Hands down the BEST pizzeria restaurant in town. The food here is so well prepared and it’s DELICIOUSLY prepared Italian food. Everything was packaged in individual boxes- not foil, and the ingredients used were top notch. I almost can’t even believe it because so often I’ll order the same exact food from other places and it’s not a quarter as good. Definitely my new place to dine for good.
I ordered a chicken vodka wrap 20 minutes before my lunch break. I go to pick it up and I’m standing there waiting for another one 20 minutes waiting for my wrap so now I don’t even have time to really enjoy my food because my break is just about over. I go to pick up and eat it and it is completely swimming in watery vodka sauce. Absolutely disgusting. The wrap was all soggy and gross I ended up just throwing it in the trash after a couple bites. I will never go back here
Great thin crust pizza. Gormet level of pizza, from a place where you can get individual slices. Started to order plates food from them, not just pizza and it’s is fresh and delicious. Bomb chicken parm, the chicken doesn’t taste like it’s been sitting in the fridge prebreaded for 3 days. Really great food all around. Went there by mistake when I was at Citibank across the street and now I won’t let my family order delivery to the house from any other pizzeria.Please open a sit down restaurant.
Pizza is amazing, the calamari is incredible. You get a shoebox full of it. Really awesome place.
Just had a great Shrimp Parmigiana Hero. Took a chance, ordered online. It took a little longer then expected but the weather is crappy. The food arrived hot and tasted great so no complaints. I will order again
It was good in a beginning but I will never get pizza there. It looks like nobody cares about how pizza looks and taste anymore. My last pizza from this place make me fill sick because it was poorly cooked. Too much acidity.
One of my favorite pizzerias on the island. The chicken bacon ranch slice is out of this world. They also make made to order calzones which are incredible. Would highly recommend a trip.
People talk about which pizza is the best on Staten Island, Joe & Pats or Deninos (Joe & Pats is better). However, the best pizza on Staten Island is Domenicos, perfect crust and large slices (if you eat inside if you get delivery theyre smaller)
We ordered a Sicilian pie and the pie was not fresh tested frozen .. never again.. ✔️
I try many different pizzas on the Island and I have give you guys a 5 STARS ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. The mozzarella pizza was delicious.
Ordered chicken parm it was delicious!!, perfectly made!!. Tomato Sauce was tasty, chicken cooked perfectly. The girl there that took my order was really nice too. Best chicken Parm I had on Staten island yet.... Definitely my new spot.
Love there service, There food is the best for pizza and really clean place
There are two domenicos on Amboy. I discovered this by accident through seamless. Suffice it to say this is not the good one.The order arrived 30 minutes late. And the delivery driver sat outside for a few minutes twirling his phone charger in the car. The food that was ordered was not what was expected. The neopolitan was a plain cheese pizza highly marked up. And the grandpa pizza was the exact opposite from what I expected at the other location. Not to mention the meatball toppings tasted more like sausage.Note to self. Check the address and dont order from this one.
Good service, Delicious pizza. Tried some thin crust and vodka slice it was real pleasure for taste buds.Will definitely come again.
Everytime I eat from here its an overall great experience. They also have fast delivery. I love ordering the buffalo chicken pie because the flavor and consistency are both awesome.
The pizza and service is great. We are enjoying their pizza. The fried zucchini and eggplant knots ar not to oily and delicious .
Good pie regular pizza could have a little better on the pizza service was fast7.2 pizza
Just moved to this area - matter of fact I live a block away and I love the pizza...one slice is enough to fill you up! Delicious sauce, great service...the rolls are excellent too!
Workers are not wearing masks ,and they were coughing all over the food, they gave me covid 19 , do not eat here
This was the best pizza I had in 20 years since moving to Staten Island! Bravo !
Thank you for the order guys, gracia! 🙏🙏
We ordered a #4 pizza for my little guys bday and it was perfect! Taste amazing also 😋
The pizza is good. The staff is nice and friendly. I eat in. But the dining area is small.
Everything is blend no taste at all far from the best i would not really recommend so far the best pizza on the island is on new drop lane there is family run restaurant great pizza and overall good food
Margarita🍕pie was delicious, excellent lentil barese, as well as the fried calamari...cheesy bread as an extra! ..Thanks for the Friday night feast!
Great place chicken parm hero 🔥 good portions excellent quality
Good Pizza. Excellent service.
Best pizza in the area! I am surprised it does not have more 5-star reviews
Food is a 5/10 and the prices are outrageous plus there a surcharge on debit cards like we live in 1986 bunch of scam artists
Its not like they have one thing that is really good. A true gem. You can order anything and it will be fantastic.
Good pizza, thin and delicious, plainty parking, friendly staff. Love it
Domenicos is excellent and their food is delicious....if you havent tried them yet, I would highly recommend them
I was told 20 minutes for a pick up. Got there 25 minutes later to stand there for an hr and get cold food. After the guy told me it was coming out of the oven as we speak.
Awesome pizza and by far the best pizza I had since I moved from my home town Chicago
This a place to go! highly recommended, pizzas are fresh just great
Excellent white pie with a good amount of garlic and oil (for garlic lovers).
Pizza was tasty, but the customer service is very poor
Pizza is bomb. Buffalo chicken is bombAnd i love that salad slice and grilled chicken ranch and bacon. Oh my god.
What happened pizza use to be pretty good. Save the wait and just buy yourself a frozen pizza.
L&B was really good, definitely get it if youre here
Good local pizza joint. Price point is a little high. But worth it.
Best Vodka pie on the island!! Everything is always fantastic and fast!
A good neighborhood pizza place. Not much room, they focus more on delivery and pick up.
Best pizza on the south shore . love their pepperoni rolls😋
There pizza is good. The broccoli and kitchen slice is very good.
Pizza is very good but delivery is terrible. Over an hour and a half on several occasions.
Orderd fried calamari it had glass in it! Called to complain the said it couldve came from the packaging ??? Really! Glass!! I couldve died!! Ridiculous 😡
Fast service and great staff and very clean pizzeria.
Best Pizza on this side of Staten Italy. Vodka pie with chicken or get the peperoni bites!
Pizza and wings are awful. Tastes worse than domino’s pizza.
Good pizza and Italian food at fair prices.
Really good consistent pizza. Great 2 pizza deal
Great tasting pizza good verity
Excellent Chicago style pie. Sauce a little on the sweet side
Honestly worth every penny, the quality is portion is amazkng
One of the best in S.I. Always a good meal. Recommend.
Its the most best pizza place in the world🍕🍕🍕🍕🍝🍝🍝
Fabulous food. Over-priced fountain sodas. Kids love it.
Excellent pizza one of the best on the island!
Love this place and the staff is always nice af! Thanks and keep doing what you do.
Great Pizza. Chicken wings are amazing.
Good food. Typically wait is 20 minutes.
Quick delivery food is always delicious 👍😎🇺🇸
Great food, friendly staff
Great pizza & super nice
Great food a d friendly service
Very Fast Delivery and Great food.
Never back again,do not drill here, check the box!
Great food and quick service
Really good food nothing but the best!!!!!
Best pizza in the area
I guess I dont have much to say about it. Its okay.
Always great, large selection!
Good Pizza,,, Fresh Ingredients
Great neighborhood pizza place
Good hero
Really great heros and pizza
Great place food fantastic
The pizza is delicious!
Type good
Very nice and clean.
Amazing.
Awsome pizza!
Great food!
Pizza was Awesome
Great pizza
Good pizza
Good pizza
Love this place
This is epic.
The place is so clean the workers are amazingly nice an the food is excellent....
Small space, awesome pizza!Their Buffalo pie is the best eva!
Total reviews rating 4.2
102 Reviews for Domenicos Pizza & Pasta 2023:
Review №1
2022-08-02Pizza is fantastic and the hot heros are absolutely delicious. The Domenicos Special hero and the Chicken Francese hero are 2 of my favorites. Ingredients always taste fresh. Owner and staff are very polite and friendly and delivery times are quick.Im extremely satisfied with this business and will definitely continue to be a repeat customer.
Review №2
2019-10-03Ordered through Grubhub. Arrived on time. Food was excellent. Pizza was cooked perfect. Vodka sauce was amazing!
Review №3
2020-11-30Ive been ordering here since I moved to the South Shore last year. Excellent food! Soooooooooo delicious!!! Whenever I call, the staff is polite and professional. The delivery always comes within a reasonable time. Definitely my go to spot!
Review №4
2021-08-16I was so excited to show my British husband NY pizza for the first time. We were visiting from out of town, and got him a decent slice in Manhattan. It just didnt feel EXACTLY like I remembered as a kid. My grandmother suggested here. We picked up 2 pies. It was EXCELLENT. Like I promised NY pizza should be. My husband was thrilled with the friendly banter and the pizza was so fresh,cheesy, delicious. Thank you very much. When visiting we will go every time and always reccomend.
Review №5
2021-11-22Domenicos never disappoints. Their hot heros always tasty and fresh. One of my favorites are their crispy delicious wings. No one seems to get it right but them!!
Review №6
2022-06-03Its takeout only. Awesome round pie, and great meatball Parmigiano!!
Review №7
2021-02-20The entire staff, especially Chris (the MVP) were so polite and helpful. He even carried my pizzas to my car and was super patient with me. I had never gotten food there before but my mom was at the local hospital and I am so grateful I chose Domenicos for their proximity but learned that they have a lot more going for them than that. The security staff at the hospital and the ICU staff were pleased with their pizzas and I thank you greatly for all you did to get my order ready even more quickly than I was told. My mom loved the eggplant parm hero I got for her (and not just because it beats hospital food lol)
Review №8
2020-06-15The Grandma pizza with fresh mushrooms is delish!!The Chicken bacon ranch isthe most deliciousBite as well. We eat here often and can honestly sayThis is the best pizza on the South side. Very freshand always great. Worth every penny.
Review №9
2019-10-10Had no issue with the food itself, however they gave us a completely different order. When I called to complain they said they will send the driver back right away and I should meet him in the main lobby. After half an hour of waiting I called back and they were closed. Chris, (The Manager) did call me back a couple of days later. He was very polite and provided great customer service. I live on the North Shore of Staten Island but any time Im on the South Shore and I am feeling for some pizza I will most definitely consider Domenicos Pizza.Would recommend this restaurant.
Review №10
2018-12-21We just love your pizza. The crust was nice and thin. Just the way we like it. Also, your workers are very a professional and quick. We will definitely come back for more.