Outdoor seating
Yes
Lukes Lobster Upper East Side in New York
Categories
Location on the map
New York, New York County, New York, US
Service options
Kerbside pickup
Yes
No-contact delivery
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible car park
No
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Bar on site
Yes
Gender-neutral toilets
Yes
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
LGBTQ+ friendly
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Transgender safe space
Yes
University students
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 212-249-4241
Site: https://lukeslobster.com/pages/u...
Site: https://lukeslobster.com/pages/u...
Opening hours
- Monday:12–8PM
- Tuesday:12–8PM
- Wednesday:12–8PM
- Thursday:12–9PM
- Friday:12–9PM
- Saturday:12–9PM
- Sunday:12–8PM
Comments (199)
Decided to give them a shot back in December and ordered the lobster grilled cheese, which in my opinion was a bit lackluster overall. For $13 I felt like it deserved a bit more lobster.Fast forward a few months and here I was hesitant to go back to try the lobster roll but noticed they also had a shrimp roll on the menu so I decided to gave that a shot. I have to say, the shrimp roll was pretty good.
Friendly service, delicious lobster (and shrimp), nice decor and a decent view, all in a small package.My companions and I recently chose to lunch at Luke’s. We would’ve preferred a warm, buttery, lobster roll, but Luke’s serves their shrimp and lobster chilled. The wait time for our food was about 10-15 minutes. Not a big deal, unless you’re as hungry as we were. The seafood was tasty and the buns/rolls were equally delicious. It’s entirely possible that I closed my eyes as I took each bite.Luke’s is pricey (to be expected since it’s quality seafood in Manhattan), but I like that they offer incentives. If you download their app they’ll give you a free beverage. On my birthday I was surprised with a coupon for a free shrimp roll.If you’re looking for a fresh (chilled) shrimp or lobster roll, this is your place.
Lobster delicious but didn’t like ambiance and the exorbitant prices didn’t help. Got the trio. Size was a lot smaller than expected. Shrimp no go and left it there. Crab took a bite would not order again. Bun nicely toasted. They wanted to up charge $8 for another mini roll lobster instead of the shrimp and crab. No fries yet on menu for a year? Staff friendly but almost not helpful. I would suggest lobster roll to go.RESPONSE: I can’t say I’ve been to many places with fries and lobster roll but would be nice.
I ordered Lukes trio and it was so good! glad they had this option because I didnt know which roll to order so it was convenient to eat half of each. Very savory meats and the roll just as good. highly recommend
We were craving lobster rolls and we found this place, it was delicious, a bit expensive but it hit the spot.
Luke’s Lobster is simply delicious—I’ve visited their Upper West Side location and the food at their East Side location was equally tasty and fresh.Certainly don’t expect bargain pricing—which you shouldn’t for lobster and seafood.The lobster roll is great and staff at both locations have been kind and professional.Expect to spend at minimum $25 and that’s just for a small meal—if you’re going in there super hungry far more—but it’s worth it for a treat, and you can’t fairly expect quality lobster to be cheap!
Just about the best lobster roll in town. Took a while to be seated but the lobster paired with their IPA and me and my wife absolutely loved it! Thanks again.
Good sandwich with lobster even if i prefer the most simple one: just lobster without any sauce or topping.In here they put some pepper and a special sauce that cover a little the actual taste of the lobster.I suggest to go if you are going around this zone!the service a little slow in the evening/night!
I had a bad experience with this spot.I walked past the door around 7:45pm on a weekend night and it took 5 minutes before anyone showed up to take my order.When someone finally did take my order, I was asked to sign my receipt which asks you to tip. Its already expensive as is ($24 for a trio with fries and drink) and I felt swindled by their tipping practice especially since they dont even have table service here.One this one particular experience it took over 20 minutes to get my food. A group of four had arrived 5 minutes after me and had not only gotten their food first but had also finished eating before my meal was even brought out to me.However, I do like the ambience and Im a fan of Luke Lobsters buttered rolls so thats the only reason why I didnt give this place a one star review.
Had the lobster roll with clam cowder. Soup was delicious, a bit on the salty side, well flavor with ingredients. Serve hot enough to burn your tongue. As for the lobster roll, why is it so cold? Even the toasted bread is cold. Would be much more delicious is its hot and freshly made, feels pre-made and left in fridge.
[EN] Superb Lobster. We enjoyed twice Lukes Lobster: the first time in Brooklyn, the second in the Upper East-side. Both really good.[IT] Aragosta buonissima. Provato due volte, a Brooklyn e nellUpper East-side, entrambi molto buoni.
Very simple yet tasty lobster. I do highly recommend. This upper east side restaurant has a very good service, and customers tend to have a friendly attitude.
My first time here and I loved it. I got full sooo quickly lol. I got the trio. My favorite was the lobster roll. The sizes look small but they are filling.
Food, Services, quality and tastes are nice and all... only thing that bug me was the smell of oil from cooking is overwhelm. If you are sensitive with smell, you better order eat out.
Very generous serving of lobster meat but the roll didnt wowed me. I was expecting a stronger marinate but perhaps most ppl like the raw taste of the fresh lobster! Just not my Favourite! Worth a shot if youre here still.
Loved it, great people and surprising delicious lobster sandwich, Maine style, fresh and great snack! The lobster chowder was a great snack too. Just a great stop over. (the wine was underwhelming...lol)
Simply love the food here and it wasnt crowded at all.Positives:1. Speedy service2. Very tasty lobster roll and mixed roll (crab, shrimps & lobster)Negatives.A. None which I could think of. 😊
I got the Lukes trio with crab, shrimp and lobster. I thought the shrimp and lobster were great but the crab was lacking in flavor. I usually love crab but there was just something missing today from the crab.
They gave you generous amount of lobster
Great lobster Rolls and excellent coleslaw. Fast service and very friendly considering its the UES. No snobbery just deliciousness.
I was a server in SF for several years, I don’t submit bad reviews lightly. $45 plus 15% tip for one walk-up counter lobster roll, a bag of potato chips, and a can of beer. The staff is aggressively unkind, for no reason at all. I’m honestly impressed. I love this area and the restaurants close by, but this place has got to go.
Had the clam chowder and half a lobster roll; go treat yourself to the full sandwich, it was delicious . Casual dining, fast service, clean restroom.
It is rare to find a good lobster roll in NYC, but Lukes has got it! Place is always packed out, but the service in my opinion is really great. I used to travel to Maine a lot, and some of the best lobster rolls I have ever had were there, but the lobster rolls at Lukes Lobster are not far off at all!
Make sure you get their stamp card so you can collect stamps for a free lobster roll. Seems like the best price for lobster rolls in the city.
We went early in the morning and the lobster abd crab where still too cold. But the roll and the filling was great. We went again to another shop of the chain.
Just order the 6 ounce Lobster Roll. If you order the 4 ounce, youll end up wanting more.
This place is on the pricey side but I recommend it for a weekday treat. The lobster role and clam chowder set me back $47 but Im not disappointed. Im glad I tried this place. Go for it if youre willing to spend extra on lunch.
Great customer service, cashier took the time to explain & appreciate that we came a long way. Food very fresh and delicious!!
Got the large lobster roll. Fresh and flavorful. You may need to order ahead when they get busy. Outdoor seating, parking in the area is not easy.
The lobster and crab rolls were seasoned well and fairly proportioned. I know the price seems high, but the rolls are quite stuffed with seafood. I think the lobster in the mac n cheese was lost. If they had just a little less butter, the crab and lobster would have shined through more, and its a shame because I can tell they are fresh and cooked properly.
Truffle lobster roll is amazing. New England clam chowder is almost as good as in Boston
Small lobsters but there are very fresh and delicious worth every dollar
Home of my favorite lobster roll in the city. Always get the Noahs Arc to share and have a little bit of everything.
I had New England clam chowder, a lobster roll, and a lobster grill cheese. The clam chowder has way too many potato but it was tasty. I suspect they put the ladle way at the bottom and grabbed too many potatoes. It tasted fantastic though outside of the imbalance of ingredients. The lobster roll was amazing and filling. It comes in two sizes and I got the smaller size. Huge chunks of lobster and everything tasted fantastic. The grill cheese was also great. Lobster is mild, so any strong flavors accompanying it seem to overpower the taste of the lobster but this grill cheese allows you to taste every piece of the lobster. They have benches to sit at outside and limited seating inside. As expected it is a bit pricey due to the menu revolving around lobster. I highly recommend the experience.
Lobster rolls in a pinch... We ordered 6 6oz rolls....Most were 7 oz with the bun. One was slightly less than 6 oz. (We got short changed in the lobster meat.....).They serve almost all tiny rubbery claws opposed to knuckle and tail meat.They are to heavy to heavy with the Old Bay seasoning. (Not a fan) I would rather have the traditional New England style lobster rolls.No, we wont be returning. Well wait for the Pearl Oyster Bar or Marys Fish Camp or another place to open. Alternatively, you can just have a fresh lobster. They should be a lot cheaper during the pandemic.The best part of the rolls was the neat packaging.
I had New England clam chowder, a lobster roll, and a lobster grill cheese. The clam chowder has way too many potato but it was tasty. I suspect they put the ladle way at the bottom and grabbed too many potatoes. It tasted fantastic though outside of the imbalance of ingredients. The lobster roll was amazing and filling. It comes in two sizes and I got the smaller size. Huge chunks of lobster and everything tasted fantastic. The grill cheese was also great. Lobster is mild, so any strong flavors accompanying it seem to overpower the taste of the lobster but this grill cheese allows you to taste every piece of the lobster. They have benches to sit at outside and limited seating inside. As expected it is a bit pricey due to the menu revolving around lobster. I highly recommend the experience.
I loved how cozy it was. The staff was excellent. Ill go back soon.
I love the atmosphere. Its a very nice place and very nice people working there. I ordered the Luke trio and was quite surprised at the size of the rolls for the cost. These are like 3 roll sliders for $20 also the seafood is cold. The actual roll was good. The food would have been much better if the crab, lobster and shrimp were warm. Although, I loved the environment I didnt think these sliders were worth the money.
The service was excellent, very friendly atmosphere and decor was relaxing & welcoming. The staff was super friendly. I had a lobster roll, which was ok, but I tasted better. I wasnt too keen on the seasoning - it couldve been better. It seems that a quick dusting of some type of seasoning was put on top. I would definitely pay them another visit & try some other goodies.
Good lobster rolls! Not cheap - but I remember getting a cheaper lobster roll off a food truck in LA some years ago and being disappointed in the amount of lobster. This one did not disappoint. They could use a few more options for main and side dishes, and drinks - but the focus here is on the seafood rolls, and the one I had was GOOD.
Chain lobster roll spot. Pretty tasty but tiny servings so be aware!
Very good lobster roll and fries! the ketchup was not that good ...
This place rocks! These lobster rolls are perfection! The roll was delicious and toasted to perfection, the lobster chunks were huge and covered in butter (whats not to like?!) and the ratio of seasonings to mayo is simply beautiful! Its simple food, done well, made right! If youre a lobster lover this tiny joint should definitely make your bucket list!
I love a good lobster roll. I also love a good crab roll and shrimp roll. Lukes has it all, along with crab claws and Maine Root soda! I always get the Noahs Ark and share with another person. It consists of one lobster roll, one shrimp roll, one crab roll, two bags of chips, two drinks and 4 crab claws. The rolls are cut in half so it is perfect for sharing! Theres a meal that is exactly half of this if you want the selection of all three shellfish but are dining solo. The seafood always tastes fresh and delicious. The bread is never too oily. And the seasoning is always perfect, not too much and not too little. The ONLY reason I would say not to try this place out is if you are allergic to shellfish. And even then, if youre only kind of allergic, it might be worth the few hours of the allergic reaction.Also must note that I am a HUGE fan of this location, definitely my favorite.
This place was such a nice little dig. The Lobster rolls were unbelievable and I had to go back and get another order. I also tried the triple rolls with crab, lobster and shrimp and it was sooooooo good. I wish I had my pics I took to post but I cannot find right now. The menu pictures are accurate here anyway. A little $$$ but you get what you pay for! Keep this place alive, totally worth it! num num num
Seriously High Quality! The lobster roll out of this world! When we get to Mars first shop up is Luke’s 🤣💥
The crab roll was delicious but the first bite had a big piece of shell. The lobster roll was great too. The cold slaw needs a little help favor wise.
Lukes Lobster has the best lobster rolls Ive ever tired! This place is a little hard to find because it is between the avenue and it is such a small place. It is easy to walk pass and miss it. But the rolls are so great! They pack the rolls with either lobster, shrimp, or crab meet. My favorite is the lobster rolls. The rolls are also nicely buttered and toasted! The only bad thing is the price. I mean it is a good price for fresh lobster meat but I cant afford to eat it all the time. They are $15 a roll. The rolls are also kind of small so I am still hungry after eating them. But they are too expensive to eat more than one.
Just off 2nd avenue, Lukes Lobster - the f first of many branches to be built around the world, offers that quaint, tranquil, relaxed environment to savor in complete abandon some of the best lobster rolls this side of Manhattan. Always juicy, tender and cooked to perfection, theyll happily use any holiday or event with a seafood theme to offer some kind of discuss on their trademark lobster rolls. They are just the right size to satisfy a quick ocean craving but be ready to shamelessly order a second serving for a complete full stomach. And their selection of beers pair oh so wonderfully with any of their menu items. Go there for the food, the chill space and the great food.
Great lobster! My favorite spot for rolls and clam chowder, and reasonably priced in my opinion for quality of food and neighborhood. Keep in mind it’s a small single register counter, so be prepared to wait a little during rush hours but a wonderful spot to dine solo or on a date.
Came here in the winter and was delighted with the lobster griled cheese. It was rich creamy with large chunks of fresh catch lobster. Of course we had to get their lobster roll too and although it was my first time eating a lobster roll being usually not a fan of lobster. I was delighted and the fresh toasted bread with the lightly marinated lobster was refreshing. Even though it was 40 degrees outside I didnt mind eating this cold plate because it really warmed my heart. My friend who absolutely hates seafood gave it a try and was very impressed although he loves grilled cheese.
The lobster roll was delicious and the workers were nice. This was my first time there and first time in NY. Visited this location (10/10/2021)
Pretty good lobster roll.but i had to lower my rating because even for lobster this is ridiculously expensive. When we paid we thought that the chips that came with the roll was just an alternate term for French fries...nope..it was a bag of chips lol...we spent 40-50 (with no beverage) for two small lobster rolls and 2 bags of chips
Love the Noahs Ark deal. The crab roll is maybe my favourite instead of the lobster roll, but the bread is so light and delicious and the blueberry soda is a treat. I wanna try the chowder next time. Lovely place to sit and chill and cool staff. Super fast service too.
I was having a craving for lobster, but I didnt want to go through the whole ordeal of finding a place that serves it, and paying an exorbitant amount for some upscale seafood dinner. I wanted something casual, and I found it at Lukes Lobster. I ordered the Taste of Maine for about $25 which comes with a 1/3 of a lobster, 1/3 shrimp and 1/3 of a crab roll, chips and a drink. It was nice to be able to sample each of the popular sandwiches served. They bread was light and buttery, and each of the filling were very meaty and lightly seasoned and dressed so that the taste of the seafood stood out. The portions were okay. Ive had larger elsewhere, but I was pretty full by the end. The only thing is that it was hard to find a seat without feeling elbow to elbow with the other diners. I know that is common in NYC, but it was still somewhat uncomfortable. Id go back though. It was great!
The portions are abysmally tiny for their price. I ordered a lobster roll with a side. One might expect a serious sandwich for the price. However, my expensive roll was a few pieces of very watery tasting lobster (which means its probably not as fresh as it should be, and likely frozen), on what appears to be a single toasted white bread slice. The only saving grace that earned them that one star, was a very tasty bottled soda. I highly recommend the blueberry drink even though its 40g of sugar.
This place is good! Not a lot of space inside to sit down, so you might want to take it to go. Food comes out quick. It was my first time having a lobster roll (or lobster for that matter) and I liked it ok, but the crab and shrimp rolls were awesome. The menu was a little different from the website when I went - no claws, so the combos were a little cheaper. Buns are hot, seafood is chilled, and it all works. They also sell Maine Root sodas.
Best lobster roll Ive ever had.
Delicious!!!! But pricey for the amount of food you get. Salty New England lobster hut feel -- although kind of small and not much seating. They dont over-mayo the lobster rolls like some lobster shops. Just a smear of mayo on the bread and then some delicious cold lobster meat on top with old pay. Perfection!
AMAZING! The lobster roll is REALLY good. Simple, fresh, friendly and tasty. The lobster is cooked and seasoned well and the butter flavour is so good! Would come back for a quick bite with some friends.
Great, efficient service despite our huge order. Love the quality of the lobster rolls here...they really pile on the lobster claws! We travel from Queens for these :)
I take everyone who visits me in New York to Lukes. Their lobster rolls are my favorite seafood. The shrimp rolls are also great, though I dont care for the crab. Clam chowder is excellent. So far Ive filled out two punch cards (10 lobster rolls and get one free), and Id be at at least three if I could stop losing them. Theyre expensive, but I dont care. If I lived closer Id eat here once a week.
Is this place authentic? My fiance and I went to Bar Harbor, Maine for a week where I ate lobster everything single day. I found myself saying, This tastes like Lukes Lobster, only to correct myself that its actually the other way around.Is it good? Ive completed nearly 4 Lobsta Mobsta cards (which is essentially 10 meals of crab, lobster, AND shrimp per card) and then some because I always forget the card. So Ive basically had about 50 meals here and only here at this location. Yeah, its good.Is it a good value? Its seafood from Maine cooked in NYC. Im not going to pretend its cheap but its definitely a good value.
This establishment is a cozy, clean, hip place to go to for scrumptious seafood. Also, they have now added french fries 😊 to the menu. The staff is very friendly and professional. Whether youre stopping by for lunch, dinner or on a date, you will not be disappointed with the service or the food which is so dam good.
Ive come to learn that everyone has a favorite lobster roll - people quibble over the buns, the seasonings, etc. My standard lobster roll is Lukes. The lobster is from Maine (his father was a Maine lobsterman) and is sustainably sourced, theres just a little bit of mayo on the buns, the lobster is drizzled with a touch of butter, lemon and spices, and thats it. Although the price seems steep at $16, its a lot of meat, and there are plenty of lobster rolls in the city that cost $25-$35. The lobster rolls here are my summer go-to. Bonus: this location has a restroom! (New Yorkers know thats not always the case.)
Steamed Shellfish Combination - As good as the Lukes Lobster Upper East Side was, this combo turned out to be even better! The broth was thin but was packed with herby and lemony flavors. Plenty of green-lipped and black mussels, steamer clams, and prawns for everyone. This was absolutely a welcome surprise!Lukes Lobster Upper East Side
Delicious you need to try this place at least once addicting flavor it’s that good cheers guys at Luke’s 🍻p.s. anyone talking about the price and portions being high and small has no clue what they are talking about. The cost of bringing lobster and serving it at that low of a cost is a gem because most restaurants can get away with giving less food for higher prices.
Ordered a lobster roll and a crab roll, the meat was great, however the bun was very cold and a bit soggy, which was different than what I used to have - warm and toasted, as I remember.
Had a trio, a lobster roll with clam chowder and lobster bisque yesterday. The rolls were all amazing! Though a bit small for the price. I like the chowder but lobster bisque is too salty for me.
Went here with a girlfriend last Friday and had a great time. More of a summer spot but we were in the mood for seafood. We both got the Lobster combo which was just the right amount and the seafood was so fresh. More of a low key ambience than I was expected but still enjoyable.
If youre a sucker for seafood, then youve come to the right place. Lukes lobster lets the flavor of the seafood speak for itself. With some butter and the barest of condiments, their lobster rolls are simple and delicious. I always get the Noahs Ark-because I like to try a little bit of everything-lobster, crab and shrimp. This place shows that you dont always need fancy decor and complicated flavors to drawn in customers-sometimes simplicity is the best way to go.
Amazing lobster roll. Wow! I love seafood so I have tried many. This place is great and the fries are also delicious. ....and they have an app to pay in advance or deliver, How cool is that.
If you want a lobster shack experience, its great. High table bar stool seating. NOT fancy. Lobster roll had huge chunks of meet in a buttery roll. Yum
Been there first time last week, tried Noahs Ark. There are 6cm small 4 pieces of different sandwiches in that menu. Tastes ok with cumin which they put in the rolls but as I said the portions are small and expensive. Their white cowder soup is delicious. You better try that soup. The far eastern server girl was nice, she has given us white chowder soup to try as a sample.
Great place to grab a bite with friends. Very easy going ambiance. The broccoli and cheese soup is tasty and perfect in the winter time. Also the sandwiches are a good option, the beer selection is good, but the portions are small
I had this today and it was sooooo delicious!! the bread is crispy and buttery and the lobster was juicy and flavorful! Will definitely come back! staff were really friendly too!
Very misleading almost fraudulent menu offering posted to Google. I ordered the Taste of Maine expecting what was described on Google menu listing. This is the equivelent of ordering a happy meal and the server however pleasant and friendly, charges you for the burger then when you receive it she chooses then to tell you that the drink and fries are ala cart , tranlation: will cost you extra. They no longer offer crab claws . . . big disappointment.The food is not bad, but it is not a legitimate culinary experience. The menu basically warns you that the soup is not made on premises but canned: made by Hurricanes soup.If you dont cook, you will enjoy it, but if you do cook, you will hate paying for something you could have made better at home for less.
First time there and I enjoy the food. Nice quite friendly staff.
Delicious! Super kind and friendly staff!
I tried the lobster roll and it was pretty good. I wish it was served warm and maybe some kind of Mayo or sauce. Other than that I had a great meal.
There are a number of Lukes Lobster places scattered around the city and in other States as well. Ive been to the upper west side location. Famous for their Lobster Rolls and after tasting one youll become a fan just as I did.
The price keeps creeping up, but the lobster quality is still unbeatable. Clam chowder is a recent addition to the menu that is excellent and can be added to any meal for a few well-spent dollars. The style is not-too-creamy with potatoes doing much of the thickening in a cross between New England and Rhode Island-style chowder.
This was a wasted trip to Manhattan for a small bowl of lobster mac and cheese which had only two small, and I mean miniscule pieces of lobster claw. No shredded lobster, and barely a hint of essence of lobster flavor. They should be ashamed of charging 15 bucks. I would not recommend this place to my worst of the worst enemies. 😲😬😝
Decent lobster roll — bread is soft and buttery, lobster is fresh, dressing is minimal. Portions are abysmally small, making prices a bit higher than they should be. Service is friendly.
Hi Luke’s Lobster! Your food is tasty, however the portions are very small and inversely proportionate to the price...For me it was fine, but my husband had to stop for a second lunch after this as it wasn’t quite enough.
Small friendly space friendly staff. Lobster aint cheap but thats just the way it is. They actually offer a pretty good deal on the combo and got some tasty sodas to go with your seafood.
Im a sandwich guy, and lets just say, the Taste of Maine was near the tops on my all-time list. I think they put crack in the perfectly buttered and toasty bread that delicately cradles the fresh seafood (which is not held back by overseasoning). Yes, its pricey...but I cant make these sandwiches at home.
The lobster roll and soups were standouts here. Great and fast service. I would highly recommend the sampler so you can also try the crab and shrimp rolls as well!
If you like lobsters this is the place for you. Always fresh always delicious.
The shrimp roll was very good!!!
The food is incredibly good, especially the shrimp sandwich.
I had the 6oz.truffle butter lobster roll, excellent taste ,but it was a little small.
It tasted like freshly defrosted lobster.
Their lobster rolls taste what lobster rolls should taste like. The heap of lobster is the star and there is some light seasoning/butter. I think I was expecting it to be larger, but I suppose it is lobster. The decorations are cute and the food is tasty.
Good food but the staff is quick, friendly and fair. Great place for a quick counter service lobster roll. Menu isnt large so you can get in and out need be.
A little slice of Tuscany in NYC.The best fresh mozzarella, home made sausage, sopresatta...I cant get enough. The guys behind the counter are so friendly & helpful - after only a few times here, they remember you and love what they do. Freshest ingredients.The ONLY down side to this place is its is CASH ONLY. I would rather pay with card b/c I would buy almost everything in the store!
Best lobster roll ever. No fillers, just sweet delicious lobster, a squeeze of lemon, butter and a bit of old bay like seasoning on a toasted buttery potato roll. All luscious. No shade.
The lobster roll is very good. Seating can be an issue when crowded but it is well worth it. They have found the perfect mixture of lobster, dressing and spices.
WHAT!! This place is awesome! My wife and I got the Noaks Ark for a little taste of everything and it was all really good. The butter had a stronger taste then I would have liked but the amount of mayo was perfectly respectful of the seafood.
Ive bought trio and was surprised for such a small size of portion for $20. And all rolls were cold, just bread and shrimps. Blue salad was not delicious. Stuff is friendly.
Amazing... Just amazing. First time here and service was outstanding, food was worth every penny. I highly recommend this place to everyone whos looking for quality fresh, delicious seafood. I dont have a problem with the portion and price when the food is this good, no exaggerations, but this is just my opinion. If the price is lowered or stays the same I dont mind. As long as the food is as good as this you can have my money!
Overpriced and no food. Note: the lobster and crab is served cold. On my way out I stop by Food Truck to get more food. I paid $28 for two baby rolls and a cup of soup.
Very friendly service, simple menu and delicious food. Crab roll and lobster roll were both wonderful! Cheaper than a lot of the other options in NYC.
Lobster rolls were good but on the smaller side. And the Mac n cheese was good just needed a little salt added to it! Overall, really good
I went to this place having never having tried lobster and it was amazing. This place is very well priced for what it is. You get a lot of lobster for the money. You can also get other seafood such as shrimp and crab.
A lobster shack in NYC! Maine lobster on a toasted roll as good as that as on a Maine pier minus the salt air.Quick takeout service and about four tables and a counter if you want to eat there. Crab, shrimp and soups round out the limited menu.
Lobster rolls are one of the best in NYC and priced well. Full of delicious lobster meat. Small place but great for a quick lunch.
Great Neighborhood Seafood Restaurant to Dine-out @, w/Traceable , Sustainable Seafood. Great homestyle Lobster Rolls light on Mayo generous on Lobster... great Customer Service Dominique Iz Awezome^,_,^ ----JURNORRIS
Have visited here a few years ago, and I`ll come soon. Can`t forget the lobster rolls of here.. more than half percent of reason why I go to NY again is here. Looking forward to consistent quality as then😊
Ive been a patron of their cuisine since they began. Always consistent seafaring delights served with a smile, staff is awesome! Love to hit them up when Im on the UES... 😉
This little place is nice. Lobster , Crab or Shrimps rolls are fantastic , prices are good and the soups are a must try. Ask for the poppyseed coleslaw.
Ive been coming to Lukes Lobster on the UES since they opened, about 2 years ago. All this time theyve been a goto spot for me - I know that if Im craving a lobster roll or lobster bisque I can go to Lukes Lobster and my craving will be satisfied for a reasonable price considering the quality and quantity of food youre getting. Well unfortunately, the other night I visited Lukes after a brief hiatus and was unpleasantly surprised - my usual, the Noahs Ark, had a change for the worse. Although it remains at its usual price of $38, the Noahs Ark no longer includes 2 orders of crab claws. While this doesnt seem like a big deal this tips the scale so that the price of the Noahs Ark is just too much for what youre getting. Especially considering the recent glut of Maine Lobster, if anything their prices should be decreasing for the same amount of food. I also had a crab bisque that was terrible. I unfortunately wont be going back.
Very disappointing, not very clean. The staff were rude and treat customers like theyre doing them a favor. Many other options for lobster. I wont be going back. Go elsewhere if youre smart.
It was so good, tender lobster and yummy roll. We’ll definitely stop by again.
When “you can’t make it to Maine”, this “standout” seafood chain’s “real-deal” lobster rolls – “chock-full” of “succulent” meat with “no filler” – are just about the “closest you’ll get” (and “priced accordingly”); the “utilitarian”, counter-serve setups suggest “takeout”, though wine and beer poured at some branches encourages lingering.
Good place to have a comfort meal. The lobster roll is a must try. Blueberry soda is totally worth the calories.
Food was good. Super expensive for a sandwich. I have 3* the options are limited, and I would have like the lobster heated, and not cold. A party of 3, and only 2 1/2 eaten sandwiches.
Not worth the hype. Lobster roll not impressive, nor was the crab roll. Just not impressed with the joint. That is what it is a little cramped hole in the wall, they stuck into what used to be the location of a great resturant.
I meet with friends this lovely place from time to time! This is the best place to dine. I visit this place routinely. The food is very good, the team is polite and the cost is good. I enjoy meeting in this restaurant over a good lunch.
Great rolls. Lobster by far was best. Little whole in the wall but seemed nice like a family restaurant.
This was my first time at Lukes Ill be back again for sure. The lobster grilled cheese was to die for Ive never had that type of grilled cheese. Its a really cool quaint spot it reminds me when I used to live in Boston
Lobster Rolls were only so so. The prices are way too high for what you get. Their beer and wine are way over priced. Burger and lobster is way better.
It was great food but I wish it wasn’t chilled seafood I like the lobster roll the crab rolls and the shrimp roll but I wish they was hot people was very nice
Simple menu, great lobster rolls! I also recommend the crab roll if you are hungry as they pack alot more meat onto it vs the lobster roll
Incredibly tasty! A little on the expensive side but the ambiance of the restaurant, great service, and extremely yummy lobster rolls makes it all worth it.
Yummy lobster roll. I like how they did not saturate the lobster in sauce because the sweet taste of the lobster claw came through. Staff was friendly.
Cold lobster no sauce, shrimp was tiny, crab on tiny roll. Root beer soda best thing out of this education.
Quiet music, friendly service and above all great food! Ill definitely be coming back here. Seats about 20 people and thats fine for move, peaceful and filling lunch/brunch.
I had hair in my soup.The guy who took my order he did not get it right.For a small store the service was slow.It took 25 minutes to get two combos.Cold food took to long!! I will never go back.And noboby had on hair nets or gloves.Their attitude was cold and distant.NEVER will I go back there.
The food was great. The place on the Upper East side isnt that big. but it was Cozy.. and if youre like me and dont read menus fully.. most of the food is Chilled. So that was a new experience.
Sooooo gooood!! You must go! Get the regular lobster roll, not the 3 sampler. I found it lacked the full taste of a whole roll.
Love Lukes! It goes without saying that their lobster roll is amazing, but you should also try the shrimp roll. It is so good.
Torn between my review. Its a nice quiet and chill little place with pretty good roles, BUTTT - I really think the portion has gotten much smaller and is definitely a bit overpriced for what you get.
Pretty good. Fairly expensive for what you get though. Ran out of fries too so the only other side was a poppy seed slaw which I wasnt crazy about..
Great value for money. Lobster packed in to the roll and lightly flavoured, not slathered in mayonnaise. A quick stop, not room to take your time.
Good Lobster roll and fries.The jumbo option feels overpriced. There isnt much difference between the regular and jumbo.
This is where I go for lobster rolls, hands down. Cool hangout spot. Great service. Good happy hour specials too. Looking fwd to my next visit.
The lobster, crab, and shrimp was delicious. 10/10
Very clean, friendly servers, and the food is amazing. Best lobster rolls in NY with lobster fresh from Maine.
Great lobster, crab and shrimp rolls! Very consistent. They have a few other locations throughout the city.
I live a few blocks away and I always liked this place. Been here a few times, a bit pricey but great lobster rolls.
Was very well decorated for the holidays and extremely clean. Food was delicious, seafood was tasty and matched perfect with the buttery bread.
It was a pleasure to visit Lukes Lobster. My first lobster roll and I really loved it! Couldnt wait to visit you soon!
Food not delicious , too salty. Have to drink a lot water to relieve the thirsty after lobster roll and crab roll. It is not worth it with price we pay for.
Bert is a neighborhood hero and now he is leaving the Lukes Lobster team. But I will still go back. We will miss u Bert. Congrats on your new gig.
Checked this place out after searching for the best lobster rolls in New York, I wasnt disappointed .. But I wasnt satisfied either.. The crab roll I ordered was actually the best Ive had but I paid almost 20 dollars for something that left me starving after... I think they need to have slightly bigger portions... This was literally a hotdog bun stuffed with crab, a nice butter hotdog bun but its still a hot dog bun... Not Big Enough Lol.
I honestly liked the dishes and service, awesome location to my apartment. The staff members are always super friendly. Will come visit again.
Smaller than I expected... and not a cheap.
Everyone schoud taste it 😉amazing lobster🦞 shrimp 🍤 rollsJust try
I highly recommend this place. We didnt have to wait long for food and the lobster roll was very fresh and delicious.
Lobster straight outta Maine. Best lobster rolls in NYC
Ok so I was all hype about Luke lobster and it was very mediocre I had a better roll from burger and lobster. The customer service is awesome. Hints the 4 stars
Best lobster roll in NYC! Lobster is cooked perfectly and not lost in sauce/roll flavor.
A little pricey for me but the sandwiches are really delicious. Employees are friendly and the atmosphere is comfortable for a casual lunch or dinner.
Best lobster rolls I have ever had. Worth every penny.
Seriously! How can I not love Lukes Lobster? Awesome concept (sustainable lobster) and delicious Lukes trio! OMG. Im drooling while writing this review!
I liked this place. It was recommended and we stopped by and it was really great. I totally recommend this place.
Lobster roll was heavily peppered and not sweet, moist or very fresh tasting.
Love this very casual place the serves the lobster very simply so you can really taste the flavor and texture of the lobster.
Fantastic food, welcoming staff members, always great character. They charge fair prices and the food quality is great. Fantastic work.
Delicious crab rolls, clam chowder, and lobster corn bisque! Very pricey (especially the soup)
This locations is not so clean. They need to do alot better with keeping this locations clean. Ive had hair in my food and another time I gave it another try and it smelled horrible in the restaurant. 😔
Hands down probably the best lobster roll in NYC. Not doused in mayo, just lots of delicious lobster meat on a bun. Must try!
Lobster rolls were deliciously moist n succulent! Cant wait to go back 👍
The trio just as good as appetizer, then you can’t stop to order your favorite one. Lobster, shrimp or crab rolls.
Stunning food fresh from the sea and sustainable. Lobster rolls are a must order.
Dont like the ordering process. We sat for 20 minutes, waiting for our food, only to discover they had given it to the wrong customer who promptly obscounded with our paid for order. And they gave it to a woman named Manuel! Really???
Always good albeit expensive.
Great lobster rolls and other options but the price always hurts.
Took the tail n kale to-go !! And a NE chowder. Momsy loved it !! Gotta go back.. She may just order it tho, cant wait on me 😝😝😋
The portions are actually smaller than I expected but quite tasty. The soda it was not so fond of however.
Went today after seeing 4 + stars on the review... This place is just ok. The portions are very small and should be cheaper in price. But I guess youre paying for location.
I love the Jumbo Lobster Roll and Lobster Bisque!!!!
Very good lobster rolls! Nice location and friendly staff.
Service always seems a little bit off but food is excellent. Shrimp roll and clam chowder are delicious!!
Always a treat. I got my first punch on a loyalty card, Lobsta Mobsta.
Split the Noahs Ark. I actually liked the shrimp and the crab roll better than the lobster roll, but all were great!
Lobster roll, no butter, some sea salt chips, a root beer. And a quiet sit watching the upper east side shift and move enjoying their evening out.
Expensive for that much portion. Also very very uninformed personnel. They serve me half glass of beer. And plates are so basic.
Good lobster, great sandwiches and a good variety of bread to choose from!
Very nice lobster roll. The bun has a buttery flavor to it.
The food was good but pricey, tiny lobster rolls for a lot.
Fresh and great tasting soups and rolls and great customer service. I highly recommend you try this place.
Hearing they were from New England was looking for a New England sized lobster role with butter... for nyc was one of the better ones though...
Really solid lobster rolls done far from Maine. Hard to beat without a long drive.
Small place, good vibe casual spot. Simple menu. Crab roll, lobster roll, slaw
Love coming to Luke’s for their lobster roll. Deliciously fresh, so yummy.
Lobster Roll was Excellent. My 1st time there will not be my last.
Flavorfull lobster roll,a bit small do
Total reviews rating 4.4
199 Reviews for Lukes Lobster Upper East Side 2023:
Review №1
2022-05-16Lobster cant taste bad so obviously it was delicious. the sampler was a good way to try out the shrimp, lobster, and crab (each piece was 2oz whereas the regular size was 4oz & larger size was 6oz which just has more meat). this place is if youre willing to spend a good amount of money for yummy sandwiches. understandable for fresh seafood. but hey at least they give you a free bag of chips lol
Review №2
2022-06-28Great lobster roll! Super tasty and very well served. Super friendly staff.
Review №3
2021-09-12Simply the best. 4oz lobster roll and a glass of rosé. The lobster is generous and buttery, the bread warmly toasted to perfection. They’re quick w service. It’s a nice treat to myself.
Review №4
2019-02-03I’m not a lobster/seafood fanatic but the lobster rolls are 5 stars, perfectly seasoned, full of flavor and not overdone on the butter. Shrimp and crab rolls were good but nothing crazy.As some have mentioned, the portion sizes are small and did not fill me up. Lobster roll is on a hot dog size bun. Given the price point I was expecting a bit more, would have paid an extra $5 for a hero sized roll. Better for a lunch or someone who prefers a smaller portion.Decor was inviting, small place, normal service. Hybrid of casual fast food and sit down style (waited 8-12 min for food to come out). It’s in the category of ‘am I suppose to tip or not?’5* for the lobster roll quality and visual appearance of food.4* for the rest of the food and atmosphere3* for the price to portion ratio ($$$ is probably more accurate)
Review №5
2018-04-22Honestly, would’ve given them a 5-Star rating if we just had the lobster roll. It was absolutely stuffed with thick CHUNKS of soft sweet sweet lobster and it was just delicious, especially if you enjoy being able to actually taste the lobster and not be overwhelmed by the butter and sauces/mayo that some places tend to stuff their rolls with to overcompensate for the lack of lobster meat. NOT here.Yes, the portion size is slightly small for the price BUT the flavour more then compensates for it.The lobster Mac and Cheese, on the other hand, lacked much lobster. There were only two pieces in ours, in fact. But the m&c was creamy and soft so it wasn’t bad overall, just expected more lobster.Staff are super friendly and amazing too!
Review №6
2018-04-15Amazing lobster roll, tons and tons of tender, juicy lobster meat cooked to perfection in a roll toasted with garlic butter, with thyme and herbs sprinkled on top. With a side of chips and coleslaw, what more can a man ask for?Coleslaw was as one might expect, crunchy fresh cabbage and carrots in a savoury tangy dressing, topped with some cracked pepper.A big plus is that the Lobsters come from a sustainable source and are farmed ethically. Definitely worth a visit if youre in the area!
Review №7
2018-05-27A small but very good restaurant in the style of a fast food lobster place. The menu is limited to a small number of items. The lobster rolls are great and the cole slaw is very good. There is no wait staff but the kitchen will bring out your food. There is only a handful of tables here.
Review №8
2020-11-21Was in UES yesterday, our old neighborhood, decided to walk around and ended up having dinner here.First time at a Lukes Lobster so I was trying to not have the highest expectations versus what weve enjoyed in Newport, RI. Turned out to be really good!I ordered the lobster roll with bisque and drink, opted to upgrade to a 6 oz rosé for an additional $8. Hubby had the crab roll + lobster mac & cheese. And yep, strategically always good for sharing everything! Their bisque was deliciously comforting. The lobster mac & cheese was actually surprisingly really good. Hubby enjoyed the crab roll and I also loved the lobster roll. They have a small outdoor dining area outside and on a beautiful not so cold evening, this was absolutely perfect!Staff were also great. Polite, smiling, actually liked taking care of customers type. May actually use that loyalty card as it works for UWS branches too! On our way out, we waved and thanked the team who took care of us, with a quick thumbs up! Thanks guys! This will definitely help satisfy our New England cravings until its safe to be traveling again! Well be back!
Review №9
2020-02-26Yummm delicious.my first time there as soon we came in we was services the place was not pack .and customer service was fast.its a nice small cozy place with seating wish its a plus. I was caugh of guard cuz I didnt know the lobster and crab was served cold .it was delicious tho would love some garlic butter and parsley on my rolls .I like that u could tasted its real crab meat n lobster ..would definitely recommend this place and I be going back for some more ...👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Review №10
2022-09-17Best lobster Ive eaten ! Cooked just right and delicious. Service was great and cordial and fast.