Giorgios in Smithtown
Categories
Location on the map
Smithtown, Suffolk County, New York, US
Site: http://www.giorgiospizzeria.com/
- Monday:11AM–9PM
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–10PM
- Saturday:11AM–10PM
- Sunday:12–9PM
Giorgios in other cities:
Giorgio’s is a beautiful place for a wedding. The grounds are beautiful and inside is too. The staff couldn’t of been nicer. Everyone was professional, super kind, and so helpful. Joe was so kind with my 86 year old mom. She was so happy and she felt special. The food was delicious too. My sons wedding was absolutely wonderful at Giorgio’s.
Good evening Giorgios Pizza, I hope this review finds you well... Let’s just get straight to the point... The food was absolutely FANTASTIC!!! I’m not much of a pizza guru but this local establishment has surely changed my mind! I ordered just one pepperoni slice with a soda... Like I said let’s get straight to the point... The cheese was absolutely amazing! Melted, stretchy, creamy goodness! (Unlike Fortunatos Pizza... 🤮❌) Also, let’s not forget about that crispy, juicy, flavorful pepperoni! Absolutely fantastic and I usually don’t even like pepperoni! Now let’s move on to the sauce... The only word I can think of for the sauce is... Immaculate! Yummy! So delicious! It was seasoned and just absolutely mouth watering! At last, we have finally reached the moment you’ve all been waiting for... *Drum roll begins...* The crust!!! Crispy, crunchy, thin, and not soggy at all! I give the crust a 5/5 alone! Overall this has been a very desirable experience! Well done Giorgios Pizza! I will be sure to recommend this establishment to every friend of mine and also my colleagues! Other than that this has been professional food critic Mort J. Finkelstein signing off.
Hands down our favorite in town pizzeria! We deliver from Giorgio’s once a week. We find the coupons on the box to be very helpful. Staff is friendly and food is always fresh and delicious. They have a wide selection of items to choose from. We love the penne a la vodka. They put bacon and onions in it! Some people may find this odd or unconventional but it makes for a heavenly flavor!! Cant say enough good things about this place.
Actually loving this place. The main guy behind the counter, Mike I think. He is a pleasure to interact with and deserves 5 stars. Good pizza as well, although the plain slice could use a little updat, its not great. I usually go with the Sicilian style cheese slice because the plain is.. Not good. Still 5 stars.
Ive lived in the area going on 4 years and always ordered from a different pizza place. I have only ordered pizza from here but its absolutely delicious. Wish I had been ordering from here all along. The only complaint I have is their Sicilian pie is small. I only order pizza from here now. Their prices are also much better than the other over priced place I was ordering from.
There are 2 pizzerias down and up the road from Giorgios that seem to get much more traffic, but man, neither of them can top their pizza. It tastes like nostalgia. The bottom crust is slightly crunchy which, in my humble opinion, is what really makes an already great slice even better. Plus their prices are great, I do wish they had a soda fountain so I could fill up my cup instead of only having the option to get a bottle!
Great staff, very friendly. Got the stuffed mushrooms, overflowing with buttery stuffing, The Deuce pasta, which really has so many great ingredients and a nice little kick in the sauce, and a philly cheesesteak pizza. I asked them to do it with the garlic knot crust and its ridiculous. Some of the steak spills over onto the knots, making little philly cheeseknots. Im very happy.
Just got delivery and I had to write a review before finishing my food (THAT GOOD). The pizza is very good and the buffalo chicken wrap was delicious!!!! Food was delivered within a half an hour and still hot! Very happy with our order and service! Will be returning, thank you for delicious food and outstanding service :)
I was just at Giorgios about 15 minutes ago for the first time. I got a margarita slice and 3 garlic knots to take home. Well, when I got home to heat it up it was a soggy mess, even after an attempt to crisp it up in the oven. (I asked for it not heated up because my ride home was 15 minutes and I didnt want it getting cold). I also ordered 3 garlic knots. The prices were fair, and the people behind the counter were very friendly. However, the pizza was horrible!! It was really soggy, and it was put together very messy. The tomatoes were sliding off as I ate it. The garlic knots appeared to be ok, but when I bite into it, it was as hard as a rock. I would not recommend coming here, nor am I going back. At least I can say I tried. I gave 2 stars for friendly staff, clean atmosphere and decent prices. But the food was a hard pass for me.
Ok so to be 100 % this place use to be great and the current owner has been working there since before he owned it and I feel has a good part in why it was great but since he bought it with his wife and father their are too many hands in the cookie jar. they need to be silent partners and let him bring it back to being great again! Oh yea and THE chick has been tough the last few months other then that the food is great
I just want to thank everyone at Giorgio’s!! I was one of those moms embraced to admit But both nick and George were gracious and went above and beyond ! Their staff was kind, courteous and helpful beyond words !! Cannot wait for my daughters wedding. With a full heart thank you
We ordered delivery from here on a Saturday. We ordered the rigatoni rustica and a house special (the works) pizza. The pasta was cooked perfectly with good pink sauce and chicken. We were disappointed with the pizza. We opened the box and it was a sloppy mess. The onions and peppers were cut so big and uneven, not spaced out on the pizza. Same with the olives... Seems like they just plopped them down in big mounds. Their pizza making skills need work.
Cold pizza, dressingless salad, and rubber calamari, these are the phrases I can use to best sum up the food from Giorgio’s. My family and I tried this place for dinner for the first time and it’s two thumbs down 👎🏻 I ordered fried calamari and pasta and got salt flavored rubber bands in a fishy red sauce rendering the pasta inedible. My wife ordered a Greek salad and a slice of buffalo chicken pizza the pizza was as stiff and dry as the bottom part of the iceberg lettuce that was in the salad that came with some strange mayonnaise not Greek dressing and then finally my son got two slices of pizza that a drunk person must’ve applied the sauce to because i can’t figure out how someone could miss. Don’t waste your money 💰
I dont normally post things like this, but I wanted to share a recent experience involving two local restaurants, one being Giorgios.A little backstory....A couple of weeks ago my mother unexpectedly was hospitalized and passed away. It was heart wrenching, as I am sure many of you can understand or imagine and threw my world upside down. My sons 7th birthday was just this week and I had lost sight of putting together something for him in light of what happened and Easter coming. At the last moment, last Saturday we decided to take some of his cousins bowling and to dinner. In total with adults and kids, about 15 people.We were going to Smithtown Lanes to bowl and then dinner. They were great as always. There isnt as much fanfare there, but they are always kind and its clean.I called Manninos in Smithtown, where we have been several times before, that morning and the man who answered was so rude to me I was surprised. In short, he told me that on a Saturday night at 5pm he couldnt take a reservation for a table like that of mixed kids and adults as he would be losing money on the table, but we could come in and spread out in the booths if there are seats in the pizza part and order whatever. I was so taken aback by it I actually asked him to please repeat or clarify and he said again, no, we wont take you and waste that space. To be clear, we asked for nothing special except dinner and for as many adults as kids. I hung up feeling deflated and sad. Not just for how I allowed him to speak to me, but that people would have that attitude about customers.Based on reviews I read in here and online, I called Giorgios in Nesconset, although I had never been there. A young man answered the phone, I posed the same question about a reservation and he was so kind and friendly. Said it would be no problem, we were welcome to bring a cake they would cut, and they would have our table ready. What a different response and feeling. I had to call twice to change the time and number of diners, and each time they were nice and accommodating about it. We went and everything was set up, which took up half their dining room seats, and they were pleasant and happy to see us. The food was excellent and surpassed my expectations and the server was friendly, funny and right on point. I observed the same warm and friendly service given to the rest of the patrons, dining room and pizza part alike. The young man who answered the call originally we met and he couldnt have been more than 19 or so, and so kind. He came out to sing Happy Birthday to my son too, at least iy spunded like him :)The experience was great, when we left everyone waved and wished us a Happy Easter. They made life long customers of us. It is further for us to travel then several nearby restaurants, but I would rather travel for great food and kindness.In the end it turned out to be a great day for my son, and us. And I learned something about a local place I will never visit again and found a new place to call a favorite.I am sorry for the length of this, and it was just my experience, but sometimes one experience can change your perception of a person or place forever. Thank you Giorgios, we will absolutely be back!!
1hr b4 closing all pizzas $1 and their food is delicious....very friendly people quick n courteous. I commend this establishment for any that has little or no money they make it affordable 1hr b4 closing..thats caring and giving back to the community paying it forward i believe making a difference in the word
Total reviews rating 4.5
173 Reviews for Giorgios 2023:
Review №1
2022-04-07Good pizza. Prices are good. Many deals and freebies available with certain orders. Free and fast delivery. I think the pizza should be cooked a little more, but ask for well done and they get it done right without burning it. Store could use a little bit of a facelift, but overall, this is a good local pizzeria shop.
Review №2
2022-03-19Ive been ordering here for years because it is close to my house and has free delivery. But between their inconsistent food and TERRIBLE delivery I would NEVER recommend them and 100% wont be ordering here ever again. Tonight the delivery driver didnt bring my soda (which is my kids favorite part of pizza night) but he said hed come right back with it so it honestly wasnt an issue at all. But he never came back!!! So after over 20 minutes later (I checked my ring cam) I called and it wasnt even on its way!! But still it isnt the end of the world. Mistakes happen. But then my wife reminded me that last time I ordered from them they delivered the wrong persons food (pasta instead of wings) and when they finally made their way back to take the pasta back and give me the wings they were cold and we ended up throwing them away. AND THE TIME BEFORE THAT they delivered greasy and soggy pizza that we had to dab with paper towels and put in the oven before eating. I mean....cant believe it took me this long to write them off. We live in New York with a pizza place pretty much on every corner. Ordering from a terrible pizza place just because they are close is stupid. Dont order from here.
Review №3
2022-04-16Ordered from Giorgios a couple of days ago. Great Service. Everything came, no problems. And most importantly great food. Very filling. Would definitely come back.
Review №4
2019-08-02I Reallllllly liked the meatballs in my meatball hero, but the bread wasnt as robust as I would have liked. The taste if a meatball and the consistancy of the meatball along with the gravy are much more important than the bread. I only wish there was a bit more texture and crust on the bread.
Review №5
2022-07-20Pizza is great. Staff is very polite. Overall always a good experience in there.
Review №6
2022-01-16I came here to pick up wings for lunch and went to pay with my usual debit card that I use for every transaction. The man who claims himself to be the owner was at the register and tried swiping my card. Unexpectedly, their card reader was not properly reading my card. He had surprisingly insulted me in front of every customer in the establishment by telling me that the bank said it was rejected and I should go to my bank. I asked him to swipe it again, and he refused stating that his card reader stated, do not honor. I politely asked him to punch in the card number and again, he refused.Is this how you take care of your customers?Instead of blatantly expressing a customers business, you could have asked for a different card or source of payment in privacy. I was majorly inconvenienced that I was forced to go to the local 7/11 to get cash from the ATM. I then returned back to the restaurant and presented him with cash from the same debit card I tried to use prior.I told the owner that there may be something wrong with his card reader and that I felt insulted that he embarrassed a consistent-paying customer. I expressed that should he act in such a manner again, that he would lose me as a customer. He told me not to threaten him that way and refuses to be spoken to in that manner. His approach should have been different, but instead acted immature and disrespectful to the needs of his customer.As an individual in the restaurant industry, I never put my customers financial situation in open air. Rather, I discuss the issue in private. In this case, the owner refused to do his job by not acting like a professional and politely asking for another source of payment or typed the card number in. I have never had an issue with my card at any other establishment other than this one.As a result of inconvenience, my wings are now cold and soggy; my lunch ruined. He never tried to remedy the situation. He only set the precedent for his employees that it is acceptable for them to speak to his paying customers in any derogatory manner while providing sub-standard cuisine. So, I ask again...Is this how you take care of your customers?
Review №7
2022-03-10The foods absolutely disgusting, the place is always dirty and gross. Very sad because it used to be better but has gone through so many different owners.
Review №8
2022-05-16Very good food with dinner specials at very reasonable prices. They also do catering and host parties in a private room!
Review №9
2021-09-29My family & I love Giorgios. We are new to the area and a neighbor recommended this be our new pizza spot. We loved the food. I used them to cater my boyfriends surprise party and EVERYONE thought the food was delicious. We used them again to cater another, smaller family event. I called a little over 24 hours in advance and Giogios did not even fret. The food was delivered on time and once again, everyone thought it was delicious. They will be my go-to food caterer til the end of time!
Review №10
2022-03-07Person Pan pizzas are delicious. And perfect for 1 person.Price is great too!