Kerbside pickup
Yes
Pick A Bagel in New York
Categories
Location on the map
New York, New York County, New York, US
Service options
No-contact delivery
Yes
Delivery
Yes
In-store pick-up
Yes
In-store shopping
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Same-day delivery
Yes
Health and safety
Mask required
Yes
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Safety dividers at checkout
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Dining options
Breakfast
Yes
Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly
Yes
Transgender safe space
Yes
Planning
Quick visit
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
NFC mobile payments
Yes
Phone: +1 212-517-6590
Site: https://pickabagel.dine.online/l...
Site: https://pickabagel.dine.online/l...
Opening hours
- Monday:6AM–7PM
- Tuesday:6AM–7PM
- Wednesday:6AM–7PM
- Thursday:6AM–7PM
- Friday:6AM–7PM
- Saturday:6AM–7PM
- Sunday:6AM–7PM
Comments (199)
Pricy muffins, I would not mind paying $3.75 for a muffin as long as they are a bit better than average. Better yet would not mind paying $6+ for an Honest Tea and over sweet sponge/muffin IF it didnt came with a rigid uninviting customer service at the cashier...seriously, if someone says hello you should at least be welcoming, say hello back not just anything else?! With such rushing tone. Not even busy to be agitated. Sucks. Maybe should have tried their bagels, maybe muffins are not their thing...IF YOU HAVE TIME, GO ELSE WHERE PEOPLE!
Expensive, the prices are a little bit for a simple coffee or a bagel. The food is bland no seasoning if any at all. The stools arent very comfortable. Only one table with two seats which usually has a homeless person sitting there at night. The display of the food is great everything LOOKS DELICIOUS. Some of the staff is friendly some are not.
Incredibly rude service from the lady at the front, bagels were expensive and not great at all. So many better options to choose from.
It was not great or the worst. That being said, there is much better bagel places to go to in the city. Would not recommend also the line can be long.
Was very good but expensive at the same time, lets see a reason bagel with veg cream cheese, a everything bagel with jalapeños cream cheese a small tea and coffee $19.00
Ok at best, the staff seemed kinda whatever on me being there and the cashier seemed in a rush to get me out the store. My main complaint is the price, $8 for a bagel and a snapple ??? Worst part was my bagel was harddd and not a toasted hard hah. It tasted good so Id be willing to give this place another chance but they gave a bad 1st impression
Perfect bagels!
Great breakfast sandwichs. Coffee was excellent quality. So good sugar was not needed
I have been coming here every Saturday and Sunday for 8 yeArs. I have accepted the grumpiness of the people behind the counter but they have never been outwardly rude to me. Today I asked the woman to please check if there was a sesame flagel again. I did this because usually they take the basket down and look closely and she had just given it a cursory look. She basically yelled at me “I said there was not and there is not.” It was not busy there were maybe 3 people in the whole store and there was no one behind me. She knows me and spoke to me that way! Imagine how they speak to other customers!!!!The bagels/flagels are not even fresh anymore and I cannot take the rudeness. There are many better bagel shops with fresh bagels within 4 blocks. I’m done with them after many years.
Horrible place, employe are so mean, delivery is never on time , delivery ppl don’t speak English , food is always messed up, Coffee spilled all around the food. No recommended
Great bagel shop, got the whole assembmy line with the personal touch down cold.. one of my observations was the regulars disperse as Ed among the line (peak time 8:30am) everyone was helpful and deliverr service with a smile. Good bagels. Great lox. Cracked out on a coffee cake as well. Sweet find for me in the area
Good selection of creme cheeses for your bagels, paninis prepped for toasting, smoked fish and vegan offerings. The staff works fast and it’s comical to see their almost “food nazi” style way of communicating. Small amount of bench and table seating. The coffee is this places only achilles heel.
$8 bagel with flavored cream cheese but no napkin in the bag? What a mess
BEWARE!!!!!!!!!!$15.74 for a bacon egg & cheese.The onion bagel was completely burntDefinitely wouldnt return to the Lexington location!
Excellent. Delicious food, courteous associates. Great food variety.
I was in town for the week for work and ended up coming here four of the five days on my way to work. Karek made my bagel the first day and every day after, he remembered me and exactly what I ordered. Such great service and so friendly (and still very fast paced)! I’d get the everything bagel with veggie cream cheese and a scrambled egg. So delicious, and so nice to be recognized even with a mask on! I definitely highly recommend this pick a bagel.
Overpriced, even for the area. Lousy service. Unremarkable morning fare.
Very good bagels and more, reference neighbourhood place for that.
The fat gray haired lady at checkout was extremely rude. I don’t know how this place stays in business with her. I was trying to checkout and she said my order didn’t exist (I got a plain bagel toasted with cream cheese). I paid and walked out waiting on my coworkers that we’re still inside. This employee then started talking bad about me to another customer! My coworkers were inside and heard the entire thing. DO NOT GO HERE! Bagels are overpriced and employees are VERY RUDE!!
Its a great place, and all though I have a soft spot for bagels, I can say confidently that these are some great, quality, no nonsense bagels, no bias. Great, energetic staff. Now dont think they stop at bagels, no way. I encourage people here to not only try the bagels. Only things is the place is small so even a very small crowd can make the place look busy. Otherwise, a nice place with a relaxing vibe.
Very overpriced, $12 for a simple ham and cheese on a roll. I get the same sandwich at a deli in my upper East side neighborhood ( Yorkville) for $4.50. No difference except for the outrageous price hike.
Had the chicken club panini, it was one of the worst sandwiches I have ever had in my life, it was a complete disappointment.
OK PLACE TO GET A QUICK BAGEL , VERY BAD COFFEE AND SERVICE OF WHO ATTENDED ME WAS NOT GOOD COULD OF DONE BETTER !
Ordered a flat everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese and received it quick. Only concern is the current price inflation. Bagel came out to $4.95 and a small Tropicana orange juice was $2.95 price came out to $9+. Its a tad bit pricey. To top it off the cashier kept repeating I dont make the prices. I dont make the prices. Your giving me bad vibes too early in the morning. I only asked the prices of my order. Cashier is a bit highly sensitive to peoples vibes. Be aware of the prices and sensitivity of the cashiers.
Great bagel 🥯 and cream cheese. A wide variety of different bagel and breakfast sandwich options. They also have smoked fish, muffins, tuna salad, Chicken salad, cookies, drinks, Coffee ☕ juices ect. I sometimes get an everything bagel toasted or plan bagel toasted with veggie cream cheese, or eggs 🥚 bacon 🥓 on a toasted roll with butter. You should check them out, they have alot of stuff
We came across this bagel shop accidentally and got an avocado and onion bagel. It was like heaven.
Mediocre at best. Ordered the sausage egg and cheese on a garlic bagel.
Bagel was hot and yummy. Lots of options and decent pricing for the upper east side. The downside was the rudeness of the food preparation staff. No order and reasoning to line formation with a simple sign of “order here.” Many workers looked to be standing around and patting down the cream cheese when the line was forming longer and longer. Cashiers were friendly. Average experience. Food recommended staff not so much.
The bagel are too thick:( so much dough but the cream cheese was AMAZING
One of the best bagels in NYC, they have a crunch you look for on the outside and the soft chewy inside. If youre a real bagel enthusiast you know a good bagel doesnt need to be toasted !!!!!(Also bomb BEC !!!!)
Winner of the World Series championship of bagels. Just kidding! Just another good bagel joint to obtain a meal.
I really wanted to like this place more and it pains me to give it 2 stars. Ive gotten an Everything Bagel + cream cheese, and it is pretty good at $4.However, it is crazily complicated and expensive to order something as simple as a Bagel + Cream Cheese + Salmon Lox + Tomatoes + Onions + Capers (a classic, right?). Heres why:- On the menu, there is a spot that lists the smoked fish and how you can get it on a sandwich or platter. It took me a couple trips here to realize that this is the option for a bagel + lox.- These smoked fish options are quite expensive. The salmon + bagel + cream cheese is already $13.50 without anything on it.- IMO, things like capers, tomatoes, onions should be included. Instead, each of those is a $0.75-1.00 upcharge, so your lox bagel is $15-16. This is closer to the price of a sit-down lunch at this point. Compare this to something like Tompkins Square Bagels, where you get a lox bagel plus all the fixings for $11 -- and you dont look like a dummy looking at the menu for 5 minutes trying to figure out where the lox bagel is. Seriously, 75% of Pick A Bagels menu was for deli sandwiches.- A positive - the people are nice, and the place takes credit cards.- If they can offer some lox bagel preset options so I dont have to verbally tell the person making the sandwich (and hope nothing gets missed in the communication like it has before), and drop the price to ~$12, I would be happy to go back more and recommend them.
Decided to treat myself to a bagel & 2 cookies for my son. Go to register, total was almost $15! Each cookie was $5. Let’s be clear - this is a neighborhood bagel shop, not a gourmet bakery. On top of the ridiculous prices, I got home & the bagel was hard & cream cheese, warm & melting (bagel not toasted.) never again.
The breakfasts are good, bagels are yummy, staff is very nice and pleasant, a tad overpriced but what you would expect on the UES. I go there just about every morning on my way to work. I go for the coffee and a bagel but return to see this one beautiful women that works the cash register. I just enjoy starting my day off by saying Good morning to her. Puts a smile on my face, not sure about hers though
We had been walking from Museum Mile and were desperate need of coffee and a place to sit. Pick a Bagel was a lifesaver location right in front of the train ;nice seating and good prices made this place a wonderful pit stop before heading back to Queens. The only thing we were bummed out about the seating area didn’t have charging outlets and the place didn’t have public restrooms. We survived we are New Yorkers and understand not every place Can have it all
Recently been coming here regularly for a black & white cookie with my partner every week as a end of the work week treat! The staff is friendly & helpful. Large selection of delicious pastries as well as a big menu of cream cheeses! Great place for a quick snack!
This establishment is very poorly ran. I went in for a simple bagel Tuesday morning. I overheard the manager arguing with the employees in the back made me feel very uncomfortable. She was wearing a grey shirt and most of the employees were watching in disgust that these co workers were doing that in front of everyone.
Only had a muffin there. Damn, was that one good. Crispy and soft, felt fresh. I dont know if anyone can make them better, maybe. But it was almost perfect. Also the bagels I saw looked very tasty.
BEST bagels in NYC. Yes, pricey - but thats NYC and they have to stay in business. Re: service - this is a NEW YORK CITY bakery. If you want to be small-talked and coddled, go somewhere else. Theyll get your order right and get it into your hands as quickly as they can. The bagels are worth it. To leave one star reviews for this NYC institution in the current climate of small businesses closing down left and right is disgusting. Support your neighborhood businesses, NYC!
Without doubt the best bagels in town. And the sliced lox easily rivals Zabars and others. But don’t miss the scallion cream cheese. Or the whitefish salad. Place is just great.
I have been coming to this bagel place for the last couple of years ONLY because the bagels are delicious. However, today will be the last. 09/8/15 at 10am. It was not crowded at all today and I was looked over and skipped in the line twice by your associates. I was overcharged for a ham and swiss sandwich that was found to be ham and cheddar when I got to my destination. Not to mention, this exact same thing has happened to my order several other times. Your cashier was not helpful in explaining why a ham and cheese plain is more expensive than ham egg and cheese. A three dollar difference seems quite dramatic. I was spoken to rudely and your sandwich maker and cashier had a whispered conversation about my order before handing it over to me. Unprofessional. I will not risk another insulting experience at your venue again.
High prices. $12 for a sandwich:-O I noticed it after we placed the order:-(. But it was really good, nice and fresh! The only thing is that two different sandwiches were filled different, the turkey really well packed whereas the ham and cheese really poor.
Not the BEST bagel place in the city but its really good
Ive just had one too many bad experiences at this place. My order has been incorrect nearly every time Ive gone, which Ive lived with since its still a good enough bagel to forgive. However, I just witnessed an incident in which one of the staff members dropped a bagel on the floor, picked it back up, and then tried to serve it to a customer. Fortunately they were called out on the issue and remade the bagel (after a back and forth with the customer and onlookers). But I will never forget that they tried to serve a floor bagel to someone. Oh, and my order was wrong, again.
Last time I eat here. A flat bagel with reg crm ch and small black coffee was $8. Crazy. Wasted way too much crm cheese. Bagel wasnt even hot even though it was toasted. Over this place. Never again.
They are always in a rush !! Never want to hear your order !! Always on edge !! To the point where they make change your mind about having breakfast
The most over priced bagels Ive ever ordered. $21 for a flat bagel + double turkey + pepperjack cheese + LTO and cucumbers and $10 for a flat bagel with cream cheese. I wouldnt go here again if every other restaurant in NYC was closed.
A very busy classic New York bagel shop! A wide selection of bagels, a very wide selection of toppings, additional soups and pastries as well. It always seems noisy and crowded, but you can usually find a place to sit alongside the window if you want to eat on site. Its not cheap: two bagels a cup of soup and a coke came to $25. But it’s an experience and you certainly feel like youre in New York!
Great big solid bagels for $1.1 each! They also have a good variety of cream cheese to choose. I got the walnut raisin cream cheese and it is perfect for my cinnamon raisin bagels!Will definitely come back for more bagel cravings!
Horrible service! waited politely cause it seemed like they were busy, a couple guys came in after me got in line behind me. All of the men behind the counter ignored me and when it was time to take the next customer skipped over me and went straight to the guys behind me. I made eye contact with several employees doing nothing towards the back and no apology or oh can I take your order, we’re you here first since you’re the first person in the line? There are plenty of other bagel places in nyc, went around the corner and got wonderful service.
Cant do without my Everything bagel, Lox and chive cream cheese.If I just get the Lox spread, they tend to lay it on too thick.Almost always got to tell the guy to go easy on it. Their Bagels always seem fresh, and have the right crispness to them. Ive had a few good salads here too, but cant stand the wait at lunch time.I come here a few times a week. Always a good experience.
Best breakfast you can have, there bagels are fresh. My favorite is there everything bagel. There paninis are fabulous and your make yourself salads are amazing with so many chooses to add. Definitely recommend this place for breakfast, lunch and for there many other snacks. There service is great, fast and accurate.
Good bagel selection and just the right amount of crunch with soft, chewy center. Wide choice of toppings plus cookie and muffin options. Narrow space with limited seating. Friendly staff, fast service
Any restaurant that is open 24 hours a day is automatically going to be on my good side. Especially one with bagels as good as this. Their coffee is OK, definitely passable, although Im a total coffee snob so Im deducting one star for coffee. With that being said, when its 3AM who can really tell the difference? They have excellent toppings for the bagels, including cream cheese and eggs. They also have some nice pastries. No matter if its morning, afternoon or the middle of the night, you can not go wrong with Pick a Bagel on 77th St. I especially like their flat everything bagels.
Best bagel in NYC. This location is my personal favorite but they are all great. These guys just do an exceptional job of balancing my go-to bacon avocado sandwich. The balance is crucial.
Pros: open 24 hours and right by the hospital.Cons: overpriced and average foodI have been many a times and while the food hits the spot, I have to say it’s extremely overpriced—even for nyc. Usually a line with a wait. Again though, it’s open 24 hours so at certain times of the day it’s your best option. If you don’t mind spending the dough, can give this place a try.
I asked the man twice if my bagel was actually toasted (I ordered a simple bagel toasted with cream cheese at the counter) because it was ready 30 seconds after I put the order in. He promised it was toasted. If was cold and absolutely not toasted, disappointed.
Prices on high side, but food is the best. Fresh and delicious. Low fat options. Toppings for bagels on both sides. Cakes, salads, soups are all fresh and delicious. And, the service is great.
Place is a rip off scam, i left there 5 min ago they charge you for your items, then they charge you made up tax amounts for each item. My receipt says $11.87, but she charged my card $12.34. The girl at the register has very quick hands so beware.
I came in and I liked the ambience however the employee taking the order came off as rude and uninterested, the same with the cashier. I want to like this place but the employees make it feel unwelcome. It felt as if they just had a give us your money and get out attitude, and too add onto that my bagel was stale.Would not recommend Pick a Bagel.
I like that they have options - tons of bagels and cream cheeses. The line was really confusing. I waited 10 minutes to pay, just because I wasnt sure which way to go.I got a BEC with avocado. It was really good, but it was $7. Not the cheapest, but I knew Id pay for that avocado. Also...I ordered a sesame bagel and they gave me whole wheat. It wasnt the end of the world, but for $7 they can at least give me what I ordered.I had to wait about 15 minutes for my food.The place was PACKED, but I guess thats a good thing.Its a little out of my way in the morning, but I would go back as a treat.
The bagels are okay but the prices are a bit outrageous... I understand its NYC but $10 for a bagel with egg salad, no lettuce or tomato is a bit steep. I was okay with paying over $3 for an everything bagel with plain cream cheese but thats too much...
Mediocre food and service with a 5th ave price tag. Plan on paying close to $20 for a lox bagel.
I had the unfortunate pleasure of stopping by this shop last night and quite frankly it ridiculous what I paid for a plain bagel w swiss cheese and tomato( Nothing else was on the bagel) . If your charging 12.75 for a bagel w no meat , then what the hell do you charge when it has meat. I think that they over charge assuming its the city and you can get away with it . But you cant. Enjoy the 12.75 for the crappy bagel cause you will never get my business again.
Guy who makes bagel is very unsanitary... touched another customers bagel she complained about when she entered store and handed to him. He then began to prepare mine... very concerning practices..
They make a really good cream cheese but recently when making a order they have an attitude , they burn most bagels to the point where it’s hard to bite , they either put to little cream cheese or it taste old . I loved this place but the workers seem to not care if your order comes out good or not. I wouldn’t recommend this place.
Pick A Bagel has one of the most extensive selections of bagels available and even a varied selection of spreads to complement your bagel. Add to that, a great selection of baked goods and pastries, sandwiches, foods, etc. Such a convenient place when youre looking for options, and as a Native New Yorker, Ill say that the bagels are great. For vegans, you must try the tofu vegetable spread!
Bagels and muffins are good. Egg sandwiches and other things are solid as well. My and many of my colleagues biggest issue is how cold and unfriendly the staff is- the cashiers, people taking your order. Have not had one good experience with an employee there. Many people from the hospital refuse to go here just because the staff is so rude.
Horrid prices for horrid food and service. There is many other places blocks away that have amazing service, prices and bagels. Save yourself and don’t go there, it’s pathetic
First day I bought there a bagel with two eggs and cheese, which cost me $4.50, today I got a bagel with cream cheese, which I usually buy on a place in Wall Street for $2.50. And for my surprise cost me $5.25, which doesn’t makes sense at all... mostly because the two eggs and cheese costs less...
Their prices are rising so fast that a bagel with cream cheese cost more than a slice of pizza. Also I dislike their service as they are rude and try not to help the customer at all. One of the workers try to curse me out cause I didnt say my order all at once. Smh
Can’t visit New York without trying their famous Bagels with Cream Cheese!
This Pick-A-Bagel just catered a small party for us and did a fabulous job! The food was delicious, the delivery was on time and the staff was extremely helpful in figuring out what to order.
Good, friendly service. Their bagels are fresh and soft. Conveniently located just at subway exit
I walked into the store, got a bagel with butter and jelly. I know i gave the lady who claimed she was the manager a $20 bill. She gives me back $7.30. When i tell her i gave her a twenty, she insisted i gave her $10. I explain to her I just came from the ATM across the street and i showed her the transaction. She tells me she believes me but she had to check the register at the end of the day.I Iive in Pennsylvania. I got hit for $10. I know they wont care, but i am so angry now.
My sandwich was delicious and this was my first time visiting Manhattan. However, my boyfriend’s panini was much smaller than it looked in the case once we received it AND it’s a bit pricy. I’d recommend trying it, but I bought only like 4 things and spent $30+ ...
Cinnamon raisin bagel with honey cream cheese.
Everytime i will buy a bagel here, i always get a wrong order.. i would order a bagel and scallion cream cheese and they would always give me a plain creamcheese.. sometimes not toasted and worst burned bagel which i got today!!!!! terrible service!!!!! how can you give your paying customer a burned bagel???
Yummy!!! Get the bagels and eat it in Central Park :)
I ran in for a quick breakfast...came out with the most delicious toasted cinnamon rasin bagel with honey pecan cream cheese! OMG!!!
15$ for veg tuna bagel with regular coffee, and when i got to work i realized it is real tuna :(((
Incredibly inconsistent on pickup. You may have an awesome sandwich or one completely wrong and terrible. Cant they read the seamless orders? They also never include napkins or straws. Im in a hurry dammit thats why I ordered ahead! Next thing I know Im trying to tear the plastic lid with my teeth so I can sip my drink.
I catered two dozen bagels and two pounds of vegetable cream cheese for a trip to Georgia. They froze the cream cheese as requested and had my order ready for pickup. Great job.
Loved our bagels and cream cheese. I had the poppyseed bagel with blueberry cream cheese and wife had a mutligrain bagel with strawberry creamcheese. We had a couple coffees too. Fresh, fast and delicious exactly what I was looking for. Really busy spot.
The bagel I had here was delicious and the service was good, but the prices were shockingly high! Ill be spending my carb quota in Queens rather than on the Upper East side!
Good quality bagels sandwiches and everything they sell. Very efficient
I go in everytime Im in the area. Love the employees. The guys always go out of their way to say hello and the girl at the register is busy but friendly. Muffins are out of this world, bagels are NY delicious.
If you like ordering a sesame bagel and getting 3-6 sesame seeds, this is your spot!
Your looking at a $10 dollar turkey sandwich for what. Wildly expensive
Occasionally I service a woman over here. She always waits to call until after her children are asleep, so I never get out until 1030 or 11 pm. This is the end of my shift, so by the time I get to the 77th street subway Im always exhausted.This bagel place is the light at the end of the tunnel. A toasted sesame bagel, piled high with with cream cheese- I devour it greedily as I descend the stairs and wait for the 6 train. Thats me, leaning against the pillar at the end of the platform, spent cream cheese dribbling down my chin, a universe of crumbs starring the front of my black jacket, the slack smile of a junky who just got well.
Good bagel, loaded topping. Staff were fast paced and very full on! Make sure you know your order before you get served!
We saw that theyre were giving free lunch for heathcare workers. When we get to the counter it was ONLY FOR LENOX HILL healthcare workers. My friends and I were so embarassed and left the store. Notice wasnt specific. We are also nurses though not from LHH we should also be respected as health care providers .
I had a really nice jalapeno New York bagle
Amazing service and amazing food. Some of the most considerate people i’ve ever interacted with, and on top of that, the quality of the food is outstanding.
I eat here all the time! They have the best bagels in NYC!
Typical fast food NY bagel place. Tons of choices. Regular and non dairy spread choices. Breakfast, Lunch etc. Bagels are good, not great here.
Lived two buildings down from here back in the mid-90s. To this day I still talk about this place to my friends about how delicious and huge the sandwiches are... Oh, and the desserts... Mmmm.If I ever visited NYC again that would need the first place Id visit.
Love their bagels!!!! And the cookies look delicious!!!
The worst and most expensive bagel in nyc. $8.17 for yesterday’s bagel with veg cream cheese and small coffee. Outrages!!!!!
Bagel was cold, and the prices are easily the worst Ive experienced in this neighborhood. Almost $20 for two bagels with cream cheese and a coffee and tea.
Friendly, helpful, tasty cookies
Update your hours on Google maps, i rushed to get to your store when it was supposedly opened until 7h30pm but it was closed before 7pm
I love there bagels
Busy spot right near 77th St 6 stop. Bagel was good (although cream cheese was different than what I ordered). Coffee was blech.
Fresh bagels. Lots of variety. Good prices. Love their cream cheese & lox 😘
Horrible service. I was the only customer, there were 3 servers and took them 5 min to talk to me (not really politely). And they messed up my order
Maybe this is just me being cheap. But I asked for an everything bagel cream cheese and a slice of him. I was charged almost $10 for something that shouldve cost for maybe five dollars. I should have opened the sandwich removed the ham and slapped it on the counter aand had them charge me $4.00 instead.
Pinked out
Bagels and pancakes taste great, highly recommend if youre trying to spend less than $20 in Manhattan. Actual place is a bit small.
They have pretty good bagel. I used to go there after doctor appointments.
Love the food at Pick A Bagel. Everything is so delicious . Breads, sandwiches, salads are all fresh. Good fast service.
My last time here.They charged me double for the same thing I have been taking few times before and she was trying to charge me more but I made sure she check herself$8.00for bagel with cheese and eggs?????? Never go back!!!!
Great bagel, variety of options. One of the best bagel places in the area
I love this place. They have every type of bagel and cream cheese you could want. Staff is super friendly.
OVERPRICING. I’m highly disappointed with this place. The food takes too long and the change the prices all the time. Today they charged me $9.78 for a ham, eggs, and cheese bagel!
Great assortment of sandwiches and bagels
Got a salad from here and the service was terrible. They didnt close the box and it opened up in the bag as soon as I got it. When I showed them this, this literally put the SPILLED salad into another box and tried to give it to me.
We love GG. 🤩🫶🏼💝
The toaster was broken but my bacon egg and cheese was still awesome
The two ladies by the register very unprofessional. Laughing and commenting on other pople in spanish. Poor customer skills. No greeting, no thank you, no recepit,no napkins etc. Will not recommend this place nor I will go there again.
Most expensive bakery in NY! $6.00 for a bagel!! NY has better places than this scam.
$8.60 for a bagel with cream cheese and a small coffee!? Food is good but the price is Ludacris.
Somehow managed to get the order wrong for two bagels. Overpriced. Actual bagel wasnt good.This place sucks. Do not go here.
Best bagel place
The staff is really friendly...loads of options for quick bites.i tried herb cheese cream n bagel.. which was yummy.... chocolate croissant was okay
Just ordered an everything bagel with plain cream cheese. it was very good but a lil pricey at over $4.
They put red jelly on my nova Scotia. Is this a joke?!!!!?
Great bagel spot for sure. I would walk several blocks for a bagel with everything and some turkey breast. Not sure what the low score is about but right on!
Lowered my rating. Been going here for years and my most recent visit, they served stale bagels, as they did on my last visit, a few months ago. May not try again.
One of my top 5 bagel and lox locations
The cashier told me wrong price in a third day of the same food order. When I asked if the prices went up from yesterday she answered no. So why the price is different!!!
Almost 7 bucks for an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese! Since when?!?!
Worst service Ive had in the USA. Poor value food that takes forever to prepare because the staff talk to each other without regard for the customer.
They charge extra for condiments. My tuna on rye came out to almost $12 with nothing but lettuce and pickles on it.
Wide variety of soups, bagels, pita and varied fare. Great wait staff, limited seating reasonably priced
Great bagels and sandwiches. Coffee is good too. Great variety of bagels and spreads.
Standard quality NYC bagels. Poor service and Upper East Side prices. If you have time, go elsewhere.
Great bagels! Decent sandwiches. Rude counter staff, dry muffins.
Oh yeah my experience first and last I go in there order a Roll with cream cheese and jelly I got a coffee small everything came out to $6.85 come on A ROLL with cream cheese and jelly $4.36 that’s insane more Expensive than Starbucks well just to let ya guys know
Sadly this great place is closed
Very bad…. good products, but I was served by an elderly person who did not understand anything
Tasty! Tons of different options
Expect to pay wayyyyy more than you were prepared to. Its good but notice all the comments complaining about price. Theyre out of control.
Pricey for an NYC bagel but yummy
Best muffins ever
Great variety great customer service prep the sandwiches everything you need one stop shop
Nice place with very good coffee and bagels but not much seating. Great for takeout though.
Great customer service great service great 🥯
Pastries were great, experience was fantastic until I saw a roach walk by the window frame, while I was eating...
The guy was so rude in there just now. Wasn’t paying attention and not listening to my order. He was trying to put what he wanted to put on my sandwich.
This young lady in front counter verynice anded kind. Awesome workersat the bagel shop.
Everything there is Goooood! Definitely worth checking out they are more than just bagels.
There bagels are awesome! I usually get the whole wheat everything!!
This place has some of the best bagels in nyc.
This place is open 24 Hours(except Sunday into Monday between midnight and 5am), has tasty offerings and good service.
Lots of Hot, Fresh Bagels. Efficient staff, good coffee. Very Busy.
Workers are rude. way overpriced, even for the neighborhood. bagels are horrible. would give 0 stars if possible
Cant go wrong with these bagels - I buy a dozen at a time and stick some in my freezer so I can eat them later!
Great spot! Love the lox and bagels. Grest create your own salad choices
A plain bagel for $10.29. Completely outrageous! Then had to leave to eat, as the stools and table was DISGUSTING.
Too much expensive!!! They charge me 13$ for bagel with tuna !!! Disgusting
Bagel and coffee was delicious and the service was great personnel was very friendly and courteous.
I ordered a tuna on a toasted plain bagel and a large hot coffee, total came to $14.15 😳 This is very price, I couldve gotten a meal for this price.
Nice bagel shop with a calm atmosphere, reasonable prices, and vegan options.
Pick A Bagel is a little small and tight. However, bagels are great
I always love the availability of options of bagels. This is my every Sunday bagel
Good bagels. Decent coffee. Store is very busy
Good NYC bagels. Can be overcrowded and a little chaotic, but thats part of the charm and the food is worth it.
Huge variety of delicious bagels and many toppings and pairings, as well as standalone food.
Great bagels everything I have try here taste fresh.
I could have just eaten Thanksgiving Dinner but if you put one of their bagels in front of me afterwards I’d still eat it
To expensive and when in the morning u dont have time all of them are on the phone for delivery, how about costumer that are inside, for the money thay ask their servise is horrible..... Pick a pocket!!!!
I got this while I waited for a broker and the food was fine but the service was horrible. My exact thought was I am giving you money for food why are you being so mean?
Delicious cinnamon raisin with tofu plain cream cheese. Efficient service, busy, but efficient.
Had a pumpernickel bagel w smoked salmon spread. Delicious.
Very fast, kind customer service. We had an excellent couple of sandwiches.
Unfriendly staff.. had the bagel with lox slices and cream cheese.. he barely put any cream cheese and the bagel wasnt just warm and not toasted correctly.
Quick and efficient bagels (and salads, soups, etc) right next to the 6 train stop
A different location than our usual pick-a-bagel, still superior bagels.
Good bagel and lox i like zucker better but if you are close by get one
I didnt expect these bagels to be so fantastic. Better than Zabars
They do not take phone orders for pick up.
Good to have bagel in the morning at this place lots of varieties of cream cheese
Everything is great except NO HAIRNETS...OR GLOVES...
Way too overpriced. Would recommend a breakfast cart instead or midtown bagels instead.
Great bagels on the way tho the Met. Been doing it for 25 years
One of the best bagel places in Manhattan; if not the best.
Decent service, bagels saves them
Mediocre baked goods with sky high prices. Many better options on the neighborhood.
Total reviews rating 3.8
199 Reviews for Pick A Bagel 2023:
Review №1
2022-07-16On MTA 77th station on Lex Ave.All city Classic upper east Manhattan. Place to take in or out. Bagelss, muffins, coffe, tea, fruit or veggie salad. Fresh, cold, Hot drinks. Razonable prices. High quality, great attendance.
Review №2
2022-07-21I love their bagels (especially the french toast one, but I think they dont carry it anymore)... but man the staff is rude! That being said, if you dont mind being greeted by a loud and aggressive NEXT!!! instead of a kind Hi!, give it a try. Oh and also, the strawberry cream cheese is amazing.
Review №3
2022-06-29Always excellent bagels, and real bialys that have become rare. They are really good. All the sandwiches excellent. You will never be disappointed here.Excellent. Delicious food, courteous associates. Great food variety
Review №4
2021-07-04Where do I even begin???? From the moment you walk into this place youre mesmerized by the smell of the baked goods. Their bagels are fresh and delicious. The coffee cakes and cookies are also delicious. There are also other food and beverages options to choose from. My mouth waters just thinking about this place. Whenever Im in the area I have to stop by.
Review №5
2022-03-26There are suddenly tons of bagel shops on the Upper East Side. This is the only one that has acceptable prices, i.e. doesnt charge $20 plus for a lox sandwich.Thank you for remaining reasonable!
Review №6
2022-04-28Always excellent bagels, and real bialys that have become rare. They are really good. All the sandwiches excellent. You will never be disappointed here.
Review №7
2020-04-05Ordered the Nova Scotia salmon bagel with onions and capers. Received a bagel of onion and capers, i.e not what I ordered. Onions were piled in the middle to give a good cross section cut which looked nice but even if my order were correct it would have been a bad experience having a couple bites loaded with onions and basically none for the rest.Capers were very generous, but getting what I ordered would have been great.
Review №8
2022-06-11So delicious pastry🥐🍪 and coffee ☕️Highly recommend this place
Review №9
2019-10-04Good experience. Little busy and the shop is small. But the bagel tasted really good. I wanted a bagel with all veggies. But the guy gave me bagel with veggie cream cheese. Almost same thing. But bagel sandwich would have been better. But the veggie cream cheese was delicious as well. I had that with 7 grain bagel. Would definitely visit again.
Review №10
2020-03-29If I could give this place 0 stars I would. I just ordered a BLT on an everything bagel, and it was so bad I threw it out.Let me start with the fact that is was so poorly put together, I could barely eat it. At first I tried to make it work, but the gallon of mayonnaise that they put on was making things difficult. The onion they used was barely even cut up, so the massive pieces of onion just fall out. The bagel was terribly so one half didn’t even have a top half of the sandwich.Cheese not melted, lettuce was all over the place and seemed as if it was put into a jar of mayonnaise before the put it on the sandwich.My girlfriend also had a bagel with cream cheese, and it was stale. The bagel was stale.I have been living on the upper east side for almost 4 years. This is by far the worst experience I’ve ever had in the UES.Go to Tal bagels if you want good service and good food.