Outdoor seating
Yes
Nutty Irishman in Farmingdale
Categories
Location on the map
Farmingdale, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Great beer selection
Yes
Great cocktails
Yes
Live music
Yes
Sport
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Cocktails
Yes
Dancing
Yes
Food
Yes
Food at bar
Yes
Happy-hour drinks
Yes
Happy-hour food
Yes
Spirits
Yes
Wine
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Phone: +1 516-293-9700
Site: http://www.thenuttyirishman.com/
Site: http://www.thenuttyirishman.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:5PM–12AM
- Wednesday:5PM–12AM
- Thursday:5PM–4AM
- Friday:12PM–4AM
- Saturday:12PM–4AM
- Sunday:12PM–12AM
Comments (199)
Went here at happy hour for a couple beers, asked the barmaid if I could try a beer very friendly and accommodating gave me a taste and I realized the beer was room temperature. So as good barmaid checked another tap also warm, we finally found a cold tap and the beer was skunky and tasted terrible. There were several fruit flies and in general looked very run down and not clean or sanitary at all. I was waiting for Jon Taffer from bar rescue to walk in at any moment. I would not recommend this bar to anyone and I definitely would not eat here just based off how many flies and how dirty it is. The only reason I am giving 2 stars is for the barmaid she was trying.
Loud, drunk men pulling down each others pants is not something I was expecting to see here. For a first time visit, we were shocked. Probably will not be returning for a while. On a positive note though, the wings are good.
The $5 lunch special was delicious and amazing for the price. Seriously, I was surprised the place wasnt packed. Definitely a must for lunch.
Honestly I really like this bar the drinks are great and so is the food. They try their best to follow social distancing but this is a very busy spot since everyone wants to be here. Its hard obviously because young people think its funny to be disrespectful and not follow the rules which annoys me but not the bars fault at all!!! Also the bartender Brittany is amazing and wonderful
Good food and drinks. came to see tiger rose band a grateful time for all.
My grandson love it here!
Lots of space. One of the bartenders was great.
Didn’t even step inside and the bouncers were already yelling at us, apparently showing up at 930 before everyone else is to much stress for the bouncer that he has to yell at 3 people to get in a neat and orderly line, then as we are leaving the same bouncer stops us at the door and yells at us because we are blocking the entrance( just so everyone knows there is once entrance and one exit both in the same spot) I know people can be rude to bouncers and it’s not their job to deal with rude and mouthy people. However right from the start not a single word said to the bouncers and they came off rude and disrespectful. Such an unprofessional establishment, if you hate bouncing and your life so much that you’re going to be disrespectful to every customer, maybe rethink your profession
I love places that enforce no cape rules.Besides that, bartender was a great service and kind. Sunday night football is good here!
Great music. Older crowd from 5 to 11pm!👍
Fun popular place to be and when they have live music its always a blast. Depending on who is playing therell be a different crowds but they are usually pretty cool. Ive never had the food before but the drink selection is good and even when there is not a band playing its still a pretty cool place to be
Dont take the reviews saying the Elf pop up bar is a scam seriously. Its $40 and you end up getting 4 dishes of food, a dessert and a drink. What more do you expect for $40? Was each dish a full size entrée? No but I left full. The place is decorated really well and its a fun night out.
Really chill bar to come to when you are in the area, theres a few other bars nearby but this is always our first choice. Fun atmosphere, cheap drinks, and good local live bands that play or do covers. I love that theres a bar area in each section, and that you never really need to wait to get served a drink. I wish your card could come up on all 3 sections though so you dont need to go back to where you opened up the tab, but other than that its great!
The DJ on Saturday nights is always 🔥 👌 💯 we have a blast every time we go to the nutty. Looking forward to ditching the seated-at-tables rules soon. Fun place!
If you live in Long Island NY, you should check out this on a Friday night or Saturday night. Its a fun place to be...
I have been here a dozen times at least. I love their chicken wings and of course their drinks! The love of all love, is the loved of being loved!
Horrible food. Beer is watered down. Extremely rude workers and the bouncer was super rude. He doesn’t know how to talk to people or anything. There’s PLENTY of bars on Main Street. Literally anywhere is better than this place.
Party place in town. Perfect place to spend weekend night with few drinks, live performances and great teenagers crowd. Lively place but small to fit the whole crowd.
We arrived at 6:45 to get a table for something to eat before the band came on at 8:00. There are very few tables in the place and we were lucky to get the last one available. We didnt get served our food until 7:50 after the waitress realized that our order was lost. We had tracked down our waitress 4 times. Too bad she didnt check on our order the first three times we asked. The sandwiches were very good or maybe we were just starving at that point. Thankfully, we were not charged. Beers were good and both beer and food were reasonably priced.The band was great.
Great music.Big stage.large dance floor
Good crowd, good drinks, but the music is LACKING, please please please get a new DJ, needs more current songs and more diverse music.
Good specials! The last Friday afternoon that I went they offered 2 for 1 of select beers and free barbecue (hot dogs/ hamburgers) with purchase. The French fries were really good and so were the nachos!.They also have great live bands on Friday nights and the staff is very friendly.
We decided to go to the Nutty Irishman to feed my nana one night and had a great meal. The service was excellent and food was great but there was this guy with dead bovine eyes in the bathroom that was a little too handsy with my 7 yr old so we got out of there asap. He kept saying how much he loved my sons lips, etc. It was disgusting. Apparently hes from a band that plays here frequently, and they allow him to stick around. Idk. I hate for an incident like this to have happened and wish the bar would do something anout that Joe Cumia guy hanging around there.
Respectfully. They draw a young crowd at the bar and do have a nice broad beer menu. However the appetizer foods offered were mediocre at best. Being in my 50’s its not a place I would return for anything but maybe an afternoon beer. There are many better places in Farmingdale for anyone out of college.
Strange place. We were in the area and decided to go for dinner. In searching we saw that they had a salad bar and since most of them have closed (Ruby Tuesdays etc.) we decided to check them out. Well, they dont have a salad bar...or anything else that shows as their menu when you search for them. Even the waitress couldnt explain the missing salad bar or menu items. It almost seemed like they copied someone elses menu. The food was only okay. The waitress was okay. Other than the disappointment in not getting anything that we planned on, this place is only okay. Try it on your own decision. They do have live bands that start at 8:00 & 10:00 (I think), so maybe thats what their draw is.
This is the bar to be at on Friday/Saturday night in Farmingdale.Cover bands vary in how good they actually are, but always play songs everyone knows. Theres a decent sized dance floor thats always crowded. Theres always a lot of bartenders, so youre not standing around waiting to order a drink. Prices are pretty standard and theres a cover to get in. I would recommend here if youre looking for more of a high energy scene. People there are usually in their 20s
The Elfd Pop up Bar was a scam! DO not go. Im so disappointed. I wasted $90 on watered down drinks, cold food, and a dirty table I understand bars and restaurants are hurting due to covid, but its not far to scam customers. Not worth the money.
A fun place for live music, djs dancing, drinking, and more. They typically have reasonably talented (and occasionally very talented) cover bands playing the greatest hits of the 90s/00s.The crowd ranges from 21-41 depending on the night, and the prices arent great but arent as bad as some dance clubs, etc.
Very nice atmosphere and live comedians. Their food was okay but not great and the bread rolls were stale. We had a good time anyway and some fun, it just couldve been somewhat better if the music and microphones volume wouldve been a little lower than it was. We had better times in the past here and hope for better in the future.
Really didnt have a normal experience: there for a book launch. Good eats, a few good beers on tap.
Overall the experience is great. At times tho there were female bartenders complaining that I didnt give a tip. Meanwhile the moment I was going to tip her, she was complaining about it to another customer saying see this is what I get. ... After that Im glad I didnt tip her. She spoke too soon. I bought beer for 3.50 willing to give tips but since she complained. I changed my mind. Other than that its a good place to come to.
Bought 4 shots and the bartender charged me 56$ after she said a shot was 9$. Last time i checked 9 x 4 = 36, not 56$. Come here if you wanna be scammed 20$ extra for “taxes”.
Did not put a tip on my card because I was intending on leaving a cash tip and when my buddy was going to order the next round of drinks they denied us and told us how do you expect us to hold your table if you dont tip and kicked us out.
Super crowded for the most part, your shoes will get destroyed from the floor being ridiculously sticky from drinks constantly being spilled and changes are someone will spill a drink on you due to the overcrowding. Other than that it’s your typical College Bar scene filled with a bunch of drunk college kids having a good time
Went in the later afternoon for a quick drink, the bartender was excellent! I told him what I typically drink and he got close with the first try and dead on with the second. Had the pretzel and o-rings too, both were awesome. Looking forward to heading back here to watch a game.
Elfd Pop up Bar is a scam! The food is terrible and drinks are watered down. They make you pay ahead of time and the event is nonrefundable !! They are robbing people for the amount of money they are charging and the service that is given. $300 table shouldn’t be eating beets salad from a paper plate . Extremely Disappointed!!
I am here right now. The band is great. Also , you can listen dance music .The people are different years, 20 years old company and 50th;).The stuff are friendly.I really recommend this place if you want relax and dance.
Looks like a nice place, but the smell of stale beer is overwhelming and the bar top is dirty and sticky, probably because of the obvious lack of napkins and coasters. Ordered a rocks drink and a tap beer, no head on the beer at all that took 10 minutes to get. One bartender at 8:10 on a Saturday night? Overall I am underwhelmed.
Love the live music/ dj combo
O El Amor was their musical talent for the evening. The masked musicians hit it off. An excellent night of entertainment!! While the place is kind of cramped when they keep the back room closed off until 30 minutes before the band took the stage, the entertainment was great.
The place was good. We arrived around 7:45pm on Friday and We pay $10 Admision for each person because they have Live Music. The band play country music from 8:00pm to 10:30pm and for Our surprise another band star to play at 11:00pm that band play 90s music. We enjoyed being their.$5 per coors light - Good price !!!I think you can go and I have fun with your friends their.
Extremely cheap beer with crazy good happy hour specials, but dont expect anything crazy. Decent selection, but it is never that cold. They often give out free samples of their apps, which are subpar but again super cheap. This is a dive bar at its best, so you know what you are getting into. One of the few affordable places still on the strip, and you never get hassled if you linger.
The owners here have broken the code during Covid. They took space behind their store, facing the parking lot, and had a band perform there. All tables regarded Social Distancing. First live band in town in 7 months! Kudos to the Nutty Irishman
Always a great time. Super friendly staff knows there way around a drink!
Great night spot. I took a taxi there a few months ago and it kind of looked like THIS
This site is my first choice restaurant. Of all restaurants I know I favor it most. I never miss an opportunity to go to visit this restaurant. everytime I want to go to a good supper, this is the place that comes straightaway to my mind. very good and all sorts of food and a large menu.helpful staff, and agreeable atmosphere. Also important, the cost is reasonable. I suggest this spot with no hesitation.
Went in for the Wednesday burger special. Place was pretty empty but still was going to try it because of Newsdays review. Order s beer and wife ordered a Coke. We ask about the special and the server said she didnt know about any special even though it was right on the wall. She then went and asked the kitchen and they said no special. Ask for the bill and was charged 10 dollars. The special was for a burger, fries and beer for 9.95. What a rip off.
Yes, I did love it ! Food, drink and atmosphere on Country Tuesdays is everything I could ask for. The dance floor, DJs and sound system all combined to make the night something to remember.The LIVE music was very good that night also.
Always consistently good food, beer and atmosphere. Staff is friendly and helpful. The owners are extremely supportive to the community. Perfect place for events too. Go to the Nutty!
Great selection of beers. Seasonal drink options available. By day the space is moderate in size. On weekends the space opens up to triple in size with 2 additional bars, live music, DJ, dance floor and outside patio in the back.
Came here for lunch as we did all of last year while working over at old Bethpage; unfortunately Nancy was no longer the bartender and the service was probably the worst I’ve ever received at a bar before. Bartender was on her phone texting the entire time and we couldn’t even order bc of it. In addition the food sucked; shame place was the best deal in town and I used to recommend it to everyone who worked with us. Last time I’ll ever do that.
Good location. Usually have live music. Some of the bartenders are incredible others seem to want nothing to do with you. Always an interesting crowd there, never know what to expect.
Two bands on the weekends. The early show is for an older crowd and the younger crowd comes in after 11pm. Very loud, but thats to be expected. Good spot for live music.
Tried to go here with a group for a friends birthday. All of us are 21, but after showing the bartender our IDs, he accused us of having fake IDs. Had a horrible experience with a rude bartender. Would have been nice to speak to a manager.
I had a great time. Awesome food as well
Went for New Years open bar and buffet. Drinks were pretty good, live music also better than I expected. Not much seating on the night we went but the places was crowded!
Would be a great place except they discriminate and chose when they want to implement the dress code. “no joggers or boots allowed” yet we sat and watched lots of people dressed the same walk in no problems. The nutty irishman will no longer be getting my business, not for a $10 cover fee. and i’llbe telling all my friends
It doesnt have the best menu, the waiters are really slow and so distracted. The music is not the thing in this places, its not a place where to know people.I went on Saturday and it looked like a Monday; although the food we ordered was good.
Our server was great. The food was great and the drinks were on point. I have to say the steak nachos were the bomb lol. Definitely an awesome place to stop in for during the day for a bit and a a drink.
Went to hear some 70s music. Apps were good. Band played until 10:00 then stopped. Figured it was a break. After 1 hour asked staff if the band was going back on and was told a new band was going on at 11:30. Would have been nice to know.
Terrible NYE experience. Way too many tickets were sold. Waited for over an hour in the freeezing cold even though I bought a 40 dollar ticket. Once I got in I could not even move it took 20 minutes to get from the entrance to the coat check in the back. It was a waste of money I ended up leaving because I could not even move or get a drink. They should really monitor better how many tickets are sold for a big event like that.
Never witnessed racial profiling like this before. Very disappointing watching the only 2 black guys get kicked out by all white security staff, for absolutely no reason.They couldnt even apologize after realizing they were acusing the wrong person. Plus the front bartender that was rude and obviously annoyed she had to make drinks didnt help.
If your looking for a great place to have a party this is the place!! I had my nephews 40th birthday party this past weekend and people are still talking about it. We had the entire back room and were over 90 people. There was plenty of room for everyone. It was a very causal party (bar atmosphere). From the start of planning the party with Katharine, she made the whole process so easy to plan. Very helpful and her suggestions worked really well. When I arrived at the party, Katharine had made sure every decoration and table was set up beautifully. The perfect party planner and very attentive. I couldnt have done it any better myself.The catering menu had plenty of food options to choose from. Everyone raved about the food, especially the penne vodka, chicken francaise and what there known for, Nutty Irishman barbque steak. The 2 bartenders Anthony and Kristina were great. Very attentive and personable. They handled the party with such ease. As far as the servers, we had Joanne, Eileen and Katharine. There work was incredible. Always had a smile, very personable, very attentive and making sure everyone had food including making sure the couple of lil ones we had got there chicken tenders delivered to them personally. Ive had many parties before ie catering halls and restaurants but this one was by far the easiest one yet. The staff at the nutty irishman are truly exceptional!!
Nacy to have a good time with friends and family
The food was not good. Asked for the wings to be dry with sauce on the side ao it would be crispy....it was not. Suppose to have bleu cheese amd celery with wi gs...it was missing. The tortilla soip did not have enough flavor in it. There was not enough wait staff for such a busy place. Asked for water 3 tomes, never got it. Wont be going nack
This place is first-rate and broad, the food was enchanting and the rates were very reasonable. quick, efficient service and very personal waiters. Recommended.
Large space local pub with a garden in the back. Often has live entertainment in house. During covid phase III , sidewalk served meals were tasty as always .
Was there for some live music at their out door dining area. Food was good. I would go back.
Great spot to watch any game ... Cold Beers 🍻 and Hot Wings 🔥
Horrible! I used to go there in college and staff were good but management were terrible. And visit there today after 5 years of graduating, and management were worse than before ! Absolutely dont recommend it!
Finest food, super nice staff, constantly great atmosphere. They charge affordable rates and the food quality is fantastic. Keep it up.
Busy nightlife, live music or a DJ keeps the dnace floor filled. Drinks are available from both an indoor and outdoor bar. Worth a visit
Each band brings different music to the venue. The sound system is good. The alcohol selection is just ok
Terrible place. Horrible bouncers
The crowd is way too young and the drinks taste different every time. I gave it 3 stars instead of less because they always forget to charge me for some of my drinks
It is nice to find a place that can offer live music bands and entertain people of different group ages. The Nutty Irishman is that fun place.
This could be your favorite place or not, depending on your crowd. I look like a white crow going there semi dressed up. People roll in there in dirty jeans and pajamas and uggs so it is literally nutty in there. Unless its your clang. You may feel like an overdressed person at Walmart. Nevertheless dj plays modern dancing music and remixes it well. The dj shifts with a band by hours. 11pm dance music. By 12 its a rock band.
If you get a bad vibe walking in dont do it down the street the dark horse will welcome your good vibes
Food wasnt good. Staff are friendly and the place is nice and in middle of the village
My wife and I went here to do a paint night. The bartenders were friendly. The paint instructions were nice. It was definitely a good experience.
Drink pricing is similar to that of some bars in Manhattan. I was there on a Friday night - the live music made it worth the commute over to LI.
Great place to meet & have fun
Plenty of space to spread out so that you are not constantly having squeeze through to the bar or dance floor. Good bands, good crowd and decent service.
Cheap beers but 20$ credit card limit. A1 place to enjoy yourself, live music and all. 10/10 would recomend.
Cant tell much about this place cause I went to see a couple bands thats it wasnt crazy about them taking my drivers license ID and scanning it to a computer system not sure what they going to be using that information for but otherwise service was good and the drink prices were OK the bands were awesome
Good venue for live music. Security does a good job keeping the riff raff out. Decent food too.
I had a great time tonight in farmingdale. I think the street fair in front of the nutty Irishman is a fantastic idea. Was with my daughter and the grandkids saw so old faces from the past. The farmingdale community is like no other. 5 stars easy
Great band, no cover for me or my friends for my bday, free birthday shots for all of us. Very cool
Great place to see live music. If youre into the Grateful Dead I recommend seeing Half Step or Tiger Rose when they come around.
Total dump. Lame bartenders who cant count money, goofy 1980s interior, and zero crowd. The middle of summer, and they didnt even have the air conditioning on! Guess they were trying to keep down the electric bill.
Good food & Bartender!
Nice night out at the bar place I hate that the bands go on later though now wish they would go on earlier like the better days.
Great place, great music, great atmosphere!
Nice beer selections, 1st band was awesome, 2nd band you could hardly hear volumes were wat too loud.
Great time! Billy Muir & The Hitmen were awesome! And I won 2 Jones Beach concert tickets from WBAB!
We were there for a private party. Staff was super attentive and the sliders were maybe the best Ive ever had.
Great bar with drinks that wont break the bank and really great dj and live music definitely going back again
Located on the strip in farmingdale def a got to when the place is hopping and you can fit in with the crowd must go to post covid
Great food and atmosphere
Great hamburgers and pumpkin beer !! live music as well in the outdoor dining area !
Not great but not terrible. Didnt have the drink I asked for which is fine but the prices were average. Nothing to write home about, lol.
This place is great and the setup is nice. Staff is very welcoming and a bunch of nice people.
Great food, good people, nice drink menu and country night is a lot of fun on Tuesday!
Good food, inexpensive, and great for parties. Staff is very helpful and caring to your partygoers.
Great food. The staff here is awesome and very courteous.
Its a smelly dive but that doesnt seem to bother anyone cause its always jumping. It just for the 21 to 35 crowd. Its a true long island stick hole.
Always a good time. And they always have my credit card and ID waiting for me the next day since I always leave in a condition where I forget to close my tab. LOL
Saw my friends uncle play here and it was a blast! band called Barely Acoustic played, they were great
All kids that try to fight you bc they cant handle their alcohol
Only reason I gave this a 3 is because some weekends, its the best place to be on planet earth and other weekends Id rather go to rikers island for a good time.
Music and drinks were good. However the place can get very crowded.
Nice bar and good sized dance pit for live performances. Prices at bar are average.
Band was excellent...Spot on, excellent musicians, vocals, fun...Will look to see them again...Freebird
Went here for a business mixer. Nice people who dont charge for a club soda, though they could.
We planned on bar hopping in Farmingdale but the great music, food, and drinks kept us at The Nutty Irishman all night.
Fun place to hang out. Large place with stage for live music. Good service at good prices.
Excellent venue to watch a band. Older crowd. No drama and great food!
A friend recommended this place and it was good. Great service, good food.
Plenty of room to dance easy to get to the bar good music great people
Fun atmosphere and great food.
Had the best time at the fundraiser for Set. Brian Moore. Great people, great music, good time.
Best dam bar in farmingdale and on long island I definitely recommend this bar lots of fun good bands and djs
My family and I went there to eat and drink on Mother’s Day. The food was amazing and delicious.
Spacious location with a friendly staff. Great place to spend a boozy Saturday night.
Wonderful bar and restaurant. I enjoy there for the country night on Thursdays.
Lunch was good. 5 dollar lunch. Enough of food for a senior. Had the steak sandwich.
Help put this place out of business. Owners of Nutty chain are horrible people that hire juiced-up bouncers to beat up customers without warning.
Amazing, fun place. The staff is attentive, courteous. Great music!,
Where farmingdalers are conceived, born, live, and die.. missing a friend from hs??? No worries!! Find em here every Friday and Saturday night!
Excellent place for the younger crowd, not so much for the for ppl ages 30 & up !!!
The service is consistently rapid, good vibes, kind employees. Will eat here again when I arrive nearby.
Had a great time, good food, good crowd, great band.
Fun place. Ate at the bar. Met interesting people. Thin pizza is really good.
Nice place but their drinks are way too overpriced.
First time there. I must say the food was pretty considering it was bar food.
It’s close to my house and a good place to go dancing but it’s over priced and over crowded
Hot dogs and burgers in the back, not sure if it only for the 5 at 5. 3 different bars so drinks are good
Excellent burger cooked perfectly meat tender and not dried out nor dripping with grease great nachos!
Use to go there all the time with my friends but I won’t be going anymore after the experience I had last night. Absolutely ridiculous.
Very loud music, couldnt talk, chjx qusedia dry, big pretzel excellent, Mac bites good.
Had lots of fun. Played a nice range of music that spanned from when I was in Elementary to High School.
Great experience had a lot of fun good drinks
Attended a Christmas party there... Good food , friendly service, nice atmosphere.
Nutty Irishman rules - great food & service, bands - and very charitable with Village Events!
Fun place. Huge soethig for eeryone. Food luve music, great band
Fun atmosphere. Good for all ages. Live bands.
Love it! Great place, good food, drinks, entertainment and bartenders
I had a great experience here at the nutty, awesome apps and great service summed up an all around great time!
The drinks were great the music was amazing, fun crowd
Fun atmosphere, great selection of on tap beers and ciders
Great place great atmosphere the food was very good and the service was spot on
Great place good crowd and Garden state radio plays there
Always stop down when doing laundry for a drink, great servers alwqys feels welcoming.
Great venue to see a band and have a good drink.
Popping 5 years ago. Now has nice shows each weekend
Paid $40 for an open bar then couldnt get in because they sold too many tickets. Absurd.
Great food, nice atmosphere and lots of fun
Food and service were good. Hard cider on tap is a plus.
The new menu is great I even stop in for lunch not disappointed great food
A quaint pub on Main Street. Bring some friends and have a good time.
Lots of fun. Great music
Same as every other bar on Long Island, except horrible DJs and bands here.
Nice Bars to hang out and very good food
They got to change the bands up, 90s bands are just killing the vibe so hard and you can heasbang only so much
Nice People, Good Food and Great Country Line Dancing Nights !!!
One of ny favorite places to drink and see live music.
We went for Lepre-con. they advertised 25 at door,on linewhen we arrived, they charged 30pp..bait and switch..
1st time there. I thought it was nice
Excellent place for a get together . Food is delicious .
Amazing joint! Great food and great music
Nobody was in there last night And they dont have pickles for hamburger how do you serve hamburgers without pickles
Crowded, hot, young crowd, but live music and DJ was good
Very busy buzzing place popular with young crowds 21-29 yr olds
Enjoyed a great time with friends always a great place to enjoy good times with friends.
Love this bar, Gets packed out later in the night
Cool place! Nice prople and great food!
Crowd was super old at 7-10 pm night... Terribly disappointed
Cozy, well-managed, and a fun play to enjoy live music/drinks/DJ sets
Excellent food and service, highly recommend!
Staff very helpful, place clean, food good, drinks gooood 😁
Good atmosphere for a quiet drink or a night out.
Great venue..good food and entertainment
Small version of their Bay Shore counterpart. Good for a quick drink.
Wonderful roomy spot to enjoy great local musicians
Their food wasnt as great as I thought it would be and they had no Spanish artichoke dip 😦
Very friendly staff and yummy wings !!!
Fun place for live music etc.
Unexpectedly fun. I didnt know what to expect when we went in.
Main street Farmingdale popular Business I Dont drink alcohol
Total reviews rating 4
199 Reviews for Nutty Irishman 2023:
Review №1
2022-03-19The place was surprisingly big. They had good live music and a dj in between the bands sets. The food was good although we only had fries and beer cheese. The staff was in good spirits even though it was St. Patricks Day and it was crowded. There was a $10 cover to get in but the coat check is free. My only complaint is I wish there were more chairs.
Review №2
2021-01-27If you have the opportunity to attend one of their themed pop-up events, TAKE IT! My friends and I went to the Harry Potter brunch for my birthday, and we were not disappointed. The food was great, the drinks were flowing, the staff was INCREDIBLY friendly and helpful, and they decorated beautifully. Characters came around with trivia questions and it was just an overall magical experience, Im definitely interested in going back for more events like this.
Review №3
2022-05-21Worst experience ever!! I’m 67 yrs old… went here because it sounded lively & fun. No one offered to find a table, ok. Sat at the bar, read the menu….the barmaid stood with her back to us . When younger people came to the bar she waited on them immediately. I will never go back again! If you are over 30….don’t waste your time!
Review №4
2022-06-06Awesome guy at the door. everytime i go the door man is always nice and sometimes generous. good times any time. live bands and dj. well mixed drinks and not to pricey. (prices are ok). music is always different and always changing. great place good times and PERFECT parking. cover charge👎 but its ok.
Review №5
2022-01-01Best Nye eve I ever had. Amazing dj playing electronic and pop music. Had live stream of times square ball drop. Drinks were great too. Live band was performing too. Best$50 ever spent
Review №6
2018-07-22AWESOME PLACE, BEEN THERE RECENTLY FOR THE COMIC BAR CON, AND THE WORKERS AND AMBIANCE BOTH INSOORS & in the BACK OUTSIDE AREA, ARE FANTASTIC!!! Great Beer and FOOD Selection!!
Review №7
2020-02-22Decent place. Skirt steak cooked medium rare was perfect! Veggies a bit over cooked but tasty. Good local pub. Guinness was very good as well. Mac and cheese was very good as well.
Review №8
2022-04-10A nice large venue with live music and several different areas within. Large outdoor area as well.
Review №9
2022-03-23Racist establishment. kicked me out with wild accusation. they made me feel unwelcome and uncomfortable. never even checked their cameras before making sure
Review №10
2022-02-26The bar was alright but $10 cover per person on a random Friday night when the place is nearly empty is ridiculous. Most I’ve paid anywhere outside of New Years