Delivery
Yes
Make My Fish in New York
Categories
Location on the map
New York, New York County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Planning
Usually a wait
Yes
Payments
Cash only
Yes
Phone: +1 917-388-3138
Site: http://makemyfish.com/
Site: http://makemyfish.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:11:30AM–8PM
- Wednesday:11:30AM–8PM
- Thursday:11:30AM–8PM
- Friday:11:30AM–9PM
- Saturday:11:30AM–9PM
- Sunday:Closed
Comments (199)
The sides are so good!!! They do not taste over processed they taste like as if you made them in your home!!! Please dont change the recipe or water it down!!! I support black business!!! 🥰🥰🥰
This take out only fish spot is on my list of favorite spots in Harlem. Make my fish hands down has earned my fried seafood cravings money.I ordered the whiting and chips. The cost, portion size and quality of food makes this the biggest steal in Harlem. I order at least once a week.The whiting fish is always fresh, crispy and perfectly seasoned. The crinkle cut fries does a perfect job to compliment the fish.The 4 piece fish and chips has enough portion size that I am always able to save some for later. Then Make my fish makes my day.
Everytime I come to NY I make sure I go to Make My Fish for a shrimp dinner! The shrimp is fried to perfection, the collard greens and mac and cheese is GREAT, everything taste like it was made right in Nanas kitchen!!! I tell everyone about this place, it comes HIGHLY recommended by me!
Totally Seasoned to Perfection and Fried Crispy enough to satisfy any pallet.I have ordered it both in person as well as through Uber Eats and never been disappointed. They give you plenty of fish and its well worth the minimal price.Excellent!!In the picture is the fried catfish.
Melt in your mouth Catfish. My go to when I want fish. And there sides no words. My favorite is there potato salad sooo good. 👍🏼 😋 👌
I happened to be in the area and noticed Make My Fish! So I had to check it out after Paint & Sip. The place is well lit, Cashier was professional and kind. She acknowledged me immediately to tell me shed be with me in a few as she was finishing up with a customer. I heard 2 customers talk about their catfish and how good it is. So Ill be trying that next time. I ordered a fish sandwich and my gawsssssh. It was sooo good. Seasoned well, good portion. I would definitely make the trip from the Bronx just for that fish again. The staff are pleasant and professional. I enjoyed my time in the establishment. P.S. Ill update more pics as I go😁
The only reason I m giving 3 stars isnt for the food...food is good the lady was very pleasant because I tried to order with her an was at the wrong counter....The order young lady was clearly on her cell phone that the young pleasant lady who gives your food had to tell her to take the order an get off your phone....its a shame someone else has to tell u to get off the phone when clearly you are in the service industry....
This was some of the best tasting fish and shrimp I’ve had in a long time. We ordered the Triple Play, Mac&Cheese and Candied Yams. Everything was DELICIOUS!!! The prices are fair and the food is yummy. It’s worth it. The portions are surprisingly large for what you pay! They give you your money’s worth. I’m definitely going back for more.
If you love fried fish, this is the place. Theyre shrimp or fish and grits is a must have!!!
4/29/21,The best CATFISH, I come from the Bronx just for all fish catfish $12. The best!! They have side orders also!
This was my first time at Make my fish and I was not disappointed. This restaurant was recommended to me by a friend a while ago. This morning I was in the mood for fish and grits and decided to give this place a shot. I’m glad I did. The fried whiting were perfect, crispy, flaky on the inside and seasoned just right. The shrimp are crunchy and the batter has a sweet kick to it which is very pleasing. The wait time was little to none and I received my order in under five minutes. Everything was hot and fresh! The cheese grits has bit too much cheese in it but once you eat it with the fish it kinds of balance out. I gave 4 stars because of the cheese if there was a little less it would be perfect. I will be there again, maybe sometimes this week.
It must be their mother’s recipe! OMG!!!!!!I went there for the 1st time (fish, shrimp, greens &Mac & cheese). I had to pull over in the car, just soI could dig in! The sides were ok but those shrimp!!they were freshly made with a sweet taste. The fishSo good and crispy as a potato chip! Love it!Same as the Fish on 145th…
The person at the register greeted me & took my order. The service was swift and seemless. Although there was an unprofessional playful bantor, to me it felt like my familys kitchen. The food . . . . . .BANGIN!!! (Side note: Slim tall brother in the back care for your hygiene in the restroom and wash your hands)
I never knew Make My Cake had a fish spot.. Amazing food & they never disappoint
THIS IS BY FAR HANDS DOWN THE BEST FISH MARKET IN HARLEM YOU WOULD EVER FIND SHRIMP & CHIPS IS MY FAVORITE MEAL GO CHECK IT OUT PPL !
Attention Brooklyn Make My Fish is the TRUTH!! I ordered the fish with shrimp oh my goodness. I also had the lemonade and the ice tea. Oh my goodness, listen this is DEFINITELY the spot I promise you. We need them to come to Brooklyn like yesterday. Tell your family, friends, neighbor, pastor, co worker, lawyer take that ride up there its DEFINITELY worth it you wont be disappointed. Make My Fish will make its way to Brooklyn but for now make your way there....
Really great fresh food ready within minutes of ordering. All around 5 stars!
The catfish is my favorite 😍 Love this place Great food
Honesty is their best policy! I inadvertently ordered twice on Uber Eats, and not only did they offer to give me the extra order for free, they also called Uber Eats right away to cancel it. Food wise: it’s consistently good and I’ve never been disappointed at this place. Please support our local Harlem fish place. And yes, New Yorkers are kind.
Im from Savannah Ga. Make My Fish taste like my moms. I always get whiting fish. Tonight first time trying shrimp.. They have the best tasting seafood. shrimpgot my fish n my first time
Make My Fish came highly recommended by my Uncle Charlie, The King of Charles Pan Fried Chicken. Let me tell you.... When I say the CATFISH WAS GOOD I MEANT EVERY WORD OF IT... HUNTEE... the catfish was to die for! Thanks Alex!!! You’re super kind and professional!!! It was a sincere pleasure meeting you! Wishing you the very best success in this business! I thank you for the great advice on my own grab and go, which will be coming very soon in the Bronx! Please recommend some of those great employees you have!! Everyone is so kind, hard working and NOT ON THEIR CELL PHONES!!! I am looking forward to seeing you again real soon! Thanks for everything!!! Last but not least, my family loved, loved all of the whiting, catfish, shrimp and the sweet potato salad!!! MAKE MY FISH IS ADDICTING!!! Support SUPPORT and most importantly ENJOY YOUR FOOD!~GEORGETTE
I live 2 hours away. Everyytime I try to get there, either they closed or closing. Well I made it for thr first time this weekend. BAAAABY. THE CATFISH NUGGETS the shrimp the all fish. And the sides. 😋😋😋 I love supporting my people. I will definitely be back. The only downside was the smell when I entered. Buy my mask helped somewhat with that. It was all worth it. 🥰
Definately a take out spot. Not a bad place for a quick lunch though.
Amazing food! The white fish, shrimp and fries are all delicious (the cat fish is not as good). Everything is very juicy, the ingredients taste fresh, and they are fried to a perfect extent! Definitely coming back to try their chicken and clam😆
Customer service is far from great and If youre accustomed to southern style fried fish this is not the place for you. Your better off ordering from the place across the street if southern is your style. The fish here wasnt nasty just also wasnt good. I have never ate catfish that taste the way theirs do. It tasted like rubber.
The employees are super friendly, and the fish is always fresh to order.its worth the money and wait 💥
Man them shrimp 😍😍 definitely my new Go To Spot fasho.
Always good. Flavorful. Well worth the money. Portions are perfect. Catfish and shrimp my favorite..havent tried the sides yet. This place is at the top of my chart.
Not too many places I will rate 5 stars but MMF exceeded my expectations. Its like those old back in the day fish and chips places in Harlem that evolved. The food was good and the fish was fresh and nicely seasoned. I chose the Mac and cheese with greens as sides and was not disappointed...at all. Customer service was courtesy and welcoming 👍
I’m a regular here, however the girl cashier who answered the phone yesterday is ratchet. Turned me off completely aside from my order being messed up. Spent $38 on shrimp and got the complete opposite. Mac & cheese was spoil (tangy) taste and the candy yams was about the ONLY edible thing. I’m disappointed because when I’ve went in person things were better. It was good while it last!
Im from Savannah, Ga. where foods taste so different n seafood is King. A little salt, pepper, some times a little season all is enough for me. I love, Make My Fish, the fish cause it taste like my moms.
I’m a regular here, however the girl cashier who answered the phone yesterday is ratchet. Turned me off completely aside from my order being messed up. Spent $38 on shrimp and got the complete opposite. Mac & cheese was spoil (tangy) taste and the candy yams was about the ONLY edible thing. I’m disappointed because when I’ve went in person things were better. It was good while it last!
Decent food here, def recommend the shrimp
First and foremost i have to give you yall props.. the food was delicious catfish/shrimp and chips was everything. I wouldve gave a five start review, however i have to respectfully say.. can yall change the floor mat or wash it because it doesnt smell good.ThanksOne love Peace and blessings
This is the perfect example of an amazing hole in the wall fish fry spot. It looks kind of janky, but the fish is outstanding. Might be the best fried catfish Ive ever had. My only negative is that the catfish sandwich is just a regular order of catfish with two slices of sandwich bread. Just putting the fish on a bun with sauce would be amazing, but its a little weird that the bread came in a ziploc bag. It was still incredible fish and Id definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for fried fish in Harlem. Also, the fried shrimp is on point as well.
The fried fish & shrimp here is good, I didnt like the French fries, wouldnt recommend ordering the fries. The potatoe salad is really good & I am very picky about who & where I eat potatoe salad from. The collard green & mc & cheese are descent
The fish is great AND THE FOOD but the owner very unprofessional. He should be careful what come out his mouth the neighborhood is looking. VERY UNPROFESSIONAL YOU CAN RUN A BUSINESS BUT YOUR CUSTOMER SERVICE IS ZERO VERY INPATIENT AND HE TOTALLY BELLIGERENT. DONT FORGET WHERE YOU COME FROM.
Nice clean place. Great service. The workers there are friendly. The wait for my food was quick and the food was also delicious. I have no complaints. I ordered shrimp & grits for myself and tasted the fish dinner i purchased for my friend. Both meals were perfect. Ill definitely return to this establishment when im craving fried seafood.
The food here is soooooo dammmm good lawd 🥰🥰🥰🥰having my daughter baby shower in December using them for that good Ole fish 🥰🥰😛😋😋😋😋and collard greens 😀 and potato salad 🥰🥰🥰😋😋they have the best everything 😋
I have only tasted the catfish and chips. And each time the catfish was well seasoned and delicious . They give a good portion , enough to split with another person but once you eat it you may want it back.Update : besides the catfish their shrimp is omg!!! Best I’ve ever tasted . The sides are decent . Beware ordering thru Uber eats . The prices are more online than in store .
The fried Whiting is deliciously seasoned with a peppery(not overly...a bit more than a hint), batter. It is freshly made (high turnover) and never oily. The shrimp are xl and seasoned well too. Shrimp and Whiting combo gets you about 5-6 medium sized Whiting along with about 6 of the shrimp all of this for $16. The tartar sauce is even good. It adds to the flavor but never distracts from the flavor of the food. If you ever went to a southern fish fry and enjoyed it-its like that. There is a bit of a wait but you can call in your order too. They have mac and cheese, collards, candied yams. All of the food is very very tasty. The staff is friendly and professional. I wish they would open a spot on the lower east side. We like fried fish too. Lol.
Honestly, I cant think of anything thats really special about MMF, but its one of the best fried fish places in NYC thus far. Thier sides are a little suspect, but thankfully their seafood never disappoints. Oh, and their lemonade is bomb - Just mad sweet. Definitely recommend.
Called in advance by the time I arrived the food was ready. Staff was extremely pleasant! Place was clean. Catfish and Shrimp Combo came with way more than expected. Shrimp was a little bland but Catfish was seasoned and fried to perfection. I’d definitely recommend!
The food is delicious. I always get prime time which is seasoned to perfection. The shrimp fish and grits with cheese are excellent and they give you alot of food. Would definitely recommend eating there. The workers are extremely nice and professional as well.
Jut went there last night with my dad. I ordered the chicken and chips. I absolutely loved it! That meal was delicious and it certainly filled me up on the train ride back home. The food took a little while to cook but it was worth the wait. The food there is cooked fresh and the workers there have a positive attitude towards their costumers. So go on and visit the make my fish restaurant in Harlem!
I stop bye and bought 3 different orders and my favorite was the shrimps. They fish and chips was on point. Shrimp and fries last was the all shrimps lawd since I left the store been eating the shrimp while on my journey back home. Thank you Ray Grind for the recommendation it was worth the trip
I went there last Friday (11/1) after many many months of procrastinating. The food was delicious! I ordered catfish and fries and just fish (whiting). We totally enjoyed our meals. Next time I will order mac and cheese and collards! Looking forward to going back, and Im telling all my neighborhood friends as well!
Good customer service. I bought whitening fish n fries . Whitening fish was so oily and greasy.
We love this place. The fish is fried & seasoned just right. The shrimp are unbelievable. We always start to eat our food in the car, can never leave them til we reach home
I love the freshness of the fish they give a plenty full amount for the price. I usually get catfish and shrimps with a side of cheese grits which is always fresh and tasteful.
When I pay Uber prices somehow I am expecting the whole experience. But this establishment at times 4gets to send u ALL ur food that u ordered so you have to call and discover that ur order was not read correctly. I was trying the Uber Special of supporting local black merchants. Always a problem here. Sometimes they cheat u outta ur $13.00 shrimp order . You should get 8 sometimes only 6 will make it. But when they are on they are on.
Staff was nice. Cashier greeted you with a smile and a hello. The food is delicious the collards, yams, Mac & cheese 😋.
Food is good, but they are slow as hell. How you going to be slow getting the food out during peak dinner hours.......Its been a while since Ive posted the first part of the review. Theyve improved on getting the food out faster and the fish is still good and the customer service is good too. Ill re-post if that changes.
Best Fried Fish in Harlem. The fish is so fresh tasting, the shrimp was perfect in size and so fresh you could taste the sweetness of fresh shell fish. Little or no salt is used in the fry batter, which allows you to taste the fish. Pricing is excellent for the quantity you received.I would recommend this restaurant!!!
My 1st time eating here was today! A few coworkers & I made a big order... and EVERYTHING was great!!!!!! I got the triple play ( catfish, fried shrimp and fried whiting) and a Whiting fish sandwich. For my sides I got potatoe salad, mac & cheese and yams! 1st but wont be my last time ordering! Thx to Mr. Pat & Alex! Your patience & professionalism is greatly appreciated!!
I had the fish and shrimp dinner w/ 2 sides (MacNCheese + Collard). This is my 2and time getting food and I havent been disappointed. Everything is made fresh and there is little to no wait time. Portion sizes are large, enough for 2 sittings. I will be coming back!
Oh my heavens. This place is unfathomable. The fish is so fresh, so crunchy, so delectable.The batter on the fish n chips is barely there, so it’s not “over battered” where it feels like you’re just eating a chicken nugget, no. This batter is PERFECT.If you “claim” to like food at all? Then you must try Make My Fish atleast once in your life. Otherwise, why are you even here?
The mac and cheese was bland and taste like black pepper, the yams were under cooked and had way to much cinnamon and not enough sugar. I mean the fish was ok, so its not a place Ill be returning. Oh and the guy fishing the fish is on the and cooking at the same time, thats definitely a health code violation.
Their peach cobbler is the bomb. All their dishes taste great. Service is excellent, wonderful hospitality skills.
Been to Make my fish numerous times, the place is clean, staff very professional food is out of this world, bye bye 145 St Nick. I truly recommend
Literally just got my food from there 20 minutes ago the wait was nothing at all and the food is absolutely to die for I come here from Jersey and everybody was very professional, the restaurant was very clean the only issue that I had was that it’s all cash so other than that it’s not really an issue just a little bit inconvenient ! Fish with fried too perfection and the french fries absolutely perfect!!! If you’re looking for a quick bite thats quality and quantity and not too overly expensive this is your best bet ! THANK ME LATER❤️
I didnt think the ppl handling the food were clean enough around the food. A guy that walked in from outside walked in and hugged a guy. They guy he hugged had on gloves, hugged him back and continued fixing food for the customers without changing the gloves. The guy that came in with his coat on fixed himself 2 side dishes of Mac and cheese and collard greens, wrapped it up and started talking. The guy also was walking funny when asked why he said it was sciatica disc problems. When I did receive my food after about 28 minutes later, I did not like it. It didnt seem to be too seasoned. I ordered shrimp and fish along with clams. I got home and threw the majority of the food in the garbage. I traveled all the way from Queens. I will never go to Make My Fish on 116th again.
The fish is Everything! Very well seasoned. It was my first time there but definitely not my last. I cannot wait to try all the other delicious stuff they have on the menu. If it is as good as the fish I may not ever cook again..lol.. A must try.
The fish is good. Mac and cheese is decent sometimes its good sometimes okay. The candied yams are good but one day I dont know why It didnt taste like candy yams. I go every saturday for dinner. The wait is fast. Longest I waited for my food was 5 minutes.
Nyc is turning to a place where better to eat at home . Consistent good food is hard to find . But the price will surely keep going up and quality of the meal will keep going down . You would think Dylan Roof ordered from this place yesterday 🤢🤢🤢
What I like about this place is the quality of the shrimps. Shrimp and chips here is so delicious for $13.00, yes a bit expensive I do agree. However! I do appreciate good food and I have spent more money than on food o didn’t enjoy lol so I Indulge 2x a month!
Eat here frequently. Nothing is perfect. Close to it.
Make sure your potato salad is in the bag!!. This is the second time I didnt get mine and they pack the order so tight you dont realize till youre home. Fish good tho!
The catfish nuggets is to die for literally, I would give them a full 5 stars but when you walk in & you see the young folks (20s-mid) behind the counter preparing the food they always gyp you in the amount that you are supposed to get for the price you spend. When you see the older folks (40s-mid) then you know that you are getting your monies worth. So every time Im around that neighborhood I will take a peek inside to see who is doing the cooking which dictates will I buy or not.
Nice location. Food didnt take long. . Whiting fish was good. Fried shrimo a little to greasy and overly breaded. I do plan to try again, because the catfish was not available when I came.
I ate the Fish dinner, had 2 side order of collard greens, they were absolutely tasty. I also enjoyed fried fish. Just be ready to wait on line order ur food.
Terrible customer service, I call several times to try to place an order. However, the person that was taking my order was not paying any attention to what I was trying to order. I called three times after that trying to place the order I was placed on hold for a long period of time and forgotten about. However once the young man picked up the phone again .He informed that I should just come in and place my order instead of placing an order for pick up because it wasn’t a big order. Also he stated that it wasn’t busy , this is not how you treat customers that are trying to support your businesses...(SMH)
The Best Catfish in Harlem...Love 💘 this place...and The Staff is Amazing u wont be disappointed ...oh the Red velvet cake is Best only on Friday and Saturday
If they had availability to provide 10 stars, I would, I had chicken, shrimps, fish, Mac and the amazing grits and cheese omg I loved it so much. This made me happy.
You can tell they fry they fish in fresh grease which makes a world of difference!!! Love the catfish and cheese grits and Mac and cheese. I just hope they stay this way.
I love the little place I wasnt sure about how the food, fish would be it can be crowded with people standing around the order line was never soo long its the people waiting for their orders that creates the crowd I thoroughly enjoyed my fish and shrimp order this was my third time there and the fish was pretty good each time
If you want food from here call in before you go in. Whenever I go it is always crowded. But the fod is good. I always get the fish dinner.fish could use a little seasoning though but besides that worth the wait
Excellent. They have the BEST Mac & Cheese and Shrimp of any restaurant. You can compare it to your mommas mac !
My BFF and I were just talking about needing a fish spot. My daughter told us about Make My Fish on 116st btw 7th & Lenox Ave. I loved the fish and collard greens. My BFF said he definitely enjoyed his dinner too. He had fish, mac & cheese and yams. We will definitely go back for fish and a sample of their cheese grits. I dont eat cheese grits, but honey it was really good. I definitely will be getting some to go with my fish the next time we go back.
I just passed front of the restaurantI didnt enter inside
First impressions: Door is nearly impossible to open. No NY.C Health Department letter grade.Food is good and servings are huge. Customer service is poor with the exception of the pick up window.
Customer service is the worse. God bless the girl at the counter. She is rude. The fish was good. with these times spending money is hard. Customer service has to be good.
Great food all the time...busy ,quiet, quick, smells delicious...best catfish in Harlem New York.
Not many soul food fish & chips places like back in the days. This is down home harlem style fish &chips joint. The fish, collards, macaroni cheese, and fried jumbo shrimps are off the chain!!!
Great friendly service, Fish was fried perfectly golden, season was on point and prices are more than reasonable. Its a small spot, seating is limited, buy other then that this is the spot for fish!
I give them 5 stars because the food is ALWAYS on point...amazing customer service but when i call and pre order when i get there its still a wait.. I mean i get it made fresh!! But if i called and im on my way, shouldnt you start my order and not wait until i get there...but other than that i love love love the food
The bomb. I moved to the south but when I went to the worlds best church #fcbc , I would eat from this place 2x a week. The shrimps are delicious. CAUTION, YOU MAY GET ADDICTED
Their food is tasty, my first time ordering through uber eats (catfish and shrimp combo with two side) half of my order (shrimps) was missing I informed them via UE and I was refunded my entired order which I didnt complain about being that I did receive a portion of my meal... But the next time I ordered (bout a month later) I received my complete order with additional order of shrimps i dont know if they remember my order from before or it was because my order was about 15 minutes late either way Im pleased with their service
I spend more time in make my fish than I do in my own kitchen The food is great the customer service is exceptional
Light and flaky and crispy and tasty!!!
I drive here every Friday from Long Island to eat the best fried shrimp & whiting ever TGIF!!!!
My fish was fried to an extra crisp. And when I touched it with my fingers it crushed into crumbs.This happened the last 2 times that I patronized them.
If you didnt know this is the original famous fish that was on 145th and St. Nicholas... The one there now is just making money from the clientele built by these owners.
Great Food and reasonably priced. Really nice staff and owner. Probably my new favorite fried seafood spot here in Harlem.
Amazinggggg...Service great. Catfish INCREDIBLE. Seasoning was perfection... will definitely be coming back. So glad their right around the corner from my apartment.
The fish at Make my Fish is cooked to perfection, just enough pieces of fish as well; and if your a lover of whiting or catfish this is the place ro get it from. Mmmm Mmmm good😋
I very much liked their dishes and service, fantastic area nearby to my home. The staff members are always very kind. Will come visit again.
I bought food tonight and it was the worst I Always buy my soul food from here not no mo Mac and cheese was spoiled sweet yams was spoiled as well I came all the way from the Bronx to Harlem sorry Make My Fish gotta do better
They have the BEST EVERYTHING in this restaurant 😍 I love it. I go once a week because I love the food so much 😋
Good Seafood. The Fish is Delicious .The Mac Cheese is like Mom made it. Its takeout food at its best.
Yes, the food is fried, except the GRITS. Prices and the quantity excellent. If you want baked, broiled or steamed seafood go elsewhere.
I had the catfish dinner with the mac and cheese and collar greens and some yam . It was alot of food enough for two serverings .
Great food friendly staff great spot prices also perfect for the amount of food that you get.. would definitely recommend to anyone also fast service and fresh food
WARNING. HEALTH CODE VIOLATION. RESTAURANT OPERATING ILLEGALLY WITHOUT PERMITS FROM HEALTH DEPARTMENT. Not surprising considering the building is filthy and the food is disgusting. They dont have a working phone number and only take cash. Interesting, wonder what else they are hiding...
LOVE the Catfish sandwich. I eat it at least 2-3x a week. My toddler enjoys it also.
The shrimp was amazing however I wasnt fond of the collard greens(2 tuff) and the mac & cheese tasted milky
Love the food but they need to open on time. Sign on the door say 11am but they didnt open till 11:30am. Not cool!
The food is always good and the staff are quick and friendly. The 1st time I was there the cashier came from behind the counter to hand me back money she had noticed I dropped
My fav spot. The female takin the orders is so sexy too. Makes me want to keep comin back.
Phenomenal quality of food and service. If its always packed and people risk getting a parking ticket, cant really go wrong.
Best fish in harlem.
I SMASHED a DELICIOUS 😋 fish sandwich!! And their Iced Tea is like liquid CRACK! Great food and FRIENDLY PEOPLE!!
I love this catfish and fries. They have open for almost a year and when I heard about them, I found myself going every week. Try it yourself.
It was my first visit and the impression was good; service fast, place clean, no complaint on food.
BOMB.COM THANKS AL FOR A AWESOME SEAFOOD SPOT. BLACK OWNED AND ALL ARE/HAVE WELCOME. PRICES ARE GREAT TOO.
Food was great. The place just smells like a stinky cat lives upstairs!
I had the all fish. It was well seasoned and moist. Well worth the price.
Absolutely a spot worth visiting, the food is awesome and well prepared, the rates are fair and it is regularly clean in here. Keep it up.
Very polite staff and delicious food. You must try the half lemonade half fruit punch and candy yams.
I love the food.. I lobe the prices. And I love the people!!! This is hands down the BEST spot in Harlem!!
The fish her is well seasoned and it has a fresh taste and and the smell is awesome.
The fish and the shrimps are good the macaroni and cheese and collard greens are in kind of small portions
Food is good.Not expensive Always taste the same !!! The BEST spot in harlem !!!
Food was fresh customer service could have been better but I was coming from a race so I might have looked crazy
The food needs more seasoning and everyone has a attitude. It wasn’t bad but I wouldn’t come here again.
Food is very fresh. The sides were great! And that banana pudding is to die for
The fish is tasty and it is not fried hard. I love the fish.
The food is always hot and delicious and the price is excellent
Customer service excellent and the food delicious fish not salty 1st time
Love the cat fish nuggets the owner always make sure it crispy like how I like.
Super Good Fish & Sides! One Of The Best Food Spots In Harlem!
Betsy ever.u don’t to go no we’re but here.everything’s good.
They have the best fish & shrimp in town
Omg the best fish in town...I had the shrimp and fish combo...💯💯💯
Delicious Whiting fish. Not greasy. Seasoned well to the crisp
As a nurse we always need to eat and we are never disappointed. I wish I can eat from here all day everyday.
Food is made to order so its worth the wait excellent and fresh seafood
Live in queens and i don’t mind traveling to get some good fish and shrimp.... great customer service
The food is alright there, plus their the only fishmart around for right now so stop by.
Best fried fish ever. They dont accept debit cards.
The best tasting seafood take out restaurant with large portions.
Awesome food, awesome service, awesome people, awesome price
Pricey but DELICIOUS! BEST SPOT IN HARLEM, the fish spot on132 need2 CLOSE DWN!
I enjoying boasting about the food because it is really fresh and good.
The food was amazing but the cash only policy sucks
In love. Food is super fresh. Great people and customer service
I love the fried shrimps. I eat there at least 2x a week
I love the Whiting. It is fresh, light and crispy. It is lightly seasoned, but good.
Shrimp can definitely use seasoning but the mac & cheese was good
Great experience food was made fresh love love this place
The food is always delicious. Never a disappointed
The food is awesome if they have cake get the cake.
Very good fish place!! They do a good job frying!
You wont go wrong getting food from there. The best, perfect!!
PPE in place. Fresh fried fish and shrimps. Friendly staff and owner.
It was delicious. please stop by for some catfish and shrimps.
Went there & had the catfish, tasted like the bin was left open in the fridge.
I love their food , everything taste great to me !
OMG! Delish!! Loved, loved the shrimp and grits 😍
REAL FRIED FISH!!! MY FIRST TIME...WILL NOT BE MY LAST
Best fried fish on the East Coast
Good Food, Good Selections, Good Prices, Good People, Fresh Food Made To Order! Its All Good!
Great food and wonderful service! Ill be going back there!!!!!!
Love it yam.potato salad is dopeeeee
IT IS A GREAT PLACE TO GET THAT CHICKEN & FRIED FISH THAT WE LIKE TO EAT!!!!
The best tasting Fish in Harlem for many years !
The food is good. Needs to be a bit more organized.
GREAT Food No Issues With Anything Ive Ordered.
Small place, take out. Friendly staff large portions moderate pricing
Amazing service. The food is cooked with soul!
Black owned business. Portioned for sharing. Food tastes the best when its busy
Best fish and grits in Harlem. Love this place
Food is always freshly cooked and delicious!!
The food is good the price is right what else can i say
The fried shrimp is really good.
Love their triple play!
Excellent Place.. the Catfish is delicious! 🤗😜🙋🏿♂️✊🏿 🤜🏿🤛🏿 🥘 🍜
Love the fish and greens. Sometimes too long of a wait
Is was NOT GOOD AT ALL! I will never go back there
These Brothers really know how to do it right...Delicious...never disappointed...
The best fish in NYC!!The Farmer 🚜
Good fresh food, not a long wait
Great tasting shrimps,greens, and macaroni and cheese
Service is great, but the food is overpriced and everything is fried.
Great location friendly staff great food
Service and employees are not trained properly. To laid back no professionalism.
Simple,fresh, DELICIOUS!! Great take-out service.
Whiting sandwich was seasoned wellWill return.
Good. Just cost more ordering with uber.
Total reviews rating 4.4
199 Reviews for Make My Fish 2023:
Review №1
2021-08-17“Make My Fish” has the best tasting seafood in Harlem hands down! I always place my order through Uber Eats & this restaurant never disappoints! Their Whiting & Catfish are fresh, seasoned well & cooked crispy outside but tender inside! How delicious! The Shrimp is lightly breaded & seasoned to a crispy sweet taste! How delightful! They give a ton of French Fries & the Mac n Cheese is excellent as well! If you’re in Harlem, you must visit “Make My Fish”! Don’t miss out!
Review №2
2022-07-13Very tasty fried catfish, seasoned well with good portions. Collard Greens & Mac & cheese was very good too! Owner was very nice, even gave me a taste test of the fish before I purchased it. I will be back for sure!
Review №3
2021-03-21Ever since my favorite fish restaurant closed, I’ve been searching for a replacement. I’ve heard good reviews about Make My Fish and decided to give it a try. When I arrived to the restaurant it was a bit crowded which I took as a good sign. The staff member taking the orders did so quickly, I waited less than 5 minutes to place my order. The staff member who took my order was very polite and professional. It took me less than 10 minutes to receive my order. I was pleased with the fast service. While waiting on my food I noticed a staff member stepped outside. He then came in and used hand sanitizer than put on gloves and got right back to work. Make sure you have cash on you because the restaurant only accepts cash. There is an ATM in the restaurant as well in case you don’t have cash on you. I ordered the whiting fish dinner with baked macaroni and cheese, collard greens, and candied yams. I appreciated getting actual whiting fish as some places say they have whiting but gives tilapia instead. There were about 7 pieces of fish. The fish was filet in which I love because I don’t have the time or energy to pick through bones. The fish was seasoned with too much black pepper, I’m not a black pepper fan as I think it’s too spicy for me. My mom loves her food with lots of black pepper and she even said it was too much black pepper for her. The yams were bland, too hard and crunchy, they weren’t cooked long enough. The macaroni and cheese had a weird taste to it was very bland. The collard greens the best side out of the three. It was cooked well and had a lot of flavor to them. Out of 5 stars, I would give: the food a 2½, customer service a 5, wait time a 5, overall rating would be a 2 because the wait time and service was pleasant. I was hoping this would become one of my favorite spots after reading all the positive reviews. However, I wouldn’t return to the restaurant but give it a try you make like it.
Review №4
2022-06-25All I have to say is I travel from Philly so They can make my fish. Im a long time Customer and its always special for me to ENJOY the Seafood here at Make My Fish. It is surely a treat. So if your in Town you should have them Make your Fish. They dont disappoint.
Review №5
2022-07-13Uggggg they fell off 🥲. Today the food was sooooooo bland. The cat fish had a little seasoning the whitings had zero seasoning.They serve crinkle dry/ greasy no taste French fries. I’m sooo mad at them. I always praise MMF & tell ppl about this place . Me & my man was so upset about the food. They lost us as a customer and probably more cause we telling everybody.
Review №6
2022-06-02Amazing fish for the price! Loved the whiting
Review №7
2020-08-01No frills spot for fried whiting, shrimp, chicken, clams. simple menu. friendly staff. great value for the amt of food you get. sandwich is 2 pieces of bread and fried fish.long wait since it’s pretty popular w locals so word of advice - call in your order esp during covid days.Will def be back for other menu items.
Review №8
2022-07-05I love it. Its my go to after work. I love the catfish and the mac and cheese. Friendly staff and fast service.
Review №9
2020-07-25The spot is very close to Central Park north. Very convenient in this pandemic situation, you can just pick up your order and head to the park to enjoy your meal peacefully with a nice view* I ordered fish&chips and mac&cheese1- The fried fish was good, they have a tasty white sauce, the fries were flaky and not that great.2- I don’t understand all the recommendations about the mac&cheese, I couldn’t even eat a quart of it, too heavy and nothing special about it.
Review №10
2019-11-03Sunday funday with the hun and had a taste for fish, a coworker recommended this spot as Ive NEVER had catfish until she gave me a piece of hers. So here I am! The catfish was amazing the macaroni and cheese was thick and gooey like i like, the collards were good and the yams sweet. The fried Whiting could be seasoned more, but I fixed it up with garlic pepper. Overall 4 stars I enjoyed the meal very much.