No-contact delivery
Yes
Cheesy Pizza in New York
Categories
Location on the map
New York, New York County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Mask required
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Crowd
Tourists
Yes
University students
Yes
Payments
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Comments (199)
Spent over 30 bucks just now on delivery for a lasagna and 4 slices. Lasagna was okay, but the slices were for a child. Such a rip off!
Honestly, if someone said they have the best pizza in NYC I would agree. Their slices are amazing!What hinders me from giving them more than 3 stars is the fact that there have been many times where the staff is not demonstrating the most hygienic practices.The folks behind the counter are constantly not wearing gloves, and handle both cash and then the food without washing their hands or putting gloves on. During a pandemic, this skeeves me out even more.I love this place, but honestly I may have to stop visiting should I keep noticing this issue. Its gross.
Theres no such thing as the best NYC slice of pizza. Theres that pizza joint that consistently produces quality, always open late, super friendly staff and extra large slices. Cheesy pizza is everything you need in a NYC pizza restaurant.
Basic pizza joint with excellent pizza. Cheesy? Not any more than other classic NYC pizza.
If you stick with just ordering the pizza, you will be in heaven. The pizza is really good! And is fair in price.
Just too much cheese on it. Couldn’t finish one full slice .
The cheese steak is delicious! Customer service is great as well.
One of the best pizza places on the Upper West Side, and absolutely the #1 best spot thats open late. They will deliver until 4 a.m. if you call them (online orders end at 1:30 a.m. though). The salads and the appetizers that Ive had (such as the fried shrimp and fried calamari) arent quite as good as the pizza, but thats to be expected when it comes to casual NYC pizza joints. Theyre not *bad;* theyre just not as good as the pizza. The desserts that Ive had (cannolis and zeppoles) are great though, especially when they make the zeppoles the traditional way, as little spheres of fried dough rolled in confectioners sugar. Sometimes they make them differently, more like a funnel cake, which is still good, but not as good as those little dough balls of sugary bliss. I would give them 4.5 stars, but since you cant do half-stars, Im rounding up to 5. Will update next time I order to post pictures of the pizza.
The pizza was undercooked. The Mexican cooking the pizza was rude, refused to give me parmesan cheese, and refused to give me garlic powder after I told him the jars was empty. He was extremely rude. So sad because had it not been for him ruining my pizza I would of came back. This place is not worth your money. Avoid at all cost.
Dont get anything but a plain slice and youre golden. Sometimes they have the best crust of any place around. Its a couple bucks for a slice the size of your head. 5 stars.
Decent slice shop and theyre open late!
Been having a hard time fonding good pizza on the UWS, besides Famiglia which to my opinion is overly priced. We found this spot and will stick to it. The right amount of all ingredients; not too saucy, and not too doughy, its just right 🙂
Somewhat pricey, but the the beef patties with cheese were excellent. Pictured are their pepperoni rolls.
The crust is a little soft. Other than that I think the pizza is pretty good
This is my go-to pizza place. I understand everyone has their preferences, and this is mine. For me, this place has the best crust, hands down. Its the right flavor, texture and thickness. My only gripe is that two toppings cost more than one. I get this is a universal pricing standard, but it still makes no sense to me, because the toppings cover the same size of space regardless of how many toppings you get. Pizza topping price should be based on what it is (meat vs. veggie vs. etc), than amount of toppings.
Owner is super nice! My brother and I come here a lot since it was minutes away from the hotel we were staying at. We usually come here at night and I personally think the service is better at night. When we came during the day the lady that was serving us was rude. The pizza they serve here is huge and cheesy 😋! love it!
As the name implies, you get a cheesy pizza here. It was good, but it was a little bit too chewy for me. They dont worry too much about keeping the tables overly tidy either. Its a good neighborhood place for a slice. You get a soda if you order two slices, which is cool.
Good food, quiet place, no crowds, just a little dingy. Its like home...I likey.
1st time ordering here. I got the Bolognese with spaghetti. Its Freggin Awesome! Nice portion, arrived hot, bread on the side and taste amazingly out of this world. My new go to. Thanks guys!!!
The best pizza I’ve ever had! 11/10 on all flavours. The staff give really good info on all of the pizza and personally the best one is the chicken and bacon and the buffalo chicken! Its very good value for money! I’ve only been in New York for 5 days and have already visited 3 times and intend to visit again.
Omg I love love love love this pizza! Its just with the right amount of cheese and they make it the way you ask. My sister always takes me here and each and every time I enjoy it. I told my husband I will take him here the next time we visit NYC bc its a must! If you dont go, I suggest that you should....its clean and they have other typebof foods. They also have a major variety of pizza flavors
It was good to see the spot still around, I remember when they first opened.Solid pizza, not top notch but a decent slice.
Good slices and tables for customers. The owner and staff are hard working and friendly. However, in NYC there are a lot of great pizza places and therefore a lot of competition. Another plus: this place is open late.
It not only is the best pizza I have ever had the people are amazing too ❤️❤️❤️
Best pizza around that area! I always go Around morning/afternoon time so around that time I always thought the staff were nice to me. I reviewed a few comments below me and i was very confused to what they had said about a toaster oven? It is a real oven that has actual fire but it just cooks the pizza quicker. Many places around where i use to live (brookyln) have them. I would recommend trying them to anyone!
This is actually my favorite pizza place in the city. I am the type who wants my pizza to be at least 60% cheese, and Cheesy Pizza lives up to their name. Awesome crust, very fast and polite, all around great pizza shop
Unprofessional, said their price just changed and then theyre guessing prices
Regular pizza is very good, havent tried others
I just love this place, its open late and make the best beef patties in the neighborhood, I hate try other places, but always come back here. The staff is also super friendly they become more like family the more I go there. My only complaint is that if you are ordering thing that gets away from pizza and such the taste is not always there. But anyway its a nice place to hang out and have a really good slice of pizza.
I had a plain slice of pizza it was ok the sauce lacked flavor usually I eat my pizza without condiments this pizza a had to add some oregano, garlic powder, and some red pepper flakes in order to enjoy it. Place was clean and the people behind the counter was plesent.
I had serious food poisoning after having their pizza! The environment is very dirty!
Nice large cheesy slices. Buy 2 slices get a free fountain soda for $7.00. For 100 & Broadway its a good deal. I added oregano and hot peppers for a little added flavor.
Been going to cheesy pizza for years. Love their pizza. Pop in if your on the upper west side, youll be glad you did...
The BEST BBQ chicken slice!!
It was ok, they was open after the 12am on New Years eve. It was clean. I ordered a meatball calzone, the older gentleman at the register called out the order saying a calzone. I repeated that I wanted a meatball calzone. Anyway I was given a gyro calzone. My fiance got a gyro that was really good though.
Sorry that the previous poster had such a bad experience. In my personal experience the pizza has been consistently delicious at all hours of the day and night - and my husband, who is an NYC native, says it tastes like the amazing former pizza parlor Vinnies which used to be in the Lincoln Center neighborhood up until about 10 years ago. Cheers!PS - Perhaps he shouldnt have chosen Buffalo wings for his pizza topping, because that is always a mistake no matter what pizza joint you go to. My advice? Stick to the classics. : )
This place was everything you would expect from a NYC pizzaria. Pizza by slice was the way to go. Perfectly crispy and fantastic. The staff was great and very helpful. The atmosphere was excellent. We went to several pizza stops in NYC and this one was by far the best, so we kept coming back!
Grandma deep dish pie was delicious
I hadnt had a slice from this place in a while. I remember how cheese and chewy with the right amount of tanginess their slices were. So I go in yesterday and this middle aged lady is handling money and putting slices in the oven with her bare hands. The worst part was she had long nails, so who knows what was under them. I left very disappointed and grossed out.
Large-scale slices (surpasses the plate!) on a thin, tender, crunchy, flavourful crust. Being so near to Sal & Carmines, I hesitated to go here, but am glad to have tried something new. Because it was delicious.My veggie slice ($5) had sliced black olives, canned mushrooms, chopped broccoli, diced fresh white onion and an extra sprinkle of mozzarella on the top. The sauce is good and tomatoey, which i love, and the cheese a typical NYC pizza blend.Calm environment, thankfully no blaring music, and perfectly bilingual (English-Spanish) staff.Seating is limited to 13 seats at tables, and Cheesy Pizza itself is in one of the beautiful historic buildings that gives the Upper West Side its pleasant character.
Good pizza. They have many other options; like beef patties, pizza rolls, garlic knots & many toppingsg, fast & clean service, also Very friendly.
1st time here and grabbed a chicken sandwhich and lemme tell you that I was not disappointed. Great sauce and cheesey too! Will be returning soon! Thank you Tom for introducing me to this place!!
My favorite local pizza place. Friendly staff, very good pizza, large selection by the slice, and open late. Only downside is the speciality pizza slices can get expensive but I think theyre worth it.
Cheesy Pizza has been on the corner of 100 street and broadway for so long. When I was a kid they had the slices for a dollar and although the price has changed it still serves yummy pizza along with so many other dishes
The establishment is not sanitary, the pizza I ordered was very soggy, the processed mozzarella tastless, the price was very high for the neighborhood, I paid $8.75 for a slice and beverage.... I didnt even finish eating.The worst pizza..
It might not look amazing from the outside, but trust me when I say this place has some of the best pizza Ive ever had. Utterly delicious.
The guys who run this place are a bunch of scumbags. Sometimes they accept credit cards, other times they demand cash and say no credit cards even though their door clearly says they accepts all major credit cards. What a joke. Pizza is subpar, only thing decent is the chicken fingers. Avoid this place at all costs.
The pizza is great, but its a little overpriced for the same quality elsewhere.
Owner treats his worker like dirt, I witnessed it one late night. He shush his worker away like an animal.. The pizza its ok. Only reason I gave it that many stars its because they open late.
Love this pizzeria! Very cheesy pizza! Go here everytime I take my kids to Riverside Park or their Doctor office.
Ive been taking my boys there since elementary school and theyre graduated from college and high school now and they still love their Cheesy pizza. Best on the upper westside.
I live this close and they would not deliver to me. They hung up on me multiple times and said I lived out of their delivery range. I called at 12:30am and their website says they close at 1:30am. Somehow the 6 minute drive is out of their range...
I love this pizzeria! Id definitely recommend this place to anybody, its worth visiting :). Theyve raised the prices on some stuff recently tbh.
Amazing tasty pizza best Ive tasted in ny, with great variety of pizzas and sandwiches. Id recommend this to pizza lovers. Great customer service.
This spot is worth trying. They serve large portions for affordable rates. Consistently neat and with awesome mood. Will come visit again.
Really enjoyed my slice but the red sauce could be more robust/seasoned & the crust a tad too thick.
Service is courteous, pizza is average. But its nice to find a pizzeria in NYC where I can get beer, too.
Love their pizza and love that they stay open late when you have those late nite munchies.
Slice of pizza had a plain taste. Garlic had a much better taste. Staff is very pleasant. Clean place.
$29.00 for ‘medium’ Grandma pizza - they call it something else. Seriously? I basic 8 slice pizza - tipped deliver guy. $35 total, for a pizza.
Pizza was delicious! The staff was friendly and the prices are good aswell, cant wait till next time
Not the best in terms of a nyc slice...kinda flimsy and wilty...the customer service is above expectation, so it kinda compensates..but Id much rather sal & carmines just up the block
I actually think this might be the best pay per slice New York style of pizza in this part of the UWS
Been going to this pizza shop for years and I loved the pizza crust is soft and chewy and they put the right amount of cheese and sauce I also love there mozzarella sticks
Ive been going here for more than 20 years. I dont have to really state the obvious lol! Theyre one of the few pizzerias that have bacon as a topping!👍🏾👍🏾
This place is worth giving a shot. They have large portions for fair rates. Regularly clean and with fantastic character. I highly recommend this place.
Best pizza in town hands down a little pricey but well worth it
Huge slices! Good pizza and a variety of popular Italian foods
Good place, good pizza! Is not the best one but is really delicious.
Very good thin crust pizza worth the price added bonus they have anchovies along with a vast array of other toppings
Gudddddddd!!! And I really like the guys,there so nice. I like the short 1 with the glasses 🤗 he work at sheshe too❤️❤️❤️
Simply Amazing, Best tasting Regular slice of pizza in NYC, nothing comes close it, plenty of cheese, and great sauce!
Really good pizza!!!
Its a good place to eat good NY style pizza get service, a bit too pricey though.
Great food service and price. Must have when in NY.
I love the pizza here, always FRESH, at anytime, no skimpy slice, a real old school large slice.
Descent pizza.but im Italian from bk so im harsh on pizza. Friendly staff
Unexpected! So good. Thin sliced chicken gyro is so good. Original pizza is huge, delicious , cheap
Great spot for a late night slice
I love cheese pizza and this place serves it just right.. the staff is polite and service is really quick.
Good service and the pizza is really cheesy they dont lie
Cheesy Pizza is exactly that, Cheesy pizza. Amazing food awesome family oriented service and food was very nostalgic.
Pretty good pizza, large selection of toppings, friendly staff, and they have pretty good zeppole. If you dont know what that is, look it up LOL!
They used to have an amazing buffalo pizza. Now its horrible. The pizza is dry and over priced
Ive ate here twice and the chicken/pizza is great,and I like the service.
The people treat you nice and the food is nice. My daughter loved that they had ice cream.
Good old local uptown Westside Pizzeria , they make it the way you want it. great staff.
The pizza was eh, okayNot the best how ever the service sucked they yreated me as of i was going to run off with out paying ..... NEVER AGAIN ONE AND DONE
Nice place for a quick stop and a bathroom break. Good pizza and staff is nice. Parking is easy on Broadway.
Great Pizza. Grabbed a cold beer and good tasting slice. The new Go to when on 103
Love this delicious pizza. Been going here foe more than 20 years
The staff were amazing, and the pizza was amazing! It was best pizza I had in NYC
Quick, Hot, tasty pizza. Slice sizes are big. Typical of ny pizza. #nypizza.
This place has a unique Pizza Oven that I have never seen anywhere else. Very fast in and out
Dont eat ther !!!! The pizza its soo old
Our food was not good, our pizza was soggy, our garlic bread tasted horrible and had no garlic on it, our garlic knots were just hard bread, and our mozzarella sticks were comparable to a standard cheese stick you’d find in your fridge.
Great food but a little bit over priced, but still the pizza was amazing.
Best Pizza place in Manhattan. Yum 😋!!
Good pizza, better after a few (a lot) drinks. Fast service and fresh pizza!!!!
Pizza is ok, but their sandwiches taste delicious. A bit overpriced though.
The pizza was authentic and delicious.
Really good pizza! Cheesy is a good name for them, they dont skimp on the cheese.
Top notch service, Very professional.
I really enjoyed the pizza. Didnt expect it to be that delicious
Credit card machine is always broken, staff never knows when it will be fixed. Was out of knots and said they wouldnt make more (is was 8pm).
Ok , average nothing great , just ok. A quick chow, ....
Friendly staff. Pizza was good but not great.
Loved the pizza here! Open late and the workers are super friendly!
I love this pizza!!! Customer service is great everyone is pleasant and fast service!!!
Horrible service, owner is a liar, didnt credit my account when they didnt deliver pizza, wish I could give 0 stars
The pizza is extremely oily and bland, plus I got sick after eating here last night
All I ordered was chicken garlic knots they were horrible, hard, no chicken in them, I love garlic and they did not use fresh garlic it was bitter.
I saw one of the workers drop spatula on the floor and just picked it up and wipe it off with a towel. It killed my appetite.
Got a sausage calzone one of my favorite foods when i got it it was cold and undercooked this is the first and last time i go there never again
Best traditional Sicilian pizza ever....
The pizza is good and customer service is on point!
Best pizza in manhattan
Service and food for quick stop is fast, friendly and always professional. I go for their pizza and coffee.
Very cheesy. Not enough flavor though.
Good food, decent prices. Weird find: amazing chocolate cake
It was ok
Good but a bit greasy
Fast food joint with AWESOME pizza. Garlic knots are just irresistible.
Easily the best pizza ive ever had!
Open late, and the pizza really does taste extra cheesy. Pretty good.
With a great meal, comes a great staff and great service. This is a one stop shop for it all.
Great service, awesome pizza very very cheesy...
It is pretty cheap, pretty decent pizza. Not much more to it, but fills a niche.
Quick pizza. Not my favorite in the neighborhood but its not bad.
Excellent pizza, service and best - hours of service
Pizza was good, open late, staff was really rude though.
Very delicious!!!
Pizza is ok. Good deal though for 2 slices and a drink.
NOT AWFUL .. THEY EVEN HAVE VEGAN CHEESE.
Very good place to go for a quick bite during lunch or dinner.
Good pizza. I l8ke anchovy. Good garlic knotd
Been coming to this place since I was a little girl love the food and staff
Love the pizza not worth the price
Great Place Great Food and open until 4am. Talk about convenient.
Literally just ordered 40$ wroth of wings, the food wasn’t even cooked probably had to throw it away because the manager wouldn’t take the wings back & giving me my money back!!!!!
I love cheese slice for 3$ and spinach roll 8$
So so pizza at best. Very expensive to not be great.
Good pizza opens late, serves beer and delivers.
It was convenient at 12AM but average pizza at best
Price too high
Good place to catch a bite late at nite. Prices are moderate.
Its not the best its not the worstPricey pizza would also be a good name.
Literally only had garlic knots and i’m in love!10/10.
Great cheesy pizza. Nice selection too.
Toaster oven pizza. They run it through a toaster!!!Soggy dough. Only in the most dire situations should you eat this pizza.
This is the best pizza I ever tasted, unfortunately Its so expensive
Great food I’ve been eating there for years
Great service and the food is amazing, I love this place
Very good pizza, great people.
Between 100 and brodway. They pizza is the best .
This place is really good. It closes late, and the slices are big.
The pizza are good and big
Great food great people very nice and there fast
The staff are hardworking and friendly.prizes are affordable this spot is worth trying,
I had the 10inch Stromboli & the Zeppoli, these guys know what they are doing.
Pizza is good, great pricing, fast turnaround...
Not so cheesy too much bread it should be called doughy Pizza
Extremely greasy and oily. If you eat an entire piece youll be a Hero.
Its a good pizza not the greatest
First visit, tried something different and it was good.
Delicious Pizza 🍕 and very very Cheesy
Wow...If youre around here, you have to try this. Its so good👍👍
A favorite place of mine. What nice people.
Best gluten free pizza in New York.
Delicious food and you get the most for your money
Just ordered one ... It was SO good! 100% Recommended
If u hungry u r going to love it!!!! , thats all!!!!
The lady that works there she doesnt serve you well when you ask her something is responds with an attitude
Because my best uncle making it from shokry fayez girgis
Nice! Nada mas! Lol!
Place is dirty and employees are like chickens without heads
Nice pizza. Big variety to choose from.
Pricey but its mid way between the softball fields and the bar.
Old menus not much variety but fast attention
2 slices and one drink $10.50 , not worth it.
Good selection of pies gokd pjzza
The pizza taste so fresh and cheesy pizza
Pizza was really cheesy taste really good
Enjoy the pizza at this location big slices
Great place to grab a bite, it was a little crowed but nothing major
Cheesy pizza is the best!
Good pizza. Nice staff
Not many options. Cash register lady needs training asap.
Greesy, and very poor service.
Total reviews rating
199 Reviews for Cheesy Pizza 2023:
Review №1
2022-06-14Ok. Shout out to Cheesy Pizza. Our 1st time in the city and at Cheesy Pizza. The pizza was great and the staff was a 5 star staff. Lovely people. So kind. Pizza was tasty and well priced. Only 20 min across the Hudson from our hotel. Very accessible.
Review №2
2021-08-24Great stop for a slice. I favor this place over others as the pizza is fresh and you can tell it hasn’t been sitting out and slices are large. Great customer service, very friendly. Will stop in again for a slice, soon.
Review №3
2022-04-15Just like the name says cheesy pizza. I saw the name cheesy pizza and I really wanted to see how cheesy the pizza really was. It really was very cheesy and great. I recommend this pizzeria. Their plain cheese pizza is amazing. I also had their vodka slice and it was awesome. I was more than what I was expecting. Ill definitely be back soon. Thank you...
Review №4
2022-05-29Absolutely delicious food, amazing ambiance and great service! The pizza crust is perfect, the toppings (especially the burrata, mortadella and calabrese) were super fresh. We had the banana pie which was lovely. Remember to save space for their desserts! Highly recommend 10/10! Service was also awesome. Yumi in particular was super kind, welcoming and had great recommendations. The whole experience was splendid. Will be coming here often.🤩🤩
Review №5
2022-05-26The owner and his wife were extremely nice. The pizza was good for our late night arrival. Surprised so many restaurants were closed so early.
Review №6
2022-02-27Tried to order on Uber eats and there was no way to order a simple Hawaiian pizza. I had to call to amend it. The lady up-charged me $6-8 for a pizza that was already $28. I’ve never heard of up-charging so much just for simple ham and pineapple toppings. What a rip-off.The pizza itself was just okay. I won’t be coming back.
Review №7
2022-01-16Been ordering pizza here since we moved to the neighborhood in 2005 and we still love it to this day!!! Great NYC style pizza, Perfect to fold and munch to your hearts content!
Review №8
2022-01-02Amazing pizza and chicken tenders.Terrible delivery service though. It’s been horrendously late/delayed when I’ve ordered through Seamless and I had to cancel my last order because it had been over an hour!
Review №9
2022-06-06Always enjoy the pizza here, and the service is quick and enjoyable.
Review №10
2022-03-19Fantastic pizza. Had the margarita. One of the best I have ever had.