Captain Jakes Restaurant in Newburgh

Captain Jakes Restaurant image 1Captain Jakes Restaurant image 2Captain Jakes Restaurant image 3Captain Jakes Restaurant image 4Captain Jakes Restaurant image 5Captain Jakes Restaurant image 6Captain Jakes Restaurant image 7Captain Jakes Restaurant image 8Captain Jakes Restaurant image 9Captain Jakes Restaurant image 10

Categories


Phone: +1 845-565-3939
Site: https://captainjakesrestaurant.com/
Opening hours
  • Monday:11:30AM–9PM
  • Tuesday:11:30AM–9PM
  • Wednesday:11:30AM–9PM
  • Thursday:11:30AM–9PM
  • Friday:11:30AM–9PM
  • Saturday:11:30AM–9PM
  • Sunday:11:30AM–7PM
Edit info

Total reviews rating 4.3

199 Reviews for Captain Jakes Restaurant 2023:

Review №1

2022-02-06

Excellent fresh seafood. Wings are to die for. Fish tacos are amazing. Excellent customer service. Served in a timely manner. Only gripe was my surf and turf steak was a little overcooked. But overall an excellent experience and highly recommended.

Review №2

2021-11-30

I took my family here for my daughters birthday. 4 out of 5 of us love seafood, and were very excited. We were able to make a reservation for a Saturday at 6pm and were seated promptly when we arrived.The service and food were both excellent. We sampled fresh oysters and tried the smoked trout appetizer (highly recommend you can all share - whole fish for $12.95 its awesome). We ordered 4 different seafood entrees and a ravioli special. Everything was spot on. The spacing between everything wasnt rushed and we really enjoyed a great meal together. Well done Captain Jakes!!

Review №3

2021-10-13

Really enjoyed this place. I thought the red sangria tasted better than the white. Split pea soup was delicious. Oysters Rockefeller were very good. The Captains Platter was great! Surf and Turf was cooked just right. The two specials we ordered, I believe one was a halibut piccata and the other a seafood gumbo and they were amazing!! I personally had the gumbo and man I have never had such a delicious seafood stew. The service was really good. Make reservations if you prefer to sit outside especially since its great weather for it right now! Wonderful experience!!

Review №4

2022-06-26

This place was an absolute blast... Local hangout spot (everyone knew everyone... But me). Service was great for being so busy oysters on point surf and turf was delicious.

Review №5

2021-08-08

My wife and I on the way home needed dinner after a long day. When a restaurant near Captain Jakes would not take us, Captain Jakes took us without a reservation. We ordered the fish and chips and fish tacos. Both were excellent! Both were cooked to perfection and generous portions. I enjoyed the rice and beans with the tacos. Would definitely choose Captain Jakes over the other restaurant who only accepted reservations but had many many empty tables.

Review №6

2021-08-15

The view outside was so peaceful and scenic. Made our dining experience that much more magical. Drinks were most excellent - the Fig & the fish was so delicious and refreshing. One of the best seafood restaurants Ive been too in the NY/NJ/Conn area. Raw bar on point, big portions and food well cooked. Suggest making a reservation. Worth the drive from NYC. BRAVO 👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿

Review №7

2021-08-08

Fully packed waterfront seafood restaurant!It was Saturday night dinner so we made a reservation. We got the best table with the view. It’s a nice place to just hang out so it wasn’t a big deal but the service was very slow. Took 15 minutes to order drinks, another 25 minutes to make order for food and almost an hour to get our food. There were very long periods of time between each visit from the server, so if you ever needed anything, it was a long wait to get it. Thank goodness we asked to serve appetizers and mains at the same time. The first sip of coconut margarita was strong and good but it was a bit too much from the second sip. Oysters were fresh and really good. Buffalo shrimp were overpowered by the sauce. Lobster bisque was okay. Red snapper was very dry and lack of flavor but the potato croquette and broccoli that came with it were good. Lobster roll was pretty blend.Overrated, overpriced and inefficient!!!

Review №8

2021-08-25

Wonderful service, and even better food. The views of the river are stunning. It feels low key even though when we were there it was rather busy. I would highly recommend if youre in the mood for some lobster!

Review №9

2022-04-26

Stopped in Sunday afternoon. Amazing, efficient service from everyone and DELICIOUS food. Everything was so fresh, flavorful and perfectly cooked. We had the Caesar salad, my friend got the Captains Platter, and I got the chicken parm. The chicken parm was amazing! Will definitely be coming back and bringing more people so they can experience how great this place is!!

Review №10

2021-08-19

Always a good meal. Sat at the bar because there were no tables. Bartender and the young man shucking the clams and oysters were wonderful. Friendly attentive and helpful. Great experience.