J&Js Pizza Plus in Castleton On Hudson

Review №1

2021-06-14

I love supporting small business especially when they are local. I would have loved to have given 5 stars but unfortunately the pizza was mediocre at best. The crust was very thin, the edges were burned, and where the cheese stopped and crust began was over an inch and a half. Boneless buffalo wings are my absolute favorite and for $16 for a dozen I was expecting a real treat... the wings we were given were completely plain, no buffalo sauce whatsoever or side sauces but the flavor of the chicken was good. The mozzarella sticks were great and I enjoyed the marinara sauce. Overall it was ok, but I really expected better.

Review №2

2021-08-25

Best pizza Ive had in a long time. Ive ordered pizza twice from jjs and never been disappointed. The only thing that should be done is when you order mushrooms on your pizza they need to add more than they do. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and the whole thing was covered in pepperoni they need to do the same thing with the mushrooms

Review №3

2021-09-04

Just moved to castleton a couple months ago and weve been looking for a pizza place for a couple months. Tried them all in EG and rensselaer area and J&J is gonna be our pizza shop. Pizza uses most likely homemade sauce, crispy thinner crust and good cheese. Wings are decent size.and cooked as ordered. Garlic knots were creamy inside and tasted great. Price even in these crazy times were below average. Seems like a family business and I think thats awesome.

Review №4

2021-08-15

Ordered a Philly Cheesesteak and a dozen wings though Doordash. 1 hour goes by and dasher had to call me to tell me they were out rolls. Why couldnt they have called me 2 minutes after I placed the order instead of the dasher calling me?? Now she has to wait another 15 minutes for my replacement order. The dasher told us they were trying to close up when there supposed to be open till 9pm. This was at 6:30pm.This is only the 2nd time we have gotten food from J & Js, sadly I dont think we will be ordering again!

Review №5

2021-07-23

I went in to grab a few slices for lunch. I ended up talking to the owner, who said he would make me a specialty pizza to satisfy my pregnancy cravings and limitations. Super accommodating and friendly. I will definitely be ordering from him again.

Review №6

2021-07-24

Worst food ever. The Caesar was made with iceberg lettuce suppose to be with romaine, had no cheese, it had carrots and cabbage you dont put carrots and cabbage in ceasar. The steak sub hardly had any steak in it and it had no taste.

Review №7

2021-07-12

My daughter cali works here so of course its great! She runs register and waits on customers and they love her! Shes friendly and always smiles.

Review №8

2021-07-15

Had a slice of cheese and pepperoni, loved em both! Food was good and the staff was very friendly, will be coming back

Review №9

2021-08-04

Great food, great service and very welcoming! My go to spot for pizza and wings from now on for sure!

Review №10

2021-08-05

Great service and amazing pizza and more i can said i give a 5 star cant wait go back