No-contact delivery
Yes
New York Pizzeria in Canastota
Categories
Location on the map
Canastota, Madison County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Offerings
Late-night food
Yes
Organic dishes
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Salad bar
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
University students
Yes
Payments
Cheques
Yes
Debit cards
Yes
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 315-697-3993
Site: https://www.facebook.com/NewYork...
Site: https://www.facebook.com/NewYork...
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–10PM
- Saturday:11AM–10PM
- Sunday:2–9PM
New York Pizzeria in other cities:
Comments (156)
Delicious NY style pizza. It has a nice thin, chewy crust and the pizza sauce had a great flavor. They offer many options for slices, including tomato pie, cheese, garlic, meat lovers, bbq chicken, buffalo chicken, pepperoni, and more.
Always consistent service and great quality food. Can get busy on regular pizza ordering days, but theyre really good about getting things out fast. Staff is friendly, most are following Covid measures but not all. Would recommend for pizza and wings, havent tried much else there.
Moved to Canastota almost two years ago and this has been our favorite pizza in the area. Have ordered multiple times and have never had a problem. Their pizza and wings are fantastic and the quality has been spot on. Delivery drivers are always friendly and usually my order arrives quite quickly.
Terrible service, no slices, frozen dough with lack of proofing, wasnt greeted upon entry, zero to no customer service.
4.4 makes me believe this google rating is nothing but employees spamming ratings. This pizza is competing for the worst in town with Hometown . It was incredibly over cheesed, under cooked, and disproportionately topped. On top of that, the quality of the cheese was so poor that I felt like I was chewing something artificial. It was the consistency of children’s slime. I also ordered wings that were supposed to be extra crispy and were more like soggy garbage and also under sauced. We’ve given this place multiple chances with ZERO change ... I will not order from here again !
I love the chicken wings but the pricing is ridiculous. So we came yup with a sauce recipe and cook the store bought wings in an air fryer. A fraction of the cost!Addendum: To be fair, the pizza and wings at NYP are awesome. Since Ive retired, were forced to cut corners and eating take out is a luxury. Were still stopping for the occasional pizza. I mean no disrespect to the owner. Very nice guy.
I dont understand why the full menu isnt available online, only appetizers. I cant imagine the amount of business lost due to people wanting to see a menu but cant. Not good business practice. I guess well order from a place that shows a full menu online. As for the food , might be good might not be.
First, the good: an extra large will feed an army of 8. A slice, based on weight alone, would be enough for an Iditarod team. Which is a great value. Except...Now the bad: The cheese, sauce and dough of a pizza is what makes a pizza special. Any one of them is awesome,, you get a great pie.. any two and you have a dream.. all three and you never leave the place!! Here, though - at every turn here, bland is the only word to describe the flavor. There is zero flavor in any of it.That said... perhaps its their lack of understanding what veggies do on a pizza (they are full of water - takes some thought to cooking).Then the worst part... it was supposed to be half and half. At pickup, they realized they forgot to put half the toppings on (kudos for catching that!). But to fix things, they just threw cold, raw toppings on it!! They didnt know I was standing right there (its a busy place)... but wow.
When we moved from Oneida to Canastota over twenty years ago, we thought we would miss Pepis. We do not. Stotas NY Pizzaria is the best!!
I live next door so I order a lot. Im slowly making my way through the menu. I have never been disappointed. Portions are large (even a small salad is HUGE)prices are reasonable, staff is always, ALWAYS great. I get really nervous ordering things on the phone and its never been an issue. Wish I could post a picture of the pizza I picked up an hour ago, probably the best thing Ive ever tasted. Love this place !!!
I ordered 40 wings 20 honey mustard and 20 hot bbq. the honey mustard wings only had honey on them and very dry .my son wouldnt even touch them .mine were so so. and took hour and half to deliver on Thursday night. i am taking business else where
Best pizza outside of New York City. Blessed to live here with great pizza only minutes away! Wings are always perfect. They make a damn good meatball sub too
Ordered a bunch of stuff about a week ago and I asked for my daughters boneless wings to be mild mean while older bunch of wings and pizza my wings I asked for hot they made her hot , I was told they used the same sauce so they gave me a credit. While so I get my credit today and they said 25 to 35 minutes I went their 50 minutes later and basically theyre still not ready. The guy said I give me two more minutes since you arent paying we got busy and he had to give my order to somebody else. I feel this is not cool why should I have to pay for their mistakes and they look like theyre doing me a favor.
My 7 year old son told me about the best pizza where Gramma lives .. I decided to stop one great service and pizza was outstanding
Love the pizza and the people but no masks on any employee …..
This place is the worst I have ever delt with. Have tried the pizza a few time and taste like there sauce is made of tomato soup and its tough to chew. Today we ordered subs, and they messed up the two sub orders. I got a dry sub, which was not what was ordered and then I requested a half sub for my son and got a full. I could look past it all and just stop ordering from here, BUT the service is so bad. The delivery driver was rude and when told we didnt order 2 full subs said it sucks to be you because its already paid for, when calling in the person every time has been rude and never actually listens. Have to tell her 2 or 5 times with them sighing and making noises because they couldnt listen the first time. I will never go here again and strongly August no-one else does. Its not worth the low quality of food and service
Delicious pizza n wings.good portions great price.and dont forget the cannolis!!
Great pizza and canoli, friendly staff and a clean. We ate inside and had a really good experience. M
The Garlic pizza wasnt very garlic and the toppings were all in the middle... Globs of flour on the bottom. The El Diablo was just covered in crushed red pepper under the cheese super greasy - not really what the description seemed like and not really edible... Went to pick up and was told few more min by the girl (after waiting the 45min they be told us) Only to sit for 20 more min when guy says those have been done... nice waste of $50 and time...
Service with a smile at every visit! Fantastic lunch special for delicious pizza. Lucky to have a great local place :)
Tasty and delicious cheesy pizza, friendly staff.
Nothing to say but OMG!!!! Pizza here is without a doubt in my top pizza joints in upstate new York hands down. Usually Ill stay away from a pizza place that says new York pizza because they embarrass themselves trying to create real new York pizza. But this particular spot is ON POINT. Thank you making my taste buds happy.
What a joke. $40.00 plus tip for 2 calzones and It takes an hour and a half for my food? This is not good business. I am a good customer.
Excellent pizza, fast service, and fast delivery. You guys rock!
Our go-to place for pizza!! Best pizza around by far!! Ingredients are fresh, owner has true passion for flavor and cares; they always want you to be happy and it shows!
This visit wasnt their best pizza but i do have to say even their not best is way better than anywhere else. Always my 1st choice not a doubt
It was great pizza, I recommend this restaurant to my friends
I love going there Im in and out in less than 5 minutes. You get any two slices during lunch with 12 oz soda for $5.00 Good customer service, and the pizza is one of the best in Canastota.
THAT Was YUMMY! GREAT PIZZA! Delivered HOT and pretty darn quick! VERY Nice young lady answered the phone and took My Order! I WILL be calling them Again next time Im in town! YUM!
Best pizza in this area. Excellent service with a true team atmosphere. And you can watch everything theyre doing. These folk are proud of their food!
The staff and manager or owner were very polite and friendly. The pizza was excellent thin crust, tasty NY style!
Ive always loved the food here but the young female staff members lately have been a little on edge. I hope theyre okay!
Top notch pizza for the area! Wings are good to. Always a treat to eat here
Great pizza for a small town. Wings are a little pricy but they seem to be like that everywhere now. I would recommend to friends for sure
Great pizza! Fast and friendly service. Better than the 4 pizza places closer to me.
We love their stuffed crust pizza. Great.
Pizza wasnt good for the price we paid and our wings didnt have any sause. This is the second time they havent been very good...
They changed their specials to boneless wings which is fine but they always seem to run out. And they will never substitue. Used to love this place but they have become a rip off.
Best pizza! Always quick and always fresh! The prices are low. And the service are very good!
Very good! Although we wanted an everything wing or medium sauce. They didnt have available.
Great pizza and wings consistently. Always prompt, friendly service and a fair price.
Best pizza in Canastota! The service is always good and the owner is there a lot and very friendly.
Pizza was good, but a little thick for NY style pizza. Tasted good, people were friendly.
Always friendly staff and great pizza. Joe is always making sure his customers are happy.
Awesome Pizza awesome atmosphere they make pizza the way New York Pizza should be great job 5 stars
Best pizza amazing service and fast. Definitely a must if your in the area they outkill canastota pizza
Friendly and polite, great food
Amazingly fast. Great pizza. Passing through on vacation and the food was terrific!
Service was fast but subs are very small with very little meat. Pizza wasn’t bad.
Always perfect pizza and decently priced
Great pizza & great prices. Friendly staff as well.
My number 1 favorite local pizza! The garlic is fabulous 😊
Awesome custom pizzas....Delicious as always!!!
I ordered mild wings the other night and barely got any sauce on them. If I pay for pizza and wings, I want some sauce come on
Best pizza, appetizers and prices in town!!! Fast, accurate and courteous delivery on the outskirts too!!
Ive traveled quite a bit in my lifetime, and nothing has ever beat this pizza. 💕
One of the best pizza places in central New York. I love there pizza.
Exstremly the best-selling pizzas in Canastota
Our absolute family favorite for pizza extra cheesy great sauce a winner!!
Staff is friendly and the pizza is good
I tried NY Pizzeria today for the first time today my kids and I loved it we have a new pizza place that we love and is close to home
This place was a great find on our way home to Ohio. Delicious fare and exceptional customer service.
Solid local pizza place that usually has slices available.
Best local pizza. Always quick delivery and always fresh.
Nice people and place but the quality of the sauce and cheese has gone down
I found a hair in my pizza slice, definitely not coming to this pizzeria again
Food was good but the menu online is non updated so the prices are all wrong
Hot Fresh Delicious Pizza Everytime Ive Ordered!
Great pizza. Fast service. Good price.
Friendly people good with special orders
Great pizza. Friendly staff.
Excellent pizza at a very reasonable price
This place has a very friendly environment, and GREAT food, as well as prices! :)Love this place!
You cant beat this place. The lunch special is accepted all day. Can t beat the deal!
Why do they charge extra for you to use a debit or credit card?
Theyare simply the best in the business thats all there is to it
Great pizza and fast service, 10/1011/10 with rice
Service was friendly and quick! Pizza was amazing!
Not very clean. Dirty tub and clogged sink. Yuk!
Thay put the pepperoni under the cheese. I like it on top . Next time I will request it to be placed on top the pie . Weird pepperoni application.
Good service , great food definitely go there again
By far the best pizza and great service.
Hometown. Just what you expect. Really good pizza. Always busy.
Right in main street. Clean quick fresh. Good slice deal.
Food was excellent and service was great
Friendly courtesy and pizza good.
Salads are fresh and pizza tasty little more sauce
The best pizza any where near canastota
Best pizza in canastota and oneida area
Best pizza Ive in the area!
Good lunch special and great choices
Awesome pizza best in central ny.
Best pizza within 20 miles
This is the greatest place for pizza in canastota
Great food and priced right!
Very good New York style pizza.
Gr8 pizza, and all around good food.
They always have good food
Great prices, great pizza!!!
Always friendly, always good food
Idk who, but someone is always hooking me up with my chicken wings
Very nice people. Very good food
Best pizza and wings in town.
Best pizza available in Canastota!
This place is the best! 10/10 would recommend.
Good pizza at a decent price
Great pizza better prices
Awesome facility great workers awesome food
What an amazing experience A+
The food and staff are out of this world
Pizza and wings were awesome
Food was great!
Fresh hot and good pizza
Love the pizza and the crew!
Hands down the best pie in town!!
Excellent pizza and wings
Always great food.
This is so good. Spoil yourself
Great pizza cheap
Nice
Great local pizza joint
Best pizza in town
Best pizza in canastota
Best wings ever
Best place in canastota for 🍕
Wonderful as always!
Not a lot of seating.
Love of my life.
Best pizza around
Great wing
Pizza is very good
Best 🍕 in CNY
Best pizza around
Best Pizza Ever
Yum
Love it
Great food.
Awesome
Gotta try this Pizza
Flavorless food
Good
Stromboli excellent
Great pizza
The best in Canastota
Very very good !!!!
Good place
Total reviews rating 4.4
156 Reviews for New York Pizzeria 2023:
Review №1
2022-01-15Best pizza from the best pizzeria on the planet!You have to get some of this! Slices are huge and tasty, the prices are below fair market value for a slice of equal or greater size from a big box pizza shop. Yadda yadda blah blah. Eat here!
Review №2
2020-12-16After researching top rated eateries, I decided to get my coworkers who live in the area gift certificates to New York Pizzeria. It is a local family owned shop, and I felt it important to support local business. I drove from Syracuse to Canastota to get these gifts. The employees were friendly and it was very difficult not to indulge in the delicious looking slices they had (see pictures!) I will definitely return with my family to eat here.
Review №3
2022-03-01It was our first time since we are new to the area. We ordered 2 pizzas with different style crusts to see what we liked. Both pizzas were extremely good and the prices were great too.
Review №4
2021-05-155 ⭐️ hands down perfect thin slices with the perfect crisp and service with a smile what can I say a very good pizza shop.
Review №5
2022-05-18Good pizza. And awesome dinners. Tastes great
Review №6
2022-01-28Sorry, last time using this place. lettuce was brown in the salad. wings dripping with grease not sauce...pizza was fine
Review №7
2018-08-03Waited over an hour for a pizza that didnt even taste good. I get that they were busy, but not a soul that walked in for a takeout pizza after we did waited nearly as long just because they were takeout and not sitting down to eat. Its a small cheese pizza. They have made at least 30 pizzas in the time that we have been sitting down. Im just so irritated. I thought it would be a nice quick stop for food with my boyfriend, but no. And staff isnt the slightest bit considerate about the wait. Dont come here. Its not worth it at all.
Review №8
2021-06-30Taste is subjective, but its been a few years since I had a cheese slice this good. Sweet sauce, perfect Dough. If this was my local shop, It would be our go to spot for Pizza. Super friendly staff too!
Review №9
2022-07-03They went above and beyond for us. Very good and were very happy!!!
Review №10
2021-11-25Went in to just grab a slice. They didnt have any cheese ready so I tried the BBQ chicken. I was pleasantly surprised. Good flavor, big slice and reasonably priced.