Kerbside pickup
Yes
Calabresellas New York Style Deli in Rochester
Categories
Location on the map
Rochester, Monroe County, New York, US
Service options
In-store pick-up
Yes
In-store shopping
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Delivery
No
Health and safety
Staff wear masks
Yes
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Safety dividers at checkout
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Amenities
Wi-Fi
Yes
Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly
Yes
Planning
Quick visit
Yes
Payments
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 585-235-7860
Site: http://www.newyorkstyledeli.com/
Site: http://www.newyorkstyledeli.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:9AM–6PM
- Tuesday:9AM–6PM
- Wednesday:9AM–6PM
- Thursday:9AM–6PM
- Friday:9AM–6PM
- Saturday:9AM–4PM
- Sunday:Closed
Comments (199)
Great service, wonderful, fresh products. Reasonable prices and an old school family run business! Awesome!
Great subs, large portions, excellent quality meats. The colon kicker is the best steak sub I ever had. See picture...
The steak subs are to die for! Super hearty bread piled high with juicy, flavorful meat. This place is the best sub shop around!
Cold subs are the bomb. I think they may have better subs then Rubinos and Rubinos has great subs
If I could I would have their food every day. But at least whenever in the neighborhood I am here. Tastes you will love and appreciate. 5 stars and more.
Awesome service and food.Definitely a must visit if youre in the area!
Best subs in Rochester. Ample portions, very fresh, great and friendly service. Dining room is extremely dated and could use a refresh but maybe thats part of the charm and experience. Definitely recommended!
Stopped there for my first time today and got 2 subs and some spicy Italian sausage for dinner tomorrow.First thing I would like to say that its a very cool store! A lot of specialty groceries sold there from local businesses, excellent meats and deli.Wasnt very impressed with the subs though. They take your order and then bring your subs to the cashier when theyre finished. I ordered 1 ham and swiss and 1 Italian assorted. The prices were very reasonable. When I got home i saw they made a turkey and swiss instead of ham which was very disappointing. The ratio of bread/meat/cheese was way off. The meat alone was about 2 inches thick but there was the thinnest, tiniest slice of cheese in the middle lol. If thats how you like your sub, this will be the perfect place for you but I was greatly disappointed.I might not be back for subs but Ill definitely stop there for fresh meats and other items.*picture shows the Turkey with extra cheese
Best steak subs in the ROC! They also sell local products for other businesses in the area.
The Buffalo Road Deli. is definitely five star. Great selection of different jars of unique items. Fresh Italian sausage. The best subs you can find in Rochester.
Had the meatball sub on a toasted roll and it was incredible! Staff were also incredibly kind and helpful!
You get the best subs in town and they give you large portions of meat compared to other sub shops and they also treat you like family
Hi Dena. Thank you for shipment of the habanero Country Sweet Sauce. It was packed meticulously and none bottles were damaged (a few you were dented but clearly not your fault). If you ever need a favor from someone in South Florida you got my number. #585ForLife
Calabresellas New York Style Deli has a very nice old world feel to it with a wide variety of specialty items. Some of these specialty items include pickles (Dill, dill and garlic, bread and butter) to varieties of sauces that would be difficult to find elsewhere (vodka sauce, meat sauces, etc.). They have a nice and relaxed feel dining area, and an excellent deli to order sandwiches from. Their prices are overall reasonable, and Calabresellas sources local producers for many of their specialty items. If you want a taste of the old world with the same type of service and variety, this is an excellent place to go!
5 stars for their subs, but 3 stars deducted for the service at their Buffalo Rd. location. I get why so many love Calabresellas...I did too. However, no sub, no matter how good, is worth putting up with poor service. Good luck ordering a sub in person between 11:30 and 12:00. I get that theyre busy, but theyre mostly interested in completing phone orders at this time, while letting their customers wait 10-15 minutes just to order in person. Then you wait 10-15 minutes for the sub to be made, while watching one lady in particular, move with no urgency, always with a frown on her face. Why not devote one employee to walk in orders? My love affair with this place has ended.
Best Grinders I have had in 20+ years...great service and outstanding food!! I wish I lived closer!!
Ordered subs ahead and had to grab some cannolis. Theyre service is quick and extremely friendly. Been going here for years and love it every time.
Holy s*** the steak sub, aka cheesesteak, is the best in Rochester. Ive been to all the Philly spots, and this cheesesteak would fall into the top 10 on... the east coast. Great service just made it even better.
The steak subs are excellent. Try adding extra sharp provolone if you want something special.
Great subs! Highly recommend this place
Well whats not to love. First class service and shipping. Dena was exceptional over the phone after my order somehow went awry. Back home food all the way in Las Vegas. Thank you.
You will be greeted with amazing customer service and if your smart you ordered the steak sub which is Absolutely the BEST steak sub you will EVER eat! The quality of the meat is impossible to beat. I can not express enough how great this place is. Love love love calabrasellas
OMG. I will drive out of the way to eat here again. Everything is amazing. Keep it up.
Dont cut the sandwich means that even offering to add fresh bread how long to wait now ? And eggplant for $ 10.00 give me a break
Great experience! Very friendly! We had a Steak sub and a Colon Kicker. Boy! Were they jam-packed with fillings and flavor!
Great food. Great people working there. Super friendly.
Best subs and Italian sausage around!
I ordered 3 Large Subs! Steak for myself. 40 plus dollars later to open up my steak sub to a long black hair inside of it. I called and Dominic says....”next time you order say Dominic says to give you a discount “!! UNBELIEVABLE!! No full refund for the unedible food I just sold you. But a discount on something that will never happen again. Disgusting Way to conduct Business. Will never give them another penny.
The best sandwich I ever had. This is my first time in here. I had turkey sandwich. They stuffed turkey like anything. Less bread more protein. Even the bread tastes authentic, and it is perfect. I had small sandwich which is the size of subways’ full sandwich. Two can share a large one. I feel like going again. Not too pricey. Worth every penny. People here are friendly.
The best local sub shops in the area... Family own and operated!!FairportPark aveLyell ave
Awesome food at a great price, will ship anywhere, all local products
Ordered from Dina Zweigles hots and Bill Grays hot sauce. Had them deliver it to Fla. , great price , 2 day shipping. Great customer service.
My fiance and I go to Calabresellas pretty often. I love that they usually have something new in the shop. I love picking up our subs on Sunday and grabbing extra snacks and goodies for later. Its been a few days now but Im still dreaming of that Bominator sub special. New addition to the menu maybe? Either way, I need another one! Much love and well see you soon, Will!
Best steak sandwich i ever had been going there 20yrs friendly never had a steak there i wasnt satisfied with try it you will always go back
I was out in Rochester on a Business Trip. Me and a Co-worker stopped here for lunch. This place has the best subs on the planet. I dream about this place. May drive from Syracuse to Rochester just to get another sub. EAT HERE, You wont be disappointed!
Absolutely the best steak sub Ive ever had!!!!
One of my favorite sub places if not my favorite. Ive only gotten subs there but they have a ton of spices, sauces, meats, cheeses, and other goodies. Very popular and sometimes has a short wait but worth every second.
Good food and good people. Would definitely recommend
Was looking for prices for trash pick up and didnt see what I was looking for so Ill have to call
Great quality sub sandwiches. Friendly staff and a large selection of Italian favorites.
Great job. This company will be around a while. Great service, couldnt ask for anything more.
Excellent Delicatessen. It was my first time here. I have driven by there lots of times. I had a taste for a sub so I stopped by. They have a good selection of hot and cold subs as well as pepperoni & various cheeses. Top notch.
Great place. Very clean and friendly. Best subs and steak subs ive ever had. Theyre not stingy with the meat. Deli is always fresh. A good selection of all sort of jars, bags frozen, pastry, pastas, candies, cookies. Take out or eat in. My husband and my favorite place for subs & such. We live in Albion and we come here for our subs & such. Well worth the trip.
I ordered a meatball sub from there. The meatballs were very tender which I loved. The sauce however was very bland to me which was disappointing. I also asked for light sauce and it was overloaded it with sauce. The rolls were just regular, also was disappointed by that. I stopped in there went on Yelp recommendation but wasnt very impressed. If they make the sauce more flavorful and put the sub in the oven to toast the bread for a bit I think it would be better.
If you want a delicious sub, stop here.
What a beautiful Italian deli, they have everything your mouth craves for thats Italian! Excellent homemade Italian sausage and the best steak sandwiches in Rochester. Calabresellas has been a Town of Gates institution for years with a second location on Park Ave in Rochester.
I lived on Long Island and worked in NYC for years, and am skeptical of any place claiming to be a New York style deli, but this place exceeded all expectations. Will definitely be going back!
Very nice friendly service, very clean, polite, helpful. Excellent steak sub. They have hard to find sauces. Im going to visit again.
Best Philly steak subs in NY! Now were in FL, we order from them to get our Zweigles fix. Dena is the best for fast, reliable shipping!
I went to this spot twice in one week.. My fav things are the hog head cheese lol, but its called sous meat up here and the spicy salami.
Hot Sopressata sandwich wit hot peppas, olives, pickles, provolone, lettuce, and tomato. Magnifico!Seriously, the best Italian Deli in the state.
Great local deli. Huge subs
Awesome as usual. Best subs guaranteed. Try the sausage!! Buy local. They also deliver zweigles to your friends in the south
Best italian assorted sub on the west side! Staff are friendly and service is quick. Also love all the local foods they carry in their shop.
My absolute favorite place to get food in Rochester. Once I discovered this restaurant it was absolutely my favorite sub shop in the entire city. Their salads are always fresh and well prepared with an appreciation for the food. I think everybody behind the counter knows me at this point and Im not even upset about that. Everybody in this restaurant has always greeted me and treated me above and beyond. I would go as far to say that this is the hidden gem of Rochester!
Best food, best people you have to go to Calabresellas. Steak subs are delicious and HUGE!!!! The owner is even there quite a bit and is one of the nicest guys youll meet. Its like going to visit family. Walking in reminds me of walking into some of the delicatessens in my neighborhood growing up.
I absolutely love this place. Not only for the food but for their values. This is what you expect from a small hometown Italian deli. A huge assortment of imported goods from all over the place. Small local business that supports other small local business proudly. Everything edible in the store is fantastic to their famous colon kicker subs, to their homemade assortments of Italian salads (pasta, macaroni, potato, antipasto, etc....). Great assortment of sweets to choose from like cannolis, and italian ice! Staff is extremely inviting and friendly, it feels like talking to family. Calabrasellas has earned an outstanding reputation in the community, and for good reason.Sincerely,A customer for life.
The gold standard for steak subs, but don’t sleep on the eggplant parm!
Awesome old Italy feel, with very friendly people. Good heavy duty sandwiches both hot and cold, unique european style treats and desserts, and a large cooler full of cold drinks! If you like hardy, simple food done well, this should be a definite stop for you!
Amazing place great homemade food the steak subs are delicious along with everything they reminded me of how the old delis used to be very nice atmosphere
Their flagship sandwiches are incredible if you like Franks red hot, but if you dont like it, then youre gonna end up with a full foot of meat and vinegar that you have to pass on to a family member. I cant really blame them for my own differing tastes, and I could tell that the thing was fantastic were I only able to appreciate it. Ill come back sometime and get something more to my tastes, and I imagine this will become a 5 star review.
I have delivered packaging products to Calabresellas twice. From a delivery view the place is awesome. The owner is incredibly nice and very helpful! The staff is knowledgeable and very pleasant! Inside is immaculately clean, tidy and displayed perfectly. The food is spectacular, I promise you wont find better quality! I highly recommend this place
Im never disappointed. The subs were full of meat and delicious. They also carry my specialty mustard at a phenomenal price. The best subs in Rochester
This is a friend of mine establishment. I wouldnt dare get a steak sub from anywhere else. If you try it.. youll be back. The service is good and friendly. Fresh salads and deli meats under glass and they have a great selection of local gourmet foods on the shelves. Aiming to please.. You will not be disappointed.
Fantastic food and staff!
Great food, huge subs.
Fantastic subs & delicious homemade italian sausage. Always welcomed with a smile...customer service above and beyond! Also, have items specific to Rochester which can be shipped out if town to a loved one missing home!
Subs are awesome. However, went to the Avon location today before 6pm to get 4 subs and they told me they were closed. Two young girls didnt want to be bothered. Very disappointed.
You wont find a better place for a delicious steak sub, Calabresellas make the best subs hands down. And the whole family would love their subs too.
These are the best subs! I live in Albion ,and come here just to get one! Loaded with meat! From the steak subs,to the Italian assorted. My Favorite is their Red. Osier Also the cannollis are always fresh! Their cold salads are delishiouso!
This place has the best subs in town. SuperService. Great selectionOf sauces and dips. Mandi is the best worker I know. They have sausage crumbles. Hard to find anywhere else.
Awesome the best subs and people in town
Delicious subs, awesome sausages, good people working there.Going in near the lunch rush can be kinda crazy but the service for subs at least stays quick.
Went to check out shipping Zweigles to my sister in Cleveland, couldnt resist the fried bologna sub... delicious!
Great service, Grade A deli selection (they carry red osier!!! All smiles) great cooked food steak subs & more. They also carry a variety of sauces and other items not found in grocery stores. To top things off they also have fresh Italian cookies and cannolis♥️✔️
Their subs are larger than anybody elses! You will see.
Dominic and his team have built a model of consistency and quality stamped on every single order and that’s not easy to do! Congratulations on the new locations as Calabrasella holds legendary status among some of Rochester’s elite eateries!!!
Sevice was fast. Pleasant staff. It smells so delicious in there. Finally found a place that sells Portuguese sausage! And the best Subs around!
I have to agree with the other reviews. This place is a gem, amazing family business. Exactly what a deli should be. Best sandwiches around. Whenever Im back in Rochester this will be a stop, and yes, a large sub is a big meal for two!!! - had the colon kicker and it was amazing!!
The best fergitaboutit.....great steak sub the best anti pasta salad Ive ever had and the people are happy to be there and friendly proffesional
It is by far the hidden Gem of all Delis and bakeries. The LG amount of meat they put on their subs is unbelievable. Always very busy, but 5hey have a great system for handling the crowd. Mostly, the staff are so flipping nice, I feel good after Ive gone on my way.
Best online service ever! I moved from Rochester to the West Coast and was desperate for white hot dogs. I casually mentioned I can’t find ring macaroni anywhere or anyone to send it to me and they sent me my hotdogs and included some ring macaroni as a surprise! I’m ready for summer now!
When the parking lot smells amazing, youre in for some incredible food. Place was packed but that didnt slow them down. Had a steak sub, and pretty much knew after I ate it that my day had already peaked and it was downhill from there.
Best subs ever!!! Great family owned business.
Amazing subs! I used to live near NYC so when I moved up here, I missed the food. Not any more once I found this place! Havent had anything I didnt like... its all amazing food and the staff is awesome too!
Love this place!!! I usually get the steak sub. Cooks are fantastic. Today my server was Hunter, he was quick and kind and gave good recommendations. Made my day!
This is the real deal holyfield! Staff was very friendly and helpful. Selection of sauces to purchase was awesome. Split a small colon kicker and fried bologna sandwich for lunch and I have no room for dinner now. The bread was perfect and the meats even better
They make the greatest steak sub ever, probably my all-time favorite food item. I honestly do my best to AVOID Calabresellas as best I can because this sandwich should be illegal, its so addicting. And its enormous, stuffed with meat and cheese. Out of this world. A life-changing sub!
Hot subs are excellent. Mac salad is great. Cold cuts are sliced too thick for cold subs and bread is spongey if its not toasted. Great selection of Italian canned goods, grocery items and desserts. Friendly service
Today was my first time trying Calabresellas and MAN IS IT GOOD. I work down the road and my company orders subs every week so I decided to see what the fuss was about for myself. My expectations were well beyond exceeded. I got the colon kicker spicy cap and steak mix (hot sub & spicy). The large sub is ~$7 and boy is it LARGE. Forget subway using cheap meats and inferior products (when this place is only $1 more!!!). Lunch time was a little crowded but it only took 15 minutes. Staff was extremely friendly and helpful. I highly recommend this place, I will definitely be coming back for more!
LOVE THIS PLACE !!!!REMINDS ME OF MULBERRY STREET, LITTLE ITALY NYC !OR THE 2ND AVENUE DELI, NYC MANHATTAN !!THE OWNER, AND HIS FAMILY, FEEL LIKE MY FAMILY GROWING UP IN NYC...SUNDAY DINNERS AT GRANDMAS IN BROOKLYN, HOLIDAYS AT MY AUNTS HOUSE IN LONG ISLAND....ALL THE TASTES OF ITALY.....AND THEN SOME !!!PASTRAMI SANDWICH IS FANTASTIC !!! DINE IN, OR CARRY OUT! PUT IT ON YOUR LIST OF SPOTS TO HIT, FOR THE BEST ITALIAN FOOD .....BAR NONE !!!!LOVE YOU D.LEE AND CAT...81 SUPPORTER TILL THE FING WHEELS FALL OFF !!
Amazing steak subs!
Great Italian /Greek Deli.. Food is super fresh and delicious. Lots of import foods too. They also make their own sausage (with fennel seeds too) 🤗
Couldnt ask for better place to get service and attention to old school italian deli! Best quality and freshness! Also have wonderful variety and expresso served hot!
Get a steak sub and it will feed you for two days. Its delicious, and I highly recommend getting with the meat hot sauce! Absolutely the best deli and steak sandwich experience Ive ever had.
I love his place and we shop here often. On 01/06/19 employees allowed a woman to bring her dog inside and stand at the service counter. I am not anti animal but bringing your dog inside a establishment that sells open food is thoughtless. I am allergic to animal dander and the dog could have triggered a health reaction. Not something to be associated with food. I would bet it is a violation of public health laws.
To me, this looks like the sort of deli I would expect to find in NYC. The place is packed with imported dry foods, a deli meat counter, and tables. If you pursue your way to the back of the place, you will find a counter at which you can order some of the most incredible subs.Personally, I am partial to the steak subs, but the Colon Kicker isnt bad -- if you can handle it.
Been coming here for awhile and t love it here. The sandwiches are always amazing and the service is great!
Best subs in Rochester, just recently tasted their Steak Sub and I gotta say, I dont want a sub from no other place. Give you a lot for your money. Now Im officially hooked, cant stop eating from there
One of the few places in town where you can still get a killer sub like back in the day. A proper meat to bread ratio unlike a lot of sandwich shops out there that for some reason believe that the bread, while important, is the star. Beyond that I had a holiday emergency this year. I accidentally had 6 pounds of Zweigles shipped to myself instead of my father in Georgia. I called in that night freaking out because Christmas was right around the corner but it was late already. I called in again the next day and spoke with Deena(?) who was extremely helpful considering the mistake was all on my end. I cannot say enough good things about this business and I highly recommend them to anyone looking for the best deli in Rochester!
The food and service is grade A. Unfortunately I cant say the same for the owner Dom. He recently rubbed me and a colleague wrong when he went out of his way to talk down on another former customer of his. Youd figure someone like himself would be a little more humble, its not like hes the only guy in town that makes sandwiches. (I could reference sandwich jokes all day but Im an adult). Anyway, we wont be coming back. Thanks for the chicken sandwich.
The best steak sub in town all of us at work go to get our subs there you will not be disappointed
The best steak sub Ive ever had. And Ive had a lot of themAlso, great salads, many local and state products for sale. Also, they deliver anywhere in the United States.
One the great many Italian Delis in Rochester. Great subs and deserts offers here.Additionally it has a small market where you can purchase sauces of all varieties, meats, condiments , breads and other rhard to find items. Worth a visit.
Great food....was fast service and clear they take pride in the product. Lots of fresh food for the money...shaved steak sub was great.....will deff. Be going back.
Hands down the best sub shop in Rochester! From the friendly staff to the huge selection of Italian delicatessens & homemade sausage u cant go wrong with anything from Calabresellas!
Its too bad I live in Florida because I love this place. Even the most simple bologna sandwich is piled high with meat and made perfectly. I might just have to make a trip to Rochester just to go back to Calabresellas!!!!
Personally, its strange if I DONT get a sub from them for lunch on weekdays. SUPER friendly staff and owners, made me feel like a regular the first time I walked in. YOU should go there. For MULTIPLE reasons, believe me.
The original on buffalo Rd is a five star, the Fairport location is outrageous in how expensive the Subs are. $11 for a 8inch sub, highway robbery. Wont return to any of them anymore and I stop at buffalo rd Everytime Im in the area.
BEST HOT STEAK SUB EVER, TO THE POINT IT WAS THE ONLY KIND I had in many, many visits.
Great subs! Especially the turkey! Fresh bread and stuffed. Heavy lunch crowd but if you have time to stand in line, so worth it.
Having lived in Rochester for 20+ years I regret not stumbling on this place sooner. The staff is awesome, the selection is great and the food is delicious and affordable. Would give a few more stars if I could.
I have been going here here for years and have been very happy with both the food and the service. The amount of food for the price is amazing. I will pass other sub places just to eat here.
Great deli for subs and cold cuts. The people there are very nice 👌
Best steak sub in rochester as long as Ive been alive my parents tell me stories from when they were younger and they would go to then bulls head plaza to get a steak sub if you dont get a steak sub from calabresella deli we cant talk subs with one another :).
Not only does this place actually care about you and remember your face and name, they also have high quality subs and desserts for a reasonable price. Subs here are better than anything from wegmans, subway, other local delis. I highly recommend giving it a try.
Excellent food! If you leave hungry I wouldnt know how. Large portions and very, very reasonably priced. Big Thumbs up. This was my first time there
This place is awesome. Little italian deli that makes RESLLY good subs with monster portions of meat. Nice seating area and very friendly service. Love this place.
Love this place. Always a great sub for a good price. Unless you have a huge appetite, a large sub is good for two meals. Everything about this place is great. 5/5
Definitely a hidden gem, and its the only place Ive ever found spicy garlic pickles!
Best subs in Rochester. Quality is top notch. Love all the local food products you can grab as well.
Everyones very friendly the food is great. Was recommended by a friend and it did not disappoint. Shout out to Al
SUBS are the Best in Rochester ! Great selection of regional made foods. Great service & staff
Some of the best subs in Rochester. Colon kicker is a must try. Owner and staff are excellent. Your one stop shop for deli meats, zweigels, and subs
Good sub. They used to have the toppings on the table. Not anymore
Steak subs are the best
Amazing subs so full of meat was so good. Also bought itilian bread and am using it with my home made sauce..is going to be amazing..
Best subs Ive found I always want one and if anyone talks about getting subs its always where I suggest
I love this place. Dominic and his team are super friendly. The food is amazing and well worth the price. Not to say that its expensive, very reasonable. If you go there once you WILL return.
This is the VERY BEST deli in Rochester!!! Their subs are straining at the seams theyre so loaded. Always fresh and always friendly.
Bought a $10 philly cheese steak for two and it fed 4! Super delicious every time. Awesome people, great store. Diamond in the rough. Love love love Calabresellas!
Great Deli to shop. They have everything youll need. The sausage is the best. Been shopping there for years and I will continue.
First time going and the subs were huge and so filling. The people there are so friendly with such a huge variety of food to buy as well
You definitely have to get a meatball sub from here, cannolis are very good too. Different sorts of pasta you can only get from an Italian store
Ive been up and down the East Coast many times Ive never found anything that came close to what Dominic and his family has to offer calabresellas little deli just a small Mom and Pops Italian deli anything they have to offer its to die for theres really no way to explain it the closest I can come is the Steak Subs its like pure ecstasy in your mouth the XXX aged sharp provolone takes every bit of water out of your mouth your mouth cheeks touch each other the best cheese Ive ever tasted come the holidays they always make specialty Italian sausages stuffed with all kinds Cheeses spinach hunks of garlic stuffed into a ultra thin casing so you dont have to chew the hell out of a Italian sausage cooked on the grill it melts in your mouth thats just one of the many things they have and they do have a variety every kind of sub imaginable they will make it if its not up there on the board roasted peppers done just right soaking in oil and garlic all kinds of salads all homemade nothing out of a bag and then we get to the desserts the cannolis & Cookies out of this world fresh Italian bread and its Altra clean you can call and have it made and take it to go or they have a nice little section cut off so you can sit and eat it definitely deserves more than five stars I would give it 10 Stars
Awesome Deli! Best hot Italian sausage in the county...Their Colon Kicker sub is super delicious... would highly recommend the Deli to all!
You cant go wrong with anything on the menu. If youre looking for a hot sub, go with the grilled cappy. If you want a cold sub, the roasted Turkey is great. You also cant miss with a antipasto plate if youre with a party.
Great food even better service. Subs are amazing
Great place to grab a great sub, been coming here over 20 years now and customer service is great. The food it would say is the best in Rochester.
I always get the steak sub when coming here! Is always so juicy, delicious and over flowing with meat!!
Because we couldn’t be together we sent a little piece of home to our son who lives in another state. He loved the Abbott’s and Zweigles! Thanks !!
Love this place, the subs here hit the spot. I have to go at least once a week
Service was fast and efficient. The steak sub was everything your Dad, bragged about to us when we talk with him when I visit her at the Cottages.
Great food!! Such friendly staff and a awesome atmosphere. Especially for Italians. Highly recommended to anybody in the Rochester area...
This is the best deli in town, hands down. The subs are to die for and everyone is so friendly. Ive been coming here for years and the experience gets better and better.
I got a small sub from here and omg compared to phillys wegmans I couldnt even finish the small this places is definitely worth the wait and the money omg Im still full lmbo
Old fashioned Italian deli. Excellent steak sandwich and deli meats.
I would not recommend anyone to eat here at all I found hair in my sub was very upset but kept a very cool professional manner. Wehter it was a mistake or not it really made me disgusted with these people i will never come to this place again.
Subs that give you your moneys worth. Fresh, fast, and a lunch or meal that will leave you full and satisfied with some left to share. Courteous, friendly staff
Awesome subs. Seriously get a small unless you are ready for a ton of food. Reasonable price for the ammount of meat they use.
They need to go to Pinos and buy a steak sandwich or Guidas on Empire thats the way you make a steak sandwich their steak sandwiches thick with a lot of gristle in it but the Store does sell a lot of other things that are very great
Crazy huge portions, and good staff. Just an interesting old school feeling experience.
Subs are extra tasty, will definitely be going back to try their other stuff.
The food is amazing! Be aware the small sub is quite large in comparison to others. Great, friendly service.
Best subs and Italian delli delicious delights ❤
The best subs in Rochester. Get the extra sharp provolone! Great service and a huge selection of local products.
You wont find a better steak sub. It seems the price is rising significantly faster than inflation however. Still well worth it though.
GREAT PLACE, food selection is awesome, Italian sausage is very good...sent products across country to famil overnight, fresh as ever..
Stopped by today to get a ham sub. Only complaint is that the ham was a little too salty, however, it would not discourage me from returning another time and try one of their other offerings.
If you are a fan of Itailian food, you will treasure this shop. If you are not, you will STILL treasure this shop! Best steak sub in Monroe County!!
The best service in Monroe county......the best subs in New York state.......thats my story and Im sticking to it. Lol.....
I love this place and the owner and his crew ..everything can be shipped to you but whenever Im in town I stop by to purchase in person because I love their energy and how they treat you like family ..and everything is so affordable ..thank you Dominic!
Best subs in town among many other things.Offers many Rochester favorites shipped all over the country for those tjat have moved.
Great personal service! People are friendly food is great, and prices are comperable to other delis. Their sandwiches are huge! Worth the price!
Absolutely brilliant sandwiches. Best Ive had since I was back home near NYC. cant recommend this place enough!
I love this place, Im always satisfied with the food the cleanliness and especially the customer service!!!💖
Best steak subs. A large is huge. Cant beat the quality anywhere.
Some of the best subs in town!
Drove up from Michigan and had our minds blown! All of our sandwiches were worth writing home about. The staff were all the nicest folks 👌🏼
Great customer service and awesome and tasty subs! Would go back anytime! Keep up the good work!
Nice little store . Great deli choices . Good prices .
Been going here for over 20 years, Great family atmosphere, even greater food!
One of the best subs I have ever had! Great fresh bread daily
Great service and love their deli
Man they have some great subs. A large is good for 2 lunches!
Feel like your part of the family!Come to shop...stay for lunch.
Very good food. Service above par. Portions are huge. Will go back again.
This place has some of the best hot subs in New York State. They also sell some of the best pickles around.
I work across the street from the new deli on Park. Friendly service and great food! Such an awesome addition to the neighborhood
First time was today. Very nice I ordered the Colon Kicker. Will visit again excited about the opening of Park Ave
Ive been going to Calabresellas for over a decade. Every type of sub they serve is great and the staff there is incredibly friendly. Id give another star if I could.
Great little deli with an assortment of fresh meat and sausages. There subs are always full of meat, and are some of the best in the area.
I have ordered from this company in the past. This time there was a problem with the delivery. Anybody in business knows that occasionally problems occur. They did a great job in correcting the problem. I will do business with them again.Thanks Dina
I went on park avenue last month. Bad customer service. Male worker refused to communicate and ignored Deaf customer. Will not come back unless workers need to change their attitudes.
Best steak sub in Monroe County. Amaxing food amd great service. I stop anytime I am close!
Italian assorted sub was good, everything was fresh. Order was made quick and the staff very friendly and helpful.
There steak subs are amazing the best in Rochester New York
Oh my God AWESOME sandwiches no let me call it MASSIVE LOVE SUBS. 1st time was today and Ill be back every chance I get!!
Best subs and deli meats, the homemade sausage is to die for and the service is just like youre family
Total reviews rating 4.8
199 Reviews for Calabresellas New York Style Deli 2023:
Review №1
2022-03-17I cannot possibly speak more highly of this deli, or of any place really. Best subs Ive had! Best selection of genuine products. All of their locations have been great, but this one takes the cake. It is completely worth checking out and indulging in this authentic experience. And youll not be disappointed in the way that these people here will treat you and get to know you. God bless!
Review №2
2021-11-23Growing up in an Italian household means I have high expectations when it comes to my subs and cannolis. I can say hands-down this is the absolute best place to go. Not only is a service top-notch and everyone’s very outgoing. But the food is it so damn delicious. As a construction worker on the west side of Rochester I feel extremely lucky to have this right by my shop. They have a nice dining area as well too if you want to sit down and eat. Are usually take everything to go though as I’m always working I don’t have time to sit down too often for lunch.
Review №3
2022-06-10Fantastic sausage! Dom and everyone there are ALWAYS helpful. A truly great experience. I drive for 5 hours for a visit when Im in town. (Did I mention the fantastic sausage!?!? 😉)
Review №4
2021-05-28Great authentic Italian food and some groceries.Reminds me of Long Island and New York area where Im from..Place is always packed BECAUSE its good!!!Took some pictures from today. You decide. Youre stomach will thank you! 😊
Review №5
2022-06-25Really great staff. They serve big sandwiches and we all liked what we got. The Colon Kicker sounds intimidating and looks intimidating, but is the best in its class.
Review №6
2022-07-10Love there steak subs the best in rochesterIf you havent been here before or havent tried there steak sub it is a must.
Review №7
2020-02-28First time here and I was quite impressed! Ordered a small sub (still pretty big with a ton of meat on it) and it was super good. The rolls are chewy and soft just as they should be. They also had a ton if Rochester based sauces and such that you can get. Highly recommended for the subs for sure and for the selection of meats and such that they have.
Review №8
2022-02-15Absolutely the most amazing steak subs tonight. The most incredible people I have ever met. Food is amazing. Will definitely go back and recommend to everyone!
Review №9
2022-06-14Their employees are awesome and so are their subs. Best family buisness highly recommend them.
Review №10
2022-06-21Great food. Huge sandwiches and salads. A true NY deli. Intend on visiting here each week.