New York Bagel in Cortland
Categories
Location on the map
Cortland, Cortland County, New York, US
Service options
Accessibility
Dining options
Planning
- Monday:7AM–4PM
- Tuesday:7AM–4PM
- Wednesday:7AM–4PM
- Thursday:7AM–4PM
- Friday:7AM–4PM
- Saturday:7AM–4PM
- Sunday:8AM–3PM
New York Bagel in other cities:
The staff are super friendly, they play good music, the bagels are good, they got good orange juice thats not from concentrate, and they got coffee mania coffee which is really good. I got a bagel w garlic & herb cream cheese, capers, lox, spinach and red onion. It was great! Thanks New York Bagel!
Ive tried not to write anything during COVID as I know things are not normal, but when you walk into a place that specializes in bagels at 7:45 AM, you expect a nice warm, fresh bagel. Not the case. Rock hard stale and absolutely no flavor (everything bagel). Service was fine, but it was also empty. I dont think they toasted it very long, because of how hard it was to begin with. Just shocked that a place with bagel in the name would serve such a bad bagel.
It was a cool Sunday afternoon in April, when I found myself drawn to the idea of a toasted bagel sandwich, So with visions of glistening melted cheese and crisp toasted deliciousness I walked into the New York Bagel, I was taken back by the amount of people in line ahead of me, and nearly turned around to leave, but the promise of local bagel heaven was to much to turn down.The line moved quickly and I soon found myself at the counter ready to place my order. 1 Italian sandwich I proclaimed, to which the man behind the counter responded we only have whole wheat bagels right now, I stammered momentarily unsure what to make of the situation, as the line of hungry college students grew behind me, It was then that the man behind the counter suggested I try the sandwich as a wrap, I agreed, and he took my name, and handed me my slip.As I waited for my wrap I took note of the eating area, very few tables occupied the small establishment, each of which seated 4 people comfortably, there was a stair case leading down, though I did not get an opportunity to explore as my name was promptly called for wrap.Tightly twisted inside the green spinach tortilla were 3 meats, tomatoes, lettuce, and, cheese, however it was hard to distinguish between the various flavors as the salami was cut as thick as $.75 worth of quarters stacked together, which would have been amazing on a bagel, but only proved a challenge in a wrap, the tomatoes were juicy and the tortilla was fresh, an overall enjoyable wrap, though Im not going to go out of my way to spend another $7+ on it.Overall if not for the wonderful service I may have given my experience 3 stars, but good customer service and presentation are far more rare than an over priced wrap with 8oz salami slices.
Best place to grab breakfast in the morning. Theyre dough is shipped straight from Long Island. They have an ever growing assortment of bagels and other breakfast items including many gluten free options. If you are in the area I highly recommend you stop by and try one of their amazing bagels, but if you arent a bagel fan, fear not, they have paninis, wraps, and other sandwiches.
Every single time I order from them they get my order wrong, this has happened on multiple occasions and the last time when I politely told the lady it was wrong her response was “well I already made it so..” I understand things happen however this has happened to me almost every time I go and I do not appreciate the way they responded
Last time I went to New York Bagel, I was given a different sandwich than what I was charged for. When I complained, I received a lukewarm apology and no offer of a refund or any sort of compensation. The items served are much better than other local options, but the staffs organization and overall hospitality is lacking here.
I came here on recommendation and was not particularly impressed. The bagels are not toasted for the bagel sandwiches, which is normally fine, but these bagels were cold while the contents were warm.. ultimately making for a lukewarm sandwich. There was also very little selection for bagels. Not much seating either.
Total reviews rating 4.3
110 Reviews for New York Bagel 2023:
Review №1
2021-12-30Placed a catering order on very short notice for 16 people. The manager was so friendly and more than happy to help out getting this order together. The sandwiches and bagel chips were amazing. They do more than just bagels. The sandwiches are upscale and simply phenomenal. Delicious!
Review №2
2022-04-01Great bagels, plus they have cool funky flavors. Not only good service and bagels but smoothies and more stuff. This place loads the cream cheese up in the bagel just like you are hoping for, trust me.
Review №3
2022-05-21Awesome and friendly staff, Ive never had a bad experience here. I love that I can get Coffee Mania coffee here. They have great food!
Review №4
2022-04-03I’m a local and have worked on main street at a restaurant myself so I try to be patient and understanding but I’ve given this place so many chances because I like their menu options but the service is awful 9/10 times. Wrong orders, people served ahead of us after coming in way after, not calling our order out. Not going back again unfortunately!
Review №5
2019-02-25They have few very nice bagels. The space has a good spot with road side view. My kids favorite there is hot chocolate. The staff is young and active. A good bagel and coffee place in the town just at the main street.
Review №6
2022-02-12I love this place. I have literally never been disappointed with anything I’ve gotten there. The staff is nice, and the owner is amazing. One of my favorite places!
Review №7
2019-04-05So glad we decided to come here on a whim. They have Açaí bowls served all day that are very delicious and bagel sandwiches made to order. I had a hard time deciding what I wanted because everything looked so yummy! Service was very prompt and kind in waiting/helping me decide what I wanted. Hope I can come back here soon for a bagel!
Review №8
2021-10-13We came here on a whim after another local shop had a really long line and were pleasantly surprised! The coffee was delicious and they had a ton of different flavors. The breakfast sandwich was a generous size and very tasty. We saw about 5 other things on the menu that we talked about coming back to try. Will definitely return!
Review №9
2020-12-30Great place to grab breakfast or lunch. Their breakfast and lunch wraps are very yummy. The bagels aren’t the best in my opinion because they are kind of on the dry side, Price Chopper makes a better fresher bagel than NY bagel does. Overall though it’s a good place to get food. The customer service is always friendly!
Review №10
2022-06-17The food, the teen, and the atmosphere are beyond measure.Love love love...