Delivery
Yes
Mr. Pizza in Auburn
Categories
Location on the map
Auburn, Cayuga County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
No
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Phone: +1 315-253-2209
Site: https://mrpizzaaubny.com/
Site: https://mrpizzaaubny.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:10AM–8:30PM
- Tuesday:10AM–8:30PM
- Wednesday:10AM–8:30PM
- Thursday:10AM–9PM
- Friday:10AM–9PM
- Saturday:10AM–9PM
- Sunday:Closed
Mr. Pizza in other cities:
Comments (126)
Wow, we relocated back here after being gone for 25 yrs. The wife has been seeing alot on social media about the place.Ordered 3 subs and a meat lovers pizza.Not exaggerating one bit, the pizza was almost 2 thick and there was no way we could eat a whole sub.4 meals for 1 deal.We will definetly be going back and now I understand why to lot (even as small as it is) was full at 2pm.
Great pizza! Antipasto delish! Shop local!
Sometimes its the best pizza in Auburn, at its worst its still great, I dont know why it differs but I am never disappointed..they are courteous inside also, and the other food here is also great. Highly recommended pizza with meatballs, as this is highly unique here in flavor, and the pizza crust is crunchy in such a good way, its different then a lot of other pizza shops. The price is average for a pizza shop, some may say a little high, but the quality more then makes up for the price.
I would rate less than zero 🌟 if I could have. We Ordered at 8:22 pm. By 9:43 no delivery- I called to check on our order and was told it was out for delivery- it arrived at 9:50 pm - cold . my cappy and prov sub was $9.17 when a whole Italian sub was $7.50. My wifes sub was good and fried dough was also good. $5 tip given but I will not be ordering again... I can make the fried dough at home.
First time ordering from here, Just waited 1 hour and 45 minutes for a large pizza and 20 wings to be delivered. Just for it to get here cold & the pizza be stuck to the bottom of the box. I called 2 times after an hour of waiting and asked what was going on, and got the same answer that the driver was on his way. Needless to say, Im going to just stick to Giuseppes like I usually do.
I really enjoy Mister Pizza reminds me of another store back in the day. That I worked at call Dons grocery up the street we made pizza just like theres I love too thick crust I love how they make it I enjoy it. Even I asked him for special little things like pushing it back make it a little crispy extra sauce and cheese I do a good job always happy. Your friend from Florida had a great lunch today thank you
Ordered a medium pizza and wings at 8:30 through DoorDash, Mr. Pizza specifically is listed as supporting doordash, my dash driver called once he got to the restaurant and said that they don’t accept delivery though door dash. So he wasted his time and gas going there. Mr. Pizza said they would still accept the order and deliver it themselves. I called the restaurant to verify, they said the order was on its way at 9:08. I called back at 9:30 and got the same response, “it’s on it’s way, the driver had quite a few deliveries, our delivery time is typically 1- 1& 1/2 hours. I have never had anyone take that long for delivery. I’m at work and I only get a 45 minute break. 9:45 my break is over.I will NEVER order from them again, this is ridiculous. Didn’t receive my order until 9:51.
I ordered from Mr. Pizza for my sons 6th birthday party. Prices are definitely reasonable. We ordered 2 sheet pizzas, and the kids loved it. Thank you Mr. Pizza for making my sons party that much better!!!Ryan C.
The pizza is good, and much different from your average mom and pop pizza place. The food has remained consistent through the years, and the owners are quite passionate about what they do. Prices are great as well.
Fried dough is the bomb!!!! Owner Bill personally delivers me the hottest and fresh fried dough. The pizza is superb and the subs are out of the world!!! Great service as well!
Reasonable prices, great food. Some of the best chicken wings in town. Highly recommend their chicken wing or chicken bacon ranch round pizzas, sheets are a bit dryer, but staff will gladly add more pizza sauce at your request.
Just had the wings with the Taco village sauce on them. They were amazing, brought back great memories from the old days. Keep up the great work!!
I ordered a large-light-baked pizza on 5/22/21(today).They said 30 minutes to be ready.I pay for it and they don’t show me...I should’ve looked before I got homeIt was over-done & I will not go back.How hard is it to make a light-baked pizza & not burn it...still charge a customer for it?????
I wanna say this first; I like this place, and so does my family, weve been coming here from across town for over 7 years. The food is great and *most* employees are kind. The wait times are not long and its warm inside, especially good for the cold windy days.Now the part that I wish wasnt true.For the last 4 months my wife has been pregnant, so instead of her going inside to order, it has been me. Im fine with that, no complaints... but IN those last 4 months, every time I go in, this woman (who I really never felt the need to ask her name) is at the counter on her cellphone.Now I get it, slow day, late day etc.... but it is EVERY TIME. And I have to usually get her attention to start an order.I stood there once for 3 minutes while she seemed to be texting because she would not look up.... Eventually, last week I decided to ask her name. (It was something like Jenny or Jen, she sorta mumbled it) She has such a BAD attitude. Shes the only person there I refuse to tip. I feel unwelcome there now. I wanna talk to the manager about this, but I feel I cant be the only one who has had this issue recently.She has given me, my wife, even my son attitude. We even a few times have gotten delivery from Mr. Pizza, and SHE is a delivery girl.... with the same mean attitude. I just dont think we should go there anymore until she isnt there. I dont want to sound like a partypooper, but the minute she gave my son lip when he asked how much to tip, that was when she went too far. We took the order and slammed the door in her face. (This happened a while ago)Now I wanna say, everyone else is great! Actually I wanna say EVERYTHING else is great. All the OTHER employees are WONDERFUL people. And I promise once I can go in there again without her in my face, I change this review to 5 stars, because the pizza, the wings, and the subs are GREAT.
Great food and great service. Very friendly staff.
Well I spent almost 65 on two pizzas boneless wings and a salad and over half of my order was wrong I strongly recommend that people order from some one else.my wings werent boneless I didnt get my salad and one pizza wasnt supposed to have cheese on it did.now I have to weight another hourand a half to get the right stuff
Every Friday my friends and I would get together and order a large pizza with mushrooms. Its awesome! The sauce is great. The pizza is even better cold. Grab a loaf a bread on your way out!
Absolutely amazing!! I ordered wings (well done, sauce on the side) and a small buffalo chicken pizza (added jalapeño and mushrooms). The girl on the phone was very nice. I had it delivered btw. Delivery was On Time and driver was cool. Wings were wonderfully crispy (did I mention this was delivered?) and delicious. The pizza...omg It puts Most places to shame in Ct, where I live. It was spicy, cheesy, thick, hearty...the kind of pizza I know right away, its going to taste good as a left over the following day. Take it from me, its good. And I take pizza and wings Very seriously. Great job, and thx!!
We always get the half sheet with meatballs & mushrooms! I dont live in Auburn anymore but when Im in town and we order - its always Mr. Pizza! Exactly as it was growing up. The crust is the best part!
Good food pizza is amazing. I like the square slice better than the. Round. Large. Great subs. Good service. Corner lot. Not too much parking. They deliver.
Fresh dough made in house, thicker pizza, very tasty along wirh great service. Small family owned business. Reminfs me of neighborhood pizza shops when I was growing up in Philly PA.
Got the best chicken wings really crispy and finger licking good and they have really good fish and cheese steak subs Im not to big a fan of their pizza though its thick crust and is really crunchy
We showed up around 8:17 pm and stood there for about 5 minutes before the worker decided to say that they were closing at 8:30 so we left but before we came we checked the website and they said they were open until 9:00pm and we called multiple times before hand and they didn’t not answer and he was very rude about it and we called WAY before they were closing we called multiple times
As far as Im concerned this place has some of the best sub sandwiches in the city of Auburn. Made fresh from homemade bread. Prices comprable two other quality sandwiches
Not bad, got steak sub an wings. Should of unwrap my sub when i got home bread got soft from being in the foil. My fault lol. But food was good. good price as well.
Best bread/dough be it for a sub or pizza .. this place is unique .. if anyone here wrote a bad review they must have an invested interest or are sparse shadow of a human.. i say this place is spot on .. owners have changed hands between the years but the recipe have stayed close to the same and have continued to improve , especially from the most recent management.. Mr pizza is #1 , true review no bias from long time customer.
I love Mr. Pizza but the past 3 times we have ordered from here the food has been bad. The wings are hard, the pizza is soggy. They have messed up my order. This is not like Mr. Pizza Im not sure maybe they have new people working.
I order from Mr pizza frequently last night I ordered mozz sticks fries w cheese and a half steak and cheese w extra provolone and mushrooms w a1 cooked w the steak I never got my sub but have the delivery guy 25 for fries and sticks I waited til tonight to call and order food in the hopes the same people working would be there but she said its been 24 hrs and it wasnt I ordered at 9:10pm I called at 8pm ridiculous it used to be my favorite place not anymore
The only place to go for good, thick crust pizza. Always has the right amount of sauce complimented with plentiful cheese. Grab a sub and wings and you will be so glad you did!
Really good pizza and wings. Friendly people. Delivery was a little slow but overall very happy customer. Keep up the good work!
Awesome home made scratch pizza including sauce the best in town we drive 15 miles for it always kind an courteous
I had Philly Cheese steak and Onion rings. Delicious. I could have made a meal on the onion rings alone. Service as always was excellent.
I love their pizza and wings and their Italian bread is the best around! We wont go anywhere else for pizza but to mister pizzas.
The best thick crust pizza around, and the best steak sub in town. Cant go wrong with anything on the menu though.
Let me start with best chicken wing pizza ever.Great cheese steaks.Also, the employees are kind of cool.
Prices did not match in store what was online spend well over 10 dollars more then the price they have listed and food was over cooked mozzarella sticks burnt would not recommend
Great food and. The best square pizza I love it fryed dough awesome ! No kidding really good!!!!!
Sub sandwiches have alot of meat in the sandwich. Sub is a good combination of all products in the sub.
Best chicken wing pizza around. Breads and subs are great. I consider it a treat every time.
Not a strict pizza place, has a variety of hot and cold subs. The staff is nice and respectful.
Steak sub amazing best homemade bread in the city just make sure to call and reserve some
Nice place, good food, reasonable price, nice staff. Awesome Italian bread. Great subs.
Best Cheesesteak in Auburn NY
LOVE their Philly Steak & Cheese subs!! Best meat around!
I heard good things about this place. First time eating there. It was good but not great. Will give it another shot though.
Owner is very rude. They cant seem to get their prices straight. Food is never done when they say it will be. Very expensive and poor quality. Never returning
Our Saturday night go to!! ! ! We love them great prices and the best food money can buy.
Throwback to school lunch pizza, excellent prices
Great subs with plenty of meat and rolls are homemade and fresh
Great salads and Italian bread! We order every Friday! Perfect every time!
They have great subs. My cat loves the turkey sub 😍
Every time I order from here my food is delicious.
Because they make awesome pizza and subs everything they make is awesome
Excellent pizza some of the Best I have had
Cheese steak is great. Loaded fries awesome.
Best meatball sub in town. Exemplary service, timely delivery.
Got a badass Philly cheese steak with peppers, onions, mushrooms and swiss. Sub game is on point.
Very polite n the steak n cheese was great.. Prices was very was reasonable...
The only thick crust pizza I like. Nice square crispy pizza.
Great if you like thick crusted pizza
My kids are very picky about pizza and this pizza was by far the best we had sense we moved to auburn
Delicious bread .....food customer service is always friendly
Got a cheese steak and a chicken parmesan sub. Not very good.
Love the cheese steak subs best in Auburn .
They charge u 2 dollars a slice and its like you are paying for a slice thats been left in there for several days
Love this place ... Never have anything not delicious... Very friendly staff
Very personal and kind service! Sub was delicious!
Great food... everything is always delicious!
The chease steaks are so delicious 😋
Excellent french fries and steak sub.
Quick, delicious and pleasant to deal with.
Best subs and home made bread in town.
Good food reasonably priced. Good value for the money.
$8 sub with profit of $7.50. They put the cappicola on with a airbrush.
Great pizza, wings and fresh bread!
Love this place the food is awesome
Best pizza in my nieborhood
AWESOME CHICKEN WING PIZZA
Always a good place to get pizza
Best pizza and cheese steak in town
Homemade bread pizza etc great food
Love their subs and pizza!!!!
Great Sheet Pizza !!
Buffalo chicken wing pizza! Yummy!!
Love their bread!
Great Italian sausage subs
I absolutely love the subs here!
Best pizza.....my favorite.
Great pizza and subs!!
Best cheese steak in town
Found $5 in parking lot! Lol
Hometown pizza shop, family owned!
Fast and very good food.
Great service...great food
Love the food and servie
Good food good price good speed
Good food and service.
Not a bad pizza place
Fantastic, meaty wings...
Good food
Great pizza and service
Visit whenever Im home.
Amazing pizza😜😋❤❤
Always delicious!!
Great subs!!
Good stuff
Is there a website that I can go to?
Excellent
Always amazing!
Ok
Good breakfast pizza
Basic
Great
Garbage
Great food
Love the pizza
Total reviews rating 4.3
126 Reviews for Mr. Pizza 2023:
Review №1
2022-03-20This pizzeria was very dissapointing and disturbing. The entire kitchen was filthy with food sitting all around the counters, trash all over the floor and employees that did not wash their hands between handling cash, trash and food. Outside of the overall health hazard of the kitchen, the employees were not friendly and it took nearly 2 hours to get a single pizza. I would highly recommend that the health department shut this place down until they get their act together.
Review №2
2022-04-19Triple AAA subs,the bread rolls are made fresh every morning,they put plenty of meat on there subs and there very delicious and satisfying subs and pizzas. A must go to for your subs and pizza cravings.
Review №3
2022-03-15Some of the best wings Ive had in quite a while. Four stars is because the price on the website was way different from what I was charged.
Review №4
2021-06-20The wings taco mild and Louisiana are great. They still carry during this chicken wings price hike 10 for $12 or 100 for $100. And they are great. I recommend trying there if you are in auburn. The upkeep to there place could use work. The only reason they dont get a five. Also the mozzarella sticks were not good. Regular fro
Review №5
2020-08-07I just love their Pizza they have their moments but Ill tell you right now I used to work at Doms grocery back in the day that I thought had the best sheet of Pizza in town this one is closed when they make it on the the mark like they did with this one unbelievably delicious
Review №6
2021-09-14Just ordered and grilled chicken salad. Chicken was burnt and dry. I ask for low fat Italian and got all oil. No flavor. Really sad my order was sub par. If you want a salad not done right go here.
Review №7
2021-11-0511/5/21 I was told this place had best pizza and wings around. I thought I’d give it a try and it was regret I don’t like frozen crust. I ordered large pizza pepperoni each slice had three pieces of pepperoni piled on top of each other. The wings were done wrong I ordered a certain kind and I got another kind definitely not gonna be a repeat customer
Review №8
2022-04-22Best red sauce and homemade dough. Dough can be bought separately 😊
Review №9
2021-09-21I ordered two steak and cheese subs, they were good until I noticed a few bites something hard was in my sub. I have no idea what this is, but it’s hard like plastic. Ended up throwing both subs out completely
Review №10
2021-04-04Nice little pizza and sub shop nestled in next to the prison. I went with the food friday eggs salad and green olive olive special. The service was with a smile and outstanding as was the sub. I was going to order a 1/2 glad I got the whole.