Outdoor seating
Yes
Il Posto Di Joey in Huntington
Categories
Location on the map
Huntington, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Kerbside pickup
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Delivery
No
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Great coffee
Yes
Great dessert
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Cocktails
Yes
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Happy-hour drinks
Yes
Happy-hour food
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Spirits
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Bar on site
Yes
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Romantic
Yes
Upmarket
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Yes
Accepts reservations
Yes
Phone: +1 631-271-2253
Site: http://www.ilpostodijoey.com/
Site: http://www.ilpostodijoey.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:12–10PM
- Tuesday:12–10PM
- Wednesday:12–10PM
- Thursday:12–10PM
- Friday:12–10PM
- Saturday:12–10PM
- Sunday:12–9PM
Comments (150)
Was here for a wedding rehearsal dinner so I cant comment on the restaurant fare. Our catered meal was an excellent buffet with super before meal service and appetizers. The space was separate from the restaurant and was well layed out for ready mingling. I would eagerly try the restaurant based on the nice meal we had.
We had our Christmas party here at Tutto Pazzo. The food was fantastic. Delicious and varied finger food, the buffet was to die for and it was a very well stocked bar. They had Weller Reserve bourbon. I really enjoyed my time at Tutto Pazzo. I look forward to going back and getting dinner.
Arent you the guy who said all those racist things about black people
Came highly recommended, but was disappointed. When I think of NY Italian I get excited, and Ive had amazing NY italian. This was just ok, and expensive just ok. The seafood was fresh and oysters good. The branzino filet was a small portion, smothered in red sauce and other seafood, but fell short on any flavor. The most diapointing was the red sauce. It was simply pureed tomatoes with very little complexity to flavor. I tasted everyones dishes (we all got something different) to see if it was just me. Nope, the lobster risotto for 2 was equally poorly executed. The rice was flavorless, like it was boiled in water, drained and had a bit of tomato sauce thrown in. Linguine with shrimp, olive oil and garlic, sounded like it should be all about flavor, but sadly no, it was very bland and flavorless. Overall, ambiance is awesome, bread 5 stars, service ok, food mediocre.
My husband and I went to dinner here last night. Wow! We were seated on time for a 7pm reservation and this place was packed. We had the artichokes stuffed with goat cheese and the filet mignon sliders as appetizers and the lamb stuffed ravioli and chicken francese for dinner. I am a tough critic because I enjoy cooking and I typically dont order food at a restaurant that I feel I can make myself or that I have had elsewhere and didnt like. With that in mind I must say the food was incredible! The desserts and presentations were outstanding. I had the brownie with icecream and my husband had the sorbet. What distinguishes this restaurant from all of the other restaurants is simply the owners. Upon meeting Luigi he was friendly, charismatic, delivered the food personally to each table with a chef apron on and not a suit, talked to everybody at each table in the room (not small talk), and spoke about his love of not only food but also children and family. We dine out a lot and you rarely ever see the owner out and about mingling with their customers. Five stars all the way around based on my experience yesterday.I have seen a number of reviews that judge a restaurant on an experience they had on a Hallmark holiday such as Valentines Day. I too have been down that road where I was disappointed on a holiday when my reservation at another restaurant had me waiting over an hour ( popular steakhouse) while five months pregnant and was understaffed. I have discovered two things: one is that all great restaurants have the same circumstances on these days and its how the restaurant handles it that makes all the difference in the end and two, dining out on a different day close to one of these holidays makes for a much better dining experience. You dont want to rush your customers and you dont want to keep people waiting. There is a fine line.Update***We couldnt wait to go back and so we did twice. The food was still very good but not spectacular as it had been when I posted the original review. However, we will definately be back again soon.
Food was good. Service was good. Upon asking the owner about a charge on the bill, the owner came to our table and his delivery was rude and abrupt. A polite explanation of the charge was all that was required instead he came out on the defensive. So that my friends, left a bad taste in my mouth. Not a good way to treat customers.
Went here to celebrate my grandsons birthdays. Delicious food. Started with chopped salad which I shared. I had zucchini linguine and had plenty left for a meal tomorrow. I highly recommend Tutto Pazzo
I found trying the seafood Mediterranean salad that tasting this entry was a delicious experience. I ordered the lasagna it was tasty and I found very good portion size lasagne and the sauce tasty made fresh complimenting but not over powering the lasagna. My food I found was excellent, well prepared with great attention arranging the food on the plate. Tasting the seafood salad made me eager to try the lasagna and I was inpressed by my total meal experience. I look foward to my next eating experience at Tutto Pazzo. I highly recommend eating here.
Italian restaurant, specializing in fresh seafood. Brisk lunch crowd with valet parking. Food has improved but is nothing to write home about. Prices have risen dramatically over the years.
Excellent food and the owner / Chef is very personable like family. Felt very comfortable there. setting is like youre right at home. Make sure you sit by the fireplace for the winter. Nice and cozy
First, Joey and Luigi are amazing owners. Their concern for every patron is second to none. The bar is terrific with a large screen tv...always something great on. Jose is my favorite waiter, first class...oh the food, delish, no really delish...have had over the years almost everything on the menu...and theres something for everyone.
This place is by far one of the best restaurents Ive ever ate at.The food was excellent & you had a extensive menu to choose from. Go, eat & enjoy....They are located across from Prime in Huntington...Well worth the trip...
A local Italian eatery. Great food and delicious specials. Handmade pasta, yummy! Owners are there to please. Efficient wait staff. Great for special occasions. Did I say great food? Yes
The charms of Italy await you from fresh seafood to a tempting variety of Italian dishes. The service is excellent as is their food — lovely setting and great for private parties.
This restaurant makes the BEST ITALIAN FOOD ON LONG ISLAND.The two brothers who own this restaurant are the most accomidatingRestauranteers that I knowWe wouldnt miss a Chritsmas Eve dinner at Tutto Pazzo..We have been going to Tutto Pazzo since they opened ,Hi, Joey,hi Louie... We have never eaten better.
Delish! I had veal saltimbocca and lots of appetizers. Definitely reccomend this resteraunt. We will be back. The sangria is so good too
We took the kids. My husband and I thought the food was great. Not really a great restaurant for people with food allergies. We asked for a kids size steak and it ended up costing twice the amount of an adult meal.
Went for my fathets birthday earky october. Attentive owners, fresh homemade pastas, friendly atmosphere. No complaints, I tried everything at our parties table except the bronzini only BC I didnt see it across the table and everything was great. They accommodated my wifes special request for veal marsala too. May go back for out anniversary next week, thanks ltl and Joey!
Excellent service! Delicious food! One of the best fried calamari I have ever had! I highly recommend this restaurant!
Went there for a party with buffet service. The food, room, and the service were all very good. Had a nice outdoor area out back for the kids to run around.
An amazing dinner with great service! Also I was very impressed with the wine selection from the high-end bottles, priced at a fairly good value, to the well selected house wines.
Had dinner here while in town for work and really enjoyed the food and atmosphere. The wait staff was excellent which added to the great experience. Would definitely go back.
Great food, friendly staff, lovely bar area all in a fabulous location. I keep going back for dinner...love the menu selection.
Been going here for years and it just keeps getting better!!! Fantastic food, wonderful atmosphere!!? Everything on the menu is delightful!!! Luigi is amazing!!
The seafood here is delicious. Its a shame the reviews are low on Google. This place is delicious and has a great bar. The patio is beautiful during the summer as well.
Joe and Luigi have a first class restaurant firing on all cylinders. Creativity is A plus here. Zucchini Flowers a seasonal dish are featured right now.
Horrible servive, waiter took the food order and disappeared, we didnt see him until we were finish our meal and ready to go. The food was only average, for the price, which was on the high side, I wouldnt return.
LOVE this place. Amazing food, great staff and the actual restaurant is beautiful. Me and my husband will drive from NJ to here just to have their food.
Wonderful food, delicious fresh made pasta, great atmosphere, fun bar, great people. Check out owner Luigis Tutto Pazzo fb page and watch the magic happen.
Consistently ....over the top. ..freshest ingredients. ..attention to detail. ..the owners. ..always close by. ..to assure that you have the BEST experience possible. ..homemade pasta and pastries...awesome service ..why... GO anywhere else. ....lol...
Excellent for a nice Italian meal. The ambiance is great with a friendly waitstaff. Definitely recommend the fresh pasta.
OMG The Cocoa Parpadella w/gorgonzola sauce was mazing. Now lets discuss desserts.... i have to eat them in 2s one for each hip. TY Luigi and Joey
Weather was perfect so we were able to eat outside, which was quiet and relaxing. Attentive staff and excellent food.
Saturday night dinner was a bit disappointing. Have had much better meals and service there before. Was crowded too be sure.
Always a great experience! Chef Luigi and his crew produce outstanding meals and the sauce is consistently amazing!
The food was awesome. It was a private party, the staff was friendly and service great.
They serve large portions and for fair pricing. very friendly employees. 5 stars from me.
Great meals and service, personally concerned about taste, service and our satisfaction. A great experience and environment for family and celebration.
Best Italian Food on the Island. Luigi is a true artist about his food. And hes the best on social media
Been going to this restaurant for years. The food has NEVER disappointed. Ive made parties and had meetings here.THE BEST!!!!
The Best Italian Restaurant Hands Down. Love Luigi and his delectable creations that make it worth the trip every time.
Excellent food and service. Just like momma use to make.. Ill definitely be back
Salmon was delicious, but sauteed spinach was the worst Ive ever eaten. Too stuff to cut.
Very good food... Did the curbside pickup , whole family was happy...
Have been dining here for years. The owner is awesome and they prepare delicious food.
Food was good but the menu was a little odd, there wasnt any beef to be found.
Always delicious! If you havent had the pesto ravioli youre doing it wrong.
Rigatoni a la vodka is on point! Their veal marsala is also a great entrée.
We like the ambiance here. The pasta is excellent and we know that we can count on being full when we leave.
Great restaurant, great food and service. Highly recommend this place!
Vary nice restaurant and great food, always very consistent with quality!
Great food with a good wait staff. Good for large parties.
Great food awesome menu. Sitting outside is amazing!
Food is great, restaurant is very nice, beautiful outside seating
I enjoyed this place a lot! Definitely had great food and atmosphere!
Excellent food was delicious
Really nice place,,,,love the setup,,, showcase of different foods,,, great bar, try the sangria 4 sure,, apps and mains incredible
Great place to eat and bring your family. Amazing portions.
Wonderful food, service and ambiance.
Friendly, Great service...we always eat well and feel like family.
Food was very good, but a bit over-priced
Good italian food. havent had a bad meal here yet.
Food is terrific and great atmosphere
Great food and nice ambiance. a bit pricey.
Overpriced mediocre food. Place smelled greasy and everything coming out of the kitchen smelled greasy!
Average at best. My pasta had no taste. Service had attitude. Not worth what I paid.
Amazing food, warm decor. Owner Luigi is the best!!
Food is tasty and well prepared. I just think its a little expensive for what you get.
Good good and always look for a discount special.Their homemade pasta is a MUST!
Nice place but was not impressed with the veal dish I ordered
Everything was perfect. Service, food and ambience , didnt feel rushed to the door.no complaints whatsoever
They do a great job on private parties. Super polite staff. Right by the water.
Great home cooking and the staff where was very attentive.
Great parking, great fpod and great atmosphere. Has a beautiful outdoor area too!
Awesome service and food is delicious and always consistent
Good old-fashioned Italian the way grandma used to make it. Love this place!
Love Tuttu Pazzo, we eat there frequently and the food is always great.
Delicious
Fantastic restaurant. Food is excellent. Drinks are excellent.
Good food and ambience. Would definitely recommend.
The food was delicious but they brought the wrong entree
Very over priced, food good but not worth it
Excellent food everything is freshLouie and Joe are the best
Fresh homemade pasta, gravy is delicious too.
Poor gluten free choices. Ended up with very expensive buttered noodles.
Real good meals I will go again
Great food, service and variety
Wonderful place to eat and enjoy the scenery.
Good food but too pricey
A little more upscale, great food
Wonderful warm staff. Delicious food.
The food and decor was awesome!!! I would definitely go back!!!
Great food, excellent service
Very nice sharp great food all fresh
OMG What amazing Food, all the way around!
Great local spot always good food !
Officially my favorite restaurant. Their chicken Francaise is to die for!
Fabulous food, friendly and fun!
The food and service was amazing!
We celebrate holidays with family. Always a very satisfying experience!
Good food, good service, nice ambience
I love this place, its really nice for a perfect date.
Great food and atmosphere!
Always good food, good service.
Nice place. Good food. Good atmosphere
Food was sub part and service was horrible.
Food was good. Service was okay.
Amazing food and incredible desserts!
Good food..Nice Service
Good food, service and atmosphere.
Amazing food as always!
Lovely meal, will definitely be back.
Cant get better food or a nicer host!
Great food poor service.
Tomahawk steak for two the best!
The food and service was great
Definitely the best Italian in Huntington!
The food and drinks are the best
Calm atmosphere, great service.
Very nice hidden gem on water
Excellent food and service
Great food and service
Great food and service
Attentive staff. Good food.
Delicious and very filling
The food was awesome
Food was amazing!!!
Service, food unequaled.
Amazing food!
It was okay , no need to return
A favorite, consistently good
My favorite restaurant
GREAT! come NOW, Nuff said !
Great waiters,
Great oysters
Always delicious
Great seafood
Great
Great food good service. A bit pricey for me but fits the neighborhood.
Number one food on long island and gorgeous staff not to mention Luigi and Joey the owners who are FANTASTIC
Total reviews rating 4.5
150 Reviews for Il Posto Di Joey 2023:
Review №1
2020-03-08Across the street from the water this restaurant has great food. Started off with a free basket of bread that was out on table with small rice balls and breadsticks. Waiter attentive and great service. Pasta was homemade and very tasty. Salads were awesome. Great dessert choices. Nice bar area to wait or hang out by. Gets crowded on a Saturday night so be sure you make reservations.
Review №2
2019-04-07My wife and I went to Tutu Pazzo with another couple and had a very nice dinner. It all started with a nice bread dish but also had rice balls in it. For starters my wife and I shared artichoke hearts with goat cheese and it was excellent. My entrée was the risotto with sausage and broccoli Rabe . I really loved it. My wife Had fettuccine with shrimp and she really enjoyed it. Overall it was a very nice meal and I would highly recommend this restaurant.
Review №3
2019-02-16This is a place that I’ve been meaning to try forever. However with so many Italian restaurants on Long Island it kept falling off the list.We arrived at noon on Saturday and the place was empty. We were greeted and immediately shown to a beautiful table with a harbor view.The menu is extensive, featuring a smaller portion lunch option.We started with clams oreganato. My husband thought it was the best he has ever had. I thought they were good but preferred something a little less saucy. The petite clams had a crisp breadcrumb topping under a rich lemon cream sauce. We certainly enjoyed soaking the sauce with the bread.This isn’t just any Italian restaurant. The star here is fresh house made pasta. If you have never had fresh pasta before you must try! It is a completely different experience than fresh made and refrigerated or box pasta.We finished with in house made tiramisu. It was awesome and tasted just like our Italian friend makes homemade for special occasions. Fresh cake and solid espresso warrants a crowd just for that.I usually keep my reviews simple. This is a MUST for anyone who truly appreciates authentic Italian cooking. Fresh pasta and fresh desserts. You swear there is an army of Nonna’s in the back.PS: our waiter was first class and there was a changing table in the women’s restroom.
Review №4
2019-04-07Really cool Italian placeIts a butcher with dry aged steak that they cut from huge slabs of beef, very coolIts a fish Mart with tons of fish that they cut from freash big fish, again Very coolIts a great bar with freash potatoe chips the come out freshBar is fun, oddly no tap beer, get tap beer please I get it its more of a wine placeWine list is big and very goodFood is great by the way, also a fun place to hang a really nice outdoor area in the back
Review №5
2019-05-06Great Italian food. The spicy crab cakes are amazing.
Review №6
2018-04-01Food is very good....Drink are a little over priced...ie $15.75 for a small grey goose on the rocks.
Review №7
2019-12-16Excellent food and great quiet atmosphere for a company lunch. The fixed price lunch was great and had something for everyone. The wine selection was plentiful and the service was accessible but not intrusive. Id definitely go back again.
Review №8
2017-08-21I absolutely love this restaurant! You can inside or outside in the beautiful courtyard. The food is delicious and the waiters give excellent service. You have to have the red wine sangria! Their menu is amazing! I can never decide what to choose. Fantastic appetizers, salads, entrees, and desserts. They even have fried zucchini flowers! My favorite Italian restaurant.
Review №9
2019-06-19Went there for a dinner with another couple. This restaurant has been there for years and we had our wedding rehearsal there many years ago. While the decor is definitely dated Italian the food is still excellent. They have a good bread basket with focaccia and rice balls to start. I had the lasagna and my wife had the stuffed sole. Both were great. While I didn’t have it this time their eggplant Parmesan is one of my favorites.
Review №10
2019-03-19This restaurant is fabulous. The food is great including the owners and staff. Waiters are fantastic - very hospitable, kind and there when you need them. Waiting time is great and they are on the ball. I recommend this beautiful eating environment to all: family, friends and business associates. We were very pleased with all. Thank you Tutto Pazzo for your great service. We shall return.