Old Stone Market in East Hampton

Review №1

2021-12-27

Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Keizer roll. Easy over is often a challenge and this place lived up to my messy eggs sandwich expectations.The fridge had some interesting offerings as shown in my posted photo.

Review №2

2022-06-07

Really great home made food, great selection of baked goods. Small store with a strange layout, but quaint and cozy. Staff isnt always the friendliest, but otherwise a good stop.

Review №3

2021-08-17

This is a gem of a market! Great for picking up last minute ingredients or things you might need for an impromptu picnic or dinner. Lunch is great! Empanadas are so good. But really I came here to rave about the peanut butter cookies. If you can get them when they are fresh, run don’t walk.

Review №4

2022-03-19

I’ve heard from multiple people that this store sells expired food. Be careful what you buy from them and make sure to check the expiration date.

Review №5

2022-05-16

Rude foul mouthed owner pushing old, stale food -- if you have to go, check the expiry dates (they are moat likely passed).

Review №6

2022-06-12

Good spot to get prepared food.

Review №7

2021-01-23

It’s hard to decide what’s best here, but I guarantee you won’t find better scones elsewhere; the English cream in particular. The list of delicious foods goes on. We tried almost everything: the chicken cutlets, crispy yet juicy; the soups, particularly the Mexican one they have, and I don’t exaggerate when I say I could eat that for lunch and dinner three days back to back; the lasagna and the chicken pot pie are full of flavor with the unmistakable taste of homemade cooking. The cheese cake is to die-for and the rice pudding became a ritual for us when we are in Amagansett. If you are around, and haven’t discovered this place, GO!

Review №8

2020-04-29

I have been coming to this place for six years, they have decent prepared food and are conveniently located. But yesterday I had the most unbelievably upsetting experience with the lady who Im presuming is one of the owners. I have never in my life been treated so rudely for absolutely no reason. I will never set foot in this place again.

Review №9

2020-07-11

Worst customer service ever, only customer in the shop, lazy employees took 20 minutes to prepare 2 simple lox bagels, yet they keep whining while you are paying with the card.No mask used properly, using wash sink to wash food, hands and utensils, miracle health department did not shut them down

Review №10

2017-04-23

Good food, BUT watch what the menu says ...Ex : Italian Hero...$7.95....At the end it says on a roll....Oh, want your Italian hero as a hero? $2 more. The baked goods are great, but pricey.