Delivery
Yes
Pizza Wagon in Brooklyn
Categories
Location on the map
Brooklyn, Kings County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible car park
No
Offerings
Comfort food
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Amenities
Good for kids
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Historic
Yes
Crowd
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
University students
Yes
Payments
Cash only
Yes
Phone: +1 718-836-5725
Opening hours
- Monday:10AM–1AM
- Tuesday:10AM–1AM
- Wednesday:10AM–1AM
- Thursday:10AM–1AM
- Friday:10AM–1AM
- Saturday:10AM–1AM
- Sunday:10AM–1AM
Comments (199)
Pizzas out of this world and diner decor is like a step back in time, 100% nostalgia, kind, attentive staff, great prices and 2 thumbs up, highly recommend! ; ) This is the Saks 5th Avenue of pizzas...so come on over...and travel back in time!
Dropped off a great customer who uses our limousine service from south jersey and she recomend pizza wagon. So bought 2 Sicilian and 3 plan slice and being a ninja turtle originally from Yonkers, I bit into a hot slice driving and almost crashed. Lol Anyway pizza was slamming, highly recomend going there. When in Brooklyn this is my spot.
Still the best pizza in the neighborhood!! Even during the pandemic. The counter and tables are always clean. They have a full supply of napkins for my messy kids!! The prices are still good and the staff is always friendly polite and have a great sense of humor!! Ive been a customer since the age of four! My kids love the Sicilian squares. We order the Regular + Sicilian pies for all their Birthday parties!!!
Old school traditional delicious generous cheesy slices no sleep till Brooklyn pizza!!
Very busy and the pizza fly out the door for a delicious reason. Best pizza in Brooklyn and we come from New Jersey to bring back pies.
A delicious NYC regular pie. Never disappoints. Pizza Wagon is one of my favorite old school pizza joints.
Ok seriously, this is one of the BEST pizza places in Brooklyn! The Sicilian pies are absolutely delicious!
M, 29Quality pizza whether youre grabbing a slice or an entire pie! Quality sauce and toppings.
Always great. Love this spot brings up a lot of memories from HS
Always a staple of Brooklyn. Pizza is still just as good as years ago.
I love this place pizza. Best pizza
[CASH ONLY] A Bayridge hallmark with prompt service. The pizza slice costs $3.00 now but thats not their fault - blame NYC being stupid expensive. However, the price of admission is worth it!!
Best pizza 🍕 😋Nostalgic experience with their original decor. They also have a walk up window which is great, love ending the night here for a perfect crisp gooey slice.
Closes early without warning. People inside rude because I came during their operating hours and wanted to get something. Wont be back.
Overall I had a good experience the pizza was good as well as the vibe. Ill be going back
I cant believe I havent reviewed this place yet . I been going here with friends for a long time. Very fast and very tasty
Very good cheese pizza... and the Boys are very kind and respectful to.....
Great slice but I could do without the free COVID on the side. People just chill there maskless. Don’t believe it? Just scroll down, they even post pics of it lol
Love the sauce and cheese ratio. Tasty crust.
Finally popped in there and luckily enough there was a post-lunch crowd fresh pie coming right out of the oven. Good flavor and it tasted even better as I was walking down 4th ave as it cooled off. Will try their square next time.
Delicious pizza and close to 86th Street Shopping strip.
Pizza is good but not as good as I remember.
Light and soft sicilian pizza- great taste.Still great after all these years
Haven’t tried pizza.Cash only 🤦♂️As soon as I walked in to pick up my pizza, i see naked pizza on top of oven.He asked my order and grabbed that dusted pizza from top of the oven and throw it in oven. And said only cash
Their pizza is the best in town! Definitely should try!
Best in Brooklyn. Staff is always pleasant and nice fast service weather you eat in or delivery. Pizza is delicious very consistent just perfect love this place. Must try.
Love it squares or round both exceptional . I GET ONE OF EACH .
Regular Pizza joint. Theyve been there for many years. They label themselves as Bay-Ridginal, since they are located in Bay Ridge on 5th Avenue and 86th Street. They are usually pretty busy. Food is ok.
The cheese and sauce are out of this world along with the crunchy crust if you get their pizza well done. Definitely one of the better pizza places that I have tried in Brooklyn. Highly recommended!
The pizza itself is ok, wouldn’t say it’s the best pizza in Brooklyn, but gets the job done. I’ve gone here twice, and both times the guys there have been rude with not the greatest customer service. I don’t understand the attitude. I don’t plan on coming back here again. Also, their menu design could be better.
OVER ONE HOUR for single pie….Rude when answering the phone and asking for updated time of arrival. Done giving this place business.
Employees have a very nasty attitude, especially delivery people. They have a high rating on google and have been in the neighborhood for a long time, so they don’t care if they treat people badly as long as they make $$$. Pizza is good but there are many other places nearby where you can get good pizza and BETTER CUSTOMER SERVICE
Glad to see it still busy 24/7 even during a pandemic.Some tips for new customers:Make it easier for yourself and the staff by ordering with what you want to buy already in mind. Some get snappy if you waste their time (and for good reason).When you go to pizza wagon, you’re asking for the menu they‘re known for, so skip the customization (this isn’t a Domino’s).Don’t be entitled, it won’t get you anywhere.Otherwise, the staff are nice as long as you’re respectable.
Excellent pizza. The guys are very nice there, my daughter was short $1 and he let her go no problem. No frills, not fancy, but solid pie.
This is a surprising better than average New York Slice. Its a great place to grab something quick. The cheese has a bit of stringiness to it as good fresh mozzarella has. The underbelly of the pizza has a good amount of char. The tomato sauce is not watery and has a decent amount of flavor.
Best NY style slice in Bay Ridge.
Old school, cash only. Great pizza
Theres a good reason why this shop has been around for so many years. They have consistently served great pizza to everyone in the community. Its always worth taking the trip and supporting local businesses like this one. Hopefully well be able to enjoy this pizza for many years.
!Rudest men I ever encountered work here behind the counter. What a disgrace. Take business else where (roccos is up the street). Where you can eat w. dignity without being disrespected for no reason & actually have a good experience all around. These men need to be addressed immediately. Wonder how theyd like theyre family members being treated this way when they go out & spend money in a food establishment....they are making Hispanics look very bad when usually Hispanics are very respectful, especially at work, but not here !! They found the rudest ones & employed em here. Not cute they should watch how they treat people before they regret it!
The slices are great the squares are better the za is fresh as hell and no grease drip.
Been going here my entire life, old reliable! Traditionally, we all prefer the pizza closest to our apartments, and vow its the best. Pizza Wagon is everyone who shops 86th Streets second favorite pizzeria.
Use to love this place, but owner allows kids from Fort Hamilton take over the place and eat subway sandwiches,McDonalds, etc while 1 kid is eating pizza and girl is rolling a joint, has no regards for the old people who kept this pizza place in business, will never go there again, so disrespected.
Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. The cozy location, old school aesthetic, and aroma of pizza that hits you from the street instant takes me back to my childhood. Whenever friends and family visit me and say they want real Brooklyn pizza, this is where I take them and they’ve all been thrilled.
Good pizza, the squares are much better than the slices IMO, but still good. The slices are pretty thick. Sauce isnt too salty like some places. Good prices and a walk up window....but they close when they want. Not when its listed.
Any negative comment just doesn’t know good pizza. One of the best in Brooklyn. Been coming here for years. Love this place!
The best Sicilian Pizza in Brooklyn. Make sure its hot when eating it.
Fantastic pizza. Get a silician or three. Great late night option and only one block from the R train 86th Street stop.
This is real New York pizza! Open late too. Great for that midnight slice after leaving the bar
Food is good don’t get me wrong but your employees are scumbags and have the nastiest attitude I give you $40 for a pie and some slices and ask for crushed peppers they acted as if I asked him for a pot of gold. You telling me an establishment has been here since the early 60s can give you crushed peppers or Parmesan cheese you got to be kidding me how about you tell your employees at customer service works?
Pizza is overpriced and overrated. Rude employees, the guys like to make fun of or complain about the customers right in front of them in Spanish when they dont think you understand.
A diamond in the rough! Can’t say enough,absolutely great pizza. I would call it an industry standard. Exactly what pizza should be measured up to. Pizza Wagon is Brooklyn pizza at it’s best!!!
Notice how almost all reviews speak about the horrible attitudes of these workers!!!!! Shape up or ship out. Making Hispanics look bad! When they are usually so kind and Hardworking!! Not rude like these pieces of work ! Disgrace
Best pizza in the Bay Ridge area. Ive been going to this place since high school in the 70s and nothing has changed in the way they make the pizza in that time. Place is always packed and seating is at a premium as its a small place. The Sicilian pizza is my favorite. Not cheap with the cheese.
Orders taking nearly 2 hours to arrive, horrible pizza place. Never ordering from here again! Absolutely frauds!
I hate giving 2 stars the pizza is fantastic! But I order delivery and the driver refuses to leave his car because hes double parked! Ive worked delivering many jobs including pizza with my own car and thats the chance you take! Ill only go and pick up or eat my pizza from them on premise!
I really want to love this place but i can’t. Not consistent. Last two times i ordered a pie it was burnt and overcooked, and i clearly told them do not burn it when i called. But when they don’t burn it the pizza tastes amazing. What a shame, so much potential in this place but very inconsistent.
I ordered a pie around 11 pm. When I went to pick up the guy was very rude and disrespectful it seemed he didn’t want to work. This happened on September 28th. I have always been there but this time was the worst experience. If you are open than you should be ready to work and give consideration to people who are giving you business. He treated very badly and was talking to his co worker in Spanish. I love Spanish people and all people of color but this guy is not a good employee for pizza wagon the owner needs to teach him how to behave!!
Really good pizza, I get the Sicilian slice. This restaurant is one of the staples of the Bay Ridge area. Definitely a family place. Im new to Brooklyn, coming from North Carolina, and I love the places that are true to the area.
Worst service ever. Baaaaaaad attitude from the guys upfront. Pizza is not alll that, the only reason I came here was cause it was the 4th of July and all famous pizza places were closed. I gave it a try and I’ll give them a big F for there baaad attitude and service by the guys upfront.
Been getting pizza from there for years. Usually good, except yesterday. I was given a pie that was pre cooked, they put on sauce and cheese and heated up. Tasted like cardboard. Manager said we were busy and sometimes it happens. He did the right thing and sent me a new pie that wasn’t pre cooked.
This is great Brooklyn pizza. Fifty years plus in business. Open late and always fresh pizza. Best in the neighborhood.
Yummy pizza, even though I like thicker crust, the flavor is so good. I cant abide pizza where the sauce tastes sugary. This flavor is perfect. This place is busy all the time, so that tells you something.
Great pizza. Definitely will stop here when Im in the neighborhood
Always the best Pizza in the neighborhood bar none, open till midnight as well if you want a late meal. No regrets here.
Classic old school no frills Brooklyn style pizza: cheesy, saucy, thin & oily! A beautiful thing! I can always count on Pizza Wagon to satiate my NY pizza cravings when I come visit nearby family.
Spanish guys they are very rude taking orders 🤬🤬🤬
Classic ny brooklyn slice pizza. Always freshm
Place is a staple in the community. I prefer the square slices, but thats me. Service is great, pizza is great, the location is perfect which makes this place a 4 🌟 for me! Enjoy and be sure to look around the place to see some history on the walls!
The best pizza I’ve tasted in NY in the last 25 plus years with no exaggeration.
Great Brooklyn slice!! Nice and greasy. Great taste. Also they serve my favorite Ginos Italian ices. Its hard to find a pizzeria these days that still serves ices.
On our NYC trip we had pizza 3 times. I always ask a local for a tip on a good spot. A gentleman suggested this place as some of the best pizza in Brooklyn. By far the best pizzaive ever had and the best of the 3 NYC local favorites.
A quintessential New York slice of pizza. This place is been around for 50 years, so if you are looking for an old school slice and a whole cheese pie for $15 youve found a good spot! 8/2018
The pizza was unreal. Its spicy, crunchy, meaty. PERFECT! I find myself trying to find reasons to go that far from where I live, just so we can go back.
Best Pizza in Bay Ridge! One of the best in NYC! No fancy artisanal fru-fru pizza, this is the real deal NYC pizza!!!
I ordered a fresh pie. The man said 10 mins I got there in 5. He puts the whole pie that was already sitting out back in the oven. He flat out told me he is NOT making a fresh pie since that one was being heated up. They have fallen off. The taste is very oily and taste old. I have been a customer since the 90s. I will NEVER eat there again! Annnddd I am telling all my friends to eat elsewhere too
I just picked up a square pie fresh out the oven. Half pepperoni, half regular. Hands down best pie I’ve ever had. So much so that I felt the need to write something.
The best pizza from Brooklyn to florida NO DOUBT!!!
Definitely understand why this place is considered a Brooklyn classic. Crisp crust, delicious sauce, and toppings piled high. Also, try the Sicilian slice. It is a hidden gem here.
Traditional Brooklyn pizza spot, nothing fancy, pumping out delicious slices that Brooklynites grew up eating. Fresh, hot, cheesey and greasy goodness! If youre looking for healthy then this is not the spot for you.
Been ordering here for years. Today we called in an order for a large pie. they asked if we want toppings. we asked what did they have available. he mentioned only 3 toppings and then said hurry up to us on the phone. ...Incredibly rude told us to hurry up on the phone while figuring out an order.Sunday May 3rd 2020 rip pizza wagon nonnos it is
I have been eating there my whole life!They started out in the 1960s in a SUPER narrow store. There was hardly enough room to wait for ur food! LOLThey expanded a LONG time ago.Pizza and calzones r very good!😃😃😃
Reliable pizza with no-frills service. Decor needs updating but it seems nobody cares about that if pizza remains the same. Their menu hasnt changed, ever. All they serve are fountain sodas, if thats your thing. In the late evenings, they open the side windows to offer slices for the midnight munchers, however be aware there are nights where they do actually close.
I always stop here for a sicilian slice while Im out shopping by myself.
Best pizza!!! Square baby, square!!! 🤣❤
Very good... classic NYC slice.
DISGUSTING!Went in about to order a pizza when i see some coins fall out of the guy at front (who is taking orders and getting the money from customer) and land on the pizza. He picks them up with his metal spatula thingy and throws them aside and continues to take orders. Didnt throw away the slice it landed on, just served it to the next customer. If they are willing to do that in front of customers, god knows what they do behind closed doors.
Great pizza, hands down! The staff was fantastic. If pizza wagon reads ,I just wanted to say thank you ,for everything!!!
I’m changing my rating from one star because I experienced the worst customer service on the phone. I’ve literally been coming to pizza wagon for my whole life.I called pizza wagon 7 pm on a Sunday. I wanted something a little different from what I usually order so I asked the guy what toppings they have He was like “ma’am we have mushroom pepperoni and pepper hurry up we busy” I’m actually fully disgusted he couldn’t take a min to take my order so I hung up and I will never ever step foot in pizza wagon ever again.It’s the principal of taking the time to help a paying customer who asked a simple question. And I get it people get busy but I just wanted to know what toppings they had but instead he only told me 1/3 of the options they had and on top of that he was hellaaa rude.
Best pizza of BK. Sometimes a bit too soggy but still taste yummy
Great old fashion Brooklyn pizza
Its a good place for a quick slice, but they dont really do variety, not even a lot of toppings. Regular slices only really.
Just straight rude honestly. This has been my 3rd time going (in most recent months) because I was convinced it was in my head. Well, it wasnt. Requested a nice cheesy slice from the pan and the guy says that pie is reserved, asked for a slice from the other pan and he said everything is reserved for pick up or delivery so.... Does that mean no more slices for the night, it was only 6:12 on a Friday??? Another time I requested a sheet of tissue paper referring to the wax paper (simple fumble in my head) After a 3rd time requesting the guy yells and responds with an attitude saying you dont see the words right here, its not tissue paper its WAX... WAX. Third time I asked several times for parmesan and oregano waiting around thinking maybe its on the table, maybe I overlooked it, and then I get a response from 1 of the guys youre in the way move move, go over there. I mean, how many more chances can I give them to talk to me like Im still a student walking there after school? Im damn near 30 and you talk to your customers like this!?!!?!? I know most people love pizza wagon but its about time that I PERSONALLY stop going. And just to be clear, if it were just the service I would have indicated such, but in the 14 years I have been going to pizza wagon, I have never felt like it was the most bestest ever. It was truly just OK pizza. So definitely not worth the poor service. And definitely worth the 1 star in combination with taste quality and service.
Over 25 years been going to pizza wagon and still the same quality taste pizza at 1am
Some of the best I’ve ever had
Best Pizza in Bay Ridge ! Been enjoying the pizza since I was a kid, and still loving it 40+ years later. Fast and friendly service, and great selection of Italian Ices.
Horrible experience. No other customers in line so as we walked up to the window and they refused to give us a menu. It was 1 hour before closing and the man said what you see is all you can order. We asked what the two pizzas were and he said its what youre looking at. I have no idea why he didnt want to serve us but well never give him an opportunity to again.
Great place to grab a slice even late, but prices are a bit inconsistent. One time was charged $3/slice and another time $2.75
Great brooklyn pizza
Been eating pizza here since I was 17. Here we are 21 years later and 1 kid later it still tastes just as good. Now my daughter and I get to enjoy their pizza.
Ive been going to this place for years. Il love their pizza. Even after I moved out of NYC, I come back to this. So freaking good
Best sluced pizza in nyc.And I am from Italy...
Want a quick slice, or an iconic taste of old-school Brooklyn, then definitely make a stop here. The Sicilians (square) are the way to go if you want the best in the city, but the slices are just as good. Add a little garlic powder and its like magic.... something special happens and the cheese tastes almost buttery..mmmmm
Nothing wrong with the NY style pizza.
Old school pizza that never needs to change
Feels like Im in Mexico I wait there for a italian experience it feels like Im in Taco Bell...very sad
I love this place!!! Every time Im in Brooklyn I have to bring a box of pizza home to my son!!! Always good!!
This has got to best the BEST regular (round pie) slice pizza in Bay Ridge! Always fresh and delicious. Always. I dont know how they do it, just glad that they do :)
Been coming here since i was a kid! One of the absolute best squares you can buy! My mouth waters everytime Im back in Brooklyn, although everything here is great! You dont last 50 years selling basically squares and rounds unless you have the goods! Always busy but service is prompt and everyone is always courteous! Truly takes me back to my childhood every time!
Best cheap slice and dtink around. they get really huffy and weird if u ask for parmesan. Get one regular slice and one sicilian because both are equally good. You can get toppings you just have to ask for its bot displayed
Excellent pizza. Best squares. Glad they haven’t changed anything over the years. Cheese tastes great!
Yum. Not too salty, not too thick, just as greasy as a good slice needs to be. Its in my top 3 pizzerias in BK.
Nowhere beats there Sicilian! It is the absolute best around now.
Extremely rude guy picked up the phone. I politely asked to change an item on my order for a delivery. He responded “come on buddy you’re taking too long, I’m busy”. If you are busy then don’t pick up the phone and shut down your delivery service Jackass.
I order delivery and they say 45 minutes. An hour in and no sign of the pizza. I call just to check if the order has left and the guy on the phone was so rude, he screamed WE SAID 45 MINUTES. YOU ALREADY CALLED AND WE SAID 45 MINUTES. WE ARE BUSY So I said that this is the first Ive called since placing the order and its been over an hour. He cuts me off and says I DONT BELIEVE YOU. Im like wow.....cancel the order then. Literally worst customer service ever....I do not recommend this place.
Very good pizza here, parking can be tough in the area if not on foot.
The real deal, authentic, Brooklyn NY style pizza! The slices have been delicious since I was a kid. And they still serve Ginos Italian Ices!!! Pizza Wagon never dissapoints
My favorite squares when theyre fresh. I remember going with my crew at 3 am after the bar, club or whatever! Now its just as good.👌
Best pizza place in bay ridge. No frills pizzeria with excellent cheese slices. I always look forward to coming back here when Im in town.
Order a regular pie and let me just say I haven’t had really good pizza In a while. Soooooooo yummyyyyy
We love this pizza!!
Best pizza shop in Brooklyn, just by the years it has been feeding pizza to Brooklyn speaks for itself. Buon Appetito!
Great pizza, great service. Best quick slice in Bay Ridge since... God, theyve always been there.
The perfect spot to relax and enjoy the perfect slices while waiting for your mom to finish shopping at Century 21. Their square slice had the right amount of cheese which is A LOT and I like it
Will be stopping here for a slice every time I go to Bay ridge and Im not even a pizza fan😅😋🍕🗽
OPEN LATE! Which is good thing when youre just leaving the bars or coming home late from work. This place seems to be open and ready to dish out some no so special slices. I do have to say... nothing about this place changed since I was a kid except for the prices... which isnt too bad today.
I don’t ever leave my home but the fact is this place is the best. The pizza is absolutely delicious and it’s such a bummer that they don’t deliver but I’m willing to travel for their pizza
I love this place awesome pizza 🍕 fast service and friendly staff.
Great pizza, a Bay Ridge Tradition for over 50 years. Could use a makeover.
Good pizza been going there for years. The drive is worth it from park slope
The best pizza, its delicious. Fast service & the staff are so nice. I have been going there for years, & the pizza has ALWAYS been great.
Pizza wagon is that place that is great because everyone says its great. The food is good enough to live up to that, but by no means the best pizza in Brooklyn.
This pizza is no longer what it once was. It is tasteless and dry. The help is downright rude. I speak Spanish and they do not realize that their smart remarks are understood by others. They should be lucky they are working.
First time visitor to NYC this past weekend. This was the first pizza I tried. Hands down best pizza ever. Love the crust
Best slice in Bay ridge
Knocked these bad boys down exactly 2 months ago when driving from Philly to Boston....best part, got em at 12:30a...gotta love being able to get good food at odd hours during a pandemic!💪🏽
Consistently solid pizza
Good old Brooklyn pizza just the way it was ment to be made
The food was awesome. 10/10. The service was great, and the pizza was spectacular. This is definitely the best pizzeria in Bay Ridge.
Arrived from Florida to visit family and we visit the Pizza Wagon 3 of the 4 days out there. Great pizza bring a store to Tampa Florida it will be a HIT.
My favorite i come here Everytime I visit from Florida and bring back pizza!! You have to try their meatball slice omg delicious they dont have it out U have to ask for it
Best pizza in bay ridge besides my own.
Idk whats going on but this place was always good.. Just went to get a slice it literally fell apart hardly no cheese and they thought they wanted To give me a old slice from yesterday. I told them. I want a fresh slice.
Born and raised in bay ridge .. Best pizza in Brooklyn.. This pizza shop has so much history and has even been in movies .. I love the service and the pizza is dam good
Oops busted! I wanted to only eat the cheese tops of the slices but the crust was so good I ate them too.
Nice shop and they open late. Got that true brooklyn flavor pizza.
Pizza Wagon has been there since 1966. Their pizza slices are delicious. The recipe hasnt changed.
Its one of the best pizza slice in bklyn
Best squares around you cant eat just one.
Great pizza place Sundays Pizza can be a little less crispy but fantastic flavor great pizza all-around good experience best pizza in Brooklyn besides Ninos.
It’s a real treat when my boyfriend brings home a pie from Brooklyn to Staten Island! Delicious classic pizza!
Pizza is great , old school style , but no variety , pretty much is what you see is what you get , they mustve forgotten to fill up the rest of the wagon ! Smh
The pizza is always great, the staff is friendly .
Best pizza Ive had. Simply just pizza.
Pizza is great, staff is terrible. Told 20 minutes for a pie but it took almost an hour. When I complained they got nasty and confrontational. Last time Ill go there
Still one of Bay Ridge best pizzas. The place has been there way before me and Im 40 years old
Vito has the best pizza in Bay Ridge and he is a true gentleman. Caring about his customers and the community at large!
Classic NY style pizza. Great cheese
One of the best white slices Ive ever had in NYC. Decent prices. Service leaves a little bit to be desired.
Great reliable pizza for the 15+ years Ive been eating here. In person is great but delivery falls flat like most pizza
Best Pizza in Brooklyn! Haters going to hate, it is way better than LB’s further down 86th street
Pizza wagon has been in business my entire lifetime. The reason is the pizza is solid! Square or round theyre both good.
This place used to be excellent. The problem is the Mexican workers. They dont know how to cook the way the original People that used to be there cooked. And they dont speak English. They make you feel that you are the foreigner. This country is going down..
The pizza is beyond amazing. no need to review just go get a Slice and a Sicilian. Hurry.
A little pricey, bit its still pretty good. Being cash only in 2021 tho is pretty mid.
Excellent pizza. Maybe the best in bay ridge.
That Pizza taste good, I love the sauce... The place it is a traditional look with decorated classic coca cola memorabilia.
The pizzas real good here and I love their sausage rolls best in Bay Ridge
Its just the best pizza in my life. U love Brooklyn-Bay Ridge PIZZA WAGON!!
When in the mood for pizza and youre in bayridge, you have to get it from Pizza Wagon.... and theyre open late!
Not the same pizza I grew up with. Lived in the neighborhood for 18 years and loved it growing up. Now it certainly lacks the flavor from its wonder years.
The best pizza I’ve ever had in my life.
Best pizzeria ever and I have tried a lot of them. Been going there for 30 years.
I always go out of my way on NYC visits to grab a few slices here. Best slice in the city Burroughs in my opinion!
This place is tied with Bay Ridge Pizza and the old Ginos as best pizza in the area. Consistent and put Brooklyn
Has been a staple since late sixties GREAT PIZZA
Really good pizzaAlways fresh always busy so u know pizza is consistently moving out
Family got sick from the pizza we bought home. Only thing I ate. After cereal that morning never got sick off pizza from anywhere before
Amazing Pizza that you can always count on, even late at night when youre craving a NY slice.
So good. Sometimes I preheat my oven when I know Im bringing a Square pie home so that it can be extra crispy
Quick slice with a Hi-C
Been going here since a kid, best pizza !
Great tasty pizza. They need to stay on top of cleaning the tables.
Very good pizza. Nice and fresh. One of the best in the city!!!
Pretty good Brooklyn pizza. The square slice was better tonight than the regular slice.
Best pizza in brooklyn!!!!!!! If this place closes down ever God forbid Im never coming to visit bayridge
Damn good and cheap Pizza if your staying in this area of Brooklyn Id defiantly recommend.
Great pizza with a friendly staff, fast service and open late. A good to place for a sausage slice :)
The best pizza. Moved to Staten Island and still get my pizza from there ❤❤❤
Pizza Wagon is a go to spot for the traditional NY Slice.
Total reviews rating 4.4
199 Reviews for Pizza Wagon 2023:
Review №1
2022-04-05Really delicious New York pizza, first time going there in twenty years and it was still just as amazing! Nice thin crust, but not too thin.
Review №2
2021-07-25Pizza here will always so fresh and when you see the whole pizza just out of the oven, the cheese on the top is still melting, and smell so good, you just cant resist to make an order.$3 for a slice of traditional cheese on top is no worry option. I think it is a good way to eat it one after one, it is not necessary ordered a lot once, since the still melting cheese is so incredible, so it worth to pay again and again.
Review №3
2022-02-09The Pizza is great, but please start using a paper on top of plates to avoid the pizza oil from going through the plate. I ruined my sweater, bc I realized the pizza oil went through the paper plate and onto my expensive light gray sweater while eating the pizza in my car. I poured thousands into this business (I’m one of their best costumers), so it’s the least they can do. Here’s photos that I took to show you what I mean (the 3rd photo is from Gino’s on 75th who use those papers):
Review №4
2022-01-25Best pizza in Brooklyn... hands down... I take it back... its not the best in Brooklyn..... the truth is...Its the best damn pizza in NYC hands down.
Review №5
2022-03-30Great place with history. Seating usually available inside, or a couple of standing only tables outside if you prefer. Order inside, or curbside at the window when the seasons permit. Great slices and even better squares. The real kicker is that the close at one....thats ONE AM!! I dont think there is any other Bay Ridge pizzeria than can claim that. Go the now! Or later. Or even much later.
Review №6
2022-06-05Love this place. Pizza is always amazing !! The staff is always friendly and cool ! They only accept cash at the moment but trust me its worth it !!!
Review №7
2022-03-20I grew up eating from Pizza Wagon and Rocco’s on 5th avenue. Once the Rocco brothers sold their pizzeria that their father started (I knew them all very well), I became a regular at Pizza Wagon. The pizza is great and one of the best in Bay Ridge, but many of the workers are nasty. They’re very impatient and aren’t respectful of any questions or concerns. If they get your order wrong it’s your fault, not theirs. Whatever happened to simple manners and decency? I only see them at their best behavior when the owner is around. The only person I can blame, though, is the owner because he should be aware of his workers. Mancini’s Wood-Fired Pizza that opened close by recently is becoming my go-to. The owners are Albanian, but their Italian cuisine and pizza are great.
Review №8
2021-07-17Pizza is good squares you have to get fresh or there not the same parking sucks but it’s definitely worth it to eat in there I would definitely never order from them again pizza came soggy and cold and took forever
Review №9
2022-01-29Burned. No thank you. I went to the 4th avenue 86 st place and see the difference
Review №10
2022-05-28Really good good pizza, I rarely eat the crust of the pizza cause some places usually burn them or toast them but this was amazing. Run by Latinos, love the way they make they’re pizza.