Phone: +1 845-279-9009
Opening hours
  • Monday:7AM–10PM
  • Tuesday:7AM–10PM
  • Wednesday:7AM–10PM
  • Thursday:7AM–10PM
  • Friday:7AM–10PM
  • Saturday:7AM–10PM
  • Sunday:7AM–10PM
Edit info

Total reviews rating 4.2

199 Reviews for Eveready Diner 2023:

Review №1


Excellent orange juice, possibly the best Ive ever had. Eggs Benedict was cooked perfectly to my taste. The frittered French toast looked delightful and my daughter said the waffles were amazing.

Review №2


Our go to diner whenever we’re in the area. Good amounts of convenient parking. Wait staff can be spotty though. Some are good while others are neglectful and do things like seat you next to the restrooms in an near empty diner.Some of the dishes are outstanding like the fried chicken, fries and pasta meals. Chocolate cake is outstanding also. The only thing I’ve ever hated was their pot pie. Chef has a weird take on pot pie…looks and taste like an over salted plate of vomit.

Review №3


Red velvet chocolate chip pancakes are an absolute must. Tasted like cake for breakfast. Good burger and chicken and waffles. A lot of chicken with the waffle and the chicken was bone in fyi. Good prices and friendly staff. Would come back. Just think they should make the chicken boneless with the waffle because you have to pick the chicken off the bone to eat it with the waffle which is a little bit of an inconvenience but the chicken was cooked very well and tasted crunchy which paired good with the soft waffle.

Review №4


I was very disappointed with the outcome of my order this evening. I am retired food industry worker who has worked at all levels of the industry. So i am heartbroken to see the decline in service, quality and acknowledgment of poor food preparation and delivery.I ordered a BLT and had to remove the lettuce. The lettuce is supposed to be the last thing you add to the sandwich and should not be wilted and brown.I took chance and ordered the seafood antipasto. The lesson is mine to learn. The seafood was covered in a opaque film. The shrimp did taste okay- but the scallops were definitely not good- they had a distinct “ foul” odor and sour taste- i did not venture past and had to throw out the entire salad.I also ordered mac and cheese bites and received a side of mac and cheese instead. Oh well i though people make mistakes- but again i tased it and so did my husband( as i thought i was going crazy) the cheese tasted rancid. Maybe they use a three cheese approach- but it still should not taste that way.Thew the whole thing out again. Overall the only good part was my husbands burger was awesome and he enjoyed it very much.Sufficed to say i spent of over 60.00 dollars for a meal for my family- wasted most of it, but lesson learned.Unfortunately i will never order from this establishment in the future. I did call to share my experience: and although the young woman was apologetic; she seemed indifferent.

Review №5


I always enjoy Eveready. Everyone is very friendly, food is always good and portion sizes are always generous.My particular favorite is the Paramount Chicken sandwich. Old school diner atmosphere. Fresh baked breads, great desserts. You cant go wrong.

Review №6


Atmosphere, extensive menu and service have always been excellent. Great selection of salads. I don’t live in NY anymore, but enjoy dinning here when passing through on 84 or visiting my parents in Somers. Just an overall friendly environment and always leave satisfied with a full belly!!

Review №7


A classic Diner, everything was up to par and the famous malted waffle 🧇 was absolutely delicious. Waitstaff was delightful, and Ed was a sight to see. Cant wait to be back again, and wish I lived closer. Enjoy your visit!

Review №8


It was very good: expansive menu, good service, and a cool vibe. The food was very, very tasty to boot!

Review №9


So, I had high expectations. The place was pretty busy. They have enormous plates. Very attentative waitstaff. I unfortunately ordered the chicken pot pie. Ive never gotten something so far from comfort food when ordering a pot pie. It was practically inedible, and I took 90% of it home for my dog since he has no expectations of chicken pot pie. My moms Ruben was delicious as was my grandmothers omelet. I also enjoyed the Pea Soup that came with my meal. Just please, please, please, dont waste 18$ on a disgusting pot pie.

Review №10


Stopped here rather than our favorite Indian restaurant for time considerations. Staff seemed overwhelmed. Food was good, but not worth the delays. Hope they can staff back up, as weve enjoyed dining here in the past.

Other Diner Nearby:
  • 3.8 ·(199)

    Applebees grill bar

    from this place 1 mi

    Wont lie their late night appetizer menu is definitely not as big as it used to be. Got two 5 dol...

  • 4.7 ·(135)

    Bobs Diner Inc

    from this place 2 mi

    Such a cute spot! We had a lovely breakfast with pancakes and a wrap and sandwiches. Really delic...

  • 4.7 ·(199)

    Georges Place

    from this place 3 mi

    Large, yet somehow cozy, this diner has that special old-school, hometown feel to it. My bacon eg...

  • 4.2 ·(199)

    Carmel Diner

    from this place 3 mi

    I was pleasantly surprised at how good the food was here. It tasted better than just your typical...

  • 4.3 ·(79)


    from this place 5 mi

    🥰🤩😍The best, fluffiest omelet Ive ever had! I am so serious too. My waffle... Lordt! It taste li...

  • 4.3 ·(199)

    Putnam Diner and Restaurant

    from this place 6 mi

    Great place with delicious food! Food was delicious and fresh. People are nice and friendly. Co...

  • 4.5 ·(58)

    Danas Diner

    from this place 7 mi

    We are regulars at Dana's Diner but finally remembered to take pictures this time! Food is always...

  • 4.5 ·(80)

    Lous Restaurant Diner

    from this place 7 mi

    A couple of days ago a friend brought back breakfast sandwiches from here, they were delicious! T...

  • 4.5 ·(199)

    Karens Diner

    from this place 8 mi

    I come to Karens a lot. Almost once a week with the wife. Sometimes 2 times a week. Food always t...

Eveready Diner in other cities: