Takeaway
Yes
MilkyWays Ice Cream & Cereal Bar in Huntington
Categories
Location on the map
Huntington, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
No
Highlights
Great dessert
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Phone: +1 631-470-3523
Site: http://milkywaysicecream.com/
Site: http://milkywaysicecream.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:2–10PM
- Tuesday:2–10PM
- Wednesday:2–10PM
- Thursday:2–10PM
- Friday:2–11PM
- Saturday:2–11PM
- Sunday:1–9PM
MilkyWays Ice Cream & Cereal Bar in other cities:
Comments (57)
One of a kind dessert house. Friendly staff and very clean premises. Really simple menu but lots of options. Hope to see it become a mainstay in Huntington.
This is by far The BEST ice cream place on Long Island, they allow you to infuse your favorite cereal with your favorite ice cream. Customer service inside the store is also out of this world. Nice and very friendly staff members! 1000% would recommend Milkyways to people of all ages especially children because the store is designed super cool and makes for a very fun experience!
Love this place best Ice cream EVER! My experience was amazing they have many variations of cereal and ice cream you can create the perfect blend.The staff is professional and friendly. Not to mention the shop was clean and very artistic great for pictures. I highly recommend, you will not be disappointed!!!
Im only giving it 3 stars because management. I went there yesterday and it was fairly busy the manager took the order and then went to the back to put stickers on cups while one of his workers was trying make 10 orders. Its not until the worker said something that someone came out to help and yet the manager still thought putting stickers on cups was more important. As a manager you should lead by examples this is how you lose workers. Other than that this place is great and the ice cream is out of this world.
1st experience there was absolutely phenomenal 11/10 would recommend to crowds of all ages , best ice cream & cereal bar on Long Island. The staff and the service is spectacular and let’s not forget the ice cream is absolutely delicious, so many different varieties of cereal and toppings the options are endless! Also they have a few locations is the best part & definitely 1000% would recommend giving it a shot totally worth it! (Caution very addicting!).
So happy this opened up! Long Island needs more spots like this. Definitely one of my favorite ice cream spots now. Not only is the ice cream good but it’s insta-worthy! The staff was extremely friendly and let me take as many pics as I wanted. Seriously tho, the ice cream and shakes are both really good. I highly recommend it!!
Best ice cream & cereal bar in all of long island, the ice cream was truly delicious would 1000% recommend to everyone. The place was designed super cool and the staff was super nice and lastly i couldn’t get enough of the ice cream i bought some for the time being and also bought more to take home. Also the energy in there was super uplifting and cool all the staff was very welcoming and i can’t get enough it! Definitely give it a shot , totally worth the experience!
My milkyways experience was absolutely amazing from the moment I walked in the door with the warm welcome from the staff. The extensive list of cereal and toppings is amazing! And the picture opportunities are endless with the amazing wall decor. I recommend to people of all ages! The staff is super friendly and welcoming. The overall vibe here is amazing, I can’t wait to come back for more!
Literally, the best ice cream shop around, from the ice cream to the vibe to the most amazing & friendly staff! They really make you feel like family. Their wide range of creativity gives you the tastiest ice cream combinations! Love, love, love!
As if ice cream could get any better. Milkyways has set the bar! It was only my first time there, and the owner himself was there and helped me decide on what to get. Owner and staff was helpful, ice cream was great and the shop itself gave off great vibes. I’ll be making this place an every week experience for sure
10/10 experience. HIGHLEY recommend coming to this spot. The ice cream is out of this world and have a ton a variety of flavors, topping and ICE CREAM CONES. this spot blows away all ice cream placing on long island. The staff are super nice and make the experience even better. DONT MISS OUT
Great vibes in there, the staff was extremely patient and friendly as well. Awesome selection of different cereals/ice cream. They have one in coram as well its just as great! Would recommend to people all ages.
Highly recommended icecream spot !! My first time experience there was amazing, the store looks super cool inside, i had to take pictures of it. I got the campfire shake & thats absolutely fire 🔥 i got there atleast 3 times a week now, all the staff is super nice too.
Absolutely great friendly place ! Owner and staff are very helpful and patient with customers , Best Ice cream shop in town hands down where creativity is brought to the next level also very fun atmosphere for the kids and even adults very cool inside , The campfire is the way to go !!
It’s so nice not having to go all the way to the city to find an amazing ice cream and milkshake place like this. The place is gorgeous and staff is super friendly, especially the owner. 100/10 would recommend.
Its good flavor new invention with ceareals kids love that invention.
The staff was very friendly and I love the concept of essentially making your own ice cream by blending in cereal and fruit/nuts with the vanilla ice cream to make your own flavor.
The employees hired here should learn how to be a little more respectful to their customers when they get their orders wrong. Instead of whispering under your breath, just apologize and remake the order no questions asked. When you’re paying $20 for two shakes it shouldn’t be a big deal to remake them.
What a place to bring my kids, this place is awesome! This crew of people is great and the ice cream is the best in town! Its a must go place!
Such a great idea, Love the ice cream love the concept! I have one request or suggestion, please come up with a bigger size cup!!
Best ice cream shop around! Friendly staff and they have the coolest store ever. Deff recommend to bring the family down ! 11/10
Great place, affordable and friendly. Definitely recommend for a nice summer treat since it is getting so hot! Highly recommend-will definitely go back. :)
Best ice cream spot on long island!! The owner is so helpful and outgoing. I will definitely be going back
Such a cool inventive place. If you havent get a chance go check this out. The ice cream is amazing
Great service with great ice cream. Theme of the store is very cool. Overall experience 10/10 would highly recommend
This place has terrific ice cream and has a great staff. Totally worth the wait and time, highly recommended!
More than just cereal blended into ice cream. Actual flavor included. Small but fun location.
Stopped by because I was feeling some ice cream got Cap’n Crunch with coconut and cheesecake bites and peanut butter drizzle and it was fire and the staff were helpful and took the time to explain everything.
Very good ice cream, stuff was very nice and friendly, recommended to everyone you won’t regret it.
Ice cream was amazing the campfire swirl holds a special place in my heart quick service well trained employees nice & clean I will tell all my friends
This place is the 💣 . Sooo yummy. I can assure you that this cereal ice cream is worth the hype.
Really unique concept, and tastes great
Nostalgic! Delicious! Fruity Pebbles
Best ice cream around! Clean establishment, courteous and very polite staff.
Unique cereal bar ice cream that taste delicious. Lots of options for toppings.
A new gem in town! The vibe is excellent and the staff is so helpful and pleasant! I recommend everyone try this place!
Interesting concept and fun vibes all around!! Great place for young ones!
Staff is friendly, ice cream is good. will come back.
Great ice cream and very friendly service . 10/10
Beat milkshake I’ve ever had in my life
Excellent customer service and great ice cream!
Such a great place with fun sundaes!
Drew was great
Very strange concept cereal and ice cream
BEST ICECREAM EVEERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR.
AMAZING!
I like this ice cream.
Total reviews rating 4.8
57 Reviews for MilkyWays Ice Cream & Cereal Bar 2023:
Review №1
2022-05-29Best ice-cream shop in the village. I was a little skeptical about blending cereal in the ice cream but it works very well. I went with the strawberry shortcake. For the life of me I cant remember what was in it but there were teddy grahms and cheesecake on the outside as well as raspberry drizzle.The adult size is very generous and a great value but I didnt even come close to finishing it. I would choose this over the bigger brands every day.
Review №2
2021-08-29Went here for the first time last night. Pretty good ice cream. I got the fruity pebbles with chocolate drizzle. At first it just looked like regular ice cream & I was expecting to see chucks of cereal but they blend it so well that it just looks like ice cream with sprinkles. Very crunchy. Feel like I needed to brush my teeth immediately to avoid a cavity haha. But still good. I hope this place lasts because that area in Huntington village tends to have a lot of places, especially ice cream shops, that come & go & dont last long at all.I noticed if you got a cone, they are hot pink!
Review №3
2022-04-20WOW. I love the simplicity and cereal theme of this ice cream shop. I got a kids cup of the Smores and it was AMAZING. The cereal milk vanilla ice cream was so incredibly delicious & the toppings were a perfect addition and not overwhelming. The kids cup was a great size for an adult IMO. Perfect spot to get ice cream after grabbing a burrito next door at New Wave :) Will definitely be back.
Review №4
2021-05-01Fun little ice cream joint with lots of flavors, toppings and options!Ice cream mixed with breakfast cereals is a surprisingly good combination, and this place does it really well.Highly recommended if youre in the Huntington area, even if its a bit of a drive I think its absolutely worth it.
Review №5
2021-02-06Great vibe & atmosphere inside! The owner & the staff are extremely friendly & recommended great flavors to try. Milkshake tasted very rich & smooth. Great place to go to if you’re craving ice cream! Definitely will come again.
Review №6
2022-02-26This was the best ice cream experience of my life!! Kharlin, Isabella, and Arianna were the best employees I have ever met! It was a cold day and I was just in the mood to eat cereal. I wanted a cup of fruit loops and Cookie Crisp to remind me of my childhood! Kharlin, Isabella, and Arianna delivered and all deserve a promotion! Also two of my friends got milkshakes and the wonderful employees let my friends pick there color straw! This was a day to remember and I will definitely tell the grandkids! I definitely recommend and the employees deserve a raise for all there kindness! There kindness made my day as well as my friends!!
Review №7
2021-05-15Loved this concept! You pick a base (they had non dairy vanilla), a cereal,toppings and a sauce. I wasn’t 100% sure if it was all vegan but it was DELICIOUS.The Cinnamon Toast Crunch I picked in made it crunchy but in a subtle way, the raspberry sauce was delicious. I picked a kiddie size and it was still too much.I disliked that they added an extra $2 for non dairy vanilla (and didn’t tell me).I went on a Saturday evening and the place had a line out the door. Not a lot of seating so enjoy it outside.
Review №8
2021-09-28We LOVE coming here for a tasty treat every now and then! They have so many options, and weve tried quite a few! Its always delicious! You can customize your own ice cream, or they have menu items with a great range of flavors! A great addition to the village!
Review №9
2022-04-03Like a family Saturday we decided to go get ice cream at milky ways in Huntington my whole family wants the ice cream 🍦 on a cone it was almost 5 o’clock and the little girl at the register after we place our order says “oh we don’t have any cones” can we do your on a cupI was very disappointed because they just opened up at 4 o’clock and it was no cones it is very far away ride to go get ice cream to this place it’s not cool and I ask for my money back on the difference in the price and I didn’t get it!!!
Review №10
2021-01-23My first experience with this place was amazing. The staff there were so friendly and nice and the ice cream tasted amazing. They have so many different choices of toppings and cereal for your ice cream. The place was so big and spacious and really really nice. I would with out a doubt go to this place again and I would 1,000 recommend this place to anyone whether if they read the rating or if they’re looking for a good ice cream place in Huntington. Besides that, Milky ways keep living the dream and scooping the cream