Outdoor seating
Yes
Croxleys Ale House - Farmingdale in Farmingdale
Categories
Location on the map
Farmingdale, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Kerbside pickup
Yes
No-contact delivery
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff wear masks
Yes
Staff get temperature checks
Yes
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Great beer selection
Yes
Great cocktails
Yes
Sport
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Cocktails
Yes
Food
Yes
Food at bar
Yes
Happy-hour drinks
Yes
Happy-hour food
Yes
Spirits
Yes
Wine
Yes
Amenities
Toilets
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Planning
Accepts reservations
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 516-293-7700
Site: https://www.croxley.com/location...
Site: https://www.croxley.com/location...
Opening hours
- Monday:12–11PM
- Tuesday:12–11PM
- Wednesday:12PM–12AM
- Thursday:12PM–12AM
- Friday:12PM–12AM
- Saturday:12PM–12AM
- Sunday:12–10PM
Comments (199)
Had my daughter’s bridal shower there on 5/29/22. from planning with kim to the amazing service headed by andrea everything was perfect! beautiful space, delicious food…. great experience!! ❤️
Use to have good, cheap wings but that had ended. Got served burned fried calamari that had to be returned. Rest of the food was subpar. Beer was ok but will not be coming back.
Been coming here for like 5 years and no matter when I go, the food is always amazing. Its unfortunate they no longer have 10 cent wings but the wings are worth every penny regardless! Will continue coming to this amazing ale house which always has a great variety of beers and ciders!
As always amazing. Best wings around. Check out their tap wall. Dave the manager always makes us feel comfortable.
Good selection of alcohol, wings are my fav!! Very spacious with outdoor seating.
The garlic parm wings are my favorite. Sooo good . Also the steak sandwich is very tasty. Amazing food🤌🏽🤌🏽
This place has never disappointed whenever I have come here. If it was just to grab a drink which they have plenty of or getting some food. It is all good. During our last visit we got the two pound pot of mussels with the Weis which was great. Got an order of hot wings which was really good. They also have a vast beer selection, if you want to try something different then give this place a try.
Out of the beer I wanted, boneless wings were great, could have been a little cheaper per beer. Would go back to watch sports and drink
Very good food fresh Everyone was social distance from each otherIrish loaded fries was unbelievable I do reccomend/ fish n chips wasnt bad either
Came in with my wife and my daughter and although it was now baseball season my daughter didnt feel like it was just a sports bar and she could enjoy a better place for wings vs Hooters. Waitress was awesome, place was super clean and refreshing. Food was fast and fresh. This is my second time here and the first time I was here it caught me by surprise that they didnt take credit/debit cards then and now the policy has changed......Kudos to ya Croxley !
Not a bad place to start or stop at for your weekend bar hop adventure. Attentive, and polite staff. Fair pricing to go along with the ambiance.
Food was okay, music was way too loud and kept fluctuating in volume. Right when you get used to it, it starts blaring even louder than before. They keep the place spotless, though.
Service was great and place was very nice !! The wings were ok but I wouldnt say world famous ! My drink was dam good though!
This is not a good restaurant. The food is terrible as is the service.Don’t recommend, don’t bring you’re family.Better off going to friendlys. The food is that bad. Have fun!
Had brunch here. Unlimited mimosa bloody mary for a great price. The avocado toast was fantastic and the cajun omlet delicious and not too spicy. Our server was a pleasure got everything right and even added extra champagne to our too juicy mimosas
Staff is very friendly and the beer on tab has a great selection. Head on down if your in the mood to have a few beers.
Absolutely awful. Terrible, watered down, warm beer. Overpriced. Feel like a fool that I had a third beer after 2 different bad ones.
Hitemco held a retirement party for a fellow coworker. Staff was top notch professionalism, garden room very spacious and accommodating. Thank you Croxleys
Came here for the special promotion on the wings. I felt they were sub par. The boneless buffalo wings tasted like chicken nuggets. The boned garlic and parmesan ones were cold. We asked the server if they could heat them up. No problem. They came back instead with a replacement plate, which was again just room temperature! Beer was okay place could use some updating. TV screens kept going blank because of satellite dish issues.
Solid spot. Good wings, quick service, friendly staff. Parking is a pain though, so if youre going with people try to car pool.
Good drink selection but the food was very bland. I would come here for the drinks and sports games but not for food.
Fantastic selection of domestic and international beers. Food was ok. Great ambience.
I went to this place, for brunch they overcharged us, and did not bring the ice cream that we order for the kid. Not going back there. If you do go to that place double check your bill.
Had a triple date this location. Awesome time great music crowd was really into the music. Had the playoff games on. Service was great and the drinks were good as well. Definitely will become a repeat customer.
Great place for wings and beer. Great customer service. Bring friends and enjoy sports night. Had a great time. Highly recommend it
Really inconsistent service, waitress was trying to keep up but it was super busy and everything kept falling thru the cracks...10 mins to put in drinks order, another 10 for 1/2 beers to arrive then wings came which are definitely not what they used to be.Overcooked, the formerly deviating Cry like a Baby sauce while still flavorful has been neutered to only slightly hotter than hot, while hot was so salty it was nearly inedible.Nearly finished wings by the time we were able to flag down server and get the other beer we ordered 20 minutes ago. Was still waiting for a salad when that arrived and we decided we had to bail out and get the salad wrapped bc we had a movie in 45 mins.15 wings of barely passable quality cost nearly $25 now, salad I think was $17 which we ended up eating at home was sad at best, yes it sat in a 45 degree car for 2.5 hours but it had to have started life pretty soggy to be as bad as it was.Not a great time, they were swamped but management seemed to just be aimlessly circling and not really making any useful contributions. Used to love the now defunct Smithtown location but idk of well be returning to this one.
Horrible service on a Saturday night. Came with a party of 5 to celebrate a special occasion and we were put in a corner table next to a private event section. Drinks took forever to get delivered to our table because of backed up bar service. Server came over to us more than 3 times acting all surprised that we have not received drinks or food. We also didnt like the vibe our server was giving us. She kept pushing us for shots and kept making up excuses for bad service. She came very quick with our bill though and she charged us for a drink that we didnt order. Definitely will not be back!!
Great place to watch a game.Great food and a nice selection of beer
First time going to this location and I do recommend. Service is good and quick. Bartender was very helpful with selection of the beers. Food was good, I got boneless BBQ wings with blue cheese. They have a special I believe if you buy a drink and get appetizers for $3 5wings or 7wings. Parking is decent but right by train station.
Food is good, a little bit pricey for a Sports Bar, however cool atmosphere
Nice placw!!! Alot of beer!! Great wings!! Taco Tuesday is awesome too!!! Great service!!!
Private room is to die for. Lors of room. Brunch is great! French toast smashing. Good times. Definately want to return.
Food was ok place was way too noisy even when not crowded. Dont plan to go for conversation.
Great place for some beers and wings !The wings here are always awesome
Probably some of the best wings I’ve ever had! Great menu for food and a phenomenal Beer selection. Several locations and they don’t disappoint.
Came here for their great list of draft beers and wings night. Always a good time.
Food and drinks were top shelve. Bartenders very polite and fast with the drinks.
Beautiful place inside and out, with plenty of space. The menu contains an extensive list of beer (with a ton of local Long Island beers) and liquor options, some of the best wings around, and a great assortment of sandwiches, burgers, and entrees. Friendly staff. A staple in the community.
My husband and myself come here quite often and really enjoy it. Unfortunately after tonight I will never be coming back again. There was a shard of glass in my food. Ive never in my life had this happen to me. They took $85 off my bill but I just feel like nothing can make up for glass being in a customers food..
Great pub food and service huge beer selection family friendly
This place is off the foshizzle ma Nizzle.How can you go wrong at a hot wing/ burger joint that houses 100 (give or take a few) different beers.
Went with a few co-workers for a happy hour. Ambience was really nice and there were a lot of beer options. Was a little disappointed in the portion size of the mozzarella sticks but other than that its a great place to grab a drink with some friends.
We were 6 on Mothers Day. We ordered the special brunch. Delicious food but terrible service. Our main dish came to the table minutes after we received our appetizer. We werent offered a 2nd drink or more coffee even though they were unlimited. The little things add up but not for the 20%tip they added to the bill without telling us.
Last night we had my nephews surprise 40th birthday party here. It was phenomenal!! Everyone of there staff members couldnt do enough for us. The food was incredible!! The service was awesome!!! I do have to give a huge thank you to one of the catering managers Eleana. Eleana you saved the night with making the cake I brought brought back to life!! What an awesome job!!! Highly recommend Croxley Ale House Farmingdale for any of your parties!!!
Great American Bar & Grill. Finest food, beer, and patrons on Long Island
Best tap beer on long island. Pet friendly
Tried ordering 50 wings with 2 different flavors was told it wasn’t possible i have to order 2 different orders of 20. Absolutely ridiculous I proceeded with my order an hour and a half before the pick up time and I’m currently now waiting 25 mins over my pick up time. Won’t be back again.
Some of the best wings around. Always great. Additionally the shrimp tacos and french dip are the greatest. Huge beer selection of micros.
Service super slow and it was not that busy, ordered a caeser salad and they used oil and vinegar and too vinegary, could not eat it, told the wait staff and still had to pay for it. Ordered blue cheese for wings, did not get it. So many places for wings, doubt I will go back
Honestly might be the last time i go there which is a shame because the wings are really good. The service is always terrible and it takes 15 mins just for us to be asked what we would like to drink. If you want to watch a specific game and its not on a tv near you, youll probably have to ask 4 or 5 times to get it changed. We have given this place a million second chances and they always let us down. There doesnt seem like there is a manager overlooking the staff, it just seems like everyone is running around like a chicken with its head off
Lunch special was a good deal. $3 for 6 boneless wings cant be beat. Taste was decent as well. The onion soup was pretty salty. Service wasnt bad. All in all... was an ok experience.
Awesome beer selection and pretty good food
Great place to hang out and watch a game while having your favorite drink and great bar food.
Love this place. Regular now, nice place to have a drink, good appetizers. Too noisy by the bar and by the tables nearby. Overall a decent place.
Amazing food from the chilli fries to the roast beef sandos with gravy. Counldnt get enough and the service was really good. If u do a fantasy football draft go to croxleys for sure
Mediocre at best. Only reason I’m giving it 2 instead of 5 stars were the amazing wings and our waitress. Besides that the food was a joke.Tacos had absolutely no flavor. Salt and pepper go a long way. The mixed vegetables looked and smelled like they were cooked days ago. I’m assuming I had the last scoop from an old batch. The wings were great along with the country fried chicken.Timing of the food was off. We received our entrees 5 minutes after our apps were served. So you got it, we’re scrambling to make room on our table while eating our apps.If it wasn’t for the friendly waitress, I’d give 1 star for this visit.
Awesome place to watch the games. The food is good and everyone working at Croxley is friendly. Keep up the great work Guys!
Been coming here for years with friends and never had a bad experience. I always ask for the wings well done and I just love it!
This is the place if you want to have your photo taken to get in. Food is terrible, service awful
Excellent beers selection. Wings are good. Overall food is good and eclectic. Staff is hit or miss, sometimes they’re attentive. Most times they’re not; but I don’t go for the waitress I go for the beer. So... Can get very crowded and loud.
Their honey bbq wings on the bone are pretty good. Went for Wednesday happy hour & they had $10 mega margaritas. They do not skimp on the alcohol! All the drinks were strong, which was cool. At 5pm they started their 50 cent wings deal. The bar gets really full, but the bartender was great. She never let me wait too long for her to take my order.
Good bar food, good service. Only draw back was the music was so loud we couldnt hear ourselves talk over dinner
We had a beautiful baby shower today at Croxley’s. The food was delicious and the service was excellent! It was the perfect venue for a shower. Hours later I am still receiving complements from our guests. If you are shopping for a venue I would seriously consider Croxley’s!
Manager David was extremely helpful. He made sure I was able to be seated right away on a busy night, even cleared space so everyone was safely distanced. Afterwards, asked if I needed anything and took the time to put on the game I came here to see. Great service - will be coming back just because of that.
Good wings, lots of TVs (enjoyed my food while watching the game). Good selection of beers. Tends to get a little loud later at night.
Wings: delicious. Beer: good selection and delicious. Good open space by the bar with seating available with outdoor option. Typical sports bar menu and service. Bathrooms are small and are not cleaned throughout the night. Also, there is a separate room for private parties.
Havent been here in years. Wings and wing sauce are not bad. Shrimp tacos are the worst I have ever had. Some didnt even look like shrimp. Tasted like old fry oil. Would go back to try other items.
Great service, great food and great beer. Been here before and after pandemic. Their staff is still incredibly friendly and accommodating.
Feel like this location had better wings than the Smithtown location. Bartenders made the drinks the right way, not too strong and not too weak. There was good music and a good crowd of people at the bar but didnt interfere with space near our table. Waitress was friendly and food came quickly during a crowded time.
How do I give this place more stars? The absolute best place for wings. Everything on the menu is amazing. Great staff. Great atmosphere. Love this place.
Went last night to chill for my birthday before going bar hopping, our waitress Justine or Justina (sorry I’m bad with names) was very sweet and took very good care of us and checked on the status of our food frequently. Food was great as always I had Mac and cheese and fried zucchini for munchies and my bf and friend had wings which were all great. Always enjoy coming here.
Friendly sevice good food and good drinks would go back
Nice place. It was our second visit, and wed return.
Decent place but nothing special. Its a very popular spot, loud, and the bar can get 2-3 deep at the right time. Often they have just two bar tenders running the entire place so service can take a while. Great selection of beers, but the wings are mediocre. The cheap price offsets it a bit. Nothing really wrong with the place, good spot to go out with friends, but just OK.
I wish I could give zero. Came in and was told to grab a high top since the bar was full which was fine...it was sitting at the table for over 20 minutes with not a single approach to the table by any staff members. Terrible customer service. Never wasting time in this place again.
Who doesnt like wings and beer? I much prefer the Rockville Centre location. Wings at the farmingdale local werent that good and beer seemed flat and warm.
Youve heard about the wings here. Well, its true. They are perfect buffalo wings. Meaty, well seasoned and cooked just right. Mild for the kids, and try a little hotter for the adults.Other food is good also, but seriously, youre here for the wings and the beer. Great beer selection. Also!
4 stars for great wings. 1 star because the bar is very expensive and the wings have gotten more expensive over the years (no buy backs at all even if you tip well).Pro tip - Get the bbq wings and combine it with the hot sauce. They might say we can’t do it (if the waitress is new). Trust me they can best flavor ever
Ive been to this place many times. Never had any complaints about the food or drinks. Only thing was once when I ordered fish and chips, Id asked for malt vinegar and the waitress brought the oil and vinegar you put on salads. That was a long time ago though and hasnt happened since. Great place. It obviously gets really loud near the bar so if youre not into a lot of loud noise, ask for a table in the back (or the beer garden if its available).
I really like the atmosphere, the food, the beer. I do feel they could work on service, I’ve had some servers that were not that attentive. Otherwise I like going here for their wide selection of beer and wings.
It was my first time going to this place I was pleasantly surprised by the layout of the place. The food was awesome. The beer and liquor selection was more diverse than I thought it was going to be. Overall a great experience hear their wings might be a must-try on the first time there.
Either incapable or unwilling to get orders correctly. I’ve ordered from them for pick up, uber eats & dined in. Every time it’s a problem. It’s a shame because the food is good but the service and getting to the meal are not. Salads without salad dressing, among other issues.
Nice place ! Good wings . Chain feel . Industrial motif.
Great place for wings and craft beer. They used to have 10, 20 and 30 cent wings on different days. I used to go all the time when they had their wing specials. Their prices have increased tremendously so, I dont visit nearly as often. I would definitely go more often for their $8 drafts if their wing prices were lower again. Cmon, earn that 5th star by bringing the special wing prices back.
Good service, good food, and beer selection.
Nice place good drinks nice appetizers
Went for dinner at 6pm on a Wednesday. Place wasnt crowded. They had dividers set up to separate the tables following covid-19 protocols. And the food and drinks were spot on. Highly recommended.
They clean the tables before we sit down. Had wings loved it,Im from the Caribbean so the spiciness was great . They the frozen drink were great they have a chocolate drink and a pina colada that I mixed and it was excellent.
Shout out toCroxley Ale HouseSports bar in FarmingdaleWent to dinner with 16 people on Saturday night. Service by waitress Stephanie was fantastic. They got all our orders correct and out to the table with in minutes of each other. The food was hot and very good. Good Time was had by all.
I always come here for wings. Never disappointed.
I wish I could give this place zero stars. I am taken back by what happened this weekend. We had our meal and our friend was paying so we went to wait outside for him. As we left the restaurant we took our masks off because we were outside. One of the bouncers came out and told us to leave if we dont have masks on.....outside again. But we listened and waited at the end of the restaurant this way our friend could see us when we walk out. The same guy proceeded to bolt at us and push us (which is clearly not the 6 foot rule) until we were down the block. Im not sure why he had to stoop to pushing us just for standing outside waiting for our friend. Horrible way to do business. We will not be back and nor will our families who spend every football Sunday and throw a huge party for st Patricks day here. You lost so much business.
Nice place for some delicious wings, good service and great atmosphere.
It was really nice of the waitress to.offer us the garden room. It was much brighter and quieter then the rest of the restaurant. Alllll the beer options of tap 😎
Service was friendly, massive beer list, had an issue with an appetizer but ill chalk it up to a rare mistake. Steak was dope.
Food was OK, asked for well done fries: not! Saw cheese curds in gravy on menu, asked if the would make poutine by putting over fries...thought someone behind me had two heads. Nothing was bad, service was good.
Great place to watch a football game, drink a variety of beers and eat wings.
Awesome place to great some really great beer there rotating rarities menu is to die for. Make sure you come on a wing night grab some cheap grub thats really good that taste even better with a nice craft beer after. The best bar I know of for middle of the island for Rangers game!
The staff was pleasant but there isnt any reconciling the menu and food. The fresh potato chips should have been easy but all the seasonings are burnt. The spinach is salty with garlic from a jar. The menu is ancient, boring American junk. They need healthy,fresh ingredients and creative choices.
Wonderful, welcoming staff, and lively! Great wings and our favorite bartender bought my Dads drinks for his 67th birthday! Cant get better than a place that loves the locals back!
Great sports bar with a ton of drink choices to choose from and all kinds of specials for happy hour and special events. The bar space is relatively roomy, but it does fill up pretty quick as the evening rolls around. The place is even great for private events, went to a wedding reception here and had an absolute blast. Food is surprisingly very good, even for the choices they offer that dont seem like typical bar fare. Plenty of parking around, either in the back or across the street. Farmingdale has a lot of good bar choices, but croxleys is certainly not one to sleep on.
They have gotten really cheap with their beer pours. I know I havent been there in a while, but they changed to centileters so people dont know how little beer they are actually getting. Most beers are under a12 ounce pour. Majority are under 9 ounces. This is way less than almost anywhere else. I wont be back and will be taking my business elsewhere as they are now very overpriced for beer. Very deceptive business practice.
Very good beer selection. Food has not disappointed me. Service is very good. Parking is no issue. Lots of seating. Specials are pretty good. A must try.
Awesome beer selection and the food is great!
I came here for a 30th birthday party. The provided good was great, and the service was excellent. My only complaint was that the beer selection included with the party was smaller than the offerings at the main bar. They still had a decent selection, dont get me wrong. I just wanted stuff they only had at the main bar. 😉
Just hosted a surprise 21st for 25 people...it was awesome! Staff was incredible, food was perfect and the Garden Room was the perfect venue!
My family and I decided to give them a shot before we had to take a train in for a concert. Putting the reviews aside we heard good things so we figured to give it a shot. We were wrong. The service was horrible. We waited 20 minutes for our drinks. We had to give our food order to another server. The food came out incorrect. We were hoping to kill some time before our train unfortunately our stay was cut short. If u can figure out the insane constraints to order wings for $.10 they were o.k. but not great. We will not be back.
There are 65 taps and 40+ bottles. Thats enough for any craft beer fan to find something they love. Ive tried over 300 beers here during the past few years and ice found some real gems. The place is clean and well maintained. Its got a good vibe and ambiance. The food is first rate, which you wouldnt expect for a bar, but this is owned by the same people who own a come of fine dining restaurants in Garden City (Waterzooi & Novita) and its clear their philosophy on quality food carries over here. Of special note are the wings, which are really cheap, yet some of the best Ive ever had, their Bavarian pretzel, sourced from some top secret location no one is allowed to know, and the bratwurst, which is just plain delicious. Ive been a regular here since the tail end of 2008 and Im consistently pleased. The staff is pretty great and very friendly. They make you feel comfortable and make it a great place to hang out!
Awesome atmosphere. Im a family man happily married for over 31 years brought my 3 daughters and husbands and 2 nieces out for snacks wings and drinks on a saturday night, super awesome service by Christina , everything was excellent noist as a saturday night get together should be , pretzels, tacos, mozzarella, wings all excellent thanks Croxleys for memorable night
Wing specials multiple days of the week + great beer selection. Weve never gone during peak times, but Saturday afternoons early evenings are great. Good and fast service.
We’ve been there numerous times. Nice bar/restaurant. Great beer selection, great wings and burgers. Other food is good as well.
Had a small party there and the food was the best, cant wait to go back for dinner!
So so food, gluten free options(beer or food) are advertised but they very rarely, and I mean rarely, have them. Update 12/23/20: The waitress we had was a train wreck. So much so that the other wait staff started to get embarrassed at her incompetence
Good experience Having food and drinks over here. Staff was interactive and knew what they were suppose to do (which dont apply for normal sports bar). Food was good and drinks were cheep. Overall the experience was awesome. A place must to go. Only down part was smelly restrooms.
Been coming to this restaurant for years. Great steaks, Burgers and More. Huge selection of tap beers. Largest in the Farmingdale area.
Good food, drinks & fun!
This place simply is awesome. Best wings Ive had in New York , without paying an arm and a leg. My goodness the beer selection I cant say enough but mmmm mmm. Service is friendly , my only issue is when they get really busy response time might lag a bit . Regardless all the staff are willing to help from manerger to the cook. 4.7 guys keep up the good work.
Cute spot with a spacious event space. The food was Ok, docked off a star because I love Penne alla Vodka and theirs was not too good, a bit too sweet. Irregardless, the servers were attentive, drinks were good, and overall atmosphere is fun!
Decided to stop in for lunch. Beer prices were more than reasonable, with a fairly diverse array of brews on. I did enjoy having a 2014 Bourbon County Brand Stout left over from the Bourbon County takeover they had recently. Burger I had was on point, getting it just rare enough for my liking. The lunch crowd seems to have their regulars, and the bartender was keen to take care of them first. With its proximity to Farmingdale State College and parking out back, I could definitely see myself coming back.
Horrible service at the bar on Sunday 9/27 in the daytime. We had to practically shoot up a flare to get attention at the far end of the bar EVERY time we needed something. Very unfriendly too! Get a new job if you hate that one so much. Jeez
Great bar, a wide selection of beers, and the staff is awesome. Steph is one of the bartenders there and she is super chill. Favorite beer of the night was Sam Adams Berry flavored beer. Taste just like a Welch’s fruit snack! Haha.
Waitresses are good and attentive. Its a bar. Nothing special but crowd is fun and live music is good too. Overall worth a visit. Keep your kids home, not a family spot.
Best wings around. Go ahead and change my mind. Good spot to chill. Friendly staff and the foods always on point
Good food and great beer selection, but the service is poor and you always got to double check your bill. They always tacked on something I didnt order. They also put a 20% gratuity even though the service is poor
Great restaurant with an awesome wing special. From 10 cent boneless wings to 20 cent classic wings deal couldnt get any better. Theyre a couple of rules if you want more then 10 you have to order by 5 and if you want to take any left over wings got to pay and extra 65
We had a party in the event room and it was beautiful! Lovely bar, clean bathrooms and very delightful atmosphere. The restaurant bar area looked really cool too. Staff was friendly :) Well be back!
Went there for the world famous wings they were definitely not known further then the block they are on let alone suffolk county. Ordered 60 wings last night and dined in i hadMILD witch the sauce was good but over cooked half the meat was stuck to the bone. PARMESAN GARLIC which tasted like shrimp for some reason, MANGO HABANERO had hardly any flavor to them and were dry. THAI COCONUT and it actually tasted like a cigarette. The building it self had a smell to it like mold. The bathroom was filthy and the sink had mold around it. If this is what the people can see imagine what the kitchen looks like. Cleanliness is definitely not a priority at this place. I definitely wont be coming back for drinks or wings any time soon
Good atmosphere, great wings and good beer. Guac and chips are pretty damn good as well. Highly recommend
Atmosphere is great, wings are above average, burgers are pretty good and lots of different craft beers too. Service at time could be better, but its not bad enough to take away from the rating.
Croxleys is always a great time. The food is great, all of the staff is great. It does get pretty packed when there is more than one Sporting Event on but even then, there usual 2-3 bartenders and wait staff are fast and get to everyone. I have never had a bad experience there.
Ordered a kona big wave that was was flatter than than an A cup bra. Elle the bartender was very unprofessional. Not likely to come back. Our server was excellent and the food was hot and came out fast. I’ve worked for a two Michelin star restaurant prior; Croxleys is an awesome dive bar. The attitudes of some of the bartenders needs severe improvement, makes me not want to revisit. Good vibe, good bar, ate outside with incredible service from our server; most definitely better than nappers.. I’d rather drink at home alone than deal with Elle the bartender ever again . Go for boneless wings don’t sit at the bar the servers are much more personable. Know ur clients, keep making banging wings. Croxleys is a staple in Smithtown, some employs need to be more respectable. Fix the employees and you deserve more than five stars.
I was a little disappointed that the wing prices have sky rocketeted.....8 wingettes for $12.00, so I tried a steak sandwich which was just ok.
Service was terrible. The waitress hardly came by our table of 12, and forgot to bring numerous things to us that we asked for, like drinks. A few people ordered different chicken meals and the chicken was terrible. It tasted like it was cooked in the microwave. Never going back here again for food.
During Friday evenings in the summer, they have free boneless wings, fries and calamari. Pretty good! Beer specials could be better but the selection is extensive.
Liam and Michelle were nothing but professional and just wonderful! Liam asked what I liked and found the beer that suited me. Michelle was nothing but attentive and sweet. Thank you both; you made my weekend better!
I can see why this place is empty fo Sunday Brunch. Food was ok at best but for a group of 10 in a 3/4 empty restaurant our meals came out over 20 my utes apart. The managers excuse “ we accidentally dropped the quesadilla” lol. I’m ok with replacing that but how about telling us that initially. Not to mention 3 of the other meals came out 20 minutes late as well. Super disappointing experience. We are local to main steewt and this place can be fun to go to for drinks but I highly recomment NEVER coming here for a sit-down meal. 2 other of our meals were made completely wrong as well. Overall, everyone dissatisfied because by the time we finally got to eat everything was cold anyway. This place deserves ZERO STARS.
Terrible place. If you are looking for a good bar scene look further. The wait staff is inattentive. I needed more water and had to go to the bar. The security IDed my friend after already drinking a beer. I have never seen behavior this idiotic. Do not go here.
I love the wings!! Perfect place to hang out with friends food and 🏈🏈🏈!!!
Pretty quick service and the food wasnt bad at all. Burger was cooked properly, waitress was prompt and drinks were a good value compared to some other local bars. Recommended.
The best place ever. The staff is very friendly and extremely professional.
Delicious hot food the whole family can enjoy...we went with the boneless wings and they were NOT ordinary, the burgers were humongous and non shortage on cheese , bacon and the like. The kids went with mac n cheese(kids like it better than kraft) and a grilled cheese that our son wants us to make at home it was so good. We didnt even sample the many beers but they have a nice selection. My only low score would be the fountain lipton iced tea(I should have asked)
Always a great place for food and drinks!
This place has a commendable beer list - lots of interesting things on tap, with a helpful menu categorizing their selections.The food was great as well - I really enjoyed both the boneless wings and my burger.
I always loved croxleys but I gave them 4 stars intend of 5 because theyve changed their baskets to little rectangle plates. Looks like theyre trying to get fancier. Not liking it. But theres a great beer selection and the burgers are still great.
Servers friendly food ex😃cellent
Great drag queen show tonight,
Awesome! Clean and proper distancing in place! Go, people!
Manager walked behind us ever couple minutes to check if the one underage person had a drink in front of her when she clearly only had water. Complete lack of respect for customers. Prices are outrageous. They have a cheap wing deal with about 5 different sur charges if you dont order the proper amount, or drink, etc. Pain to get in. Waitress is not friendly by any means. Will NEVER come again. Drank a water and left.
They served literally everyone around us. We were here for 45 minutes, they didnt serve us, people came in after us, and they served them. Like no one even gave us water at the table. We were ignored for almost an hour before we went somewhere else.
Easy to see right off of Main Street servicing Farmingdale and the adjoining areas of Suffolk County. Parking on the Street is available but it fills up fast especially at night and on the weekends. Clean facilities. Weekly food and drink specials. Nice staff. Credit cards accepted. We will most likely be going back.
My wife and I recently stopped into Croxleys because we heard so much about the wings. We are both in our mid 60s. We just wanted a snack and to try the wings. the waitress told us we HAD TO order a min of 10 each. OK no problem. We had a couple of tap beers also. We ate all but a couple of these wings. I asked to take the couple of wings home, To my suprise the waitress told us it would cost us 65cents each to take home. YES I know people order massive amounts, eat a few and think they are going to take home the rest for that menu price. I understand that. BUT you must draw the line somewhere. We are seniors and sometimes get full alot quicker. We only had a couple left. Give me a break. As far as the wings they were over deep fried and not juicy at all, Although the flavor was good. I think the staff should have the right to decide on the amount of wings a person can take home with no extra charge. Like I said, People who order massive amounts and want to take them all home should not be allowed, but as far as my experience, I will never put myself through that again. Re-think your policy.
Friendly hostess brought me to a table. A quick glance at the menu and beer list and I knew whatI wanted. Yet there I sat. No one said hi. No one came to offer water or ask if Id like a drink. I finally got up and walked down to That MeetBall Place. No one noticed me leave. The place wasnt even busy.
Lots of specials on the menu for different days a week . I had chicken wings on the bone. French fries and beer of course the best combination. So many beers to choose from. Theres a beer for everyone.
Had my sons party there. Just a regular sports bar with like a million different beers. They were very accommodating and we had a good time at a reasonable price.
Always loved the chicken wings! Even more when they are 10 cents or 40 cents 😁. The service is always great and the drink prices are standard. A good atmosphere also.
Love it! Great food, great music, attractive crowd/staff and a welcoming clean atmosphere, what more could you ask for?
I just did a graduation party for my daughter in the Garden Room at Croxleys Farmingdale location. The room itself was terrific with plenty of seating/tables and a full-sized bar for the party. The food was delicious and the staff did a tremendous job. all in all it was a great experience and I would definitely do another party there in a heartbeat.
Very well covid-19 set up.... cold beer good wings would be five stars but little too much sauce for my liking
Extraordinary environment and super friendly service. The meals were fresh and yummy. Will clearly recommend this place to anyone. Convenient rates and large meals. Great job.
The Chicken Quesedillas Were Delicious...The Side Of Pulled Pork Was Disgusting...The BBQ Wings Was Okay, Nice & Crunchy...
Really great beer selection. had some falafel tacos one time that were really fantastic. they have new grimm beers often, so its definitely worth a visit
This place is just amazing. The food, the staff, everything. Loved everything about my visit there.
Awful experience all around. Theres nothing worse than having a hostess walk past you for 15 minutes while you wait to be seated and not be acknowledged, then have the waitress fail to bring a menu, ask if id like to order, and when I finally ask if im allowed to place an order, she shrugs and walks away like Im a leper. After I ate my 14 dollar cold hamburger, which I had to get up from my seat and order at the bar, I go to pay the tab only to find out the bartender added three drinks to my bill that I never ordered, and I had to wait 5 minutes to tell her my bill was wrong because she was yapping about her friends bf drama with the other bartender while she looked at me three times knowing full well that I was waiting. Awful wait staff, awful experience, and the overpriced food was cold to boot.
We frequently go for the wing nights. Great selection of beer. It can get crowded on weekends and during big sports events bit nonetheless always a good time there!
Deceptive Practices.Orderer beware be watchful. The new wings menu states you will be charged a 20% service charge, and they do, for the entire order. If the service was worth a 20% tip this would not be an issue, the service is not worth a 20% tip.Then I expressed my dissatisfaction to the Manger, she said she would do something this time only, well she had a change of mind between speaking to me and running my credit card.Net result, a lost patron. Shame, I did enjoy the restaurant, would drive 10-12 miles past many other fine establishments to get there, well not any more.
Decent bar snacks, stiff drinks, good service! But dont order the garlic parmesan wings.
I certainly enjoyed their dishes and customer service, fantastic area next to my house. The employees are always super friendly. Will come visit again.
Our favorite place for both date nights and family/friends dinners !!! In my opinion they have the best wings and menu out of all the Croxleys 😍
Service was great, staff was super friendly. The prices are very reasonable, especially the lunch specials. Very impressed with the food and beer selection. Very cool place. Will be back.
Croxleys was decent when it started but has turned into a very low quality run establishment across the board. Overpriced bar food fried and grilled usually overdone or underdone really falls short of expectations. Staff is unprofessional basically a bar trying to be a restaurant with bad food. And as far as craft beers go, its always been my experience that most of them suck, sorry but thats the truth. I would not recommend to friends.
Very well organised and convenient restaurant. They serve large meals and for fair prices. I enjoyed the meals very much and the staff were super amiable and chatty. Will definitely recommend this place.
Great beer selection but average pub grub. The staff and thier service is top notch. Just got to work on the food.
Our party of six couldnt be seated because two of us werent there yet. We watched a ufc fight and had drinks and apps. Service was good and prices were reasonable for the area
Good food, ok service. But when it came to pay, they overcharged me. $.40 boneless and $.50 wings don’t exist on Sundays. They are slick, and for that I won’t be going back there.
You know Ive never been enamored with Farmingdale Croxleys selection of beer, and especially the fact that they fail to carry the Long Island regional beers seems pretty sad to me. But myself and a bunch of my work friends went there for the 10 cent wing night. The wings arent amazing, but hey, at 10 cents a piece Im willing to settle for something that is definetily less than world famous. But after the attitude of the staff this past experience, I think well be taking our business elsewhere from now on. We arrived at about 6:50 or so and told the staff we had a large group, they balked at the size, but said as long as we were willing to wait 30-40 minutes it would be fine. We agreed, and noticed a large group (approx our size) already seated, so we assumed that after that group finished their meal that we would be able to sit. So we took a seat at the bar, ordered some beers and began chatting. About a half hour later the group left, the table was cleared, and then... THEY SAT A GROUP OF 6 AT THE TABLES WHERE WE WERE SUPPOSED TO BE SEATED AND THEY HAD JUST GOTTEN THERE!!! We asked what was going on and we were told to be patient. These people proceeded to order 1 drink each and then sit there for almost an hour. For 30 minutes they sat there at an empty table with no drinks, having paid their check. The wait staff was rude to myself and my friends, we waited an hour and a half for a table that should have been available in half the time, because whoever was assigning tables screwed up. The staff was rude, and when we were seated the service was slow, and innattentive. Ive been to all three Croxleys on the island and the other 2 seem to have good staffs, and fun atmospheres. This one needs a new staff.
Good bartending staff. Large selection of beers. Wide open space. Sit down eating available. Televised sports events shown here. Great for UFC fans.
Best food, super nice staff members, constantly awesome character. They charge fair rates and the food quality is great. Great work.
Croxleys is the go to beer bar in Farmingdale. Lots of clise by parking, cheap eats and one of the best draft beer selections around. They always have a selection of rotating rare beer finds for that snob in your group, aka me, as well as lots of solid crafts for ever persons palate. Also. Did I mention cheap eats? Like wing deals most days and burger and beer specials on Thursday and happy hour? Its a great spot and is always hopping.
Though the food is very good; the service is not. We use to come here all the time but not so much anymore because of the service. Today an entire glass of water was spilt on me and you would think they would at least take off the sodas.
Great food good time Bartender Matt was awesome, will definitely be back!!
Went there this past weekend $81 for lunch for 16 wings and 2 bacon cheeseburger 2 beers was good not $81 good will not return no wonder people aren’t going back out now that’s price gouging I know you have to make it up but come on that’s overkill sorry 😣
Great old fashion and wings .. the mac and cheese is a delight for the tastebuds .. seating is beyond adequate for each size of group you wish to bring .. service and staff are quick and precise.. great place
Terrible food. Terrible service. Onion rings tasted frozen. Chicken wings were gross. Waiting on the server for the past 37 min...I want a drink, or just my bill so I can go eat somewhere else.
Food was good. Service was a little slow but ok. Great beer selection.
The waitress was a bad one...I think she was new and inexperienced. The food however was delicious and on Sundays they have an amazing offer in buffalo wings.
Beautiful venue for a bridal shower.
My favorite spot after work
Brunch was great and the staff was excellent our drinks were always full
The food was delicious atmosphere was very welcome me great customer service the drinks all day you good for breakfast or brunch specials
Crowley burger was cooked as ordered and side order of sweet potato fries,delicious. service was good. A good selection of beers.
Total reviews rating 4.2
199 Reviews for Croxleys Ale House - Farmingdale 2023:
Review №1
2022-04-29So I remember coming to this place quite a few years ago on a couple of occasions and enjoyed the food here. Wow tonight was a MAJOR disappointment. We ordered takeout this evening and all I need to say is the the food was not that great at all...And on top of that, I had specifically asked for a specific type of burger. Did not get it and noticed when I picked up. So they prepared the new burger (at no additional cost), but this was still the wrong burger asked for. On top of that the tater tots were not ordered either the way we had asked them for it and they were quite soggy.I would not recommend coming here for food. If you are young and enjoy sports, good atmosphere for you. Not a family joint.
Review №2
2022-01-26Wow was the food disappointing! Went last night for my friends birthday. We both ordered 1 drink each and each had the boom boom chicken sandwich. The drinks were good. The sandwiches on the other hand were below sub par. The chicken was a frozen round chicken patty not a breast or even breaded tenders for that matter. No seasoning. We were going to get dessert too but the sandwiches were so bad we decided to leave and just pick up cookies from stew Leonard’s. The check was over $60 with tip for 2 drinks and 2 frozen chicken Pattie’s with a handful of fries.
Review №3
2022-06-01Great bear menu, tons of good choices on tap! I really dont like wings, they are usually passé, but last week I was here with a large group and we ordered 5 orders with sauces on the side. WOW, for the first time in years, I actually enjoyed wings. Crispy, not greasy and cooked perfectly. The sauces we ordered were a mix of flavors and they ranged from OK, to delicious to pretty damn hot.For dinner I ordered a burger, and it was good too. Likely a frozen patty, but not overcooked and done nicely!Minus one star because the restaurant was understaffed for a quiet Wednesday and service was pretty slow.
Review №4
2022-04-01Holy cow, dont list an item on your menu if you have NO idea how to make it. The old fashioned was probably the worse Ive had. Whiskey, water and a random orange slice is a terrible excuse. So I asked for a jack and coke, I could read the entire menu through this drink. Not only was the bartender giving an attitude about it, the waitress was reflecting it. I give them a two star because the bar looked clean and up kept. Wings were a tad dry here among 7 of my coworkers. We wont be returning.
Review №5
2022-07-05The front door staff member was very rude and discriminating towards my service dog. She was at my heal and was acting appropriately. The man would only consider outside dining. Even though I wanted to sit outside, I have the right to sit indoors with her as well.The only reason for something to be said would be if she acted out of turn.While at the restaurant, my girl was calm, at my feet, did not react to the people around, the train horn, nothing.As such, employees should receive additional training in understanding the ADA. You may not deny access, or ask a person their disability, but you can ask for the animal to perform basic commands. Not all disabilities are visible, and it is not their job to evaluate a person.
Review №6
2022-06-06Been awhile since Ive been here. Was a quieter night stopped in for a drink and wings. Fig old fashioned was just ok. But the traditional habanero mango wings were amazing! Food came out quick and hot. Will come back just try a diff drink
Review №7
2022-07-01Was good 2 years ago but since has doubled in price. The food isnt good anymore. The bartenders have absolutely no idea how to make most drinks. My friends asked for gin gimlets and they put soda or seltzer in it. And when we got the receipts for the bar, my friends Jameson and cokes were 16$ and they werent doubles. He was also charged for a double when he got a single. Its gone downhill so bad.They also added popcorn shrimp to their menu a while back and my friend who is allergic to shellfish started having an allergic reaction because they fried the cheese curds and the popcorn shrimp in the same oil.
Review №8
2022-03-27Food was top notch, perfectly cooked burger. However, I was not happy that a $9 regular IPA came in a tiny bourbon snifter. I know that double and imperial IPAs come in smaller glasses but I dont order those. My wifes Montauk Wave Chaser came in a small glass too. Your food was great but I wouldnt come back until you use pint glasses again.
Review №9
2022-07-04A tremendous place to watch sports. Great amount of quality beer selections. Clean comfortable and Matt the bartender is sincere genuinely caring and has a great attitude.we will be back
Review №10
2022-03-03I call on football sunday, to get the so called “best wings in the world” and come to find out you guys don’t take reservations that day, or atleast according to the girl. I had to walk in and when I arrive I have a 30 minute wait for a table!! After waiting 10 minutes (but what felt like forever) I was finally sat and brunch was already over. This place is so unorganized… I will NOT be returning!