste the same way it used to. Whoever cut the vegetables didnt even cut them to consistent size. It looked like the salad was prepared by a child.My favorite dish has always been the lamb gyro with rice without the vegetables. The last time I dined here the gyro was flavorless and the rice was overlooked.I really hope that this restaurant which has recently been sold to new owners re-evaluates its quality and recaptures the one of a kind flavors which it previously delivered consistently.Updated 6/15: Since my review three months ago this place has gotten even worse. The Sheppard salad which I have been ordering for ten years has lost several ingredients and has been pared down to tomatoes, cucumbers and onions topped with a ridiculous amount of feta cheese to cover what it lacks.
Used to like this place. The quality of food has gone down tremendously. Last couple of times weve ordered from them, food was not fresh. Salad was made at least couple of days ago, it was fridge cold with mushy old tomatoes and smelled horrible. Same applies to the liver appetizer, which was stale and was made a while ago and was only heated in the microwave. Not coming back.
They serve shawarma or Doner kebab both chicken and beef. Their serving is quite fast. The food is delicious and the price is affordable. On the other hand, their place is small is it not very comfortable to it there when it is crowded. Yet, they have delivery service too that can be a good option. Overall, I like it and it deserve 5 stars.
The worth Turkish food ever.The rice and lamb jiro disgusting . I.ll never gonna order food from this place again.
As a customer for over 8 years, they have gotten EXTREMELY WORSE. On multiple occasions they would bring orders that I wouldnt even feed to my dog. Soggy food upon delivery! Last time I ordered, I waited for over 1 hour and 40min. DISGUSTING!
I usually dont write bad reviews but the service in Anatolian gyro made me so sad and angry that I just cant stop myself from sharing.I have been their customer for more than 12 years. They usually had fresh food and nice service.Few days ago I called them and placed an order for a pick up. My husband and I got two wraps with grilled chicken.When we started eating both of us were surprised that in two sandwiches the chicken was burned to that point when it gives you disgusting bitter taste.So we opened up the wraps just to see if maybe we were lucky to get those pieces on our first bite. But unfortunately both wraps are filled with charchoral colored pieces of chicken...I called Anatolian gyro and told the lady who picked up that the chicken in both sandwiches was burned. Her response was: “ No, it was not”So I made my husband go back to the place to show them. They were extremely rude! And they did not offer to exchange the wraps or return the money. Their response was: “ sometimes it happens”....So I called them, after hanging up on me several times, I succeeded and asked for the manager. The same lady told me the manager was on vacation and gave the phone to another nasty lady. Who told she doesnt understand what I want and they would accept the wraps if they were not bitten.I am wondering how we supposed to find out that the chicken was burned obviously I dont have an xray vision.So instead of an appropriate customer service I got rude attitude and spoiled food.Anyways after few hours I felt sick and nauseated. I guess those few bites of burned chicken didnt go along or maybe the meat was not fresh and they decided to grill it deeper to kill the smell.I would never ever buy from them again.
Very Expensive and the food is not good 🤮
Food is very fresh and very tasty. Lamb jyro tastes great as well as Russian salad!!! Service is Amazing!!! Kids loved French fries!!!! Very friendly and kind staff!!! I came in with my 2 small children and everyone from the staff was so nice and friendly to us!!! Ever since, my husband and I order from Anatolians almost every day!!!
The food was great & the rice was on point. Overall, a nice Turkish spot. Me & my homie ordered a platter & wrap with I think a side order & the price was really good for everything!
The food was usually good been going there for years . I ordered chicken kabob one skew was fine the other skew was raw in the middle . I told the waiter he just gave a blank stare. Told the manager he said nothing not an apology not a replacement for the half the meal not being good
AWFUL service. Been waiting for my delivery for 2 hours, food came cold and lamb was undercooked. When I called the restaurant to find out about my order, the girl hung up the phone on me. If you guys dont know how to do deliveries, then stop. Your business is disappointing. Also get some polite people working for you.
Presentation and restaurant atmosphere is nice! Thats about it! Food gives major heartburn and if youre lactose intolerant avoid the gyro as they use milk! I curse these people! Ugh!!! The first time I asked how the food was prepared, they lied to me! Never going back!
Not even worth the one star. Food came super fast it was still cold. The lamb Gyro had more fat than meat. This place sucks I’m never ordering from there again!
The best Turkish restaurant in Sheepshead bay. Flavorful amazing food. Their delivery is quite fast and so is their in-restaurant service. Personally, I feel that their Adana Kebab is an amazing choice, along with any of their soups. 10/10
I have been to this place many times before but for the first time I decided to order it was the worst customer service I could receive. I placed my around around 12:57pm it is now 2:40pm I havent received my food. This was unacceptable I called around 1:57 to see what was wrong they said I gave them the wrong phone number but I know for sure I didnt because I made her repeat it more than once to me and she was correct. Im completely annoyed at the moment. I honestly shouldnt pay for the food at this point. 1. They are late with my food. 2. The person taking my order seems either annoyed and doesnt want to work right now. WORST SERVICE I HAVE EVER HAD IN A LONG TIME!
Food is tasty, people working there are nice so one star for each, I was gonna do 0 or 1 without these, reason for that is that I paid 17.5$ for one Shawarma, thats not how it works, also thats not how it should be working in this neighborhood either its not Manhattan, my suggestion is that owners/management need to re-evaluate pricing, revenues gonna grow too as a result
I placed an order at 715pm through seamless. Estimated delivery time stated 755-815. 815 i called the restaurant over and over again. No answer. I called seamless. At 830 after waiting on hold the restaurant told seamless it will take another hour for delivery. No one bothered to call. This is disgusting. No delivery takes over 2 hours. Disgusting service
This place used to be a lot better. They used to provide you with accessory foods, eg., lemons and sauce. Now you need to ask, which is okay I guess. In addition, the lentil soup now has too much water in it; disgusting. Other foods are good. Overall this place is decent for the price.
I’m not a bad reviewer ever but this place stays making mistakes. Jasmin the mgr refused to credit me for their own mistake of sending out the wrong meal at 9pm. Honestly the food is ok at best but their customer service is third world (makes sense for a Turkish restaurant). It’s funny but I asked them directly if they are willing to lose a loyal customer for over an $8 freaking meal. This jasmin lady clearly just arrived from a village. Anyways done and done never again will I go to Anatolian. F**k your restaurant.
I am regular customer in this restaurant . I came to order falafel wrap and lentil soup for my husband. When I picked it up and open the bag at home , it was chicken soup. My husband doesn’t it chicken or meat . I called to the restaurant and asked to change chicken soup to lentil and do delivery for me , because It WAS NOT my mistake . The girl , who worked Friday night , on November 15th , said me that delivery only in 2 hours !!!! And DID NOT apologize about this situation . And actually she was yelling at me!!! I asked to speak with a manager or her bosses , she said nobody there. So , guys , Your service is awful !!! I am so disappointed. Never come back .
Best turkhis restaurant in the city probably states Amazing lamb pita !!! Always Quick servis and friendly people.TIP : İt’s always very bussy if you order ahad , it’s going to be beneficial for you, will save U a good amount of time. Just in case...
Amazing 🤩 love the food.
Excellent food. The only 2 problems I had was, as soon as my friend and I sat down, the waitress asked if were ready to order. We didnt even look at the menu. Then as soon as we put our folks down, the waitress came and took our plates away. We werent even finished eating
The food is constantly well prepared and flavorful, cashiers hands out awesome customer service. I really like the cleanliness and character. I highly recommend this spot.
Very rude stuff!!!worst service ever from the Turkish guy in the front. He refused to put rice on the side like it’s a big deal. Never coming back!!!
Very cheap place. never get white sauce or hot sauce. always forget utensils. prices are high .food is ok. hot sauce and white sauce costs them nothing. they charge 2$ extra for feta cheese that should come with salad included. cheap people. Never again
Clean and good food, I prefer this place and often buy from this place, however it is pricey a small plate of gyro and a soft drink will cost you $$$$16-somthing, food is good 👍
Great place when youbeat there. Delicious food. As with all deliveries it doesnt come super hot. But still very good overall I both eat here and order all the time
Came here before leaving NY, what a great meal and restaurant to finish my trip. You have to try the Lamb Gyro on Pita or Wrap, really really good with tender meat! Also the octopus salad is always fresh! Ill definitely be back!
One of my favorite neighborhood spots. The salad has a bit more parsley than what one might expect, the bread comes out hot and the mixed grill is the way to go for meat and falafel appetizer for non meat eaters.
I actually like the food but they’re so busy couple of times I ask for specific things and they keep repeatingMistake on my orderWhoever going to order good luck for you guys
I visited for the first time. We liked kebabs and gyro very much. Overall, the place is tasty and mildly priced. Although, the only downside we noticed is service. Perhaps our server had a bad day :(
Had a mean craving for some lamb today. A friend who worked in the area recommended them and I was not at all disappointed. Not exactly cheap, though not exactly expensive. What it is, exactly, is delicious.... and worth itWill visit again.
The place offers a large range of delicious food. I loved dining here. Staff members are always friendly, pricing is reasonable and the spot is always well organised.
In my neighborhood, I love coming here atleast twice a weak
Came to sure down and eat but they took forever bringing us menus do we decided to order to go. Come to find out its not because they are busy but racist because the next group who came in was a group of white women and they had menus given to them while they were sitting down. RACIST PLACE DONT GO HERE IS YOUR A MONITORY.
The cashier is totally ignored me and was speaking on the phone while I was waiting to order.The gyro portions on the rap became to little. It was a lot more meat before, but price isnt change.I dont think Ill go there again (
Very tasty 😋 I was happy the chicken was not dry like many other Turkish doner (gyro) spots. Coming from someone who’s been to many places in Turkey- this place is great!
I went to Anatolian Gyro to have lunch 2 days ago. the place was empty at usually busy lunch 1 pm hour. the place use to be in other location and was great. Very affordable and cozy. Now they did some renovations. The prices went up dramatically. Before they had half portions, not anymore.The place was freezing!!! it was not hot outside at all but their air conditioners worked in full blast. I was shivering! when I mentioned to the waitress that it was too cold she agreed with me but said they can not reduce the cold air blast because people at the kitchen may feel too warm!Well.. I eat my plate with small 4 pieces of shish kebab and rice and drank a tiny bottle of Turkish water for $17 incl tip in 5 min and run away. It was completely uncomfortable to eat in the refrigerator .2 hours later I started feeling that I am getting a cold. Was sick for 2 days already with running nose and sore throat. Never again...No wonder the place was empty...
Good food, but make sure to order at least an hour ahead during peak times as they are busy.
The shepherds salad is something that is a must try. The balance of salt from the feta and the bitter from the lemon juice makes this quite addicting. The gyros are overflowing with meat and they give generous portions of just about everything served. The prices are quite fair for the taste and amount of food provided. They did get slammed after the hurricane and took some time to come back but along with all the business they came back in full swing within weeks.
Chicken gyros in pita, w everything and extra white sauce. Get extra napkins. Red sauce is very hot. Get a green tarkhun soda and a water to wash hands after and use some hand sanitizer (carry one) and its as if you never ate. Chew some gum, no smell. Otherwise do not eat them outside/in car/at park. Delicious but very messy food. Most of menu is overpriced. Stick to the gyros. Lamb shouldnt be reheated.
Amazing gyro. Fresh great taste. Pita soft. Very friendly staff. And very good prices
5 Star for Anatolian Gyro. My favorite food is gril chicken kebab. I havent found any other place do better grill chicken than here. Add your must try list!
BEST CHICKEN GYRO ON TURKISH BREAD EVER! EVER X2! Also, strawberry cheesecake, Shepherds Salad, Soup etc. Nothing is not Great!Our 1st stop after the Courthouse, as Husband & Wife, was ANATOLIAN!
The food was amazingggg. Loved the cashier she was so good at her job. Down to earth kind of place. Very busy because the food is much better then beyti on brighton beach..
In my humble opinion number one Turkish food in south Brooklyn NY. Everything is done
I ordered at 2:30 pm today online on there page for a chicken kebab plate to brighton beach i waited 40 minutes when i called the restuarant back and they told me they recieved my order and that it would be at my house soon. i waited till 3:45 when i realized soon was taking too long and i called the place again, woman said it was already on its way. here i am at 4:15pm calling for the 3rd time when i get on the phone frustrated and the woman says THEY NEVER RECIEVED MY ORDER. so when i ask her for her to let me speak to a manager or supervisor she tells me he only comes in the morning, i ask her for her name she tells me she cant give her name. the attitude was disgusting and they clearly dont take their job seriously. i will NEVER order from there again !!!!!!!!!!!!!! 2 hours for a chicken kebab plate that was never put in but charged for!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Staff doesn’t follow directions. I clearly ordered a small container of chicken gyro and a large lamb gyro along with two large shepherd salads. I get a chicken and lamb gyro entree with the container filled with rice when I ordered separate salad. $50 spent for a wrong order and they could care less.
Terrible. I tried once and gave it a second chance. Unfriendly mechanical unaccommodating staff who doesnt know the abc of customer service and think too highly of the food they serve. On top of all that they are more expensive then other, same type, places in Brooklyn and Manhattan.
Appetizer platter! 9 different things to taste. (My friends loved the home bread. Served warm.) And the brown top custard. Kinda like Turkish flan.
The meals and service were above our expectations. I really enjoyed the atmosphere of this place. Amazing place to take the family out for lunch.
Ordered chicken thighs they tasted old and dry, almost like they were waiting for a week for me to order them. Not going to order from this place anymore. There are better places to eat from than this place.
Food really good, especially the Falafels and humus! However, they left out one of the dishes we paid for (and the most expensive one). So dissappointed about that!
1 sauce for $100 of food. Disappointing.
We ordered chicken gyro but they gave lamb instead of it.it was there fault but there customer service is disappointing. I will not recommend this restaurant.not recommend at all.
Bad service!... Bad service!... Bad service!...She (women in black) took our order but I think never placed in the pos system as a result we waited like 30 mins than she showed up with one main dish ( we ordered two) eventhough we had soup order and were expecting to get soups first. After I remind her soups, she was like Gelmedi mi çorbalar? with a broken Turkish. I replied with Gelmedi amk. And left our table for good which made us happy. A guy approached with a soup 10 mins later and I had to remind him that we ordered two, finally he brought us 2nd one. After we done with soups, the same guy brought one main dish and I had to remind him again we are two and we ordered 2 main dishes. We just head to MASAL cafe for dessert. We really had hard time to make them believe that we are 2 people here and we both are hungry :). They did their best to make us share one soup and one main dish but after a real effort I won the fight with women in black and we got 2 soups and 2 main dishes. I feel like a hero now. :))
They forgot to send me my drink. I called and they took care of it right away. Exceptional customer service. Great food too
Been here last week.Customer service was Zero Star.Chicken kebab was 5/10.- Adana Kebab was 0/10.( It’s smelly and raw.)
One of the best places to eat. Everything on the menu Ive had has been great. Atmosphere is good for both couples and family.
I love their food. I placed an online order it it took 2 hours. It should not take that long for 3 orders of liver rice n salad. Smh. The worse delivery service ever.
The girl thats with the men behind the counter was very rude and aggressive. She messes up the extra sause that I payed for and all she says is so what just eat it. I asked to speak to the owner and she didnt want to give his name. The girl at the register is very nice.
Terrible service. Ordered delivery was waiting for 1 hour 20 mins food came cold, called them they said there is nothing they can do. I order a lot from them. Never again, there a tons of Turkish places on Sheepshead bay
Turkish guy in the front is extremely rude! Never coming back. Honestly I wanted to smack him
Casual and quaint. Great grilled chicken pitas ! Warm bread and Turkish coffee. The service is friendly and certious. Nice place for a quick bite.
Tried this place once with a friend and I am addicted ever since. I enjoyed the great vibes and delicious dishes and beverages. Highly recommended.
Poor customer service, they don’t do what the customers are asking for.
Placed an order at 7:40 pm just two chicken gyro wrap which takes 5 mins to get readyHowever i called them again at 9:10 pm the lady who picked up the phone said my order is still on the wayDont order from Here other wise you will waste your time you gotta wait 2 hours for deliveryWorst delivery service i’ve ever seenActually they don’t deserve 1 star either
Great Turkish Restaurant in Sheepshead Bay area in Brooklyn. The food is always fresh and full of flavor and spices. great to eat in or for take out.
The food is good and portions are medium sized. I usually get a gyro sandwich here but my only problem is the staff is very busy and sometimes forget orders.
Great Mediterranean food. The prices are decent. I have nothing bad to say about this place.
Their gyro is really nice. It is only thing that I eat in there. I think Ive eaten 15 times already. It is really delicious. I always stop by when I come in Brooklyn.
The MOST 🔥🔥🔥 Lamb Gyro I ever had. Great place for a quicky👌 but they also seem to have pretty good dine ins too, and the host was gorgeous 😳#ChangeMyMind
You dont need their nasty attitude !! better options out there. bad customer service .not customer friendly.. just saying .. this is my experience with them.
Great lunch spot but their platters are really pricey. Love their sandwiches though, very yummy, and staff is on point and professional.
One of the best Mediterranean/Middle Eastern restaurants in Brooklyn!
Always delicious, always busy! I guess the two have to go side by side. Be sure to have time to wait if youre coming at peak hours, It will be well rewarded!
I was expecting to eat a real turkish taste there, but unfortunately the food was awful. I am an almost regular here. All the time hoping for a real turkish taste, but I am disappointed every time. you are not getting wjat you are paying for. The prices are expensive as well.
This place was unexpected. A casual atmosphere, great food, warm and friendly staff. FAST table service. The pistachio rolls are to die for!
Delicious turkish food, especially the best lamb gyro in Brooklyn
Amazing place, amazing food
Disgusting food, tasted like vomit in my mouth. Worst Turkish place I have ever ordered from and I love my Turkish food.
Best place in the neighborhood for the fresh gyros and shish. Their octopus salad is to die for. A russian salad is a very good take on the traditional Olivie salad (w/o meat). Stop by or take out - fresh and tasty. JS
I ordered 3 timesLast time was today , mothers day. Besides waiting twice on hold for total of 20 min. I was overcharged at least $10(1 chicks giro -$12, 1 liver-8,1 babaganush. Extra French fries- 46), the address was recorded indirectly, the French fries was almost raw as well as live(red drippings in the plate).
Staff is always on point when taking order either if your dining in or taking out unbeatable lamb and chicken gyro platters food is always fantastic have been eating here since 1994
The gyro was delievered..my meal ruined meat gives strong rotten odour lettuce all link and bread like a weeks old.i am familiar with turkish cuisine but this is very disspointing
I was call them waile when i driving to make an order for pick up. Somebody pick up the phone and said hold on and was wait 10 minut. So in this 10 minut i was in restorant. I ordered chicken gyro with pita bread and adana kebab plate. They are gave me chicken gyro with pita and adana kebab with pita. 👎👎👎
Nice and tasty gyro, like this place and always come back3 stars because i ask for an extra green or salad, didnt mind to pay extra , the reply was you have enough !!!Didnt want to argue ....But i think if i pay a full price i should get what i want , agree?
The meatiest, juiciest gyros and freshest fries Ive ever had. I used to come here all the time with my boyfriend for a good meal and to watch some football.
Every time I order for pickup I come and am still forced to wait for the food I ordered 20 min ago. The staff doesnt give a craps about nothing you can see it on their faces and their food off course reflects it I wish there were more options on sheepshead bay rd.
Horrible place . Food is not worth the ghastly price and the service is terrible. They also have 2 dollar phones and cant hear you when you call. If youre not wearing a suit when you walk in they will give you dirty looks. Dont expect any better from nasty turks
I think its a bit overpriced but when you taste it, you dont care that much, restaurant looks clean inside and thats nice.
Excellent Gyro with Home Bread (dont forget to ask for the white and hot sauce). Their hummus is fresh and very tasty too.
Delicious meat dishes, great desserts. Interesting menu and very fresh food, which always pleases.
The best Turkish food in the area. Always tasty and quick deliveries.
Ordered food through the Grubhub and never received it. When i called was told that they forgot to print it. Never again
Love their all kind of food, specially Turkish Coffee 😎😎😎
Great Turkish cuisine on Shipsehedbay Brooklyn. Good for a quick bit. Quick service. Very tasty chicken gyro
Food is fresh and delicious! Best Turkish restaurant in the area! Thank you guys for your awesome work!
Disgusting, horrible customer service. “Manger doesn’t speak on the phone” . Bag came saturated in oil. Order was wrong and on top of that waited an hour and fifteen minutes for a delivery.
Best Turkish restaurant in SheepsHead Bay. I am in love with this place. I like very much the Lentils soup, the spinach bourek and fried callamari. I definitely recommend it.
If youve got an appointment to keep, dont go here.goof good negated by slooooow service.
Love the food here. After growing large they are less personal but food still good
Worst food ever, my wife is still with stomachache 2 days ago. Never come back.
Bahlava and pistachio roll is wonderful, my favorite thing about this place, but everything else is REALLY EXPENSIVE the food is too expensive. Bahlava is still good!!
Always awesome!!!Delicious and fast. Thank you.
Total reviews rating 4
199 Reviews for Anatolian Gyro 2023:
Review №1
2022-05-26Delicious food. I always get the chicken gyro platter. The falafel is homemade and amazing. Cheese roll appetizer is amazing. I recommend trying all the appetizers from here, they will not disappoint. Food is fresh and served with Turkish bread. Inside is updated, modern, and clean. They have delivery and take out
Review №2
2022-06-01I have visted many Turkish joints around NYC and this happens to be one of the best.Service is good...friendly yet professional.Food is excellent. Had the lamb kabobs, salad and a few other items. Everything was amazing.Btw the bread is absolutely fantastic.No issues finding street parking on a Saturday night at 8pmWill definitely visit again.
Review №3
2022-01-12It astonished me how much business this place has for such mediocre food. My food was packed in a way such that everything leaked. Also the prices are kind of expensive. Please just go to a halal cart if you want good gyros and lamb.
Review №4
2022-03-01This place USED to be ok, however, lately the food I purchase from them is not acceptable... and its time I go to the myriad of better Turkish Restaurants in the area (Kings Highway alone has three nearby). For example, I just ordered from them tonight about 10pm.... within 30 seconds after I ordered and paid the cashier, my number was called (I thought it was kind of weird, because it was too quick of time to make the gyro sandwich I ordered). I live only 5 minutes away, and sure enough, as soon as I got home I opened my sandwich to find the gyro meat was COLD.... it was obvious I was served meat that was already cut off the gyro and sitting their rather than being made a fresh sandwich with warm lamb meat. For the price you pay, you could take your business to the local competitors who will actually have the decency to serve you fresh cut meat that is warm. Been going here for years, but their service and food has been so awful lately, I will be going to the Turkish spots on Kings Highway for now on.... it is a little further from me, but at least I know I wont be served cold lamb meat that has already been cut off the gyro and sitting on the bottom just waiting for a customer like me to disappoint. Stay away!!! You have been warned.UPDATE: Not only was the meat served cold, but half of it was also burnt/charred. So if you like the meat on your gyro to be both charred and cold (as if it was found on the floor behind an oven), Anatolian is for you!
Review №5
2021-09-20Have been ordering from Anatolian Gyro for years and never expected to have this type of experience. I was eating my gyro and kebab platter I bit into some type of metal object and it scratched my whole mouth, to makes matters worse I looked to see if there was more metal objects I found a long piece of hair. This is just unacceptable I added the pictures below so you can see. This is very concerning. Never eating here again!
Review №6
2022-06-05Used to be a much better place. The shepard salad didnt taste good and the portion was very small. Its so many choices for Turkish food, better go somewhere else.
Review №7
2022-01-03Moving back to sheepshead from bushwick/Williamsburg - first thing we wanted was gyro because we really missed it. My co workers put me on to Anatolian Gyro Restaurant. Hubsand I tried it out as a date night. It was so nice! Atmosphere is nice, waiters are friendly and kind. And the FOOD IS SO GOOD. We live a few blocks away but We like to order in- still fresh, still delicious. We always always always get their French fries and shepherd salad. Their fries r def best fries ever. They’re very accommodating- all I wrote on Grubhub was “I’m pregnant please feta cheese on the side and extra white sauce”. I like to drown my food in it and it costs extra on Grubhub. Only paid for one extra. They did not cheap out on my hubs w the feta either 🙂 always pleased with them for a while so finally giving them the shout out, thank you guys! (P.s. my mom is obsessed with them too ). Delivery men are also always so nice, the one today saw my crazy yorkie jumping out of my arms and he didn’t want me to drop my food and my belly is huge he was super helpful put the bags on my table because he saw I’mStruggling !! 😍❤️😩❤️ pics don’t do justice but I’m too hungry to take nice pics 🙂
Review №8
2020-09-26In my opinion, Anatolian serves the best Chicken, Lamb and mixed Gyros in the Sheepshead Bay and Brighton Beach environments. You can easily order ahead or show up to place your carryout orders. The fresh baklava and European sampler desserts are delicious and plentiful for up to four people. I cant wait for this pandemic to be over so that I can dine in and sample more of their authentic menu offerings. Excellent service and delicious food in a clean and very well run establishment.
Review №9
2022-03-01Truly delicious gyros! This place never disappointed me with food. Been coming here for at least 4-5 years. Just one small nuance , sometimes they got rude people by the cash register… but their food does compensation for that
Review №10
2022-05-20Used to be a regular customer there Sunday and sometimes Thursdays. Every grill person there knows my orders and cashier also. But some how some way I get the treatment of first time bein there. Seriously over many years going back to when there were on sheepsheadbay rd. This is why I stop going there to much of a headache to always explain how my food should be done which is wellllllllllll done with cuts of small pieces in the end. In 1 plate how is that such a big deal to remember??