No-contact delivery
Yes
Central Pizza in Central Islip
Categories
Location on the map
Central Islip, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Phone: +1 631-582-4363
Site: http://www.centralpizzali.com/
Site: http://www.centralpizzali.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–10PM
- Tuesday:11AM–10PM
- Wednesday:11AM–10PM
- Thursday:11AM–10PM
- Friday:11AM–10PM
- Saturday:11AM–10PM
- Sunday:11AM–10PM
Comments (121)
I’m a fat boy I love to eat! Been too a lot of different pizza places , but this place was much more than that for me, it was a celebration spot! Came straight from my sporting games with a couple of my teammates, “aye let me get a lunch special!” , we would say ready to eat some satisfying pizza! Not only is the pizza good , but they have some good wings!
One of the best pizza spots on Long Island. I’m a city guy and I can tell you, I always love ordering here. Super clean place, the staff is super friendly and very welcoming not like other pizzerias, your actually appreciated every time you come. Everything here is bomb you won’t regret eating pizza here 5 stars all the way!
Amazing pizza, garlic knots... JUST AMAZING FOOD! Would be too much to name all i had here but you’ll enjoy!!
Owner was very nice. We made a order close to closing. Pizza was still great and fresh and was happy to help us even late. Next time I am in town and need pizza I will come back here.
Sal and the boys are the type of guys that make a stranger feel like they are family. The pizza is the best in the entire area. It is consistent everyday. Also, when you order a pasta dish, you get enough food to last you 3 days. You always get good service and good food every time. Try the Hawaiian slice. It is EXCELLENT!!!
Pizza is phenomenal and service as well. Always feel welcomed when there. If youre ever in central islip and are looking for great taste, please stop in. You will not be disappointed. Highly recommend to anyone.
Central Pizzas pizza is unlike any other pizza iv had and my coworkers couldnt agree more! The vegetable pizza is so tasty with fresh vegetables and the garlic knots from this pizzeria are huge and soft like little buns! Everything about it is recommended 100%. Bring your friends and family down and enjoy
I order to regular slices of pizza, they only had one regular slice of pizza in the display case, so instead of just making a new pie, they opted to give me 2 slices with extra cheese on them, when I ask them about it, he said this is how we do Ill pizza. Clearly there was a regular slice in the display case. So instead of making a fresh new pie To cut up for the rest of the day they gave me 2 slimy cheesy slices. I dont like laziness when it comes to my food.
I ordered delivery from here while staying at the Holiday Inn Express and it came in a very reasonable amount of time. They were super polite and very accommodating, willing to deliver to wherever we were at the hotel, our room, the pool, etc. My kids devoured huge plain slices of pizza while I enjoyed an enormous buffalo chicken calzone (enough for two people PLUS leftovers for lunch). Highly recommend.
Newly discovered this little hidden gem. They bring the flavors of Brooklyn out east. The Regular pie is amazing and the Stromboli and Garlic knots bang. Cant wait to try more off the menu. Definitely my favorite in all of Suffolk.
Best pizza place in Central Islip! Staff is super friendly and the service is lovely.
This site is my preferable restaurant. Of all restaurants I know I favor it most. I never miss an opportunity to go to visit this restaurant. everytime I feel like having a decent meal, this restaurant comes right away to my head. best and all sorts of food and a large menu.professional crew, and great ambience. Also, the bill is good. I praise this restaurant with pleasure.
I have known these folks for many years and been going here since I was a teenager. Not only are the food treats beside pizzas but they are such caring people. I always look forward ordering from here and enjoy their wonderful meals. I hope to see an expansion of their restuarant one day.
Pizza aight,lunch special prices went up,Old man the owner always grumpy up by register his prices are kinda high compared to other pizzerias nearby ,He will burn the bottom of your pizza crust if you dont tell him not to hot ,His staff workers on the other hand cool people and polite
Ive been going to central pizza as a kid and I love that they are open until the late hours of 11pm . Theyre very welcoming and tell which pizza is top notch . Never can go wrong with central God bless the staff.
Owner rips ppl off. $4.50 lunch special is $5.00. I ordered that and a beef pattie. Each item was taxed INDIVIDUALY and then I got taxed on the ENTIRE CHECK, plus GOT TAXED on the beef pattie. When I asked the owner to explain, he refused. Dont come here. Save your money. Ppl say this pizza taste good? REALLY??!!Are you guys family??!! The girl behind the counter was visibly embarrassed by the owners lack of customer service skills. What a horrible 1st impression they made on me. Guess whos not coming back.
Wings are Way too salty wayyyy to salty!!
Smh pizza wasnt tasty. Server wore a mask under his nose all while coughing over the pizza smh
The owner is very kind and gentle, my kids love to go to that place for a pizza cuz he sometimes give them ice cream jajaja the pizzas are very very good, recommended place 5 stars
Menu doesnt have a lot of veggie choices. On request they made a nice veggie pizza. Cant complain the taste.Shop is kind of hidden, need to pay attention to find the shop.
Always good food at central pizza
This place definitely a rip off I ordered a pizza and the guy hung up without telling me a price I get the pizza and look at the bill 24$ for a pie alone.It was the greasiest pizza Ive ever had for 24$ that pizza better be amazing that pizza was not even close to worth 24$
I’ve been coming here since I was born and I’ve never preferred any other pizzeria. The pizza has a taste like no other and service is amazing and great people
Best pizza around the area. You cant go wrong with the regular or pepperoni slice. Will definitely try the other food they have soon.
Pizza was great, service was quick, they were friendly, they even threw in a free 2 liter bottle of soda.....the wings were also very good....mozzarella sticks were a hit with my daughter. Ill be back!
Best pizza in town because everything is nice and fresh manger owner salmon and gio and staff are very friendly and they treat everybody as a customer with respect .All so dinners are very excellent and so are the deserts are very good over all everything is fresh and taste good but one employee his name is Rubin thinks he is a funny guy but is a good employee and makes most of the pizza and dinners and everybody likes him
Worst pizza place in central islip customer service is horrible and do not even try to place an order. Cuz they will hang up on you when your not ready to order. No stars for this unfriendly so called pizzeria.
I order from here oftenService is very good. Food fresh and hot. Recommended.
This is the best pizzeria on LI. The pizza quality and taste is like no other and the employees are simply the best. I recommend this place to everyone that enjoys real pizza
Horrible experience, the owner was rude when I asked a simple question about a special’s price. Instead of answering my question with respect, he rudely points to a little sign and says, “can’t you read!” . Never spending a red cent in that place!! Rude an disrespectful to “certain customers”.
The best pizza I have ever eaten!! I live in Canada, I come here once a year and I cant leave before I eat it! ❤🍕
Bad place to call for a delivery the charged me 37 plus dollars on a sicilian with chicken as topping and one soda called another pizza place and they charged me 15 dollars for the same orderHorrible customer service and very expensive I would give zero stars if I could
We ordered specialty pizza and werent disappointed. Slices were large, cheesy and they didnt skimp on the chicken. We both couldnt finish it, doggie bagged it. 😋
This place makes the best barbeque chicken pizza.Ive gone to other places and no one can compare.When Im in the mood for barbeque chicken pizza,I have to go to them and I live in Farmingville.Its worth it.
Pizza was very undercooked dough wash mushy. First time ordering here. Do not recommend
From all the countries I have been and places I have been this is the most delicious pizza I have ever tasted!! You have to try it! ❤️ ❤️ ❤️
The pizza is amazing but i love the chicken calzones the workers are always friendly and helpful plus 4.50 for 2 slices and a soda is a bargin
The absolute best pizza on long Island! Thanks Sal!
The guy with the glasses. That’s my homie. Nicest guy you’ll ever meet. Never any problems when he’s there. And the pizza is bomb. Best in Central Islip
The best pizza around town. The guys here are amazing! I highly recommend this pizzeria.
I’ve been coming here since I was young. Owner is amazing and food is great. I have also gotten food catered from here. Love it
Fettuccine Alfredo was excellent. Had the lasagna last time.
Great pizza , excellent service , the owner is a real gentleman and genuinely cares about his customers
I’ve been coming here for years! Pizza is great! Feels like home❤️
Absolutely delicious. 😋
The pizza is good Im not going to lie but the customer service is horrible starting with the manager! 10/26/17
The worst Supreme pizza i ever had is from this restaurant
They didn’t serve a someone pizza just because they were black sorry but never going back there!
Great pizza, great people, what else could you ask for. You will not be disappointed.
Excellent pizza, great atmosphere. Very good treatment. I would definitely recommend it.
Grandma slices are amazing!!! And the customer service is 5 stars great pizza place
Its my go to pizza place! Their food is delicious and the service as well.
There wasnt shrimp mainly bread and sauce
This old guy is terrible. Never again! I dont recommend eating here!
Food is fresh and the staff are very welcoming. The pepperoni pizza and garlic knots are must-haves.
We love the Pizza here !!!!! My family and I come here every Sunday🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Got the beef patties with pepperoni overpriced and nasty.. They used to be good not anymore
Very good hot and always fresh. Dont forget there heros meatball parm is so good. As is all there fine food.
Pizza dramaticly over priced and very greasy uses subpar ingredients got sick
The $5 lunch special is awesome 2 slices and a drink me and my son stop in regularly
EXCELLENT pizza and service! Very friendly people! Come down and open a restaurant in Greenville,SC!
Foods amazing its also one of the few places on li you can get zepolies.
Im my eyes its Bronx style pizza!!! Im home baby! No nonsense on the slices, they get right to the point...
Great experience love there pizza.
The best NY style cheese pizza of Long Island
Godd pizza and heroes. Fairly priced.
Solid pizza but must be eaten fast.
Great service! Definitely good pizza!
Food is absolutely delicious!!! Been going there for years and wouldn’t go anywhere else! 😊
Been going there since childhood... love them... food is good customer service great.
Pizza is very good and is always quick and great service!
Bbq chicken pizza is amazing and crust is so soft unlike la slice
Love this place been coming here for yrs outstanding Pizza
The best New York style pizza that I ever had
Honestly the best pizza in Central Islip.
Always good food fair prices been going here for many years
Best pizza! In CI! Love it!
Good pizza, i come here everyday
Had there lasagna with meatballs excellent.
Every time I come into town on business this is always one of my first stops!!!
Food is great and has decent prices
Always great food and friendly service!
Love there meat ball heros tests great n crispy
Best Pizza outside Brooklyn..
Its an all around great establishment.
Is good
Awesome pizzaNice service
Great place fast service love them
Best pizza in CI
Great Pizza and great guys...👍🏾
Never ask the phone I called 3 times and they never answer the phone
RobertHenry 💌
The pepporon pizza is amazing
Best pizza in town
Great fpod
Amazing place true classic
Yummy good pizza
Great and friendly staff 👍
Fantastic for a quick bite.
Excellent service!
Delicious eating!👌🏻🔥
Love it
Great pizza
Good pizza
Terrible pizza
Good pizza
Lovely place
Lovee pizza
We have loved this place for many years, roast their garlic breads, the different kinds of pizza are delicious. unique place😋😋😋😋😋😋😋🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤
Dinning room
Niceeee pizza
Total reviews rating 4.4
121 Reviews for Central Pizza 2023:
Review №1
2021-09-22Without a question central pizza got the best pizza ever!! Amazing quality. They have great service, delivery and delicious meals.
Review №2
2021-11-04Excellent pizza! this is buffalo chicken my favorite one.the best pizzaria in the island and ezcellent service.
Review №3
2021-12-05One of the best pizzerias on Long Island hands down! Everything is amazing, in my opinion the best way to judge a pizzeria is their regular slice and trust me when I say this, they have one of the best regular slices I’ve ever had. Pizza is always on point never disappoints. Try the grandma slice too. If you’re in central islip this should be the only place you get pizza!
Review №4
2019-05-24I see a sign on the counter stating “$4.50 two slices and a fountain drink” I order and the man says that’s a lunch special. I told him the sign says nothing about a time or lunch. It just says special just like the pic I took.There was nothing on that advertisement that said “lunch special” so my total came out to $7.50 plus tax.... I was hungry and had a long day so I took it. But i won’t be coming back here again.Pizza was mediocre to say the least.The place smelled like cats.
Review №5
2022-02-25Best pizza ever I come all the way down from Deer Park to Central Islip just to get this pizza always request Half pepperoni and half Hawaiian the best
Review №6
2021-08-31If you want to really thank your friends for helping you move shell out the money for the Central Pizza Taco pizza! I happened to find this place by accident and they had just made one for the lunch crowd. Every slice is a meal! Theres so much toppings on it that you need a fork and knife for the first few bites. Some of the best crust Ive tasted.
Review №7
2021-10-25Central pizza by far out weighs any other pizzeria in this area, the owners dedication to his food and customers on scale 1-10 is 9.9 . He custom builds pies to your liking ! That’s my kinda of guy !! Keep up the good work !!
Review №8
2022-01-07An honest and unbiased review. I was driving through the area on a job call. I saw the lunch special sign and walked in. The sign said $4.50 but it’s actually $5, no problem.I got my order and the pizza was good but it was a little over greasy ( inferior ingredients I guess) so I patted it down a bit with my Napkin. Slices are decent size and if they like you they’ll cut it even bigger apparently.That leads me to customer service. I noticed that the gentleman up front , I’m assuming he’s the owner because he’s in most of the pictures, is not very friendly with the younger crowd. He wasn’t too talkative with the school age kids or anyone around my age. He was very talkative with all others who came in and looked over 60 years old. Now that could be that he feels more in common with them but it still doesn’t warrant being cold and un-welcoming to allOthers.Overall if you’re looking for a cheap lunch special .. you get what you pay for. Don’t be offended if the guy upfront is rude and you’re under 60 years old.Remember I said LUNCH SPECIAL! Everything else is over priced and looks like it’s been sitting there for years.Recently went back and things have changed for the better. The heros get a thumbs up now along with the chicken parm dinner. I was surprised to see the amount of food i got for the money and it tasted good.Owner still a bit cold but ehh its just how some people are. So im changing my original 2 star rating to a 4.Price ,product and big portions make it worth the pit stop during work.
Review №9
2022-06-19I would say good taste good price good service.
Review №10
2022-04-14DELICIOUS pizza....and fast delivery. Thanks. Will come back again. Thanks.