Takeaway
Yes
Onofrios in Mastic Beach
Categories
Location on the map
Mastic Beach, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Dine-in
Yes
Delivery
No
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Great coffee
Yes
Great dessert
Yes
Popular for
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Offerings
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Dining options
Dinner
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Romantic
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Planning
Accepts reservations
Yes
Phone: +1 631-395-3332
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:Closed
- Wednesday:4–9:30PM
- Thursday:4–9:30PM
- Friday:4–10PM
- Saturday:4–10PM
- Sunday:4–9PM
Comments (119)
For me its a five-star little place close in our nice little town the food is always great the staff is always helpful The Waitresses are always checking on you to make sure everything is good and if you need anything else and the owners are always on site talkin to you making sure theyre doing a good job and the prices are excellent we had two glasses of wine 4 rum and cokes a full size antipasto salad mixed vegetables chicken francese and a New York strip steak which came with salads and for dessert cheesecakes plus Saturday night there is live music all four 109.43 to get that kind of price you have to stay home and eat and play the radio!! Its a place definitely worth going and checking out
I havent been here in almost 10 years... and you know when you walk back into a place and you hope it still is what you remembered and then youre not satisfied? This is not the case. Everything was delicious. Service was great. Their pizza is just awesome. Love their house dressing. I love this place. I love that I feel like Im at my aunts brownstone in Queens and we are sitting in her living room because we couldnt fit in the kitchen. I am not going to wait another 10 years. Thank you for bringing me back home.
Great little gem. Food was great. Enjoyed it. Highly recommend. Saturday night live music 7pm. Will definitely go back many times.
Had a terrific meal. I am tough on Italian food and I was made very happy. Service was fine. The place was so that we can have a conversation without talking loud. The menu was diverse and everyone was pleased. Parking was fine. I will return for sure. This place is about the food.
Hometown favorite since I was a child. Excellent food at great prices. The atmosphere is so warm and inviting and the staff is beyond helpful and sweet. If I could give more stars I absolutely would!
Good Food Service at a Fair Price
My family has been going to this restaurant since before I was born. Its a great family Italian restaurant. The waiters/waitresses/owners always greet us when we walk in. It can get crowded at dinner time, so come a little early or expect a little wait. The food is delicious! They have pasta dinner nights and they also do takeout. The pizza is awsome and according to members of my family they have the best pizza crust on long island.
Quaint little Italian restaurant serving your usual Italian cuisine. My wife had a garden salad and commented how fresh the lettuce was. I had French onion soup which was passable. As a main course my wife had fried calamari, it was over cooked and appeared to need the oil changed in the deep fryer. I had Chicken Marsala. Mine was under cooked, a little tough in spots. Besides these problems, the food took a long time to come to us, and our server was more interested in another couple who were obviously regulars. The guy kept yelling across the restaurant. When we were ready for our check, our server, possibly the owner, sat back down with the other couple once more.
Love this little gem of a family owned place! Pattie is so wonderful and her staff.. it’s like eating over a great friends house and their Mom is the best cook!
Nice friendly people, family atmosphere.But veal was a bit tough and marsala was more like soup.
Absolutely one of my favorite places to go. Never had a bad meal there, and Ive been there at least 50 times!!! Always good, Always friendly, and on Friday you get to hear the guitar player! Awesome place!!!
Could give it any less, I would. From the get go, disappointment was imminent. We had to go get our item silverware so we could bitter our bread, eat a salad, and eat what they called French onion soup. When asked what type of dressing i wanted, I was not given any choice, but rather played a guessing game as to what was available. When I finally settled on house made creamy Italian, I was given something that resembled kindergarten paste. My wifes French onion soup resembled some sorry of steak or prime rib au jus, with burnt cheese on top and a burnt bottom. When we did finally recieve or meal ( an hour later ), it was the most horrible adaptation off Italian food that I have ever witnessed. I had what appeared to be 2 and some pieces of manicotti drowned in a flavorless sauce complete with a topping of not very melted mozzarella. I ended up adding salt and pepper too it just to get some sort of flavor going. My wifes stuffed ravioli were undercooked and rubbery to chew, and her sauce was just as horrible as mine. Water was served in dirty glasses without ice and or beverages came in clear solo cups. Paying $17 per plate, again 2 and some pieces of manicotti and 4 rubbery stuffed shells was horrible. Calling this establishment an Italian restaurant is like calling McDonalds a seafood gourmet. I would be embarrassed to run this place. Next time, Ill just drive the 25 minutes out of my way too go to O Sole Mio in Stony Brook, and even wait 3 hours in a snowstorm for that matter, at least I know it will be real Italian cuisine. Spoiler alert if you still want to go, the bathroom light switches are about shoulder height ( for someone thats 61 ), so have fun with that. AND, as I type this review, my stomach is making some funny sounds and same thing is happening to my wife.
The pizza is The Best!! We went for a friends birthday dinner and everything was delicious and the staff was so nice and very accommodating. We will definitely go there again!
I started eating here in 1973 and the place was already around for decades.. Although the pizza is very good, I prefer the entrees including heros, pasta and ravioli as well as the salads. Interior is clean and old school and typifies what a real Italian eatery should be.
Enjoyed the food and dining experience very much. Good price too, they were running a special where the dinner and choice of soup or salad was only 12 dollars. Waitress was friendly and prompt. Dining room was nice to eat in
Food is decent. Averagely good typical Italian. No bells. No frills on the decor either which seems to be there since the towns heyday in 1955. The biggest issue is service and payment. If you get one of the local hires to serve you- great. If you get the OWNER to serve you or especially to figure out your archaic style know-your-math bill, too bad for you. I didnt eat in-house much, but out of the few times I did, she blatantly overcharged me, with NO APOLOGY.
Really relaxing atmosphere. Delicious pasta. Excellent pricing. I’ll be back.
This place was recommended & we live in area. It was worst Italian place ever been to. Went 1st time will never go again. (Later people said it was very good w original owners it changed.) Your outside sign is misleading as well when people looking for this name but in big letters you have your names. Heres highlights..When u have some1 greeting u when walk in please tell the 2 guys/waiter to wear NON stained shirts. The mens room was gross he said. 1st place been to ever with issues putting ice cubes in glasses. Water to table should have ice. Same with icetea/soda. Why not? Is ice expensive for you but you charge alot for meals We had.We had to ask and brought out 1 cup w some ice. We sat ate dishes. For 2 it was expensive (we didnt have alcoholic drinks). Appetizers I had the tortellini was very good. Salad 2 choices dressing isnt enough, had house dressing sorry but it wasnt good I didnt eat it. My shrimp parm had only 6 shrimp non breaded which it wasnt cheap. Idk where u get your red sauce/who made it I got sick throwing up from it. Never had experience in Italian restaurant like this. Fyi iceteas, soda are poured from can-no soda dispensers (saw him do this).
Ive never been there before but my friends go there and it is terrific. The food is so delicious. And Im sure Ill be back there again and again and again.
Wonderful food, quiet atmosphere and very nice staff
Spent a few beautiful nights here. The service was warm attentive and delightful. Amazing garlic bread made of clouds and love in all seriousness. Everything I have ordered has been melt in your mouth delicious. Chicken marsala and Veal especially. I frequent Onofrios on special occaisions as they are slightly expensive but completely worth every penny. Must try it you will fall in love!
Wonderful..Great visit. Food is fresh and delicious. Will go back again. Its a hidden secret.. Quiet place for a great dinner with that special one... Thank you for everything Patty.....
House salad and house creamy Italian dressing is incredible. Their pies are one size only and different but awesome. Order a meatball, mushroom with extra sauce...trust me.
This place is the real deal. Service is like you are part of the family. Service is great. Food is incredible. Get the house dressing on your salad and any entree is marvelous!!!
Food is great. Its not too formal. Live music. Strong drinks. Deffinetly one of my new top long island spots to get a real meal.
Yummy food Patty is a sweetheart, it is a small comfy place to eat. may take a bit to get your food but it is all made when you order worth the wait
My ex swears by this place as for me I’ve had better pizza!! I’m glad I won’t be going back!! The nastiest pizza I ever ate!! Sorry but it reminds me of high end ellio’s! Even tasted like cardboard to me!!
WOW!!! Fantastic food and service. Great prices. A family favorite. Live music was perfect. We were all very impressed.
Mastic Beaches greatest treasure who are familiar with classic Italian food. The best Pene a la Vodka and pizza anywhere no contest. A homey and cozy atmosphere. Mangia Mi Amici. Caio
This place is awesome!!! Im from Hauppauge so I am used to Branchinellies!! And its too far for me 2 go... Anyway... I was lucky enough to move right down the street from this GEM Onofrios!!! BTW... Umm.Ya! Its been around since the ......60s!!! Anywho... Eat here!! Try there salad with there house dressing... Pizza!! And ANY OF THERE PASTA dishes!!! Yayyy! To Onfrios!!!!!
Excellent pizza..like fried from Block Island!!Soo freakn good you seriously need more theN one pie if more then three hungry people..fresh ingredients..tastes amazing..price is fair..enjoy!
Very Good home cookingNice people and Quaint place. Reasonable prices.Only draw back is a limited menu.
Great food and service. We only ordered pizza this time it was deliciousLooking forward to going back for dinner
Just love this place!! Great food and wonderful people. Owner Patty makes you feel like your at a family dinner.
Good food nice people
Very cute romantic italian restaurant. Excellent food and great family service! I recommend this restaurant to everyone I know! Best Pizza - Everything is great!
Great food. Yummy pizza. Small quaint but decor could use a refresh. Parking is always tight.
Been many years. I so miss their pizza. Moved to N.C. Many years ago. This is just the very best pizza and Italian food.
Delicious!! Yummy Italian food, great atmosphere, SUPER friendly staff/family
Just so you know if you order main dishes for take out...you have to chose between salad or pasta...you do not get both. First time in all my life Ive heard of that.
I loved it as usual but today was even better cause my mom and i got a early dinner so no one was there great food atmosphere and service
Looking for a quiet spot nice place to goSmall, really good food, served nice and hot, not cheap, and not a big selection, but really good. Older could use update
Great local place for Italian food. Lots of options on the menu. Very friendly staff.
One of my favorite places to go to for dinner ! It’s a cute place , the staff is very friendly and the food is delicious!
Great portion sizes for the seemingly high price, so totally worth it!
Delicious food! The pizza is amazing.. gear Italian resturant and I strongly recommend it!
Great food, prices, quiet comfortable atmosphere and very friendly staff. Yum!
Amazing food, welcoming place. I love the staff, especially the managershe is lovely
Outstanding quality , home cooked food. Definitely recommend Onofrios , for dinning in or take out.
Best Pizza Old School. Stop by on the way back from the beach.
A homey place where you are almost sure your grandmother is in the kitchen cooking your favorite meal. I loved this place.
Amazing meal and the price is right for so much food they serve.
Last of the last my favorite Italian restaurantLive Pattie and Steve truly old word, old town!And the food far above the rest
Great food, I love garlic bread with melted cheese. Awesome
Best pizza ever. Service was great. Love Patti
A hidden gem!! Great food, great service!!!
Sorry to say that our experience was less than satisfying. Service was extremely bad, and food was average at best.
Small place w/great food. Service was good also.
Great little place to get some food, I recommend the steak.
The homemade creamy Italian dressing is AMAZING!!! Im obsessed with the house salad and stuffed shells!!
Good selection of seafood. Affordable prices. Nice place
Amazing little family-owned place great place for two people to go have dinner
Excellent food and Service as always.Thank you Patti
Shrimp franchise is my go to meal, quaint, friendly, good food
Love this restaurant. Steve, Patti and the chef Millie are amazing
Loved it. Patti and Steve are good people.
The best pizza in the Shirley/ Mastic/ Mastic Beach area, hands down.
Wait staff was outstanding the sauce was a little thin
Wanted to try it for years. It was delucious.
Best pizza ever! Too expensive though.
Wonderul food great friendly service and cozy atmospher I highly recommend it
Excellent food. Excellent service.
Nice food here so I give it five stars
Felix the cat 😸 gives this place a 👍🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 great food, great service, Enjoy..😸✌️
OutstandingGreat food ,great service
Great food love this place also awsome food
Quaint little Italian restaurant in Mastic Beach with common American Italian dishes.
Homely, hygienic, very friendly and warm in heart and in food.
Best thing mastic beach has to offer. if you go there you will be hooked.
The veal marsala is some of the best ive ever had.
Great meal great service great atmosphere
Friendly atmosphere,,good food
Replace service was out of this world food delicious
Always excellent. Great service. Friendly staff.
Grate food and great prices
Best thick crust pizza anywhere.
Enjoyed everything
Great place love to eat there
Great food great staff
Best pizza 🍕in town
Excellent food and great anbiance
Excellent food and service
Every time i visit it feels like home.
Absolutely 5 stars and more!
Good food
Awesome food out of this world
Great food and service
I love their pizza
Love! Yummy!!!
Good meal all around
AWFUL
The best in the area!
A nice Italian meal
Always good.
Consuming a appertizing meal
Great
Awesome food
Good kitchen
Atmosphere Atmosphere Atmosphere!
Total reviews rating 4.5
119 Reviews for Onofrios 2023:
Review №1
2022-01-30Been going here on and off for 38 years when I would go to my friends summer house in Mastic Beach and the pizza still tastes the same. Consistency is the secret to the delicious pizza pies. The many dishes they serve are also excellent.
Review №2
2022-03-06Ive been going here since i was a kid and i always enjoyed their food, until tonight. We ordered a chicken pizza and received chopped up frozen chicken on a cheese pizza, its honestly pathetic and i cant believe how bad it is, tastes freezer burned too. Smh
Review №3
2019-06-27EDIT/WENT 6/16 to go out for fathers day. We were very very disappointed. Been living here 10+ yrs tried Ontofrios now but you might pass it looking for the sign to say it. Easily you can spot which I didnt know changed owners which reflects on the sign as Steve & Pattis-same place different owners.( does say Onofrios est.1950 underneath).This day it wasnt packed @ that time. Dont expect it to be big inside.FIRST its very nice when you walk into a place & are greated! To be honest Steve & Patti it would have been better if they didnt. Both fellows had STAINED TSHIRTS on & no it wasnt that something just spilled on them. Im sure you could agree on that.It was 2 of us the bill was just over $80 before tip! Thats pricey for what we got which I will detail. Portions werent big, no alcohol, no desserts...read on-Our drinks were icetea & soda. This is only place ever been that serves your water and drinks w no ice. Then when asked for ice brought us 1 cup out w some. Idk y skimp on ice. Fyi beverages saw him pour out of a can usually its fountains. Took several times ask for our beverages.-Ordered the appetizers of tortellini and muscles for him. 1 french onion soup and came w 1 salad. Hope u like 1 of 3 choices of dressing-greek ,blue cheese,creamy italian. Got italian as dont like the others, the italian had weird taste I didnt eat it. (We are not picky and eat out all different types food, places)-french onion soup was just ok.-app tortellini I had was actually the best of everything, was very good.-he had muscles in white which were cooked perfect and on the bigger side-he had seafood combo cooked fine tasted fine except red sauce-I had shrimp parm w penne alla vodka for the pasta. The pasta penne alla vodka is my favorite but not good. Its the sauce they use dont like. Took 2 bites and couldnt eat it.-see by the pics not much to eat less then 10 shrimp. They are not breaded if thats what u r used to.-sorry but this is an italian place. The red sauce sb yummy. It was the worst Ive had out at an Italian place ever.I got sick right after we left all night.-he used mens room said just cant understand the upkeep. The walls not all way painted but not as if they started to repaint them more its been the 1st paint job never got chance to finish. Needs to be cleaned too. Its not good feeling walking into something like that.Maybe times are tough for them Idk but very disappointed as we went to celebrate fathers day.As a reviewer I just tell as it was/is as I would want someone to be honest when reviewing place.We wont go back, I have family moving out this way they wont go.PS another poster said there was live music not when we went. Maybe its on different day/night.---Below from week before top post..They are closed Mondays will have to try another time (have all stars because havent tried yet so wouldnt give bad review)
Review №4
2021-09-15LOVE Onofrios! They have the best pizza, hands down! Small family owned little gem in Mastic. My family has been going since they opened way back when- my dad, my sisters, and now my nieces all love this spot. Great for a family gathering or to just pick up a pie!
Review №5
2021-07-20Food was just so so. Their prices are definitely cheaper than Mama Lisas or La Volpes, but you get what you pay for. When we arrived they werent that crowded. Waitress kept apologizing saying the oven was full with baked clams so the food was taking longer to get out. We were there for over 2 hours!
Review №6
2022-02-13Great atmosphere! Food was awesome, Carl Bruno played guitar and sang
Review №7
2021-06-06Cant say enough about this GREAT restaurant. We come every year for special occasions & my daughters birthday. They remembered us & my husbands 1955 Mercury Monterey. Treated like family, the foods delish &everyone is friendly & accommodating. HIGHLY recommend!
Review №8
2019-09-08Excellent service, super friendly staff(Christine)was awesome. Delicious Italian food definitely recommended.
Review №9
2021-12-13Patty makes the place feel like home. Beautiful ambiance, excellent food, and live music on the weekend...great little Italian restaurant for over 50 years.
Review №10
2021-04-23Im sorry to one my growing up. This meal was kinda like when you realize grandma isnt the same grandma in cooking anymore. Maybe let grandma coach from the sideline. But with all this, I cant imagine their pizza ever losing its grace..please please, please.Yes, thats right, by the late James Brown.Sauce extremely salty. Carbonaro is very disappointed. Their replacement was Lasagna, I felt so bad. wasnt much better. It is with deep pain. I dont want to believe this..so Im hoping it was just a bad day. Their service was great.