Nickys On the Bay image 1Nickys On the Bay image 2Nickys On the Bay image 3Nickys On the Bay image 4Nickys On the Bay image 5Nickys On the Bay image 6Nickys On the Bay image 7Nickys On the Bay image 8Nickys On the Bay image 9Nickys On the Bay image 10

Categories


Phone: +1 631-206-3311
Site: http://www.nickysonthebay.com/
Opening hours
  • Monday:11:30AM–9:45PM
  • Tuesday:11:30AM–10PM
  • Wednesday:11:30AM–10PM
  • Thursday:11:30AM–10PM
  • Friday:11:30AM–10PM
  • Saturday:11:30AM–10PM
  • Sunday:11:30AM–10PM
Edit info

Total reviews rating 4.2

199 Reviews for Nickys On the Bay 2023:

Review №1

2021-08-16

Went there with a party of 9. Nicole was the barmaid she was fantastic. Great personality and great drinks. Or waiter was not so good. We all got seafood and my daughter got a hamburger, her plate didnt come out for about 10 min after we all got out food. So by the time hers came out all our food was cold. They did take off the cost of the burger but unacceptable. The manager apologized and said they were very busy that day.Food was good nothing to get crazy about.

Review №2

2022-05-23

Had a beautiful lunch here this past Saturday with my friend and everything was amazing. We ordered crab cakes as a starter and they were perfectly cooked and accompanied by a delicious dipping sauce. We both ordered the lobster rolls and omg they were loaded with lobster and just so damn delicious! I ordered the salty mermaid or something like that, it was a yummy drink. Although tbh I did expect it to be bigger for what it cost. For dessert we ordered a slice of cheesecake and Keylime pie and they did not disappoint. Our waitress, Brianna, was attentive and super friendly. We will definitely be back to see her and have more lobster rolls! 😊**I will say it was definitely more than we expected it to be. So plan on a pricey meal when you come here. Let me be clear that it was absolutely worth it, we just didnt realize because the menu has most items listed as being market price. However, since we didnt ask, the fault is ours.**

Review №3

2021-09-01

Great location on the water, food was delicious and service was very attentive. They had long island Vinyard wine, which was a nice surprise. Perfect for an after dinner walk around the pier. The photos are sesame encrusted tuna, rare with fried rice and corn salad. The second is pan fried halibut with arugula and cherry tomatoes.

Review №4

2022-05-06

The first soft shell crabs of the season are in! The quality is outstanding. One bite and all the worlds problems just melt away.

Review №5

2022-06-27

Best seafood I ever had. Stuffed classic amazing. Tuna was exquisite. Soft shell crab off the hook. Lobster roll incredible. Service and view of the bay was insane. Bring a fat wallet. Your gonna want it all.

Review №6

2022-05-02

Beautiful place to relax and enjoy a good plate of seafood! We try the shrimp stuffed with crabmeat and the lobster roll,so delicious!

Review №7

2021-10-03

Fabulous dining venue which I recommend highly! My daughter was a hostess here during her summers in HS! Nicky is a Gem! Love the food! Love the ambiance! Love Nicky’s!💖❤️🥰

Review №8

2022-06-20

All the food was good, but nothing blew me away. Don’t get the chips, unless you like ruffles out of a bag. The lobster roll had so many different tastes that I couldn’t really taste the lobster. Fried seafood was good. Also Very expensive. But the venue was really nice.

Review №9

2021-09-27

I was not impressed at all. The food quality was pretty bad. Way over priced. The only reason I gave this 2 stars is because we ate outside on a beautiful evening. Our waiter was good. Besides that, we will not be going back. The lamb didnt taste like lamb ($37). I think there was beef gravy all over it? My wife didnt want linguini and they wouldnt offer another pasta or rice so she had to get French fries. For $37 shrimp scampi with fries.

Review №10

2022-06-20

I love this restaurant because of the view they have on the terrace, the very tasty food, the very friendly service.