Delivery
Yes
Paesanos Pizzeria in Liberty
Categories
Location on the map
Liberty, Sullivan County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
No
Wheelchair-accessible seating
No
Offerings
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
University students
Yes
Phone: +1 845-292-7510
Site: https://www.facebook.com/pages/c...
Site: https://www.facebook.com/pages/c...
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–9PM
- Tuesday:11AM–9PM
- Wednesday:11AM–9PM
- Thursday:11AM–9PM
- Friday:11AM–9PM
- Saturday:11AM–9PM
- Sunday:Closed
Paesanos Pizzeria in other cities:
Comments (199)
Been eating here for like 10 years or more it seems. Love the low prices and love the food. Always hot tasty and finished promptly and the place is very Family friendly also.
This place is so good .so nice. And always Consistent with what they do cant wait to eat there again . Im calling them now .thanks for great food peice out.
Good food, good service will def stop by again next time I am in the area
I love the delivery,they tend to say it takes longer but in reality it takes like only 20 minutes, for me, they’re quick with it and the prices aren’t that expensive, love the pizza
Best pizza weve had in the immediate area. For the best fancy pizza you have to go to Livingston Manor or Mountaindale.
For the last three months I have been calling Paesanos every Saturday and Sunday at least 10 times each day and nobody ever picks up the phone. No matter what time of day it was.. no body to take an order for take out or delivery.. not a single answer... so I would call Munson instead because I can at least order a takeout.... its there a diferent number? Or maybe u should install a second phone line, call waiting or something... really disappointed.. why is it so hard to make an order for takeout and pull up 30 mins later when the food is ready.. oh wait they had that untill they stopped answering the phone... if its a mistake by Google in regards to work hours .. contact them to fix it so u get no further bad reviews
Tonight my wife and I ordered from paesanos pizza. I had the best eggplant rolitine I have ever had. The Italian combo wasnt half either. I know theres other pizza places in town but why Ive been going here for 6 years not about to change now. Keep up what your doing you know you can see it we all know it you guys are the best not only in Liberty but the best in Sullivan. Great job !!!!!!!
Love stopping at this pizza place, everything is delicious, fast and the staff is always super friendly!
Alright, folks.... I’m literally typing as I eat because it’s just so good right now these people deserve a 5 star. FIRST of all, I ordered delivery... super fair prices and amazing phone service. Was simple, quick, and efficient all at once. The food arrived about an hour later. (Was warned of this so NO issue there) Delivery guy is new, and he’s super sweet with a chipper bearded smile. ^^ BUT.. WHEN I TELL YOU... I opened my food to steamy perfection aroma. Okay?! And the flavor is remarkable and he quality of my Alfredo sauce was perfect to taste. The bread was still soft and hot! Salad and drinks cold! And super filling! I’ve been eating here a LONG time so the fact I haven’t given a 5 star review yet BAFFLES me! Apologies on my end but THIS PLACE... is hands down best in Sullivan county!!
Being new to the area we dont know slot of places to get food from I was sent here by my home builder (John) and he was right. The food was great! We got a very large to go order and everything was very tasty.Will be back often
Last time there I saw workers handling multiple raw and cooked food products/items without gloves or take preventive action to stop cross contamination of food served to customers. Workers were touching everything with bare hands. Never washed hands as well as use gloves. Dont go here
Delicious pizza, i was not expecting it to be so tasty 🤤…. If i ever be in the area, i will definitely go again. Buffalo chicken and cheese … mmm 😋🤤🤤🤤🤤
The customer service here was incredible! There werent too many customers there anyway when my family and I arrived so our food was served promptly I was surprised like shortly after we took our seats. The pizza was a little more melty and oily than I liked, but still delicious! I would definitely visit again. Nice restaurant! Had a casual and relaxing atmosphere to it.
This place is just great, they have fantastic food on every level that I’ve tried so far, their service is on time and they are about average in pricing, but let me tell you, with food as good as they cooking up, it’s worth the money. The fettuccine Alfredo with chicken is amazing, I’ve had hot subs, pizza, the baked ziti and meatballs with spaghetti. All on point. Thanks again guys and girls over there at paesanos. Well done.
Love it here! Never dissapointed, the staff is friendly and learns faces quickly and although they are always busy they are also always friendly and accomodating.
Very disappointed went to order food for delivery wich theyve done before but now all of a sudden they wont deliver because they only have a delivery range of 2 mi unless you spend $30 or more so very disappointing. Never had a problem till now
Food is great! People are friendly. Sometimes the wait times are a little long but probably on their really busy days! Never had a problem. Definitely recommend
Nice place good pizza always supper busy convenient location great costumer service the place is clean and they follow Covid-19 restrictions so they are not to many tables to seat !
Good food, friendly customer service, just a little pricey. I frequent the place and its the only good pizza in town. Just wish prices were a little better. I know theres wiggle room.
Love the food.especially the chicken ranch pizza
Great pizza and 🍝 spaghetti and meatballs!
Paesanos is one of the best pizzerias youre going to find - in Sullivan County or anywhere else! The pizzas are expertly prepared and served piping hot. Orders are taken at the counter by a very nice lady with an infectious smile and food arrives promptly. At certain times this place is busy as a beehive so its wise to call ahead and order in advance. Prices are very reasonable and the menu offers much more than the usual fare. Highly recommended!
Great service, love the penne Alla vodka, chicken Cesar best around! Very clean and fast service!
Not very good, bland pizza and the chef salad was sad, sad, sad, ice burg lettuce, wishbone dressing, no egg, very bad. The garlic bread is also terrible, a hoggie roll with some prepackaged garlic and maybe oil or something. I would definitely not recommend. Luckily we have a much better pizza place near us, and will soon be back open so I never have to eat here again.
Im giving this pizzeria 2 stars because the food is good. If the food wasnt good they would get 1 star. I came in to pick up food for my job and because I was paying with a company card I asked to have the receipt itimezed and then apologized for the hassle. The man behind the counter then responded with yeah, whatever with the rudest attitude. I wont be going here again due to poor customer service.
Nothing fancy here - just great food and fast service. Heads up - If you like wings, their medium is mild at most other places and the hot is actually medium. Whatever the heat, theyre still tasty.
The pizza was very good, much much better than I was expecting. The staff was very friendly, filled my order quickly and even had hand sanitizer available for customers. Ill definitely be back again.
Best pizza I have had in the area. The meatball pie is by far my favorite! I havent had anything bad from here ever. They are my go to pizza place no matter what. If youre looking for a good pie, give them a try!
My friends took my fiance and I here for the first time today it was amazing! They had a bunch of different pizzas to choose from and they do pizza by the slice. I give the pizza an A++. Definitely go here if you want some great pizza
I have been to many pizzerias in my life time. Peasanos is by far the best. The closest to NYC pizza that you can get in upstate NY. They also have so much other great Italian specialty dishes.
Great food more than just pizza and very friendly and polite staff and surroundings
Absolutely delicious food ...love that they deliver ... its weird that I can order the same thing 2 nights of the week but pay different prices each time though....over all exspeirience is good....clean well kept and friendly....
My favorite pizza joint!!! If your looking for a quick slice or a full dinner this is the place. Ive never had a bad experience with the food or the staff. This is a busy little pizza parlor but the staff is always friendly and efficient.
I love the pizza at Paesanos Pizzeria. The people are friendly and good people.
If you love salt then this is a great pizza if you dont love salt Dont go near it loaded with salt
Great food! We order from there often. Always good, never an issue.
Best pizza place in town, been eating here since they opened years ago. They staff are very kind and courteous, and then food is always awesome.
This is a Sullivan County treat. The pizza is great. Very nice sauce. The price is right and they arent cheap with the toppings. Worth the stop.
Hands down the best pizzeria in Sullivan County. Awesome staff. The wings are soooo good. Id give them an extra star if possible for encouraging people to recycle.
I came here with some friends and was pleased by the service we received. They were very reasonably priced and the food tasted great! I would definitely recommend this place if your in the area.
Great food. No food poisoning, Ive been eating here for years.
Great Selection of Pizza to choose from. Always fresh and speedy delivery. If youre in the area, certainly stop by to see the large selection of specialty pies. Great sandwiches & salads too!
Hands down best pizza in Sullivan County and I have had this opinion for at least 10 years if not longer. Great prices. I will always recommend this place!
Ordered a delivery, they delivered it 35 minutes late, and it might have been better if they never came at all. I shouldnt feel like I sacrificed something after eating a piece of pizza. A pizza without sauce is lost, and there is no finding redemptionthis pizza. I was, however, impressed with their unique ability to both char and undercook the pizza simultaneously, the crust was the textural equivalent of cardboard that had been sitting in water for hours. The sauce was somehow thinner than water and it looked as though they just used red watercolor paint instead of actual tomatoes. I will NEVER be ordering this pizza again.
Great old style pizza place. Always great food, great service and reasonable prices.
This place has the Best Pizza and Wings! Hot Heroes to die for! Entrees too. You NEED eat here ALWAYS! Great staff. Clean place. Nice remodel.
I was impressedThe Garlic Knots were really good even though they shorted me on the quantity I ordered
Rich authentic Italian American atmosphere and a gem to the heart of the catskills!! Fast and friendly service!! Portions are well becoming of the pricing which is not overwhelming
Quaint and delicious. Best New York style pizza in the area for a decent price
Excellent pizza. Always great food from there
By far Sullivan Countys best NY style pizza, superb hospitality, a great find, located in the Catskill Mountains in the charming town of Liberty NY.Great Pizza, Great Menu, Great Food, Great Hospitality, Highly Recommend
Great pizza,heros,etc been eating there for years. Lance and Kurt are great always saying hello to everyone who walks in. By far the best pizza around.
Best pizza in Sullivan county!!!! No competition and the staff is always helpful and treat u like family. My favorite place for take out
Legit pizza. Wings good and appreciate the blue cheese. Thanks!
Best pizza in Sullivan county, possibly beyond! Outstanding quality pie can be found here, so give them a try.
It was a great pizzeria. I really liked the service, & they were really nice. The pizza was good.
Most disgusting food I have ever tasted from any pizzeria, the food taste like burnt plastic. I ordered from this pizzeria before and food never taste like this until today. I definitely would never eat from here again.
Your food is very delicious and very great delivering food and the prices are not too high and you are cheaper than anyone else is in liberty
Great people. Kind and courteous. Food is off the chain. My #1 go to food place. LOVE the fettuccine alfredo and the fat sandwich
Pizza sucks. They dont cook the pizza all the way, they use cheap sauce to maximize profit. They tell you your pizza will be ready in 20mins when it they takes an hour, and its still under cooked.
Great Pizza friendly staff
Excellent great prices fast service plenty of seating, comfortable atmosphere and best of all the food is great. Highly recommended.
Best pizza in Sullivan County.
This place is awesome. Their smallest pizza is a 16. Got the works and it is the Bomb! Friendly staff!
Paisanos is a great restaurant and the guys are very good and what they do youre very polite to customers the food is also very very good
The staff was very friendly, and the pizza was very good! Generous portions and reasonable prices.
OMG Its great. The people are great the atmosphere is great and the food is great. If you are looking to meet up with friends and eat in Liberty. THIS IS THE PLACE TO DO IT.
This is a gem of a pizza place. Some of the best pizza you’ll ever have and fantastic, delicious garlic knots.
HANDS DOWN THE BEST !!Just like NY style pizza
Best food around. Definitely get your money worth with amount of food they give you!
Been going here for over a decade. Pizza is consistently fantastic, plenty of variety, and I always get exactly what I ask for.
Its the best pizza and Garlic knots around. If your looking for an awesome pizza then you have to go here.
Their food is amazing. The owners are super friendly. The menu has so much to offer.
Always great pizza when Im away from NYC . Made fresh and the staff is always friendly!
This is the best pizza place in upstate New York imo. The pizza is great quality for great prices!(looking at you liberty Pizza hut 🙄)
The food is great but the delivery sucks, they dont pick up the phone slot of the times.
They always make it fresh and perfect. Tonights Roast Beef Sammie was so good guys. Thank you!!
Good atmosphere and very friendly service my son loves this place, I didnt feel well that day and only got water but will go back
Food is awesome. Go there Go get some
Great food, reasonable prices. The loaded chicken salad is fantastic.
Best place I have ever visited. Excelent pizzas and sandwiches. The best cheesesteak in liberty NY
Best pizza in town
Friendly service and good selection. Sicilian pie w meatballs and onions was our dinner very good
Im not a huge pizza guy, but there pies are good, and they have a lot of other options that arent pizza. The staff is friendly and professional.
Pizza and sandwiches are absolutely delicious! Does not disappoint with customer service either!
I enjoy their pizza very much, wings as well. Service and delivery is fast and pleasant.
Great pizza pasta dishes salads hot and cold heros. Delivery service always busy around lunch
Paesanos Pizzeria makes the best pizza and Italian food hands down. Try it you will be hooked just like everyone else is.
Great Pizza, Friendly and fast service. Great dinning.
They have really great subs for a fairly decent price the sub is worth the money though any day of the week
Paesanos is one of the best pizza places around I usually have the ZD and its the best pizza is very good and the people there are really wonderful that work
The chicken marsala Pizza was delicious! The place is clean, staff is super friendly, all around great experience!
The pizza is the best around!!! Great prices. Worth the drive from anywhere
The best taco pizza ever in a fantastic atmosphere its a must go place
Best pizza in the area not greasy fast service great selection
The food was excellent and more then enough in each serving. Price was good.
Amazing and a lot of food served very big meals and friendly owners thanks had a good time
This is my favorite pizza place in Liberty. The other interns and I come once every couple of weeks. Ill certainly miss it at the end of the summer.
Great pizza!Pretty much best in town.
Delicious food, speedy service and an array of different specialty pizza
Tasty pizza, nice atmosphere, friendly staff!
Best all-around pizza in the Liberty area. Steakout is a close second!
Great choice of selections Pizza is done very well ....Great Service.
Great food!
If you are in Liberty, then this is the place to go for pizza.
Excelente services AND 🍕 ummmm yummi GB all the workers🙏👍 👌
The food is great and the prices as well. Staff are pros. Stop in!
Every time I go their I have great food
Very good bbq chicken pizza. Also alot of other varieties
Always good choices and nice employees.
Great place for pizza!! The best in town!!
The best pizza I ever had!!!
Very friendly staff,great location,and food is always amazing😃👍💯
Best pizza in town...only wish they delivered to Foxcroft!
Very good food reasonably priced
We love it thats the only place we go for pizza.
Awsome place!!!!excellent chicken bacon ranch pizza
Great prices, great pizza!
Great food place to chill and eat!! A little pricey
Excellent food and prices. Pizza that rivals Bergen County.
Great place to eat. Grilled chicken salad is awesome.
Workers & customers not wearing masks, but good pizza
Great service and people even though they are Giants fans!
Great food and always friendly.
Decent pizza for the area. I have gone back.
Yummy Pizza and great service. Be back tomorrow.
Great food prices are good too
Love the food and great service with friendly staff!!
Best Lasagna ive had! & in from Green Bay Wi. Its worth the stop!!!
Great staff working there and great food!
We love the people that works there and the food.
Always good food, always friendly service.
Theyre pizza is the best in town!
The Best Pizza in a 50 mile radius.
By far best pizza around with decent prices
Best pizza in my small area
Best specialty slices anywhere!!
Great prices and good food
Best pizza place around Sullivan county
Best pizza, hands down in the county!
Awesome service and people. Food is great.
Good pizza and quick service.
Great food, always!
Great food and amazing staff
Always fast, hot, and fresh. Fantastic meatballs!
Good great for a quick bite
Great Pizza Fast friendly Service
Great food great service. Great prices
The food is always fresh and delishes
Local favorite. Staff is great, food is great.
Great pizza and prices!
Best pizza in liberty hands down!!
Nice staff and really good food
Best pizza in the county. 🍕
I love this place...always friendly...great service.
Its the best in town its just amazing🍕👍
Best pizza in Sullivan county!
Great pizza best gyro ever
Garlic nots very tasty
T bff e pizza great and every time in liberty
Good pizza. Good prices.
Always fresh and fast friendly service!
Best pizza in Sullivan County
Great food great prices
Very goog pizza. IMO the best in Liberty.
Very good meal 😋👌😍
Great food and great service!!
Food was banging first time ate there
Great food and great service
Good food
Good food and nice staff 👍
The food was good and good service.
Good food great service
The best pizza in the town!
Best pizza on the planet Earth
Its always good here.
Best pizza shop in Liberty...
Great food and pizza
Great food and service
They have every pizza.
Good people good food
Great food great service
Love the pizza
The best pizza in Liberty!
Best slice in town
Always amazing pizza
This pizza was bad news bears
Great service and food
Love it
Total reviews rating 4.6
199 Reviews for Paesanos Pizzeria 2023:
Review №1
2022-04-19Usually I get delivery but for one person it may be a bit expensive ($10-20). I ordered a specialty garlic pizza with chicken Caesar salad. The crust is soft, not soggy and ready to fold. The sauce is sweet while the cheese melts perfectly as to not make a chewy crust. Secretly I ate a whole small pizza in one sitting so it must have been to die for!!! I was super impressed with the house made dressing, shaved parmesan and grilled chicken in my salad. If you decide to take out, the cost is a bit less. I always order two slices of pepperoni to go for a mere $6. The Gambinos are hams and definitely on point. I would go out of my way to visit. I am looking forward to trying more options on the menu. As far as I know, this is the local favorite. I would approve. You are definitely missing out if you havent tried Paesanos.
Review №2
2022-07-09They make up the prices on the phone and add a lot to it. Then when you say Um can you repeat that please 22 for a small is double the menu I picked up today, they get scared and change it. Other than scamming the pizza is awesome. Similar to brooklyn and a cute convenient place for new york pizza!
Review №3
2022-06-13Delicious pizza here. I got 1 pepperoni and 1 buffalo chicken and both were fantastic. I would definitely go back here again.
Review №4
2022-01-31I had just finished working after being in the cold all day. Stopped to get some pizza. Got the pepperoni roll and a corner piece of their square pie (not the Sicilian itself but the other one,which idk the name).Corner slice was amazing. Right amount of basil with fresh mozzarella. What struck me as a former pizza maker was the pepperoni rolls. As rolls sit on the display case they tend to lose their initial 3d shape. These rolls had their original shape and were fresh- fresh. Ill stop back anytime Im down there
Review №5
2022-03-21Great food, everything was delicious and was delivered no later than when they said. Only thing is the menu shown on Google shows inaccurate prices. Go to their Facebook page or yelp for photos of their menu and actual prices, which are still decent for what you get.
Review №6
2022-04-15Great place for quick bite for family out
Review №7
2022-03-01Good food and prompt services. The fried ravioli and pizza is really good, better than other pizzerias in Liberty.
Review №8
2021-09-17Best Pizza n Ny hand down matter of fact everything Ive had here is BUSSIN
Review №9
2022-06-02Great pizza, great customer service, favorite place to dine in...
Review №10
2022-05-07Good (not great) 4/5 star pizza minus one star since it was the most expensive ($28) pizza I ever bought (large, 1 topping).