Delivery
Yes
Bagel Gallery in Smithtown
Categories
Location on the map
Smithtown, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
In-store pick-up
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Health and safety
Safety dividers at checkout
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Dining options
Breakfast
Yes
Planning
Quick visit
Yes
Payments
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Phone: +1 631-360-8406
Site: https://24hourhotbagels.com/
Site: https://24hourhotbagels.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:Open 24 hours
- Tuesday:Open 24 hours
- Wednesday:Open 24 hours
- Thursday:Open 24 hours
- Friday:Open 24 hours
- Saturday:Open 24 hours
- Sunday:Open 24 hours
Comments (191)
Great bagels 24 hrs a day. Super convenient.
My bagels went stale after two days. They feel like a brick now.
I used to go to “24 hour hot bagels” for years just to get a good bagel. Recently- I’ve been using them for catering. Bagel platters. Sandwiches. Wraps. Salads. Fruit salads. Cold cuts. The list is endless... they NEVER disappoint. The food is delicious. Fresh. And a lot of it! The staff is friendly and helpful. And the owners always make sure that they don’t miss a detail. 5 stars all around!!!
Went for a late night stop at the Bagel Gallery. The egg/sausage bagel sandwiches were great! Also picked up cinnamon and strawberry bagels which were simply delicious!
I Gotta say... I Really like this place. The food is pretty consistent. I wasnt a big fan of it before but its definitely got better.
The food is always good, the staff is always friendly and its open 24 hours!
Place was busy but that wasn’t the problem every bagel place is busy in the morning. However instead of making my order correctly, which was a simple bagel toasted with butter, they rushed it and I got a warm bagel with butter. I could’ve told me cat to microwave a bagel with butter and gotten a better result. I only added an extra star because cashier was nice.
A staple in the Smithtown area because theyre open 24 hours. Need an egg sandwich at 3am, theyve got you covered. Recently moved locations, but still the sane great place. Reasonably priced also.
Always fresh and delicious. Open 24hrs too!!!
Maskless employees, a big middle finger to its customers. Also, they call their Italian sandwich The Mobster, equating Italian-Americans with criminality. Average, stale bagels.
Great food anytime of the day, staff always friendly
Great place bagels sandwiches amd its cheap!
Tasty bagel. I went there at maybe 9pm and the guy had my order (two bagels with cream cheese) ready in maybe a minute, minute and a half. Crazy fast. He clearly was used to moving at breakneck speeds, but the bagels still came out great.Definitely qualifies for a long island bagel, but these happened to be warm and it felt like the cream cheese was toasted with the bagel, which was a delicious touch. $4 for two bagels w/cream cheese is also a great price for the bagels they gave me, especially nowadays.
I was charged $15 for a dozen bagels ( with 3 free) last week up from $13.20 seems high
Food taste good breakfast and bagel 🥯 😋 is 👌 awesome
THE benchmark for all bagel shops!This is THE bagel place. Bagels, sandwiches, and being open 24-hrs/day are perfection. This is what a bagel place is supposed to be. Any other bagel place not doing what Bagel Gallery is doing, are just not doing it right.Since the late 1990’s, I’ve come here for bagels before work, bagel breakfast sandwiches before road trips, and late night bagels after the bar closes or just after 4:20am. Since moving out of town, I still make a point to visit Bagel Gallery whenever I am in town.No matter what time of day your life/schedule leaves you craving breakfast or a bagel, we can rely on Bagel Gallery to have our back.THANK YOU Bagel Gallery!!! 🥯Also, I’m very glad you didn’t close. I got sad there for the time I thought you were closing. I’m very happy you just moved down the street. Maybe a better location for foot traffic; although, that spot by 347 and 111 was a great driving pit stop point without having to go out of your way. Regardless, thank you for remaining open.
Ive ordered jalapeno creamchesse bagel. It was okayish.
By far my favorite spot for bagels...always fresh and tasty...open 24hrs
Suprisingly clean & well stocked. Crew handled the large queue of high school grads w/efficiency & patience. AND theyre open 24 HOURS !
It’s so sad that this place used to have the best bagels. They have severely declined in quality and the amount of cream cheese they give on a bagel is so cheap. The bagels are no longer fresh, and no better than Dunkin’ Donuts honestly
Since moving from 347 to 111 they lost some people along the way. First the baker so maybe sold store as well when forced to relocate? I mean you see in the old pictures they sold rainbow cookies that they baked they used to sell muffins that they baked now everything is bought when order a muffin thell go in the back and get this giant Box with them. Dont get me wrong theyre still baked which is fine its just this place definitely changed hands and Im upset because the bagels are not as good 😝and the rainbow cookies are prepackaged too. I frequent the late evening. The bagels are definitely different and the the tall man is gone. The night woman is fine but the bagels arent as good.
Normally a great place, but am here at 2:30 in the afternoon with a long line and only one person working. Unfair to lone employee whos busting her butt to help everyone. Do better.
Greatest Bagels Ever. So many varieties. Great sandwiches. Open 24 hrs.
I visited your store today. I love your bagels, always have, BUT, your one worker is extremely rude. The mid-aged blonde with the chest tattoos really needs to work on her comments/attitude. Shes old enough know better than to belittle customers with her comments. So sad.
The best egg sandwich probably on all of Long Island. Open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, so you can always get your bagel/BEC fix. The staff is super friendly! Theres almost always a line between 5am-1pm, but it moves pretty fast. Food is always fresh and made to order. Love this place!!
The food is very good, if you get the right order.. For a place called Bagel Gallery they really like to give you your sandwich on a roll instead of the bagel you asked for. I hate rolls so this is extremely inconvenient. Also, they want a $25 minimum for delivery ??? I work in an office VERY close to here and I am forced to order breakfast elsewhere.. It is nice that they are open 24 hours though. You get better service in person when you can open the food before you leave and have them correct it because its usually the wrong order. Watch out at night though because the guy who works the nights is a complete a**hole !!!
Nice little bagel shop great sandwiches and friendly fast service.
Been going there 45 years. Best bagels in the area . And open 24 hours a day!!
Best bagels in my opinion. In fact their bagels are so good they actually supply for many other local bagel shops. They have been around literally my entire life and they have always been amazing. They recently changed locations but quality of food and service is the same.
I was visiting my parents where I grew up and needed to take some bagels with me on a 6am flight out of JFK. Not only are they open 24 hours so I could get them at 3am, they will custom make your bagel order (Im guessing if you are ordering by the dozen) if they dont have it. Also, great service.
Overly priced and dishonestI got a regular small soda bottle here, they said it was $2.75, which is a bit much for what it was, but whatever. When I went to check the charge, they’d actually charged me $3.25 for it.
Lovely and friendly staff. Delicious food at any time of the day.My favorite bagel store!I havent been in any other store since I try this one out!
Bagels are delicious. The only problem I have with this place, is that if I place an order ahead of time, I still have to wait on a long line to pick up, then my food is cold. Better not to call ahead.
Great food open 24/7 and priced right, kinda slow but its fresh and worth it everytime - recommended the balboa
I went to the bagel shop this morning to get coffee and a bagel the guy who took my order did not even listen to what I wanted as I was speaking he kept walking away very rude so he got my order wrong then I asked for coffee light he puts one drop of creamer in my coffee I will never come back there again
Only been there once, but the bagel was good and the people were really nice.
I went to this bagel store at around 10:30 PM with my boyfriend. It was one of the most unpleasant expierences with customer service in my life. Old dude working the night shift who obviously hates his job, and that does not mix well. As soon as I entered I was met with dirty looks, awkward stares, and overall anger. When I reached the counter, he automatically was unpleasant and angered, almost spoke over me to make me hurry up my order. And then even after I told him my order, he had to yell at me 3 more times because he couldn’t remember the cream cheese. Worst of all the bagel itself had SO much cream cheese on it that the whole bagel itself was covered. I had to wipe it down to even eat it. But that isn’t it, while using my card in the chip read which takes a few seconds he stops and goes to help the guy behind us and take his order. He’s now filling up containers with food for this man, and it’s been 4 minutes and I was just standing there waiting for my card back. When I finally spoke up and asked he said “YEAH I KNOW.” And gave it to me with the dirtiest look I’ve ever seen. He was honestly hideous and made me so uncomfortable, I definetly will not be bringing my business back to this establishment anytime soon. Truly disgusting.
Love this place. Always come here after trivia night at Tap and Barrel. Delicious bagels every time. Guy working the counter could use an attitude adjustment though.
This is not only the best bagel store I have ever been to - and I have been to a lot - it is just a great place to go - period. Friendly, relaxing with AWESOME bagels and better coffee than DDs. Ive walked through blizzards to get here.
The place was super dirty and there was a guy with a check board who basically ran into me when I was trying to look at the menu -- turns out he worked there. The person who took my order was super impatient with me about what I wanted -- I couldnt find the list of cream cheese and he wasnt about to help me and then he didnt bother toasting my bagel until I said something... Also, too much baking soda in the bagels...
The bagels are not bad except for the one I had today. My big is that they need to remove their gloves while handling money or just have one person ring customers up and not handle the food.
The r family that has owned and run this store for so many years is a dear friend of my family. They lost their son Rob to cancer about 18 years ago and this is the last place I saw him. They family loves what they do and always provide excellent service. I have lived upstate NY, Florida, and Colorado-no visitor from LI gets in without bring at least a dozen bagels from here. I bring 2 dozen home every single time I visit NY. Cathy Truett the found of Chick Fil A would not approve of this. One of his legacy items was that the stores are closed on Sunday because that is a family day. DO NOT close this and hurt a family. Thank you for your consideration.
I love love love the bagels this place has and more so I LOVE their potato salad. I typically detest mayonnaise but their potato salad is the one mayonnaise based product that makes me forget to be squeamish about the mayo. That being said, the customer service is ATROCIOUS. They are timely and efficient, yes, but they consistently have THE worst and most downright rude attitudes. Additionally, half of the employees seem to understand that a 10 dollar lox sandwich comes with a side of potato/macaroni salad. The other half do not. So, every week when I order the same thing I always have to wonder how hard Im going to have to fight these people to get something that comes with what I am already paying for. The food is delicious, but their absolutely disgraceful employees and the way those employees rudely treat the very people who are the reason they have their jobs at all (i.e the customers they talk down to) is not only rude and annoying but really just plain obnoxious. If they fired basically everyone who works there except for the ONE (yes, only one) little lady who always seems to be friendly and have a smile, this would go from 3 stars to 5 instantly.
Well stocked, friendly staff, authentic long island bagels
Good bagels & breakfast sandwiches. Prompt, friendly service, reasonable prices.
Amazing food with amazing owner! Great for breakfast or lunch.
Excellent bagels, super fresh, the bagels were still hot and easily made the 14 hour trip back to Chattanooga as fresh bagels....will definitely be back next time we are on the island!
Im giving it one star not because I dont like a hot bagel enema honestly who doesnt this place has the best hot bagel enema on the island there open 24hrs you can get one any time of day its great I love it but I give it one star because me and my amigo come here every night for our nightly hot bagel enema and turns out tom wasnt working if Tom was working Id give it 3 months 2 weeks 72 hours and 15 minutes worth of stars Toms the best hes a hard working guy hustlings bonds on the side, bond man during day hot bagel enema at night keep up the good work if I go tomorrow and see Tom there Ill change my review to 5 stars if not you getting a big ol goose egg
I would enjoy this place much more if the night shift older man working wasn’t such a rude, smart-ass, disrespectful, unpleasant person...it really ruins my vibe @ 4 am when i really want to jus enjoy my bagel and not feel like i’m disrupting his entire life....CUSTOMER SERVICE = 0 .....bagels are decent tho if he didn’t put 8 thousand pounds of cream cheese just to be a dick.. seriously dude just retire if you hate your job so much...and first and foremost please do not work in customer service if your NOT at all a people person. You really ruined my night sir. I hope no one else had to experience this as I did TWICE i thought the first time he may of been having a bad night...i thought wrong..
Great bagels, hard-working staff. Lines can be long, but they move. However, the store needs a make over and a good cleaning.
The bagel are always hot, the best in town, and the service is so friendly, but at the same timevery professional. Everyone there works very hard and always with a smile. FANTASTIC PLACE!!!!!
The food was ok. There was a long line at 11am and it was slow moving. The staff was very nice. But Not enough working behind the counter. 25 minutes to get my Sandwich and coffee and I saw 2 people get off the line because it was slow moving.
Service was great bagels were just right
24-7 high quality service and food.Bread makes a sandwich.The bagels are excellent.The coldcuts awesome.Ive only had the macaroni salad and it is spectacular.The atmosphere is country style with high 2 thick tables.Its incredible.I drive 9 miles to eat there and I do that 5 days a week.By the way the breakfast sandwiches are to die for.
Very good bagels, always fresh especially like the minis
Very polite help, ordered for pickup and order was correct and tasty
Excellent service, and very good sandwich
The best bagel place on the island. Its not a fancy place but its open 24/7, great location when youre hopping on the highway, and their bagels are second to none.
Fantastic bagels and lox. Great coffee, too.
Showed up last night. Waited on line for 20 mins. Looong line. One person working. When my turn he said he did not have the one bagel I wanted. So frustrating. Plenty of other places to go.
Best bagels in Suffolk County!!! Friendly personable staff. New location is clean and fresh. Ill be there every Sunday. Thanks Bagel Gallery!
Best bagels and open 24/7. The line is always super long but moves pretty quickly no matter what time of day.
Good vibes all around. Best bacon egg and cheese out there! Open 24hrs for service so you can vibe with your bagel.
Love them! Food is good and I love that they are 24 hrs so I can get a snack in the middle of the night
Best bagels ever, sometimes the line is long but it does move quick and its worth the wait! Highly recommend the sunflower flagel.
Used to be Hot Bagels in Hauppauge. Still the same great bagels in the Uncle Giuseppe center.
Absolutely the freshest bagel I have had. The staff was friendly. Will go again !
I. Lived around the corner from here for thirty years.This is the best bagels hands down.I miss it everyday bagels in Florida are not good.
Unbaleavable bagels and great service . I will definitely be back there for sure.
Open 24 hrs . My son loves their egg sandwiches !
Great breakfast bagel sandwiches
This is my bagel place. When I think bagels I will go here every time. However, for the first time ever I had a negative experience. The man behind the counter was extremely rude and when my girlfriend wanted to pay shouted it out as if it were a negative reflection on me. Also, he got my sandwich completely wrong as if he wasnt even listening to anything I wanted.
The Best bagels on Long Island forever!!!
Best bagels in Smithtown and egg sandwiches are on point as well.
Best bagels! I love this place! They offer a wide selection.
They are open 24 hours. Super convenient and delicious food.
Great bagels, and their open 24 hours! Although I wish that the grill was on more often for egg sandwiches.
I like that the place is 24 hours and clean. But the bagels are terrible, mine was hard and stale and the staff are very rude.
Great shop - great people. They have fixed everything we have brought. Fair & reasonable. Like having a friend in the business.
Really good spot, Im happy I stopped here while in the neighborhood.
Food good counter service stunk
Bagels suck and most of the people working there are RUDE specially the older guy who works overnight he was cursing at me for literally no reason at all and acted like it was such a big deal to get my bagel for me and to do his job...he was very anger and I called the manager the next day...I would have liked to jump over the counter and smack his denchers out of his mouth
The employees are the friendliest , they make the best breakfast sandwiches and their service is fast ! Keep up the good job , highly recommended
The wait was longer than expected but worth it. The food came in heavy portions and it was great...
Best bagels on the island hands down. dont walk in like you own the place and youll be treated right. not too difficult
Great service. Great bagels. They keep the line moving even when its crowded
Ordered a bagel toasted and the guy behind the counter started complaining and gave me an attitude the whole time...
Great bagels open 24/7 . The staff are nice and the bagels hot!@
The best 24 hour bagel store. Love the fact they always have hot bagels.
I always go here when, I dont have time to eat at home
Good deli food however cold with door constantly opening.
Been using since it opened over 30 years ago. Good bagels, and variety of cream cheese
Always great bagels and they have mini ones for kids
Best bagels and egg sandwich on LI!
I expected to have more than 2 strips of bacon on a bacon egg and cheese sandwich
Really fast an efficient. The bagels are great and the customer service was very nice.
Eveything you could ask for and more from a bagel spot
If youre from Hauppauge/ Smithtown you probably already know this place. Open 24/7/365, reasonably priced, good service, and again its open 24/7 so its good for a late night.
Good bagel place. Open 24 hours when you are headed home after a late night and need a snack.
Delicious food! Got the hungry man hero and it was bangin!
Highly recommend never placing an order for delivery here. It takes them 20+ minutes to admit they aren’t delivering.
One of the best bagels places in the area, expect long lines on weekends and holidays
24/7 with some of the best bagels on LI. Awesome for late night cravings
Best bagels and coffee on long island.Open 24 hours a day
Delicious bagels and baked goods, available 24/7!
Always go here on Saturday night.
Love their bagles, strawberry cream cheese, only it needs to be consistent quality.
Need a lesson in cleanliness!!!! Wearing gloves doesn’t mean you should handle food and tender simultaneously. That can spread a ton of germs, and defeats the purpose of wearing gloves at all!If you are handling food directly making caontact with your hand please make sure you have no open wounds 🤢ITS A NO FOR ME!!!
I love their bagels ! So good and delicious
Grabbed bagels for the drive into nyc, had limited selection of bagels but lots of cream cheese options.
Bagels always hot, soft and fresh. Best bagels around.
Hometown favorite. Open 24 hours and great for late night bagels
Great place love that they give free drinks on Mondays with bagel
Best bagels in town owner is hands on worker and owner
Simple bagel place in a strip mall. The employees there are super nice.
Quite possibly the very best bagels on Long Island.
Bagels are always good n fresh I love this place
Great food at a reasonable price and quick service
Amazing Bagels everyday. Wish I was there right now.
This place used to be the best ! Now that Toms gone I don’t visit much.
Love this place! Great employees and good food
Fresh bagles everyday and its so close and convenient to my house
Best bagels on Long Island & the friendliest people.
Clean....large seating area...no wait...excellent bagels and loads of options...very friendly staff
Great service and good quality 👍
Always busy. Egg bagels are awesome.
Everything tastes like Chef Boyardee, you have to be really drunk to eat their food
Best bagel place in smithtown
Good Bagels ,always open, most of the help is friendly
Reliable for good late night sandwiches and sodas
Love the bagels. work in nyc this is the closest thing to nyc. love the Bagels
The best bagels ANYWHERE, BAR NONE!
Awesome place! Especially because its open 24 hours!
Amazing Bagels and excellent service!
Their hot bagels are top notch
Great bagels
Best bagels on Long island.
Solid 24/hr bagel spot
Get the everything Bagel. Toasted it is just great.
Amazing hot fresh bagels
Awesome egg sandwich drop the mic
Open 24 hours - just awesome!
A town gem. 24 hours is a real treat!
FRESH BAGELS
Best bagels on Long island
Amazing been around for ever
Always fresh even at 2am.
Good bagels.
Good food and its 24 hours
Amazing bagels and breakfast sandwiches.
Very good
My favorite bagel store.
Love the HOT bagels !
Best bagels in the world!
Clean good food and polite service
Great bagel assortment.
24 hours.
John Bagels is a manly stud!!!!!! 😎😎😎😎
Best bagels in town
Coffee was cold
Delicious
Nice, fresh bagels
Awesome
Awesomeness in bagel form
Great
Excellent
Great bagel!
Yum
Yum
Great heroes
Love this place
Best of the best !!!!!!!!!!!
Best on LI
Friendly staff
This place is an institution
Good bagels
Good bagels
Cool bagels
Where is Tom?!?!?!?!
Awesoooooommmmmeeeeee
Amazing lady at night holding it down solo
Total reviews rating 4.4
191 Reviews for Bagel Gallery 2023:
Review №1
2022-04-24Bagels were hot out of the oven. Light and fluffy. They are open 24 hours a day. Very popular with the younger crowd after midnight for sandwiches and snacks. There was a bit of a line. Had to wait 20 minutes before getting served.
Review №2
2022-04-26Great 24 hour bagel store that has lots of options and great food. Good place to get a fresh cup of Joe in the morning and a delicious bagel. Philly cheese steak here is decent.
Review №3
2022-05-16I always liked the bagel here but this one day I went there and quickly a line of people came in behind me. We had a big order and I felt bad for him so I decided to help him putting the stuff in the bag (I worked with customer service and I now the feeling of a rush). So he got mad and started to yelling at me and be like a jerk. I felt so bad, I thought I was helping him, that’s all. I honestly never want to go back there again.
Review №4
2022-04-15Came here just because they had gluten-free options but they lied! No gluten free products!
Review №5
2021-12-26Very disapponted!! I have been going to this Bagel place for decades. I always thought it had great bagels and made a point to go whenever I am back in town for a visit. However today when I stopped in not a single person working there wore a mask. Not the people working at the register or preparing food in back. About half the customers in line had masks on. A woman at the register was coughing all over. I walked out. So disappointed in this place for the lack of concern for the safety of their customers.
Review №6
2022-02-02One of the best bagel shops in the area. I really appreciate that they sell mini bagels also for those times you dont want a jumbo bagel.
Review №7
2020-11-17Incredible bagel spot! Just go! They have such fresh bagels (with great prices) and their sandwiches are always to die for! Warning though, they tend to be SUPER busy in the AM ( Especially on Sundays).
Review №8
2018-07-13Excellent 24 hour bagel store. The lines move quickly and they always have really fresh bagels. One of their best items is the chicken salad, definitely get it on a bagel and youll be in love. Its also great in a pinch if you need a meal at 2:53 am and have nowhere else to go.
Review №9
2021-10-16Best bagel place hands down. Food is amazing. Staff is great. And they are very reasonably priced and the food comes so quick!! Been going here whenever I visit family and I’ve tried so many other great places in the area but this is the best. Bagels are so perfectly cooked. They will make your eggs any style.
Review №10
2021-12-26Watch who you let cook your food,This lady misheard me and caught a crazy attitude then my food tasted funny