Outdoor seating
Yes
Cosimos in Newburgh
Categories
Location on the map
Newburgh, Orange County, New York, US
Service options
Kerbside pickup
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Great coffee
Yes
Great dessert
Yes
Great tea selection
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Healthy options
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Romantic
Yes
Upmarket
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Yes
Accepts reservations
Yes
Phone: +1 845-567-1556
Site: http://www.cosimosunion.com/
Site: http://www.cosimosunion.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:11:30AM–9:30PM
- Tuesday:11:30AM–9:30PM
- Wednesday:11:30AM–9:30PM
- Thursday:11:30AM–9:30PM
- Friday:11:30AM–10PM
- Saturday:11:30AM–10PM
- Sunday:12–9:30PM
Cosimos in other cities:
Comments (199)
The food at this location is subpar compared to the other locations. I decided to give it another shot after the renovations. We sat down for a late lunch around 2:30 and ordered two drinks from the bar. After ordering the drinks the waitress came over to inform us that they got a large takeout order and wouldnt be able to serve us pizza for at least 45 minutes. We got up and left. How do you take a takeout order when you are unable to accommodate the patrons in your actually restaurant. This place is a joke. Never again
High school friends who meet a fee times a year. We decided with the renovations we had to go and see it. It was beautiful! They did an awesome job. Although their cups for soda/water was so small. The poor waitress kept running back and forth to fill us up.
They have recently renovated the place and it looks amazing. The staff was friendly and professional. They also added new dishes to the menu and took off some old ones. So, if you havent been in awhile go and try the new dishes.
They have a nice sized menu with a variety of offerings. I had the rib tips and they were very tender and tasty. The service was excellent, everyone was very helpful and I didnt see any cell phones.
My family had such a wonderful dining experience this evening! Everything from the appetizers (waffles fries, meatballs) to entrees ( chicken parm, chicken Francese, harvest salad with chicken) and desserts ( carrot cake, lava cake) was absolute perfection. Billy, our server was warm, welcoming and highly efficient. ( and quick witted:) This was an all around delightful outing. We will be back!! Well done, Cosimos!!!
Stopped here to charge the car and decided to check out the restaurant. We have the mushroom pizza and it was awsome. We got our food very fast and the people were very nice.
Started with the Italian bread with Gallic and olive oil. Only complaint it wasnt virgin olive oil. The calamari was perfect, asked for extra marinara sauce, received it quickly. The brick oven pizza was exquisite. Threes service was friendly and courteous.
I love the place the food was delicious the service was wonderful little loud in there but everybody was happy and cheerful that were birthday parties and it was great it was a happy place. It was very clean very nice well prepared represented very well
Been a Cosimos on Union regular for over 20 years. It reminds me of the kind of Italian food I had living in California: fresh, healthy, and tasty. I highly recommend Cosimos for lunch or dinner.
This Cosimos (Newburgh) is a very good spot, the only caveat is that they use just a bit too much oil on their pesto sandwich. Pesto plus fresh mozzarella plus a fried tomato is entirely too much oil altogether and leaves a bad taste. I removed the tomato and all was delicious, just a suggestion. Other than that, it was an excellent experience. Will be back again.
I had the half pizza and half salad. It was very good. The service was excellent. The server brought us bread and oil right away. Our drinks were always refilled.
Haven’t been out to eat since pandemic, was excited to go last night to our favorite place to eat. Been a patron for many yearsWas very disappointed yesterday! Food was stale and tasted horrible. I know restaurants precook pasta and certain things but, this was bad. I had chicken Francese and it was horrible, hubby had chicken pizza and the chicken was dry and old my son had chicken parm and again he said doesn’t taste the same.Portion sizes have shrunk and prices have risen, it’s understandable they raise prices but portions were very much decreased. The only thing we enjoyed was the calamari appetizerVery disappointed
BLT pizza and Greek salad. Patio dining while charging our Tesla at a super charger in the parking lot. Win Win.
Ive been here a few times and food is usually good as well as service. Well recent visit ordered the shrimp & scallop pappardelle. $35 for this special plate. No lie came with 3 scallops and 3 shrimp. 2-3 oz of seafood on top of a handful of pasta for $35? Have no issue with money but that was a ripoff. Ive had better $17-22 dinners everywhere else. Too many places to eat at to give this place another visit. Dont waste your time.
Had Waffle fries with roasted herbs and Gorgonzola sauce and and Pizza. It was amazing.Their outdoor seating has a grapeyard too which was very nice and also rt next to the Tesla Supercharger.
The atmosphere is lovely. My boyfriend and I enjoyed a salad and personal pie. Phenomenal seasoning on both. The sauce on the pie was delicious. Absolutely reccomend.
The shrimp scampi pizza I had was amazing. What my boyfriend had was good as well he created his own .
We just left this place. had to pick up a friend. it was packed!!!! we had to wait 20 minutes to get in. but it was worth it. pizza was outstanding!!!!! crust was delicious. pizza ia a must try!!! try the flat bread to.
Absolutely amazing will definitely be back services was great and food amazing
Best bakery in Orange County. Courteous and friendly staff. Love this bakery.
Very good restaurant! The servers were very busy, but they were still very kind and patient. I got the margherita pizza and it was very good.
Service was awesome, and the food was really good. Myself and my wife and kids loved the food. Pizza was nice , little different from what I am used to, but very very good and tasty.
Food was very good. Definitly will eat there again. Those Mozzarella Cheese Stix are wrapped in Prosciutto and lightly breaded. Bon appetite. Service was so-so.
Absolutely..Delicious..Great Service.. great social distancing, proper mask..limited people allowed..I felt safe and Loved the service ..Lobster Rissotto..
Everything the group tried from the bread and oil, apps, salad, pizza, sandwiches, entree, to dessert was stellar. What a great place to get a Tesla charge and nosh!
I had a great experience the waitress was absolutely a sweet heart and the food was fantastic definitely my new spot
The ambiance was very nice, food was good, large portions, amazing staff make you feel so welcome.
Great staff, my daughter and I love the food and atmosphere.Renovation is awesome!!!!
Excellent. Restaurant. Great food. I love the Shrimp Baguette.
Handy to intersection of two major interstate highways 84 & 87.Great rate of charge. 6 head-in bays.Located in Southeast corner of Cosimos Plaza. Lots of good food and even outdoor dining within 50 feet of chargers.
Amazing wood fired pizza. I had the fennel sausage and the flavours were just spot on. Sauces and fresh mozzarella made daily on site. Prices were very reasonable. Definitely worth a visit.
Had my rehearsal dinner here and this is a classic Italian restaurant with excellent service and one of the best places to rent a private room for Anniversary, Wedding, Graduation, etc in the area. Decent price for the quality of service. Solid, absolutely classic Italian and Italian American dishes. Good wine.
Pretty good pizza for a place so close to Denny’s. A bit doughy and cheesy but still great. Salad wasn’t half bad either.
We stopped by Cosimo’s to charge the Tesla we had some of the best calamari I’ve ever had and great pizza, definitely worth the stop!
Chicken Pallard Salad. This place has consistently good food. Definitely a go to for my wife and I.
This place is great! Seemed almost too nice for the reasonable prices and location - its like a high-end Italian restaurant went on vacation to the suburbs. They manage to be very classy and have excellent food while maintaining a friendly, casual atmosphere & charging very reasonable prices. Service was fantastic - attentive while never interrupting a conversation or making us feel rushed (even though we were there at closing time). Tesla Superchargers in one corner of the parking lot are very convenient if thats what youre driving. My only regret about Cosimos is that we were passing through town on our way home from a trip, so it will be a long time before I get to visit again.
Really cool little place. Excellent service. Had the meatball pizza and it was outstanding. Brick oven pizza is not always my favorite, but this was first rate.
Thank you for the amazing party. The staff handled everything. Luis was amazing and went above and beyond. This was the most stress free event of my life. I would not hesitate to host another event here!Thank you a million times over for the amazing food and customer service!
Very good food! fresh and tasty. Fast and friendly service. Highly recommended.
First time there. We were in the area and our son suggested it. Seemed to be a quite popular place. Food was good...great choices. Waitress was bubbly. Had a really nice first visit.
My wife and I love coming here. We have been here on many occasions for lunch and/or dinner and weve never been disappointed. The food is delicious, reasonably priced and great portions. The staff is kind, friendly and very professional. There is a warm feeling from when you first arrive and are greeted upon entrance. Major shout out to Erica. She always makes our experience so enjoyable. You cannot go wrong coming here.
I rate this restaurant a 2 would’ve loved to give it a 5 because the appetizers were Bomb ! and the entrees wasn’t bad . During our time here we started to place our entree meals when the waiters started moving tables around . I hear them say we can’t move them around we already seated them . (speaking about my guest and I ) so we continued to eat when two ladies came in and started to set up BABYSHOWER decorations while we eat and spoke around our food . The manager nor the waiters told us anything . It would’ve been lovely to be notified what was going on. Instead I had to call to speak to the manager she claimed she didn’t know but she did , so I was told... Anyways we weren’t offered a refund . Our bill was 80 dollars for two appetizers and one steak entree which I guess some would say isn’t bad. Instead we were offered a free desert for ONE . I should’ve never took the desert but i dislike problems, the waiter was really nice on the bright side left a nice tip . Not a pleasant experience at ALL .
The crispy polenta at this location is the worst ever. I had it at the Woodbury location it was nice size and delicious. This Newburgh location is cheap and greasy I am so disappointed that I spent $12 on this take out appetizer. Look at it.
Family and I went out for a birthday dinner. The entrees were great. The service was ok. Unfortunately, we ordered creme brulee for dessert not realizing that they put a shot of some kind of strong alcohol on it. My 13yr old tried theirs first and complained. I couldnt eat mine either. Thankfully, they took my childs away and got her a different one. Wish they have us a heads up about it. Especially before serving it to a minor.
Solid Italian food. The pastas Ive had havent been 100% traditional. The pasta with broccoli rabe and sausage sauce has a red tinge to it, which I dont believe is authentic, but I still like it. The Rigatoni alla Nonna has mozzarella in it, again, not what Im used to, but very good. Nice atmosphere, and very good service.
Awesome food and great atmosphere. Make sure you make a reservation or be ready for a wait. Well worth the time and price!
Great good and they allowed my pupper on the patio which was perfect!
Atmosphere and service were exceptional. Steak salad was not good but two of the four in our party were impressed with their meals. watermelon habanero margherita was a hit!
Ordered calamari and bruschetta as apps.. both were delicious! For dinner I ordered eggplant and angel hair with garlic and oil..it was on point! My husband ordered mushroom and garlic pasta.. he enjoyed it very much! Our waitress was super friendly..
Great brick oven pizza selection and burgers! Friendly wait staff and beautiful location. I cant wait to go back!
Service was so polite and the food was fantastic!Pictured: Waffle fries and melted gargonzola
Great food. Nice customer service.
Just opened after remodeling packed as always great food and service
Food is quick and reasonably priced. Never had a bad meal and I would gladly pay 50% more for equivalent Italian food. Never had a bad appetizer, entre or desert
They have a very delicious gluten free crust!! Perfectly crispy on the outside and doughy on the inside.
$$$ Great brick oven pizza. Great food. The place is always packed but I have never felt crowded. Five Tesla charging stations.
The experience was fantastic. Our waitress was on point and so was the food. The shrimp scampi pizza was delicious! 😋
The service and the food was very delicious
Very friendly staff...food very good. Would highly recommend the wood fire pizza and mixed grill. Reasonable prices and fast service.
This place is amazing! The waiter was polite, efficient, and accurate, very personable. The staff helped me with additional to-go requests toward the end of the visit. The portions were great ( food and dessert) food was cooked as requested...will definitely be back!
Handled a group of 13 with no problem but doesnt do separate checks. Food was great. Hookups for electric cars is available.
I have been eating at Cosimo’s with my family for 20 years. The staff are pleasant, the food is good, and the establishment is very clean. Everything on the menu is really good. I enjoy the Salmon, the pasta dishes, the salads, the burger, and the pizza. If you have a problem, they will do their best to please the customer. It’s a Family Business.
Only four because we do not try enough of the menu to be fair but what we do get repeatedly (calamari, Margarita pizza, coffee flavoured icecream on the molten lava cake, and the Brotherhood Vineyards reisling)is great. Had them cater a few years ago also and it was superb. Repeat customer. Five stars thus far based on what we usually get.
We eat here pretty frequently! We love everything from appetizers to desserts. You can’t go wrong stopping here. The staff are always friendly and the food and drinks are always great. We take out and eat in and are always satisfied! They always take great care of the customers!
My first impression of this place from two decades back was not thrilling, but recently I decided to give a try based on advice from family and I may have to reevaluate that thought. I had a Chukar dish on one occasion that was delish but still lacked body and then came back a week later for an off menu Shrimp Scampi that they actually do in pizza form that was also not bad and only because it lacked body also. I say that because I am used to rich French style sauces, so label me too picky if you will. Otherwise some staffing change is in order, but apparently that will take some Democrat(ic) movement in our Congress to change that!
Cosimos on Union is an old favorite BUT I only like going there if I can sit at the bar and the bar is always jammed. Sitting in the back room for some reason just ruins it for me. Maybe cause every seat back there is a bad one or because the lighting is bad or it feels like a you are eating in a cafeteria. IDK but whatever it is if you can get a seat at the bar its a great place to go. Great food and nice staff too. I think they should turn the place into one giant bar and I would eat there every night.
Yum! Great place to relax and have a brick oven pizza. Love the ambience.
Yes was my first time here and its not that bad. I had the mozzarella fresca pizza. It was good the crust was nice when crispy. Only reason I didnt give it 4 stars was the service was just ok. We were seated and people after us received their bread and oil before us. And then we were asked if we would like some. The other tables it was just brought out with question. Also the server was my caught up talking with a friend and taking care of the dog she brought. I have no issue with the dog being there I just hope she changed her gloves before handling the plates being brought out.
Its always delicious and service is top notch.
Excellent Food and service! This place is always a favorite place to eat. The staff is always friendly and treat you like a valued customer. Highly recommended
Great place to eat. I have been coming here for many years and the food and service is always exceptional. The serving staff is very friendly and makes your dining experience over the top.
Food is amazing and the pizza is akin to NYC...
Visited Cosimos for the first time in many years. Was always a favorite of mine before my relocation. They have not skipped a beat! Food and service continue to be top notch
Comfortable outdoor seating. Visit is limited to 90 minutes which is plenty of time. Food is delicious, staff is friendly and courteous. Seating is directly inside their parking lot and view is to the traffic on route 300 but who needs a view with food this good. Come with friends and loved ones so that the conversation, drinks, and food will delight you!!!
Beautiful outdoor dining under the grape arbor. Fantastic service and the food, as always, was delicious, well presented and ample. I had the tomato sandwich: fried crisp ripe tomato, with mozarella, prosciutto, and pesto with a tiny kick, on a toothsome baquette. Perfect lunch with its accompanying Caesar salad, or fries. I opted for salad. Very yummy. A couple the next table over were sipping sangrias that looked amazing. I was driving, so a carafe of water was my choice. Go to Cosimos.
Good food, I found the service was excellent
Staff was great as the food. Pizza was one of the best and the chicken parmesan excellent
Fantastic food, welcoming staff and a nice atmosphere make for a time that wont disappoint
Walked in tonight at 9:16 and was told we can’t be seated, online the restaurant says it closes at 10pm. When I mentioned the owners name Nicholas who I know personally they than said the website has the wrong hours. They did not even allow us to place an order to go. Unreal. Never will I come back sorry Nick.
The food is always outstanding. Always. However, our spectacular service from Tatiana made me leave a review. She went out of her way to make our night special. Thank you, Tatiana!!
1st time experience. Beautiful environment. Excellent Service. Delicious food. Ill be back the next time Im in the area!
It a nice place with pleasant staff. A little more expensive than I expected. A small Caesar salad was $8.00. The chicken francese was very good.
I like to come here for lunch meetings occasionally with clients and the food and service is always great and never feel rushed. I wish I lived closer as this would be my go to place for a good meal. I truly appreciate a restaurant like cosmios that delivers a consistent product and I always know what I can expect when going here
Great meal and awesome service too
We ate at the outside tables, waitress was sweet and professional, the food was good, but floors were grossly dirty, they need to power wash their floors. Its pretty nasty.
The pasta, the salad, all the ingredients used are fresh and all the produce come from local hudson valley farms. The service is very good and its a place where families, couples, and friends can have an excellent meal; its vegan friendly too. I really enjoyed my meal.
I went on Monday, 1/4, for a birthday dinner with a couple friends, and my mom. We were at the Newburgh location, and Kintura was our server.The food was good, drinks were better, but what really made this experience 5 stars was the service.One of my friends is new to her food allergies, and had to be very careful about what she was ingesting. Kintura answered every question with ease, and was beyond accommodating when faced with questions she didnt have the answer to.We were a couple minutes late for a 745 table, and knew that with Gov. Cuomos orders we would need to be clean outta there by 10. Kintura wasnt pushy, and didnt rush us. The way she reminded us of the 10pm cutoff though was just professional and tasteful.All around, this girl made the mark and was fantastic. She had us laughing and joking together. She knew her menu, including gluten free options for food and drinks. It was phenomenal all around. Thank you for a great evening. :]Being in the service industry myself, and having had some off days here and there, it was BEYOND refreshing to have someone who cares, tends to, and goes the extra mile for their guests.
Great food, great atmosphere, and great customer service. Have also recently started using their online order and pickup service which has also been great! I am hooked on their Romano Chicken Chop Chop salad. One of the best Ive ever had. Their wood fired pizzas are also yummy!
This is a local favorite with quality food and service. They have wood fired brick oven pizza and more traditional Italian dishes as well.
Very nice atmosphere and great food and service.
We scheduled a retirement dinner here. We had a party of 19 and all of the food was great. All appetizers and dinners came out piping hot and exactly the way we ordered them. The staff were friendly and accommodating and our server was excellent and attentive. Highly recommend.
Totally enjoyed the food over here. Amazing backyard.
Great food. And serviceAlways a new variety of all the favorites.
Great dining atmosphere with exceptional service. Food was decent but could have been better. That is, it lacked expected flavor. I ordered a southwest pizza. The pizza really did not have any southwest seasoning on it. It was, however, plated nicely. I would absolutely visit this restaurant again as other menu offerings are absolutely detectable (i.e. various pasta dishes and salads).
I have had Cosmos before and I absolutely loved it; however when I ordered the Grilled Chicken Penne as Ive done in the past, I bit into the worst chicken Ive ever tasted! I sent it back and the waiter said that the chicken penne is made in the morning. The chicken tasted old and disgusting, total false advertisement. Beware of the grilled chicken its more like “marinated for days old disgusting crap”! Save your $$$ you’ll have a better dinner warming up a Stouffers frozen dinner at home :(
The food was pretty good, but road to the parking and the actual parking is atrocious. Thats not their fault. Just a heads up though, people will run into the one way parking lot and take pictures for 5 minutes not allowing any cars to pass until theyre done. Here the trick though, when they start posing for a photo while impeding traffic, blink your high beams at them like you were in the discotheque in the 70s and immediately stop when you get an angry look and pretend it wasnt you. Theyll probably rotate 90 degrees but rinse and repeat. When they pose, hit the high beams like it was a joystick from the Mortal Kombat 3 arcade machine when youre cornered; when the dirty looks come, it wasnt you. Keep doing this until they move to an area so that you can drive pass.ProTip: these people typically park way too close in the parking spots. Since youve wasted this much time, get those extra irony laughs when no one can get into the driver side of the vehicle.Again, food was pretty good.
4.5🌟 Food was excellent! We had pizza...crust & flavors awesome! Very nice Tuscan atmosphere. Service was just ok (thus the half star). They also have Tesla superchargers in their parking lot! Very convenient for us Tesla owners!
Their fried calamari was amazing!!! So good. I bought one of their sauces. I jar my own sauce with san marzano tomatoes but I wanted to support the business.
Had the calamari as good as ever, and if the sauce that comes with is a bit spicy ask for a milder sauce not a problem for this place. Service is good staff friendly
Every Cosimos I go to always has consistent meal quality. The brick oven pizzas are delicious. The wait staff is always prompt and friendly. Ive now been to the Poughkeepsie, Newburgh and Woodbury and each time Ive had a fantastic experience. This restaurant is easy to get to and has lots of seating. Theres even a Tesla Supercharger in the parking lot. You wont go wrong here
Quick, easy, and delicious. Right off 84, was great to call ahead and grab some salads (pesto chicken and honey ginger) before we got back on the road. Hostess was so friendly and brought food right out!
Great service, good food. It was good. Honestly think olive garden tastes better.
Amazing g Italian food on par with much more expensive restaurants in the city. Attentive and fast service. A total gem! Found it by accident, since it has a supercharger on site:). Must do fir all Tesla owners!
Wonderful space for an extended family dinner, after bidding goodbye to our loved one. Food was fabulous, service lovely, and everyone enjoyed themselves.
What’s this??? Where we put 10 stars ?? Very nice food, service great and nice ambiance!!!
The waitress was bad. We didnt get enough place settings for the 6 of us. When she realized she only brought 3 said she would get more but didnt brought out 1 loaf of bread (5 slices) for six of us. We asked for cheese, salt, pepper, crushed pepper again only brought out 1 small container for 6 people and nothing to use to distribute it so we either had to use our fingers (pandemic going on) or our already used utensils. We ordered a drink after 15 minutes it never came we tried to then cancel it she said it was already made. She never came back with it when we asked again she said someone else must have took it....ummm! There was no social distancing between those tables at all. I could touch the table behind me which is why I will not be returning until Covid clears up. Shame on you Cosimos!
Exelent the food was delicious!We eve have a pizza, some entres and dessert. My plate was Fra Dablo .👍👍👍👍👍
Hostess was nice and prompt, service was great, unfortunately the food was not to the level I expected. Lobster baguette was good, lobster was a bit over cooked, mushy. Ordered steak medium and it came over nearly rare had to send it back to get cooked a bit more and that doesnt normally turn out well. Butter that should of been melting on the steak was still a solid slice. It was a very bland tasting steak also. Pork dish was ok, somehow chunks of chicken made it into this dish, not sure how.
The atmosphere is really nice and the staff was pleasant and professional. The food was delicious with large portions. Everything we had was delicious. Being Italian myself, I can tell you they served authentic Italian food. The only thing stopping me from giving it five stars was a smell of mildew when you first walk in (where food is prepared) and at the bar. Mildew scares me because you can get really sick from it. The bathroom was nice but the floor couldve used some attention. In all, I would definitely come back.
Just stopped for a salad, but it was great and a generous portion. Spot on service. Used their Tesla super chargers.
Great food. My family gets food from there all the time. Definitely recommend Cosimos.
Great food! Even better service! busy or not they always make you feel welcomed and it makes you want to go back! We eat there weekly and everything on the menu and weekend specials are great!!!
My very favorite restaurant in the tristate area. They always deliver the best service and the most excellent food. 10/10 in every aspect. Highly recommend.
This is my favorite place to dine!The food is so fresh, the portion sizes are large and the service is always fantastic! You try it once and you will be hooked.
Great food...Great service.Busy Saturday night, was told 30 min wait.Ended up getting sat 10 min later.Food arrived fast, unbelievably hot.Got the Lobster pasta with jalapeno bacon.
Great food, friendly staff. I order to go about twice a week. Just wish they would give you plasticware without me having to remind them. It happens every single time, must be company policy.
Had Chicken Parm, my wife Chicken Francese. Both were good. My piece of chicken was huge. The waitress we has was quick and friendly too.
Great Italian restaurant nestled in Newburgh. Excellent Calamari! We were a party of seven. From Ravioli to Veal Parmesan to Chicken, everything was perfect. Staff was very attentive. Very reasonably priced.
I give 5 stars for the cooks. The waitresses on the other hand, I didnt know that home wrecking was on the menu. Make sure to order that next time.
SUCH delicious food! The staff are always so sweet and helpful. Everything there is good, literally everything!! But the Grilled Chicken Paillard salad is my absolute favorite!! You. Must. Go. Here!!
Service was perfect. Food excellent. Wish they would add a few clearly gluten free menu items. With celiac disease affecting 3/4 of our family, even a small gluten free menu would bring us back more often.
I was very pleasantly surprised at how good the sauce was for my chicken parmesan. The service was great the food was very well prepared and portions were generous. Im not much of a chain restaurant guy but this Cosimos has it together
Food was ok. But ordered a carrot cake to go and found this when we got home. $9 for a tiny piece of cake.
Always great food but the phone staff is in need of some serious training on their phone etiquette. No one likes rude. It’s times like these where your polite approach to your skill can make all the difference in the world.
Outstanding food. Great service.My new favorite!
I have never had a bad meal here. There Tuesday deal is great and is delicious. The Thursday and Sunday I felt were overpriced for what you get but still very good.
Delicious Salmon dish. The Gorgonzola fries should be illegal!! Sooo good!
Ive passed this place several times and always noted their parking lot was full. I took my better half for lunch the other day & found out why: The food is Good! We both had the specials and neither of us were disappointed! Service was quick and it was a fine lunch. Stop in.
Food Always great. When I come here my parents get great food that I share with. I usually get the bow tie pasta and its delicious. Clams are also good and so are the Italian foods and burger and sandwiches. Great variety of food
The food is always fresh. Each dish has its own flavor, not the same sauces used in every dish. Service is good, sometimes slow when busy, but this is a nice, sit down restaurant, enjoy the friends and family youre with and have dessert!
My penne a la vodka was a little bland and not creamy enough. My mom got the pesto pasta and though it was great for the first few bites, it got boring quickly with only a strong pesto flavor rocking the taste buds. Calamari and service were good though.
I ordered the beet and kale salad and my boyfriend ordered a grilled chicken sandwich with salad. The complimentary preappetizer bread was not warm. The waiter was very friendly. Excellent service. I would go back.
Stopped by to charge my car with the convenient Tesla Superchargers nearby. This is a more upscale level Italian restaurant with good pizza and Italian dishes. Service was friendly and timely. Would definitely stop back in when Im in the area.
I cannot say enough good things about your restaurant. For the 2nd time I met high school friends, from 50 years ago, at your restaurant. Your staff is patient, kind, friendly and attentive. We come from CT, PA, Putnam County, Westchester, Queens, Greene County. Lunch was delicious! We will be back in the Spring. Thank you!
Really good food with fresh ingredients and very tasty libations. Usually busy, but service is still more than satisfactory.
Great atmosphere and excellent italian cuisine. Also has a wine cellar event room for large parties. Service could be a bit more organized for larger groups, but standard dinner service is great. Favorite among locals.
One of my very favorite places to eat! Wonderful food, great atmosphere and awesome service! Dont forget the bar with a nice selection of wine and spirits! Large portions as well! Make sure you are very hungry when you get here! I will be back often.
Great meals for all. Had a great time nice Italian food mix.
My daughter and grandson were with me and we will definitely be back. We shared a pizza and salad which were delicious. My grandson ate a plate of bowties with Alfredo sauce and finished it. We had a great lunch.
They have a great menu and both locations are great. Newburgh seemed a bit more cramped and there is an echo in the main room so u hear other peoples conversations, but the food was delicious. I like the Poughkeepsie location better bc if u go alone, u can eat at the large spread out bar.
4+ Stars?Great food. Server was VERY nice and helpful.My one regret: forgot the damn leftovers in the table!! I do that too often in my aged brain state.
Always great food and service
One of the best restaurants in the area, Ive eaten here a number of times and always had a great meal. Great variety of pastas, pizzas, and other mains. One of the most extensive and delicious salads menus Ive seen anywhere outside a vegan or vegetarian restaurant.
This cosmos is my review in Newburgh NY.Their food is awesome. I recommend to anyone! But i have to say today just to get seated I had to ask an employee what you have to do to get seated. My husband and I waited15 minutes till I asked that question. One hosted taking an order to for take out. One girl standing next to her looking around. She steps away. Then I ask for help to see when someone would take our names to get seated. Waited for the second hostess. Learned the girl standing next to the first hostess is the second hostess. Why make someone wait that so long. To take a name for tables. We went to wait at the bar the girl doesnt take our name. Wow. But on the other note. The bartender was awesome. The waitress awesome! Food awesome!
Didnt eat here bc there was a 45 min wait for two people on a Sunday evening. Got there at 5:30. They do have a Tesla charging station in their parking lot, with 5 parking spaces. Our Tesla was fully charged already so we went somewhere else.
Recently I enjoyed a gluten free wood fired grilled eggplant pizza at Cosimo’s. While the gluten free crust is the same that I could get at any local pizza place , the wood fire really does kick it up a notch. I hope that Cosimo’s will do something to improve their gluten free pasta as it is barely acceptable.Our server, Janine, helped make our experience at Cosimo’s relaxing with her friendly, attentive manner.
The food is always great and the wine selection is the best in the area. Our usual server, Brianna, is attentive and conscientious without being intrusive. Definitely one of our towns best restaurants.
Tasty selections are all over the menu! The brick oven flatbreads and pizza are very good. Service sometimes spotty, especially when they are busy. Worth the trip if you are in the vacinity.
Consistent quality food, service is on point. Love this restaurant.
Absolutely terrible! And....we didnt even get to eat! Went there with our two children and was told a 35 minute wait. We waited.....and waited and waited. Almost an hour and a half later, still hadnt sat down with visible empty tables available. Watched a waitress whos friends showed up and she squeezed them into an empty table in her section. The waiting area for seating is smack dab in front of the mens bathroom. Constantly moving to wait an hour and a half for your table. Needless to say, we left!
Great food! Had a half pizza/salad combo, simple Margarita style... love that wood fired taste! Great ambiance and service as usual!
Was here for a birthday party. The food was good. The hostess was clueless, but our waitress and busboy were very very good. They did a great job handling a large group.
Awesome..Wont miss it next time though area!Highly recommend!Thanks for a great meal!
Great italian food. Not the traditional, run of the mill Italian, so dont come expecting the same menu as a Pizza Hut. Be a little adventurous in your order, and youll have a great time. Great atmosphere, quality service, but more pricey than Id like.
Great food. Good prices. Seating is a little cramped. Busy on the weekends, expect to wait. Awesome wait staff. Love the penne a la vodka with sun dried tomatoes.
Authentic menu and tastes amazing. Celebrated a birthday here and evening was perfect. You may even dine next to a local celebrity like we did! Definitely returning here - great service and delicious food.
Very crowded but seated quickly. Food was good. Portions big.
Overpriced, got order of pizza wrong, but did give us a free pizza. I dont like the gourmet food.
Love this place! Great food, friendly staff, great decor. Tesla charging ports in parking lot. Did our baby shower here also and turned out fantastic.
Great food. Strong menu. We were there on a cold night and were seated next to a window. Drafty doesnt begin to describe the climate. Kept our coats on the entire time. Very uncomfortable.
The food was OK but the staff was rude and when we saw a cockroach running across the floor we decided at that point we would not return for future dining.
I thought it was pricey until I realized they give you a huge portion. Highly recommend the pork chops. My friends all liked the food as well. Vegan pizza available.
Eggplant Parmesan was not what I expected from an Italian restaurant with Cosimos alleged reputation. Soggy eggplant, very thin sauce with about a half inch of melted mozzarella cheese that was just warm and solid on top when it came out. Spaghetti was perfectly Al dente, so the side dish was better than the entree. Wish I had taken pictures
Great food. Fast, efficient and friendly service. Not too noisy. Very nice place. Highly recommend
Everything is up to par, I feel as though the creativity has gone and is on track to being another chain restaurant group. Hopefully there will be more flair to the up coming menus as seasons change. Overall decent food for Newburgh.
Great service , very good food reasonable prices. I wish their outdoor patio was bigger.
Very busy place. Only waited a short bit for a table. Food was great and the wait staff was even better. Grabbed dinner while our Tesla was charging up, on our way through the area.
Came here for an x mas party. Good food for sure. Slightly busy for my liking but they had parties plus other diners. Overall pretty good.
Only placed a take out order as a road trip stop, but everyone I encountered/spoke with was friendly. Food was prepared well and quickly.
The staff is very understanding about dish alterations to accommodate a gluten restriction. Gluten free items were perfect and delicious as were everyone elses items.
Really good. Food had some different options but the basics. Would definitely recommend
I dont get what the noise is about. Ive eaten here numerous times with friends and family. I have to say that as for my experience the food is pretty okay, mediocre at best. I dont know if there is a lack of amazing italian food that Newburgh once use to have so no one knows any better but the food here is not great. Its also ridiculously over priced for what it is. If it were extraordinary sure but its simply okay at best. The last 3 times Ive eaten here Ive also gotten sick to my stomach as have friends. It scares me to think what sort of Kitchen Nightmares is going on in the back of the house. I dont eat here unless Im invited to by someone.
If you want to go to a *real* restaurant, go to The Station in New Paltz. Cosimos is a complete joke on every level possible. It was my and my wifes anniversary today. I called 1.5 hours before for a reservation, and they told me to call back a half hour before and theyll hold a table. So I did that, and when I arrived a half hour later they told me that I had a 30 minute wait even though I called in advance. I do work for Cosimos at my store, and there is no way they would accept this service from me. They run the lousiest, non-communicative service (sorry if your staff cant understand big words) so maybe next time they need something from our store, Ill jack their prices for wasting our time. Both the manager and hostess were rude. If I get a call from the owner and a free meal, Id consider wasting my time by going there again, but never again will I recommend them to a living soul. Maybe the dead, because the dead people can wait. But dont lie to me and make me follow your rules, then break your own rules.Not to mention now Im eating my anniversary dinner at Fridays right down the road, and the servers are more polite, the food is debateably better, and I havent felt pushed aside since I entered. I hope Cosimos drowns in debt. I cant wait for the next time they ask our store for services. Ill triple the price for the inconvenience.
Fantastic food! The servings were enormous on the lunch menu and worth every penny! The procuitto w mozzarella sandwich was awesome with a huge side salad.
Excellent quality and delicious food. Ask the service was great even though we can at the very end of the night.
Excellent food and good size portions! Wait staff were very accommodating and always there! Well be back!!
Had the Burrata Pie special pizza of the day. Phenomenal.
Had lunch here with my daughter yesterday, great food, service and they had no problem letting us move to outside dining. I love this place and always get a good meal here!
Best place to eat. They need one in NJ. So I can get the Romano chicken chop chop. All the food is excellent here. Great place to eat with family friends or even alone.
Good food, generous portions. I had a snapper in a Vera Cruz sauce with a Tuscany Pear salad made with arugula, yum! The snapper came with grilled Brussel sprouts which were a bit over cooked and creamy polenta which was delicious. The bread that comes at the beginning was olive with chunks of olives, very good bread.
Amazing food ..I highly recommend cosimos restaurant.The Italian food they serve is amazing and very tasty .my favorites are the fried calamari.chicken parmigiana with zitis in vodka sauce with mushrooms and sun dried tomatoes.👍👍👍👍👍I’m getting hungry just thinking about it
Horrible pizza! Very cheap on the toppings. Not worth the price! Primos in New Windsor is 100xs better!
We love this place. Wood oven pizza is awesome and wife loves the antipasto board. Service has always been excellent.
Had a delicious dinner outside here. Use to visit now and then when I pick relatives up at the airport. Great place to stop before heading home with my guest.
Food was excellent (I ordered a couple pizzas for the table) and the staff was very nice. They also followed the COVID guidelines very well and kept the place clean!
Excellent, clean, great service, one of the best places I have ever eaten. Food was AWESOME!!
Very good food, nice enviroment. The staff was friendly and professional. We made a reservation of 10 then had our table right on time.
Entrance in an awkward place, very, very crowded tables, servers squeezing by to go out french doors behind your seat!!! And food is so so..I had the seafood diablo that had more cherry clams than Ive ever had in one dish for a cost of $21. Sorry but every thing was too expensive for little. Especially the portion of tiramisu for $9...
This place is hoppin. I have been coming here to original for many years. I love how they encourage green trsnsportation with Tesla charging stations close to the front entrance. HOWEVER, I drive a non-tesla electric vehicle...how about a charge for the rest of us?Every meal I have ever had here has been top notch. Flavors are great. Menu is diverse. Even the classics such as whatever Parmagiana and fried calamari are exceptional.The wait staff are friendly and appear to have superhuman stamina and patience.I recommend you add Cosimos to your short list of reliable, hip, and comfortable favorite eateries as I have.
Total reviews rating 4.5
199 Reviews for Cosimos 2023:
Review №1
2022-01-02This place was fantastic! Interior felt very cozy and service was very friendly. The food was also great. The pizzas are a great price for their portions, and I especially loved the ricotta on the broccoli pie. The white clam sauce pasta was also delicious.In addition, there are several electric car charging stations right in their parking area, which was very convenient.Would definitely love to come back again.
Review №2
2022-05-19It was our first time to Cosimo’s since it had been newly renovated. We were seated by the new doors to the outside eating area. With no exaggeration, every 1-2 minutes wait staff went in and out and the door would make a loud long noise as it shut. It was very disturbing and made our dining experience very unpleasant. Then my food came and the juice looked like muddy water. The chicken was good but the juice made everything else taste bad. We usually have dessert but we couldn’t take the door noise anymore.The waitress was very attentive and pleasant so we left her a good tip. If we go back we will ask not to sit by the door.
Review №3
2022-07-07Great! The food was great and decently fast as well. If Im being honest their bread is some of the best Ive ever tasted also.
Review №4
2021-12-06Great experience, food, and staff! One of the better pizza and Italian joints in the area. And there are a lot!Had a figs and prosciutto flatbread pizza and it was delish. The server recommended to add peppers and it was just perfect!Still Covid aware, masks on the staff and barriers throughout the place. The restaurant wasnt too busy and easy for customers to spread out.Highly recommend!
Review №5
2022-05-04Tried the rice balls and pork chops. The rice balls were like none I ever had before and they were AWESOME! Getting pork chop is always a risk, but this dish was cooked PERFECTLY and was very flavorful! Would definitely order both again but the food was so good, I will be returning to try something else. Don’t know who the chef is, but the food was amazing! Staff was super friendly and attentive!
Review №6
2022-04-23Oh yeah! Been waiting for Cosimo’s to reopen after the renovations and they did not disappoint! The new look is absolutely awesome, gorgeous and sexy!My wife and I went this past Wednesday to sample the new atmosphere, drink menu and food selections. The new drink choices are creative and tasty! Not a lot of changes to the menu, but we did try the tuna tartare and the shrimp baguette and both were outstanding!!So glad Cosimo’s is back. And it’s better than ever.
Review №7
2021-11-12Warm service and delicious eats.Even with a funky glass, the overall experience at Cosimos was delightful. What are the odds of having the only dirty cup out of five glasses? Regardless, the waiter was quick and apologetic about the situation.The cleanliness in general was far better than our previous restaurant blunder- just read the prior post regarding P & Gs in Newpaltz, NY. The bathrooms at Cosimos were clean and had fragrant soap. The extra attention to hygiene was appreciated. Unlike the other restaurant, the customer service here was welcoming and the water staff wore face masks. The energy was far more comfortable than our previous restaurant blunder. Further, our waiter was attentive and responsive towards the partys allergy concerns.I thoroughly enjoyed my eggplant and goat cheese sandwich. The ginger sald dressing was also pleasant. The party equally enjoyed their meal; from the spicy chicken fuscilli to eggplant parmigiano, the freshness and quality of the food were well received.Overall, thank you Cosimos for making our Fathers birthday better.
Review №8
2021-10-12Great service, amazing food! Couldnt find the kids menu on the website but they do have one.
Review №9
2022-05-06Very good Italian & Pizza restaurant that stays busy. I highly suggest reservations for the weekend especially. They closed temporarily to remodel, and are back open with slightly different hours while they finish the remodel. The truffle Flatbread is amazing. Best pizzas in the area.
Review №10
2022-07-07Food was very good... staff was very friendly... everything was fine except we were outside and there were gnats all over.I dont blame the restaurant for this but just want to warn others you might want to eat inside.