Cafe Europa Pizzeria & Restaurant in West Islip


Phone: +1 631-587-7000
Opening hours
  • Monday:11AM–9PM
  • Tuesday:11AM–9PM
  • Wednesday:11AM–9PM
  • Thursday:11AM–9PM
  • Friday:11AM–9PM
  • Saturday:11AM–9PM
  • Sunday:11AM–9PM
Edit info

Total reviews rating 4.5

107 Reviews for Cafe Europa Pizzeria & Restaurant 2023:

Review №1


Pizza is amazing but don’t even try going through slice when ordering. They need to not try and force you to use the app. They closed before my order came. Even spoke to them on the phone because the app wouldn’t let me fix my order, so they clearly had my order. It said out for delivery yet nothing. Had to cook my own dinner at 9:30 after waiting on an order just to find out it was never coming. I can’t fully blame them as it is also slices fault but completely unbelievable.

Review №2


I love this place I have dined in and had take out for years and it never disappointed. There food has always been always fresh, on point absolutely fulfilling with amazing creativity. Not too mention they treat there customers like family very warm environment. Recently had to move due to my job and my family and i still crave there food. There calzone pizza and muscles garganzola is absolutely amazing.

Review №3


Best Grandma and pepperoni pizza I ever had in my life. Me , my wife and daughter have declared it our favorite and only pizza we order . Thanks foe the love you put in making your pizza!!!

Review №4


Cafe Europa makes an awesome Sweet Thai Chili Cicken pizza!If youre looking for something on the healthy side, the Vanessa Skinny pizza is a good choice. How many pizza places do you know that put avocado on a cold pizza?!

Review №5


Update:Still amazing! Been going here for years and Im very picky pizza person.Favorite place for pizza! I literally drive almost 10 minutes to get their pizza, this place is the best around. Specialty slices are amazing! Vodka is my favorite and I also Indulged in the Mac and cheese slice, which I can tell you anyone would eat this and it offers something different for kids as well! Garlic knots are delicious! The staff is very friendly and place is clean. Highly recommend

Review №6


Calamari is like rubber, what kinda bread stick do they serve? Pizza tastes like its old pizza reheated. Just not good food at all. People are very nice just poor food

Review №7


Cafe Europa has delicious pizza, but it’s the warm and friendly service that keeps everyone coming back. Mike, Joe, AJ, and the entire crew do an excellent job of making everyone feel welcomed. Stellar customer service with a neighborhood feel. Be sure to try their their Sicilian slice and The Brooklyn slice. Everything here is delicious.

Review №8


They charged me $9.88 for 2 slices, almost $ 5 dollars a regular slice ...way to expensive, and to top it off not welcoming at all. I should have complained and questioned but my kids were hungry.Other reviews say Everyone greets you when you first come but I must had visited the wrong day.

Review №9


Worst experience Ive ever encountered. The delivery driver got lost, called me, was incredibly rude, then cancelled my order without notice.Would NEVER try this place again if you paid me.**Edit**In response to your laughable retort, I dont need or want your terrible food (as countless other reviews have stated. I feel fortunate I didnt have to suffer through it. ), and your driver is making up a story to cover for his own foul attitude.I would never treat anyone in the service industry so poorly, and instead of getting defensive on his behalf, perhaps next time you should get the facts straight. Regardless, Ill make sure to spread how little you value customer service.

Review №10


Cafe Europa, simply put, is excellent! Picked up another order last night and the sicilian pizza, cold antipasto salad with shrimp and chicken rolls were delicious. Their selection of pizza is astounding. Try the BBQ chicken pizza, you wont be disappointed. Placing an order online for delivery or pickup is extremely easy.I would be remiss if I didnt mention the staff. Everyone is friendly and welcoming. Love this place!

Other Pizza restaurant Nearby:
  • 4.5 ·(199)

    Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta

    from this place 1 mi

    Delicious!!! Got the margarita pizza and meatballs which are both now new favorites for me 🤤 Got ...

  • 4.5 ·(66)

    Teresas of Long Island

    from this place 1 mi

    This was my first time ordering from Teresa's. I'm was pleasantly surprised and that's saying a l...

  • 4.5 ·(145)

    Crispinos Pizza

    from this place 1 mi

    Pizza is ruined for me back in Indiana after having NY pizza. Buying by the slice and getting som...

  • 4.3 ·(199)

    Chuck E. Cheese

    from this place 1 mi

    Having a party here was great! Our server was more than helpful and super kind. The manager was a...

  • 3.9 ·(59)

    Oak Neck Pizzeria & Catering

    from this place 2 mi

    For +/- past 10 yrs, we've ordered our meatball parm heroes here, once a month or so, driving pas...

  • 4.5 ·(61)

    Bella Cucina

    from this place 2 mi

    My friends, and I love going to Bella Cucina for lunch because of their everyday lunch special. F...

  • 4 ·(55)

    Anthonys Pizza & Pasta

    from this place 2 mi

    Not only are they racist and hateful to black people the man overcharged me and chatged Mt Italia...

  • 4.4 ·(199)


    from this place 2 mi

    The food was very good. The only critique I have on the food is that the appetizers and 4 out of ...

  • 3.6 ·(106)

    Dominos Pizza

    from this place 2 mi

    A great dominos pizza franchise, been ordering from them since 2015 and have enjoyed every produc...