Kerbside pickup
Yes
Carlos Pizza Oven in Riverhead
Categories
Location on the map
Riverhead, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Phone: +1 631-369-2010
Site: https://www.ordercarlospizzaoven...
Site: https://www.ordercarlospizzaoven...
Opening hours
- Monday:10AM–10PM
- Tuesday:10AM–10PM
- Wednesday:10AM–10PM
- Thursday:10AM–10PM
- Friday:10AM–10PM
- Saturday:10AM–10PM
- Sunday:11AM–10PM
Carlos Pizza Oven in other cities:
Comments (167)
This place totally hit the mark! Slice of pizza, calzone, and meatball hero. The cheese used in the calzone were some of the best Ive ever had. All was great. Super nice and speedy service.
They make decent pizza, they do deliver (or at least they use to,Im not sure anymore?) The prices are a little high, much like most of the pizzerias these days, and one of the guys I spoke with on the phone once had an attitude that totally turned me off, hence why I dont call for delivery no more..its all good, my money is good anywhere!
Very good pizza. Friendly. Its the best tasting pizza. I get mine well done. No complaints
I got pizza for myself and for my friend, which I dropped off to him. When he opened the box in his kitchen he messaged me saying “this is the saddest looking pizza ever” and I have to agree. To say it was underwhelming in visual appeal and flavor is being exceptionally kind. Sure, the people there are wonderful, but, oh man this pizza was .5 out of 5 stars. There’s literally zero chance I’d ever eat their pizza again. Sorry!
Ever since I first had pizza there a couple years ago it is still my favorite place to get pizza, and the prices are great!!! Also everyone there is friendly and you get your pizza super fast, so I recommend you go eat here :D
My first visit - pizzas looked raw and unappealing, so I went with a calzone - ham and cheese - one partial slice of ham at the crust and no more within the cheese plus cheese had raw shreds of mozzerella - burnt on the outside. Staff was fine. I still wont go back.
Has been the best and most friendly pizza place for more yrs I can remember
Great Long Island Pizza spot.
I hate the pizza there the veggies has to be cook but they dont allow to cook as well... The pizza and slices are really enormous I dont remember how much I spend that day but I never going to be back!
Excellent service, good food options, 2 tvs to watch a game or two very friendly staff.
The pizza is lovely! The customer service is impeccable, solid 5 star rating.
I ordered a pizza for first time, when I picked it up. The dispatcher was mopping then cash my order, then kneaded the dough doing all without washing his hands. I was very disgusted to try the pizza and think that poor hygiene can make me very sick.
One of the best slices of pizza I ever had. If you live a few miles away, it is worth the trip. And there is a great variety of toppings.
Good pizza for a god price . However , sometimes they seem inconsistent . I usually get a plain slice and Some pies are better than others . But the good ones are good !
Terrible pizza and terrible service. Place is dirty, bathroom is DISGUSTING. Pizza tastes like trash.. Literally no clue where these good reviews are coming from like someone else in the reviews said, if you want good pizza go somewhere that’s not this place. Staff is quite unfriendly and definitely rude. They just don’t seem to care about the customer whatsoever.
Decent pizza but their credit cards rules are insane. Purchased 3 pies, two plain and one meatball. Cash price $40 but since I used my credit card it cost me over $50. 25% increase for using a credit card is completely ridiculous.
Love their pizza, especially the Grandmas. Friendly service and prompt delivery.
I have eaten at a lot of pizza places out on the East End and I must say Carlos pizza oven has phenomenal regular slices Sicilian slices and Grandma slices all of their food is excellent and the guys that work there are so friendly and nice if you want a good slice of pizza this is the place to go
Called for a delivery and man was awfully rude from the begenning and than proceeded to Hang up on me because I asked to pay with card. Never have once experienced such unprofessional and rude behavior from a food delivery business in my entire life . Way better off going to cucina25 they were 20 minutes earlier than estimated and provided excellent customer service .
The best pizza in the town. Very friendly crew. A lot of good memories.
Never ever get pizza from here!! I order two pies and while I was eating it there was a dead bug inside it. This was very disgusting!!!! It was my first time and I absolutely had a terrible experience!
Been going since I was a child. Is and will continue to be a family favorite spot. My son claims it as his pizza night place.
Reliably great pizza and service.
The pizza is very good here and all but I wouldnt splurge money here with every visit since the slices may be expensive in some cases
Went there last night. Watta great crew .food is delicious and service is outstanding..guy even helped me bring out to my car.thanks a bunch for just being so nice
Not gonna say its the best for specialty slices, but the chicken rolls are on point and they make a great cheese pie, also good music inside usually.
Had a very good experience in this spot with my daughter. The food comes out rapidly and the service is just fantastic. Prices are affordable.
People are very nice & Great Food Good. Good Combination. Place not very Big but seating available. Your Cute neighborhood local Pizzeria!
Better cheesesteaks then Philly
$2.50 for a 16.oz water its water come on ???
Best Italian takeout in Riverhead
Pizza is awful!!! Staff is unfriendly and borderline rude Dont know where all of these positive reviews are coming from?? Go somewhere else if you want decent pizza because this is not it.
Pleasant StaffDecent FoodCash SavingsCould stand area cleanup
So much better pizza within 2 miles
Always good fresh pizza served hot . Great prices and great owners . There’s a lot of pizzza places in Riverhead but thIs one is the best .
Love their pizza and heroes! Whenever I order delivery it comes quickly and is always still hot!
They have huge pizza slices and they are delicious I recommend stopping by if you are interested in some good pizza
The food is always very good, and the staff is great.
Great simple pizza! Tasty, crisp crust.And awesome knots
Dont waste your money on the worst pizza ever. couldnt even finish up a single slice out of large pie.
I have come to this place with my friends after school many times and the pizza NEVER Disappoints me.
Their pizza has gotten better. Pretty good, And im not a fan of pizza
Really cheap tasting and no flavour, so many better pizza places than this one.
Good pizza, honestly I had a few brews before eating so.... Yea. Good pizza though
Excellent pizza, friendly staff and good prices
Nice place for a slice. Good for take out.
Friendly atmosphere. Good PizzaAsk for Kielbasa Pizza. Baked pasta is a favorite.
Great pizza.gotta get s slice.
Great Pizza. Always clean. Wonderful service
Supposedly lost my order ticket. Waited a hour and a half, decided to call. Im sorry kitchen closes at 9, theres nothing i can do for you. Thanks Carlo.
Food was good. This is a typical small scale pizza joint
Some of the best Sicilian Ive ever had, dense and heavy, not all puffy.
Great place to grab a quick bite or pick up dinner. They have done in too.
Great food and customer service. Parking is always available..clean place and many options.
Owner was very pleasant. But the bottom of the pizza was hard and kinda burnt.
Always friendly and they have great food
We Love this place, the crew is exceptional, nothing is ever a problem for their customers!
Amazing food they are always so friendly and they have amazing specials
Their pizzas are amazing and the canollis are from another world
Great pizza and sausage roll, nice friendly service
Ordered a few trays for catering, excellent food, friendly service and punctual.
Great group of people working there. The food is excellent.
Excellent pizza. Nice seating accomo.
My kids love the spot the best pizza in town
Decent pizza, friendly staff.
Its my pizza place in Riverhead. They deliver. Nice people.
Never a bad meal here and the staff (Peter and Paul are awesome)
Great place.best pizza ever
My favorite hot wings even though I often get MILD.
One of the best place for pizza pie in Riverhead 👍🏻
Best pizza in Riverhead. Great bunch of guys behind the counter
Great NY pizza going back to when I was a kid in the 80s.
The pizza was average.
Great pizza and price!
This place is trash.
Best food in the town of Riverhead for a good mix of Italian food
Always good pizza.
In my opinion the best pizza in town.
Everything is also good. Great place.
Great pizza. Place needs a facelift.
Great place for slices. Pizza is on point.
Best pizza in Riverhead!!! Customer service is wonderful!!!
Always delicious and they are always very nice.
Good pizza
Awesome people and service everytime I visit
Best Greek Salad! Pizza is awesome too!
That philly cheese steak!!! OH MY GOD!! Love that place.
Pizza so hot you can assume Carlo made it.
Loved it great pizza and great lasaña
Best pizza and Italian food in riverhead
Good Pizza, honest people.
My daughters favorite pizza.
Great food!! Great prices!!
Kielbasa pizza in polish town, cant beat it.
Hit or miss Cant get it right all the time
Tasty juicy FRESH!!!!!!! My NEW favorite
Overall really good pizza
Best pizza and pasta in Riverhead!
Food sucked
Spinach and mushroom pizza was delicious!
Very nice
Dirty bathrooms will never go there again
Everything was good I must say
Great lunch special
Keep returning, so its dellicious
Delicious, clean and friendly!
Great food, great people!!!
Delicious, inexpensive and fast.
Fresh and great service
Best pizza in town
Great Italian Food! 😋💕
Wow, food as usual was awesome
Always great food
Best pizza in Riverhead
Seems a little salty. Slices got smaller
Delish, everytime
Good pizza good food
Good food
The sausage roll is the best!
Excellent pizza, Crispino Pizza...
Pretty good pizza
Good for a quick bite.
They are awesome
Love them!!!
Good food
Very nice
Great food!
Delicious pizza!
This place is on point. Plenty of choices!
Great friendly staff.
Graet
Great pizza
Great pizza
Mid
Very nice place
Awesome pizza.....
Great food
Awesome
SHAZAM!!!
DIRTY
Pizza dry and doughy
Great service
Great food
Overcooked burnt bottom
Pizza is amazing
Awesome 🍕👍
Two young people with very bad attitude treated us badly for wanting to use the health service using vulgar language and aggressive people turned to usPizza very tasty but attention for those two young people very bad
Family friendly atmosphere, good prices and good taste
Good service
The piza is rich and vien amabrrs
Pizza is very good
Delicious the 🍕
Im lovin it
Very good food
Excellent
🍕🍕🍕😋😋😋
About
Total reviews rating 4.2
167 Reviews for Carlos Pizza Oven 2023:
Review №1
2022-04-07Knowing how subjective pizza is because it tends to be based from what a persons expectation are, I will be willing to say this pizza is very good. I tried a chicken slice and was very happy with its freshness and the crust they use. I would come here any day of the week over any chain pizza stores hands down! This is my first visit here and I can say it will not be my last.Back for another visit, todays slice is the CBR, Chicken Bacon Ranch slice. It was very tasty with a nice smokiness to the bacon and just enough ranch dressing without going overboard. It was a very delicious well-balanced slice. This slice is not to be avoided!
Review №2
2021-08-24Ordered a sausage calzone and it was fresh and hot. Some of the best quality cheese (mozzarella and ricotta) Ive ever had in a calzone. Person who took my order was kind and attentive and even brought the calzone to my table. Would come back again!
Review №3
2021-09-30Below average pizza. Buffalo slice was wayyy too much blue cheese and not nearly enough Buffalo. Forgot to take a picture of it before tossing it but here is the pepperoni which was very mediocre. Service was STUPENDOUS though. Only redeeming factor is the workers. FINAL VERDICT: wouldn’t come back. I came for food not great service and average food.
Review №4
2022-04-18I got a sausage roll twice from here recently and they were both rock hard, I could not eat it. $12 for nothing. These used to be so good, its a disappointment now
Review №5
2022-01-17No idea where all of these negative reviews are coming from; best pizza in town, especially the crispino slice. Im kind of suspicious of anyone who thinks their pizza is flavorless lolHands down best italian hero & their gyros are stuffed & delicious.Prices are on par with most prices in the area. Remember we are still in a pandemic. Costs have gone up so all businesses unfortunately need to do what they have to in order to sustain.Pete is awesome, super kind & a big supporter of our schools, sports, kids & community in general -always willing to give. This is our favorite local business to support.
Review №6
2018-11-28This was my first visit and it felt like I had been going there my while life. The guy behind the counter seemed to know everyone coming in and The entire process was amazing. Never felt so at home. Cant wait to be back in the area so I can order again.
Review №7
2021-06-22Good place especially Pete he’s the nicest man there I like it just the Hispanic guy a little off but other than that everything is good local but no issues
Review №8
2022-05-11Going to the place is cool but when I order to go to the greens they can’t because it was dangerous years back back it isn’t anymore..
Review №9
2019-01-16Pizza is tastless and extremely floury in consistency toppings are bland they also demand a surcharge for paying by card. On top of having an unusually high minimum charge to use a card. Definately extremely sub par for a pizzeria worst Ive eaten on long island
Review №10
2019-08-19We do not live near here to try the rest of the mebu. Every year during the Polish fair, we get kielbasa pizza. I would never have thought of it, but now cant live without it.