Delivery
Yes
New York Pizza in Plattsburgh
Categories
Location on the map
Plattsburgh, Clinton County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
No
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Phone: +1 518-563-0677
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–9PM
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–9PM
- Saturday:11AM–9PM
- Sunday:11AM–9PM
New York Pizza in other cities:
Comments (97)
Amazing pizza and the man making it is so nice. Great place for pizza night
Best pizza in Plattsburgh and deff the best price!!!!
Excellent New York style pizza. Owner was right, We ate the whole pie immediately. Let me tell you, if you want a NY pie with typical old school NY hospitality, this is the place for you. So worth the 3.5 hour drive!!!!! My future wife and I have decided we will HAVE to share a pie from here on our wedding day. Please open a store in Keene NH!!!! We would be your best customers!!!!!
Pizza is Excellent, Me and my wife have been looking for a good pizza since our favorite place closed down a couple of years ago. We have finally found it and excited to go back. Keep up the great job.
Been all over had many different pizzas from different states and this is by far the best and freshest pizza you can find homemade from scratch the place it self is clean well kept the owner Bill is fun and friendly and the people that are leaving bad reviews are Karens and some of them work at other pizza shops that suck and are afraid because New York Pizza is the #1 best Pizza you will find anywhere
Pizza is alright but thats all they have. no wings or anything else. theyre also always out of pretty much every topping you can think of. hope you like cheese!
Went in on this cold new years weekend night, and ordered the 2 pizza-2 liter deal. The pizzas were excellent. Cooked to perfection, price was right, friendly owner, and fast service. Im a Plattsburgh native, and very impressed. Dont waste your time anywhere else. This is the best pizza in the area.
Shut the door and locked us out, told us they dont make pizza and ontop of it told us they had no dough. Never returning there ever again. Seems like a cover to traffic drugs/guns. very shady.
Best pizza I have ever had eating there again before I leave
Excellent pizza yum yum - Had my first slice of their pizza yesterday and it was delicious! Ive lived in plattsburgh 5 years and I cant believe I am just now trying this place out. Great pizza and at a great price. Right now I can get 2 pizza pies and a 2 liter for 20 bucks. I can see this place as my go to pizza restaurant for awhile to come!The guy that said the crust is too thin obviously doesnt know what a new york pizza is!
Great place to grab a pizza. He really does have the best pizza in town and he uses only the best ingredients. He only sells pizza by the whole pie, and he doesn’t carry any sides or extras. If you can get over the fact that he doesn’t sell anything but pizza and can enjoy good food then you should think about stopping by.
Always a pleasure to eat this pizza. Super friendly staff and amazing pizza. Inside is a bit underwhelming but the owner is a super nice guy. My pizza tonight was done in 8 minutes! Give them a try!
Passed the place many times but finally tried it. Very good pizza and prices a little cheaper then national chains. When I was there limited selection as they had run out of several ingredients and charge card machine was broke. Worth a visit
Small gem, pizza is excellent!
The Best pizza shop in plattsburgh
Stove and floor etc, was actually dirty. Ive heard he has good pizza but I myself wouldnt eat here. I guess he does mainly delivery thats good cause the inside is not up to my standards not even close!!!
I am ffrom Long Island and have always looked for a comparable pizza in the North Country, my search is over the best Pizza intown hands down!! The owner has pride in his Pies too, he always shows me what he has made for me, and you can see he really loves his work.
Sausage has a sweet taste! Inconsistent price. Ive been charged $16 for 1 and 2 toppings, which should certainly not be the case. I would typically get 2 toppings, paying $16. Then, a couple of times, I opted for just 1 topping to pay the few bucks less, but was charged the same $16 every time as if it was a flat price! This left a bitter taste in my mouth.
Ive had better pizza 🍕 out of a .99 cent box from the local dollar store 🏬.
Absolutely amazing pizza! Easily the best pizza in Plattsburgh by far. As close to NYC style as you will get outside of the city. The owner gets his supplies direct from NYC too.
Pizza was good. But thats all they have is pizza. The menu on facebook and there website is over 2 years outdated. The lights were off. And one of the owners friends was at a table watching tv and checking his blood pressure with a very loud little machine. Register didnt work so you will get change back from the owners back ppocket. Also I do believe the owner is a dealer so if you need some drugs he can hook you up lol.
Very good pizza, best in Plattsburgh....tasty sauce and great cheese ...and dough is legit. Best you will find in this area....lil small hole in the wall place.....thats where the good food is found...Owner is from Bronx and hes a cool cat too. Call ahead....good eats.#BuddhaReview
Best pizza in Plattsburgh
Best pizza in the area and at a great price.Just try it
If you go to college here and are eating anything but this I feel bad for you. This is clearly the best pizza in the area. Ingredients are from the Bronx. This guy does it right. Really great prices too.
Best Pizza I have had. If You love pizza you will love this place.
My first day in Plattsburgh was visiting this place at lunchtime. I just moved here for new job. Walked in, looked at the menue overhead, and asked for slice, no slices....so I looked at the menu again saw it said subs and sandwiches, no sandwiches, just whole pies....then take down your stupid sign, you idiot.....asked to use bathroom, he says use the laundromat next door....definately a front....dont bother....
The pizza was okay but the restaurant appeared like it was going out of business and there were no other options. Also the price of one pizza was about $20 and you can only get a large.
Definitely the best pizza around
GREAT pizza. Honestly one of the best cheese pizzas I’ve ever had. This will be my go to place when I come to Plattsburgh.
Every other pizza place in Plattsburgh is pure and utter trash. Trust when I say New York pizza is the spot, its how pizza is supposed to taste. Youre welcome!
Drove 2 hours from Vermont to try this place out based on the reviews. I would do it again, awesome pizza and a cool pizza maker!
Went in for the first time tonight..got a half plain half pepperoni..delicious, ate half a pie myself..knows his pizza and the best ingredients..its the go to for me from now on
Best NY pizza North of NYC, I drive 45 minutes each way to get one of his pies, theyre that good.
Great New York style pizza and I would know cuz I live in New York City dont think youll find Better Than This Town or anywhere nearby
Only whole pie or a slice? Cash only.Never ordered
Owner said it would be good... Hes 100%...go get a pie Plattsburgh peeps.
Hes always got the best NYC style Pizza. Best cheese best sauce. Hands down number 1 on Plattsburgh NY.
After trying EVERY SINGLE pizza place in Plattsburgh, I have to say - New York Pizza is by far the BEST!!
Always amazing food prepared quickly and deliciously and you cant beat the two pizza special
Best pizza in town and cant ask for better owner operator he is so pleasant to talk with and his cooking is off the chart
Great pizza! The pizza guy made pizza in the Bronx for 27 years.
The best pizza Ive had in Plattsburgh! The building is old but the pizza is first rate!
The only true NYstyle pizza north of Glens falls. At least as far as I care.
Great pizza...The owner is a really nice guy. The pizzas are good and done quickly
Best pizza in town but the guy is too cheap to hire a delivery driver. Would be 5 if they delivered
Nice price, friendly owner, good food and fast service... honestly the closet to New York pizza.
A great pizzeria and more, wings and subs are delicious. Great service , cleanliness is good, staff is friendly and courteous
NYPD! New York Pizza is Delicious! thank you for the experience, everything was good!!
Best real pizza in the county... Real NYC/NJ pizza
Very good pizza! Everything was good. À good place for take-out.
Excellent Pizza... Do your self a favor and give it a try.
Best pizza in town and its real nyc pizza
Its pretty good pizza a little greasy but I love it
The pizza here is really good and reasonably priced!
Excellent pizza, rather go here over Bazzano
Theres none better.
My go-to pizza place for many years!
Great deal on the 2 pies and great pizza!
Best pizza in town and awesome service!
The BEST pizza in the entire area!
Wont find another shop with a owner who is as passionate about food and ingredients!!!
Best doggone Pizza in the entire city of Plattsburgh!
First time in town... went because it was not in center of town... awesome pizza!
Love this place awesome pizza great service
Best Pizza Ive ever had!!!!
Best place in Plattsburgh for pizza, hands down!!!!
Best tasting pizza in town!!!!
Awesome just like NYC pizza
Best NYC pie in town. The real deal.
Pizza as it should be. great customer service.
Pizza was very good
The best pizza in the area!
Always great service and great food.
However I give up. They never answer the phone!!!!!!!!!!!!! Going with Big Sals now.
Very good service and very good food
Best pizza in plattsburgh
Yummy.
Great pizza
Best dough in town
Pizza is nasty😖
Yummy pizza
Great pizza
Great pizza
Best in town
Great pizza and Great Price. Visit here many times
Amazing pizza and best service. Definitely recommend
Total reviews rating 4.4
97 Reviews for New York Pizza 2023:
Review №1
2022-07-07Absolutely delicious pizza. The service is incredible too. Nice and honest people. Definitely recommend
Review №2
2021-10-10One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Incredible value and no fuss. Just great pizza. It was so good.
Review №3
2022-05-21I really enjoyed this pizza, the owner is a funny guy. He was right, it is the best pizza in plattsburg. Will definitely go again
Review №4
2021-09-25My husband has been going here since forever and Ive never been. Well tonight was my first time trying pizza from here and I must say, absolutely phenomenal. Best tasting pizza around! Fresh and homemade. Great price too! If youre up for some great home pizza definitely stop here, it is well worth it.
Review №5
2021-05-29Best pizza in Plattsburgh with great service. Nothing in the area compares. This is now my go-to pizza place. Nice thin crust with fresh ingredients.
Review №6
2022-04-16Fantastic pizza at a reasonable price! Glad we discovered New York Pizza. Well be back!
Review №7
2017-04-26Best pizza that Ive ever had! He started out making pizza in the Bronx for 34 years! Its the real deal New York style pizza!
Review №8
2022-02-21First time ever going here, definitely won’t be the last. Great pizza, great service.
Review №9
2022-06-06Top notch pizza pie. Its authentic and made with a lot of love❤👍👍🍕
Review №10
2021-11-17Perfect pizza, great sauce and cheese, dough thin and crispy, all high quality, for most reasonable price,the owner is a good guy only place I go for pies in town.