Delivery
Yes
Citarella Gourmet Market - Southampton in Southampton
Categories
Location on the map
Southampton, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
In-store pick-up
Yes
In-store shopping
Yes
Same-day delivery
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Safety dividers at checkout
Yes
Highlights
Great produce
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Planning
Quick visit
Yes
Payments
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 631-283-6600
Site: http://www.citarella.com/content...
Site: http://www.citarella.com/content...
Opening hours
- Monday:8AM–7PM
- Tuesday:8AM–7PM
- Wednesday:8AM–7PM
- Thursday:8AM–7PM
- Friday:8AM–7PM
- Saturday:8AM–7PM
- Sunday:8AM–7PM
Citarella Gourmet Market - Southampton in other cities:
Comments (199)
Everything I got was great and fresh and every employee was extremely helpful from the butcher who assisted picking out two steaks of sword fish to Britney, who helped me decide on what kind of pie to buy, key lime, which had a great crust. Their selection was small, but for a store its size it had a lot. My only draw back was the prices but they seemed on par with the level of quality and service. High prices seem to be a reoccurring thing in the Hamptons for this visitor.If you are looking for high end groceries this is the place to visit.
I ordered pepperoni pizza. It looked really good but tasted like it was reheated several times. The crust was hard and the pizza was dry. The salad was good. The food is VERY expensive, and is below average. You can get MUCH BETTER pizza at most Pizza places.
Wonderful selection and fresh produce. We had the hot soup and drove to the Ocean for sunset.
The place is too expensive! I bought a lunch, which was rice, roasted vegetables(little), and three small pieces of chicken, the price $20,51 unbelievable!! I never paid for lunch that price! If you need to get lunch, don’t go there, unless you don’t care about money…
Very disappointed in their specialty offering (ie dairy free, gluten free, etc). The rotisserie chicken was very good but the sides were tasteless and uninspired. 3 been salad and couscous and chickpea
Pricey but great quality. Great salad bar. Citarella sells food only...no kitchen gadgets or paper product, etc. They have dey aged beef :)
Okay but they dont carry ethnic foods and some other regular items
Extensive ready-to-eat food selection. Affordable prices (for the Hamptons 🙄)
A little pricey, but the food is fresh and lots of food shopping options.
Love the store - but I purchased prepared eggplant parmigiana and there were no direction for reheating or cooking. Called and was told that microwaving 3 minutes or in the oven 5 minutes would work. Used the oven and 7 minutes was definitely not enough. The dish was cold! I dont want anyone in my family to have digestive illnesses at this difficult time - and the cooking/heating directions are very important-- Citarella needs to ensure that directions are put on each item and that customer service gives the correct information.
Fab place mega food ... great facilities:-)))) XXXXX
Best market top shelf they have a wonderful selection of cheese and ready to go
Very nice and price to go with it. Pesto sandwich was good but had cold spots.
Market was well stocked and clean. However waited 10 minutes to be helped at counter. I was the only one on line. Help too busy working behind counter. Was ignored
Busy, overpriced, and low-quality in many areas. Very little parking, too. Would not recommend.
Absolutely love this place. The salad bar is fantastic, the fried chicken is the best in the area by far, great seafood, best oyster selection, fantastic desserts, pizza, sushi, soups, breads, breakfast/sandwiches made to order, cheeses, lots of gourmet pre-prepared dinner items. Also great for kids, everyone gets what they want, and they have a great eat-in dining area. You will love it too.
This place is amazing! Beautiful gourmet market with food everywhere you look. They have prepacked salads and sandwiches, they have hot pizza and sandwiches. They have a huge food bar with everything from pasta salad, rice balls, brussel sprouts and chicken dishes. Plus regular everyday groceries and fruit. And a beautiful desert selection. Highly recommend!!
Youre probably familiar with this place if you live in, or ever visited Southampton. Every town needs grocery stores, and this one is up there in terms of quality. The selection is very wide, and the quality of goods is also likewise, high. Its pretty honestly, straightforward and doesnt need reviewing on Google.
This is an outstanding grocery store/food market and a great place to stop for a quick lunch that wont break the bank if you come to town with the kids. There is something for everyone and the prepared food is really fresh and delicious. I live in Shelter and would kill to have a Citarella on the island. Its also a great place to go to get a beautiful bouquet at a good price for a hostess gift. Everything is high quality, fresh and youd be hard pressed to come up with any food item thats not stocked on the shelves.
Although I am a local this was my first trip & I was very pleasantly surprised! Normally supermarkets are not staffed with the friendliest (or most helpful) people, but Citarellas is the exception! Yes, they are a bit expensive, but Id rather spend a little more if Im going to get better service & fresher food! Ive got ZERO complaints!!
I shop regularly at my hometown Citarella in Greenwich, CT but when summering in Southampton, I buy all my meat and fish here. They have the highest quality meat and fish available. The made to order pizza also is madewith the finest ingredients available and is amazing. The only drawback to shopping during the summer months is the long lines and wait time when checking out. Highly recommend!
The food selection is great but the staff is incompetent. Service is horrible. I walked in at 610 pm and was there for the salad bar. There were no ladles at all. There was no way to serve yourself. I had to ask for it. Also the staff is non English speaking. They are talking amongst themselves in Spanish.
The creme de la creme gourmet market. From seafood to prime meats, from vegetables to fruits, from dairy to pastries. Outstanding products. The flower assortment is from Dutch Petals, beautiful. Great gift ideas. Helpful and friendly service. The atmosphere has a great vibe.
It is a very nice market a lot of healthy items along with pre cooked choices.
Over price place too expensive
Great meats and fish. We got amazing NY Strips and Wild Salmon to grill back at the house and it was awesome. Super selections and the staff on totally on top of their game.
Citarella is a great place to go for lunch when working in Southampton. the only thing I would say is they need a bit more variety in their soups. They tend to have the same soups over and over again and I would love to see more variety there.
Market based out of NYC. Wide selection of high end items. Very expensive to grocery shop there. The deli counters however are great for lunches and snacks. Prices are cheapest in the area for soups, pizzas, and burger and fries. Popular lunch spot.
Citarella is an upscale supermarket. If you are in Southampton and looking for different lunch choices, this place may be a good option for you. They offer hot and cold lunch and even have staff on the premise who also make sushi, pizza and can make anything on the grill. Located right in the town, parking in the summer is tough.
Yo, I gotta be real with you. This Mediterranean salad is straight up so good that even tho I hate olives I’m even eating the olives. Like, yeah the prices are more than some other grocers but you get what you pay for and this is like a God of a salad. If you want a baller salad definitely head to citarella. Fresh ingredients and Dynamo taste 10/10
Expensive..well stocked..great fish..produce and bakery. The fried chicken is amazing..though the stagg dont know what the fruit or veggies are to enter price code..they need training
Gourmet Marketplace throughout the East End. Fantastic meat, fish, produce and specialty foods. This is where the fancy folk shop, so bring your wallet. Also have to say they have amazing friend chicken!
Citarella, in my opinion, is a fabulous place to shop, dine and embrace aromas of many incredible dishes. I never leave Citarella without a new item such as a jam or fresh loaf of bread. Great variety of indebles.
This place puts the word Super in the food market. Citarellas is a foodie paradise. As you enter, your senses are pleasantly overcome by the fresh floral scents and merges quickly to the wafting of baked goods and home cooking aromas. Which way to go first doesnt matter as you as it is highly doubtful you will do an about-face. There are a well-stocked meat and fish counter, fresh vegetables and fruits as well as tempting pre-made dishes and cooking stations where you can get a hot breakfast, lunch or dinner including pizza! And dont forget the bread and cheeses! There is something here for everyone to enjoy!
Nice but high price
Great selection! I must say the mango mousse from the bakery section is amazingggggggg.
Those guys are ripoff....be aware!From selling expired burrata cheese ( Exp.date hidden by their own label ) several times, rancid French ham, .....I just realized later.Today the fishmonger gave me 1/2 Lb lump crab meat for the price of 1 Lb!I drive all the way from WHB and back......waste
Excellent shop. A little bit of everything can be found here. Pizza, heroes, subs, drinks, beer, produce, candy, baked goods, and more. Food was excellent, and the bread and meats seemed excellent quality.
This place is filled with amazing food from allover the world. The staff is very friendly. You do pay the Southampton tax tho, as it is pricey.
This store has all the specialty and gourmet items you will need for your recipes! The selection of fresh herbs is wonderful. The fresh meat and fish selection is amazing! I love this store!
Really good Citarella branch, with an amazing salad bar. More selection than other locations of the same brand. Always friendly cashiers and good coffee!
The best salad and hot bar ever, bakery is heavenly! Staff are cordial, pleasant and very helpful. Best produce in the area hands down. Assorted soups every day.
One stop shopping for all your food needs. My kids love the salad and hot food bars. Great for a quick bite if your trying to eat healthy.
Great selection of groceries Freshly cooked food to take out and catering available. Clean,well organized. Freshest meats ,fish, baked goods..
This market is really good! I almost went there everyday during my stay there! Love the sushi and fried chicken! They also have good salad and other food.
Over priced but good
The selection there is unbelievable... No matter what youre in the mood for you can be sure they have it and everything is so clean and delicious... I cant wait to go again
Vast selection of charcuterie, desserts and gourmet products. I always end up spending more than I wanted but thats because of the great variety and quality.
For two salad two waters for the price was ridiculous. Salads should cost no were near 60.00 especially if its a small salad the portions didnt fit the price.
Very clean, great variety, nice prepared food, pizzas are very good, nice sandwiches station....maybe they should start a fidelity program to get some discount...🤔
The best and freshest groceries in Southampton can be found at Citarella. The fresh catches, expert advice of the staff and all food provides an elegant solution for every meal of the day. Parking can be challenging as one gets closer to Labor Day.
Excellent selection and great cooked food too! Unfortunately, pricing is Hamptony; IOW, about 15% more than normal. Since I live in town, I save that on gas if I go west anyway.
Good food. Should start reward points
Food is good but over priced. Workers are nice to certain people.
The customer service was very poor. Our holiday meal of brisket, potato pancakes etc was almost inedible. I expect so much more from Citarella.
Great service. Best salad bar in town. Check out line moves quickly. Wonderful cheese and bread selection.
Best deli in the area!
When it comes to gourmet markets, owner Joe Gurrera knows his stuff. One of the best fresh seafood selections in the Hamptons, prepared foods change with the season, hot soups, sandwiches, gourmet grocery items, fresh produce, quality meats and a great spot to stop pick up a copy of Dans Papers and have a coffee. If you are a foodie like me, shopping here is like being a kid in a candy store. Not inexpensive mind you but worth the trip.
It’s a shame that they charge what they do and then the food spoils within a day or two of purchase. Be very wary of checking expiration dates, which aren’t even listed on many of their items.
Rip off. Daughter bought a bagel for .99 and they charged 2.00 for butter. I brought it to their attention and they saidthats just the way it iswont go back
Always one of my favorite Hampton markets to go to. Easy to find favorite and delicious food to eat. Why cook?!
Usually crowded on summer weekends, but a great selection of quality specialty grocery items as well as prepared foods. Good iced coffee, too.
I have worked for Citarella for three consecutive summers 2014-2016 and I loved it. I was a great employee there since I was reviewed by customers and coworkers of my great customer service skills and was too often times complimented. In August 2015 I was given my weekly cheque of 500+USD which I deposited to my bank account and it was after I went back to Jamaica at the end of that summer 2015, that I got a letter from the BOA to say that the cheque was bounced and they returned it to my employer. Ever since Ive been contacting both Citarella and the BOA re the issue of the cheque. Ive been told by my manager at Citarella to contact their HR and ADP who deals with their finances and I have been doing so for one full year and more, only to be told by HR that ADP said the cheque was paid. After numerous visits to the BOA Ive gathered all the necessary and even unnessary documents to prove that the money was deducted from my account but all Citarella says is that the money was already paid and thats their bottom line. I am really really in need of the money owed to me because I have some debts I still have to clear and the mere fact that I need some of it and even more for school. I have taken this route because I think Citarellas HR, deletes my emails without responding or direct my email address to spam because of my million emails and calls and I refuse to let this money die and I end up losing. I hope HR or someone who can help me get my money see this review and analyze this matter. I need my long over due money. I really do!
Has everything you would need in a store. A bit expensive but that is Southampton for you. Good soups and sandwiches.
Meat needs to be checked more often. Got Chicken thighs 2 times that smelled so bad I won’t shop for meat off season in there anymore.
5 stars without a doubt..fresh produce from all around the world...prime meats, cheeses, breads a true Italian dream and a fantastic place to shop for all..Tumeric Shots!
Its a great place to get food for your delicious meals
Food is delicious, selection is decent, but prices are sky high.
Nice shopping experience. Totally taking advantage of non-price sensitive patrons.
5 begrudging stars. Its a decent Citerella, especially compared to others nearby. And Citerella is ... Well, you understand, right? Too expensive, but sometimes the best choice there is. Like I said ... 5 BEGRUDGING stars.
The best meats, fish and produce available! Expensive, but worth it! Very helpful staff.
Excellent food always fresh but price is on the high side. But you do get what you pay for quality wise.
Always fresh, best meats and fish, breads, baked goods and fried chicken from the buffet takeout foods.
Top rated food options across the board. Especially the produce
Great sushi to go. Pizza is also excellent. Nice urban vibe. Very expensive for groceries.
Top quality at a great price. Everything is amazing specially seafood, fish and meats
Wonderful food. Good to know: although the store closes at nine, the deli and other specialty departments close at eight.
Fantastic selection of a variety of foods, all tasty. One word of caution: its pricey.
Lobster roll was as good as some of the more expensive lobster shacks and we got fries included for under $20.00
Food delicious ,costumer service poor ,at the cool meat 4 employees talking anf we waiting🤔
Everything about the location is he best. The food and presentations great, also parking is not a problem.
The food was very good but extremely expensive
15 bucks for half gallon of OJ. Walmart is better but non existent in these parts.
You cant really beat it, its all really very good and they get going early , great selection, they have a zillion things
Overrated supermarket, high prices and very little local produce. You have a better selection in any other supermarket in SH
Great food. Fantastic salad bar. Can seat inside
Kind of on the small side, but its a citarella cant really go wrong. Has a great eating area.
Its a good place. Good quality stuff.
Ridiculously expensive, I wouldnt go back there unless I need something desperately that any other place doesnt have, prices are not marked on lots of items, so you are surprised at cash register
Good place to grab lunch and go! Wide variety of food items!
High end grocery with wide selection of pre-made food. Avoid during peak time (weekend lunchtime/dinner time)
Very good and well maintained market usually visit the one in East Hampton......Definitely reccomend
Best , unbelievable, such a wonderful shopping experience
Love the food because it is always fresh and everything is very delicious!!
Extremely clean place, eat in or not, many fresh nutritional options, good expressos.
Citarella is an amazing gourmet market offering the best of everything in thier Southampton location.
Omg . They best southern fried chicken I ever tasted.
Love that they carry difficult to find items not carried at the typical grocery including International items or their own brand of an international item!!
They have everything!! Super nice interior as well. Bustling as I would expect
Picked up lunch and dinner. The hot food buffet is good and changes slightly every day.
Excellent choice of gourmet foods. Expensive quality products.
Well prepared, gourmet and basic foods. High quality produce.
Delicious food at Citarella, every time a pass by I must stop to grab something to eat
Clean overpriced market.
Beautiful food. Great service. Extortionate prices.
Great selections from meats and cheeses to organic groceries, with a helpful staff
Top quality and efficient yet polite service. Unusually commodious eat-in space.
Overpriced. Decent selection. Great place for sushi grade fish.
The selection and presentation makes this grocery store one of my favorite spots in the Hamptons.
Went looking for gift basket didnt really see anything different for the money that they wanted.
Excellent quality butcher, fish monger, and pastries. Coffee could be a bit better
Nice little grocery store, a little bit pricey though
Good place for food shopping. complete meals, and to take away or eat here.
Excellent produce and meat selection... prices to match quality
Gross.i feel like the employees are treated very poorly behind closed doors.
Their products are awesome and tasty, but its pricy.
Got a real nice variety of food and really fresh fruits
Over priced deli, good product array, but pretentious prices, but everywhere else is worse.
Nobody speaks english besides the manager who you can hear yelling at his workers from across the store
Very clean and large selection. You can eat there too...
Great soups, salads, breads, cheeses...love the pizza and fried chicken!!
Fresh with many goodies to choose from. Love shopping there
Got food from the hot bar was very good worth it 👌👍👍
Great selection for beach picnic
Good variety and quality however the staff has never been friendly and theyre definitely overpriced
Good roast beef gourmet food. Pricey but good
👍Very good, nice selection.
Good food and dont usually have to wait long
Very expensive but good quality. Steaks are excellent.
Has everything my heart desires. Caviar, octopus, pie. Oh my!
Loved how complete the store is. And I love the soup servings.
Expensive but have a good variety of things to choose from and friendly employees
Amazing food! Little pricey
I question how fresh there food is. Sometimes it just seems refrigerated
Incredible selection of quality food!
One of the best grocery stores ever!
Quality meats 🍖, and plenty of organic and vegan choices 👌
Excellent place for great food. a little pricey
Large selection quality food staff is always very friendly
Fresh food, vast selection, definitely Hamptons prices ; . . .
Awesome selection and fresh organic choices
Citarella is the best in every location! High quality
😘😄
Good cheese selection as well as fresh fish
Hot tea great...Wi-Fi didnt work...
Lovely selection of Passover delights!
Just a great, quality food store.
Expensive but good food for a quick bite
The best grocery store in South Hampton. Hands down.
Always have everything that I need and they never disappoint.
Great fish and produce for the area.
Went for breakfast. Coffee and oatmeal was outstanding.
Youll find things you wont find somewhere else, its definitely worth visiting but it is, sadly, overpriced by 40%...
The best place
Great market with a terrific selection.
Has everything and high quality. Prices are too high
Steaks were excellent. Veal chops were excellent.
Beautiful products and great selection of items.
Great prepared food and fresh produce
Great food coffee and products
Pricy but great place to get what you want
Incredible, very good selection of everything, good quality
Great place to buy food, many options
Love this place greta staff fresh food
Great market but the shoppers there are rude as F
Good food reasonable prices for the hamptons
Overpriced on everything.Definitely taking advantage of the wealthy people
Great stuff, but overpriced. Like the whole area
Excellent place and good food!
Great costumer service . clean and organize .
Very expensive... And sometimes not the best quality..
Great selection of food.
Great prepared foods, lots of goodies
The best!
Very good food very high price
Excellent fresh food!!
Great place to buy fruits and vegetables
Freshest, best quality food!
It has noice food
Much Ado about very little considering what they charge
The best place to buy parts
Awesome choice of groceries
Owner is very friendly and always accommodating
Very nice gourmet supermaarket.
Good hot food tables
I had sushi...it was excellent!
Gourmet grocery srore, expensive but delicious
Ok. Good enough
Very good hot food
Total reviews rating 4.3
199 Reviews for Citarella Gourmet Market - Southampton 2023:
Review №1
2022-02-07A select food market with all quality items, packaged and ready to go order as well as supermarket items. Fish and seafood is quite good compared to others in the 10 mile radius.
Review №2
2022-07-17Very centric location, small but has almost everything you need to eat or drink and other brands that you usually don’t find in other stores. A hit pricey, but everything I eat there is always delicious. The pizza was amazingly good.
Review №3
2022-07-06Excellent selection of produce, meats and fish. Also pre-prepared lunches are really good. Sandwiches, wraps, sushi, hot food bar...all worth a stop. Ive been to several Citarellas on Long Island and the Southampton and Babylon stores are the best of the bunch. Make a stop at any Citeraella if you can
Review №4
2022-05-01Missing prices on so many items. I am sure it is against the law to not price items; bakery goods for instance, no prices and no signs. They should be reported to the authorities. And, there are no olives anymore for sale (they used to have greek olives, peppercini and such); no whitefish salad only a spread filled with mayo; no smoked whitefish; no ability to get 1/4 lb of a deli item (rather than 1/2 lb); so if you want 1/4 lb of tunasalad lots of luck. The store has declined unfortunately.
Review №5
2022-07-06This place is wonderful, the variety of exotic fruits and vegetables are always abundant. They have fruits i have never seen anywhere else. The staff is very friendly as well.
Review №6
2019-09-09We came here to find a healthy dinner for the night and we weren’t disappointed. Great salad bar and sushi selection. Would be nice to offer gluten free soy sauce. Beautiful cakes, pastries, breads and pizzas.
Review №7
2022-04-19Always clean, everything is delicious, just wish they had more vegan options.
Review №8
2019-01-21I really love this market. They have an amazing salad bar##hot foods displayed like a buffet ##sushi## pizza## they have prepared hot soups#lots of options##all the food taste so fresh and healthy##not greasy at all
Review №9
2022-01-20Aside from the cumbersome aisles that cordon you to their registers, this is the Valhalla of Long Islands Cutarella stores. Coffee Bar, Hot Bar returned after Covidded times, huge meat, vegetable, pastry variety and selection all with a decent priced cup of coffee, front &back parking with dual entrance/exits. The Best, but youre going to pay for it, of course. Especially,. when you MUST visit a cash register!
Review №10
2021-10-14Always great stuff! Wish more of the product prices were labeled more clearly or somehow made easier to see to help make mydecisions. My favorite there is the fish Dept. Selection is great & fresh and the staff is very helpful and courteous.