No-contact delivery
Yes
Mustachios Pizzeria in Buffalo
Categories
Location on the map
Buffalo, Erie County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
No
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
LGBTQ+ friendly
Yes
Transgender safe space
Yes
University students
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 716-874-8909
Site: https://www.mustachiospizza.net/
Site: https://www.mustachiospizza.net/
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–11PM
- Tuesday:11AM–11PM
- Wednesday:11AM–11PM
- Thursday:11AM–11PM
- Friday:11AM–12AM
- Saturday:11AM–12AM
- Sunday:12–10PM
Comments (199)
First time customer. Great pizza. Sauce and cheese is all the way to the edge. Sweet sauce. Looks like a fresh remodel inside, very well done. Will return for more.Only issue is no parking really but its not a knock on the business at all. Hence the 5 stars still.
The last few times I had ordered a pie from them it was overcooked and tasted like the pizza box maybe because they dont use a paper liner because of that we dont get pizza from there anymore
Service was best around. Meet the owner and he made us feel like family. Food came out better then we could have imagine. Meat lover extreme hands down best pizza ever had. If your ever around eat there you will not go away hungry
This is such a great little pizza spot. They do offer lots of other options but Ive only ever ordered pizza. I would usually order a pepperoni and mushroom pizza and it was always very good. I didnt love the sauce but I would still order the pizza. Most recently I ordered the chicken finger pizza which is to die for!!! Definitely one of the best pizzas Ive ever had, and its close by! You must try the chicken finger pizza, you will not be disappointed!
Excellent pizza and wings. Super friendly staff. Will be going back again.
First time ordering tonight, we ordered for 6:15 n got here about 6:40 for Bills game. Figured it would be a little late due to high demand on a Bills Sunday, but will be ordering from them more often. Pizza was really good doughy but crunchy at same time, wings were good, we had garlic parmesan n medium, the garlic parmesan could have used a little more sauce... But over all really good n cant wait to order other items in future.
Pizza was incredibly greasy. Also was not well cut. Had to go back and recut all of the slices.
Whoever made our pizza tonight for our delivery did a fantastic job!! Very impressed.. lots of cheese, lots of sauce and toppings but most of all the crust Is absolutely perfect!! Thank You!!
Amazing!!!!! Best pizza. My daughters favorite ❤. Love the mustache boxes too!
Im NOT much for deep dish and sweet sauce, This place Wasnt too sweet or deep ( Great with the Toppings & Cheese ) Well Deserved 5 Stars . . . ....
Love the pizza and sweet sauce. Great lunch special
The BEST pizza in Kenmore Tonawanda area. The food is always great! I tell everyone I know about them!
Some of the Best Food & Service in the areaGreat ordering system !! Great menu !!Really Convenient and Super Friendly Staff
I special-ordered two large antipasto salads for a guest with severe allergies. The manager listened carefully and made sure the order was completed exactly as ordered.Everything was delicious and ready on time. We ended up ordering a pizza later in the day, and it received rave reviews.Thank you, Mustachios, for taking such good care of your customers!
Philly cheesesteak pizza is amazing!!! You will not be disappointed!!! I also love that when you order wings online they have an option for “crispy.” My order has always been right and fresh! I highly recommend this place. I think it’s far better then a lot of well known pizzerias that I will not name.
Mustachios has the best pizza and wings and has quickly become a favorite. The staff is always friendly and service is always with a smile. Not only is our order always perfect, but no other pizzeria matches them in quality or taste. Hands down the best.
Omg ! Here visiting family ( raised around the corner ) and got the antipasto salad . Thing is huge and worth the price
I have came here on more then 8 different occasions. They never have cheese pizza and only offer pork . Not a choice between pork and beef pepperoni. I keep walking away disappointed each time because I love there pizza. Last time I had cheese pizza from here was September...
I purchased a small pizza cheese & pepperoni. The crust was crispy but also doughy while the cheese and pep did slide around a bit but could be solved with a touch more cheese near the crust to give it a nice holding point. Great flavor in the sauce and it made me want more when I was done with my slice always a good sign! 8/10 ordering again.
The wings were good but the cheese slid right off the pizza 🙄
Great! Driving by and we thought lets get a quick pizza. I asked them for some additional toppings on what was already made, no problem. And...delicious as always
This is my new favorite pizzeria. I discovered them through the Slice app and Im glad I did. They use fresh ingredients and fresh dough. Their antipasto is pure heaven! It has over 12 ingredients and the large one weighs over a pound (same with their Supreme pizza). Everything I have ever ordered is outstanding and their order/delivery is prompt and hot.
Got my first pizza from Mustachio’s Pizzeria a week ago. Why did I wait so long! Nothing skimpy about their pizza - it was loaded with thick gooey cheese (just the way I like it), lots of pepperoni cooked to perfect little cups and a nice thick crust. Absolutely delicious! And, unlike lots of other pizza places I’ve been to, my pizza was ready at the time they told me it would be and I could tell it had just come out of the oven rather than being sitting under a heat lamp to keep it warm. Getting home without pulling over to have a slice was a struggle!
The woman on the phone was SO RUDE. I was calling on behalf of a nonprofit organization I volunteer for. We were having a fundraiser and looking for some pizza donations. She told me if I want to ask for a handout and solicit her that I need to do it in the mail. I told her how rude she was and she hung up on me. This is how they treat people? Yes we were looking for pizza to be donated to the fundraiser.. if you were not interested in helping you could have said so. Instead you insulted us and said we were soliciting and asking for handouts. I will make sure to tell everyone I know that orders here not to eat here again!!! We can eat pizza where the people are actually humans with hearts.
Ordered a party pizza last, that was far the BEST we’ve had in a while!!!! 🍕❣️🤗 Thank you!!!
Our favorite spot around the corner from us! If you live in North Buffalo, they have delicious pizza and wings. It has become our go-to place! Everything is always fresh, they don’t skimp on toppings, and they’re always friendly when you walk in the door. 10/10 recommend!
The bbq pit wings crispy are the best around! Meat falls right off the bone. Their bbq is very very scrumptious! Their apple logs with caramel are addicting, thats the perfect snack dessert for sure!! Their pizza is also amazing not greasy but cheesey and the sauce is really really good! Their bread sticks are amazing as well! Overall Ill be ordering from here again.
The best chicken wings I have ever had! First time ordering chicken wings to my liking here and everything was perfect. Food was ready earlier than expected and directions were followed. I will definitely order here again 👍
My family has been ordering from this location since the first day they opened years ago. Have been loyal customers ever since! Almost every week we get their amazing pizza on Tuesdays. My favorite is their ham and cheeseburger subs. Great portion sizes and made to perfection ever time. Highly recommend this place to everyone we know. Their wings are always cooked well and crispy. Their French fries are a personal fav in my household. Staff has always been friendly. Can’t say enough good things about this place.
One of the best pizzas Ive had. Nice level of sauce (not too spicy, not too sweet), good crust, lots of cheese and cup pepperoni. It was the perfect pizza! I would definitely recommend Mustachios.
Amazing food great employees! We have been ordering here for years and the food here is better as time goes by. Working outside of the building and the owner came out and brought us a pie🍕nice to know their are good people out their that care and are generous to look out for others.
Amazing, tasty, juicy, substantial, expensive but its worth every penny!!!
Delicious pizza, crust was thick with a crispy bottom, good sauce nice even cheese to pepperoni ratio. Steak sub was tasty and filling plenty of steak lettuce, tomato and onion and just the right amount of oil. Looking forward to my next visit.
Ive been going to mustachios for a long time, never really had any issues but my last three orders have just been terrible. The first one was just covered in mayo which I just dealt and moved on. The second one was a stinger Sub all the steak was pushed to one side of the sub, was falling apart and was rolled so tight their fingers ripped thru the bread. Third I ordered a full sub got a half. May have to find a new place
Second time ordering here after a cousin recommended it. Mild wings a little rubbery, could have been cooked a bit crisper for my taste, pizza- the crust was tough & chewy with spicy pepperoni. Ask for mild pepperoni if you dont like it spicy. Leftovers I gave to family & I ate a grilled cheese sandwich.
Regrettably I ordered a fish fry at another restaurant this afternoon.At the end of my meal, I was asked how everything was and did I enjoy my meal. I shook my head no!Hostess asked why? I responded with a question.“ Have you ever eaten at Mustachio ‘s?She said no, why?You will have to get a fish fry there… they are delicious, fresh and plentiful.She asked, Where did you say that was?”I smiled and said, “Mustachio’s of course!”
They have good sicilian/thicker than NYC style pizza and their wings are pretty good. We call and pick up our orders and it usually only takes them like 20 minutes to make the food. Finding a place to park can be problematic sometimes, but Im never there for longer than 5 minutes and I like the pizza so its not something I worry about much when driving there.Also, if you are like my sister and decide to ask them for extra sauce on the pizza, they will give you extra sauce. I personally find their normal sauce to crust ratio just fine. 😂
I ordered two subs one steak with mushrooms and fried onions and the other chicken finger . First the delivery driver delivered food and left on the dirty porch 🤮 so I called and the manager offered to re make the subs and send with a different driver. Ok cool so instead they just changed out the bags and resent soggy cold subs not even hot subs to be re made!?!. The steak sub was bland steak tasted dry and in seasoned ! the mushrooms were not fried or cooked and the whole sub tasted bad and like mayonnaise and mushrooms!! The chicken finger sub was cold and it just was not worth a two hour wait to not be re freshly made . 2nd bad experience
Absolutely the best pizza in kenmore/tonawanda hands down. The subs have an unbelievable amount of meat on them. The wings are cooked perfectly and the fingers are the best Ive had. And when you walk into the door, its absolutely Spotless and your order is always on time and hot. Well done on all levels.
I have ordered pickup from Mustachios multiple times over the last 2 years and have always enjoyed my experience and the pizza. However, last night (8/1) I had an experience that makes me not want to give them my service again. I placed an order at 8pm for a delivery, gave my information and order and was told it would be delivered within an hour. About an hour and a half later with still no pizza delivered, I called and asked for the status and was just told it will be there soon and was hung up on...I wasnt even given a chance to give my name, address, or order. At 10pm, now 2 hours after I placed the original order, I called again. When I spoke to someone, I learned that my order was never placed and my pizza was never made. I understand that these mistakes happen and I would not have been upset had it not been for being hung up on before. I ended up cancelling my order and let the employee on the phone know what happened and was offered a $5 credit on my next order. Again, if the person I spoke with at 9:30 had taken the time to speak with me, this would have been sorted out and I would not have been waiting for a pizza that was never made. For waiting for my dinner for 2 hours with guests at my house, a $5 credit does not seem sufficient for the inconvenience. I am disappointed because I do enjoy Mustachios but I have a hard time recommending this place to someone or going there again.
By far the best pizza, Ive had in Buffalo, a must for pizza lovers, I usually dont do reviews, this is my first one ever, thats how good the pizza is 😘🥰
I have lived in buffalo my entire life. This place is superior compared to normal favorites such as Just Pizza, La nova, Anchor Bar, and Duffs. They are always consistent. Wings are crispy and pizza is great. Never underestimate local pizzerias in buffalo!
Went here right before a Bills playoff game and they were absolutely slammed, but they got orders out on time, were patient with people and didnt lose any courtesy or quality. Cant argue with that work ethic. Food was good too of course.
Best pizza in Buffalo and their wings on the pit might be even better!!! Plus they’re always doing great promotions like letting you guess the score of the Bills game to win free pizza. There’s a reason they’ve been around for like 20 years folks!
Mustachio’s is close to my daughter’s home, so I’ve often had their pizza and wings when visiting... I like it so much that the last couple of times I’ve ordered pizza, I’ve gone a bit out of the way fir Mustachio’s. WNY has so much good pizza, but this has become my favorite!
We ordered a large and 50 general tso flavor and Omg by far the best we have had in a long time! Thank you and if you havent had the general tso wings make sure to try them, 5 ppl ate and everyone of us enjoyed it!
Update, back being a fan. When you pick your food up it is much better. We had a calzone 🔥, we had some moustache garlic bread 🔥, and got a pizza and wings last week, everything was great!Updated review. Past 3 orders have been brutal. One time the pizza was dropped and upside down in the box with everything all over. Previous time cold and took almost two hours for delivery. Today on a Wednesday the food was cold, pizza and wings soggy. We live 5 minutes away but our puppy had surgery so in a whim we said lets have mustachios. Small pizza and 10 wings for $40, and would have rather had digiorno and frozen wings. Honestly, ever since pandemic, service and quality has dropped tremendously. Wont be ordering here again for a long time, if ever. From 5 stars to 1 star. Based on previous 3 orders. Very unfortunate but typical to start off fresh and great and after a couple years let it all go....
People are cool and the food is great. I love everything there but the pizza actually. Just not my style but people like it.
The last true buffalo-style pizza place that I know of in Buffalo
Just got an order a few days ago. Basically just a Hawaiian pizza but made with bacon and chicken instead of ham. It wasn’t very good at all which is super surprising because I’ve gotten this combination from here once before and I’ve never really gotten a bad order from mustachios (usually I order subs) but this pizza is just so disgusting and disappointing that I don’t think I would order from here anymore.
My family and I came to visit this Pizzeria all the way from Toronto. Let me just start by saying that we have gone to a lot of the pizza shops around buffalo and Mustachios was the BEST out of them all. My wife and kids absolutely loved it and the owner Bill treated us like family. Even all the guests who walked in were very friendly and said hi. I would love to rate them 10 stars. We will definitely be returning here. I wish they would open up a joint in Toronto
First time customer tonight, now a long time customer! Everything was great from service to food. The pizza is amazing and the wings were cooked to perfection. On top of that, it was nice to speak to someone on the phone that was well mannered and polite! Thank you for the great food and for the great customer service!
Recently started ordering from here. Weve only had pizza and wings so far so I cannot comment on their other food. Pizza is good. Bottom is cooked perfectly and it has a very nice crust. Pepperoni is perfect and the right amount of cheese and sauce. Wings we got hot and medium. Hot wasnt too hot. Id personally like more heat. Had a big order for a party, everything was perfect and they helped carry my order to my vehicle. Definitely will be where we order from in Kenmore.
Ordered for the 1st time. LG pizza and a Turkey sub.Pizza was great, asked for light sauce and well done. It has a nice sweet sauce with a spicy pepperoni. Nice texture with a good doughTurkey sub mozzarella cheese, Turkey needed more flavor to it.Worth the price for a fast dinner. I will probably order again if out this way again.
Love there phone, and almost every knows my name. Bad
First time at this pizzeria. I will be going back again because the pizza is excellent. Sweet sauce, just right amount of cheese, and double the amount of pepperoni versus other pizzerias.And the pepperoni is thick and oily, not thin sliced and dry like most places.
My family and I have been going here ever since they took over Mystic Pizza - I think was the name. We’ve never had anything but great pizza, the wings are always quite meaty, and it was nice to see they’ve taken some precautions in light of the current health crisis.
I have been a Pizza connaseur my entire life, and anybody that knows me know I make one of the meanest pizzas on the planet. But I must give props where props.are due. Great Delivery service great customer service, and a pizza that blew me away. Thank You Guys very satisfied. Highly Recommended by me.
THE BEST PIZZA IN KENMORE!I love their pizza, wings, their subs are amazing too.Basically, if you order here, you will be satisfied with all you receive. The workers are friendly, and work quickly. Could not ask for better service.
Mustachios has pretty consistent food. Its never awful. Last night it happened to be great. Chicken fingers were sauced and cooked perfectly. A little on the small side for the price (about $15 for a single order of chicken fingers with fries and 2 extra blue cheese cups. Currently they are partially through the process of remodeling and so far it looks like they have made some very nice improvements.
Talk about delish!!! Recently I was visiting my daughter and Mustachio’s is just around the corner, so of course I had to try it. The dough was fresh & chewy yet the crust had crunch. The pepperoni cups were cooked perfect (each cup just started to char) but the sauce screamed of authentic old world Italian (seasoned just right with just a bit of sweet). I look forward to my future visits!!!
It was ok Ive had better the service was great
Best pizza and wings. I live almost right next door so I order a lot. The BBQ sauce there is fire. Lots of places bbq just taste like sugar. I normally get 10wings n small pizza (which is like medium at most places 6 slices) wish around $20 and everytime I’m so happy. My favorite pizza places ever!
I tried to order a sheet and 50 wings for my dads 64th birthday and asked for 5 wings plain for my 3yr old because she wont eat them with sauce and its too spicy for her and they would not do it. I dont understand how hard of a request that was ? made me very disappointed Ive been a customer here for over 10 years and never had an issue. How hard was it to just put 5 wings aside with no sauce? Lost a good customer so sad !
The pizza is absolutely amazing here and the service is one of a kind. They make everything hot and fresh for every order. I do suggest giving them a call and ordering a pie for yourself.
Tried the pizza and wings for first time and everything was delicious!! Also love the beef tacos. Is now my go to place when ordering out!! The people that work there are very friendly , great customer service!!!
******Update: they made me a small pizza & it waa delicious and NOT soggy! Also, Bill had been emailing me and gave me this pizza at no charge to make up for my previkus experience! He was correct, it was amazing pizza. Apparently the slices are kept warm in a proofer so I suggest you get a small instead of slices. AGAIN EXCELLENT CUSTOMER SERVICE!!*********** It was close 2 hospital so from out of town I gave a chance! The pizza was soggy like it was a sponge, literally soaked! Staff was friendly, said they ran through oven again but it was still wet sponge!
I order the calzone almost weekly its fantastic and I love their sauce
We love Mustachios, their pizza is to die for. We are also big fans of their Calzones and wings. The service is great, all the staff are friendly and make us feel welcome and remember who were are when we come. That might be telling of us and how often we come :) When we get delivery its always fast and hot when it gets to us.Great food, awesome service could not give them a higher recommendation.
I ordered a full rack of BBQ beef ribs with fries, coleslaw and bread. It was excellent, didnt come close to finishing it, the ribs were loaded with meat. Will be reheating tomorrow. No complaints, nice clean, well run establishment.
Have always, thoroughly, enjoyed the food from here. I don’t know who the guy was who I tried to order from today, but you shouldn’t make your customers feel stupid simply because they may be ignorant to what comes on all of your food or what their options may be. It shouldn’t matter whether your busy or not. Treat all of your guests individually and don’t expect they know the menu like you do. Other than that, awesome place. Not sure when I’ll order again due to this guys rudeness.
Just picked up a large pizza today for my first time. The pizza tasted awesome, when I walked in store the environment was nice and SUPER CLEAN!!!! Definitely a 5-star to be my first time here. I love it !
We order from here at least once a week. Everything is always hot and delicious! Their pepperoni is my favorite! Must try!
This is our local pizzeria. Those of you who read my posts know what Im about to say...the food here is downright yummies!!Weve had many different pizzas from here as well as salads, calzones, wraps and chicken fingers. I would also highly recommend the ravioli.So if youre in Kenmore order and take it home. The one drawback to this place is that theres very little in the way of seating.
I love their pizza. It is among the best in the area. Ive found the service to be good as well. Re: Employee hygiene. How do you think you would look working in a hot kitchen? Im sure they shower every day, but it doesnt take long to become sweaty and unkempt looking. I know because I myself worked in a kitchen years ago.
Delicious, my new favorite local pizza shop. Have been going for a bit and havent had any problems with an order yet. Doesnt hurt that I can order online, which is how I found out it was nearby.
1st time ordering from here and everything was amazing. Great pizza. We will be back again.
Ordered large pizza & bucket specialAnd a ham sub.Everything was good except the medium wings should’ve been cooked longer and requested extra saucy but the wings weren’t saucy at all.
The last family party we had I ate the wings, they were all very good but the teriyaki were out of this world. Pizza was excellent. We will be having Mustachios at all our parties. Sharon Van Ness
First time in New York and wanted to try local restaurants. So happy we found Mustachios. Service and food was excellent and the owner Bill talked with our family and made us feel so welcome. Other restaurants should take lessons from Bill and the crew at Mustachios. Great food and excellent customer service makes us want to come back!! (We would love a Mustachios in Charleston, South Carolina 😊)
This is my favorite spot to get Pizza. The staff are friendly and I usually see the same faces so its nice to be taken care of by people who youre used to. They recently did some upgrading and the place looks great with the changes. I usually get pizza and wings. My favorite place for them.
I never have any complaints. I can order a delivery or pick up and its always ready in a reasonable time. Even during the superbowl. Food is always fresh. Ive yet to have a messed up order. Ive been ordering faithfully for the last 3 years!
The small pizza is HUGE! I was expecting a truly small pizza similar to Pizza Huts Personal Pan Pizza, like 5 inches. But this was significantly larger.
The best Delivery in Buffalo. Their wings are some how great as well. Top 3 wings in Buffalo, try the hot mustard. They have an expansive menu and everything is great.
Tried Mustachios pizza and wings for the first time a couple weeks ago. The food was very good, will definitely buy there again.
We have sampled a few varieties of pizza, wings, and dinner items, and have not been disappointed yet. When they estimate the time the food will be ready for pick up or delivery, they are spot on. Thank you, Mustachios!
Great Wings..Char Barbeque is the Best.Sorry i forgot to mention the pizza...This place is truly a Great place to get you a delicious Pizza and some great wings....
If youre not eating Mustachios, youre NOT eating. One of the best pizzerias in WNY. Great food, good prices and a personable staff.
I’ve lived in Kenmore for a long time, and I’ve ordered here periodically, but lately it’s the only place we go. I’ve gotten delivery (mainly subs - stinger, finger, turkey, bacon cheeseburger) 4 times in the past few weeks and I couldn’t be happier. Subs have been perfect every time, and that was no change tonight. Delivery before the quoted time, hot subs arrive hot. Just overall, couldn’t be happier. This will be a continued go-to for us from now on. Great job.
If this place sold stock in this company I would buy it. Food is amazing and they called me to say they messed up a minor detail on my order and offered apologies. This kind of attention to detail is making me proud of this local place.
The food does not taste all that great, no seasoning at all, the food taste bland, I read the reviews and I was quite surprised till I got my food now Im really surprised order two cheeseburgers a antipasto salad which was mostly lettuce I mean a whole lot of lettuce and a steak sandwich , all I tasted was the cheese on the steak sandwich, the two cheeseburgers the guys threw them in the garbage, my opinion order at your own risktwo people for the cheeseburgers they threwthem both in the garbage
Do yourself a favor and have the Steak Hoagie Supreme pizza! Its one of the best things I have ever eaten! Youll thank me later. The tacos and fajitas are also top notch... The only thing holding me back from the 5th star is the wings... For some reason, I always have issues when I get wings from there.
Hoping the pizza is decent...looking at this page for prices and expected the family pack was going to be $20 then added tip for driver of $5....my bill came to $37.62. Manager said they wont honor price on this site...that hes tried to contact them for 8yrs to change it. Im hoping the pizza and wings are worth it...BAD TASTE ALREADY AND 1ST TIME ORDERING!!!
Great food, good prices, awesome staff. The owner even took time to talk to me and my wife to discus what to stay away from with her allergies.
Excellent food I ordered pizza and wings I was never unhappy with their food and all the time Ive been going to them one of my number one pizzerias to go to
The food is great ( cant say enough about the spinach ricotta pizza!) and the service is good, but remember to add 5+ min on picking up anything. not to much of a hindrance if you know about it but makes the wait a little awkward if you didnt.
My1st time ordering from this establishment customer service was nice... My problem was i wanted to try the garlic parm for the 1st time and i asked 4 crispy wings not only were they rubbery but not done ....needless to say they were unedible so as i see it money wasted ....dont think i will order again
So I ordered a Pizza from mustachio’s this is how I ordered it small light sauce extra cheese and well-done the sauce was overflowing on it they didn’t cut it and The cheese was literally falling off in the box completely ridiculous
Normally I LOVE this place, but I ordered a calzone without the ricotta, just mozz and pepperoni....first of all, there online menu says that its 7.50, I get there and I was charged 11.75...not a huge deal, but it was misleading. Then I get home and cut it in half, and there was almost no cheese AT ALL, yet it was insanely overloaded with pepperoni. So I called to complain which i have NEVER done before, and the guy tells me they put the right amount on it. I am so pissed off that I just paid 12 bucks for dough and pepperoni....get it together mustachios! I will never go there again.
I finally tried Mustachios after driving by their place for over 2 years. Intimidated by the big, curly mustache that continually brought images of hairs in my pizza, I never had the nerve to try it until recently. I was pleasantly surprised by the lack of hair in my food. The pizza was okay - nothing too special. It tasted kind of like bowling-alley pizza - the bland, pre-made type that isnt terrible, but isnt really great. The real surprise came a day later, when I started to feel a little ill. I later learned that food poisoning usually sets in about a day to day-and-a-half later. Seeing as this was the only real food I had across a whole day and a half, it seems likely that Mustachios was the culprit. Eat at your own risk. No hair though!
Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Thanks for the free small pizza guys! Wish you guys had a spot in blasdell area.
This place has amazing food . The owner has remodeled the the interior of the dining room and and looks absolutely gorgeous and stunning. If you need your food delivered it is done in a very timely and professional manner.
This place have the worst sevice an customer service in the world gave me the wrong order and refused to correct it.. Ill never order from this place again...
So Im here from south dakota I ordered pizza from this place last night and had no idea this would be the best pizza Ive ever had ...seriously Im going to come back to Buffalo for this pizza.....this pizza would leave Gordon Ramsey speechless...Im considering quitting my job and becoming a homeless bum to be closer to this pizza👀🤣🤣
Excellent service. Extraordinary food (my dad recommends the steak hoagie). The owner Bill, by far, has made this one of the best New York experiences I’ve had on vacation.
Food and service is always top notch!
Pizza is not much better than Chuck E cheese! Wings are always undercooked and rubbery! The subs are the only good thing here!
This place is only two blocks from me, so I read some of the reviews and decided to chance it. With so many pizza and wing options, just ok isnt good enough for me. I ordered pizza and char pit wings, nothing special, just ok. Probably wont go back.
We love Mustachios! The staff is friendly and efficient and the food is always delicious. Great local place.
Great pizza!! Baked until done, unlike every other pizzerias raw dough.. Good quality ingredients.
Beautiful service and good quality food. Clean and healthy environment
Wings were tiny and undercooked, and tasted like the fryer was filthy. Staff all looked like they dont shower, kitchen looked dirty, and I didnt see anyone wearing gloves or hats or anything. Seriously not recommended.
Absolutley fantastic pizza! crispy pepperoni and the best white pizza in town. You wont get better than Mustachios service and quality.
Worse than terrible. Food was gross last time I got, but its the only place on the way home from where I work, On the last vist the real problem was the service. 2 guys with tattoos, Im used to pizza guys guys being rude but these 2 stunk, and not like grease but like B.O. I dont think showers are part of company policy here. And I saw why when the owner showed up, typical type of jerkoff that owns these places, he was ruder to me than the people that work for him. I ended up just throwing the food in the trash, judging by how upset the skinny guy with the tats looked by me showing up and actually paying money towards his paycheck Im sure he spit in it or something. From now on I just go to Tops and buy real food on the way home from work and cook it myself, at least that way I know its being made by someone who has good hygene and cares about the quality of the food.
Good food and friendly staff. Our old pizza place changed for the worse, so we tried Mustachios and loved it. Never going back to the old one.
Pizza was under cooked, got onions and they were soggy, need to cook 1 more minute, other wise great dough
Spaghetti and meatballs pizza is delicious
Ordered from them weekly until a couple months ago, The man taking my order literally was telling me “we write this on paper, I’m running out of room” when I was telling him what I wanted on my subs..like oh okay. He was so rude. I cancelled my order and haven’t been back.
Great pizza! Perfect amount of grease to put it on target! Love the triple cheese anchovie pizzas! Very cool staff, very timely!
DELICIOUS! We ordered a small and a large pizza. This is more of a carryout place but we ate there. Pizza was really good and reasonably priced.
Great food and a huge variety. Wings are nice and crispy and pizza is delish. Other appetizers are great too.
I have never ate at Mustachios ever but i decided on the fish and fries. The fries were good / great the fish on the other hand was HORRIBLE over cooked to the max
What a dump. The pizza is worse than just pizza or mister pizza the slices are tiny tasteless and greasy in the worst way. Theres a weird smell to the store I dont know what it is. The metal music was way to loud and annoying to have to listen to while waiting. I got 2 slices to eat there but I took about 3 bites and wanted to spit it up I threw it all away.
Best Pizza in Kenmore. Fast and friendly service. Slices always ready during and after lunch time.
Great food, wait times inaccurate. Ive always arrived on time for pick up orders but had to wait roughly 10 extra min. Food is worth the wait though.
Pit bbq wings are great... when theyre great. But they arent always. Place lacks consistency.. feels like no one cares.
Some of the best Strombolis Ive had. I cant speak to the quality of the pizza but if its anything like the stromboli... Worth an honest visit.
Best pizza in Kenmore!!
Best calzone Ive had in many years. Super fast th and friendly staff. Will go back again.
Last couple times I went there at the pizza and wings have been excellent
Extremely friendly staff and a great Stromboli. Their marinara is amazing if you like it sweet
I love their Supreme Deluxe pizza is amazing goalie $23 cant beat it its huge has all the toppings and its loaded
Inviting, friendly atmosphere. The chicken fingers were large and delicious. Couldnt eat them fast enough.
Great pizza and wings. The people there are really nice too 😁
Large portions great taste
Ive always gotten a good pizza and wings here. The staff is friendly, definitely would recommend.
Delicious pizza! Great friendly staff and service!
This place is amazing they have excellent food great salads good pizza and theyre spending a lot of money investing in the building itself!
Decent food at a reasonable price. Great BLT sub but otherwise just another pizza place.
Felt sick after eating their pizza and the staff is pretty rude. Would rather get dominos than eat from here.
Fantastic service and amazing food - they never disappoint! The Charbecue Wings and Potato Skins are the best in town
Best pizzeria in the area food is great prices are reasonable Services fast
It is was ok, they took a long time to get the pizza ready, which is was not very cheap either, not really worth $16.99 for a small pizza. Bbq chicken.
Been there twice and both times we had a great pizza!!
This is for the manager there, I order all the time and Iam gonna still keep ordering but that being said I wanted to let you know, I ordered 2 fish dinners today and they were not wroth 1 star my husband got blue cheese instead of tarter sauce my tarter sauce was not edible the potatoe salad was hard it was was a busy day but I think costumes would rather wait for there food to be right then to have it rushed out and wrong!!
Very courteous, good food excellent service. And they hook up the military discount
Our go-to pizza place! Great wings too!!
When they are good, they are great. When they are not so good, they are average. Most of thre time they are pretty good. Calzones are a solid sleeper pick.
Been a regular here for years, always a great standard cheese pepperoni pie. Try the taco pizza!
Nice Buffalo style pizza! Our new go-to.
Best pizza in Kenmore.
I apsolutley LOVE Mustachios. We order at least once a week. Happy with all. Enjoy all the workers...
Great pizza I also had a 2.00 coupon from the valu blue pack coupons that come in the mail.
Ordered a small double cheese and pepperoni pizza and 10 wings, when they delivered they sent a double cheese pizza and 10 wings, when I called about it the manager argued with me the we only ordered a cheese pizza because thats what the receipt said, if you are going to argue with me and tell me Im wrong when I know what o ordered you will not get my business from here on out your customer sucks.
Just bad. Mediocre at best=pizza. Subs all bread!!!
DEEEEEEE LICIOUS ❣️ bbq pit the best
Best pizza around Buffalo NY
The pizza and wings are great and the people ans service are great as well
Everyone at mustachios are great they were my home kitchen for 6 months over this pandemic I THANK YOU ALL
Very good food i reccommed the chicken finger salad and they are very friendly and polite
Great pizza and wings at a reasonable price.
Food was hot and tasty, but the gravy on the poutine was a bit thin for my taste.
Great pizza. Great people. whenever Im in that area I stop at mustachios.
I love buffalo chicken finger pizza, it is especially yummy from Mustachios :)
Favorite local spot for pizza, Wong, or calzones. Never disappointed when getting food from here
Amazing food quality, generous portions and great customer service
Not the best sanitary but some unfriendly workers
I thought that the food was great me and my wife and kids love the food and service bigg thumbs up!!!!
Great food. Pizza, subs. Great staff, and very quick service.
Great service, awesome spaghetti dinner, and theyre remodeling - love the better sheltered entrance...thanks.
Walked in randomly just looking for a quick lunch, walked out a forever loyal customer. These guys just do pizza right period.
Good pizza!👍🍕
Great local pizza place with great prices. Great staff and good eats.
Best pizza place Ive found in buffalo yet!
Delicious pizza and you can buy by the slice!
This is my favorite spot for sure they never disappoint 👍👍
I love this place. The people who work there are literally the best.
Amazing place , food on point with whatever you get 🤘🤘
Delicious and neighborhood family! The staff is unbeatable!
Got a couple of hot slices to go they have great pizza
Awesome service great food and owner is there a lot and always greets you and clean
I’m very upset tonight me and my family order a pizza from my regular Spot mustachio’s and came in looking like this
Excellent pizza. Good, but pricy, wings.
Excellent food,Excellent friendly employees..
Pretty good food fast
Ordered delivery. Pizza was delicious & the food was delivered promptly.
Hands down the best food in town..the staff is quick and courteous..I love this place.
Their calzones are THE BEST! Great staff, great food.
I always feel welcome when I order from here. Never had anything bad either
Total reviews rating 4.4
199 Reviews for Mustachios Pizzeria 2023:
Review №1
2022-03-20A lot of people have seen my last review about mustachios regarding a bad experience that I had with the pizza back a month ago. After the owner was aware of it he Immediately took action to solve the problem and for that I am grateful. I will leave some pictures here of the pizza we received today for my son’s birthday. It was really good and cooked to perfection.
Review №2
2022-02-04This place has great food. Main reason I keep coming back is because of the awesome delivery drivers that are always on time and very courteous. Typically it’s hard to find this with most pizzerias. I normally get Travis, Dom or Seth as my delivery driver and man are they great kids. Great pizza and even better that I can expect consistently swift delivery!
Review №3
2022-04-02I always enjoy any food I get here. This Pizza is great! The wings are great! My latest discovery has been just how amazing their fresh cooked roast beef is. No one likes a roast beef sub with processed meat and it is some of the best roast beef around. Places are good when they do more than one thing well and you guys nail it every time!
Review №4
2022-06-05We started recently getting a large cheese pizza and antipasto every Saturday. The quality is always the same its excellent. Very consistent with fast delivery. There antipasto is delicious and comes with everything you could possibly want in it. I definitely recommend this restaurant. 😃
Review №5
2021-03-18This place seems to keep getting better. Classic buffalo style pizza. Dough was thick and fluffy and had a buttery crust. Everything I have had here is good. Definitely recommend giving this sleeper a try
Review №6
2022-03-25Im a regular, great pizza, wings and never disappointed by other menu items we order on occasion. I suggest this pizzeria to others in the area and when I have company I order from here and theyre always satisfied as well.
Review №7
2022-07-09Dear Pizzeria, Mustachios; Overall, was pretty good, but uh, kind of worried how they got on mars, and still do delivery? Im sure its fine though, they managed to be right on time.. Im glad the tech from Elon Musk is going to good use. - From your new loyal but concerned customer: Spee (P.S. see attached image for additional context, please and thank you.)
Review №8
2022-07-04Popped in Saturday ordered 2 subs to go. Ready in about 15 minutes!!! Usually we order delivery. Which is always spot on. We are more than happy with everything!!! ❤️
Review №9
2022-06-21Ive been there often since it is right around the corner from my house. Food is good. Front counter guy is rude af. I can get good food with better customer service elsewhere. Will NOT be returning.
Review №10
2022-07-09My first visit to Mustachios and boy was it great. Very friendly and professional staff. Great portions, prices and selections. This will now be my families go to !!!