Kerbside pickup
Yes
Nonnas Pizza in Peekskill
Categories
Location on the map
Peekskill, Westchester County, New York, US
Service options
No-contact delivery
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Healthy options
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
University students
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 914-737-3222
Site: http://www.nonnaspeekskill.com/
Site: http://www.nonnaspeekskill.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:10AM–10PM
- Tuesday:10AM–10PM
- Wednesday:10AM–10PM
- Thursday:10AM–10PM
- Friday:10AM–10PM
- Saturday:10AM–10PM
- Sunday:10AM–10PM
Nonnas Pizza in other cities:
Comments (199)
I made an order online and when I went to pick it up the gentleman in the black mask was extremely rude and put my order in right when I picked it up which I had to wait inside for an additional half hour for my order totaling over an hour from the time I placed my order. To make matters worst I question the integrity of my food after making a questionable reply to his co worker about my food prior to me leaving! There are way better places in Peekskill and Cortlandt Manor then this place they just happen to be near stop and shop! I ordered numerous times from this place to be have this happen!
When a restaurant has consistency in the Taste, Quality and Quantity, I bring all my friends and family there!!!
Pretty good all around.Wait staff could be a little quicker but theyre not too bad.Portions are goodPrice is average.
This place either should do two things. Take the word pizza out their name or be forced to pay New Haven CT $1000 a year to use it. First bite was my last and the only reason I paid my bill was because I felt bad for the waitresses due to rising inflation
Love everything from here!! Their baked ziti is so friggin yummy!! Oh and the chicken franchese and they put it over angel hair for me mmmm!!!! Like every time we order, it’s always so good!
Decent pizza, average wings, very cute delivery guy
Food is the best part. Great tasting food at a great price
The pizza is excellent! They have many different specialty slices. My favorite is the chicken marsala slice, delicious!! We shared a Caesar Salad and it was also very good.The portion was large enough for 2 people to share. I will be coming back to try other dishes. Highly recommend
This is truly an excellent restaurant, they have a wide variety of dishes at a reasonable price. Everything is fresh and the staff is very courteous. There is plenty of free parking as well. I found this place from a Google Maps search and Im very glad that I did. They have a repeat customer in me
One of the best buff chicken slices Ive ever had.Amending this to 4 stars. Went for 2 slices today and was wondering how they finished so quick. Its cause they didnt heat them up. Home now eating cold floppy pizza. Its like a sport car with no gas in it. Super disappointed.
Great pizza and good size and selection. My go to place.
One of the better pizza places in the area. Go here often. Food is always good. Place is clean and well maintained. Staff is always polite and friendly. Would reccomend
Even though this is a pizzeria restaurant, the food is well priced and amazing. Always manage to bring some back home.
Not sure how to rate this as we walked in to the pizzeria, ordered a couple cold slices to go with a side salad. it was Halloween and they said 10 minutes, after 15 minutes the person at the register asked us what we there for. We told her.After another 10 minutes we left. Cannot comment on the food we never received as it took over 20 minutes to put 2 cold made slices and a side salad together.
I order the seafood paella, with appetizers and a personal pie, and some connolis. Women says it will be ready in 35 minutes. It takes 1 hour and 5 minutes but it’s Saturday and I get that.They said it’s going take a little longer cause of the saffron rice. Get home, appetizers were made when called in, so there soggy and only one mozzarella stick in the combo. Pizza was cold cause it was made when called in. Seafood Paella, 2 dead mussels, over cooked shrimp, WHITE RICE in a onion, pepper, garlic sauce. Also asked for a Caesar salad, got the house. No bread, two little stale garlic nots. $65.00 bucks. I work hard for my money and going out is a treat, Go to Stella’s right down the road, the chef is a awesome man.
Me and , 2 of my Veteran friends went there to take out dinner as always the food was delicious. The staff was geared up for the rush of men and women Veterans. They went above and beyond for Veterans day!! Thank you, Mr Clarke. 82nd Airborne Division Veteran 🇺🇲🪂 Ft Bragg black hawk unit 🚁
Their customer service is excellent and the pizza is the BEST.
I really enjoyed the pizza and the atmosphere
Great pizza. Excellent food. Amazing staff.I wish I lived closer.
Ordered dinner for delivery to Cook Pool. Cell service was terrible but the staff stuck with me till we got the order placed! 45 minutes later, exactly as they predicted, dinner arrived. They are so easy to work with, so reliable and have wonderful food! Thanks!
The food was amazing! And shoutout to Nonnas for the custom dairy free slice they made for my 2 yr old who has a severe dairy allergy! My son was so excited to have his first pizzeria slice! Will definitely be back!
My mom and sisters were here for a week. They ate at Nonnas four times! They live in California, but say that NY pizza is the best theyve ever had.
Great pizza, my secret little piece of heaven.
Moved to the area 3 months ago. Hoping to find an Italian restaurant as good as the one we left. Found it! Great food, great people. Love their homemade dinner rolls!
Splendid food and wait staff, lighting in the back dining room and wall art make the environment warm and cozy for family, friend gathering or for couples to have a good time eating out!
Delicious food , great service . Went during the holiday season. Everything was excellent 👌
Used to live in nyc FiDi, closest thing to NYC pizza in Westchester. Really great pizza and delicious and expansive menu. Also the service is great, they had made an error and the owner/manager got on the phone with us personally and not only gave us the refund but sent the product we ordered. Really delicious food. I’d recommend the arugula salad too!!!!
I went there to eat a slice of pizza and never again will I eat there. The cashier was on his lunch break and he made comments on me and my sisters for buying soda elsewhere. I did have enough money so I went somewhere else. He made us feel very uncomfortable and embarrassed, the staff should keep their comments to themselves.
Great Pizza, Great Service & Yes... coming Back
I would like to thank the staff of Nonnas for giving a great VETERAN day to me and my fellow veterans, the staff is so helpful and polite, great job guys. Im now and will be a recruiting customer.
On vacation here from FL. We enjoyed our meal a few nights ago. Looking forward to going for pizza before we head back. Pizza in FL not good!
After receiving burnt black grilled chicken in the penné vodka I had delivered along with pizza and a sub.I called up and very nicely asked if I could be refunded the price of the chicken penné a la vodka dish.The lady who I assume is the owner replied by saying that if I give her my info she would refund me $3.95 for the burnt grilled chicken because the pasta was probably ok.I was so shocked by her level of customer service I literally hung up the phone in disgust without saying another word.Horrendous !!!
Always enjoy our meal and service.
For a place that had me convinced based on their excellent reviews on service, Im quite disappointed with my experience so far in trying to place an order. The website states the business opens at 10AM and provides an option to place on order online. I placed the order at around 9AM and provided explicit instructions that the order needed to be delivered to our location, which is a 10 min drive away, by 11:45 sharp. I called the business at 10:05 AM to double check that they received the order and confirm all the information provided. The man who picked up the call seemed very annoyed to take the call and was quite rude. He would not give me a chance to speak and proceeded to state that he cannot confirm my order since the business doesnt open until 11. I called back at 11:15 and the woman who picked up quickly said to hold before I could get a chance to speak and kept me on hold for over 10 minutes. After returning to the call, I asked for confirmation that they have received my order and will get it in time for 11:45 to which she specified that they opened at 11 and that they havent started the order and will need about 45 min of delivery time. I informed her that their website and other locations state their business opens at 10AM which is misleading to potential customers and that based on the time shown, I placed an order believing that should be ample time for the business to receive the order and deliver in time. She was not receptive to my feedback nor seemed to care about my concern for receiving the delivery by 11:45 for a major client meeting and hung up the call abruptly. Truly hoping the pizza will be worth this hassle and delay but they certainly wont be getting another call or order from me again! Customer Service is a key element of attracting and retaining customers and if they are not concerned about it, I have no interest in ordering from them again.
Great lunch spot for salads, pizza, heros, and traditional Italian dishes on the Lunch Special menu.
Love ❤ best atmosphere 👌 great tasty food!!!
Not sure whats going in with Nonnas..Ive always liked going there..Always liked the way the waiters behaved with dignity and excellent service to customers..and the food has been pretty good in the past.Im giving it three stars but I am being generous considering how I was given what should have been a juicy and tasty hot sandwich the other day...I ordered eggplant parm on a wedge and I was given a sandwich packed with dried out lukewarm, tasteless, eggplant with a tiny bit of sauce and unrecognizable amount of cheese on top layer only. It seems like it was just thrown together..I should have returned it but Im always afraid to do that since Im not sure what would happen to my food if I did..a few weeks ago I ordered one kind of sandwich and got another kind..This was probably an honest mistake, but now this with the eggplant.There must be a problem somewhere...I will not be going back anytime soon..
I think they lost what made them good. It’s a good product followed by good service. I went there the other night ordered 2 slices extra cheese, one slice pepperoni and a beef a beef patty. So they placed everything in a small box. When I asked them if they placed everything in a small box they laughed. He stated we were really careful. When we got home it was completely ruined. They just made the store larger. They need to remember to treat all the customers proper. People will go somewhere else. As a result they lost my sales.
Not the place if youre looking for real, authentic Italian foodThe quality has gone from passable to bad
One of the best pizzas in Peekskill.
I had order a plain pie from here and it’s simply great pizza. Staff is kind and courteous. Took two stars off because I tried to order a pie 20 Minutes before their posted closing time and I got rejected.
Solid pizza for the area. Pies are little smaller than expected, but have a good taste. The chicken Parm roll is worth it!
Pizza is ok cant really say as it was the already made pies that sit . Maybe i will order a fresh pie next time.Will review when i order a fresh pie.... but all in all it was ok
Great pizza. Always come here when I am in town. Ordered a whole pie. Nice and fresh and tasty. Took around 20 mins to be ready. Staff and service was good. Chickens wings were just ok. I would come here again when in the area. Thx
The best sicilians youll find outside of NYC. And the best pizza in all of Westchester.
Great food, love the shrimp fradiablo pizza.
I called in my order and was told it would be ready in 20 minutes. I sat in my car in front of the store and waited the 20 minutes. As I walked in, a woman was walking in behind me. The man behind the counter took the woman behind me first. I asked about why would you take the woman who behind me first. He replied, oh she paid and was waiting outside.(I did say I was waiting in my car in front called in my order )and she ordered online.Either way, you take the women who was second iine over the person who first? Btw she was white and Im black. I will tell All my friends to NEVER buy from there.
Excellent service with KAT!Food was really good! Prices are a little high, still we enjoyed ourselves! Ex:Adding Shrimp to salad $8.95 Spinach Salad was 11.95 really ? Over $20 bucks? Otgeeeise always a 5 star place for us!! KAT is always Very accommodating!! We gave her $16 tip
I always order take out on the weekends at nonna’s ! tasty family owned restaurant
I agree with the last poster. Nonas is not what it used to be. We ordered a very large online order. Their own website has a order online button. So we decided instead of calling ordering through online. The total was $115. We received a call that their online prices were no accurate and the new total was now $221. That is a total joke. They are advertising their prices on their own website and then calling to say sorry those prices are inaccurate, itll be another $106 please. And BTW a 12 inch Cauliflower pizza for 13.95 is absolutely ludicrous. SAVE YOUR MONEY.. Totally not worth it..
First time customer. I went for take out after a long hike in the area. Orders are made fresh when you call. I had to wait 15 minutes but it was the BEST buffalo chicken salad I ever had ! Generous portion and great taste! Will definitely return!!
Went there for dinner tonite for the first time and I must say that the food was quite good. Good size portions and everything appeared to be made fresh . Quality of chicken was very good and tender too. The service on the other hand was beyond horrible. I wanted to write the guy a note about how terrible his service was but my wife insisted that I still give him a tip. Just to give you an example of how bad it was. There were 4 waitresses just standing there and even when I asked for help it still took about 15 mins to just get a menu another 15 minutes before the waiter came over and asked if we wanted drinks. I asked for bread which never came. I asked for bread a second time and it still didn’t come , after the third time it finally came after our salad. Food took quite a while to come and then the waiter went MIA , during our entire dinner . My drink was empty before we started dinner. I eventually grabbed another waitress who brought me a drink after I was done with dinner. Then the wait for the check began. Waited , waited grew older and eventually grabbed the another waitress who found our waiter and the check shortly after arrived. I would go back because the food was so good but if the service is bad again , I will certainly walkout and not fall victim to that kind of bad service again.
A bit more expensive than other pizza places in the area but their slices are definitely top tier. Good service and quick even on the really busy nights.
If I could give 10 stars I definitely would. I have eaten dinner with my family at this restaurant several times and always have been blown away by quality and taste. But I have decided to finally write a review tonight because of 2 servers in particular. Danielle and Patricia, hands down the best servers we ever had. They went well above and beyond any expectations you could have. Danielle and Patricia even took the extra time to form a personal relationship with my entire group, from age 6 to 88. Completely blown away by their hospitality.
Lunch special was reasonable and flavorful. Chicken parm, sauteed broccoli, side salad and potato croquet $11.95. Stopped going here for a while, but decided to try again. Server was friendly and attentive, filling water and wine glasses, etc. Will definitely be back.
They are the best from there salads to pizza and all the rest of the menu. The food is fresh and hot if you get it delivered or pick it up your self. The double sausage pie is to die for its the best!!! So give it a try you would be disappointed. Ill be ordering again.
Love the pizza! Staff is great... and only place I can find a good Focaccia slice. Space is nice and clean (and organized). It’s pizzeria style on the front side, where you can choose to sit and eat quick and not be ‘served ‘ (even though they still serve you, lol) but also in the back they have a sit down restaurant style serving I enjoy.
I’m sorry to say but I used to come here of lunch a couple days a week and the food was pretty good. But now a days I been ordering delivery since the COVID-19 pandemic. Twice the food took more than an hour to deliver to me and the first time, the pizza came cold the meatballs and soup were lukewarm. BUT I GIVE THEM A SECOND CHANCE, THE PIZZA I RECEIVED THE CRUST WAS BURNT. I HAD TO THROW IT AWAY. WON’Y BE COMING HERE AGAIN.
I havent had a Sicilian pizza in a long time. This was definitely one of the best. And the sauce was just right. The dough was just the right height. Not too doughy. My wife had eggplant rollatini. It was delicious and a generous portion. Our server, Antonella was ultra friendly and very courteus and professional.
As this style of pizza goes in this part of Westchester, you wont do better (okay, Amiciis WAS great too, but not any more.) Both dine-in and take-away are excellent. All food is very tasty and the staff friendly. The sauce, while a personal favorite, will be viewed as overdone by many Italian pallets (there is a complex abundance of both herbs/spicing and quite salty, and is more along the lines of Polish, German, or western Balkan red sauces, than traditional Italian. But please try it: I think its wonderful.). Service is very quick despite heavy customer loads. Recommended. [Note: They do a decent manhole/Frisbee premade/frozen crust GF pie with their own sauce & toppings: I suggest the pepperoni or margarita. Small & expensive, but were used to it. UPDATE: 10/2018: The expensive GF pies now have an absolutely HORRIBLE powdered plain Matza crust. They dropped the two semi-edible previous versions of pre/factory made GF crust and the current one is simply inedible. Dont waste your money. There are LOTS of good GF crusts available, some from local suppliers, why not try some? or better, make your own?]
The food was fabulous and the people were so nice will definitely go back when Im in the area
Theres a good selection of Very Different kinds of Freshly Made Hand made Pizza here! Really tasty to have for Friday or Saturday Night Diners with your personal Family or Friends! A very Large Selection of Dietary Sodas or Teas to pick from as a drink to have with it!!
I gave it 3 stars because the food lacks flavor. Every good chef knows that when you make pasta you need to put salt, and their pasta has no salt infused within the pasta, so its bland and no matter how much salt you put on it it still lacks in flavor. The pizzas are good and filled with favor, any thing that isnt pasta is good. But it seems that most people like bland food when our palettes have hundreds of different taste buds. Theres a difference between a five star restaurant and a pizza place. 5 star restaurants know how to please all your taste buds.
The food I was able to eat was good... But I was only able to try an appetizer... I have a shellfish allergy... And when I placed my order the person on the phone mistaken me for saying mussels instead of mushrooms, and I made it clear because I repeated two more time.When I called to have the mistake corrected the manager said that he would correct the mistake and replace the order even though I offered to pay... The order never arrived and and when I called back I was spoken to briefly and was hung up on twice... Disappointed in the phone service... And also felt disrespected by the hang up
The best pizza in the area I am in. I tried a few of the pizza places around Fishkill and they were all just alright. Then I tried nonnas and that is now my go to choice. The pizza is excellent, whenever I go in i always have a pleasant experience. They have a friendly staff. The plaza its in is sometimes a pain to get in and out of and for parking. If you are in the mood for pizza I highly recommend this place
The staff is amazing and the restaurant is clean and well designed, FOOD IS AMAZING, it’s a-little more pricey compared to other pizza places in the area but 100% worth it Great Food!! MY FAVORITE!!!! 100% Recommended
Nonnas food and service are always excellent. You cant get it wrong with any of the several dishes they offered.My family and I love this place and had been customers for several years.
I love Nonnas in Peekskill. Some of my favorite things to order other than pizza are the meathball parm, Zuppa de Pesce, Caprese slices and the chef salad. The only reason for 4 stars is because any time I order take out they always seem to forget the ranch dressing which totally ruins my dreams of delicious ranch on my salad.
The service is always great. The staff is friendly and inviting. The food tastes wonderful. One of the better slices Ive had in the area. Its especially cool how the decorate the windows for the holidays. The whole atmosphere is family with the staff.
Food is fine but the people working there are horribly rude
We had 2 pizzas and some stuffed shells at our table and everything was delicious. Shells had a little too much sauce but were delicious. Server was serious but pleasant. Great atmosphere for a casual sit-down.
My friend and I ordered this pizza for delivery. It took over an hour to be delivered. The pizza was tasty, but the crust was pretty thick and the pizza was greasy. My friend gave it a 3/5 but I thought despite its issues, the flavor was there, so I went 4/5. It will not be my first choice, but I would order from there again.
I have been a regular at Nonnas Pizza since it opened. The food is always terrific and everyone is always so helpful and accommodating. Great family owned Restaurant!!!
I used to be a big fan of this place. But things started going downhill- I believe there was a ownership change at this location. Previously, no matter how busy, the staff would recognize me by name when I came to pickup every week. The pies were great. Recently, its still busy, (no decent competition in the neighborhood), treat you like a number. The order girls on the phone have messed up my order several times. Train people what a cold Margarita pizza is vs a hot Margarita. Ridiculous. Im going less and less.
Food is just so yummy :) and those handsome young Italian men at the front are so polite and have wonderful manners. Excellent customer service at the cashier, in the food, and the entire restaurant.
I have enjoyed many good meals here, but the 3 dinners we picked up last were not as ordered. Everyone is entitled to a off night
Can you say tantalizing tasty? The gluten-free cauliflower crust topped with Nonna’s sauce & cheese is the best in the area! Super friendly fast service in a clean & inviting dining area. My wife loves their white & lasagna pizza slices! I’m so looking forward to the owners carrying GF pasta soon! You must try the Italian sausage & broccoli rabbe!
This place is great however had to weigh an extended amount of time to get my order because of a Greek salad. I know theyre kicking it what is quarantine thing but should give a heads-up and how long I ordered will actually be.
Best place to get pizza! Ive been coming here for years and their pizza are always the best Ive had!! Also their other dishes when dining in are to die for. Its very delicious and well made.
The lines out the door really say it all. The heavy volume allows them to keep a wide variety of fresh pies with various toppings always ready, by the slice. They also have a small, sit down restaurant section in the back which serves a full Italian menu. VERY generous portions, never had a bad plate of food here.
Every time my wife and I go there for lunch we have a great time. The pizza and sandwiches are great, and consistently so, and the staff are friendly and helpful. When I say, Nonnas? my wife never says no.
Was Door Dashing when I visited THIS time, but the place was jumping as usual. Lots of different combos available on the menu makes this the go to Italian spot. Mom and Pops pizza vibe in a restaurant type setting.
One of the best pizza places in Westchester. The guys behind the counter are always very friendly, the food is always delicious, and the specialty slices are to die for. My only dilemma is that I spend my money here WEEKLY :(
Friendly staff. Good food
Great pizza made fresh.
I am happy that I came here to dine while I was in the area based on reviews. Im happy with the food. BUT the one thing that I would change is the amount of sauce that they put into a pasta dish. It was way way too much where I had to look for the actual pasta. i.e. penne ala vodka. It would be that much better if they went easy on that sauce please. I would come here again though. And now that I know I would just ask them please please go easy on that sauce. Thank you
We have been going to Nonnas since they opened, both eat in and take out and have never had an issue, until today. They have 9 Veal dishes, one which is breaded (veal parm), all served with a salad. I called today to order a plain breaded veal cutlet over a salad...they refused to make this for me and said “we don’t do that.” I called back as I was astonished they could not accommodate this (I have ordered this before from them mind you) and they again refused. Very poor customer service. We will definitely think twice about going there again.
The best Buffalo salad, white slice and regular pizza in a 35 mile radius. No joke!!!
I used to get my wings all the time from here. But now they started been STINGY and charging you extra for blue cheese or ranch saice and EVEN CELERY really? The order of wings are $12 + taxes and they are 12 of them so that’s 1 buck each wing pretty pricey right?! And they still charging you EXTRA for celery and sauces? No way! Next time I’m going to a better place! Good bye stingy people keep your celery and your sauce God damn it!!! 👋🏼👋🏼👊🏽
Omg! Delicious 😋😋😋! Great pizza, from Plain cheese to loaded toppings and a delicious Italian hero! Totally enjoying, 🔥🔥🔥
Excellent food ALWAYS!Love the white pizza in place of bread. Large portions at very reasonable price.Great service.
The food at Nonnas in Peekskill is AMAZING - especially the salads!! Everything is delicious and portions sizes are fantastic and a great value! The staff is always so welcoming and friendly - love love love it
Portions are huge, great prices, real fast service, good sized dining are and clean bathrooms. Love this place
This is coming from an Italian born & raised in the Bronx: This is the best pizzeria in Westchester! Been going there since it opened and take out at least once a month. The staff is excellent and the pizza is wonderful and consistent. Good, old fashioned type. Recommendations: try their buffalo wings. Best Ive ever had (believe it or not) Also: The mussels fra diavolo. I usually reheat the sauce the next day and serve it over linguine! Prices are very fair and you can usually find coupons in Clipper or their flyers but theyre not valid on Fridays. My suggestion: dont go on a Friday night. The line is usually out the door.
Started out JUST ok....went downhill fast, I used to only eat the Cobb salad anyway, and in the beginning it was adequate in a pinch...now I wouldnt go near that place,no thanks. Pizza greasy, staff not friendly
Its best pizza and the service is great. good place to take friends and family. one of my favorite places to eat, keep up the great food and service. thanks! from my family
Food good and good service but only one waiter for the entire room.
Im originally from the Pacfic NW and have always loved pizza, calzones, and Italian food.All my life Ive heard that if you want to get great pizza, go to NY.......sadly I have yet to find that pizza of the Gods that everyone always talk about here in NYHowever Nonnas Pizza ranks very highly up there.Its darn good, and their calzones are huge, very filling, and loaded with tons of cheese.Ill definitely be back.
This is my go to place. The food is always good, well prepared and tasty. Each entre is enough for just about two people. Add an appetizer and a second side salad and you are good to go.
I give them 1 star because there wasnt a choice for 0. We waited about 1/2 hour for the worst eggplant wedge I had in my entire life. I believe it was called eggplant caprese. Eggplant was like leather. The mozzarella had no taste and the red pepper was disgusting!! While I tried to gnaw on the eggplant, the inside of my boyfriends mouth and throat was getting cut up from the hard, sharp, dry chicken cutlet wedge he was eating. We will never step foot in Nonnas inThe Beach Shopping Center again!!
Some of the best pizza around!!! Everything here is really good!! Had them cater my daughters birthday party a few years ago.
I have only tried out the buffalo wings and the pizza so I have no idea what any of the other stuff tastes like. They serve 12 wings and if you get it hot, it comes bathed in buffalo sauce which is excellent as far as a wing lover is concerned. Now onto the pizza…….some of the best pizza you’ll ever taste in your life, especially the gourmet pizzas (buffalo,bbq,parm,marsala…….and they have a wide variety). You absolutely have to try out their pizza atleast once in your lifetime or else you will definitely be missing out on something. Even their vegetable slice is excellent!!!! One of the rare versions is the lasagna slice which they have once again done an excellent job with. I have nothing but amazing things to say about the pizza at Nonnas. A must try!!!!!
Always delicious here! Our waiter, Benim, I think is his name, is amazing!
Great pizza and friendly people. You can get table service here too, even for just a slice. Love it.
The pizza is great! Nice large slices, too!The staff is also very friendly!
Great place! Solid pizza at reasonable prices. The non-pizza stuff is great as well- big portions and legit quality.
Horrible experience a few years back gave them another chance and it was another horrible experience... we asked for a half sausage half mushrooms. The mushrooms were simply just thrown in the center of the pie in a pile and as soon as we attempted to lift a slice everything just slid right off.. we gave a second chance to them, we wont be giving a third!!!!
Love this place. Awesome selection of pizza slices. I have also had the food from there. Never disappointed. Food is fantastic
Some of the best pizza Ive ever had, great people working there.
They had the delivered the incorrect dinner. It should have been fried ravoli, instead they brought over regular ravoli with no sause. Since I was working and had to wait for my dinner break which was a half hour later, I was digusted so I threw it out. My co worker called and explained what happened, the rude young girl on the phone gave my co worker major attitude and said make sure the original ravoli comes back with the driver. omg are you kidding. Not even an apology for taking down and delivering the wrong food. That was not a good experience and was terrible customer service!! Never again nonnas!!
Great pizza and other food! Pretty affordable to boot. I feel a little guilty/unhealthy after I leave, but it is an Italian pizza joint, so I cant knock it too harshly. Best pizza in town!
This is a favorite of mine. It never disappoints. I always eat in the dining room. They serve a great free bread with melted cheese and tomato bruschetta with every meal.
One of the best pizza spots in Peekskill. Service is always great. People a friendly and of course the pizza is bomb. And the slices are huge.
Great service and outstanding food. Look forward to a return visit.
Great place to get pizza if you live in Peekskill. They can be super busy on Fridays but weve always had a good experience here.
THAT LENTIL SOUP! OOOOOH! I ate every last drop in my bowl. Really delicious. My hubby and our son had pizza. They ate the entire pie.
Solid pizzeria with very good dining room to boot. I recommend the tortellini alla gonna. Or they deliver. Either really good stuff and friendly staff
Nice environment, good 🍕 and rolls, friendly staff and affordable prices. Jamaican patties are not good and chicken tenders lack flavor.
Best pizza I ever had. Great customer service.
Service is great, food really good. I always go there. I have tried the one in Yorktown too but it is not the same. Go tho the one in peekskill beach shopping center
Perfectly crisped slice!
The food is absolutely delicious here and the staff are so sweet and kind and we truly enjoy stopping here after we go next door to have our nails done.
Very Nice Place! GREAT FOOD! The Pizza Is AMAZING! Thin and Crispy... The way a pie SHOULD be! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The food and staff are very good ,best pizza around and reasonably priced
Good pizza, good service.
The food is fantastic and the service is great. Highly recommend Nonnas Pizza. The chicken parmigiana and baked ziti Sorrentino are excellent choices!
Phenomenal food, came to visit from syracuse, 10 out of 10 will come eat here every time i’m in peekskill.
Great food, great atmosphere, and always wonderful service. The staff makes the place. Always fun, always full a great neighborhood staple
Pizza and other food is great, service is excellent, has a separate area for the full dining restaurant. Would recommend to anyone that happens to stop by the Beach Shopping Center.
Not good pizza, chicken rolls or heroes. Sauce tastes like it came out of a can, dough is missing something. Overall not good.
Serve is terrible ,kinda rude on the phone,,had to call twice ..right up the street.. not even a busy day 55mins later..Cold Pizza...Deliver guy was nice at least..
Pizza is great but you cant beat their chicken rolls. (Buffalo rolls personally) staff are super friendly even when they are slammed.
Best pizza in the area, thin but chewy crust. Their antipasto salad is delicious!
Always have a great selection of diffent slices and types of rolls. Love their penne vodka w/chicken.
Excellent pizza and other items. Highly recommend
Customer Service is a key element of attracting and retaining customers and if they are not concerned about it, I have no interest in ordering from them again.
I love their pizza def the best where I live at compared to the rest that are around my area.
Just received my Lasagna Pie , absolutely delicious !!!I love Nonna’s Pizza !!
The best pizza Good food .At great price s.
Good variety (beyond pizzas), and great taste. Great place for deliveries (not so much for eat-ins).
Excellent service and good, quality food. Portions are huge and always delicious, whether you take out or eat in. When eating in, it is very leisurely.
Not only is the best Pizza: but their staff its funny kind and they greet you like you are family.
Great service best pizza around and great food.
Great food and services
Love this Pizzeria entire family enjoys the food atmosphere awesome love it love it definitely do return every week
I enjoyed my slice with ectra cheese nd the atmosphere was great...employees...all smiles nd very polite...will visit again nd again
Nonnas has amazing pizza. The white pizza is so good.and garlicky you think you died and gone to heaven.
Good pizza for Northern westchesterNice workers. Parking for pick up orders stinks though
Freaking awesome... We were looking for an authentic New York pizza...and this place has it all... Fabulous
Great food and very authentic take off Italian food. A little pricey but worth the treat.
Amazing food, great prices and the friendliest most accommodating staff there is!
I Enjoyed my meal the Staff was Very Good Polite, and Very Helpful the food was Very Good ! No Rush to leave ! Enjoyed my Stay ! I give this place a 5 !
Food is always the best. Their pizza is the best in the area.
Pizza was good-but wait time for others in group to receive food was long overdue.
You want real Italian food! This is the place. Wonderful service, you are dealing with professionals.
Fast friendly service and clean!! Not to mention the food is amazing 😍
Best local pizza joint around. Chicken noodle soup is the ticket.
Excellent pizza great service
They just remodeled the front and it looks great. Amazing food and staff as usual.
Love their food. chicken sorrentino is my favorite dish and ALL their pizza is delicious!
Great pizza. Fast and friendly staff. Inexpensive.
Better than your typical New York pizza place, very friendly staff
Food is delicious, and the staff is very friendly and accommodating. Highly recommend!
Creative pizza with flair. High quality ingredients make for high quality pizza.
Whether eating in or taking out, Nonnas gets it right!!! They will customize any dish. Well done!!
Great food, atmosphere, amd beer menu.
Casual restaurant offering delicious italian food. Eat in, take out or delivery. Quick service.
I dont know what all the hype is about. Pizza is pretty terrible.Edit: went from a 2 to 1 star. Food is terrible with no flavor at all.
The pizza is fantastic. I had the chicken francess and it was fantastic too.
Wonderful menu options, great pizza and the lobster ravioli is the best
The food is good but today the service wasnt (I understand its mothers day and your busy but you still need to be professional) and they got my order wrong
Very friendly atmosphere. Food is delicious.
Excellent delicious choices, friendly staff, nice atmosphere
Very good Italian
Good selection of pizza, plus sit down service in back
The food is always good and the staff is friendly and attentive. Highly recommend
Great food & fast delivery.
Excellent service and delicious pizza!
Love love love! Definitely my new go to spot for pizza and wings
Services is good. Pizza is delicious.... Try Ham and basil...lol
Love the food. Best pizza
The Italian Restaurant! You like Italian? then go there. Great service and excellent food.
Best food possible..great servers..friendly..accomodating..SO GOOD! DELISH!!
All food fresh and well prepared. Great portions
Friendly staff and great specialty pizza at a reasonable price
This place is great. The portions of food is a nice amount..
Good pizza joint with plenty variety and generous portions
The service is awesome and if your around this area i recommend this place they have reasonable prices
Crust just the way I like , and healthier varieties that I dont think Ive seen anywhere else .
Total reviews rating 4.4
199 Reviews for Nonnas Pizza 2023:
Review №1
2022-03-28Im a O.T.R driver & bought food from here 2night 4 the 1st time. Got a large cheese pizza 🍕, spinach roll with marinara sauce and a tiramisu for dessert. Bill was $29 & some change. I gave a 15% tip so it was alittle extra. Just didnt like the fact that they wanted 2 charge 4 parmesan cheese! I thought that was ridiculous. Most pizza businesses generally have that on the table or counter top with the pepper flakes. Other then that food was decent.
Review №2
2022-03-15Well, walk in to order Pizza,, Love the variety they have. I ordered the Spinach, cheese and eggplant slice. They served it up cold not to tasty needed something,,Dont know What. Went to pay the GIRL at the counter needs to work on her Social Skills,, Does not know how to say Hello to anyone including a Stranger,, its called CUSTOMER SERVICE. Might as well put in a Self check out.
Review №3
2022-05-22Pizza was delicious and slice s are very big. Used the rest room twice and both times they didnt stock Tp. I told the manager of the floor, he never attended to the situation. Three other customers came out of restroom stating same problem. I at least carry tissue in my pocket book. Not cool.
Review №4
2022-03-23I was visiting with my family from Massachusetts to enjoy authentic New York food. I had previously been here years ago & it was pretty okay but we wanted to give it a second chance. It severely disappointed me. The staff respectfulness has gone down and you can hear fighting from the back. Not an environment I would want my grandkids around. I ordered baked ziti and it was nothing special. I had to also ask 2 times for a lemon with my water when I ordered that originally. Even with it being not crowded, wait times are insane. I wish management or the owner would be able to take care of these problems as it used to be a place with okay food with good prices, but after my visit, it will not be on my list to visit again. Covid has ruined many places and it seems this one has gone in the gutters.
Review №5
2022-04-30Nonas in the Beach Shopping Center is Great. Each dish is homemade, to order.The service is excellent, and has Old World charm.I have always had a great meal here!
Review №6
2022-06-10The sandwiches are delivered in sandwich shaped containers. A real game changer. More space and venting means YOUR CHICKEN CUTLETS SANDWICHES STAY CRISPY FOR LONGER. Im not uploading a picture. See it for yourself.And make sure that you order the eggplant parm with vodka sauce. Also make sure you have pants on. The driver is getting there wayyyyyy faster than you think.
Review №7
2021-12-28Ever since we first tried the pizza here, we haven’t ordered from anywhere else! This is my favorite local pizza place. We probably order take out or delivery from Nonna’s at least once or twice a month and we have never had a bad experience. The pizza is delicious and they always accommodate special requests. The few other things we’ve tried on the menu, such as garlic knots and chicken wings, have been really great also. Love this place!
Review №8
2019-05-26Lots of pizza options! There is plenty of seating space. The personnel was very knowledgeable about the food options and they were very kind and considerate. Would return to try their pasta.
Review №9
2022-01-29I ordered food online and it never came. I called them up and they said the system is down and they cant refund me the money. The lady on the phone was extremely rude and I spent 30 dollars plus a 7 dollar tip. This is unacceptable and I wouldnt recommend anyone to go there. If you want pizza go elsewhere. This is also a chain business so if you wanted to support a small business owner this isnt a small business owner. Dont be fooled.
Review №10
2022-02-21We all have our reservations and ideas on prices. We had dinner for 2, lamb and chicken marsala, 1 hot cocoa and a glass of house wine, $ 55.00. How do you feel about the price is up to you.