Appointment required
Yes
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent in Bay Shore
Categories
Location on the map
Bay Shore, Suffolk County, New York, US
Planning
Phone: +1 631-666-8350
Site: http://www.michaelsthere.com/?cm...
Site: http://www.michaelsthere.com/?cm...
Opening hours
- Monday:9AM–5PM
- Tuesday:9AM–5PM
- Wednesday:9AM–5PM
- Thursday:9AM–5PM
- Friday:9AM–5PM
- Saturday:10AM–1PM
- Sunday:Closed
Comments (81)
Michael is one of the nicest, most professional, salespeople Ive ever dealt with. He was able to give me the best prices for Home and auto Insurance. Highly recommended! If you want to laugh and have a nice conversation during the process, call Michael! You wont be disappointed!
Claudia and her stuff are a very knowledgeable team. They carefully looked at every aspect of my records and gave me a great value for my auto/life insurance.You guys are the best!
I’ve been a customer for many years and recently purchased a new used car and had a couple of issues with which I needed assistance. Claudia was so helpful and so patient and worked out everything for me; she went above and beyond and I’m very grateful. I highly recommend her and this branch of State Farm Insurance!
I love this State Farm office everyone is so nice and professional, especially Claudia she’s my absolute favorite! I always go too her for any questions or issues I have and she fixes them literally within the hour! I had a issue today, called right up and she took care of it instantly! Always takes my stress away and I NEVER have to worry with my policy. Thank you!!
I have been with Michael Stagnitta for years! I’ve never been disappointed! He and his staff are always so pleasant and accommodating whenever I may need something. Michael, has always been one to put customers first. I will recommend this agency to everyone!
I began the process of obtaining a quote yesterday afternoon, via email, texts, and a phone call with Claudia and Victoria. By lunchtime today, after being greeted warmly and sincerely by Michael, I was in the office, finalizing and signing-off on my State Farm auto insurance, while also completing the questionnaire for the State Farm life insurance underwriters.The paperwork for both was detailed, but Claudia talked me through every step, patiently and professionally explaining what it all meant, offering me options on the various products State Farm could handle for my particular life and needs. She was not pushy or condescending, which was a welcomed relief.Victoria, State Farm recent hire, had discussed with me yesterday the details of my car, current policy, as well as my life insurance, relaying all that information to Claudia before the three of us got on the phone later that day, to get a better idea of my needs and weigh my options for life insurance. Today, as I sat in Claudias office, Victoria was very attentive to what Claudia was explaining, as Claudia guided her through all the steps to be completed.Within an hour, I walked out with a folder containing my State Farm insurance, beating my previous insurers rates. From now on, its State Farm for me!
My car was hit & people ran Mike S went after the people who hit it & had there ins pay to repair my vehicle.. Could not ask for a bettet agent !!!
This team is the Best and they treat you like family. They can be counted on to the fullest extent. They are truly Professional and know how to treat their customers. They are excellent both Claudia and Michael. Thank you all.
Claudia and the whole team at State Farm in Bayshore, NY has been a dream to work with!! My husband and I had both car insurance and first-time home buyers insurance needs and the professionalism and quick response times were incredible! Most important to us, we were explained very thoroughly the details of what we were paying for and the quality of the insurance we were receiving. We are so happy to be in such great hands with this team!!
Claudia and Victoria are always the friendliest they can be, and know what there doing. Fast response to any requests I may have. Michael is always looking to save me money, and takes a minute now and again to laugh with a few jokes. Ive been with Michael Stagnitas Bay Shore State Farm since it opened and dont plan on leaving.
Great Experience.Claudia Aidenian is my go too person she’s amazing and a great helper. Started with Claudia from the start and she understood my every need.If sometimes I can’t get in touch with Claudia I get in contact with Walter who is also helpful and friendly.Truly appreciated and I truly recommend.
The most helpful team there is!! Everyone in the office is extremely knowledgeable and efficient. Claudia is always quick to assist with anything we need!!
Had a great experience at this location, would definitely be recommending it to friends and family. Everyone was very friendly, informative and professional. Special thanks to Michael, Claudia and Maria!
The process of buying a home is arduous to say the least. The easiest part of my process was dealing with Claudia Aidenian at this agency. Her professionalism, responsiveness and knowledge made buying my first homeowner’s policy seamless. In the process she was able to save me money on my auto policy as well! I highly recommend Michael Stagnitta’s State Farm office for all insurance needs.
From the time I called up on the telephone to get a quote until the actual policy is delivered was a very positive experience. After discussing my needs with Claudia I decided to switch my auto policy as well as the homeowners policy I originally went into the agency to purchase. I met Michael Stagnitta shortly after entering the office along with the other people that work in the office they were all very nice and had a great sense of humor. After getting the information I need it I was able to compare the other quotes that I have gotten. I decided to have State Farm write the policies for me State Farms quote was very competitive with the other insurance companies that I contacted.I couldnt be happier with my decision to go with State Farm, I want to thank everybody in the office for all their help and kind attention!
I worked with Claudia on several occasions. So kind and helpful, very patient with all my questions. Gets things done quick and easy and at the best price
I have multiple policies with State Farm and I have to say that I love the company, I recently had to submit a claim and the process was so incredibly easy thanks to Michael. Michael and his staff are great, they make sure everything is done the right way and that the proper paperwork is on file to expedite any claims. Overall, I love the staff here, they have great personalities and extremely professional! Im very happy here.
The perception that relationships with insurance agencies can be difficult and unrewarding for both parties involved is true. That was my experience with the agencies that I dealt in the past. Miraculously, well I shouldnt say miraculously, perhaps stoke of luck is a better term, that I met Claudia Aidenian who proved to be one of the best agents, and who had vast knowledge of the products and services that State Farm offered. Furthermore, her personality and disposition ignites assurance that as a customer you are important. She made me feel important, and she made me feel at ease. She asked the right questions and spent time to know me. Yes, I know, this was astounding and welcoming. If all agents were like Claudia Aidenian then we would have a perfect world. Thank you for providing exceptional services to your clients. Thank you for making me feel as important as anyone else, and thank you for taking care my insurance needs.
I have been with the agency pretty much my entire adult life and have always been treated great. Michael deals with most of my stuff personally. I have home, auto, hospital and motorcycle insurance with him and he and the agency always provides the most time and attention when needed. I highly recommend this agency, I am always sending people to them. Currently I am sending my employer to bring all of his business insurance needs over because I know the agency with take good care of him.
Let me start by saying I just switched from Geico who had just screwed me by doubling my rate for just one accident. I must say the change couldnt have been easier. I was greeted over the phone by Claudia from a local agency and she has been phenomenal throughout the whole process. She walked me though the quote and changeover step by step and even saved me extra with a bundle. My experience so far has been great and I would reccomend this Statefarm agency to everyone specifically Claudia she was awesome and really helped me out.
I am a new State Farm client and i would like to thank Claudia Aidenian for her excellent service. She treated me with the utmost professionalism and courtesy and made my experience dealing with State Farm very smooth and painless. She makes me feel like a family member rather than a customer!!THANKS!!!
Michael and his team are amazing. They were so competent and honey and worked with me to get my the best policies and coverages for my new home, auto, and condo. I will use them everytime!!! Thank you James Howell and Michael Stagnitta.
Good Day!Ive been a client of State Farm since 1992. When I returned to NY for familial reasons in 2008, I requested and subsequently had my account transferred to the Bay Shore office of State Farm where I wanted to be. Bay Shore is my hometown in this country and I prefer to do business with local owner/operators. It was at this point, ten years ago, I met Michael Stagnitta, the Agent and business owner. We had a good chemistry from the start and Ive had the opportunity to watch Michael while he helps a client in the office or is on the phone with a client.Michael is an affable communicator and believes client service is job #1! He also has an excellent trait in that should he not have an answer--which is unusual--to a question at hand, hell say, I dont know. Let me find out and Ill let you know as soon as possible. Frequently, hell do it while hes with the client. One cant ask for better than that.In this day and age of name your own price in only 15 minutes faux insurance companies, its great to know Micheal is truly there for you representing a really good company. Im certainly not going anywhere!!Sincerely,Al Abrahams
Very quick response on all policies that was needed , team knows all correct information to lead you in that best way for any insurance needs i have every insurance that me and my family needs through Mike office. Mike is very honest and not looking to get by anyone only what the best for his clients. highly recommend will always be my first to go state farm company!..
When my wife and I switched to State Farm it started off great, we saved money, everyone at the office was fantastic. The problem started around October 2017 when our rates slowly when up anywhere from 10 to 15 dollars a month with no warning or explanation. November 2017 we got married and my wife got married and my wife rented me a corvette for a day. So we had to up the insurance for the day which worked out to a couple of dollars for the day. We stopped in on a Saturday to bump up the insurance and it would go back down the next day on Sunday. Well the local office is closed Sunday so they put a note in the system to lower the insurance that Sunday and we made a call to the National 800 number as a reminder. Well it never changed and though we called several times, it never went back down for months. So after many calls, we get told by a lady in the local office that yes it was a mistake they could only refund any money for only one month (b.s). Finally sort that out with the national office and we notice the bill went up again with no warning or explanation. Finally we are told that the safety rating on my wife’s 2017 Jeep Cherokee (lease) went down 10 percent and our rate went up. Was also never told or warned that a claim made against our insurance went through almost a year after the fender bender even though I was told by Michael himself “not to worry”. Fast forward to March of 2018 we switch to geico mid month. Naturally trying to cancel our policy was just as hard as getting any answers about our policy to begin with. It is now may 24, we still have not recieved the half month rate refund due to us but they still have things listed as active for State Farm. Like my car and some personal policy items which is tough because we had to send proof to State Farm that we switched to Geico, we also recieved a call from the bay shore office this morning at 952 am they left a message stating our payment is passed due. Well wouldn’t you know I returned the call and was told that they didn’t call us or leave a message (which they did). Michael himself was fantastic and always took great care of us. All other employees at his office are very very close to useless and very hard to deal with. So my review is they are great in the beginning but after a few years they will screw you!
Michael and his team are always eager to help, and are a phone call away. It’s so nice to able to call a company, and actually get someone on the phone! They are alway quick to reply and help with any questions I have.
I have been with Mike for many years now. His service and friendship are unparalleled to any other. Mike and his entire team go above and beyond. Even as of recently Mike saved me thousands of dollars in home owners insurance.To make this a family affair my father is taking his business to Michael Stagnitta as well. Michael is to be well known for his integrity, genuine loyalty, service and overall friendship.Thank you Michael for all that you do! You go above the call of duty!C. Vinolo
I was telling my wife,after coming in and meeting Michael,Claudia,Jim, and Larry, that of all of the insurance companies and people we ever dealt with,this office is the happiest place weve ever been to. Such a pleasure to be doing business with them. Thank you!
Claudia is great. Helped me through this pandemic, I called her after hours and helped me like no other insurance company has. I’m with state farm because of her period.
Claudia is my agent and she is the best! Saved me money and is so nice.
AMAZING , Michael is GREAT , Explains everything step by step , Tells you of the best options and opportunities for you based on your situation . extremely happy with his service from him and his team .
Claudia was fantastic. She was able to help us with everything in 5 mins. That we couldnt do in the last two weeks and was Walter there also. Lol .Im not even a client WOW
Could not be happier!! Quoted me much less than I was currently paying & have since moved over all of my insurance policies to them. Homeowners, Car, Personal Items & Life Insurance! They have it all!! Thanks Claudia!!!
The entire staff is always courteous and knowledgeable. Even though I don’t call that often, when I do Michael still remembers what car I drive!! It’s nice to be known by my name instead of a policy number. That is priceless!
Awesome team.i took out a policy on my bike and Mike suggested I take this plan that would pay out for my hospital stay.well that payed off and Im greatful he suggested it because I was hit on my bike and the guy took off.left me in a bad way.without working, as I heal this really helped me cover my bills.thanks again Mike .I would and will recommend dealing with them to anyone.larry my agent really nice guy.there on top of there game! Thanks again!!
Claudia was amazing! So patient with my questions. So glad I chose this branch.
I was treated with respect and outstanding customer service by my agent Walter. He went above and beyond to help me and was very responsive to my needs. This particular State Farm was double aces.
He’s an awesome guy always looks out for me and my family! I give him 10 stars he never let me down. He’s a great insurance agent one of the best I know! So if your in the area stop by and say HI!🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾
I am overly pleased that I made the call and switched auto insurance providers. Im saving a good amount of my hard earned money and for that I say thank you State Farm.
Claudia is great, she’s attentive and knows her job well. And mike is a pro with a great sense of humor
10 stars … love our hometown agent , best team on Long Island!!!
Mike is a great guy, couldn’t ask for anyone better. He saved me $250 a month and I’m now receiving more than I originally had from Progressive. Thanks Mike you rock!!
I had auto insurance for 266 then they boosted it up to 600 in a month Progressive is better you only pay 325 296 with a bundle and they dont spell your last name wrong to mess up your car insurance
Very nice people and professional, they are always available to find the best price of insurance for you. They are the best.
Very friendly I feel like in my family
Ive been doing business with Micheal Stagnitta for over 15 years Very professional and hands on. His employers are very professional and VERY helpful as well. I highly recommend this agency...
The service is always prompt at Bayshore statefarm
The employees at this office are professional, knowledgable and SUPER Friendly. They go above and beyond in the servicing of my account with personalize emails, phone calls and reminders when needed. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!!
This office is the best insurance company Ive been with since having my license for over 20 yrs. Everyone in the office is very helpful and we are happy being a part of the family.
Claudia Aidenian was wonderful and professional and really made me feel like I was hanging out with family. Great experience.
Ask for Walter! He was extremely polite and helpful with our renters insurance! Highly recommend!
Mike and his team always provide awesome costumer service, with amazing attitude !!!
Excellent customer service, extremely knowledgeable & professional. Very honest & willing to help under any circumstance. I highly recommend!
The best State farm office is very nice very nice people thank you so much State farm Mr Mike
I worked with Cinthya and she answered all of my questions and made sure I got every discount possible for my auto insurance.
Very helpful, fully informed on how to decide the best coverage for my car , best customer service I’ve had in a long time
Unbelievable experience! Quick and efficient! Great Price! Extremely Happy! Thank You!
My friend
Michael and his staff are the best..Great customer service 👏
Good team and they work with you. Dont see them as an agent see them as a friend. Thanks for everything you guys are amazing.
Michael and Claudia are the best they are very professional and welcoming to the office
Great staff, very knowledgeable and informed. Very easy to work with!
Claudia Aidenian was wonderful and professional. Thanks for all your help.
I recommend Michael & Lisa they are very professional and helpful. This is the place to go if you need insurance.
Excellent customer service highly recommended. Walter is always so helpful.
It was a professional and wonderful experience I would suggest using his services.
Great people and atmosphere. Very helpful in everyway. Goes above and beyond to meet your needz.
They took care of everything and made the process enjoyable and easy to understand. Thank you!
Great place , great people, great service!
Great people!
I have been working with Michael for a couple years now. They beat everyone price and are just a pleasure to deal with. Mike and Claudia are always on their A game.
Total reviews rating 4.9
81 Reviews for Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent 2023:
Review №1
2022-07-06Maria Loja was extremely patient, personable, and responsive to all of my questions and repeated calls. She treated me like someone she knew for years, even though we only met over the telephone. Maria helped me not only figure out the best plans/ policies for myself and family members, but she followed up with me via email and welcomed my phone calls. I am very appreciative of her humanity and the time she took to help. She went above and beyond, and actually took time to know my name. Her and the entire team are awesome. Thank You 🙏🏾
Review №2
2022-05-19I have Been with Michael Stagnitta ( State Farm Agency ) Over 10 years, Largely because of their Professional, knowledgeable and Courteous demeanor. Special Thanks to Claudia the Office manager and Chris the Sales representative for answering any question I may have and always going above and beyond to =make me feel like a valued Client. Thanks Guys
Review №3
2022-05-26Michael is amazing! Claudia is amazing! Staff is amazing! They are always there for us and we are well taken care of! Highly recommended! We travel over a half hour to their office...yes theyre that good!
Review №4
2022-04-12Best experience with an agency office I have ever had. Everyone is very attentive and professional. Claudia is amazing and those few times when she might not be there Michael has jumped right in to assist.
Review №5
2022-05-24I needed business and life insurance and was very frustrated finding anyone to help. I contacted the agency and Claudia was extremely helpful explaining the options available and getting everything set up for me.I highly recommend contacting the agency for all your insurance needs. They are very friendly and extremely helpful.
Review №6
2022-07-06Just an awesome experience. So very easy to contact to answer any questions/concerns. The team at State Farm exceeds expectations, just the best at what they do!
Review №7
2022-08-10Christopher Rothke, is 1 outstanding professional. Knowledge base is Impressive. Quick and thorough thanks Christopher. My problem, request and questions resolved as always.
Review №8
2022-01-27Michael and his group are amazing! Everyone on the team is willing to help in any way they can. The team is very responsive, knowledgeable, and they truly make it as convenient as possible for you to adjust your policy or answer your questions without having to go in. Ive only gone in once because I had a lot of questions when joining a new policy. Even then, the person I met with stayed after hours to adjust to my work schedule which was truly above and beyond anything I could have asked for. He also took the time to answer my questions and explain my best options and wasnt trying to rush out the door even though his shift had ended which I appreciated so much! Wonderful team and wonderful service!!
Review №9
2022-02-17I had the best experience at State Farm. Both Mike and Claudia are absolute gems and are always helpful and kind. I will recommend State Farm to anyone looking to change insurances. They are incredible! Wish I could give more than 5 stars.
Review №10
2022-03-24Im 55 years old. Hands down Claudia is the best insurance broker Ive ever had. The whole office is highly recommended! Very helpful! Even though she might owe me lunch now!🤪