Outdoor seating
Yes
Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe in Patchogue
Categories
Location on the map
Patchogue, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Payments
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Phone: +1 631-730-7002
Site: http://donatinapizza.com/
Site: http://donatinapizza.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–11PM
- Saturday:11AM–11PM
- Sunday:12–9PM
Comments (198)
Such an amazing place for delicious gluten free pizza! Service is friendly and the food comes out relatively quick. They also have a good selection of soft drinks. Overall a great place for gluten free Celiac safe pizza.
Cant believe this was here 2 years and didnt know how amazing it was. Mike, the owner was awesome and accommodating with suggestions. I need to go back to try everything on the menu
First time I’ve ever had scratch made GF pizza instead of some frozen junk and they did an amazing job, no cross contamination issues, and also have DF options too. Easily my new go to restaurant
My favorite is the Detroit style pizza, got 3 slices of them. At work I warmed them up and was salivating; I took a few bites and needed a drink because it was so salty. The tomatoe sauce was way to salty. I had a few sodas and water so I enjoyed eating them with plenty of drinks.
Delicious 12 wood fired gourmet pizzas. I really enjoy both the Arugula and Caesar Salads. Casual and nice atmosphere, with great wait staff. A new favorite.
If you want true NY pizza, be sure not to opt for a slice. The drink offerings are top notch.
Donatina in response to your reply to my husband regarding not doing 1/2 and 1/2 toppings on a Neapolitan pizza and calling out my statement as false- I would like to correct you and show you in fact I got this twice before and enjoyed it but you were absolutely not willing to satisfy a guest and literally fine with guests leaving your restaurant hungry and unsatisfied. I will attach a photo so you can correct yourself and see my statement is in fact 100% accurate and your pizza with 1/2 and 1/2. Very sad situation- you should be customer obsessed and accommodate such a small thing. I would be willing to discuss this further with you by phone or in person if you do in fact care about customers and having a favorably image in the community.
Love their Detroit and tried the special speck pizza with pesto.
This is my second review and Im editing the original one. It took a year to try Donatinas again after last visit. They had servers this time and presented their appetizers before the main entrees. We ordered the italian chopped salad that was very fresh but overly dressed. Too much vinegar so they got 4 stars for that. But their potato & bacon pizza/sausage & cherry pepper pizzas were the best pizzas Ive eaten since I went to Italy! Scrumptious! ..I highly recommend Donatinas...
Great place , brick oven pizza was delicious and the deep dish chicken ranch was awesome, definitely tasty and quality food, nice location and plenty of choices when it comes to pizza 🍕 will be back again !
We had the burrata pesto pizza and it was delicious! Their crust is so good. Service was great too. Lots of pizzas to pick from.
I have not ordered a slice of pizza that wasnt delicious. The place is spacious, clean and were always given outstanding service. I come from the north shore to eat their pizza. Awesome.
Incredible pizza. Ive been to all the brick oven hot spots in the city and can appreciate good pizza. This place is up there with the biggies. The thing I love about this place is along with the brick oven pie they offer a regular slice as well as the Detroit slice- a deep dish work of art. Good beers as well as other tasty menu items make this a great restaurant.
Absolutely insane. The absolute best Gluten Free pizza Ive had in ages. Extremely nice staff, super sociable.
Wow wow wow! It is not often we are excited and then blown away by a local pizza place. This place knows what they are doing and all of those amazing descriptions deliver! I was thrilled that they had vegan options too! Also, the person who answered the phone was extremely nice and helpful when asking about ingredients as someone in my family has a food allergy. This will now be our go-to pizzeria!
Food is fantastic. Best Chicken Parmigiano out there. Prices are very reasonable
Gluten free Sicilian is the absolute best gluten free pizza Ive ever had.
This was a great place to sit outdoors and enjoy pizza. The place has a great atmosphere and a wonderful menu. Enjoyed every bite. Will definitely go back!
This has to be one of the best places for pizza and other things..I had the teriyaki pizza.. it was delicious...2nd time I had the mushroom pizza.. again no disappointment there...3rd time Sicilian..3 time track record!!
Such a hidden gem!My family and I placed an order over the weekend for the first time and we were so pleasantly surprised! We tried a few of their different Neapolitan Pizzas and were amazed by how delicious they were. Im already looking forward to ordering again - it was that good!
We love Donatina! Best Gluten Free deep dish pie on LI! Maybe anywhere. Clean and comfy, friendly service, free parking. We are so glad to be back in Patchogue!
Me and the family really enjoyed the Detroit Pizzas! We have tried alot of different Pizza restaurants however this place is really awesome!Think really Crispy!John the owner was a great guy to talk with and everyone was so nice !Great Parking too!Inside is totally Mint and very clean!A PATCHOGUE GEM!Highly recommend!
Its our families new pizza spot. The atmosphere is perfect, the staff fantastic, and the food? Forget about it! High quality toppings on the pizza, genuine Italian ingredients, I cant say enough. My kids love the authentic oven which Ive heard was expensive and from Italy herself. Just try it and youll see.
Brought my family here to show them what i thought was a really great new pizza place. we were not able to sit together and the owner was very rude when we tried to move a couple of chairs around to accommodate our entire family sitting together. we left, and went to one of the other many fine restaurants in the Patchogue area. this place isnt as great as the reviews make it sound. pizza is good, but within 1 mile there are 3 other pizza places that are Just as good, with better service and a much more consistent track record.
Wow, delicious pizza! Everything from regs to Long Island Clam pies, you wont be disappointed! And the Dessert pizza put a huge smile on our little girls face! Would eat again!
The pizza is DELICIOUS, I will say that! But I will absolutely NEVER give this place my money again after the way the owner treats his employees. I watched him smack his employees hand with a spatula looking thing after the employee asked him a question. DISGUSTING.REPLY - The owner, behind the bar (tall Italian man) was the one who smacked the employee (who was a shorter Hispanic gentleman) on the hand/wrist after he asked a question about a ticket. We were standing in the take out section while watching this.
Solid pizza, read about this Donatina in a Long Island magazine and had to take trip and grab a few slices. The pizza was average the staff was bla with little personality. I wont make a special trip that way again but glad I gave it a try.
Food is really good. Staff is very nice but perhaps needs training. I came in on my birthday with about a total of 15 family members. We were planning to grab some pizza & walk the town. The restaurant was completely empty however, the young lady wouldnt allow our family to sit in the main dining area. She was told that her boss would be upset about it. I asked her if i could speak with him because we just wanted people to be able to sit down, and was told that she would have to call him? I have a disabled parent who had to be placed on the end of a table with her wheelchair and in everyones way due to not being to sit down together.If the restaurant had been busy, I would have not pushed the subject, but the staff did see how frustrating it was to me and my family and didnt do anything to fix it. I would go back, but I know better to not bring a big crowd with me as they were unable/unwilling to accommodate.
Im a real pizza fanatic.This is the best pizza Ive had on Long Island by far.This place is on the next level.Unbelievably good.Perfect Neapolitan pizza.The crust is light and airy.The sauce is delicious.We also ordered meatballs and they were excellent as well!Just do yourself a favor and go to Donatinas.You will not be disappointed.Highly recommended!A+++
Amazing crust and original/creative pizza choices. We were introduced to a delicious honey pepper infused topping for the Detroit Pizza. It was outrageous! This place takes pizza to a whole new level. Friendly place/service. Nice selection of beers/wine. Going back for the ham & fig pizza next week. Oh, and best Spumoni ever!
Finally tried Donatinas last week and have returned 3 more times already. The food here is amazing. The Detroit style slices are a must have though everything Ive had has been great..
Best gluten free pizza I have ever had and it’s really not even close! Probably compares favorably to most other place’s normal pies.My family loved the normal pizza as well- I could only imagine how good it is!
Absolutely fantastic pizza place. They are walk up and dine in. The detroit slices are a style I wasnt familiar with but wow I keep coming back for it. Also the garlic knot crust slice is a perfect slice for people that love the classics
First time I have been here. Drove by many times. Glad I went! Food is really good. The pizza was delicious, with imaginative creations and combos. Delicious Italian food. Good beer and wine. Service was friendly and attentive. Definitely worth stopping by.
We had calamari fritti, nice light coating and very tender and we tried the Detroit pie which was excellent. Usually we dont go for thick slice but I had heard from a lot of people and it didnt weigh you down like most Sicilian belly bombs and the sauce with a little kick was Devine.Our waitress was so sweet, knowledgeable and helpful.I would highly recommend.Cant wait to go back and try some others.
I recommended to my wife trying this pizza place in Patchogue that I read about figuring , hey what the hell how bad could it be. Well the pizza was way above expectations. We had the brussel sprouts and bacon and the ham and figs. WOW! The pizza was delicious and the crust was to die for! Although it may seem a bit pricey, it is well worth it. We have already scoped out a few choices for future visits. P.S. They have their own parking lot which is a plus!
My daughter has been telling me how great Donatinas is! So we took the family and I was impressed it was as good as she said if not better!! Definitely going back really soon!
We went for the wood fired pizza, which was totally on point. We chose the L.I. Clam pie, and believe me, it was not an easy choice. The food was delicious, but our server, Joseph made the experience an A+. He was friendly, knowledgeable and attentive, which we appreciated as much, if not more than the wonderful lunch we had.
Whoever said basic is a nimrod. This pizza place is AWESOME. Great styles and variety offered, friendly staff, and great location. Get the pistachio honey pizza... my family loves it.
First time visiting and I’m vegan delicious would definitely recommend to other fellow vegans. Prices are good too. Will be back.
Fantastic meal, cant wait to go again. Real food! Had Lobster ravioli and clams linguini.
Awesome eatery with a large selection of tasty specialty slices. The Detroit style is amazing! Definitely worth a quick stroll if you are hanging out at BP or are out and about in Patchogue. Enjoy
Perfect crust and the right amount of ingredients. Very delicious wood oven pizza.
Owner is rude and could care less about his guests, went today and he refused to make a pizza with different toppings on one side. What pizzeria doesn’t do 1/2 and 1/2?? He actually said right to our faces we don’t split toppings and refused to do it. What a joke- he’s nothing like his brother Scotty that I can tell you. Good luck as my experience will speak volume in the community- this one bad experience can be told to friends, neighbors, relatives, co workers etc, sad that Donatina the owner doesn’t know this for himself. To let a guest walk out of your business over 1/2 toppings on a pizza is quite sad. Went up the road to Satellite pizza in blue point, ordered a small pie with 1/2 meatballs and ricotta and other half with pepperoni and peppers $14 and owner here laughed how they wouldn’t do that here.
I have been gluten free for 10 years. I have celiacs so eating anywhere is pretty difficult. The first time my boyfriend and I went to Donatina, John (the owner) mentioned that they would be making their own gluten free pizza when I asked about their gluten free items. I questioned the fact that they would be making their own crust since everywhere orders the same frozen, hard, tasteless crust and dresses it up.Well, tonight was the night. They started making their own gluten free crust and I was speechless. It was thick, airy, moist and beyond delicious. The dough had bounce to it and if the owner didn’t bring it out directly to me, I would have questioned if it was gluten free because it was THAT good. They are making Detroit styled pizza with it and I couldn’t have been more pleased!John and his staff are completely aware of how serious celiacs is and took every precaution to make sure my meal was safe.I am so thankful Donatina has joined the delicious Patchogue restaurant family and are offering such amazing options for celiacs like me. Thank you, Donatina!
Im so excited to have this place in town and looking forward to see what theyre going to do once theyre fully operational! This is the perfect place that Patchogue needed and theyll be serving up late night pizzas once theyre up & running which will be great.We came in last weekend after recommendations from friends for their soft opening. Honestly, it was fantastic brick oven pizza. Although they had a limited menu and were taking cash only, there were SO many options for pies, focaccia, and an open face calzone.We tried the Brussel sprout/bacon pie, the chicken caprese, and the cabonara pie. All of these came out quickly and HOT and were de-freaking-licious. Im looking forward to trying something new out tonight.
Pizza is not bad but the nickle and dime mentality towards their buisness is rediculous. A 3 inch pepperoni pinwheel cost almost a dollar more than a slice of pepperoni pizza and it doesnt come with a small cup of sauce thats a dollar more.... always have an issue when i go here. This is the last time i stop heree. seccond worse pizza joint in the neighborhood, next to del-fiore. the two most terrible pizza places on long island, and they are a mile apart from one another.
Amazing Detroit slices. Awesome original topping combos, and these slices pass the stand up test! Cheese is ON POINT. Prices are great, and the service is fantastic. A new favorite!
Really good pizza,I will definitely going back.I would recommend stopping in to try out there pizza..
Great place. I love the bacon chicken ranch slice. All food is fresh. Place is quiet n clean.If u like crunchy crust, get the Sicilian slice.
Amazing place super clean smells amazing got the Mozzarella sticks and those are One Of. A kind 100% percent recommended coming here.
Best pizza on long island with a great atmosphere you can run in to grab pizza to go, sit causally or you can sit for a date night. Staff is amazing and ontop of everything !
People working there Super Nice! Food Amazing! Nino is the best pizza maker in the world! A must go! Detroit Pizza Unbelievable! You will love this place.
Sat at the bar. Nice and warm and cozy. Pizza was incredible. Jimmy was phenomenal. Young guy, respectful, mature. Way ahead of his time. I will definitely be back.
I just experienced the most incredible Gluten free pizza EVER!!! The dough is made HOMEMADE onsite! Thats right Folks! No more frozen GF pie crust for us 🤗 Donatinas Chefs hit a tremendous home run with this pizza!MOLTO BENE! Grazie!!!! ❤🍕
Having to make an unexpected pick up at the Patchogue Railroad Station, I can only hope it happens again because I discovered Donatinas!!! 18 West Avenue, this little gem packs Italian flavor into every bite! I enjoyed my one slice of their Sicilian Pie. (I can not eat more than one by medical choice, otherwise, Id have a pie going home in my car!!! How a foodie like me got lucky to suffer from stomach disease is so unfair. But I make the best of it by limiting the quantity and steering clear of foods that bring flare-ups. This pizza has to be the lightest, most airy crust I have ever tasted. They advertise cooking it in a Marsal Deck Oven. Now there were many decadent choices, but as it is Good Friday, I kept this simple. But the Ham, Taleggio and Figs pizza looked terrific. Nonnas Meatball and Ricotta with spicy garlic tomato sauce and fresh basil, well need I say another word. Patchogue has become a haven for food and cocktails. Parking can be challenging, but there are several lots. The excellent news is Donatinas is at the west end before you get to the main trafficked areas, so park your car in their lot and bring your appetite!!!! Bella, Bella!!!$
Great pizza and great staff!
Was there once before. It was ok, the server was nice though. I had seen a couple of weeks ago that they have Detroit style so I figured I go back. Went today - a Saturday about 8:40 PM Walked in, pretty empty, about three full small tables, three to four at the counter, two servers, guys making pizza, two other guys behind the register. The guys behind the register were involved in a conversation with about four costumers - not taking orders, not handing them food, just talking. I was standing near the tables waiting for someone one to say hello, sit anywhere, sit here, can I help you etc.. anything. After 4-5 minutes, the servers went to a table, back the the register, to two people at the counter, back to the register, staying at the register, talking between themselves, but never looking up. They never even looked around to see if the people already seated needed anything. The one at the register finally glanced at me but just turned right back around to the register, the other server just kept talking to her and she gave me a glance but also never acknowledged my presence. after a few minutes of this I told myself that I would give them two more minutes. If no one said boo to me I would leave. The guy at the register stayed in his conversation, the guys making pizza understandably kept making food - not their job to help the costumers, and the two servers never gave me another glance. So looked at my match, two more minutes have passed so I went up to the register and told them I was sorry to break up their conversation but I’d been standing there for five minute - it was more - and no one’s even said hello or have a seat or anything. I’ve seen this kind of thing before. It’s big in the old time city deli/lunch counter places where the workers never look up to see if the costumer need any help hoping to do less work. Also some business once they believe they got this, they adopt this behavior. I worked in retail for a long time and have zero tolerance for this kind of thing. Anyway, when I finally broke up the conversation at the register the guy behind the counter started to come out but I told him forget it. I thought to myself that every business I’ve been to that acts like this doesn’t stay in business long so I told the guy that I would make sure to visit after they’re out of business. Not going back.
At home quarantined with family members and social distancing.....the best 6 pies I have had in Patchogue in a long time. I live right up the block and out of work. Thank you for making it worth the purchase!!!
Best wood burning margherita pizza I ever had.Jhon great family man.House wine is delicious and I cant wait to go back for more food.
Excellent pizza, as in NY but just round the corner. Very nice ambience and people. One of our favorite places on LI.
Pizza was pretty good! Italian classic rock was the icing on the cake.
Awesome place; great location. Great pizza ... best spot in patchogue. Relaxed.. 1130 am a great time to go with a little one lol. Had the whole place to ourselves
The pizza is absolutely delicious.... reminds me of pizza we had in Italy!The gluten free pie is amazing as well!Can not wait to visit again.
Amazing wood fire pizza, and the deroit is out of this world. fantastic staff as well. They use great ingredients with alot of variety of italian meat and cheese
CELIACS REJOICE! GLUTEN FREE Sicilian Pizza was delicious. This restaurant will definitely be one of our go to places for pizza.
Great new spot in Patchogue! We had the truffle parmesan fries and the pesto burrata pizza, both absolutely delicious. Well be back again soon to try more! 🍕
I do qwikride and this is my spot for quick food always delicious and the pizza u wont find anywhere else .. definitely worth a stop in
Delicious hand made pizzas...wonderful staff too!
The pizza was weak, buffalo wings were small, truffle fries were drowned in rosemary. But doordash made good delivery time.
All I can say is amazing pizza. Just had the clam pie and it was delicious!!! Will definitely go back.
One of the BEST places I have ever been to. Love it! Detroit Pizza.. Kills it and I LOVE the truffle wood fired pizza! Go to this Gem....
Excellent!! Go enjoy the different food & the IPAs if your a beer drinker. Definitely going again!
Absolutely delicious...the dough was perfect with just the right crunch! Will definitely be back...thank you for making real brick oven pizza.
My go to spot for late night BEST pizza - and Im from Brooklyn !!
Loved it here! Roberto makes pizza like picasso makes art, sit at the bar and be pampered while watching your pizza being prepared.
I went here with my girlfriend and the service was absolutely amazing! The food was delicious, the prices are fair, and the staff is very friendly. I would highly recommend eating here.
Great pizza I had sesame glazed chicken. They put so much meat and very tastee
Just got back and WOW only had Detroit style but was absolutely delicious crunchy full of flavor good price very nice waitress!!
Good food good prices and awesome staff
Excellent service. The Detroit pizza was delicious. My wife loved the open calzone.
I grew up in little Italy Ive had pizza from Lombardis from Johns in the West village from Brooklyn... this little place in Patchogue is as good as the best of New York!
I have been hearing good things about this place and decide to go today. I got there 11:15am today and they were closed and according to the website they open at 11am. Not a good first impression.
The best pizza I’ve had since living in brooklynService was greatWill definitely be a regular hereAna & Jeff f
My chicken parmigiana was unbelievably good. The sauce was just perfect. I definitely would recommend this cafe.
The Detroit pizza was delicious, a little bit salty, but the crust was perfect. Will definitely go back
Great pizza, reasonable prices and a great kid friendly atmosphere. A great addition to Patchogue. A must try!
Great pizza, great vibe! The Detroit BLT is off the charts!!! If you haven’t been you’re missing out!!
Worst pizza and service Ive ever had.completely gave me the wrong slices overcooked
Unique and delicious pizza!! Service was great.
What can you say? AWESOME. Detroit style is amazing . My mouth is watering thinking about that delicious sauce and crust . Woot woot.
Delicious food, wonderful people, great prices. Try the Detroit pizza... Amazing!
Open face brick oven Calzone was out of the park as so was the Detroit style pizza highly recommend it!!!
FRESH from scratch pizza, Detroit crust has a crispy cheese crust. The clam pie is amazing!!!
They offer gluten free options that are as delicious as there regular menu. Staff is wonderful. Go and enjoy
Amazing pizza! Definitely going back.
Excellent pizza and mussels amazing ! Our go to pizza place! I always get the mushroom bressola.....
An absolute destination. Best pizza ive had in years. Spacious and casual. Brick oven
The pizza is amazing. I can’t wait to bring my family. Finally great pizza.
Detroit style was fantastic! Cheesy garlic knots were good, get the sauce with them.
It was awesome as usual. The open faced calzone is the best.
Pizza was good. Didnt have to wait for my pie
Great tasting food, had the arrinchini, berrata and Detroit Pizza with roasted mushrooms
The staff is amazing, the pizza is amazing. Fiannaly Patchogue has great pizza!
To John and all the crew you guys are the best from your food to your personalities thank you always.
We had the Detroit style Pizza with 1/2 meatballs 1/2 olives, we cant say enough good things, probably the beat Pizza Ive ever had.
Great food, fantastic service!
Detroit style pizza very good......other than that, just another pizza place
Its is a lovely place and food is good
Awesome pizza. Not a ton of seating though. Might have to wait.
Great pizza. Detroit style really different.
John and his team have really done a wonderful job with this place. I am currently about to get a pie for the 3rd time this week.
The food was good but it was ruined by the poor customer service behind the counter
Warm and comfortable dining; very fine food...
The Open Face calzone I give 9.5The pizza is a solid slice 7.4
The pizza was ok , however I didnt have a wood fire pizza. The service was ok
Great pizza 🍕 spot! Awesome staff!
My first meal moving to Long Island. Absolutely delicious!!!!!!
Amazing pizza and the truffle fries were delicious! We will be back!
Great Brick oven pizza. lots of choices, a place to go to over and over again
Brussel sprouts and bacon on a pie in a brick oven like that. Cant get better. Little pricey but worth it
Fresh great pizza in a relaxing and aesthetically pleasing atmosphere.
Advertised theyre open till 3am on Fridays, door was locked and lights were off at 12
Best pizza around, my favorite place.
Some of the best pizza I have ever had!
Good food
First time there. Seemed ok will go back give it another go
Awesome Mushroom piece so delicious
Great pizza will definitely buy there
Amazing atmosphere, amazing workers and even more amazing food.
Great food great service great people thanks John, all the best Donn Straight Up Detailing
Wish the guy making the pizza would keep his mask on... everyone else does.
The Best GF pizza I have ever eaten
Very clean.good service.great pizza
Absolutely delicious! So glad to have this place in Patchogue!!
The food was good and the staff was friendly; would recommend.
Good quality pizza.
Pricey but the food is good
Excellent wood fired pizza. Nice crust
Best chicken bacon ranch
Good place and clean also they have wonderfull atmosphere
Good food, a little expensive for a small prosciutto or barrata pie!
The best pizza wood fired oven
Brick oven pizza is excellent
Good food but a very slow service
Amazing food but pricey.
Just had the Detroit pizza! Delicious!
Amazing. A true asset to the patchogue restaurant community.
Awesome place..does not disappoint
Great space for dinner or parties, delicious food!
Great food atmosphere so so
A nice slice
Brick Oven Pizza was delicious...
1 of a kind pizzeria on li NY.
Seriously unexpected goodness. Loved every bite.
Awesome Detroit style pizza.
Interesting twist on pizza with the Detroit style
Very good detriot style pizza
Best of everything all under one roof!
Great food and excellent service
I love the Detroit plain and mushroom
Weak crust. Good flavor
Good food. A bit pricey
Friendly service
Food great and great service.
Amazing Food and People!!!
Food is excellent
Basic.
Hiya, chuck fargione here.
Best pizza in Patchogue
A really good slice
Delicious food.
Excellent food!
Vegan options! 🥰
Love the toppings.
Amazingly delicious!
Wonderful pizza!!!
Great pizza !
Delicious
Fine
Great pizza!!!
Best of everything.
Everything is the best!!!
Over priced
Great pizza
Slowest service.
The staff at Donatinas are not only professional but also polite. Besides the food is incredible. The only gluten free pizza that tastes like pizza. I wouldnt order from anywhere else. Lets just say they go out of there way for their customers !!!
A lot of bread
Total reviews rating 4.5
198 Reviews for Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe 2023:
Review №1
2022-02-11Got a pizza. Great. Also got an eggplant dinner. See photos. Instead of eggplant we ended up with a baked clam dinner which my wife has had before and was gritty then and gritty now. Beyond disappointed.
Review №2
2022-05-27I am new to LI in the last year and I have been searching for the best pizza. Having tried at least 30 NY style joints that all tasted similarly, I finally found a creative and outstanding place. I lived in the Detroit area previously and I was blown away by the Detroit style pizza here. The crust is perfectly crunchy without being heavy or doughy. My family enjoyed both the Brick oven style and also the NY pies. We met the owner who was very friendly and shared his story about how he learned to make these different styles of pizza. I loved the flavor of the sauce and will definitely be going back!!
Review №3
2022-06-11Great place! Stopped in last night on the fly with my wife and sat at the counter near the pizza oven. Watched our food get made and it was delicious. But this was the best part...an order comes in and the pizza chef starts working his magic and for fun I timed him. 5 pies of various types prepped in 3min 59sec, into the oven and while cooking he was getting the boxes ready and adding wood to the fire, 5 pies out of the oven in 3min 29sec. The guy is a machine...the back of his shirt says it all!
Review №4
2021-10-04Very good pizza. Different, tasty. Detroit style, wood oven style, traditional style, you name it, they make it. Good beer on tap, nice little bar. Stop in for a quick bite, you will enjoy it. Its part of Patchogue Village but off to the side. Worth the visit
Review №5
2022-06-29Its OK, thought it was pricey for the small pieces of pizza .Just received a response from the owner which said Thank you , although I appreciate the quick response they didnt address one of my concerns. 2 small pieces of Sicilian style pizza each slice was like half the size of a regular Sicilian slice available at any pizzeria and a regular slice with broccoli 15.00 dollars I think thats way overpriced however to receive a response of Thank you left me to believe review wasnt even read !! If youre going to respond clearly you should read the review or dont bother. Thanks .Edit I responded to response from owner on my original review.
Review №6
2022-06-20Family and I really enjoyed this place during a visit to the area. The place we clean, service was fast AND friendly and the food was really good. We have a few different pizzas and they were all good. The cheese stuffed knots were all good. I would definitely recommend it!
Review №7
2022-02-06The pizza has so much potential. Presentation and texture is great, but it’s so bland. The garlic knots had more taste than the pizza. Which the knots were just as bland and didn’t even taste like garlic knots. Such an unfortunate order.
Review №8
2022-07-01Amazing grandma slices, Chicago style in oven from Italy I believe.Everything is delicious. Love its on outskirt of village easy parking and dont hv to go thru town and deal wit h traffic. Give them a try u wont be disappointed 🌞
Review №9
2022-03-17They make their own Gluten Free Pizza Crusts!!! The only GF crust style choices are Sicilian or Detroit (basically very similar to Sicilian). I almost always get the pesto chicken as a topping. As with any restaurant that isnt wholly GF, Id still recommend taking a Gluten pill (Ive gotten slight cross contamination).
Review №10
2022-04-29I love the environment in this restaurant. Super clean and quick service.