Outdoor seating
Yes
Fisher Bay in Bridgeport
Categories
Location on the map
Bridgeport, Madison County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Delivery
No
Highlights
Great coffee
Yes
Great dessert
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Healthy options
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Planning
Accepts reservations
Yes
Phone: +1 315-633-2244
Site: http://fisherbayrestaurant.com/
Site: http://fisherbayrestaurant.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:4–8PM
- Tuesday:4–8PM
- Wednesday:4–8PM
- Thursday:4–8PM
- Friday:12–8PM
- Saturday:12–8PM
- Sunday:12–8PM
Comments (94)
I was expecting something pretty special. Waitress was terribly slow sat at our table for 10 minutes before they came over and asked us what we wanted to drink. Only about six people at the bar no other tables being used. My wife and I both had sandwiches which for both substandard for a $10 bar food sandwich. Will probably never return
Went here the other week and took our grandparents out for dinner. Absolutely lovely! The service was great, the food was amazing, and we got a great view of the lake while we ate. Would come here again for sure
There were 2 steaks on the menu. One was 1 lb for $21.99 and a 3/4lb for $17.99. I ordered a 3/4 lb steak. It looked really big but I started to eat it. The manager came over and asked how I liked it. I said it was good and reallly big. He said it looked like 1 lb. I said no, it was 3/4. The waitress came by, said she made a mistake and gave me the 1lb. Steak. She never offered to give it to me for the 3/4 lb price. Since I would eat it I decided not to complain. When the bill came it was$24.99, not $21.99. Iaked her why. She said they had the right to change prices w/o notice. I asked to see the manager. The price was reduced to $20.99. Very, very poor customer service.
I always have a great meal here. They have fresh seafood choices, great chicken and steak options, and today I had probably the best chicken parmigiana I have ever had. Great food today capped off with an amazing view of a very placid Oneida Lake. Make this a definite stop on your food tours and adventures!
My sister held a party for her daughter-in-law as a baby shower. The food was excellent and everyone had a wonderful time. The help was very courteous and friendly. Even though it was raining outside Inside it was full of warmth and happiness.
The Fish fry was good. The service was poor. We ordered shrimp cocktail for an appetizer and reminded the waitress when our meal arrived. Never received them until we were done with our meal. We never saw our waitress the rest of our time waiting for our check. Never was asked if our meal was good or if we needed anything. The collard greens were full of sand. Mentioned this to the maitre de and was given some vague poor excuse. We had to track someone else down for the check. I would not waste your time or money.
Very good food, but I was disappointed when my check arrived at the table. The cost of my sandwich was $2.50 higher than the menu stated. The waitress explained that seasonal prices vary. There was a statement to that effect on the menu. I incorrectly assumed it was referring to seafood, not a corned beef sandwich.
This is the best place on Oneida Lake. This is the best kept secret in Bridgeport. The food is always fresh, cooked to order. Never a bad meal. It can get busy, it is family run business so if it is hectic, cut them slack. It is worth the wait.
Great place for banquets as the food is delicious and there is a great deck & patio right on the water to relax on before and after eating. The management always works with me to set up just the right banquet and they are very flexible. Really good home-cooked food!
This is my 5 star go to for my fried haddock dinner! Always fresh and a light batter to die for. To be honest Ive never had a bad meal at Fisher Bay. Prime rib on Saturday is awesome. A place to relax and enjoy the lake view.
They dont require masks which I cant believe because I thought it was mandated by the state. No one in the place was wearing one. The food was good but the place is very dirty. I probably would not go there again
The pizza is spectacular. The location is wonderful. Even though I wasnt thrilled with my meal Id still definitely come back. Friendly service and family friendly too!
We went on a Friday for fish dinners and their fried perch. All was good. Service was a bit slow. Very casual setting. Large windows to view lake if you like.
Food was good and plentiful. Waitstaff was friendly. Chef came by several times including bringing us a sample of an item we werent sure about.
K is a great bartender she has a friendly smile and makes you feel welcome. Owner is friendly if hes in a good mood. Food is tasty and fast service if not that busy. You cant beat the view of oneida lake either.
Stopped in with a group on a Saturday at about 3pm after kayaking, it was a ghost town. Not sure why, because this place was pretty good! Ordered the (quite large) burger medium rare and it was ACTUALLY served medium rare. Be warned: one side of fries is enough for two.
Great atmosphere , amazing food and the owner is a super nice guy . Makes sure he walks around and speaks to all his guests . He even took the time to show me the correct way to eat prime rib with Yorkshire Bread which made it even more amazing then it was !!!
Our 1st time there! Came from across the lake, docked the boat..Cajon scallops and local caught fried perch...yum!!!! Super comfortable atmosphere/felt like family....definitely recommend!!!
Nice little place. The atmosphere had a small town feel to it. The food was great and the prices were reasonable. Really cant ask for more.
Great food and atmosphere. Price is very reasonable and the menu has something for everyone. Great Saturday night prime rib special. I highly recommend.
Decent food at a small cozy lakefront spot. Sometimes if theyre busy youll have to wait a bit as they dont have a large staff but overall good dinner/lunch spot or grab it to go!
Thats where I had the Cajun Perch in a Basket, Saturday Night Prime Rib Special, Beef on Weck, and Fried Clams. They were so good!
Our dinners were delicious. Waitress was very nice. Always smiling.All of the workers were all friendly.
We celabrated our parents 55th Anniversary. It was a special day to remember.
Well Id love to be able to comment on the quality of the food here, but we couldnt get past the extremely rude old woman when we came in that seemed to be trying to get rid of us, after waiting for about 45 minutes in a next to empty restaurant we decided to oblige her.
Prime rib was very good. Service was good even for a table of nine. Everyone in our party enjoyed their dinner.
My wifes Steak wasnt cooked to order and the baked potato was hard. My sea food platter was good.
Was looking forward to trying it but hours were incorrect and food is only available on Thursday, Friday and Saturday.
Ive been to this place, and was impressed with their perch dinner, as it was the first time ordering perch after a day of Fishing from the boat launch in the parking lot.
Pizzas were tasty and good price. Saturday prime rib is delicious.
Love the prime rib on Saturday! Mashed potatoes are homeade and the yorkshire pudding is a great addition:)
Great place for a quiet Quant meal from seafood to a steak. Owner comes around and sees how the meal was . Very personable.
Very good food, nice people. Older setting but nice views of lake and new development. Comfortable and relaxing.
Stay away,you have been warned.
Family restaurant. Owner is very personable. Excellent food. Would go again!
Fried clam dinner is the best I’ve ever had, even growing up in Maine!
Mixed drinks were reasonable price wise,and food was plentiful,we couldnt eat it all.
Good service and great food. Large plates and usually leftovers to take home.😀😀😀😎
Great food and friendly service at a fair price. Would definitely recommend.
Fabulous as always...we love it there, always great food !!!! The four of us
Great service and great food! Fresh water perch was a special!
Great food, great atmosphere, and fantastic customer service!
Great food, great view, and a good place to stop when on the boat!
Great food, great atmosphere, even better prices!
The Haddock Crab special was delicious and the service is great!
Fish not very good and the sweet potato fries were burnt black and tasted it.
Very good food had a wonderful time.
The staff was great & the portions were huge!
Love the Dog! Extremely nice people, great environment, and cold beer.
Great plate food excellent good service.
Beautiful beach n sunset. Loved being with family at their camp.
Beautiful views, great food and service
Sweet potatoe fries were burned and the prices are crazy hi.
Great food great people great place must see
Great service and exceptional food!
Nice view of the lake and good food 🍽
Good lunch! Very tasty.
For a place we Happened to stumble upon, I was very happy
Lorne and Mary make you feel right at home.
Prime rib was very good.
Awesome fish, delivery only.
Always a friendly face serving you.
Good food, good service.
Great people, great food.
The best prime rib around.
Good pizza and wings.
Great food no waiting
The food was delicious.
The perch is awesome ! Great place
It is on the water and the food is great
Amazing perch, great atmosphere
Good Food
Delicious Food.. a must stop
Good food
Pizza is the best!
Love it
Best greens ever ever ever
Very friendly owner
Amazing seafood!
Perch was great
Pricey
Great food
Delicious
Hidden jem.
Total reviews rating 4.2
94 Reviews for Fisher Bay 2023:
Review №1
2022-04-24Had locally caught (fingerlakes) fried perch and it was out of this world, along with shrimp that was some of the best I’ve ever had. The fried haddock dinner was great as well, with phenomenal coleslaw to go along with it. The owners were tending the bar which is where we sat, and they were very welcoming and cordial. Would be back again!
Review №2
2019-04-20Hands down, the best lake front restaurant in the US. 5 star service, 5 star food. Ive ordered multiple times, delivery, dine in and out. Saturday prime rib is to die for. Quality is job 1 for Fisher Bay. I cant say enough for the home town restaurant owned and run by the quality of real American folks. Great food and awesome service. What a treat to find great cooking and a family atmosphere. Felt like I was at home for dinner. Recommend all to stop and say hello to a great place to dine and relax. Hats off to Fisher Bay. Updated menu and pics attached. Thanks again for the great meal and company.
Review №3
2019-05-15What a strange little place. So tough to rate. Dive bar, almost? But the menu was diverse. The perch was excellent. The service was fair to good. The restrooms need a major overhaul and had me scared to eat. Seriously. The smell. The view was fantastic.
Review №4
2022-01-01A new year afternoon at the Fisher Bay will remain a pleasant memory.Warm and wonderful owners.The best pizza to be experienced.and so was the coleslaw and onion rings👍👍👍
Review №5
2022-05-27Yum! Great people! GREAT pizza!
Review №6
2021-06-16Will never go there again! Waste of money and honestly the staff and management are very rude, and disrespectful! I will never do anything alone the lines of eating or and future tournaments for fishing. The older gentleman that owns this place and his wife are straight drunks. If you want a great or even a good place to eat I would never start here.
Review №7
2019-09-14Cheyenne, our waitress today, was so kind, friendly, and professional!! Our food was ok (grilled chicken sandwich/fries and haddock dinner w/fries), but we both wish wed ordered the prime rib, as the guests next to us really seemed to enjoy theirs, and it looked fantastic!! Menu is extensive and kid friendly as well. View was spectacular!! Nice place to stop on the water for a quiet bite with great service.
Review №8
2020-08-02Went for dinner tonight and although I will say our food was very good, there was no regard for the current Covid situation. There was a sign on the door that masks were required, however I did not see one staff member wearing one and many people walked in and out without one. We were seated outside, however any other restaurant I’ve been at with outside seating the staff still had masks on. We did go in to get our table and no one inside had them either. Makes me question what other rules they don’t take seriously.
Review №9
2020-02-29Four of us celebrated my wifes birthday at Fisher Bay last nite, which is a very friendly neighborhood type restaurant and bar with a great menu. This was our second time there, first time for lunch. Two of us got the stuffed haddock and although my wife loved it , she could only eat half there was so much. I got the large order of perch which was fried perfect and it was great. My daughter is vegan and although their vegan menu is limited they bent over backwards to make sure she enjoyed her meal and she did very much. All in all it was a great time and well do it again.
Review №10
2019-04-24What a wonderful family restaurant! Wait staff and owner were very friendly. Had the clam strip dinner. Very tender, fresh, and sweet. My husband had the Cajun scallops. Wonderful and tasty. This was our second time. Definitely will return again!!