I Love NY Pizza in Hudson Falls
Categories
Location on the map
Hudson Falls, Washington County, New York, US
Service options
Health and safety
Highlights
Popular for
Accessibility
Offerings
Dining options
Amenities
Atmosphere
Crowd
Payments
Site: https://www.ilovenypizzaofforted...
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–9PM
- Saturday:11AM–9PM
- Sunday:12–9PM
I Love NY Pizza in other cities:
One of the best reasons to live in or visit the area: great pizza, and they accommodate custom orders. Their menu would be absolutely perfect if they made dessert knots (knots filled/braided with chocolate instead of garlic butter).Knocking a star off because we rarely if ever see anyone wearing a mask when ordering in person, and another because the person handling phone orders on weekends can be rude.
We drive an hour to this place. Its the only pizza place we go to. But lately the past few times we have gone for pizza we noticed the sauce and topping do not cover the crust leaving at least crust. Not enough sauce as well. Hopefully this can be rectified because its a great place to eat!
Late for work, stopped at I ❤ NY Pizza, HF location, just got a couple of their Flintstone sized pieces, about a dozen choices, and Barqs RB. Quick, about 4 min, tossed them on car, no, the car didnt tip over.Scooted onto work, just in time. They always are polite & helpful though Im rushed.Those Flintstone sized chef salads,,,,like bopppaa hoooma maau maau...boppa...
This is hands down my favorite pizza place and has been for years. Great portions, even better prices and quick service. We moved to Vermont 5 or 6 years ago and when we make the trip back home we get two large pies, one to eat and one to take back.They also have the best ranch dressing Ive ever eaten.
We ordered tonight they said 45 minutes....needless to day 45 minutes passed and then another 30 minutes..even after I called to check and she saod any minute..he will be pulling in..still another 15 minutes and food was cold...and for the price..thays very poor service
I ordered a simple order. Extra crispy wings and extra blue cheese. I received neither. Called and the person in charge was RUDE! Said it’s not his fault because the of the containers he uses but he will send a blue cheese. How friggen RUDE!!!!Third time I am disgusted with these people..Third times the charm... I’m out
Large slices of pizza, excellent prices. There is a sizable menu, as well as many readily made pizzas to pick from. Quality is not what youd expect from the price: its very good. After having pizza(my favorite food) from just about every place around here, this is probably the best. Value, flavor, and choices.
I cannot say enough good things about this business. As someone who is from downstate NY, it is very difficult to find good pizza in central NY, and in the Adirondacks. This is by far some of the best pizza I have ever had in my entire life, and the deals cannot be beat by any of the competitors! I drive a distance to get here and it is more than worth it every single time!
If I could give Zero stars I would. I order a pizza from them at 430 on a Sunday night and I didnt get it until 630 at same night and I was only 10 minutes away from them. Then my sister payed with card and they charged her account twice once for the actual price, second time for $500.00. This was all over pizza and wings like I am never eating here again and there hours are wrong so we cant get this fix. I HATE THIS PLACE.
Excellent food, great prices & lower cost than other local restaurants of same type. Delivery is fast & excellent as well. Their hot subs are never overcooked. While they have a great menu of choices, its limited comparatively. The best home delivery dining experience in Hudson Falls.
A great place for pizza and more. We had a fine lunch here and were blown away by the selection of fresh made, wonderful choices. Heaven if you are a pizza lover...and great prices. Handicapped accessible and very pleasantly laid out with space to breathe between tables, not jammed in. Worth a trip!
EDIT:This place is not what it was. It seemed like after a while, they changed brands of their ingredients.I instantly tasted the difference, & it wasnt a step up. Then a bunch of new kitchen & wait staff appeared. Very young adults if not late teens.. Again, you could tell the difference, not for the better, but this time it was more substantial & significant. It seems like the first year they were on the corner of Main & John, they concentrated on all the qualities. ie - service, food, & prices. Then it seems like after they had us hooked, they went cheap, & are hoping to ride human natures adversity to change.. But thats just what it seems like IMO. The first 6 to 12 months before & after the move to John St. they were manufacturing magic. After the 2 dark-haired girls left, its been a slow & steady decline in various ways since then. Back then my original review (below) was 100% earned & deserved. It seemed like their hearts were in it then.ORIGINAL REVIEW:A diamond in the rough...Everything is always great here. Finally a city style pizza joint in Hudson Falls! Quality ingredients & great staff make this my favorite eatery in the village, and one of my favorites in the Glens Falls region. Ive been a fan since the start. Since then, word has spread & theyre much busier now.. A testament to what a gem this place is..Love it! 💘
First of all everytime I go in there barely any of the staff has there masks on same with people waiting for their food. I then go and ask are there no masks anymore and she says we are very lenient here, we dont care. But by nys guidelines they can be shut down because of the no masks. Will not be going there anymore when they dont care about customers safety...
I wish there was an option for zero stars, but there isnt. I decided to try I love NY Pizza after having a bad experience with another local pizzeria. I ordered chicken tenders, french fries and a small chicken bacon ranch pizza. It came to $27 and some change. I thought that was a bit expensive, but I figured its worth it if its better. What a mistake. It took them over an hour to deliver when Im right down the road. The chicken tenders were bland and very dry. The fries were soggy. The pizza wasnt too bad but certainly not worth what I paid. I cant believe Im saying this because I prefer mom and pop shops, but the local pizzerias here have made me a believer in franchise pizza. I couldve gotten better from the grocers freezer. Please dont waste your money.
I have ordered pizza for delivery from this place for several years. I ordered twice in the last week . I called today and was told by the person on the phone we dont deliver that far. I ask to speak to the manager who said the same thing. When I told him I order regularly and had ordered just 2 days earlier he said the same line as if I was lying to him then left me on hold till hung up. The pizza is good but to disrespect a loyal costumer like that it very unprofessional. Sadly I will never give them my business again. I am sure Not everyones experience with them is bad but costumer service like that unforgivable.
Pizza is great service is wonderful had a few of their hot dishes like baked ziti, order it and it got served much too cold, tye waitress took it back got it back too burned. but i do prefer mine so much better than yours. Dont get mad or angry with what i have to say. If you dont like what people are saying than fix what you or someone is doing wrong or otherwise do not ask someones opinion.the service is great and wonderful
Ordered a toss salad and only got a container full of lettuce and when i called i was told i had to come get a different and they would not deliver.I said i wanted the cost put back on my card and was told i could only get a credit i told the guy i would not be coming back and he hung up on me GREAT custmomer service
Great food majority of the time. However, sometimes wait times are a little much (45mins for pick up), but I guess thats average for other busy places. They need to update their website!!! The prices are not correct on the menu. What was $28 online, was actually $37. Their prices have gone up on items just recently and their online menu hasnt been updated since 2014 it appears.
I was very dissatisfied with my calzone. They do not season the ricotta at all,very bland. ( please ad basil and oregano) i was also shocked at just how small it was, marinara on the side,tasted like right out of the can. The pizza is good,wait staff is always pleasant and have a smile on their face.
The waitresses were short with us and unwilling to help. Despite theyre seemingly unhappy presence as a whole, they seemed to be chaotic behind the register. They misheard how we wanted our wings and instead of agreeing they were wrong,they just shrugged it off and we were stuck with the wrong wings. One waitress walked away from us in the middle of our sentence. The food was okay but they staff and wings werent.
I have gotten good large salads from here in the past. So I tried a Greek salad, when I got home and looked at it the cheese was covering up the 1 olive and 4 pcs of tomato along with the brown lettace. I will try again because they do have good food but the tip will show my dissatisfied visit.
Prices dont line up with their website and they refused to honor them. I wanted 50 wings which should have been 24.50 according to the website. They wanted to charge me 30. Price still isnt bad, but I had gotten the money from a bunch of other people who chipped in for a party and was not happy that they were unwilling to work with me.
We got raw wings. Really raw. We have called all they had to say was just the way the wings are. We even asked for them to be cooked twice. They would noteven send a new set of wings or refund us. I told them we saved them and have pictures. Very disappointed. Beware of there wings.
I just called at 9:15 a guy answered and said were closed I said I thought you dont close till 10pm, click he hangs up. Talk about rude and unprofessional and then they wouldnt answer the phone again. First of all they could have just said usually we are but we had to close earlier or something. You dont ever just hang up the phone on a customer. I know they wont ever get my business again.
So they do deliver on time but when we called for a delivery the first time they answered then phone and sat there for a minute then hung up we called again and the lady was so quiet we asked her to repeat everything three times and then when she had to do that she was rude about it and the guy who delivered didn’t give me my change so not very happy with this place right now
Total reviews rating 4.4
199 Reviews for I Love NY Pizza 2023:
Review №1
2022-04-24I have bought our pizza there for a long time, but lately been a mistake every time I order but I just let it go because these are tough times for many businesses.But this time was burnt and wrong sauce. The man on phone said he could replace if I wanted to drive back to get another one but I couldn’t do that. That was really only option, not good business practice. I realize they are very popular but really?
Review №2
2021-08-18Pizza and wings weren’t bad, could use more sauce, didn’t seem like there was any on the pizza, but it reheated pretty well. Not bad, but for NYC there is no shortage of pizza places to eat from so we will probably try a few others and may update this review at a later date.Unsure about customer service - as I didn’t personally go in to place the order, but from what I was told - it wasn’t awesome and wasn’t terrible.
Review №3
2022-03-20We usually eat there and even though its always very busy service is great! Those girls work their butts off! Food is awesome as well. We absolutely love their chicken wings. Calzones and pizza are also wonderful. I cant wait to try the chef salad next!
Review №4
2022-04-07One of the best pizzas in the region. Love the crunchy base and huge slices!
Review №5
2022-05-28Tried this place while visiting from NYC. Ordered a regular cheese pizza and garlic “knots”. Saw the name so I thought it’d be similar to pizza back home; like a New York slice. It’s not lol. But it’s not bad for the area. The reviews hyped up the place.Their “garlic knots” I ordered are literally just baked dinner rolls with buttery garlic flavor lol. Marinara sauce that came with the garlic flavor dinner rolls was good though
Review №6
2022-05-26I ordered a pizza asking them to make sure the cheese went as close to the edge as they could. It was a specialty pizza for $19.50. When I got it home, they did the opposite. Each slice had about 3 of cheese and topping, and the crust was about 3... which ended up in the trash. Will never order from them again. Had I known, I def wouldnt have given them a $5 tip!!
Review №7
2022-04-15Been going to this place for years, great food and did have ok prices. Not anymore. I ordered a dozen wings and a medium pizza. Came to pick it up, 33$!! There was a sign saying higher prices due to inflation. Give me a break! Will not be going back. What a shame
Review №8
2022-04-03I ordered a Turkey & Bacon Sub when it arrived there was absolutely no Turkey on the sub & when I called & spoke to the manager Josh he told me he would take the sub back & have the driver give me cash back he never even offered to remake the sub .I was a loyal & regular customer of I love ny pizza in hudson falls until today they will no longer be receiving my business
Review №9
2022-05-13Hudson Falls does not have Good Wings, not here not anywhere, We demand Good Bone In Wings that are not over cooked and dry ! I pay good money and a good tip every time !
Review №10
2022-05-04Great pizza! Great prices! Great selections! Our go to pizzeria always!