No-contact delivery
Yes
Ciminellis Pizza & Restaurant in Bethpage
Categories
Location on the map
Bethpage, Nassau County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Planning
Accepts reservations
Yes
Phone: +1 516-939-0009
Site: http://www.ciminiellispizza.com/
Site: http://www.ciminiellispizza.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–10PM
- Tuesday:11AM–10PM
- Wednesday:11AM–10PM
- Thursday:11AM–10PM
- Friday:11AM–10PM
- Saturday:11AM–10PM
- Sunday:11AM–10PM
Comments (130)
Delicious food reasonably priced. Great service.
Went to Ciminellis Pizza & Restaurant in Bethpage for a local Valentines Dinner last night and it was amazing!The table was set up and restaurant was decorated beautifully for the holiday! The bread/garlic sticks they give to start are fresh out of the oven warm and so delicious. We got a small salad and mini rice balls for appetizers. Baked cheese ravioli (one with tomato and one with vodka sauce) for the main course. Chocolate lava cake and hot tea to end the night.The wait staff was extremely attentive. I think it was possibly the owner there (maybe a manager/higher up) who provided all the women in the restaurant with a rose for Valentines day, which was totally unexpected and so nice. He also gave us a comp after dinner drink with dessert! There was no rushing us at all to finish up and was a nice relaxing environment. Everything was amazing (some food we devoured before I could take a picture lol). Great local spot, highly recommend⭐️
Had a great experience, great tasting pizza pie for me and my family! Got 2 pies, FRESH YUM! definitely recommend this family run pizza shop to anyone in the area. VERY TASTY and best local pizzeria in Bethpage New York!
Pizza review: excellent sauce, slices are small, soft crust, very unique pizza style. A bit too $$$ compared to other local pizza shops, but well worth the extra $2.Shoppe looks clean both in front and back. Delightful staff.
This has always been my go to place for Italian food, but lately it has been loosing its luster. This past Friday I had a little difficulty placing the order for two heros. Its a good thing I double checked as I would have only received one. That all can be attributed to a new employee and can be forgiven. My wife had gotten a Traditional Grilled Chicken that was really tough and came with onions & peppers that I didnt ask. Nothing could be salvaged..Very disappointing.
We arrived at this spot for dinner. we heard about this restaurant from quite a few people. Well, it was a winning. we were warmly welcomed by the crew and we had an excellent feeling. The food was just great. We enjoyed every moment and we will definitely return to this restaurant. Highly recommended.
First time out since COVID quarantine!! Have never been to Ciminellis before, went tonight because they had an outside dining area. We all had a great time. The food was great and the service was excellent. Angelica really made us feel comfortable and we noticed how she constantly used hand sanitizer. Wii really felt taken care of
If i could rate more than 5 stars i would. Amazing. The food was the best i have ever had. The desert is also a must have. Also the staff was so nice, reminded me of souther hospitality in the north. Nothing more i can ad other than if your on the fence on what to eat, this is the place to go!
A lot of specialty pies, all are tasty with a fast turn around during the day. Parking can be a little crazy during the day but I have never been let down. There are a few Pizza places in the area but these guys actually use real garlic on their garlic knots.
We love Ciminellis Pizza Restaurant, the food is great their , we get great service and it is very convenient not far to go for a good meal. We enjoyed the Flounder Francis it is 1 of our favorite meals when we go there Bill the owner is great we are friendly with him and his staff all know us the great us when we go there. I give it 4 Stars*****. Pices,are also reasonable we feel. We definitely recommend going there.
Always great service here. Super friendly staff. Food is delicious. The hospitality is superb. I couldnt say enough good things about this place. I go once a month all the way from the bronx. That has got to speak volumes.
Clean and the food is always good and fresh been going here since the late 90s never disappointed and the staff are always kind and attentive would definitely recommend this place to my friends and family as i always have !
First time beyond the pizza counter. Never knew the dining room was there. Servers were very nice. Food was very good. Will definitely be back.
Very nice Valentines menu. Flounder francaise was tasty with linguine
Ordered ahead of time. Showed up and the clueless dude at the cashier never put in half of my order. Had to wait another 20 mins for my pie and the rest of my food was barely luke warm. Also, flat soda in the machine. Rookie place. Go down the street to Pappardelles in Bethpage where they never get your order wrong.
I admire this restaurant very much. theres a very nice ambiance. The cuisine is superb. the service is dynamic and the crew is polite. The price is honest. truly recommend.
Good place, its on our lunch rotation. The pasta specials are tasty and inexpensive. For $6.95 you choose a pasta type (spaghetti, rigatoni, penne, fusilli, angel hair, linguine) and a sauce (marinara, spicy marinara, meat sauce, bolognese, a la vodka.) The portions are relatively large and come with bread.Their non-special menu is good too, but expect to pay a bit more.Finally their pizza is pretty good as well. The biggest downside of this place is the parking lot. Gets crowded quickly and there is a big bump to get into it, so watch your bumper.One warning, towards the end of the year there are a lot of luncheons that go on here. If you come and the back is full of a big party, service may suffer. If youre in a hurry then just get pizza up at the front.
Ciminnellis is our take out “Go To” for every occasion, large or small, and they never let us down; the food is delicious and the service is outstanding every time. We also enjoy their back room for both parties and regular dining. They are an asset to Bethpage
Very good cauliflower crust pizza here
The decor is nice and service was OK. The pizza was good but pricier than other restaurants. Overall fantastic dining experience and wont hesitate to come back!
Excellent food quality and service, small family owned place reflects the best qualities of product with a local feel. Come hungry! Owners are great!
Always a pleasure to eat there. The staff knows you by name, they even know your specials. Food is delicious.
HAD DINNER WITH MY WIFE LAST NIGHT , THE WAITRESS IS A ROCK STAR.I HAD VEAL THE VEAL WAS VERY GOOD. THE RED SAUCE WAS VERY PASTY. TOO MUCH TOMATO PASTE. A BIG CHANGE FROM THE LAST TIME
My favorite spot for pizza/pasta. Super friendly staff, and very clean restaurant. Definitely recommend!
I honestly enjoy the food and service, fantastic location next to my house. The workers are always welcoming. Highly recommended.
Finest food, very nice employees, consistently fantastic mood. They charge fair rates and the food quality is good. Kudos.
Thats nice they take down my review about their horrible packaging and they think its okay to serve people food that spills all over the bag, dont go to this place they only want you to see the good reviews!
Fantastic Granma slices..!! Loaded with plum tomato.. I plan on exploring theyre menu further
There food is worth the drive..the place is super clean and everywhere you look is super clean they even have a t.v. to watch..whats even cooler is they have a restaurant in the back room for parties and the front part is a pizzeria...super cool..i give them a. 5 gold stars...
The last few times we got pizza from here we thought it was very good, but tonight everything we got tasted like dirty tap water with a chlorine aftertaste . We ended up throwing out half of what we ordered and wont be returning.
Their pizza is 4/5 stars but over priced and their over weight delivery guy likes to assume the change is his tip money. There are comparable pizza places neat by almost a third of the price cheaper
Was goin there alot latley food was aways on the money however last 2 times in a row they forgot my 2 salads then the other day ordered a double order of fish franchise witch is usually very good and it was terrible no taste very oily no flavor call 2 complain nextday was told boss would get back 2 me witch he did not but was told by an employee that they would credit me 1 meal witch didnt make me happy, dought i will b going back there
50th bday party. Food was phenomenal. Service was spectacular. Staff was very friendly and accommodating. Wish I could give them 10 stars
Staff was very helpful regular slice of pizza soggy I wonder do they have new owners their food is usually awesome
Great food. Been there many times for lunch and dinner. Chicken Parmigian, Lasagne, penne ala vodka, are my favorites.
I order a philly steak sandwich to pinwheels and to slices of pizza I waited 20 minutes for the sandwich and all the cheese was Stuck on aluminum foil.the two pinwheels where cold like they just come out of the refrigerator and the pizza was ice cold to this was the worst food I ever had I had to go out and buy other food so my 2 kids and wife can have dinner i will never go back to this place
Went for a bday dinner party. Service was very good. Food was nice.
Toppings way overpriced. Large pepperoni and mushroom pie 33.50 with tax. WHAAAAAAT? Must be the new math. $5.25 per topping. Ridiculous!
Great restaurant,real good food. Staff helpful and friendly. Decorated with class.
ATTN ALL FOODIES! Best food and service in town! Very kind folks who also make high quality fare.
Best pizzeria just happened to be driving by he should have 15 locations he would do well in every location chicken salad slice tender and juicy also sausage slice the sauce is great
Got a white pie with chicken and broccoli. The pie came out with large pieces of grilled chicken and whole stalks of broccoli and we loved every last bite.
This place has the two most important recipes of a very good restaurant: Great quality of food and very nice staff!
The cost is very good for the people of the area. Their food portions are large. Anything you get is great. Service is good.
Totally love the food and the quaintness of the dining room.. excellent service always!
Been eating here with my family since early 90s Billy is a awesome guy Jose is just as awesome.
Exelente food the service fantastic and Jose is a great guy gracias jose
I enjoyed the pizza with my grandson there
Had calamari tonight.........the best. Nice amount, great sauce, hot and crunchy. A++++Would order this again. Bob R.
Great pizza! Friendly servers and a varied selection of food.
You habe three pizza places in the heart of bethpage..hands down this the best one... Grest selection, great staff, AMAZING FOOD!
Food was great excellent service would definitely go back
Good italian food at reasonable prices. They have a pizza place at the front and a fine dining place in the back.
Ive sampled clam pasta in white sauce all over the states and Italy, and this was by far the best Ive ever eaten.
Love this restaurant...the food is great and Bill the owner is so friendly. My family always thinks of ciminellis first.
Excellent pizza, especially the specialty slices. Great service too!
I’ve been going to this place for years. Great little neighborhood joint.
Great pizza. Excellent customer service. Will def return.
Good food in an intimate dining room attached to the pizza take out area.
Best pizza place in Bethpage!
Food and service excellent! Very pretty dining room!
The salad is made to order which truly love. The pizzas are delicious.
Ive only had the pizza from this place and its outstanding.
Great food.. Love the grilled chicken salad slice!
Great food nice people dining room has great service
Good tasting food. Prices are okay. Friendly service.
My go to place !! Fresh food and the staff are great
Food is good. Staff is semi friendly. Worth a try.
Ordered a plain pizza. Very bland. Had better pizza from 7-11.
Bbq chicken pizza great. The pepperoni pinwheel with sauce was not that great.
Very good food! Wait staff very friendly!
Great variety of Pizza. Excellent counter service.
Delivery order showed up 1 hour and 15 minutes late and food was COLD!
Food was good service acceptable good all around dining
Been eating their pizza for 20+ years, cant find better in Nassau
My favorite pizza place. Try my favorite dish, shrimp parmigiana hero.
Great food great staff, a family favorite
Great food all around. (Not just their pizza)
Excellent food, just like eating at home!
Fantastico! Best cannoli Ive had in years!
Amazing and friendly, well organized and clean!!!
Great place! Great food and great service!
Excellent food! Great service!
Excellent job. They always treat me special.
There was yummy food there
A GD place for pizza look elsewhere for dinner
Amazing staff and amazing food!!
Food is always fresh and always good
Excellent The best pizza in Bethpage
Good food and friendly staff.
Average food
Food is great. Service is great.
The staff and food are amazing.
Food not as good as it once was.
Best pizza in New York
Not bad, place seems busy.
Very nice dining room
Great pizza 🍕
The best Pizza in Bethpage.
Excellent food and service.
The best bethpage the food is.Best bethpage
Great food and service
Excellent Pizza and more!
Great food and service
Very Good Pizza
Awesome pizza and Italian food
Great pizzeria in Bethpage
Food not so good!
Good food, service, 🍕
Best pizza in town
Food is yummy.
Very good 👌
Healthy portions
Another tasteful slice
Awesome
Food was delicious
Good pizza.
Great pizza
Great pizza
Lousy serboce
Total reviews rating 4.4
130 Reviews for Ciminellis Pizza & Restaurant 2023:
Review №1
2021-12-27Anthony is an exceptional waiter. The food is awesome. And there is plenty of parking available. Highly recommend Ciminellis for lunch or dinner. And ask for Anthony!
Review №2
2022-04-12Food is decent but we’re done with ordering from here. There is ALWAYS something wrong with the order - countless wrong food orders, and even more times giving the drastically wrong delivery estimate times. It’s beyond frustrating (especially when planning meal times for kids) to enjoy the food they offer but repulse the experience so much to have to find a new spot.
Review №3
2019-09-14Great place to visit with your family. I went for my wifes birthday and this lady was awesome. She even made changes as my wife needed for her food. Very family friendly environment place.
Review №4
2017-10-02I ordered an everything pizza WITHOUT mushrooms and olives, But i got an Everything pizza WITH mushrooms and olives. Which is fine I guess, im allergic but whatever right? I called to have it changed and they didnt want to because they were closing in 15 min. Wings were good but the service eehhhhh. It was okay. And i got a random french fry which was very weird lol
Review №5
2022-07-15Sick of getting a blanket of cheese and crust. Does anyone put sauce on pizza anymore??
Review №6
2022-03-03My husband and I love Ciminellis! Weve both been coming since before we met each other 13 years ago. Shockingly enough my hubbys favorite is the Salad Slice :) Highly recommend 👌
Review №7
2021-12-27We came with 16 relatives for a funeral luncheon….Anthony was kind prompt personable & he was sooooo helpful with all r orders!!! Great food & service…we’ll definitely return soon.
Review №8
2021-08-01Moved into the area a year ago and never heard of this restaurant. Friends put me on to La Piazza in Plainview which is great. Until my neighbor mentioned Ciminellis and asked why do I keep going to La Piazza when they are always busy. He invited me to go with him one day and my family and others have been hooked.Have your pie made well done. The texture, and sauce are amazing. The owners son Tony, knew it was my first time and I mentioned howmy wife loved grandma slices. He gave me a free slice and sicilion packed up and said give this to her.My wife was very pleased and loved it. Thank you Ciminellis you will see us soon.
Review №9
2021-08-25Pinwheels are absolutely to die for don’t t leave without one.
Review №10
2021-06-07Waited an hour for the food and live up the road. When you call they put your info in the computer. first night they put the wrong address, next time I called in an order they put in the wrong town sending the driver to farmingdale. I had guest over it was a bad experience when I called the manager asking where my food was that it was a hundred dollar order he said we got all new drivers they get lost easy. 20 years in the industry myself thats not how you handle a complaint. Food was ok but the wait for the price ridiculous. Were not going back.