Delivery
Yes
Brooklyn Fare in New York
Categories
Location on the map
New York, New York County, New York, US
Service options
In-store pick-up
Yes
In-store shopping
Yes
Same-day delivery
Yes
Health and safety
Mask required
Yes
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Safety dividers at checkout
Yes
Highlights
Great produce
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Planning
Quick visit
Yes
Payments
NFC mobile payments
Yes
SNAP/EBT
Yes
Phone: +1 212-706-0623
Site: https://www.brooklynfare.com/
Site: https://www.brooklynfare.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:7AM–10PM
- Tuesday:7AM–10PM
- Wednesday:7AM–10PM
- Thursday:7AM–10PM
- Friday:7AM–10PM
- Saturday:7AM–10PM
- Sunday:7AM–10PM
Brooklyn Fare in other cities:
Comments (195)
I think they have the best cut up mango in comparison to whole foods, trader joe’s and the nearest bottega - their prepackaged cut up fruit selection is top notch, fresh and generally amazing! I come here at least once a week to stock up on mango!
My favorite grocery store in the west village. They have everything and it is all so fresh! The employees are super nice and helpful. I go 4x a week!!
I always love coming in here and grabbing fresh seafood or meat for dinners. They always have a great selection of items and a wonderful atmosphere. Staff is always super nice as well!!
Great selection of produce and other items and the staff is always helpful and friendly. And, I love their coffee selections.
We love this grocery store! The free delivery is a life-saver and their staff are always helpful and welcoming in store or our.
Love this store--excellent supply of prepared foods, produce, meats, grocery items with sometimes surprisingly low prices.
Always stocked with what I need. Great produce. Very clean shopping experience.
Decent selection of all the usuals, though I prefer their other location off the L on Lorimer Street, Manhattan Fare.
I like this place because it’s a grocery store you wouldn’t expect in the neighborhood. It seems they’re only found on the west side of manhattan.Atmosphere: it’s casual, a lot of space, fast pace. You’ll have room to push a cart and walk slowly to browse the goods. Feels clean. Smells clean.Service: the staff is mostly found by the registers. They’re young, friendly, vibrant. They remember your names and faces.Food: they won me over with their chocolate chip cookie. I also question them for selling Entenmann’s baked good but I get it, sometimes you want that commercial good. Their brownie isn’t worth it. Get the chocolate chip. The ice cream selection is great. Their cheese selection is a big. Their produce is always fresh.
Had nothing but good things to say about them until recently. Their prices were generally good and everyone is helpful. Certainly appreciated all their efforts throughout the worst (for now) of the pandemic.But I stopped in recently after my morning run to pick up romaine lettuce. It had gone up $4 in 1 week. One week.I know there are supply chain problems but this is too extreme. I did check prices in other grocery stores in the neighborhood and no one has raised their prices as much as Brooklyn Fare has.And theyve stopped their members reward type thing.And trying not to give up on them I stopped at the deli last night. There were 4 people working behind the counter. I was the only customer. All 4 saw me at different points but continued talking to each other rather than take my order. For 7 minutes. Again, I was the only person there. It was around 6:30 pm, not when they were closing up or buried with orders. Just me waiting for someone to take my orderTheyve lost a customer
Great market! Any neighborhood would be glad to have one, especially when NYCs two goto chains make so little effort to approach civilty or even...excitement about food. In with the new! Definitely.
Amazing grocery store with such a wide selection of fresh and pre-made food and all of the standard basics. Love it.
Brooklyn Fare is extremely organized and the staff all very knowledgeable, friendly and helpful. Great selection too.
Great brands and variety, cheaper prices. Always clean. Love it.
Excellent store with very fresh vegetables and an excellent selection of cheeses!
I love Brooklyn Fare, their merchandise is fresh and they have awesome sales.
Great grocery offering and delivery options. Cant beat in the city.
Too pricey, $10 per pound chicken, organic milk up to $10 per gallon
Best grocery in the west village. Beautifully stocked, great options to choose from. Only stressful part of shopping here is the deli area. Considering taking this part of my shopping elsewhere. Try to find anyone to help you and then not feel like a nuisance for asking for turkey or anything. Its hostile at times. For everything else you need its there.
Awesome location and selection of items! Highly recommend
The staff is helpful and the store well stocked and organized
Priced for the neighborhood and not for the quality of the products. The main disappointment is how quickly their products spoil. Fruits are very expensive and the quality is generally poor. Workers are pleasant and helpful. I would like to see a major improvement with product management and quality(alot of expired items are on the shelves).
Best customer service. Decent prices for the west village!
I normally avoid upscale-but-homey-looking places like these (Whole Foods, Trader Horn, etc.) as if they had the plague (or COVID-19), but I must admit that this place is actually very competitive with the average supermarket. While they are definitely upscale targeted (Wagyu beef, anyone?), they also have some very good deals (non-mass produced bread), a wide selection of produce (different types of potatoes, oranges, et.), cheaper pork cuts, varied inventory, and some good sales. On top of this, their store loyalty card gives 2% back, instead of the usual 1%. Larger than the average Manhattan supermarket, with (slightly) wider, but noticeably longer, aisles. Try it a few times, at least, to get a better sense of the place.Update, Jan. 2022: The store loyalty card has been effectively discontinued. Its only usefulness now is to verify purchases made in the event of a necessary return where a receipt was not requested or lost. Still generally better than the nearby DAgostino and Gristedes, however. Oh, and let me add that the checkout is always plentifully staffed, unlike most stores (especially the nearest ones).
Clean, good selection (especially harder to source vegetables), and the line is never long - even on a Sunday evening. All the women at checkout are very nice.
Oh happy day...a big market in my neighborhood to take on Dags. Wonderful selection in each department, fair prices, nice staff, plenty of cashiers and careful, fast delivery.
No frills clean food. Small but cozy and friendly service. I had the grilled chicken and egg special
Upscale mid-sized supermarket for the generally upscale clientele. Fares stock consists of common staples as well as more unusual and specialty items for the vegans, the foodies, and the glucose-intolerant of us. There is also a deli, a bakery, a butcher and a hot table of take-out ready-to-eat items. Much of the food is seemingly over-priced but the upkeep and rent of a supermarket in this hood must be enormous. Thats why there are hardly any other supermarkets in this part of town and certainly none within walking distance. Nonetheless, EBT/snap accepted. Very kind and generally knowledgeable staff.
The two guys at the sandwich area have the worst customer service.. you have to chase them around.. they see you waiting obviously to order a sandwich and they walk around turning the other way.I have to say, the evening girl has the most amazing attitude, always attentive, they should lear from her.
I love Brooklyn Fare, although I often forget that is there! In a neighborhood that is shockingly devoid of lots of great markets (I mourn Gourmet Garage still!) Brooklyn Fare is important. Great produce and quality items you don’t find other places. My only reservation is that the aisle are so tiny and confusing I end up not getting everything I need and feel rushed. But then again, that’s me 🙄
Clean, kind staff and a great selection!
Love it! Really high quality products
Always friendly and love the deli sandwiches
Great selection and the store is large so it never gets too crowded. Meat is a little overpriced.
Beautiful, Clean, Respectful, very helpful, plenty of employees. Good prices. Fresh produce, but one thing its very hard to park so make sure you have someone with you so they can stay in the car.
Pretty good selection, but aisles are so narrow its always hard to navigate. Must they restock shelves constantly?Bought expensive flowers there. Dead the next day and had to be tossed. The bakery is hopelessly overpriced for mediocre quality products. Prices at the checkout do not always match the posted prices. Preprepared food is not only overpriced but never good, often inedible, not fresh.
Thank you Brooklyn Fair for coming to West Village and finally giving us a decent supermarket! Absolutely fantastic variety of fresh food, from fresh guacamole, lemon grass, aloe vera sticks : simply a great fruit and veg selection (literally everything you could ever think of and need!). I love the pasta selection ( a whole aisle), and the deli/cheese is great. I could not be happier with the variety of food and drinks offered, and to top it all off, the staff are so friendly and helpful. Every time I go I get a hello from one of the managers, really quite spectacular for NYC!
Very expensive, cant blame them though that rent is probably crazy. Food is good, prepared food is good. Beer selection is pretty good. The bok choy salad at the deli counter is fantastic. Produce section is great. Cheese section good. Bulk section is okay. Fresh fish section is good I got a nice cut of wild salmon for a substantial price. Butcher section is not bad but as I said everything is expensive.
Pricing is all over the place. Look for decent sales, and make sure the sale price rings up. Lots of hard to find or not so common items. Nice enough sales people, managers are very helpful. Aisles are narrow and annoying, especially when a stroller is headed your way. Peak times are a nightmare (aisle navigation) and the checkout line is long, but moves fast.
Expensive as hell! $12.99 for a container or Justegg!!!!! I get two for that price in Brooklyn and NJ. Location really does affect price.
Great experience. During the entire pandemic they were always fully stocked with fresh produce and very reasonable prices.Great fish and provisions as well
Neighborhood eagerly awaited opening in the West Village as with the closing of Associated on 14th Street, we were without a supermarket within less than 10 or 15 blocks.. I went on the first day - only found 3 items I was willing to pay the price for (all happened to be sale items). The cashier offered me that weeks flier, which I had already seen and gave me a rewards card. I needed some ammonia the other night to finish a cleaning job, made a special trip only to find they did not have ammonia. Okay, today went specifically to buy a bag of frozen peas I needed for tonights dinner, and also to see what else might be on sale with the new weeks flier. They did not have a bag of frozen peas! They had Polar seltzer advertised and while they had a huge section of every flavor under the sun, they did not have any regular seltzer - the stock boy kindly informed me that they had sold out. First day of sale, theyre sold out??? Also all the other flavor sections were undisturbed and full to the edges of the shelves. They had fresh catfish advertised but didnt have catfish in the fish department. Progresso soup was on sale but I couldnt find a shelf tag saying which varieties fell under the definition of traditional and thus on sale. After walking all over the store, I ended up with a bag of carrots! I hope things will get better with time - its lovely to have a market close to home, but if they never have anything I can afford to buy regular price and are always out of sale items, its not quite as lovely as it sounded.
Talk about yummy. Sign me up for seconds.
My favorite grocery story in Manhattan. They have a great selection of coffee, fresh pasta, and veggies. Their fresh meat selection is average but stands out is the general quality overall got the price. Insider tip: the breakfast sandwich is the best bang in the city.
We love this neighborhood market. Clean, friendly, helpful, wonderful selection and sales items.
I live two blocks away and am so happy this place came to the neighborhood. I feel like if you go and shop the sale items, you get great deals. I used to bike to Trader Joe’s once a week but now I only go there once a month.
Great service at the deli counter, friendly and on point. Loving the bakery goods, has become our go-to for holiday pies
Large space what is very rare for a New York supermarket. Great selection of vegetables, fruits / organic and non organic. Meats, cheese, fish, household items, variety of teas, coffees, frozen food, take out. Great option to shop
This place carries quality products, and the workers are v friendly. Couple of downsides: the selection of pastries was much smaller than before, and theyre pricey.
Their food always stay fresh ( organic food on point 😀). Prices are very affordable for the area you live in. They also have delivery. Very nice staff, they great you with a smile, down to earth and always willing to help.
Amazing selection of food and beverages here. They even sell Bundaberg beer from Australia - a pack of 4 for less than $3 (making it even cheaper than Australia, whaaaaat!). You will be able to find anything you’re looking for here. Dare I say that it gives all the other grocery chains in Manhattan a run for its money?
Fantastic, tasty ,upscale selection. The fresh food behind the deli counter(prepared fish and meats , vegetables , etc)is tasteless and stale , though . Other than That disappointment, one of the best supermarkets around
Well stocked with all the essential food. Very fresh. The store is clean and well organized. Great drink selection.
Strange how emails don’t get a reply, though public reviews do🤷♀️🧘♀️
Nice selection, tight space, dont get a cart if you dont need one. great prices, especially for the selection and neighborhood. This is my new go-to grocer in the village.
Some of the worst customer service I have experienced - I was sold raw meats and produce that were out of date but the manager refused to refund or even give credit for new produce. Not to mention how he bullies the female staff!!
Layout takes some learning but fairly priced grocery store for high quality and hard-to-find products
Replaced the old DAgostinos. Its more upscale- they have a nice cheese selection and gorgeous produce. You can get aloe leaves, lemongrass, artichokes, etc while at DAgs you were lucky if they had broccoli rabe in stock. Great add to the neighborhood especially as Mrs. Greens several blocks up looks to be going out of business.
The supermarket itself is nice, but there are a couple of employees that are SO rude!!! Itd be the perfect market if you didnt have to deal with the unnecessarily irritable or snappy staff member or two; every time.
They sell excellent produce and they are well stocked with a great variety of products. To pay is sometimes a hassle. Not enough people at the counter and technical glitches.
Great assortment of food and goods although pricey. They did have soda stream cartridges which I havent been able to find.
Great vegetables, cheese counter, deli, fresh meat and fish. On the expensive side bit not crazy for Manhattan supermarkets - well run, clean and friendly staff.
Better than it has to be in a neighborhood with limited options for supermarketing. Almost always a pleasure to shop here.
Gorgeous market complete with most any comestible you can bring home to enjoy. A world apart from the former DAgostino which thankfully split.
What a ripoff! This Israeli-born Moe Issa owns this chain of ripoff supermarkets and which he initially offered the bait-and-switch a number of years ago and taking over the previous ripoff chain DAgostino by selling a very few items at reasonable prices and selling everything else at higher-than-usual prices. My caretaker walked in her this afternoon to buy some fresh spinach and was astounded to read $13.00 for Organic Spinach. She called me to ask if she should buy it and I answered No Way! This Moe Issa should be tarred and feathered and deported back to his home country where he can rip off his own People.
I just love Brooklyn Fare. Its right around the corner from me. The staff is warm and helpful. Everything is nice and fresh. Besides, Im a Brooklyn girl by heart.
Great selection especially produce. Some of it can be quite expensive. Cashiers obviously could care less about their jobs.
Not very impressed with the quality of the produce. Lots of items here and nice to have a large market in the West Village, but I prefer Whole Foods.
Unfortunately, items listed on sale in their flyer never seem to be on their shelves. I was promised a sale item would be in tomorrow three weeks ago. Never arrived. Today, the brand of ice cream advertised on sale was limited to two unpopular flavors. When asked, Why dont you at least have chocolate? the answer was, We dont have room. Duh! The Greenwich Avenue store is nothing but a maze of room. If youre looking for a bargain, this is not the store for you.
All the aisle were very pack, there were no room to walk. Besides that the store was clean and they had good prices.
Great grocery store. Love their prosciutto. They do need to make better sandwiches. They are quite slow and take a long time. And their sandwiches just dont taste good.
Good place for last minute puck up cause I work close by, has a good variety of things there..
Reasonable prices for the area, a great selection of products, and great weekly specials. More Whole Foods than Trader Joes, but with more of a market feel.
Best market in West Village
Great store with a huge range of different foods, it also has an excellent deli, sandwich bar and also sell pies and cakes. Its a bit on the expensive.
Great higher end supermarket with a friendly helpful staff. My only complaints is its hard to navigate very narrow ailes and the staff is always restocking the vegetables
What a cool little spot! fills a nice void in specialty food stores. not as corporate or big as a trader joes or whole foods. lots of specialty goods, and local fare!
Great selection. Good produce. Nice people
Continues to be a drain on average New Yorkers finances especially those of us who are senior citizen living on a fixed income. I buy fresh bananas here 2-3 at a time for less than a dollar. Standard milk, eggs, butter, coffee is highway robbery at Brooklyn Fare. Brooklyn Fares owner, Moe Issa, is a typical businessman in search of greedy profits and damn everyone else. Wish he goes back to Brooklyn or wherever hes from and drains their wallets. By the way, Issa is a pathological liar.
The grocery you can depend on and trust in at NYC. Deals almost every day. Shop here and save big.
Great selections but the prices are insane. Very expensive. I would not shop here again. Youll get much lower prices in Brooklyn.
They have everything you need. Very organized. Very helpful. Workers cant do enough for you.
Lovely place to visit
Beautiful gourmet store.
This is a great place to work and shop for food or on line, my experience here has taught me self control and gratitude for the ppl I serve and respect...
Vast selection. One of the few real supermarkets in Manhattan that isnt crazy crowded, is spacious, and has good products.
I had a flower deveily at the Brooklyn spot its a beautiful place very big place
Love this store!! No need to shop anywhere else.
Amazing store, best grocery in New York with great prices. Management does a really nice job.
Great. Brooklyn Fare is one of my favorite grocery stores.
Great products awesome experience and the best breakfast bar in the area. Love there desserts
Surprisingly very good prices to be at its location. Well organized shop. Will visit more often.
Overcharged by 20% at checkout, even when I asked the clerk to double check. She refused. When I got the receipt. There it was, overcharging for items I didn’t purchase.
Brooklyn free is the estimate supermarket in the area. Good bra do, selection and quality in all products.
Large selection, clean atmosphere, great ready prepped meals at the deli, and a good member program
Great grocery shop, especially like the bread options. Though a bit pricey
Very compact store with fresh fruits and vegetables. Very calm atmosphere.
Nice place, cant tell you about their prices cause Im from Brooklyn so everything here seems over priced to me
Yes its got items not avail at other shops.
Small, pricey but a variety of stuff
Great selection, incredibly friendly service, very positive shopping experience
Amazing selection of foods with wonderful people eager to assist you. Excellent all around!!
Good sandwiches and plenty of options and have good coffee also very reasonable prices
Do you like groceries? They got them! Is this in Brooklyn? Not at all! Whats this world coming to?
Good prices, friendly staff, good selection. (And always fun music playing!)
Place is awesome. Best grocery experience in the city.
Convenient neighborhood market. Good quality produce. A bit pricey.
Great store
Fresh food and awesome service, what more can one ask for!
Fresh food and awesome service, what more can one ask for!
Great place to grab fresh organic and not so organic healthy groceries
The most covenient neighborhood grocery for me with good fresh made pasta and selection of cheeses
Fantastic deli and fresh food area, I use it for groceries and lunches
Great selection, friendly staff, but the layout is a little cramped and confusing.
Good stuff, good prices, good service. Im so glad we have Brooklyn Fare.
A different kind of selection for me. But for that area, its just right. So 5 stars for that reason.
Clean, with a variety of options. Upscale without the upscale price.
Great staff
Bad customer service. high prices
Clean, bright and great selection. Expensive but comparable to other similar places.
Great store, pretty good prices.
Fresh produce, organic natural products and several healthy snacks
Great grocery selection and friendly staff
Picked up a package of Boston rolls. Surprisingly better than expected.
Nice beer selection...very clean
Getting expensive. If needed go. But western beef if a food option on 16th
Good supermarkey with good decent prices. Always have good sales
Great store for locals and daily necessity
A little expensive but a lot of variaty and high quality producta
Great selection though a little pricey.
Love the customer service
Very nice place, they have everything!!
Close to home, good sales and a friendly staff
Always find good books
It has everything you need.
Friendly staff, good selection of products
So much to choose from. Great prices. Decisions, decisions!
Excellent ice cream selection!
Burgers where cooked perfectly so juicy so fresh fresh
Great selection prices high.
Great Deli, Great Sandwiches and awesome selection
100% like
Great store with a great rewards program
Wonderful grocery store!
Has good fresh produce.
Great market for anything you need.
Wow! Affordable relative to the bodegas.
Better than dags.
Great spot in West Village.
It is a nice supermarket, it is expensive
Best of the best
Great but can be expensive..
Goid selection of food and other items
Best value in the Village
Like a miniature Whole Paycheck!
Nice staff and good options.
Nice owners, helpful staff.
Really nice super market
I love this store!
Really healthy options!
Very positive experience.
Very happy with this place.
Hipster food at hipster prices.
I love this supermarket!
O.k.
Super
Great selection
Great grocery shop
So expensive, so unprofessional.
Awesome supermarket
Quick, easy, convenient.
Great supermarket
Good sales
Good shopping !
Great supermarket
Selection
Yes
Fine market
Excellent place where you will get storage items, prepared food, fresh products, you can also have a coffee in passing.The attention of all employees was super friendly.
It is clean and everything is fresh
Very good everything
Good local supermarket
A good super market
Customer service .. is exelent
Maximum
Total reviews rating 4.4
195 Reviews for Brooklyn Fare 2023:
Review №1
2022-06-09I love Brooklyn Fare so much. They have EVERYTHING. Even though the stuff is fairly small, you can get rare-to-find ingredients like preserved lemons and fresh lemongrass, as well as a giant cheese section, a bakery, a million different types of tomatoes, so decent sakes (great sales for this neighborhood), and hot food section that is the best hot food I have ever had (the lasagna is better than the one my Italian mother makes…). If I move, I will still make subway journeys to BF because they’re really amazing. And everyone is super nice here, too!
Review №2
2022-06-05I am a regular shopper at Brooklyn Fare. They pack a great selection of quality produce, including organic, store made prepared food, fresh fish, along with excellent grocery items. The staff is helpful and friendly. The store is always clean. And they deliver! So glad to have Brooklyn Fare in the West Village.
Review №3
2022-06-03I have been a steady customer at Brooklyn Fare since it first opened. I have had nothing short of great raves for the entire staff. When I was recuperating from a minor operation, I ordered online and my order was delivered within hours, as promised. During the early days of Covid, I also ordered online and the service was also terrific. Now I shop at the store and am extremely satisfied with the entire staff. Thank goodness they are so convenient for us seniors!
Review №4
2022-06-07Always a terrific experience, shopping at BF. And I’ll be ever grateful to them for taking such excellent care of me during the pandemic. But they’re great at everything they do. Always good vibes in the store to go with their great product selection. Well done Brooklyn Fare!
Review №5
2022-03-17I used to love it here when there was this Asian/Spanish girl making the coffee and sandwiches. She was beautiful and always smiled and talked to customers in a high manner. And she made THE BEST coffee, it was always piping hot. These other girls serve you half cold coffee and barely toasted sandwiches to match. The quality of this place has deteriorated. The cashiers could not care less about you and are always talking to each other, ALWAYS. Super disrespectful about how they treat customers. I keep coming back in hopes of seeing her but it seems she left for good. I won’t be returning again.
Review №6
2022-02-18This location has really gone downhill in the last few months. No more weekly sales flyers so unless you search the website before going you wont know whats on sale till you get there and hope the item is priced correctly. The meat and poultry never match the sale price on the website. I asked the price of brand packaged burgers that were supposed to be on sale and was told the normal price and when I questioned the price he yelled at me and told me why did I ask if I already knew the price and I told him I wanted to confirm it was on sale as advertised and the price scanner wasnt working. He said he would have it fixed for Me by tomorrow and that there was another scanner on the other side of the store. So I went to it and scanned the burgers and of course they were not on sale as advertised. I could not argue the price because sales flyers are no longer available. What supermarket doesnt supply sales flyers to shoppers!? Ridiculous especially since pricing has increased so much so that some of us seniors can only afford to purchase sale items. One more thing check the expiration dates on everything! Items are left on the shelves past their expiration. I no longer shop here unless I have an urgent need.
Review №7
2022-06-08I’m so glad to have this supermarket so close to home. It’s upscale, clean, well-stocked, and incredibly convenient — especially with delivery options. Prices are on par or competitive for the area and the produce/items are fresh.
Review №8
2022-06-07Convenient, friendly staff. They were great when the pandemic started. They have a great selection of food. I can always find everything I need here. Love it
Review №9
2022-06-01Nice selection of goods at this location. Some good deal and also some higher prices. There always seem to be a line but it usually moves quickly.
Review №10
2022-06-10Everyone is so very helpful and courteous! Once I was shopping late and didnt realize the store was closing. WELL, the store manager helped me home with my groceries! Im 79 years young! I love this store!!!