Outdoor seating
Yes
Four Brothers Pizza Inn in Amenia
Categories
Location on the map
Amenia, Dutchess County, New York, US
Service options
Kerbside pickup
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Delivery
No
Health and safety
Staff wear masks
Yes
Staff get temperature checks
Yes
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Bar on site
Yes
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Planning
Accepts reservations
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 845-373-8178
Site: https://fourbrothersrestaurants....
Site: https://fourbrothersrestaurants....
Opening hours
- Monday:11:30AM–9PM
- Tuesday:11:30AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11:30AM–9PM
- Thursday:11:30AM–9PM
- Friday:11:30AM–9PM
- Saturday:11:30AM–9PM
- Sunday:11:30AM–9PM
Four Brothers Pizza Inn in other cities:
Comments (198)
Wide menu selection, friendly staff and owners, convenient location with positive ambience. The drive-in theater and mini golf are nice touches as well. Definitely recommend visiting one of their locations!
Everything was Great! We shared the Lasagna and the Chicken Dinners!The Staff was pleasant and Attentive!
#Greek culture #drive-in #wonderland, #mural by Pete Wing, RIP. The Expresso is divine. #feta #personal pizzas #fine food #ambiance
Delicious food, tried the cauliflower crust pizza 🍕 😋 delicious. Great service with a friendly atmosphere.
The MATERNITY ward at Sharon hospitalThank you!!! For wonderful, delicious pizza and pasta ! And beautifully made salad !You have costumers for life !!!
We were in the area to enjoy the fall beauty and tour a historic house, 4 Brothers was suggested to us.It was a very good tip.4 Brothers is a great place for food and relaxing with the whole family. There is the main restaurant with a very pretty outdoor seating area (with heaters for the little chill in the evening air.)There was also walk up food trailer and a charming drive in movie screen.Every thing was bright, colorful and clean.Everywhere you looked were charming decorations and happy people enjoying the company and great food.It was a very pleasant visit and I hope to come back.
Best one of them all. Environment is inviting, food and staff are great.
The food and the customer service was amazing! We will be back to try all the great menu options.
My husband and I took our four young children to four brothers to check out their place for the first time today. We are SO happy that we spent our Friday evening to enjoy the beautfuil land, rides and play sets for the kids, wonderful food, and to top it off a drive in movie! Extremely family friendly and the owners were so down to earth and really care about making your visit a time to remember. I cant reccomend this place any more! If your thinking on visiting, just go for it and you wont be disappointed! Thank you Four Brothers giving my family a new spot to enjoy a dinner and movie.
Great service and tasty wraps. Great after ski lunch.
We have been coming here for years... ever since we discovered the outdoor dining in the summer. Not only famous Four Brothers style family fare, but a genuine garden, replete with all kinds of flowers, vegetables, herbs, a fountain. and beautiful old trees for shade..... all very well tended.Definitely one of our favorite affordable places with atmosphere. The owner has created a wonderful oasis, and it is very child friendly. We love it! :-)
This place has the best pizza and greek salad around, the ingredients were fresh, aromatic and tasted amazing! We left with a bag of fresh tomatoes and 2 bottles of greek dressing. Plus the drive in and ice cream stand are wonderful. highly recommend it
Excellente place for family, there is much to see and the scene is amazing.
Great pizza, great food, great service, and Pete Wing painted the murals in this restaurant.
Higher quality and well prepared food compared to their Pleasant Valley location. Larger restaurant and they do well filling tables. We’ve always been seated immediately. Wait staff is personable and serve professionally. In the past few years, seasonally, they’ve set-up a small drive-in movie screen and a small ice cream stand that we’ve been wanting to try but haven’t had a chance.
I have always loved Four Brothers in NY. I moved to Az 4 years ago and have had family members send me the Greek Dressing. I ordered myself this time and thanks to Four Bros I received my order today!! Excellent customer service
Real good food, professional wait staff. This is a must stop and eat here place for us as we travel on Rt. 22 in N.Y. state. We have never been disappointed with what we order. We love the Greek salad with their signature dressing. The dough for the pizzas is hand made fresh.Their other selections are just as fresh and delicious. They also have an outdoor eating section. They have custard soft serve vanilla and chocolate ice cream + other treats and they have a drive in movie theatre that shows current hit movies of the week on Friday & Saturday nights. Show times do start after the sun sets. Do stop by and give it a try.
We went to this restaurant on Sunday 11/1/20 and their was 9 of us for lunch. Our bill was $172. The problem was, we had bought a cake with us for my brothers Birthday, and when I asked for plates to serve the cake on, our waiter said it would be an additional $9 ($1 per plate) to use the plates!! What the hell is that about! Has anyone ever heard of this happening? We just spent $172!! The other waitress said she had never heard that!! We are there roughly 4-6 times per year! Guaranteed, I will ask that that waiter not wait on us...if we even decide to go back there!!
Amazing place! Top notch service and incredible pizza! Thank you for a wonderful evening with a large group you handled us amazingly.
I love this restaurant! They serve decent dishes, their menu is varied, The chief cook in that restaurant is an expert, I love a lot trying all their food. The food is consistently fresh and tasty, the attitude towards the guests is friendly. I often eat in this restaurant and I not even once was discontended. I recommend it to all.
Stopped in for lunch after an event at the Maple Brook school. Our server was attentive, separated the bills without question, never checked in to see how meals were. Bathroom was clean and well-stocked. Dining room floor was clean and all tables were set. I got the chicken parm with spaghetti. The meal portions were healthy, definitely big enough to get a take home box. Will definitely go back to try other items on the menu.
Good place to stop on the road when youre in the Berkshires. I had the salmon on a salad and it was superb. My friend had the famous Greek salad and it was very good. Service was friendly, quick and competent. Would eat here again.
Good prices on pizza. I also enjoyed the bar, hung out there for a while- its small but they have everything.Wish Id eaten at the restaurant, but I ordered a pick up. When I got there though I realized the place had a really great atmosphere. Might take my family there some time.
I’ve been coming here since the 1980’s and I love that the pizza and decor has stayed the same ! It’s so good and feels nostalgic. It would be great if they stopped using plastic straws and styrofoam to go containers though!
Went to this place back in the summer of 2003. Showed up with about 15 staff members from a special needs Camp about 10 miles away. They were about to close but insisted that we can come in and I told them that we will leave them alone but they insisted. Then they decided to limit the menu because they shut off all of their equipment and we pretty much could only get salads and sandwiches. Nothing cooked because the ovens and fryers were shut off. Then they had the nerve to keep asking me and my 15 friends to leave as soon as possible to try to hurry it up. I was pretty outraged by it. Left no tip considering the service was not very friendly or good. But upon reading these reviews I noticed small town people are making comments about Mexicans working in the back and all these other negative things. It just goes to show that small town America is still a place filled with raging racism and hatred. Perhaps the Mexicans are working there because none of the people in the town are qualified enough to even work at a place like this. Major disappointment both for the restaurant as well as the town itself.
This is our fav date night, a double feature and dinner under the stars. Amenia is a sweet upstate town and Four Bros has it all. Great for kids.. young and old!
The outside dining is very comfortable for social distancing. The atmosphere is relaxing and they serve delicious food. You should stop by and enjoy. We sure did.
I only gave it 4 stars because the Spanish lady who’s the bus lady who picks up all the dishes and what not watches you eat and literally stands by you and waits for u to put the empty dish at the end of the table it’s like we don’t have any privacy to eat! Other then that food is excellent and wait staff is very polite and nice! Owner is very polite as well when he’s here he welcomes everyone!
Depending on what you order here the food ranges from good to very good. One time I ordered calzone and it was excellent, another time I ordered baked ziti and it was a little bland. I havent been here enough to try different entrees to make a very accurate assessment. Nevertheless the prices are very good and the staff is always friendly and very pleasant as is the atmosphere.
Always fun for outdoor dining!
If I could give 0 stars I would I dont know what happened it used to be so good. The last few times Ive gotten food there to go my cheese burger was not cooked it had days old brown lettuce in it, the chicken wrap chicken was hard as a rock, the mozzarella sticks didnt even have cheese inside of them. I kept giving them chances hoping the next time I ordered food it would be better but such a disappointment ever time.
Great staff, good food.. its a really nice hang out spot and the service here is excellent
I remember four brothers having amazing food from many years ago. The sauce is still ok but honestly food not much better than steaming hot reheated diner food. Disappointing, Never coming back.
The pizza here is to die for. Fresh ingredients all around— my favorite is their Margherita pizza. I especially love their cozy outdoor seating area!
Since this place is in the middle of nowhere for me, Ive only been here a hand-full of in the past 8 years when going on the Christmas day Vermont ski trip. Its a tradition to stop by this place on the way up or returning to grab dinner with some antipasta, mozzarella sticks, and a pizza pie.Just last week, we were here completely exhausted from a long ski day, and the smell of brick oven pizza made the whole family wake up. As my friends Dad puts it, this is the best worst thing for you. Even the plain slices taste great without any additions, but it is surely a once-in-a-while treat. Id probably gain too much weight and get clogged arteries - thus is the result of most delicious food. Plus - everything tastes better after hours of driving and skiing.The restaurant itself looks fantastic. The walls are painted to give it an old Roman ruins type of feeling. The lighting makes me feel like everything is yellow-ish tan (which summarizes parts of Italy very well). The staff is attentive and extremely nice - great pizza and even better company. This place will always be a classic and always stay a regular.
Stopped here while passing through looking for a quick bite to eat and was blown away by the service and quality of the food.
We haven’t been here other than the drive in which we love, for a meal in quite some time and I now remember why. The specials offered chicken cordon bleu with garlic potatoes and veg for $15.95 and my husband ordered barbecued chicken for $13.95.We ordered Harney Tea in a pot which came in a mug with a spoon in it, diner style. Nice silken sachet too!The BBQ chicken was tasty but the steak fries were greasy and the coleslaw bland. My cordon bleu was broccoli and cheese and the waiter tried to tell me that was the way stuffed chicken comes! I had to remind him that the special menu read cordon bleu .The vegetables were almost raw hard and the tablespoon of potatoes disappointing. He begrudgingly re-ordered the cordon bleu which was just a premade packaged limp thing served on a bread plate well after my husband was finished. Such a waste of time and money and appetite. No apology although the owner was sitting there the entire time, and no offer of consideration with a dessert or a second cup of tea.We won’t return and should know better - these items wouldn’t be Greek specialties and our waiter was not well informed or well trained, although personable.We’ve had good meals and good service at the Millerton and Gt Barrington Four Brothers.
I certainly enjoyed their dishes and customer service, great area nearby to my residence. The employees are always very kind. Will come visit again.
Ive been enjoying 4 bros for many years. Always had a great meal until today. Ordered the greek salad as always and for a change, I ordered the alla vodka. The lettuce in the salad was old. It was brown and unappetizing to say the least. I mentioned it to the waiter who said it looked bad to him too, as he walked away. No offer to replace it. The alla vodka smelled exactly like beefaroni I ate as a kid, and I ordered it with shrimp. I lifted a forkful of pasta and shrimp and put it in my mouth. They left the tails on the shrimp!! Really?? You couldnt take the tails off of 6 large shrimp??!! I honestly am stunned by my meal and not in a good way. I seriously love the pizza, best anywhere. And, always loved the greek salad. What happened to you? The bagged lettuce has to go! Your cook staff needs to pay attention to details, like taking the tails off the shrimp served in a sauced pasta dish. Youve become complacent with your popularity. Im so disappointed. Youve sold out to convenience and the fast food mentality. What a shame! You used to take pride in serving terrific fresh food. I guess it had to happen, eventually all good things come to an end.
4 brothers is a fixture in the mid Hudson valley region. Really good pizza, salads and Italian type dishes. Other food, not so much (dont bother with the burgers, fish and chips, fried chicken etc). Good place to go for a decent lunch or dinner.
Great service and food and they have a drive in theater too.
Had a very good experience in here with my girlfriend. The food was served quickly and the customer service is just excellent. Prices are reasonable.
Good place... I have been here some other times but today I remove some stars because the waiter (the peruvian guy) need to be more profesional doing his job.In mi opinion and some friends as well, he likes to make the latinos inferior to him... this guy need to be more humble and treat all customers in the same way, because I notice how polite and nice is when there is a white customer, but if he finds someone looking like him (latino) he changes completely into a different sever.
Basic food. Definitely not bad but a bit overpriced. Good for every once in a while
I always leave full and happy. Delicious pizza (I love their crust), and friendly service. We been customers since the 1980s.
One of the worst experiences. The pizza was bland and undercooked and the salad was mostly iceberg lettuce. A medium size pizza and two salads will bring you at $45. I shouldve gone to Montes. Why did I even bother?
Had a awesome experience in here with my daughter. The food arrived rapidly and the customer service is just great. Prices are fair.
The Greek/Italian ambience is kind of bizarre, and I cant tell if its neat or just odd. The restaurant is a very big place, Im good for groups – the food is nothing really special (rather bland).
Good food, good service. Love their pizza. The dressing on their salads is homemade and can be bought to use at home!
Nice place very authentic which means lots of olive oil on the pizza .The decore is some what dated, but the entrees are authentic and well made.
Friendly Staff & Delicious food ! The Carrot Cake is Delish👍🏼 & Dont leave without trying their Greek salad & homemade Greek dressing
It was awesome! The best Greek food ever in NY state! Well worth the four hour drive! I highly recommend this restaurant!!!
Pleasant dining room, service was polite and quick. Food was good, although the Alfredo sauce on the Carbonara was oily and quite heavy.
Good food, nice portions, friendly staff.
Loved the french onion soup. The pizza was okay, medium size is great to share between 2-3 people.
Me and my parents decided to try the out side area where you can get a quick bite so we ordered two hot dogs and a cheese burger all with fries and a drink and when she gave me the price I was shocked I went here thinking it would be cheaper but it cost over $30:00 and it might not seem like a lot to some but I thought it would have been cheaper than going inside the restaurant.
Good food and great service.
Cute outdoor patio, pizza is OK (thick), didn’t like that the person in the kitchen prepping orders wasn’t wearing a mask
We had our own little room for this get together. The food was great and the service excellent!
Wine is served in an airplane style bottle and the calamari was overcooked . Nice clean place and nice wait staff however. Beware they charge you for club soda.
Service and food were great. Booth table was all sticky on the edge. There were lots of dead bugs on the windowsill.
This spot clearly knows how to serve their clients. Always with a kind mindset. The food is fairly priced, always flavorful and neat.
Food was bland, eggplant rolls had no taste, and overpriced, onion rings were good, pita pizza not real good either
Atmosphere is great And drive in was a fun experience. Service was bit slow and unorganized and our dinner order was mistaken with anothers.
Great family friendly place with delicious foodand lots to do. We love the drive in too!!
Exceptional and delicious food, I love the character this spot has, and the workers were friendly. I will definitely come back.
Awful service, food took for ever and when it finally came out it was all wrong, its a shame such a nice place get ruined by awful service
Good food, menu lacking
Great pizza and a good menu of other great food. Always have had fabulous service
Service a bit slow but food was good
Great place for pizza. While its not traditional new York style its still pretty good pizza.
Nice place to eat. Very nice people, great food. Will go there again.
Waiter was extremely rushed, didnt stay at table to hear complete order. Waited too long to receive check.food was adequate.
Probably the best pizza I have ever had. Great atmosphere and very friendly staff.
Delicious food. Beautiful setting and most important, great service (with a smile)
Go there often always find the place clean ,food good,waitress friendly
Cousin and I went for lunch. Both had the broccoli quiche. Excellent!
This place used to be the place to go! But now all they serve is Ginsburg frozen food and over charge you for it a large pizza and a salad is ridiculous!!
Food was good service was fineNice place
Always good food, good serv, and good for the community.drive in movies
Lovely environment and amazing food no matter what you order!
Not good any other time I been it was good service was bad the bbq wrap was over powered by onions and the bbq sauce was soupy not happy with it at all
Omg this pizza is heavenly! Large cut toppings, tasty sauce and a beautiful patio to sit on.
Finally found a place near us that consistently delivers awesome food! Everything is top notch!
Good Italian and Greek food. Generous portions. Very reasonable prices.
Great place! Nice atmosphere! Great staff! They even have a drive-in!
Good mozzarella sticks but okay water
Excellent food, the BEST Greek salad ever & great service@
I live for their Greek dressing! Trust me, its the best in the area!
Nice staff, fast service and consistent quality. You know what your getting and it doesnt disappoint.
Great food. Ate outsides .
Awesome food and service was excellent...
Love the options , can’t beat the drive in ... what can i say ...love my town #Amenia
Great Greek salad and free Wi-Fi in a town without cell coverage. Beer and wine limited.
Great service and great food you guys really need to open a spot in Brooklyn
Amazing food been going there for over 25 yrs
Good food, old decor. Service is great.
Excellent food with a warm and charming atmosphere.
Excellent place been there lots of times very clean and nice people . Ed Gnos
Good pizza and great calamari with equally good marinara.
Amazing Greek salad and deep dish pizza, excellent service.
Hey...It clean area...open and more room...nice people there. Not too crowd . I like it
Nice local diner for Greek style food!
Food isnt as good as the price implies, but it is decent and you can do the drive in next door.
The food is always good and the wait staff is helpful.
The food was fabulous and the place is adorable
Good food. Nicely decorated for the holidays. Enjoyable.
Great local pizza joint with a Grecian touch.
They always have great food and great service.
Stay away. Horrible food and dirty place.
Great food, wonderful service and exceptional ambience....
We went back after a long time service was the worst waited and when he dropped the food off never came back never go here
Stopped on the way home from a day trip. Excellent Food & good service.
Awesome food great service and great setting
Great pizza, cocktails, Greek salad, and drive in movie theater
Quick service, good food. Nice place !
Great food and service was excellent 👍
Great food. Polite staff. Prompt service
Very good food and service. Ill go back.
I enjoy my overall meal experience here.
Love the place amazing really enjoyed it everybody should take a visit
Their rigatoni carbonara is great.
Greeks suck at making pizza. Im sitting in this place right now!!! Go to santos down the road and youll be glad you did.
Food was ok calzone small for 9 dollars
Great food!! And good service
Love the spinach pie , service is great .
Great food! Fun place!
The service is exceptional and the food is great
Our waitress was the best ever
Very good pizza! Good service!
Good food. Wednesday is spaghetti night.
Delicious food and drive in movie theater!
Great pizza,great service!
Great Food. Cozy old fashioned comfort food.
Nice place to eat!!
Good selection fast friendly service
Good food. People friendly
Chicken parmesan delicious
Terrific Greek salad
Good food, great Mexicans.
Good food, great service
Good pizza! Long waiting time...
Longtime pros. It doesnt get much better. Buy some dressing for home.
The best lemon chicken soup.
Go often, love the good and service
Great meal with super service
Good food and great service
Nice atmosphere and delicious foof
It was old school with fake plastic flowers and vines...
Love the pizza and salads
Service was slow food ok
Friendly and prices are just right
Good food in general
Fast service tasty food
Good food and staff
Best pizza ever!
Good food and good service
Good food and good service
Great food.
Best Greek Salad in the world!!!!!!
Best..Food...Period!!
As always, very very good!
Good good and ice cream
Good food !!
Local pizza place for everyone
Staff is friendly and helpful
Loved every bite!!!
Salad and good meal!!
The best
Great people and food
Great pizza and sandwiches
Great place to meet
A really great place.
Very good food
Love this magical place.
Yummy calamari!
Good food.
Cozy and nice place
Great food
Great food
Great location.
It was good
Stick to the pizza.
Beautiful place
Tasty food
Good place
Small place in the town of Amelia, but with delicious snacks and especially with delicious pizzas, the house is delicious, the service very well and the reasonable price, and a classic in the area, but on your way through these villages pass To eat here.
The place is super cozyAnd super delicious everything that is cooked
Total reviews rating 4.3
198 Reviews for Four Brothers Pizza Inn 2023:
Review №1
2022-06-01Excellent crispy base pie style pizza. Dough was soft and crust was crispy. Great pizza with fresh ingredients.The lasagna was satisfying and tasty. Didn’t have much meat but the rich cheesy sauce made up for it. The lasagna sheets were somewhat thick.Overall a nice friendly place for a Friday evening meal. Warm, helpful staff.
Review №2
2021-07-12Dropping my daughter off at camp and stopped for local quick bite and found this place. Basic food nothing special but nothing “bad”. Restaurant depot food warmed up. Pizza was fresh but was not a fan of the sauce but the crust was nice a soft texture wise. Quick and easy but not worth price.
Review №3
2022-05-12First off I want to say they serve the appropriate amount of salad dressing for you to add to your salad. I didn’t have to ask for extra and I added as much as I wanted. The dressing was good, similar to Olive Garden, as was the salad itself. The came out quickly. It was good, better than expected, being at a movie theater, but not a place I would go to unless I was seeing a movie. I had the spanakopita, my boyfriend had the chicken gyro. We also had mozzarella sticks which were really good. I’d be tempted to get two orders to go to nom on while watching the movie.
Review №4
2021-07-22The place is cute. Has a good atmosphere and lots to do. Food is okay, service is good. However, $75 for burgers and shakes for four people is legitimately insane. There are several high class restaurants within a few minutes of this place that you can enjoy a five star meal for that price. If you’re okay with paying 75 bucks for fast food then you will enjoy the experience.
Review №5
2022-06-28The food is really great, we ate at Four Brothers two days in a row. This location has an awesome atmosphere especially for kids with an outdoor seating area, movie theater and kiddie rides. The staff is really great and helped me out after leaving something there -- they went above and beyond to keep it safe and have it returned. Thanks Tom and John and the entire staff!
Review №6
2022-06-22Been going to Four Brothers since opening over 40 years ago. Never had anything other than great meals. Food is top quality, best pizza & Greek salad anywhere & super friendly staff. Billy runs a superb restaurant. Worth the trip.
Review №7
2019-12-29Me and my Mom went in on a Sat night around 8:00 on our way home from NY. There were only a couple of other patrons there. You seat yourself, I grabbed a window seat. The waitress came right away with the menus and drink order. We ordered a small veggie pizza. The pizza was yummy. I had to flag down the waitress for a refill of soda and extra napkins, which I shouldve of had to, as she only had 1 other table. Nice atmosphere, except the fake hanging plants those definitely should be taken down. I noticed they have a small private dining area right as you walk in to the left, and they also have a drive in movie area in mid-winter months. I will definitely be back when in the neighborhood again.
Review №8
2022-05-20Food was good but they were rude about tips me and my friends went but we were a bit too short for the tip and they were nasty and made snarky comments that we didn’t tip the right amount. Plus they told us no when we asked to split the bill….
Review №9
2018-12-16Unbeatable food at unbeatable prices! Friendly staff (mostly young local trainees with about two senior waiters thrown in). Bathroom small but spotless. The venue has a welcoming, homely feeling, and can accommodate larger parties. The vestibule has several local announcements posted, and there are local newspapers/publications for pick-up. There are about four beers on tap, and several on bottle. Prepared foodstuffs are retailed by the cash register. Outside there is ample private parking, and a drop-box for donated clothing.
Review №10
2022-06-26Everyone who works here is friendly and the food is very good. Big shout out to Tiffany and the rest of the folks keeping the customers happy.