City Club Hotel image 1City Club Hotel image 2City Club Hotel image 3City Club Hotel image 4City Club Hotel image 5City Club Hotel image 6City Club Hotel image 7City Club Hotel image 8City Club Hotel image 9City Club Hotel image 10

Categories


Total reviews rating

199 Reviews for City Club Hotel 2023:

Review №1

2022-05-12

The location is great. Close enough to Times Square but far enough to be quieter. Close to Grand Central.If you’re a diner aficionado the Red Flame diner is but a hop skip and jump away. And you’re close to Butter and Kellari - two great restaurants.The room was clean albeit dated and a bit worn. It’s aged better than other similarly aged places I’ve stayed (Hampton Inn for example). The shower was great and the tub deep - possibly an issue for older folk.It’s a solid 3.5

Review №2

2022-02-01

So far its a very pleasant stay. Front desk so friendly and the in room bar is fantastic. Since Im a VIP member I received a free bottle of champagne or wine! I wish the restaurant was open but its still the pandemic and the times that we are in. There are plenty of restaurants that are still open in the area. Not far from Time Square. Samantha and I are off to the Chinese New Years Eve parade tomorrow.

Review №3

2022-06-28

Positive: Price was decent and the location was solid Negative: Yes. This was NOT a 4 star hotel. Room was old and parts were pretty dirty especially the carpet which was massively stained. No lobby, my key cards stopped working at least 4 different times during my stay. The staff were great and helpful though.

Review №4

2022-02-09

I stayed there with my wife and daughter for a few days and had a wonderful experience. The hotel is not new, not fancy, with smaller rooms but the service was excellent and the location is very convenient. Room service warmed milk for our toddler a few times and doorman helps with the luggage.

Review №5

2022-02-06

We booked a room for a romantic birthday evening for my wife, and we were VERY pleased! George at the front desk was cordial, welcoming, and professional. He upgraded us to a queen bed room and a complimentary bottle of champagne to celebrate the birthday evening. The room was clean and the bed and pillows were very comfortable. Free wi-fi and HDTV with multiple basic and premium channels along with a daily newspaper were included. Quiet night, friendly staff to wish us a great day when we left was a warming touch to a cold, rainy February morning. We will DEFINITELY stay here again, highly recommended!

Review №6

2022-04-17

Positive: Location is great. Couple blocks from times square and very close to everything. Employees are very nice and helpful. Negative: Room did not have any fridge or coffee machine. It was advertised as with a fridge. It is a small room with a queen bed and a sofa. It was enough for us 2 adult and 1 kid.

Review №7

2022-03-17

Positive: The staff. They were friendly, helpful, professional and courteous. It was surprisingly quiet based on proximity to Time Square. Negative: It needs some maintenance and upkeep done. I would get rid of the phone in the bathroom and put in some electrical outlets. I would get rid of the mirrored wall as nobody wants to watch themselves use the toilet or shower...at least not in my world.

Review №8

2022-06-02

Awful experience // essentially a scam // avoid at all costs:-No hot water on arrival-Room in awful state. Peeling wallpaper, chipped skirting boards etc-“Petite” room significantly smaller than the photos-Air conditioning unit so noisy it wakes you up all night-Cannot have been refurbished for at least 20 years-Lift cabinets look like it´s come from a scrapyard - Curtains in hallways with rips-The hotel claims 4 stars but it´s there no chance its worth more than 2 stars.The only positive was that they gave us our money back when we left after 1 night when we were meant to be staying for 4 nights.All in favour of cheap and cheerful, but there´s nothing cheery about this misery.Conclusion, pay a bit more and stay elsewhere.

Review №9

2022-02-10

Worst hotel I’ve ever been in. For over $100, it’s disgraceful. It reeks of cigarettes and urine, both in the hallway and the rooms. Cigarette butts in the window, stains on the sheets, floor was gross and stained, pillows smelled, hot water ran out, and they hit you with a hidden fee and take it out of the security deposit. The walls are actually falling apart. The upkeep on this place has been abysmal. Honestly it’s filthy, really gross feeling. I felt the need to shower after sleeping in the bed. It’s actually the worst hotel I’ve ever had the misfortune of staying in. I would never recommend it to anyone and hope they go out of business so they stop scamming people into staying there. Avoid at all costs

Review №10

2022-03-19

I’m really confused by all of the positive reviews here. I got the room last minute via Hotwire and it had a 4 star rating. Nothing about this place was 4 stars.To start, when I arrived, the front desk attendant was outside, possibly taking a quick break. As he entered the hotel, he didn’t even bother to hold the door open for me.When I got to my room, it was in pretty rough shape. It literally was falling apart at the seam. The wallpaper was peeling, the paint was chipped, the ceiling was cracked, the headboard was just gross.The only room that was decent was the bathroom, but of course there was someone’s hair in toilet.Just spend the money to stay at a more reputable establishment with real reviews.