No-contact delivery
Yes
Caterina Pizza in Brooklyn
Categories
Location on the map
Brooklyn, Kings County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Mask required
Yes
Staff wear masks
Yes
Staff get temperature checks
Yes
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
No
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
No
Wheelchair-accessible seating
No
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Healthy options
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 718-277-2571
Site: https://www.caterinapizza.com/
Site: https://www.caterinapizza.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–9PM
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–10PM
- Saturday:11AM–10PM
- Sunday:12–9PM
Comments (199)
This place is so friendly and I love their food. Wait time is always reasonable and usually short but even if it’s not I enjoy sitting down at the table and waiting because the atmosphere is easygoing and comfortable. Their calzones are my absolute favorite but their pizza is also probably one of the best kinds of pizza I’ve had in Brooklyn. They also take cards which is a plus for me since I rarely carry cash. I would come here everyday if I could honestly, and 5 stars doesn’t seem to be enough stars.
Worst pizza ive ever had. it was floppy and uneven ingredients.
I dont know if this is the same Caterinas pizza from 1977. The one I knew was on Shepherd Ave and Fulton St. I lived over Veruso Reality. That was back in 1978. Omg what memories. As I dont remember the owners name. The pizza was awesome. I live in Atlanta and nothing is a comparison. God bless and stay safe.
When placing the order the person who answered was very friendly. Delivery man was also very kind and friendly. The food was very good! Garlic knots were big and flavorful. The chicken Parmesan was everything I expected and more! I def recommend and I will be ordering again.
Very good service and the pizzas are delicious 😋
I have been going to this pizza place since I was in 3rd grade. Its as old school Brooklyn as you can get! Same Italian owner is still there after all these years being as funny as ever. Great pizza...but even better pasta dishes. Their chicken parmigiana is heaven (along with the warm Italian bread)! The portions are huge...easily enough food for 2 people. The fountain drinks... my favorite is the fruit punch...are sinfully sweet EXACTLY how I like it. Some argue that the pizza is the best in the entire area. I agree😋
This was my childhood pizzeria growing up in Brooklyn. Vito and his family are like my family. He knew me since I was 5 years old and Im 41 now. Always great good. I love visiting him. Thank you for the great memories Vito. Love you guys.
Made a quick stop on the way home to eat-in with the family. Great pizza, owner is amazing (came out from behind the counter with toys for my girls when he saw the little one was crying and cheered her up). Ive grew up in this pizzeria and have been coming here since 1993. Its amazing to see its still being ran by the same caring owner.
Its a local pizza shop that I have been going to for years. Always has great food. Be warned in the summer and after school its becomes a hang out spot for teens to get a cheap meal, so your food might take a bit longer to get ready. They are open late Friday and Saturday night. The staff is super friendly and makes everything just the way you like it. They do deliver, but I usually order over the phone and walk over and get it.
Good pizza ninja pizza gone without a trace
Nice place. The cheese and sauce were evenly spread over the pie. Good food overall.
Best pizza ever i order every week.. sometimes twice a week.. bouta order rn…. 🤣🤣
An absolutely fantastic neighborhood spot. A true Brooklyn pizzeria. The classics (cheese or pepperoni and beef patties) are usually what we order and are always on point. LOVE this place!
Told owner I cant come in, no mask. He came back 3 minutes later with a mask for me. He said now you can come in. Pizza is good. Order a pineapple slice.
Nice humble old school joint !
Great tasting pizza and usually great service. I’ve been ordering for decades. Today I order a large pie, got the wrong order, and cold. I called back to tell them it was wrong and the person over the phone got irate and says “thats what I ordered because thats what he wrote on the paper”. I’m a vegetarian and I didn’t order meat on the pizza but thats what he said I ordered.
So ive been comming to this place since i was a little girl. today i brought my daughters in because my little one won a student of the month award and with that, ps108 gives them a coupon for free pizza n soda. im always at work so today we had time to come and claim the coupon. my little girl was so excited she did good and was gonna get her pizza reward. we get to the shop and the guy asked me how can he help me, so i asked if theyre still redeeming the awards. (student of the month) he tells me yes to write her name on the coupon since it was blank stapled to the award (just like the school gave it me)i didnt have a pen and i have a back injury on top of being 7 mths pregnant so i didnt want to walk all the way to the car and since the guy was actively making pizza i waited to tell another worker if i can borrow a pen to write it with. this older lady comes to me and i show her the award and ask her for the pen she takes it from me, takes off the coupons and then goes into the 50 questions about why the name wasnt on there and all this other stuff. i explained that the school gave it to me attached to the award ive never redeemed one of these b4 and so i dont know why they didnt write a name and that i figured since it was attached to the actual award with her name on it, i didnt see the issue. besides the school staff member said to just go to the shop w it and that they would know . apparently not. long story short...she didnt give her the pizza because the coupon didnt have a name and i guess im expected to go back to the school for them to write it in smh ...my daughter went home crying not understanding y she didnt get what she earned, despite having her proof. so to make up i had to make her pizza at home. way to kill a childs spirit. im so disappointed ive been comming here so long and to be treated like i was scamming on some free school coupon or like im begging for a hand out is ridiculous. i wont be comming here anymore!
Still the best pizza love how the hot cheese just slides off. The garlic knots and zappos. Finish off with an icy. Since a teenager lived in area. My kids likes it too. Maybe go today pick up a pie though Im way up flatbush. 😋
Its neighborhood pizza. Not bad, not spectacular. Its good. The salads are made fresh and are tasty. My only complaint are the zeppoles...clearly made well ahead of time in large batches and kept in a large tupperware in back. Refried to warm up. Stale and hard to chew. The only thing fresh about them is the dusting of powdered sugar put on them before you pay. Gordon Ramsay would be appalled. Ill stick with a slice or 2 since this area of Fulton in Cypress doesnt have much else to offer.
Very annoyed.. I ordered a pie..the order came out wrong. I contacted the owner and another associate over the phone and they kept saying that I ordered something else. Thats not customer service. Instead of me bringing it back now come thru dont offer to fix another and have it ready when I come by. I should not have come back. I used to come there for years and this is what happens. Worse part is I get hungry up on.. And I was nice and cheerful over the phone. Very disappointed.
One of the best pizza in the neighborhood, everyone is always welcoming and the shop is always clean.I love that its a hangout for kids as thats where most high schoolers build their memories, the pizza shop.
Felipe makes the best calzone I have ever tasted. The pasta is always fresh and such a great atmosphere! Inexpensive and still high quality. I visit here at least once a week.
Amazing people owner is the funniest man Ive met. Very friendly. Food is amazingly delish. You always get Big portions worth every penny. I highly recommend this pizza shop
I love Caterina pizza. My aunt introduced me to it as a child. Now in my 40s its actually the same owner from since i was a kid still running the place which is probably a big reason why the food is so delicious and quality. He has to have been there for over 30 years. Matter of fact he has because I asked him one day and he told me so. The owner seems like hes from the old school when people actually cared more about presenting a quality product then about making a quick buck selling horrible food. Caterina pizza in my opinion actually taste better than some of these more popular big name franchises. If they had an option to give 10 stars i would.❤❤❤❤
Great pizza and Italian food in all. Try the meatball Parmigiano on a hero
The food was honestly really amazing. I couldnt pick what to eat, because what ever they made from scratch..... was and still is very delicious. Thank you! The food was awesome! Ohh and one more thing! Caterina Pizza makes everything with extra....like a slice a pizza is twice as big as any other pizza near by!
The delivery driver came to the wrong address when I specifically told him the correct one. I did receive a call telling me to come outside, thats when I noticed he was all the way lost. I saw him almost sit my pizza down on one of those things they build around trees on the sidewalk, and Im like.....Really! Anywho...I met him down the block and it was SO WORTH IT. PIZZA WAS BANGING!! Mere suggestion....COMMUNICATION IN YALL STORE, I DONT WANT NO PIZZA THATS BEEN SAT ON A DIRTY SURFACE. Overall, if they had delivered to my door, the pizza couldnt have been better! Slept well and sound😀
Een going there for 30 years and the pizza is still AMAZING!!! Vito is the Best! You must try everything...the food is GREAT!
So we are moving into this area and me and husband went in for a sandwich waited for 30 min then we rem we needed food for our son at home we ask for another slice the employee fling his hands up in the air and said dame uou should have told me before now u gotta make a new one and food was just ok but I never going there again bad rude customer service
Best homemade Italian pizza in the neighborhood. Real welcome feeling food smells good environment. Love this pizza diner
I love this place! Great service, food is always fresh and the pizzeria itself is very clean. Ive been going to this spot for over 27 years and the food and service has always been excellent!! Vito knows how to maintain a business very well :)
Lived on Arlington Ave for years. Joined the military and now live out of state. Recently visited Vito with my wife who absolutely loved the pizza. He was friendly and hospitable like always. Gave us t-shirts :-) In which I wear proudly and brag about Brooklyn pizza. Have been eating their pizzas since they (Vito &Sal) first opened in 1977 on Shepherd and Fulton. Pizza is still the BEST! Travel or Food channels should visit and do a story. Definitely a New York landmark!
Pizza is yummy😋. something in the sauce makes this pizza special and the crust is perfect. has been here for years love it
I have grown up on Sal’s pizza. We moved to NC and make it a priority to see Sal and his Pizza every time we go to visit NYC. It’s the best!!!!! Build one in NC PLZ!!!!!
After 33 years of going the owner is retiring. Nice mom and pop pizzeria. Good luck to the new guys.
Pizza tasted like school lunch pizza smh not good quality
Found a dead fly on my pizza as soon as I opened up the package, was immediately disgusted. When I went back to confront them about it, the owner was acting as if I put it there and didnt want to give me my money back. I will not be eating there again and I would advise you not eat there either.
Just called to place an order and the guy was really rude and unprofessional, he hang up the phone twice without giving me the price so i ended up canceling my order.And its so bad because the pizza its really good here but service over the phone sucks!!
I loved it they have great pizza
The best pizza from my neighborhood growing up was a coin tose.. BEST PIZZA In Brooklyn East New York/ Cypress Hills section if not then in the whole NYC. I grew up in the ENY neighborhood and as kids we always argued who had the best pizza on Fulton st! (It was pizza wars) lol there were 4 main pizza joints down Fulton st in ENY...•Trinacria Pizza2788 Fulton st & Van Siclen Ave 11207•We called it Cleveland pizzaria2957 Fulton st & Cleveland Ave 11208•Caterina Pizza3035 Fulton st & Essex st 11208•Mikes Pizza3337 Fulton st & Cresent stI was always on Van Siclen Ave so I was team Trinacria until the owner Franks wife past away in the mid to late 90s. The store was shut down 4 a few day then reopened a couple days maybe a wk later. So frank took an offer in the early 2000s and gone out the restaurant buisness... I went to Caterina and had a 🍕 of life!! Me and my friend Jospeh stopped by for a quick snack; that quick snack became the regular for us... A 🍕 of life was introduced!! Even getting to know the creator himself Vinny! Vinnys always talked to his costumers and was very kind Italian guy with a smile on his face all the time. I also remember his wife or so I thought it was his wife... lol but she was very nice aswell. I loved that she had thos curly hair look all the time reminding me of my past. Overall the winner was and still till today is Caterina in 2018.Trinacria is now a chicken joint/pizzaCleveland pizzaria is noe a liquor storeMikes pizza still standsBut as far as 6.5.2018 CATERINA WINSTake a trip and taste review for yourself!BUT I TOLD YOU!!
Pretty good pizza,nice size slice but same trash h00d pizzeria trash sauce,would have gave it 5 if the sauce was good.
Worst service ever. I would never order from them again. Never accurate on delivering your food. Horrible horrible horrible. They lie so much and prices always change. And some of them are rude. I rate them 0 stars. I hate them all.
The best pizza i had in Brooklyn and i have been to alot of places. The employees treat you like family as soon as you walk in and they dont try to empty you wallet for a slice
Very good pizza. The owner is very friendly and funny. I enjoyed dining here and I will be back soon.
The staff is lovely. Warm and attentive. I enjoyed my pizza.
Just ordered and I must say I am very upset with the delivery service .. delivery man had the audacity to complain that I didnt answer my phone when I literally called him back within the minute he called me and was downstairs 2mns later . . I have a newborn so its difficult for me to leave my house for food and I didnt expect this rudeness.. food is good but better service means more ..highly disappointed .
Been eating there for over 35 years great food and people prices are good.
Best pizza... I’ve been coming to this pizza shop for over 20 years
Been coming for years ,great food, but nothorrible customer service !!Manny is very rude!!!
All out my favorite pizzaria.Food is on point always. I grew up eating from this place. Always a friendly atmosphere and everyone there is amazing.
Its a shame, I have never been to the eatery, however, Ive been a loyal customer for over 15 years lol. My Friend ordered & they delivered & Ive been hooked ever since. I just love this place. Getting ready to order now. LOL
I love this place! I miss it terribly, I live in California now and every place I eat pie at I compare it with catarina pizza. Even so called places that supposedly serve Italian pizza or new York style pie here in California dont compare!!
Caterina pizza was first started on sheppard and fulton. I used to go past that pizzeria when wed go to play baseball at Highland park. Sal & Vito were working there as bus boys and eventually owned that location. As time went on they bought the place on Fulton st and theyre still there. Every time I visit NY I have to stop buy and get my favorite pizza. God Bless Vito and Sal. Thanks for the memories.
Love the food. Great service they need to get rid of the so call manager. Equipment can be working i.e. credit card machine and he says it doesnt. Hes the only reason why I stop going.
I luv the pizza here is so delicious but the bad thing is that you have to wait about 10 or 40 minutes in line and you have to wait like 30 minutes just to make a pizza ๏︿๏
Eat here every other weekend the kids love it.. there pepperoni pizza omg Great.. been coming here for 5 yrs ..
Best pizza in the area. Actual authentic flavor rather than the common generic tomato sauce most pizzerias use.
The pizza here is mad good nfs, but the guy that works there is mad cute!! oh and I highly recommend their penny alla vodka pasta just saying👀
Made me walk over a block to get my delivery. Driver absolutely terrible and rude. Person in the store also rude. How hard is it to type in an address on gps and deliver. Ridiculous
Used to live down the block. Went back to get the same taste. Same great food.
Best pizzeria around my area ... clean friendly fresh food and fast service ... all staff are nice ..
Been going to this pizza shop for literally 30 years. Great food, great service, very friendly staff
Its okay pizza. Lack of flavor and the meat options are old. The only thing thats great is the baked ziti but not the catering option
Good pizza good ingredients they use top flour for therepizza and home made sauce great staff go there like 3 times a week
THE best pizza in town. Hands down. The Italian owner has been there for 30+years.
Great vibes!!! Family owned business 💞 The pizza is on point!!! 🍕😬 I buy at least 3 slices.
I absolutely Love the delicious Pizza here. I recommend every one to taste
Best pizza spot in the area. They use quality ingredients.
The food was purely delicious,service was friendly and prompt.As an Italian-American who knows good Italian food because My Grandmother was The Best Cook,the hardworking people at Caterinas are The Real Deal and the prices are more than reasonable.
I order a large pizza for delivery one night and they were quick and the pizza was great. Keep up the good work!
Amazing pizza and pasta.. yummy.. Good service. Friendly workers. Fast delivery.
Love there pizza,really flavorful!!
The food I ordered was delicious and it was delivered hot and within 30 minutes.The only problem was that it was delivered by a very rude obnoxious man who was demanding that I give him a larger tip than what I had already given him.I was disgusted by his behavior and will never order from here again as long as he is employed there.
A cozy place where you can enjoy an old style slice of pizza. If you want to try their hot dishes, I would recommend you the bake ziti with shrimp
Great place. This is a true and beloved Italian pizza restaurant. Love the food..
Is one of my favorites in the area
Best pizza in Brooklyn go to it all the time and deliver is late so dont really need to leave your home
The pizza there is great I order from here all the time since I moved to east new york
Eat here at least once a week. Home made food at very inexpensive prices. Family environment. Delivery available
Funny and friendly staff, the owner is a great guy! The pizza and garlic knots are incredible!
Very friendly staff, super clean and the pepperoni pizza is delicious!!!!
Pizza was good Italian ices were not mrinos as advertised, my sister was not happy about that
Vito is a nice old man the food is made with luv and the penne alavodka is out of this world pizza is awesome will be going there for years to come
Best pizza in Brooklyn!! They claim their cheese are imported from Italy and I believe them!!
I The credit card machines never works on Sundays they make you pay with cash on purpose Monday through Saturday the credit card machine works laugh out loud theyre losing business their delivery driver icomplain whenwe pay as customers with debit card
Best pizza in town and they tomato sauce is great that what make the pizza.
My favorite authentic pizza spot in Brooklyn. Making great pizza in the same spot over 35 years.
Go here everytime we make a trip to visit the family. Literally the best pizza in Brooklyn.
Ended up hear at random after I had a meeting in the area. Food is great as well as the service!
I ordered a bake ziti chicken cutlet from here and the sauce had no flavor and the chicken was so bad and the mozzarella sticks were still cold and hard really disappointed.
The best pizza in this neighborhood and also the guys are all so friendly
Caterina has the best pizza and Italian food in the neighborhood at reasonable prices.
Best pizza I ever had
The food there is excellent go there all the time and I recommend it to everybody.
Amazing food, really nice employees5 stars
Excellent local pizza place. Sicilian sliceis so on point!
For over twenty years of coming here the best pizza, Ziti & garlic bread, sandwiches, etc...the best!
I love this pizza been coming here since i was a kid
Excellent food great taste and yes actually Italian made
Horrible customer service . Delivery took forever and when the pizza arrived it looked like it was used as a hockey puck in the back seat of his car .Then to top it off I ask to speak with a manager and then the owner tells me theres nothing he can do about it .
Great service, great prices, and good pizza.
I have been getting my pizza here for years. These guys dont need to change anything
Good pizza 🍕
The best pizzas in Brooklyn of them all no lies
Went to this place since bornI know them like family and food is good
Very good pizza, i would revisit if in the area
Not bad tell them lightly cook ya pizza and you be fine
Excellent NY Italian Pizza! Delicious
Food is good, but to whoever is picking up calls, fix your attitude
Best pizza in all of east new york.
Been eating Caterina’s pizza for years.
Amazing pizza... best pizza in the area.
Good service and excellent pizza 👍
This pizza is real and it tastes So god Im gonna dieeeeee
Excellent Old School food. clean. decent service. huge portions.
EXCELLENT BLACK OLIVES GREEN PEPPERS AND MUSHROOM PIZZA PIE.. SORRY I ATE IT ALL BY MYSELF.. NOT!!😁
Best pizza ever now that east new York Brooklyn pizza
This is the best pizzeria in Brooklyn
The employees are friendly and the pizza is pretty good
P🍕 zza is good my kids love it
👍👍👍 great as always super thin crust pizza
They make great pizza in East New York
Perfect place to go on Sundays after church... best baked ziti in Brooklyn!!
Chicken parm with spaghetti in vodka sauce is everything
Its okay, pizza is alright. Nothing to race over. The people are cool tho
Cool people good food and comfortable atmosphere
Very friendly staff and amazing pizza
Cheap pizza they make right quick
They still make pizza the old-fashioned way
Always great its like visiting family everytime I go there thanks for the great service
Food was great but service was lacking, a little on the rude side.
Clean small busy but the food is good and fresh
Great pizza and nice people.
Love it, best pizza in town!!! Vito is the best!!
This is authentic Italian pizza.....Yummy
Best pizza in east new york..
The pizza is ok but charge too much money for a slice of pizza
Awesome pizza and penne a la vodka ♥️
Best pizza in NYC. Hands down!!!!
Pizza is good, little expensive, however you request your pizza, they make it
Great pizza and staff
Been going here since I was a baby. Moved to cleveland. I come here anytime Im in town or near. Coming from philly today.
Just a small mom and pop pizza store that makes good pizza
Great the best pizza in Brooklyn
Great atmosphere and excellent food!
Love,love,love Caterina Pizza great pizza and Italian food.
Terrible pizza. Don’t do it!
Love it🤗favorite place for BK pizza...
The food is very good and a very welcoming vibe
Ordered 1 hour ago.1 order ready the other now I have to wait.. horrible service
Highly recommended food!! And workers are dedicated
Great food, fun atmosphere!
Friendly service, great people great food!
Nice low key place. Food was excellent.
Better the all the other in the neighborhood
Best Spaghetti and Meatball Parmesan. Been eating it for years.
Food very good and good pricing
Same as when I was a teenager; awesome food....
Great people great atmosphere excellent food
The best pizza ever
Best pizza in the neighborhood
Very good pasta dishes and pizza
One of the best pizzerias in Brooklyn
Very rude when trying to place an order over the phone
Good pizza delivery to the right place
Traditional Italian Pizza from traditional owner.
Lost its taste. Same owner cheaper products.
Best pizza in the neighborhood!
I love their pizza
Food n service is great
Great food good people
Best pizza in this part of Brooklyn
Great food and friendly service
Love there pizza 🍕
The pizza is pretty good.
Very good pizza
Pizza was delicious!!
Excellent food $, staff
I now this place for 35years is an Italian pizzeria
The best pizza in Brooklyn!
Decent food. Family owned
Excellent food and good service
Fresh food great service
Best pizza in the neighborhood,
Best pizza in town
Best pizza ever
Delicious
I Vil love the place and the crews
Quick, convenient and the food is delicious.
Total reviews rating 4.4
199 Reviews for Caterina Pizza 2023:
Review №1
2022-03-05The staff there are great hard working guys.Im from long island so when we go to brooklyn this is our pizza joint. We have the fried calamari, and pizza. The pepperoni wheels are great. The picture that I posted is my left over pizza, I cant wait to have it. All meals are fresh. Definitely reccomend.
Review №2
2022-06-05Ordered a pizza last time and a pasta dish. Hated the pizza but liked the pasta Sunday rolled around so I ordered two diff pasta dishes Absolutely awful sauce The man who sold this place to these people was Sicilian. Don’t tell me he didn’t give them the sauce recipe Won’t be ordering again. Sorry
Review №3
2022-04-19Really good pizza here, but I loved the baked ziti! I ordered some for take out and it was so fresh when I got it home. Their whole menu is delicious!!!
Review №4
2022-07-02Been eating Caterina’s since childhood. Best pizza spot on this side, always fresh and flavorful. Delivery is a plus too!
Review №5
2022-07-02The place is nothing fancy whatsoever but the pizza was good. I ordered extra sauce and it tasted great.
Review №6
2022-06-21You want some good pizza come check the spot out Pizza ready fresh small place but very good customer service
Review №7
2022-03-01I dont regret coming in,, not from the neighborhood was hungry,, I havent had an delicious slice of pizza in a long time and their Buffalo wings 😋 👍🏽👍🏽
Review №8
2022-04-18I’m a first-timer, called in a pie & was told 15 min. It was ready in 15min! Worker energy was very good & respectful. Will visit again!
Review №9
2021-07-04The best pizza I ever tasted. I bought 3 different types of pizza and they were delicious. Marina pizza delicious. A slice that they dont carry but they made it for me, with ricotta, spinach and extra cheese, delicious. Also a regular slice and it had so much flavor. Usually pizzeria are so cheap with the sugar when you order zeppoli not here they drench with sugar and I didnt have to ask for more sugar. 100 out of 100 for me. And no they not paying me to say it. The only thing I didnt like is that they tell you one price and when you go to pay with your debit card they charge you extra because he stated the machine automatically charges you an 8 point Something charge. Never seen that in my life. The machine enters the amount you put in. The pizza was so good I would I didnt care afterwards.
Review №10
2022-02-17Came from Miami and wanted that authentic New York style pizza. The meatball pizza was great! Also the calzone was good too. Ill recommend out of towners who are looking for pizza to just come here if youre in Brooklyn.