No-contact delivery
Yes
Buttermilks Chicken in East Islip
Categories
Location on the map
East Islip, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
Payments
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Phone: +1 631-581-3000
Site: http://www.buttermilkschicken.com/
Site: http://www.buttermilkschicken.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:Closed
- Wednesday:12–7:30PM
- Thursday:12–7:30PM
- Friday:12–7:30PM
- Saturday:12–7:30PM
- Sunday:Closed
Comments (63)
Probably the best chicken Ive EVER had. I got 4 chicken fingers, fries & cornbread. Perfectly seasoned & awesome service. I shared this new found gem with my coworkers & theyll be eating here too. It was delish!
Didnt even know this place existed until 2 hrs ago. Local to me. Just ordered 3 sandwich combos and a 2 piece chicken meal. Everything tasted great.Only thing waffle fries that are listed on menu were substituted with regular fries without being told.. didnt know til we got home to eat. I was REALLY looking forward to waffle fries... Will definitely order from them again
We recently tried Buttermilks Chicken for the first time, and have quickly added it as one of our go to places for ordering out.The food is excellent, with a delicious batter and crispy crunch on the fried chicken and moist, tasty grilled chicken. I most recently tried the chicken salad on a pita and absolutely loved it. Dont get me started on the cornbread - it has an amazing texture and taste.The menu is diverse and the service is outstanding. They do need to further update the ordering system on the website but not a significant concern. I also wanted to call out the great setup during the pandemic - I felt completely comfortable ordering by phone or web (Ive done both) and picking up in the restaurant. The staff have been extremely pleasant and it feels like they really do love the food they offer and the business they are growing.Highly recommend trying!
It all started with my boss telling her department about a fried chicken place one day and we decided to try it for lunch. The group order started with 4 people, then quickly increased as more and more coworkers caught a scent of the amazing fried chicken from here.Thank you, Charlie, Jen, and team, for always making amazing food each time, and for always being so friendly!
Food is delicious, fresh, generous portions and reasonably priced. Love this place. Order from them regularly
My family & I stopped off to pick up lunch & go to Hecksher State Park.This place is awesome! The best chicken sandwich I ever had. Great service & atmosphere. Will definitely be back soon!
Amazing is all I have to say. Farmhouse chicken combo was delicious. Chicken was well cooked with smoked Applewood bacon so so good.. Cornbread sweet and moist . And the biscuits omg the biscuits. Hands down one of the best Ive had. Moist in middle right outer texture I was absolutely in love. My only regret I did not order enough for my morning breakfast.
This is my go to place for chicken. I am particularly partial to the spicy chicken. It has a nice kick.
I was not impressed. I ordered a grilled chicken SANDWICH and the chicken was cut up into bit size pieces like you would find in a salad. Who uses chopped chicken in a sandwich? It kept falling out ever time I took a bite. My husband had a salad and wasnt impressed at all. Not a great first impression. Probably wont go back. There are too many choices out there. Sorry buttermilk....😥
OMG. So glad I saw this place. I never order sides @ chicken places, but after reading reviews, I tried the mashed+ gravy. They didnt even need the gravy. I got 1 cornbread, something i never eat, I wish I had more. They recommended the coleslaw, I said who eats coleslaw? They gave me a portion on the house. It was so good Ill be getting it every time I go. The chicken was crispy outside, hot and juicy inside, perfect. The people that work there are so nice. Check it out for yourself, cuz Ill be going back for sure.
So glad I stumbled on to this little gem. The fried chicken was delicious! And the mashed potatoes - just like my grandmother used to make - simply excellent! Gravy, of course - yummy! Very friendly service. I will definitely be back. Thank you and all the best!!
I asked why I was charged $.50 for my chicken sandwich. The server told I was building a sandwich. My frist and last time.
Everything on the menu is really good!!! I cant even go back to chick fil a or popeyes! You wont regret coming here. My favorite things to get is the Farmhouse crispy chicken sandwich and the 1/4 dark thigh and drumstick combo. All their sides is amazing as well!
So good ... chicken was tender and juicy wafflefries always tasty slaw is tangy and delicious still crisp even the pickle slices were bomb.com! would def recomend to a friend. Good all around flavor and service .🤗😊
Tried Buttermilk’s for the first time tonight. Was THIS HAPPY, to find the people from Rizzo’s still there. The chicken was great, cooked well, not overly salted or seasoned. The sides were good too, Real-live mashed potatoes. No boxed mix here. Service was beyond friendly, as it was as Rizzo’s. So grateful for re-imagining an already great place. Will visit often.
I drove 17 miles because of the reviews and I try to support small businesses. I ordered the Peck family meal and am not happy. I don’t know whether or not it was because I ordered so close to closing time, but the chicken was very subpar. $28 later and my family is not happy at all.
Great menu of fried, grilled chicken items. Scratch cooking that tastes great for a fair price! The sides are wondeful too. Dont miss the cornbread/biscuts
Best Fried Chicken, Onion Rings, Coleslaw, and Homemade Cornbread! The Service is also Exceptional! Great Meal for a Good Price....
The quality of the food is excellent! Very clean and friendly service. We had placed an order for pick-up, was given a time, a the food was hot and ready when it was supposed to be. Definitely a must check out!
Great restaurant, great food and the staff do am incredible job.
The chicken sandwich is amazing, especially with the sauce they put on it. Cant wait to go back and try more things from the menu
Great fried chicken! Mashed potatoes are moist and tasty; they do not need gravy! The price is right as well!!
I Have Had The Chicken Leg Comb With Fries, With Onion Rings. With Biscuits As Well As Cornbread! It All Is Wonderful. But The Santorini It Fabulous! Try Everything!
Fried chicken very moist, even white meat.
Delicious chicken sandwiches and onion rings, I wish you had a store in Kansas City!
Rude owners, trash chicken recipe, they messed up the order, i had to drive back 20 minutes and just so the guy owner can be flat out rude and out of line with me. Horrible.. Avoid at all costs !!
The chicken sandwiches are so good. The fries are usually hard though.
Asked for sauce on the side to see if I liked it and they just put it on the sandwich. The front counter lady read my order saying sauce on the side when she handed me it too.
Finally something in east islip that isnt pizza, or bagles. Hopefully the place can get through covid and continue to thrive. Had the spicy chicken thighs and chicken sandwich. well made. Definitely worth it to check it out
Always loved properly fried chicken marinated in buttermilk - gives fried chicken a new dimension !Just looking at the menu is mouth watering
Im visiting from NC the chicken is so good Ive been there three times this week!
Well worth the wait.Chicken was crisp,seasoning was not TOO MUCH, and inside was cooked to perfection and moist.Will definitely be back.
Awesome chicken, especially the tenders best you will ever eat.
Hot, fresh, awesome! Best chicken in town. Amazing hot chicken.
Fried chicken cooked to perfection. Excellent sides. Looking forward to next time.
Very good chicken sandwiches and the place is clean. The owners are very kind and friendly.
Excellent food. Friendly staff. Will definitely be back
Good food! Great people!Very good cornbread
Great food and staff. Always have a great meal from here!
Its just good! The cornbread. The mac. The chicken. Its just good!
Just ok. Will have to give it another try
Delicious the chicken was great nice and crispy
Delish!!
Food was fresh and delicious.
A delicious alternative to chain fast food
Better then chick fil a and Popeyes
If this sandwich was music genre itd be funk.
Great day
Mother cluckin good stuff.
Great food I love it
Tasty chicken. Will definitely go again.
Great food
Loved the chicken club
Total reviews rating 4.5
63 Reviews for Buttermilks Chicken 2023:
Review №1
2022-05-13Support local! I had the classic chicken sandwich and I can never go back to fast food. Delicious! Real fries! The service was attentive and the location is inviting and well kept. You should order ahead but thats because the food is not kept under heaters or lanterns. Most of all, the chicken is not too salty which is sometimes the case.
Review №2
2022-04-01The chicken was absolutely perfect, cornbread is to die for and the mac and cheese is fresh and homemade. I am utterly shocked how i hadnt heard of this place before because the food blew me away. Owners were the nicest most personable people too. I can say without a doubt ill be eating here regularly.
Review №3
2022-02-10I work in the area and finally decided to give them a try and will definitely be back. The chicken sandwich deluxe is better than anything you would get a chick-fil-a. Very good ambience and kind workers as well. Got my food within 7 mins of ordering which is extremely fast. Will definitely be back.
Review №4
2022-01-28I had the Roadhouse sandwich and it was soooo delicious. You could tell it was made with fresh ingredients and homemade. Best part was that I didnt feel like I was going to go into a coma like I do when I eat chicken sandwiches from fast food joints 😅 Cant wait to go back and try the classic 😋 I had the pleasure of meeting the owners and they were so nice and down to earth. Ill definitely be back and would highly reccomend!
Review №5
2022-07-12Stopped in instead of going to a Popeyes or KFC and as long as I’m here on LINY working I will be a customer. Finest fried chicken I’ve ever had
Review №6
2022-03-26The classic is the best chicken sandwich I’ve ever had in my life and I’m a fairly fat guy close to 50 years old so trust me I’ve eaten a lot of chicken sandwiches in my life and again the classic is the best chicken sandwich I’ve ever had in my life! The onion rings are also awesome!
Review №7
2022-03-26I rarely leave food reviews but I was definitely misled by the other reviews. I ordered a chicken sandwich and it has absolutely no flavor. Not one bit of seasoning. Even the sassy sauce is underwhelming.
Review №8
2022-07-06First time coming here and the food is made to order! The food was delicious and I wish I could get a big bottle of the sassy sauce lol, it was so good 👍
Review №9
2022-03-30The food was awesome, fresh and delicious. Everything about the place was cool right down to the eclectic music. The staff/owners were very personable. I highly recommend this place.
Review №10
2022-04-12Chicken was cooked to perfection, cornbread excellent the couple next to us couldn’t believe how good the coleslaw was and to top it all off the place was spotless.