Kerbside pickup
Yes
Milk N Cookies - Cookie Caf & Cereal Bar in Mamaroneck
Categories
Location on the map
Mamaroneck, Westchester County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Great dessert
Yes
Popular for
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Offerings
Coffee
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Dining options
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
Tourists
Yes
University students
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 914-630-7276
Site: http://www.milkncookies.co/
Site: http://www.milkncookies.co/
Opening hours
- Monday:1–10PM
- Tuesday:1–10PM
- Wednesday:1–10PM
- Thursday:1–10PM
- Friday:1PM–12AM
- Saturday:1PM–12AM
- Sunday:12–10PM
Comments (131)
The first time I came here I had high expectations and they were not met. I got the stuffed churro cookie. The cookie was dry and the filling was not that good. A few weeks later I decided to give it a second try and got the smores and funfetti cookie. They were excellent! Both times I came here I noticed that they easily run out of items. There was a small selection of cookies and no iced coffee left, but I definitely will go back.
I took my seven year here for a treat after hiking at Saxon Woods and she was so excited but couldnt make a decision and seemed to take forever. The man behind the counter was so patient and kind!!! We finally choose the Cookie Monster cookie and it was AMAZING!! Well totally be back.
I bought one of each flavor for a house party. The cookies are large but I feel still over priced. They were also extremely dry. Many guest tried pieces but nobody ate them. The funfetti flavor was probably the most liked out of the bunch.
Mediocre at best... the cookies are served warm which give the impression that they are tasty (heat adds more sweetness) but once they are room temperature they are hard and tasteless.They were also served undercooked on the inside with a weird texture. The cookies have no flavor at all, they all taste the same. The funfetti are the only decent ones there.The cookies are way overpriced.I was charged 14.65 for 3 cookies which are not big at all.My stars are only for the staff which was very friendly. Would not return.
Beside the excellent and knowledgeable gentleman that took great care of us, the ice cream and cereal infusion was a delight. Definitely recommended if your looking for a different kind of treat. The caramel cookies are bomb. 😀
It may be a slightly pricey sugar coma but it’s an oh-so-delicious one. Customer service & hospitality needs some definite work, though.
The staff was less than welcoming, they have only been open a few weeks. Their staff should be encouraged to ask if this is your first time, there was no explanation of the menu or what they sell. Yes, milk and cookies is in the name but..how do you sell them? How are the drinks put together? Their staff seem a bit unorganized. The decor is cute and good for a picture, and what they offer is delicious. I am disappointed that they do not offer dairy free options, which closes off the potential of reaching to a wider selection or array of customers. Very underwhelmed, the staff made me and my friend uncomfortable to be in the environment. The straw that broke the camels back was the girl manning the register had long nails and seem to have a bandaid on, then was manning the food station with no gloves. which make it a bit unsanitary.Overall: the experience was very disappointing. And the chairs are uncomfortable, as you slide off them easy.
This place was soooooo good!Food was amazing stuffed cookie and shake was sooo good!Owner was very friendly and happy to answer any and all questions we had.Would gladly go back if im in the area again someday and would highly recommend to anyone who likes cookies shakes or cereal or has a sweet tooth and would like a new experience!
I saw this place on Google Maps and was super excited to try it out...it did not disappoint! The milkshake was thick and the cereal mixed in was on point! The cookies were bigger than I expected from the pictures online but I did not try them yet since I was filled up by the shake. I definitely recommend it to anyone with a sweettooth in the area.
Waste of time, i can poop out tastier cookies. Dry, tasteless, mushy and under cooked. Would have been better off picking up rocks off the side of the road and eating that. Overpriced garbage. Very disappointed
Cookies are awesome - perfectly baked, just the right level of doughy awesomeness
Stopped here on a whim during a trip from Long Island to Boston which turned out to be a fantastic decision. The cookies and ice cream were fantastic. With all the options they had, the gentleman behind the counter was happy to walk my fiancé and I through all of the different cookies. After we finished even he checked back in with us to make sure we had enjoyed everything.Next time we’re passing through we’ll be sure to stop Again!
These cookies are delicious! Soft and filled with goodness. They have a bunch of amazing flavors one of them being the Cookie Monster ( blue sugar cookie filled with chocolate chip cookie ) ... my favorite!! I live in VA and I was really excited to come down and try them, I had messaged the account before hand and they were helpful and responded almost immediately. The cashier was awesome as well, I didn’t get his name but Thank you to you and Simon for being so accommodating!
Beyond amazing !! By far the best cookies I’ve tasted ! I definitely will be recommending my family and friends to go visit !!!!! Amazing customer service & Several options to choose from
So yesterday was our first time and the kids loved their cookie and milkshake. We definitely come back to try it myself. Great services from the moment we walked it. The guys were very friendly.
Overall bad experience. They were very unorganized. The little boy was super rude and just told us the flavor he didn’t have available without acknowledging us. No hello and did not feel welcomed in the store. The cookies are almost completely raw. Honestly, the place didn’t seem clean at all from the way they handled the cookies. Really turned off and we will not be returning. Also really over priced. This is not Manhattan.
Such a delight! Thick and creamy vanilla vegan ice cream with fruity pebbles , it was such a treat to my taste buds and my soul. The service was excellent and was happy to see that they were open during the pandemic... so thank you for your great service and awesome desserts
Amazing! Banana Nut Cookie Butter is the best! The Cereal infused Vegan Milkshakes are insane. My nieces and nephews love their cookies. Super clean, fun environment. Definitely satisfies your sweet tooth. Perfect for catering kids birthday parties, etc. Happy customer :)
Cookies are delicious and service is wonderful. I go fairly often. The price is worth it. They dont only have cookies but also ice cream and you can put whatever type of cereal in it. It is awesome. Definitely a place you should stop at if you have a sweet tooth like me.
Really cool 😎 spot!! Delicious milkshakes and bomb cookies!!
Always love coming here! They remember my order and never let us down with the shakes, had the apple pie cookie and it was super filling but still really awesome! I don’t know about the other customers but I love the playlists they have it makes me want to hang around longer to enjoy my shake :) staff is always very sweet too which is appreciated
These cookies are freshly baked daily and so delicious. Youre able to purchase alone or blend your own concoction of ice cream or a shake.
My favorite place to go get my specialty cookies.
Amazing cookies, amazing gluten free cookies, soft and yummy. Staff is always so nice and such a lovely little place to stop. It’s a weekly stop now!
The cookies were really good and big enough for two people to share. I got the chocolate chip ones and they were very chocolatey (which I like). The cookies are $4.29 each and when I was there they did not have as big of a selection as on their menu. I don’t know if I just came after a busy moment but the selection was a little disappointing. The store is small and there is very little sitting.
Man....can I get a vegan option please? Cookies n Cream in Bronxville does it right! And for my family who aren’t vegan; stated that the cookies here were mediocre in comparison.
First time I went was today. I got the Oreo cheesecake and Funfetti cookie. I went around 4pm on a Friday, it wasnt crowded so I was in and out in a few minutes. The cashier was welcoming and friendly. I am not a huge fan of cheesecake and this definitely seemed just like an Oreo cheesecake and was good. Out of the two, I TOTALLY choose the funfetti!! Now for the price each cookie was $4something, BUT they are thick pretty big cookies. I reccomend this place for your sweet tooth.
I went to Milk n cookies grand opening weekend. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The cookies were delicious, and the vibe was super cool. I tried the cheesecake filled cookie, which was amazing. Definitely worth the trip and will come back again.
I was super excited about this place opening near home but I was quickly disappointed by the overall customer service. First off they were very limited on their cookie selection, they didn’t have most of the cookies that were on the menu. Second; the girl that was taking orders was very rude! She pretty much threw the cookies in the box and didn’t even let us finish our order. She went right to the next customer with a totally different attitude, a much friendlier one! And LASTLY when we got to the register I told the cashier that we weren’t done with our order and SURPRISE SURPRISE he was also very rude. He walked away in the middle of the transaction. I’m really hoping it’s not a racial thing but the customers behind us were Caucasian and were treated with patience and kindness, unlike us who are Latino... I really hope the owner of the store sees this and properly trains his/her employees on their customer service skills!!
Ok.. lets start from the beginning... walked into the store and the decor was fairly simple but very trendy- kind of looked like it had cookie goo dripping all over the walls in a nice black and white contrast. I couldnt decide what to order so I went with the basic and got a chocolate chip and a funfetti cookie.. not going to lie, it was one of the best cookies I have ever had. It was worth every penny, one bite satisfied my sweet tooth for the day and being that the cookie was basically the size of my fist- I was able to take a bite a few hours later and even the next day.needless to say, the guy who took my payment and rang me up was a pretty nice guy who had a conversation with me for a few minutes and made me feel welcomed- I will def be going back next time Im in the area - def for one of those clasic chocolate chip cookies.
Very busy on a Friday night around 9. Chaotic scene with only 3 workers behind the counter. Sign on the right says order here but the line was not defined and the guy in front of me hadnt ordered but he wasnt sure where the line was. Bunches of people waiting for orders and the friendly staff looked overwhelmed. Many different cookies on the menu but no ingredients listed. This is a crucial omission when its this busy and hectic. Im sure when its slower part of the schtick is for the staff to explain the cookies and sell you on the variety. But when its crowded, a detailed menu would keep it moving. We had to ask what each cookie was and the staff was helpful but it slowed down the line. We got a Cookie Monster, a Funfetti and Banana Nut. $14 for 3 cookies is steep but they are hefty. Again, staff was friendly and the store is nice and clean. Go check it out but be patient.
I dont eat anything here because Im lactose intolerant. My wife loves it though and insists I give it a good a rating. It looks good. She recommends you go.
Tried very hard to like it. Store and cookies look aesthetically pleasing, but the cookies are terrible. Theyre tasteless! No flavor and just mush in the center. They need to change the recipe or this place will go downhill.
At first my experience here was good. The guy on the phone was nice and helpful since i was picking up a larger order. BUT when i came to pick up, the doors were locked and i had to be let in?? This was 11:30 and they open at 11:00. Mind you, i told the guy on the phone I’d be there at 11:30 to pick up. Then the guy in there didn’t even have what i ordered ready for 11:30 still waited at least 15 minutes. Then when i got the order, i didn’t get a receipt. At the time i didn’t realize i didn’t get it since i was in a rush. Now, i have been emailing the owner because i need the receipt and have gotten no help. 4 messages later and still nothing. Only responded once to ask if i used a card. Completely rude and awful service. Will not be going back. The cookies aren’t even made there, they’re just warmed up. Not good enough to possibly deal with this again. Can go to a bakery and get much better desserts and service.
The cookies were just ok. Had the Cookie Monster and was underwelmed. The ice cream was actually pretty good. Had the fruit loops and enjoyed it. There is no real seating inside. There are few chairs along the wall but its a very open space that could have a few tables. Its worth a visit if your walking up the Ave and need a little treat.
So I havent actually been to the storefront, Ive only ever ordered delivery. Yes, we have Uber-eated ( is this even a word lol) these cookies to work and they are INCREDIBLE!! They always arrive warm. The inside is soft and gooey, with a slight crunch on the outside. I can only imagine they are even better at the shop.
Love the cookies here! The store is very cute as well. My two favorite color are the dulce de leche filling and the oatmeal/ apple pie cookie. I love that the place is open until midnight because I get late night cravings. They also sale shakes and ice cream but I have not tried them yet. I would reccomend this place for desserts.
Amazing Amazing AmazingI love that you taste the flavor of the cookie and not just sugar...My 1st time todayIt was a rainy day so we decided to take a ride for some junk food and oh boy what a great choice the staff was very friendly and professional I made sure my wife got her own box so she wont take mine didnt work out later that evening when I saw 2 bite on one of my cookies...
Not sure if worth the hype. Kind of small for the cost. My Cookie Dealer is way better.
I was pretty excited in seeing a new dessert eatery in Mamaroneck but unfortunately the service wasn’t pleasant. First, The man at the register was a bit rude and not so friendly. Second, he rudely chucked my friend and mine’s cookies onto the counter as we tried to pay. Lastly, we returned home to enjoy our cookies, my Oreo cheesecake cookie sadly had a lot of egg shells into which was a huge let down. I’m willing to give this place another chance but not anytime soon.
Milk n’ Cookies is the place to go! The cookies are amazing, their cereal infused ice cream is one of a kind and their milkshakes are the best around. It’s definitely a top place to visit when in Westchester. Other reviews say the costumer service is poor, however the handful of times i’ve been there, i’ve been greeted with smiling faces and amazing music.
Very overpriced and tasteless cookies. This place was abuzz on a Saturday night and so we went to check it out. Wanting a cookie and a scoop of ice cream, rather than a large sundae we asked if we could order the scoop. After some back and forth, it was allowed but for one scoop of bland vanilla ice cream (and I’m an avid vanilla lover) they charged us the same price as a sundae!! To top it off, our churro dulce de leche cookie tasted like nothing! Highly disappointed, do not recommend.
I’m a home baker and I love my baked goods but these are by far the best cookies I’ve ever had (and I’m hard to impress)! Obsessed with the s’mores cookie. The owners are so kind and welcoming. Will be going here for the rest of my life!
The taste of the cookies are amazingly good. My favorite is the Cookie Monster and Birthday Cake.However, paying $5 for a cookie and $8 for a milkshake with cereal is kinda over the top.Anyone agree?🤔
My girlfriend and I went to check out Milk and Cookies for a rare late night cheat snack 💪 I’m not someone who enjoys sweets but the cookies were delicious. My girlfriend felt the same way.There is also credit that should be given for young entrepreneurs taking risks and opening a cool new experience spot in Westchester such as Milk and Cookies.Good luck !
I tried to Uber Eats on Saturday, and did it twice. I had to call them and they told me they couldnt fulfill my order because they were out of cookies and were closing early tonight, your a cookie store? Tried again last night, called them and asked them if the have cookies, they gave me a little attitude, I called them back and they stated they cannot fulfill one of my cookies because they ran out. They stated they were going to put in a Churro which I never received, I’m pretty sure I was short cookies but didn’t even care that much, I chalked this place up as a loss because they don’t even bake enough cookies on a daily basis. It seems people are just going there for the hype- please order more ingredients, hire more people and bake fresh, the cookies I had were not fresh- they almost tasted as stale as the “end of the night donuts” at Dunkin’ Donuts.
Waited on a long line to find out they did not have any of the cookies we wanted. Only one person taking orders and one person just standing at the register on his phone most of the time. They should let people know waiting on line that the majority of the cookies were not available.
Amazing cookies! The apple pie cookie is just superb! We’ll be back!
Been here a couple of times and the vibe is laid back and friendly, the cookies are good although i was a disappointed with the Cookie Monster flavored cookie (a bit on the bland side) . in my opinion funfetti and triple chocolate are the best.
My milkshake did not🙅🏽♀️ bring all the boys to the yard🚶🏽♂️🚶🏽♂️🚶🏿♂️🚶🏼♂️ because it was too milky 😑 plus they skimped me on the rainbow sprinkle and chocolate syrup in my ice cream cup. Other than that pretty good soft serve they need to be more generous with the toppings especially since a milkshake costs $10.00 🙄
Milk shakes are the best around! Funfetti cookies are addicting! Dope place! You can have cookies anytime of day. Go get them!
Very kind staff and absolutely delicious freshly baked chocolate cookies. I highly recommend this place!
At your kiosk in the Garden State Plaza Mall and there was no one at the kiosk for an hour. At least 25 customers left because they lost patience. 6 of us stayed and waited a whole hour and notified security. At least have the decency to put a sign, someone could have went back there and easily stole items.
Cookies are delicious. I was visiting for the first time from the city and found that service was not too good. Very young and distracted, not too attentive if you werent another young person or a friend.
Delish!!! Well worth the calories and crazy price for a cookie. Cant do it every day but once or twice a month, YES!
Kids love the cookies at this place.bservice was fast despite the line. Coming back to try the ice cream next time!
My first reaction upon entering this store was, “ah! Another place with great ambiance.” Unfortunately after the ROUGH and RUDE manorisms displayed trying to push their trash batches of cookies because they’re SOLD OUT OF REGULAR CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES OR ANY OTHER COOKIES BUT TRASH is completely unprofessional. The “Brad and Chad” at the counter we’re trying to pick up chicks and held up the line.1)How do you not have cookies on deck. YOURE A COOKIE STORE!2)PUSHY MEATHEAD EMPLOYEES3)NOT WORTH THE MONEY.Not worth your time.#FrozoneReviews
Staff was very friendly. The cookies🍪 were delish! I highly recommend the cookie monster.
$6 for a bowl of cereal? I could get 2 boxes of cereal for that price the whole place is for pretentious rich kids that wear yeezys and Liston to drake the whole place gave off a vibe of rich white kids that say the n word and “do you know who my dad is?” this hipster gentrification BS has no place in mamorneck
The ice cream there is outstanding with the cereal mix in it and my girlfriend loved the cookies she got, literally went back a day after the first time trying it
So delicious! I love the churro flavor! I’m so glad this hip and edgy place is near us! Definitely going to be my go-to coffee and cookie place xoxoxo you guys are doing amazingggggggg
The funfetti cookie was very delicious, it’s a must tryBUT.. the smores cookie was way to chocolatey inside wasn’t much of a fan. But super clean inside.
Totally worth it. The cookies are omg goodThe staff is super friendly and the place is clean and there is an energy or buzz about Milk N Cookies that it is here to stay.
It has no hygiene when serving them. They open the small paper bag by introducing their knob to the center of the bag to place the cookies later with a spatula. The problem is not when placing the cookie, in which they open the bag with the gloved hand, introducing 🤜🏻
The cookies look way better than they taste.
Love this place. The cookies are amazing and the ice cream is even better. The store is beautiful and a great addition to the village of Mamaroneck
Sorry but this place is over priced, and the cookies taste bland. They look better than they taste. Don’t know how someone can give this place more than 2 stars.
Im in love with blueberry Cheesecake!
The cookies are a little pricey but they are delicious and the customer service is excellent! 5 Stars from me ⭐️
Amazing cookies. The owners are very nice and accommodating. What a wonderful addition to Mamaroneck Ave. please go!! You will NOT be disappointed !!
I bought 4 different cookies 3 where ok but the strawberry one horrible a bit over price but I will go back to try ice cream next time
Got a completely uncooked cookie :( now my stomach hurts. Sadness 10/10
Best cookies and customer service. My kids loved it. Will definitely be coming back soon.
The cookies are big and impressive, with a gooey center. The variety of unique flavors is very cool.
What an interesting place! The cookies are excellent. One complaint... Not enough seating.
No gluten free baked items despite the pre opening publicity that said there would be..
The cookie was disgusting I paid more than 4 dollars for a cookie and threw up after because the texture and the taste of the trash cookie.
I am very disappointed with this place. Bought a chocolate peanut butter cookie which says it is 4.00 and it wound up being 4.74. Went to eat it and it was hard as a rock and very burnt!!!
Loved 😍
Was cute..but no seating..no whip cream..sundae with tip $10. Good but expensive.
My cookie was so hard, and cold like what in the world. i paid 4.90 for a damn cookie? nah, never again
Cookies are always warm and freshStaff is kind clean and quiet environment
Awesome place,very clean, Cap’n Crunch milkshake was one of the best I have ever had!
Hours say they open at 11 a.m. Have gone 3x at 11:05 a.m. and they are never open. Door is locked and people are prepping in back. They see us and ignore.
I loved the cookies!!! 😍😍
1st time .. nice place, coffee is great n oreo cheesecake was GREAT!!!!
Not cheap but unique. They have cookies stuffed with stuff which makes then really big.
Little expensive. Great cookies
Great cereal ice cream!
Despite coffee being on their menu, I was given a shrug and told to try next door when I ordered it.
My fav cookie place the cookies are amazing
Great place for a treat. The kid helping out was so energetic and helpful.
Favorite ice cream spot. Amazing cookies!
Always great cookies and DEFINITELY get milk!
Cookie monster is amazing! Staff was friendly and helpful!
Amazinng ice cream best desert ever
I’m confused. Where the in the world are the chairs at. There is plenty of space in that establishment
Best cookies and infused ice cream around!!!!!
Very expensive. So addictive.
Customer Service was good but this is so overpriced for nothing to write home about.
Best cookies ever!
Not bad. Overrated
On moms boianos is 100 times better!!!
The Cookies are So Delicious.
BEST COOKIES IVE EVER HAD!!!!!!
Unique flavors and great service.
Far from stellar e experience .... from service to product
AMAZING!! A great addition to Mamaroneck Ave!
A bit pricey but worth it!
Good cookies and cool decor
Loved it
No vegan options.
Soooooo gooooood
Great new place!
Delicious
So delicious!
Always delicious
Simply awsome.!!!!!
Love this place!!!
Out of cookies
The attention is very good, the boys have incredible energy! The cookies are SPECTACULAR and always fresh. And the best thing is that they close late and you can hear basically at any time!
Total reviews rating 4
131 Reviews for Milk N Cookies - Cookie Caf & Cereal Bar 2023:
Review №1
2022-02-25Around 10:00pm, we (my girlfriend and I) decided to order from Milk n’ Cookies for the first time for a late night dessert since the menu obviously looks amazing.Unfortunately, we were both left extremely disappointed with raw cookies which contained an immense amount of sugar - to the point where you can’t finish a full cookie without feeling sick (we ordered 6 not knowing how big they are).The only reason why I’m writing this review is because I just ordered Boston Market and it came with some Chocolate Chip Cookies which tasted 100x better than Milk n’ Cookies. I just wanted to forewarn those ordering from this establishment!TLDR: HUGE Servings, Raw Insides, extremely disappointed, Boston Market cookies are superior.
Review №2
2021-12-12Stopped by to purchase more of these delectable dainties. These cookies will make a person whose lactose intolerant drink cookies and milk. I love the blue Cookie Monster and marshmallow chocochip ones.
Review №3
2021-12-15One of the best cookies in NewYorkI love the classic cookies 🍪 and the Oreo 🍪🍪Indeed you can’t go wrong with anything left 🍪🍪🍪I tried the galaxy and the pink one cheese 🍪🍪
Review №4
2022-02-27Love these cookies and shakes. Service is good and they really care about each customers experience. Favorites are chocolate chip, Cookie Monster, apple pie, birthday cake, lemon blueberry cookies.
Review №5
2022-06-29Good product with a lot of variety. Some flavors could be better identified tho -- have to rely on counter persons memory, which is a concern w allergies. Good service and pleasant space
Review №6
2022-04-22The place is SPOTLESS. Extremely clean and professional. Vegan options too! Friendly staff.
Review №7
2021-05-30Pretty good cookies triple chocolate and oatmeal apple pie were good just a little over priced I feel like it could be a little bigger cookie for what you get but overall a good quality cookie
Review №8
2020-11-28As a cookie fanatic, my tastebuds and expectations were blown away! Milk n Cookies was constantly raved about within my community so I decided to give it a shot. As a typical college student (broke and stressed), I ordered only one item and proclaimed my broke-ness to them in hopes of getting something free! Typically in situations such as these, many restaurants are greedy and dont really care enough to feed a hungry college kid in need. Milk n Cookies heard my plea and my cry for help and decided to give me not one, not two not three but FOUR free cookies. In the end, my point being, Milk n Cookies is absolutely amazing and deserves much more kind-hearted recognition! Thank You Milk n Cookies! You got yourself a new customer/lover!
Review №9
2022-07-05Got the monster cookie and chocolate chip cookie. I was looking for ooey gooey cookies. Instead I got mushy on the inside and cakey on the outside. Sorry but at 4.50 a cookie not worth the price.
Review №10
2021-11-06After I had a back procedure earlier in the week, I told myself that I deserved to finally try Milk N Cookies. Got one for my mom and assistant too. The cookies were so good I cried! They arrived warm and gooey. They were better at relieving my pain than the prescription pills. God bless the inventor of Milk N Cookies! 🙏