Jimmys Trattoria image 1Jimmys Trattoria image 2Jimmys Trattoria image 3Jimmys Trattoria image 4Jimmys Trattoria image 5Jimmys Trattoria image 6Jimmys Trattoria image 7Jimmys Trattoria image 8Jimmys Trattoria image 9Jimmys Trattoria image 10

Categories


Phone: +1 718-229-5319
Site: https://jimmysbayside.com/
Opening hours
  • Monday:Closed
  • Tuesday:12–10PM
  • Wednesday:12–10PM
  • Thursday:12–10PM
  • Friday:12–10PM
  • Saturday:12–10PM
  • Sunday:12–10PM
Edit info

Total reviews rating 4.5

199 Reviews for Jimmys Trattoria 2023:

Review №1

2022-03-21

Food is phenomenal and huge portions! Every single person in our party loved their meal. The francese was light, the Marsala was perfect and my parmigiana was exactly what I wanted. Service was a bit slow but the entire wait staff was very attentive and we didn’t mind it being slow cause we were enjoying the family time together. Minced baked clams were fantastic as well!! Highly recommend going to Jimmy’s.

Review №2

2022-04-21

A fancy restaurant; and by fancy I mean at very least pants, shoes, and a dress shirt.Excellent service. Whether it is a napkin or orders for 20 people, the waiter(s) are always ready to assist. They are well mannered. They know how to take a light joke, and even hit you back with another. The place is very clean and has a beautiful atmosphere. Not too bright, not too dark, nice and quiet. The restaurant never hints, let alone pressures their guests to leave.The food is fresh and tasty. Top notch platters and dishes. For a fancy restaurant the price is pretty reasonable. There is nothing bad I have to say about it, except that they dont serve Pepsi in a can. But in a great place like this, Ill settle for Coca Cola.

Review №3

2021-10-24

Excellent Food and good service!! Was a saturday around 5.30 p.m so we were fortunate they were kind enough to seat us without a reservation. I can now see why the place was so crowded as e everything we ordered was made fresh and absolutely delicious. Service could have been a little more attentive however it seemed only 3 servers for the entire restaurant and thats just a crazy load to bear. We will be back for sure as it was also quite affordable and the staff was very friendly and helpful.

Review №4

2022-03-28

We had very good service and the food was excellent and abundant. The atmosphere was most welcoming as we were greeted bythe host (possible owner )who thanked us for coming.We have been coming here for several years for family & friend gatherings and are happy to say that we were never disappointed. I do recommend this restaurant whether dining in or take out.

Review №5

2022-04-01

Enjoyed and delicious family dinner here last week to celebrate a birthday. We sat at a round table with plenty of room for 7 plus a toddler in a booster seat, and could still hear each other across the table. Service was excellent and personal, and all the entrees were delicious (fish, chicken, veal, gnocchi, and pizza were all equally raved about). Wish we could have tried desert, but portions were generous!

Review №6

2022-04-26

Great italian restaurant. Make you feel welcomed. place where you can have a conversation. They give you lots of food on your plate. So nice staff and manager. Have gone there 2x . will return again soon.

Review №7

2022-06-23

A superlative restaurant with an exceptional service, reasonable prices and delicious food. A great place to meet with a family or old friends. You feel at home!

Review №8

2022-05-10

So Jimmys was recommended to me by a co-worker who had eaten there several times. My wife and I decided to give it a try last week for our anniversary. Restaurant was clean, and well lit. Our server was friendly and very attentive and we were seated right away. Started off with some fresh warm semolina bread with herb seasoned olive oil which was delicious. We both love clams casino and were happy to see it on the menu so we ordered it as an appetizer. We have enjoyed clams casino at many other places and they are usually prepared as whole or chopped clam with bread crumbs, some finely chopped onion and green/red pepper, sometimes chopped garlic, and some chopped bacon on top with butter and seasoning. That is where the disappointment started. Our server brought out a half dozen clams on a plate. As he walked away, we both looked at the clams somewhat confused. The clams appeared to be steamed. On top of the clam were some large pieces of chopped onion, with a large chunk of roasted red pepper covering the whole clam, and a piece of bacon on top. No breadcrumbs, butter, or any other seasoning. We both thought that maybe this was just a different way to prepare the clams and ate them but were very disappointed. On my return to my office the next day, my co-worker informed me that in his experience at Jimmys he always had his clams casino prepared the traditional way so I am not sure what happened to our dinner. Next we both had a salad. My wife had a mixed green salad and I had a Caesar salad. The cucumbers in her salad were very bitter and my Caesar salad had no cheese on top, either grated, shredded, or shaved. For an entree my wife order eggplant parmigiana and I ordered shrimp parmigiana. The marinara sauce was delicious; light, sweet and just the right amount of seasoning. My wife thought her eggplant was just OK, nothing to rave about. The breading on my shrimp was extremely soggy, and just slid off of the shrimp. The shrimp themselves were rubbery, and had practically no taste. I am going to guess that they were previously frozen and most likely farmed raised. Since the last time my co-worker was there was pre-COVID, I have to wonder if there is a new chef working. Whatever the reason, my wife and I will not be returning. There are so many other Italian food options in the Whitestone/Bayside area, I see no reason why we should have to waste money on sub-par food.

Review №9

2020-04-27

This is my goto spot for authentic italian food for dine in . Im not sure if they change ownership but I decided to ordered take out for my family for the first time and boy was i disappointed. ordered lasgna and baked clams for my kids and this is what i got. This is not what i expect it from a authentic italian restaurant. This is what you get from a gas station in the middle of no way, Never again.

Review №10

2022-01-23

Food was excellent. Service and staff definitely not excellent. Aside from bringing our entrees and sides minutes apart, when we re-asked for a cup of coffee (for the 3rd time in 10 minutes) the waiter/busboy literally laughed in our faces). Also very few staff members wore masks or even tried. I wasn’t checked for proof of vaccination either. This is a bayside classic and wish they were better about these things.