Delivery
Yes
Peters Diner in Amityville
Categories
Location on the map
Amityville, Suffolk County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Mask required
Yes
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Great coffee
Yes
Great dessert
Yes
Great tea selection
Yes
Sport
Yes
Popular for
Breakfast
Yes
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Healthy options
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Spirits
Yes
Vegetarian options
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Breakfast
Yes
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
Groups
Yes
LGBTQ+ friendly
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Transgender safe space
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 631-693-9003
Site: http://www.petersdinerny.com/
Site: http://www.petersdinerny.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:7AM–9PM
- Tuesday:7AM–9PM
- Wednesday:7AM–9PM
- Thursday:7AM–9PM
- Friday:7AM–9PM
- Saturday:7AM–9PM
- Sunday:7AM–8PM
Peters Diner in other cities:
Comments (199)
Good food, great service!
Always great food with tremendous service!!!
Breakfast was ok. My family and I decided that we wanted a better breakfast than IHOP and was told about Peters diner. The staff is friendly and the service is quick but the food was just- ok. I asked for my home fries to be prepared crisp but they werent and my omlette was not tasty. My hubby asked for his waffles to be made soft and they were prepared crisp twice! The pork sausages were very good. I really wish it was better maybe this was a bad day for them...on the other hand, because of there good customer service- I will return.
The food is good for a diner. I didnt like the attire of the waitresses. They were made to wear short black skirts with tights. Its my opinion. I would suggest wearing black slacks. Another thing is the home fries were bland.
The food, service and hospitality are great 👍 👌 😀. Covid-19 regulations are followed with plexiglass partitions and the customers arent piled up on top of each other. Definitely get enough food 😋 for your belly and money 💰. Great place for the family or on a date. Very clean also. 😋😋😋😋😋
The food was fresh and delicious. First time back there in a while andI wasnt disappointed. Highly recommend. I definitely will b back.
Great food, great service
Been coming here and bringing friends & family for years when they ask wheres a good place to go around here for breakfast? Food is always great, staff is friendly, the waitresses even remember us when its been years between visits!
Its an excellent family oriented dinner place, managed by its owner, with very good prices, the food is done according with your own taste, for instance I like the home fries fried, not sagged and with more onions on it, but they have to be fried, crunchy, so they always do it my way... and if you have any complaint you just talk to Pete, most of the time he is there... I hope you enjoy your visit, like my wife and I have done for years, most of the time on Sundays after Mass...
Excellent service and perfect diner fare!
Always a great place to eat. Wonderful management and staff. First class service. Delicious food service.
If you live in or around down town Amityville you should know and go to Peters Diner lso referred to as the Bay Village Diner n I believe its historical past. Its an impeccably clean dining room. Weve (my wife & I) ate there several times now and weve never had a problem or complaint. The service is very polite and professional, the food excellent. I always make sure to try something different every time we go. This neighborhood diner has been around for decades and no wonder why, its a well run diner/restaurant. When youre in the Amityville downtown area make sure to stop in for a bite there, youll really enjoy it.
Very good food. Great service.
Always great service with cheap but high quality food.
The food was so gd. My man and I enjoyed it here so much. Fast and friendly.
It was ok my beef hash could have been cooked a little bit more the same for the home fries. They both needed a crust. Coffee was good and my egg white where nice and fluffy. As for the atmosphere small town American feel. A good place to come once in awhile
Good food good prices the gentleman that runs the place is very nice clean efficient delicious
This diner is worth traveling to. The food is amazing, the wait staff super friendly.
The food and service was great! Very clean which is always a plus!
Delicious! Stopped here for breakfast after a visit with family in Copiague and was thrilled to find grits on the menu - in New York! And they were tasty! As a Texan on vacation up north, it was a yummy taste of home. Friendly staff, quick service, great food. Loved it.
They make the BEST FLAN in the world !!! For you who dont know its a dessert. A custard with caramel sauce 👍. I highly recommend u try it !
Great prices, staff, and food. Never been dissatisfied yet. They do need better brands of salad dressings and fresher dessert selection. I never order the desert because they dont appeal to me. Im a visual person so I look for it to attract me.
Delicious food and great service
We ordered a BLT and a panini. The BLT was great. I had no idea what the other sandwich was. It was NOT a panini. I wish I had taken a picture of it.
I always order off Uber and door dash the best breakfast food the price is just right but I think it would be nicer if you guys had breakfast specials like some of the other places
I’ve done take out from Pete’s Diner twice, yesterday and this evening and I honestly was blown away with both dinners and that goes for my wife and two boys. We can’t wait to sit down and eat there for dinner. Excellent food, great service at reasonable prices.
I love going to Peters ! small but plenty of seating. Friendly staff. Quick service. Clean and decorated for every holiday. Oh yeah, the food is delicious. Very cozy and very comfortable.
I love this diner! Its family owned and they welcome us every time we visit NY. The food is great, the staff is very friendly and the service is quick. They even have cheese grits!
The food is always well prepared and yummy, employees gives fantastic customer service. I like the cleanliness and mood. Will come back again.
Ordered a cheeseburger deluxe medium-rare pickles no coleslaw. chocolate shake.Chocolate shake cost $4.95 was in a coffee cup. This was a takeout order. It was actually a half full coffee cup. My cheeseburger came very very well done. And to top it off there was coleslaw on all my food. I hadnt been there at Peters for about ten years ,I wasnt happy with their food then. Guess Ill wait another 10.
Ill give it another try, but Ill lower my expectations now. While the service was great the food in taste was sub-par. On top of that what the fish and chips I got was hardly worth the price even with the soup which was luke-warm. $13.50 for one piece of fish and a hand full of fries.
Competitive prices compared to other local LI diners, very friendly and good food. Not the best diner food, but good enough to frequent each Sunday morning.
I love this place. It is cozy and I have not gotten anything that doesnt taste good. As diners go, this place is excellent.Not a late night place to go, but nice to have around if youre in the area during the daytime.
Ive been a fan for decades, even when they closed then reopened. Easygoing atmosphere, clean, delicious food, and a sweet wait staff. I highly recommend. Try their egg whites with bacon ... so gooood!
The chocolate mousse cheesecake my wife had was amazing. My apple pie however left something to be desired. Great and friendly service though. We will definitely be back!
Very good service with friendly staff and pretty decent food. Go there just about every weekend.
We enjoyed the wonderful and more than enough for two people picnic set yesterday. It included exactly everything as it was described in a perfect and delicious quality. the shop itself and the staff are wonderful and happy to help. We will come back.
Great food, my family loves it here
Ive been coming to this place all my life! Its always been a nice family orientated place to go! Food is always good and hot when it gets to your table.
We stooped by Peters in our way home to Connecticut and we had a GREAT breakfast. We had a perfect western omelette and delicious corn beef hash and eggs. We like our homefries burnt and we have a hard time finding places to do it and they did that here for us. We smoat at the counter and the staff there was so awesome. From the Host to our sweet Server they were all friendly and talkative and made our visit fun! If you are nearby you need to go here!
This was my secind visit. First time the chicken and waffles were outtatanding so I ordered it again. Was very disappointed with the food. The waffle waa notncrisoy, the fried chicken had no taste and the syrup was awful. Soublt I will go back and if I do go back, I will try something else
Food was ok couldve been hotter, like the fact there practicing social distancing although I did see one gentleman walk in with his family and he did have a mask on and his family did, and no one management or staff said anything to him. Overall everything was ok.
Great cozy atmosphere, server was friendly and host (owner) was inviting. Breakfast was delicious, fast and hot! Very nice place.
Excellent food and service. The staff were extremely hospitable and made me feel welcomed
Great local diner, I go there mostly for breakfast but lunch was great aswell, service is always top notch and like I said very local type diner no fancy decor etc. But I prefer that local vibe
Such a pleasant environment. Yummy food and desserts and the staff is well mannered and friendly! Hard to find all these things in one place! Thank you Peter!
This is the local community Diner. I have been going here since I was a little girl. The staff is always friendly.. coffee always hot ... and food always inexpensive and good. You cant stop in with out seeing someone you know from Amityville. Breakfast is my favorite.
Consistent, reliable Greek diner. Easily the cleanest one Ive ever been to. Immaculately clean, and thats important. Food is always fresh and flavorful.
Food is delicious and the staff is terrific
I visit Petes diner often the food is always good the staff are usually friendly and the service is great. The prices are reasonable and you get a lot of food for what you pay for I would recommend eating at this restaurant
Great food. Great staff. Close to my house
Never a bad meal.!! What you expect from a diner ! Friendly courteous staff. Im there twice a week at least. Gus always greets w a smile and my newspaper.
Great service. Great food. Definitely will not hungry. Sooo good
Watery mashed potatoes. Meatloaf bland. Lamb was over cooked. Usually love diners. Seemed neighborhood friendly.
You look very nice Diner. Everything looks nice and clean the staff was great. The food was excellent.
Pretty good food; great pancakes, decent omelletes. Bacon can be a little dry, but thats something most restaurants and diners suffer from now and then.
Love going to this Diner. Its a family owned restaurant, your hosts are the owners. All staff are very polite, nice and clean all around and service is fast.
Lovely food and lovely staff!
Not the best diner around but still really good. Great staff, but has a tendency to get real crowded some weekend mornings, but thats part for the course with LI diners. Great omelettes and burgers.
Very good food and the staff is great!
Great lil place. Friendly staff, clean searving non greasy food. Delicious. Reasonably priced, large menu item selections.
I have been a few times for breakfast. It is all that a diner should be, and here the wait staff are friendly. Food is good, diners are not haute cuisine, just ample stapl e food at a good price.
Great place and great food! Has been open for years and is each time
No nod to the murders. But, they made up for the oversight with their patty melt just being so damn delicious.
My breakfast was very tasty! Omelette was cooked exactly the way I like it. I was from out of town so probably my one and only experience
Nothing fancy here, but if you want a good meal at a good price i would recommend this place. we had a very good waiter and left feeling good
Service and food was great
Theres no other place as friendly, clean & delicious fresh food.
I ordered the Greek omelette and it was delicious. The staff is wonderful and attentive. My husband and I love going to Petes diner!!
Been going to Peter’s Diner since I was born. Great pancakes and breakfast in general.
Great food, nice prices, excellent service!
Ordered delivery and they gave me runny, undercooked eggs on top of burnt pancakes. Beware.
Had a short stack of pancakes with scrambled eggsThe butter was rock solid and could not melt. Hate when that happens
One of our favorite places for friendly service, good food and fair prices. Warm friendly atmosphere always.
Tasty, nice sized portion. Great service plus easy parking and fast seating. Couldnt ask for more.
I went to this place and I ordered stake and it smelled really bad and I put a complain and they didn’t do anything. When we wanted to leave we asked for a box and no one listened to us. Service is very poor. And before you eat make sure you check your food.
Get the best customer service here... waitress was awesome. Covid safety is top notch here
Nice staff and great food!
Great food reasonable prices and friendly staff.
Service slow, didnt get what we asked for chicken way over cook and laying around
Nice place. Good food with quick and friendly service.
Very busy today had to wait 20mins for my order, waitress was throwing items on the table rushing .plus when we did receive our meal her side palm and fingers was touching my toast. Yukkk
Food is great and the staff is amazing
Owners are so nice and treat the kids like they are their own. Food always delicious and wait staff is so friendly.
Ive been coming here for years.Wonderful staff and excellent food.
The food and service are always great, and the prices are reasonable. One of our favorite places to go to eat.
Good Food and Super Nice Staff !!!Shout Out To Maureen Who Goes Above And Beyond !!!
Great environment nice people good service yummy food
The food was delicious and the service was friendly and efficient.
Great food! Staff nice clean cozy just love it there!
My favorite local diner. Peters has the best Chicken Souvlaki Platter. Its one of my comfort food meals.
The food and service has changed from when I started going here 8 yrs ago. I particularly dont enjoy going here as much.
Great food and clean establishment. They don not rush you out the door.I will always go back there when Im in the area.
Great, cozy and clean with good ambiance diner. The food is excellent. Staff and the owner are friendly.
Great service. Pleasant workers. I come for the grits when I dont feel like making them at home. Never had a bad experience.
Best breakfast I have ever had. Biggest plate of food! Service is phenomenal!
Great service and food very clean but a little small for a LI diner
Xmas decorations are nice to see...food was typical diner and the service was good.
Nice little family owned Diner right near the Amityville train station thats been around for years , with plenty of parking and a large variety of delicious meals.
Good food and great service
Had the Reuben, it was delicious! Almost as good as Carnegie Deli (now closed) in Manhattan.
Happy place to visit. Sometimes there is a little waiting on a line. But thats because people want to be there. Good service and good food.
Very good food. Fair prices. Good service.
Cozy little spot. Good service, standard diner fair. Price was reasonable.Good diner.
Love this place, my Mom Loves it even more!! Great food and very inexpensive..
Peter is amazing and so is his diner! Best food in Amityville and always a friendly face too! A+!
Great tasting dishes, wich you can taste fresh ingredients
Very friendly environment! Ive gone there for years and have had the same best results every single time it never gets old.
Great prices & food! Never disappointed
Service was good ... I had a turkey burger to go .... It was good help was polite.. Courteous... I will go back
Great place I eat there all the time great food and great service
The best dinner food and great friendly service
Price is high, $4.75 , for one egg bowl of grits , $.50 for extra small package of honey.wow how things have changed.
Peters diner is tthe best everyone is so nice what ever you order it is coming out right he is just the best i love peters diner the best on long island ask anyone in Amityville just the best the best salads the best soups breakfast a nd lunch dinner
Amazing food and customer service, definitely stop here on your way to NYC or out!!Food fabulous
Great place and staff. Food is excellent.
Good food, lunch special have huge portions, specials could use a bit more variety.
Well I had a turkey club with swiss cheese and bacon with a baked potato with cheddar cheese and bacon. I was all good
Great environment nice people good service yummy food
Nice small dinner, good, fast & polite service with fare prices
Love the diner. Small but vet cosy and comfortable. Staff excellent
Me and my mans fav breakfast spot ! When we get back to the east coast we will have breakfast here every morning
Largest meal ever, 2 large stuffed chicken breasts, fries, veggies, soup and salad. Awesome price.
Wasnt too fond of the food. I got silver dollar pancakes and they were almost bitter
Pete and his son are so friendly and the food is always great. The wait staff is great too!
Place is a legend. Always enjoyed my meals here.
I love this place nothing like an old fashioned diner and the workers are so nice!!!
Good wholesome food, great service.
Delicious food and excellent service
Great breakfast, there own parking lot, food is always fresh! A great diner!
Good food, great service, cozy with easy parking. I will be returning.
Excellent food and joyful waitress
Great service, and the food was good. I had a Reuben that was too big to eat for one meal.
For the pricee of the food you get a whole lot of food i couldnt eat all bought the rest home
Very pleasant good food.
They have good lox and bagels it was awesome food
Cozy little Family Diner, waitresses are fantastic and the food is fabulous the only Diner in Amityville that I absolutely love
Great food and wonderful service! Love those French fries !
Great food and service. Cozy diner with plenty of tasty dishes to choose from. Sunday brunches.
Hot food tasted good, clean nice setting
I love Petes Diner! The customer service is awesome as well the food and the atmosphere.
Been going there since childhood great place respectable establishment
Good food and friendly service.
Great food and great service.
Great food, friendly people
Great restaurant friendly service 5 stars
Always get a warm greeting from Gus.Food is good and well prepared.Price is low.
Great service. Great food
Good food and portions for the price
Love this diner! The entire staff makes you feel like family here.
Clean Friendly staff. Prompt service. Great food.
Classic neighborhood diner, great breakfasts, good burgers.
Great local, service is a good but need for coordination with the customers when go in!
This is a great place to eat either by yoirself or with family or friends.
Been coming to Peters forever. You want good diner food, this is the place.
Great food friendly service
No complaints, waitress was courteous, and food came promptly
I love the ambience great food friendly staff quiet settings easy access
The food was great and the waitess was bery friendly
Great food and staff.
Good food fast, friendly service
Always a great meal with awesome staff
Good diner. Large portions. Friendly staff.
Multi chapter menu. Open all the time. Serves everything and super quick
Great place to enjoy any meal.
Great food all the time and services
Always a good to get breakfast food
Love going to Petes. Food is great, staff is great and of course Pete is great 😀
Good service, great food!
Good food, good service
Delicious clean! Support local businesses ❤
A friendly place with great food no matter when u go
Great food and huge menu
They gave me a burnt steak and messed up the kids food I wouldn’t visit again
Triple A service. Great waitresses. Great food
Its my go to breakfast place, nobody better the best home fries be sure to try the home fries
Great food and fast service !!
Foods great here. I will definitely be back
If you like cole slaw.. come here ok? Service good everything is good just come here!
Excellent food!! gyro tziki very good.
Always great food and service
Great breakfast service! The Wait service is awesome!
Good food and the place is nice
Love this place. Great coffee friendly service
Great diner fare. Very clean, nice decor.
Mr.Pete great man food price also great
Friendly staff and good food
Amityville s best. I am a been in amityville over 20 years and I can say this the best diner in amityville hands down
ITS FANTASTIC word of advice always get the fries their phenomenal
Total reviews rating 4.4
199 Reviews for Peters Diner 2023:
Review №1
2021-10-17Petes is an Amityville institution and doesnt need this review, but Im writing it anyway. I am convinced this diners kitchen is actually a portal to Narnia. There is simply no way a kitchen that small can turn a menu that big into perfect dish after perfect dish that quickly, without access to some sort of Deep Magic. The staff are all courteous and thoughtful, and if youre a regular, theyll never forget your coffee or tea preferences. Give them a visit, if you havent already. This is a local diner done truly right.
Review №2
2022-06-26Nice little spot! Everything was delicious I had a patty melt and cream of turkey soup. Gear food very clean highly recommend!
Review №3
2022-05-31Nice place but the area looks like a bad neighborhood, there food taste good but there sausage links are small & so are the eggs are too, Ive been to other diners around the area & they have a better portion thats keeps me filled up all day
Review №4
2022-05-21I love this place, Ive been going since inwas a kid with my family. Food is always great and the menu is diverse with out being overwhelming.
Review №5
2022-06-24Love the food owners and staff they treat you like family !!!
Review №6
2022-01-27SO: no huge tips, no education anymore: so sad! However, nice food.1st of all: nice place with good and variated food. The owners so nice and made us some jokes. Place called our attention on our visit in Amy and decided to enter. Good decision cause I repeat, we ate so nice with a perfect quality-price. Thing we just found (and I also work face to public) rude and impolite was the behavior from our waitress. Seemed to be a nice woman, feeling ready to make our lunch such a time to remember. That was until she checked her tip. I perfectly know how it works, but just imagining some servers give you a nice service ONLY to get more tips at the end, is just inacceptable and sad. I dont get how this could be a way to work, either your attention to customers is based on. A really shame for us, as long as we gave her $8 buck tip (JUST 2 plates). Was a nice % from the bill and the face she just turned once counted the tip -in front of us- was unbelievable. WAS NOT at all even able to say goodbye to us once leaving - at least the owner did. If that amount didnt made her happy, she better stay at home and not giving service. Tips are a subject to respect as customer is who decides. Quest is: which qty she expected to receive? $25? $40? More than the lunch? Still dunno if she had a bad day. Not forgiveable anyway. 15day stay in Nyc ANYONE gave us that type of attitude.However I insist: food was great and obviously thats not a review to not to go there and have a good time.Just be prepared if THE woman comes to you with her (initially) smile!
Review №7
2022-03-08Excellent, old but nostalgic, historical diner w a comfortable, cozy atmosphere. I love the long mural on one wall, that shows what Amityville used to look like as a seaport town.The food is definitely good homecooking, w casual and delicious meals. The employees friendly.
Review №8
2021-11-07Friendly staff. The owner was walking around making sure everyone was satisfied. Nice portions and great taste. Old school atmosphere. A place to go when you want to have comfort food and a smile from your server.
Review №9
2022-05-07Excellent food. Great location
Review №10
2021-10-10This place is the best! Everyone is so nice and its cool to hear the regulars just sit and chat and talk about life. The food is great but, my favorite part was time traveling 20 years back in atmosphere. Also, they butter your toast for you which is amazing. I love this place!