Delivery
Yes
Pams Ice Cream Shop in East Islip
Categories
Location on the map
East Islip, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
In-store shopping
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Great dessert
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Planning
Quick visit
Yes
Phone: +1 631-581-9345
Opening hours
- Monday:9AM–9:30PM
- Tuesday:12–9:30PM
- Wednesday:12–9:30PM
- Thursday:12–9:30PM
- Friday:12–9:30PM
- Saturday:11AM–9:30PM
- Sunday:11AM–9:30PM
Comments (98)
Nothing says Hometown like Pams Ice Cream. Ive been going there since I was a kid and now I bring my kids there weekly. Absolutely great ice cream, ice cream cakes, ice cream pies, etc.
Very good icecream. Im a huge icecream loverAnd for years I thought carvel was the best.They serve a high quality soft serve andHard icecream. They make all there icecreamFresh in house including the hard flavors.They are family owned and ran. There prices areConsiderably lower than most icecream shops,And Tuesday is buy one get one free sundays.
Great place. Really good homemade ice cream with a good variety of flavors and some surprises as well. I like their buried treasure and my wife enjoys the marble crunch. This is a place youll want to bookmark for future visits. The parking is easy access and directly in front of the shop.
This is a great mom and pop over cream shop. They offer unique flavors. They are one of the few ice cream shops to offer butterscotch topping.
Pamela and her ice cream place is a staple of m childhood. When used to go there back then I would always get the raw beef icecream on a waffle cone. They make the icecream themselves and use really high quality meat. The beef chunks in the icecream are so tender and juicy. Im thinking you should try this place out once . Also the egg salad on a cone is good too.
Love this place. Soft serve Sundays with a great selection of toppings. Cakes. Cones. Cups. Lowfat and sugar free options
I LOVE Pams Ice Cream!!! It is always perfect hits the ice cream spot no matter what you want! I go for the pre made quarts in the freezer. The burried treasure is the best and where else can you get a quart of homemade ice cream from $5.80?!?
This place is definitely worth a visit for ice cream. Unique flavors and amazing quality ice cream. We return twice= and the staff were great
The best ice cream spot in East Islip. Tuesday night is the famous buy one Sundae get on free. They have both soft served like carvel and excellent hard ice cream.
Nice ice cream parlor....had lemon sherbert, never had it before.... delicious !.... definitely going back
I have been going to Pams for close to 20 years now. I prefer to patronize small businesses in any case, but Pams gets my business because the ice cream is incredible. You might wonder how an ice cream shop has a line out the door on a tuesday in january.....yep its THAT good. The cakes are totally reasonable...especially since they are fresh made to whatever combination YOU want.....beats any of the chains all day long. Creamy ice cream, the kids behind the counter are on the ball, just a great ice cream shop. Oh yea....try Pams version of the flying saucers...youll want to bring one to carvel and ask why they cant make em like this!
From my 8 year daughter (a huge ice cream fan), “Fresh, amazing, and homemade! It is the best ice cream place I’ve ever been too!”
We really enjoyed the Tuesday buy one get one free Sundays...Great value...Freshly prepared ice cream
Excellent ice creamYou cant beat homemadeExcellent customer servicePam has a new customer now
Great staff! Wonderful Ice cream, theyre very accommodating! Support your local shops!
Nothing fancy. Just incredible homemade ice cream and friendly service.
Great ice cream. Great service. My son loves going to go there. Great prices and great special d
The ice cream was amazing...and it was quite affordable. The flavors we tried were so yummy...blows coyles and all the other places away!
When here for the first time and got some really good ice cream, recommended place
Great local hole in the wall for homemade ice cream!
Best ice cream, great service. Theyve been a staple in East Islip for years.
I have been going here for years- it is the BEST. Cant beat the Tuesday 2 for 1 sundaes
Love coming here! Best ice cream around! So lucky to have around the corner!
Best ice cream!! Great people!! Tuesday is BOGO! Yummmmmy
Great ice cream here. Best ice cream in town!
Great homemade ice cream, just wish they had seating.
Great ice cream from a mom and pop shop. While other places have a larger selection, the staff is alway very friendly.
Two for one sundae Tuesdays are my favorite time to go, plus I’m supporting a small business
The best ice cream anywhere! We love Pam’s.
The ice cream is melted they do not have ice cream only cakes
Best place to enjoy ice cream , great taste with economic price.
Best ice cream on Long Island
We come from Queens NY to here to enjoy these delicious ice cream. we recommend it !!!.... muy ricos!!
Very good ice cream, friendly staff.
Best tasting ice cream around at amazing prices
Always friendly and they switch up the flavors, great price, great treat, a must try!
Pams is the best ice cream I will literally drive across the island to get Pams
All ice cream is home made. Go there on Tuesdays for the special!
Best homemade ice cream cakes in town
Very good service
You can enjoy lots of flavor of ice-cream.
Amazing homemade ice cream. Love it!!
Best homemade ice cream ..unique flavors!!
Best tasting ice cream friendly service
I have been going here forever. It is the best. Best service..quality..price (esp. Tuesday).
Best ice cream around.
GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE. GREAT HOME MADE ICE CREAM. NICE PEOPLE.
Its really good
Good icecream carvel is better
This is our Familys favorite ice cream spot!
Unbelievable on a mission from God found my destiny this is the best puts all others to shame great
Ive been coming to pams since I was a child and I love it soooo much!!!
Best ice cream shop anywhere!
Best icecream around
Best ice cream on Long Island!
Best soft serve ice cream
Classic ice cream shop. Avg priced
Best ice cream around
Delicious 👍🏼👍🏼
Why do i love this place? Because its Pams.
Thank you Pam youre great 👍
This the best ice scream shop .period!
Best icecream cakes...
PAMS IS WHERE ITS AT!!!!!
Great home icecream
Such a cute hole in the wall !
Two for Tuesday on sundaes
Love there Ice Cream!
Chocolate Overload is quite good!
Always the best 2fer Tuesday
Iconic landmark.
Good ice cream.
Been going there for 15years
Delicious ice cream !!!
This place is pretty neat
Love it so much
Great flavors
I love this place!
Great service!
Delicious
Ice cream!
2 for tuesdays!
Family owned
Amazing service
Great place
The best of the best
Best ice cream place!
I live in Brentwood and I boy 3 or 4 days a week with my wife and my children we love the ice creams there is a lot of variety they are healthy they also have sugar free very delicious and the prices are very reasonable for sure. I recommend them to all
Total reviews rating 4.8
98 Reviews for Pams Ice Cream Shop 2023:
Review №1
2021-07-31Always Amazing Ice Cream, since I was a Little Girl. Love Their Dole Whip & Coconut Chocolate Chip Ice Cream. And they have Two for Tuesdays buy on get one free Sundays :)A Repeat Customer ♡
Review №2
2022-07-05I really like their ice cream, but they messed up my order, I asked for a small with mint chocolate chip ice cream, the guy then asked me if I wanted any toppings and I said cookie dough, and he gave me cookie dough ice cream.. I didnt want that I want mint chocolate with cooking dough toppings, now I have less mint ice cream :/
Review №3
2021-10-21Pam’s Ice Cream is an absolute favorite of ours. Their ice cream is always the best, and no other store compares. The ice cream cakes are better than we could ask for and made exactly as we ask. We are so glad this gem of a store is there and Pam is the nicest lady. We always look forward yo our next visit!
Review №4
2021-11-02I love this place. Ive been here a few times now throughout the year and have to say its consistently good. I have tried a couple of other ice cream shops in the area and Pams is the only one I keep coming back to. They have a great selection of flavors and most importantly no aftertaste.
Review №5
2022-05-18Best ice-cream ever!! Shhh...dont tell anyone
Review №6
2022-02-19Best Ice cream in town
Review №7
2021-07-31Ice cream was decent. Coconut chocolate chip had zero coconut flavor. Pretty much just vanilla. Had 3 scoops, 3 different flavors. 1st 2 scoops were good sizes, but the last one was about the size of 2 tablespoons. I made a comment about it and the cashier just gave a blank stare.
Review №8
2021-06-26This used to be my favorite ice cream shop. They loved when I came in twice a week spending $30At a time. I just got here at 945. Looking to buy a quart and they refused to let me in. Big boss man just sat in the back while his employees were acting rude. Im telling you no one spends more a week than anyone. Thanks for nothing.
Review №9
2021-07-09Best place I have ever had ice cream (banana with oreos and hot fudge being my absolute fave)!Im slightly biased but you dont work there for 8+ years if the ice cream aint good!! 💙Miss you Pam!
Review №10
2019-11-08Went here for the first time the other day and I didnt regret it at all! A small ice cream that has better ice cream than it looks! And the amount of ice cream you get in a $5 sundae is great! They have so many flavors to choose from and so many other options! Give this place a visit! Friendly employees too!