Delivery
Yes
Jersey Mikes Subs in Buffalo
Categories
Location on the map
Buffalo, Erie County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Mask required
Yes
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Crowd
Tourists
Yes
University students
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Phone: +1 716-412-2400
Site: https://www.jerseymikes.com/3404...
Site: https://www.jerseymikes.com/3404...
Opening hours
- Monday:10AM–9PM
- Tuesday:10AM–9PM
- Wednesday:10AM–9PM
- Thursday:10AM–9PM
- Friday:10AM–9PM
- Saturday:10AM–9PM
- Sunday:10AM–9PM
Jersey Mikes Subs in other cities:
Comments (133)
Very friendly staff. Very clean. And love love love Jersey Mikes sandwiches!!
Love their nice, fresh subs.... I especially love the Mikes Philly cheese steak sub...like being back in Philly..... they arent shy about lots of meat and cheese and all the other ingredients and they make to your order.
This place is really good, everything taste fresh. You definitely get your moneys worth. And the Rosemary bread is amazing. Also this place is always really clean which is a bonus.
We went to the Hamburg location on 2/22/22 around 11:30-12. This was our first time eating at Jersey Mikes. What a wonderful experience. I can’t have gluten the staff went over and above to make sure my sub was gf. They wiped counter and slicer changed gloves and used separate utensils. I commend the Hamburg team and who ever trained them. I will be going back very soon
Jersey Mikes was ok. It was a sub shop. I thought it was over priced for a generic sub. Better than subway but in the same plaza you can get a better sub at Wegmans.
Ive loved coming to jersey Mikes for awhile now because it always seems clean and fresh. Today was different, the place was dirty when we walked in, the employees were acting out and yelling like toddlers. Nobody followed any safe food handling practices, even emptied the last little bit of mayo from the old container into the new container. I think Im done with jersey Mikes for now, especially this location.
Love this place every one friendlyOrder is right every time
Meats were canned no toast on roll Get better same size and cheaper closer to home Tried it didn’t like it
Rude employees, tried to get out of a doordash pickup by telling me “it was already picked up”. So I called the customer, and during this watched the employee complain to 2 other employees about having to do the order lol. Sorry you wanted to pack up early but don’t accept the dash order then, I had drove out there in Orchard park and waited patiently I wasn’t going to lose out on my pay/gas usage because you didn’t want to make that order. 🤷🏼♀️
Disgusting behavior and treats employees horrible and allows them to be treated horrible by racist customers.
The subs taste pretty good, but they’re very overpriced, don’t have good options for sides, and the wait to get a regular sized steak sub at my most recent visit was downright pitiful. They’re making it hard for me to want to come back.
Good service, below average product. Especially in a place like buffalo where quality subs are a dime a dozen.
First of all I got sub for my bday and free. Them subs sucks 1 and your out the door. Flavorless and on top. There using tops rolls which are really worst rolls to use. Use Costanzas rolls if ur pay a premium. Attitudes too. Do yourself a favor and make yours or go to a pizza shop. Just this one by Wegmans or get a Wegmans sub. Subway way better
Whats not to love about Jersey Mikes? Love their sandwiches!!
For $18 I would expect to be asked what I would like on my sub.
Very good subs . Great staff. Had a great first experience there. I will go again
Absolutely delicious subs. The staff was polite and courteous. Just wish there were more locations around WNY.
This is one of my favorite places to eat. The bread is always fresh the meat and cheese are always sliced right there while you wait and stacked high. Excellent and speedy customer service even during the lunch rush. I’ve gotten food here a lot and it literally never disappoints.
Ordered a turkey sub and there was very little turkey and the topping was very little.will stick to Wegmans for my subs
Darn, they put the wrong sauces on all my subs and switched them up which pretty much ruined the whole order. Things happen but I think they need to be more careful reading the tickets. Overall, its just OK . Pretty much just overpriced subs. The bacon and packaging is good.
Wow. Great subs. Fresh cut meat and cheese while your watching. No skimping here. One of the best sub places anywhere no doubt. Delicious.
This was my first time eating here and I really enjoyed the food! It’s simple but good, I ordered online and it was finished right on time. The workers are friendly!!
Love the subs, and by far the best bacon at any sub place around. With that being said, when ordering a club sub, make sure they dont screw up and miss out on putting the bacon on... huge disappointment. Tough to say its worth the price for what you actually get.
Excellent service as always a little pricey but hey at least you get what you pay for good food
First had a delicious steak sub at an airport Jersey Mikes so I was eager to try another. Very disappointed! A very long wait for one truly disappointing sub. Once and never again.
Order via app. Great service, great food, absolutely loved the subs. Covid compliant and delivery pickup.
5 stars to the staff, cleanliness of the store, accommodation to my food allergies etc..this store is 5 stars from store to staff and the food was excellent! Reason for only a 4 star review is because $41 for 2 people to eat there when you can get 2 steak dinners with salad and side along with 2 drinks for the same price...this company charges way too much for their food..so unless youre really wanting it or just kinda hungry id go elsewhere due to corporate pricing but this location is wonderful!
Ordered online for lunch. The order was perfect and prepared right on time. The food was delicious and the staff was very friendly. Will definitely be going back.
Food is always delicious and fresh. Loooove this place, might go there again today!
Terrible , overpriced food, subway is better for the price !., they refuse to toast rolls, and when I asked about it was met by a real stand offish lady. No thanks. Not very clean either.
Incredibly poor service helmed by teenagers with no concept of how to maintain a business. I literally waited 10 minutes and was passed over by 3 other customers. I wouldn’t go to this place if you need a quick bite for delivery or takeout in the Hamburg Southtowns era.
Great subs glad too have one here if it wasnt for the giving promo Ii wouldnt have known you are here . Super busy with promo but Give your selves a pat on the back . GOOD JOB YOU DID THE BEST YOU COULD
Fleshly cut meat and cheese. Clean facility and friendly service. Tasted great too!
Lets start by saying this should be FIVE stars all day. I dont understand why subway exists and why pizza shops sell subs with places like this available. The thing that killed the review... while dining in, one of the staff decided to aggressively sweep the rug with a broom directly towards our table. Having dust pick up and breathing it in, killed this places rating. Mentioning to the staff are you kidding me, we are eating right here he continued while looking at me like I was being the burden...
Terrible service...long wait time...and expensive for what you actually get..Unhappy with the experience and will NOT BE GOING BACK HERE. First time is our last time here, will be going to FIREHOUSE SUBS FROM NOW ON.. its way cheaper at firehouse and they are way more friendly and the food is cheaper. Save your money and go to firehouse or subway instead.
The individual who was preparing my sub was also working the register. The individual didnt change his gloves while accepting money and making change. It was a very unsanitary experience. I will be trying another location from now on or going somewhere else.
Great subs. Need more locations had to drive @ 50 miles round-trip. But worth it....
They better keep this place clean because thats about all that I can say positive. Service was slow and clumsy. My sub roll was stale. The rest was ok (I guess). If they spent half as much $ on food quality as they do advertising, it might be better. I dont think Id order here again, even if it was free.
The chicken bacon ranch is so good
Meh...Overrated and completely unimpressed...family was as wellStick to your favorite local pizzerias and sub shops for much better experience and qualityDont waste your time IMHO
Well when I walked in there were 3 employees and not a single one said anything to me, I waited 7 mins before someone said Ill be right with you... I felt that the sub was very overpriced, not alot of steak on the sub, was very skimpy on the toppings. It was very good though.
Im not giving this place any Stars! The subs were TERRIBLE! HOW CAN YOU CHARGE 50 BUCKS FOR 3 SUBS! IF YOURE HUNGRY FIND SOMEWHERE ELSE TO EAT! WE CAME FROM DEPEW TO TRY THEM BECAUSE SOMEONE SAID THEY HAVE AWESOME SUBS THE ONLY THING AWESOME WAS THE ROLL!! SUNNY WASTE YOUR TIME!
Awesome service! Had to get a gluten free Italian combo for a buddy said it was amazing. Could not believe the bread was gluten free. GREAT SUBS!!!
Stopped in this morning around 1030. Wonderful experience. Food was amazing and very friendly staff. Drove 45 mins to get there and for sure will drive 45 to go back!
Very disappointed in the quality/ quantity of the food, roll was very dry and tasted stale. I know it never looks like the pictures but when I order a $15 giant sub Im expecting more than an average 12 sub roll that has barely any ingredients on it. There was practically no sauce on it and about 1/3 of the roll had nothing on it. Would not recommend to anyone, Ive had better day old leftovers from subway for half the price and thats not saying much!
Very overpriced for what they give you everyone was rude ,food was was below average I’ll keep going to subway
Great subs..Wish they would open up one close to me. Olean New York or Salamaca New York. I couldnt stay away.
The subs are not that good on their way over priced 15 almost $16 for a sub is too much and then some of the people there are liars I asked for one ingredient extra on my sub free ingredient tomatoes I asked him to put them on yeah they did I get home no tomatoes so I will be going back there again.
Very good subs. Great people working there
The subs were delicious but 17.00 for a giant steak is too much.
Subs are delicious but now is the 3rd time that weve ordered ... been told 20 minutes and its been an hour .... still waiting here for 2 subs. I cant honestly understand what the problem is .... management needs to fix this problem asap.
I was very impressed by the cleanliness of the mckinley location. Management there has everything covered everyone was busy and customers were being taken care of in a very timely manner. I ordered the buffalo chicken sub, the roll was delicious fresh and soft. I was very disappointed that my sub was made with ground chicken and not fried chicken fingers that I am use to, I would never order it again or recommend to anyone else. I checked the menu and no where on there does it give you any warning this is what your gonna get. Kudos to mgr and staff of this location.
Clean place, fresh food. Im happy theres a Jersey Mikes in Buffalo!
$35 for 2 steak subs???!!! They were good but not THAT good. Wont be ordering again.
Used the app to order hoping it would be faster. People who walked in after me and had to order got service first. They already had my order. I wont be using the app again!
Wonderful subs. Fresh & delicious. A little pricey tho!
It was very clean. And the workers were amazing. I would recommend this place to all my friends.
Awesome 👌 best subs ever.Well worth the money
Nice to see this chain locally. Good subs! Runs circles around Subway.
First time visit, very clean, sub was fresh as seen on commercial. Cold cuts were fresh will definitely return.
Really good subs. Highly recommend the Big Kuhuna. Hard working staff for sure. Very friendly
Fantastic service for a new store. Fantastic subs, worth the money.
First of all you should go back to Jersey. Roll was awesome, but I never had crunchy sauted peppers. NINE PEOPLE BEHIND THE COUNTER! SUBWAY DOES A BETTER JOB WITH TWO. Lastly, go to Jims Steak Out, and I remove the star because I couldnt post without one.
The whole family was happy with our meal! We 10/10 recommend we will buy from here again soon! :)
Sub was delicious, only reason it got a second star. Ordered online and was told 15 minute wait and the two subs I ordered would be done. Showed up to the store 17 minutes later, then continued to wait for an additional 40 minutes in the store and watched close to or around 15 people walk in and be served then sent on there way. I asked the person running checkout if it was done around 15 minutes into waiting (30 mins give or take total time from ordering) and he read the ticket and said not yet then carried on. Then I asked another employee at around the 40 minute in store waiting time (approx. 57 minutes from placing my order) and she had the cook finish it finally. Subs were very good but wont be returning, Firehouse Subs only in the future for this guy.
Over $16 for a whole sub. Over 16 minutes waiting in line. I give the quality of my sub 16/100. Just another example why our local subs are so much better. Wegmans, Jims Steakout, Ninos, Blasdell Pizza...ALL better.
Loved the new location. Easy to order and even offer bowls instead of bread.
$16.58 for a sub!?!????! It was a good sub no doubt, but it’s the most I’ve ever paid for a sub and nowhere near the biggest or most tasty. NOT “a sub above” for sure, maybe “average at best, at a price above” would be more appropriate, The workers were put out by 2 simple questions from a 1st time customer, maybe they need to take notice of current unemployment rates.
Love the subs and the employees are very friendly
Good eats. Only complaint is they couldnt hear the sandwich.
Really not worth the money, the best part was the bacon and thats about it.
Ive lived all over the country and visited this store in most places Ive lived. This is by far the worst one. I had to reddit my order almost a dozen times. I was running up wrong almost as many. In the end, I just let the person behind the counter ring me up wrong, including charging me for my free birthday son every though she was counting it against me, just to get the torture to stop.
Best sub in buffalo since moving from NJ 9 years ago. No one else in Buffalo comes close. They just dont understand how to prepare a proper Italian combo here. Get it Mikes way.
Sub was good a little pricey for what you get and the service was so slow!
After seeing numerous commercials on TV, yet having no store locally, I can say it was worth the wait. The subs are incredible. We started with a turkey and provolone. The meat was freshly cut right there and put right on our sub, with the standard toppings we like, plus one extra that only Jersey Mikes has....The Juice. Youll want to get a sub or two, then come back for more. Their hot subs are also delicious and meaty. If you havent been here, you should definitely go. They truly are A sub above
Great subs but a bit pricey.
My first time at Jersey Mikes Subs. Freshly cut meats, freshly baked breads. Fresh toppings. Great tasting. Large subs. Impressed.
Awesome service and food! Cant wait to go back.
Jersey Mikes blows away any of the cruddy sub places around. Freshly sliced meat always makes a difference.
My wife and I figured we would stray away from our usual Firehouse subs and try something new. Sadly it was a mistake. We were rushed to order and requested things be left out of our subs and when we got home to eat, our request was ignored. Not great quality, over the top greasy and overpriced for the amount of food you receive. It did not help it took 20 minutes to make our subs. Do your best to just drive 2 plazas over and get a firehouse or Wegmans sub.
So happy there is finally a location near me, best subs around
Delicious....very fresh.....substantial portions. Prices are in line.
Quality Subs with Quality Ingredients, at a price.So this was my first experience. I first ordered a normal sub. Utilizing my first coupon it was only $5 dollars. I was happy took the sub home and ate it. Sadly realizing how small it was I finished it easily and still wanted more.So I used another coupon and got a giant sub for 50% off. Was only $8 so I was also happy. Brought the sub home and ate most of it.This is my problem, if you dont use coupons the price is rediculous. I could order a sub just as big for $10 at litterly anywhere else. I can even get more bang for buck at DiBellas.TLDR; Expensive subs but good quality.
Seriously, Jersey Mikes. Reign in your store. I work at Home Depot, right behind you. I shouldnt be having to dismiss your requests for review 5+ times a day just because Im at work. It makes me want to stop eating at your restaurant.
Great Subs made the way you want it! Look for coupons in The Penny Saver.
Worst online ordering app ever keeps deleting entire order. Who ever designed it should play in traffic with a blindfold.
Their oil & vinegar is great on the turkey club sub
My husband and I ate at the original location on our honeymoon at the Jersey Shore. Absolutely loved it. That was 10 years ago and we still talk about. Saw it was coming here (finally) and even better, right down the street. Ordered first day it opened. It did not disappoint, same as we remembered. Fresh ingredients, meat sliced to order, super friendly owner! Must get it the Mikes way, completely makes the sub. We will definitely be ordering from here all the time 🤗
We ordered a Philly Cheesesteak sub. We were disappointed. They surely didnt look like the pictures, seems it was more roll , not enough meat, cheese or peppers and onions. Was very disappointed and for the money we thought they would be better.
My 1st time, not impressed, went there because part of purchase was donated to food bank. Order took long time, then I was told they lost the order, so, after paying, I had to give the order again...to wait even longer. And the person cleaning the cheese slicing machine used the same cloth (towel) to clean the counter, and then the slicer again. 6 people working behind counter when I was there and seemingly without good organization. Not to mention that the floor was filthy dirty with food scraps. Place does not get my recommendation.
Food wasnt bad, but not worth the money. $17.12 for a Philly cheese steak and medium drink.
In Florida the Jersey Mikes offered horsey sauce on their subs and a sub called the 99.I was a little downed by the fact both are not offered here, Ive been wanting Jersey Mikes since moving up here several years ago.I gave it a 4 cause the sandwich was still good, just not as good as what Im use to.
Steak Hoagie is nasty Steak Ums same for the chicken hoagie. 2 subs for $15 not even close to worth it. Waist of money. Threw food in trash.
Had lunch there for the first time yesterday. Ordered the Chicken ,bacon ranch sub. It was delicious! Two friends that were with me also loved their subs. Staff was very friendly and they sanitized each table as patrons left. Gentlemen walked in not wearing a mask (every establishment in Western New York has a sign posted about mask mandate!) He walked up to order holding his hand over his mouth! Apparently the staff told him no mask no service. He walked out of the shop and drove away. I applaud Jersey Mike’s for keeping us safe. By him holding his hand over his nose and mouth, he would have his germs on his hand and passed them on to the person cashing him out. Thank you, thank you, thank you!
Must try if you havent ever been! Got the club they slice meats to order!
My first experience with Jersey Mikes was just embarrassing. I ordered a chipotle chicken sub and I got a sub but it was subpar. The sub had no chipotle sauce on it, the chicken was dry. The entire sub had 3 slices of green peppers on it. To top it off it was way overpriced. I’d steer clear of this place and go elsewhere because at least you get what you pay for. Enjoy your franchise closing after 2 years!
Best subs around.
Best, freshly made sub I ever tasted.
Delicious!!!! I wish we had one closer to us.
Well 16 bucks for a ham Sub consisting of 5 thin slices of ham, 2 inches of lettuce, 4 slices of tomato 🍅, eat from your local pizza sub shop. I wont be going back . They wont be in business here in WNY long.
Sat Nov 8 made second visit for lunch at McKinley store. We had hoped 2nd visit would have proven to improve 1st experience. SANSWICHS GREAT!!!. SERVICE & PREPERATION SOME OF THE WORST WEVE EVER EXPERIENCED.. STARTING with COMMUNICATION BETWEEN STAFF. ORDER TAKING TO PREPARERS misererible. Time for order to pick up Misererible . People waited in line 20- 30 minutes (you arnt that busy!) One table didnt get 1 of 4 orders right. A staff was replenishing the chip rack by squeezing th potato chip bags crushing th chips to fit in maximizing stock. On shelf when carefully advising her she defiantly told me that she puffed the chip back up when stuffing crushed bags in rack. . We do really enjoy you food but will not bother coming back or recommending others until you demonstrate retrained staff. TmSincerey Ron ClaydonOr
Because the subs were better and they have more flavor
A lot of stuff on their subs. I like the oregano spice and their sub oil.
Great subs and friendly service.
Great service, even greater food.
Service and sandwich was delicious
Love their mikes way
Food and service was excellent!
Great fresh food
Was the sandwich worth waiting 40min for? No, no it was not.
Do not come here waste of money
Love it and will go back
Delicious subs 👍🏿
The food was ok
Best sub in wny
Great subs
Great subs
Awesome periodt!
Yum
Delicious
Horrible
This is my fave sub shop. They know my name, and remember my order, every time.The employees are great.
Best ever!!!
Total reviews rating 3.9
133 Reviews for Jersey Mikes Subs 2023:
Review №1
2022-07-04Love Jersey Mikes. This particular location, has a weekend special going which makes it worth the trip. Trip. Also this location is always nice and clean. Which I greatly appreciate.
Review №2
2021-11-13First time at Jersey Mikes & I definitely will be going back!! From the moment you walk in, its super clean, the staff is so friendly and the food....cmon forget about it ! So damn good! I got the Original Italian on rosemary bread with provolone cheese The meats & cheese are cut fresh right in front of you. Definitely A sub above I cant wait to try some others subs! Bravo 👏👏
Review №3
2022-04-16Went and purchased 3 subs and the staff was absolutely amazing. Made our subs quickly and were so kind and courteous. I asked their names because of how exceptional they were. High five to Matty, Dan, William, and Izzy!! Thank you for the great service and the subs were delicious 😋
Review №4
2022-05-15Everything so fresh. Great staff. They were all working together and very hard. Thanks you all. Our new best place for subs.
Review №5
2022-05-25Eat here for lunch 2-3 times a week and we never have a problem. Food is always right, and food is always good!!
Review №6
2022-07-08Awesome place. Quick, clean, professional. Always great food.
Review №7
2022-05-08Decent subs, but sooo expensive! You’d be much better off going next door to Wegmans or even Firehouse subs instead.
Review №8
2022-05-18Yesss I love it here they get my food right all the time
Review №9
2022-06-05Absolutely loveeeeee jersey mikes!! Food is always fast and fresh! Order through the app on your way and pick it up it is sooooo easy!! And soooo good!!!
Review №10
2022-06-01Super clean, friendly and fast service. Sandwiches are huuuuge